Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Queries: A Stellar Smorgasbord About this episode Astrophysicists Neil Tyson and Charles Liu answer a feast of fan-submitted questions, ranging from asteroid mining to the heat death of the universe, selected by co-host Eugene Mirman. Plus a new “How Tweet It Is” segment with Neil and Bill Nye.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm your host Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and this is StarTalk. This is Cosmic Queries Edition.
0:32 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
0:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cosmic Queries. And I'm ambivalent whether I prefer Cosmic Queries that is a single topic or whether it's potpourri. This one is potpourri, which is easier to stump me, and if we're gonna do a potpourri, I don't want to do it alone.
0:46 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
0:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I know who to call.
0:48 Eugene Mirman? Mm-hmm.
0:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've got like a bat signal, and my friend and colleague, Charles Liu, Charles.
0:54 Charles Liu? Hi Neil.
0:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There you go.
0:56 Charles Liu? Or shall I say Robin?
0:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, this is not your first time on StarTalk. It's your nth time on StarTalk, as we say. That means you've lost count, and it's some large number algebraically. And so Eugene, we have questions that come to us over our Facebook pages and our Twitter and other outlets, and sometimes we can gather them into one topic, but other times we can't. And it's a potpourri. And so I have not seen the questions. Eugene is gonna read them, and you and I are gonna try to answer them. That's what this is. And if we can't, we just say we have no clue, go on to the next one.
1:35 Eugene Mirman? Then I will answer it. If you don't know, I probably know it.
1:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Charles, and I might not even agree on an answer. That would be kinda fun, we'll see.
1:42 Charles Liu? That would be awesome.
1:43 Eugene Mirman? Scientists ever disagree? Just kidding.
1:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So let's do this, okay?
1:47 Eugene Mirman? Alright.
1:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What do you have Eugene?
1:49 Eugene Mirman? Well, this is from Patreon.
1:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By the way, just quick, our Patreon supporters are one of the categories of Patreon support, gets your question asked first.
2:02 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
2:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I don't know what that's worth to you in supporting StarTalk, but that's what's going on there. And the reason why I have Charles is Charles knows so much about random stuff.
2:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Spooky amounts of random stuff.
2:17 Charles Liu? Is that good or bad, Neil?
2:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's it's both.
2:21 Eugene Mirman? We'll find out what you know, and then I'll let you know if it's good or bad.
2:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, there you go. Eugene, you'll you're the adjudicator. Go.
2:27 Eugene Mirman? Okay, uh, Keilia Silves asks, oh, and Jeremy Kaiser together from Minnesota, they ask.
2:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They are Patreon supporters. Thank you for your support.
2:35 Eugene Mirman? Thank you. Will asteroid mining ever be financially viable from a purely business standpoint?
2:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, let me answer that, and then Chuck might have a have a have a have a additive to that. I did not believe that it could be financially lucrative because if there's gold on an asteroid, then you go get it. What did it cost you to get the gold? Probably more than the whatever thousand dollars an ounce it's going for now. So what's the point? Until I spoke with asteroid mining people who said in the in the future, we're going to have operations in space, manufacturing in space on the moon, on Mars, at at at the gravitational balance points, the Lagrangian points, and they will need raw materials. And so you would go mine the asteroid, take the raw materials to these other places,
3:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? and then you don't have to go in and out of Earth's atmosphere in our gravitational well. Is that about where you said on this, Charles?
3:32 Charles Liu? I think so. So within, say, thirty or forty years, it won't be feasible. But as soon as we get manufacturing in space, it will start becoming economically more feasible.
3:42 Eugene Mirman? Is there an amount of platinum that an asteroid could have that would make sense to bring it back to Earth?
3:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I thought about this, and let's say there is such an amount, and then you bring it back to the Earth. What does it do to the platinum market? It completely drops the price of platinum. Okay, so now watch. You say, well, that's bad. You might say, however, if the price of platinum drops or anything that's previously cherished and in rare quantities. Creative other things you can do with that material start to gurgle up in the, on the landscape of innovation.
4:15 Charles Liu? Right.
4:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And not that I can think of one now, but Charles, uh, what's, what's an example? When we finally, oh, aluminum. When it was first extracted from bauxite.
4:26 Charles Liu? Yes.
4:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was a cherished metal. It was light. It, it, people were replacing silver with it. It was, you wore aluminum as a, as a, cause to show you were wealthy.
4:36 Charles Liu? That's right.
4:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then once that process, it's not mining an asteroid, but it's the same idea. Once that process became more and more efficient and cheaper, and now we throw away aluminum.
4:45 Charles Liu? We wrap our food in aluminum.
4:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We wrap up an unthinkable thing back when they first extracted it from bauxite.
4:51 Charles Liu? That's right. So then.
4:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing to completely collapse the market.
4:56 Charles Liu? Right.
4:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Of a metal that is previously rare.
4:57 Charles Liu? What if it was a metal that has not yet been discovered? That would be the only thing that might be valuable enough to bring back.
5:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think we, well, Charles, correct me if I'm wrong, the periodic table of elements is complete at this point.
5:07 Charles Liu? Uh, well, up to about a hundred and fourteen on the atomic number scale. Yeah. So what about a hundred fifteen? Is that not possible? Uh, that has a half-life that's so short that it would disintegrate. It wouldn't survive in an asteroid. But what you might be getting at Eugene is the issue of having rare earths, you know, little tiny percentages of things that we don't normally use a lot right now. But say we put in semiconductors to increase the ability of our cell phones to run micro transistors and things like that.
5:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Cause just cause they're rare on earth, doesn't mean they're rare somewhere else. Right?
5:39 Charles Liu? Exactly. They're rare earth, not rare asteroid.
5:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not rare asteroid.
5:42 Charles Liu? So the answer is not a particularly great business model if, right now.
5:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Except it could completely transform civilization.
5:49 Charles Liu? Yes.
5:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the utility of one element versus another.
5:52 Charles Liu? Once you're in space, it's easier to get more gold in space.
5:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Keep going.
5:56 Charles Liu? Yeah. Um, all right. So Megan Fischel, also a Patreon, uh, patron asks.
6:02 Eugene Mirman? A few of my astrology inclined friends claim the reason. No. I know, Graeme, the reason my iPhone has been a bit dodgy recently is that Mercury is in retrograde. Is there any validity to their claim?
6:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Charles?
6:17 Charles Liu? No.
6:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
6:20 Eugene Mirman? Sorry.
6:20 Charles Liu? Wow. I'll say this, Mercury does go in retrograde. But when it does, we can't see it because it's actually in the direction of the sky that the sun is. So we wouldn't be able to detect it anyway in any visible format. And so in terms of what's happened to the cellphone or anything like that, uh, any kind of effect is completely non-existent. Now, it's interesting that you say this though, because I was getting on a bus once, uh, in New York's Port Authority about 10 years ago.
6:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the bus went retrograde.
6:49 Charles Liu? Barely, yeah, somebody barely got on the bus, was like dashing on and sat next to me and said, "Ah, I know I was late because Mercury is in retrograde. I just knew it. I just knew it." So, maybe, you know, collective belief creates a fantasy that might be propagated to this day in modern cellphones. Who knows?
7:09 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, too bad they didn't leave 15 minutes earlier.
7:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And another point about the concept of retrograde, the very word retrograde traces from a time when we had no notion that Earth was in motion around the sun. And so people actually believed that Mercury would be in motion in space, slow down, stop, reverse itself, and then pick up its previous motion slightly after that, as though that was a physical thing happening to Mercury.
7:38 Charles Liu? Mm-hmm.
7:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And retrograde, all it is, is what is your point of view on objects that are all in harmonious orbit, moving around the sun? And so, so, and I thought when you talked about the person miss- almost missing their bus, I thought you would say when you're on a bus looking out the window, see another bus, and you see that bus go backwards, and half the time you see that, you say you're actually going forwards.
8:00 Charles Liu? Yeah.
8:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right? So you're gonna say, "Oh, it's backward bus." No, you're the one in movement, not that. And so a lot of that language and a lot of that cultural, uh, uh, misappropriation of cosmic phenomena claim about because we did not know that we were all moving around the sun. It's that simple.
8:17 Charles Liu? Okay.
8:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, next.
8:20 Eugene Mirman? Uh, Ben Yeast from Facebook asks, "I read that if our universe turns out to work a certain way, it's possible for black holes to rotate so rapidly they prevent an event horizon from forming. If we do live in a universe where the, these naked singularities are possible, what evidence of their existence would we look for?"
8:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, Charles, I gotta...
8:42 Charles Liu? Well...
8:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a hard one, Charles, take it.
8:45 Charles Liu? Thanks a lot. Uh, he might be referring to something called a maximally spinning curved black hole.
8:53 Eugene Mirman? Mm-hmm.
8:54 Charles Liu? And that is theoretically possible, although it wouldn't last as long as a typical black hole that's spinning at a slower speed, just because it wouldn't stay in equilibrium very long.
9:04 Eugene Mirman? What's that length of time we're talking about, like milliseconds or years or hours?
9:10 Charles Liu? Well, you know, I have to go back and check my general relativity notes from graduate school. I'm sorry.
9:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Me too. Okay, you too. No, no, Charles, this is, this is cosmic queries. You can say, "I don't know."
9:23 Charles Liu? I don't know.
9:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or, "I once knew, I don't know anymore. I'll get back to you, call me in the morning." So, we're, I mean, we don't know, we'll just go on to the next question. That's part of how this, that's part of how we roll here.
9:34 Charles Liu? No, that's fair. Okay. Now, naked singularities, though, if you're looking for them, you're kind of looking for them the same way as you look for any other black hole, through gravitational lensing. You want to see what they have done to the view of space and objects in space behind them, and by the patterns that they create, you can deduce whether they are maximally spinning, or whether they're static, or if they're supermassive, or any combination they're at.
9:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, once again, the power of inference, once we have good data on what they're, on what other things are doing in their vicinity.
10:05 Charles Liu? Yes.
10:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. Or light paths that go past them.
10:08 Charles Liu? Mm-hmm.
10:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. All right, what else you got?
10:10 Eugene Mirman? Uh, Dick Craig from Facebook, he wants to know, "Can the mass of the Earth change, and wouldn't this slow or speed up our time?"
10:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, the mass of Earth is changing every day. We're we're gaining several hundred tons of meteor dust a day.
10:27 Eugene Mirman? Oh, really?
10:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes. But Charles, aren't we also losing some air to the uh, or isn't?
10:32 Charles Liu? Yes, a small amount going out. Uh, the mass coming in is still more than the mass going out, though, on a given day. So we are growing a little more massive every day.
10:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the mass going out is we're losing some of our upper layer of our atmosphere.
10:44 Charles Liu? Yes.
10:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Correct. Okay. So, but 300 tons sounds like a lot, not compared to the mass of the Earth. And I tried to run some numbers on this, Charles.
10:53 Charles Liu? Oh.
10:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I and I got something like, uh, a gnat flying full speed ahead into the side of an elephant was some huge factor greater than what Earth would feel if it got hit by a comet slamming into its side. And so you don't see elephants concerning themselves with their mass by how many gnats land on its back.
11:23 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, but if the elephants became bigger every day from gnats, you know, given a billion years, it's a little bit bigger.
11:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay. All right. So let's answer that question, Charles. So
11:33 Charles Liu? Okay.
11:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Make the Earth a little more massive. So what?
11:36 Charles Liu? All right. Well, Earth is six times 10 to the 21 tons, right? If you add 300 tons a day, that's what? A million tons a year? That would still take longer than the age of the universe to double Earth's mass. So we would have to wait a very, very, very long time to see any gravitational effects.
12:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Any meaningful gravitational effect.
12:06 Charles Liu? Any meaningful gravitational effect.
12:07 Eugene Mirman? I have time.
12:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
12:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And if Earth's mass go up, then we all start weighing a little bit more.
12:15 Charles Liu? Yes, right. But there's no effect in our orbit, really, because the way that Newton's law of gravity works, the speed of our orbit around the sun would not change unless appreciably or measurably, unless we started to approach the mass of the sun. And Earth is less than one three hundred thousandth the mass of the sun. So that's not going to happen for even longer times than the age of the universe.
12:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And by the way, what Charles is doing here, we spend many, many years in solving problems, thinking about how the universe works. By recognizing this quantity is large, that one is small, here we can ignore the small quantity. The most, or this quantity divides away. And this, this, this, these are tactics we have to gain some sense of how the universe works without worrying about it on such a level of detail that it becomes a distraction.
13:06 Charles Liu? Mm-hmm. Right. Like, you know, just quickly in my head, I would say your analogy of gnat on an elephant is very close to the actual effect. You can imagine if Mount Everest were hit by a snowball every day, how long would it take before Mount Everest would actually be appreciably more massive or more large, say, than it is now? And the answer is a very, very, very long time.
13:30 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
13:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
13:31 Charles Liu? Okay.
13:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What do you got?
13:32 Eugene Mirman? Uh, Michael Vaca from Facebook, he asks, "I'm concerned Snowden is right about strong encryption making alien signals look like background noise. Are there other ways to sense life remotely?" I don't know about what Snowden...
13:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we interviewed Ed Snowden for StarTalk, and we are proud on StarTalk to have brought him to Twitter. And so I had the very first conversation with him on Twitter that he promised he would do on air with us. And so in that conversation with him, we talked about encryption. And Charles, there's an interesting point, I don't know if you caught that episode. So encryption, so hold encryption aside for the moment, let's look at a JPEG, a JPEG or MPEG. So what does it do? It takes a signal that otherwise has a lot of information in it, but maybe not so much, and it somehow combines content in a way that reduces...
14:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The total information a little bit, but retains as much as it can so that you can minimize the size of the signal as you transport it. Okay? So, in an image of you right now, there's a large white area background. I can represent that mathematically, rather than having to retain all the details of that. And my mathematical representation is more efficient to move through space, through anywhere, than if I represented the whole thing. So, so there is a hypothesis that a sufficiently intelligent alien will take their signal and JPEG it so effectively and so efficiently, if I can use that JPEG as a verb, that there'll
15:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? be no discernible information left for someone to reach in and decode it. And so they're perfectly communicating with one another all the time, but we, trying to eavesdrop, will think it's completely noise.
15:23 Charles Liu? Now, so this is an accidental kind of encoding?
15:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, an accidental. So if you want to eavesdrop on civilizations, the most efficient way to send signals is to take whatever is decodable in the signal and re-represent it more efficiently.
15:37 Charles Liu? Right. Well, that kind of data compression that you described for JPEGs and so forth, they have an algorithm, right? So, you can, if you knew how they compressed it, you could unravel this information.
15:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, that's the key, but then you have to send the key on the other side. So we'd have to ask the aliens, "Please give us a key to your encoding method so that we can eavesdrop."
15:58 Eugene Mirman? Okay, so no one thinks that we're encrypting some stuff, they're encrypting stuff so strongly? Not encrypting, but, but, um...
16:05 Charles Liu? Compressor, compressing.
16:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it's not so much encryption. It's compressing a signal so efficiently
16:11 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
16:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? that the eavesdropper on it will no longer be able to distinguish it just from noise. Because if there's any discernible signal left in it, left in it, that meant there's more encryption, there's more
16:24 Eugene Mirman? Compression.
16:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Compression, that it can still survive.
16:27 Eugene Mirman? Then the other question is, are there other ways to sense life remotely? But I don't know that they're mutually exclusive.
16:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, just see if they're polluting their atmosphere on the planet.
16:36 Eugene Mirman? Just look for planets with other cars?
16:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, if the exo-planet has aerosols, ozone depletion, smog, that's a guarantee there's
16:46 Eugene Mirman? Lamborghars.
16:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No sign of intelligent life.
16:48 Charles Liu? And if, if we are able to watch some system for a long period of time, for example, we can watch for periodic behavior. Right, like just the way that decades ago, people thought that maybe pulsars, which are dead stars that turn very rapidly, maybe that their regular beating was a sign of intelligent life.
17:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, right.
17:10 Charles Liu? If we had many such beats coming from, say, a single solar system or something like that, then we might imagine that there were many such things happening and if there were not-
17:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In other words, it's not random and so you've got a-
17:20 Charles Liu? Yes, finding non-random-
17:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, if it's not random and it's predictable, then maybe somebody's doing the non-randoming and the predicting on the other end.
17:28 Charles Liu? Right.
17:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, we got just a few more seconds for this segment. Do you have a quick one or do we have to delay it to-
17:33 Eugene Mirman? I'll ask a quick one.
17:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Quick one, go.
17:35 Eugene Mirman? Uh, Linton John Davidson from Facebook asks, "How do I get people interested in science?"
17:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a quick one. You're lying, you are lying, you are li-
17:46 Eugene Mirman? You said quick and what I interpreted as, I could read that very quickly.
17:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Charles, give me your best eight-second answer to that.
17:53 Charles Liu? Listen to Neil.
17:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're listening to StarTalk. Stay tuned for another segment. Welcome back to StarTalk. Here's more of this week's episode.
18:21 Eugene Mirman? Matt Alley from Facebook slash San Antonio asks, "Trillions of years in the future when the universe is in its final whimpers, how might an advanced civilization be able to hold on to survival by harvesting energy from the last remaining celestial bodies?"
18:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
18:38 Charles Liu? Wow, well, yes.
18:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're talking about a future where all the gas that currently coexists with stars has been turned into stars. And the stars, one by one, start to burn out.
18:53 Eugene Mirman? Mm-hmm.
18:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so, when you go some trillions of years into the future, they will be the last civilization on the last planetary system around that last star. So Charles, what are your reflections on that?
19:05 Charles Liu? Well, uh, he, the questioner may be referring even further into the future, when protons themselves start to break down, and then black holes themselves dissipate through Hawking radiation, uh, ten to the one hundred years from now. Uh, in that case, then there's really no way to harness that energy, because it's all kind of waste heat, entropy, and so forth. But you could imagine-
19:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, just to be clear, so what we're saying is, you can have stars burn down, but there's still other ways to extract energy from phenomenon in the universe. And, and, but the universe is actually winding down in every possible measurable way.
19:46 Charles Liu? Right.
19:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so, when the particles decay to even lighter, smaller particles, then they can't decay into something else. And then you are left with a particle-energy wasteland.
19:57 Eugene Mirman? But is it, is it possible to have some sort of artificial planet that you live on that-
20:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, that's, this is the, this is the deep part about it. Because anything artificial meant you created a thing that has a metabolism and a source of energy to drive it.
20:11 Eugene Mirman? And the energy will be completely gone.
20:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The very fact that you would claim to be alive in that situation. You, you are producing energy. You have a body temperature above air temperature. You, you, you are a machine.
20:23 Eugene Mirman? Thank you.
20:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You can-
20:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And even when you die, you're, there's a, you're a microbial machine, with your molecules are still decaying.
20:34 Eugene Mirman? There won't be enough dead bodies for this artificial planet to keep eating, is what you're saying.
20:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Charles, yeah, how about the dead body energy source?
20:42 Charles Liu? Well, you could do the best you can, but in the end, once you get to the true heat death of the universe, uh, there's really nothing you can do, other than, I don't know, maybe start a new universe.
20:51 Eugene Mirman? Ah-ha! There is a solution, and it's to start a new universe.
20:56 Charles Liu? I didn't invent that solution. You, you should, uh, refer to one of Isaac Asimov's great short stories, called "The Last Question."
21:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
21:05 Charles Liu? I think it's really, really profound and deep. He wrote it very, very well.
21:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, alright. I, I think I've read that long ago, but I'm gonna pick it up again. You'll find out.
21:13 Eugene Mirman? Right.
21:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for that reminder.
21:14 Eugene Mirman? Start a new universe.
21:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Create a new universe.
21:16 Eugene Mirman? I don't know, if it's trillions of years from now, that science might exist.
21:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right.
21:20 Eugene Mirman? All right.
21:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What else you got?
21:21 Eugene Mirman? Uh, I have more. Okay, Jazz, uh, that's, uh, Jazz Gonzalez asks, um, hypothetically, if someone was to successfully create and open a wormhole to go back to a past time, would that wormhole continue to suck in atoms in the environment around it, eventually imploding and possibly destroying the universe around us?
21:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
21:49 Charles Liu? No.
21:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
21:53 Eugene Mirman? Right.
21:54 Charles Liu? No.
21:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, wait, wait, so, wait, so.
21:57 Eugene Mirman? Are there a handful of reasons or just like, no?
22:00 Charles Liu? Well, a wormhole, when you create something like that, um, it's naturally going to collapse in on itself.
22:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it's unstable?
22:10 Charles Liu? Yeah, unless you continue to put tremendous amounts of energy to keeping it open, right? Uh, and so it won't spontaneously sort of go out of control and grab as much stuff as possible, sort of sucking everything in.
22:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What would be cool, though, is if the wormhole, which gives, does give you access to the past, which does give you access to the past through certain trajectories through it.
22:33 Charles Liu? Yes.
22:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If you put the entire universe back through the wormhole, you can send the whole universe back, uh, to yesterday.
22:42 Charles Liu? Yeah. Whoa. How about that?
22:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In principle.
22:46 Eugene Mirman? Hmm, great. Did we just, what did we just discover? What exactly are you thinking?
22:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Call me later on that one. We, we'll figure, we got the equations on that.
22:55 Charles Liu? I think we got a paper to write.
22:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, okay. All right, what else you have?
22:58 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
22:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, we just, just before we went to the break, there was that question, please explain how big a what is? A gram? What was?
23:04 Eugene Mirman? Uh, the, no, the gram, uh, sorry, it was, it was around here. Oh, yeah.
23:10 Charles Liu? Gram's number.
23:10 Eugene Mirman? Explain gram's number, like Graham cracker.
23:13 Charles Liu? G R A H A M.
23:15 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
23:16 Charles Liu? Apostrophe S.
23:17 Eugene Mirman? I had assumed it was like, uh, like.
23:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sorry, I'd never heard of it.
23:20 Eugene Mirman? Some theorem.
23:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've never heard of it. Have you?
23:21 Charles Liu? It's, it's, if you take a certain, uh, geometric expansion of numbers to try to get to big numbers, you know how like, uh, a billion is? A big number because it's got nine zeros after a one and a googles even bigger because it's got one hundred zeros.
23:35 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, I read about that in Numbers magazine.
23:37 Charles Liu? A googolplex, which is one.
23:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Also, it's one of those big numbers that has a name is what you're saying.
23:42 Charles Liu? It's a gigantic number and it's based on you can construct it using a geometric expansion.
23:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The only big number I knew of was Skew's number and I didn't know Graham Graham had a number too.
23:51 Eugene Mirman? A big Skew's number, which is bigger, you think?
23:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's ten to the tenth to the tenth to the thirty-fourth power.
23:55 Eugene Mirman? Why is why so weird at the end?
23:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Which dwarfs a googolplex. It's self-dwarfing.
24:00 Eugene Mirman? Why is it to the thirty-fourth, not thirty-fifth?
24:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cause, cause, cause Skew's did it.
24:06 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
24:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, I don't know. They come up with these numbers, that's what I'm saying. And it has surely has some significance in mathematics.
24:12 Eugene Mirman? Right.
24:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That I cannot glean.
24:13 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
24:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At this point.
24:14 Charles Liu? Right. Now Graham's number is actually way larger than even Skew's number. I don't know exactly how.
24:20 Eugene Mirman? Three times as large?
24:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's twice as big.
24:23 Eugene Mirman? It's big. It's very big.
24:25 Charles Liu? If, what I have heard is that if you take, um, all the numbers that Graham's number would take to write it out in, in actual physical form, even if each number.
24:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Me, numeral, each, each numeral.
24:39 Charles Liu? Were smaller than an atomic nucleus, there would still not be enough room in the entire observable universe to hold the representation of Graham's number.
24:49 Eugene Mirman? It's a very big number.
24:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, Eugene, for confirming that fact. After Charles just explained how big it was.
24:57 Eugene Mirman? Now I really have a sense, it sounds quite big.
25:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. I will say that.
25:02 Eugene Mirman? All right, uh, let's, let's go, all right. Uh, from Eddie from Godly Texas asks, uh, regarding the Fermi paradox, if aliens do exist, which of the possibilities do you think is the most likely scenario?
25:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, Charles and I will trade off on this. I would say the most likely scenario, I have two most likely scenarios. One of them is that they have actually visited Earth.
25:25 Charles Liu? Well, do we need to explain to people what Fermi paradox is to begin with?
25:28 Eugene Mirman? That's probably a great call.
25:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I thought Eugene would do that, though, but.
25:32 Eugene Mirman? Sure. I'm assuming it's, uh, the ways aliens might have existed or visited.
25:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, so if you can run the numbers on this and. If aliens are like humans and live as long as humans do and are ambitious like humans, then they might have a space program and then they would go colonize a planet.
25:48 Eugene Mirman? Yep.
25:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then that colony would then build its own space program and colonize two planets. And then those-
25:54 Eugene Mirman? I would have colonized two planets.
25:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, no. So, so we-
25:56 Eugene Mirman? That's-
25:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're one planet, we colonize two planets. Each of those two planets colonize two planets, alright? So you, it's, it's two to the nth power. It grows rapidly. It's, it's an exponential. And it turns out, you can occupy every single planet in the galaxy in less time than it takes for you to evolve from one species to another. And so, in the, under that calculation, if there are intelligent aliens anywhere who had this ability, where are they now? They should be pitching tent right next to us.
26:29 Eugene Mirman? Mm-hmm.
26:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, and Mico Fermi, a famous Italian physicist, uh, proposed this question. So either, there are no aliens out there, or there's some other explanation for why we don't see them. And so I have two explanations. One of them is, th- they came to Earth already-
26:47 Eugene Mirman? Mm-hmm.
26:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, and saw humans and concluded there's no sign of intelligent life on Earth and left. Okay, had, did have one. Then another one is maybe they landed the same day that Comic-Con was happening. And so, nobody-
27:02 Eugene Mirman? They're in San Diego.
27:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're in San Diego. Uh, but Charles, you have a, do you have a, a less comical answer to this question? It's a very serious question.
27:11 Charles Liu? Well, um, one of our colleagues, uh, Steve Soder, actually told me this idea.
27:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, Steve Soder co-wrote both Cosmos series in 1980 and the one that I, that I, uh, hosted. Go on.
27:24 Charles Liu? Yeah. Um, Steve said that it's possible that once intelligent civilizations achieve the ability to colonize, they wind up all destroying themselves before they successfully do the colonization. Uh, if you can, for example, create a spacecraft that can go some tremendous speed, a one percent the speed of light or something like that, you're too tempted to use it as a weapon against your enemies rather than doing something productive like exploring space.
27:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I think that, I think the argument was even more subtle than that. It was, whatever is the gene for expansionism-
28:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If I expand to here and you expand to there, I also want to expand to where you went.
28:08 Charles Liu? Right.
28:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so you have overlapping borders of expansion and that is, has the seeds of its own undoing.
28:16 Charles Liu? Right, so it creates annihilation before we see them. So we, in that scenario, are doomed to, to self-destruction at some point when we get sufficiently advanced enough, uh, technology to do so.
28:28 Eugene Mirman? It's a very unidelic Star Trek is what you're describing.
28:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah.
28:32 Charles Liu? And, and I think Eugene's hit the other one that I think of, right? Is that, uh, aliens are sufficiently benevolent that they hide and disguise whether or not they're there. So that they allow us to develop and become citizens of the universe in a cheerful.
28:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That is so beautiful, Charles.
28:48 Charles Liu? I didn't invent it.
28:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or we are their computer program and, and somebody's PhD thesis to create a universe.
28:55 Eugene Mirman? I mean.
28:56 Charles Liu? Yeah.
28:57 Eugene Mirman? How long would it take us? Like, how long do you think before humans could call, like actively colonize some other place?
29:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You have to colonize it on a level where then you become another civilization that needs no reference back to the original. So, we speak English.
29:10 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
29:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the United States because colonists came from England.
29:13 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
29:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, and so, England in a sense landed on the moon because descendants of their colonies did that.
29:20 Eugene Mirman? Right.
29:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right? So, you, you, you have to become a self-sufficient thing and not just still on the dole.
29:26 Eugene Mirman? Meaning how, how likely is it that there's civilizations like ours that just also can't colonize? That's the.
29:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because we're too stupid or too ineffective to know how.
29:36 Eugene Mirman? But, uh, and then there's other ones like that too.
29:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I don't, I don't see any signs on our horizon that we are that kind of civilization. That we're gonna occupy every corner of the galaxy because we're that awesome. I don't see that happening.
29:48 Eugene Mirman? Alright.
29:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Next question, what do you have?
29:51 Eugene Mirman? Okay. Ronald James from, uh, on Facebook asks, "How fast is the universe expanding from an Earth-centric perspective in light years per Earth year? Also, how fast is the rate of expansion, same units increasing due to this dark energy junk?"
30:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, Charles, you have those numbers on in your head?
30:10 Charles Liu? Well, the current expansion rate of the universe, astronomers refer to as the Hubble constant, right? Which is seventy-three kilometers per second per megaparsec.
30:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hmm.
30:22 Charles Liu? Uh, and if you do the proper unit calculations, that just basically means that we are expanding at about one-fourteen billionth of our own diameter per second.
30:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay, so every year we expand one-fourteen billionth.
30:41 Charles Liu? One-fourteen billionth of our current diameter.
30:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Gotcha.
30:45 Eugene Mirman? Okay. You have that. I did the calculation.
30:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You agree, yeah, you agree.
30:49 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, yeah. When you weren't sure, I was like, I, okay.
30:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? By the way, you can imagine growing anything at that rate.
30:54 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
30:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right? What grows at one-fourteenth of its size? No, one-fourteen billionth of its size per year?
31:02 Eugene Mirman? Hatred.
31:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that is so that that's the rate at which the universe is growing.
31:08 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
31:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, good way to think about it, Charles. I'll use that again for sure.
31:11 Eugene Mirman? Okay. Ocean, uh, McIntyre asks, could neutrinos and their oscillations play a role in detecting mapping and understanding dark energy?
31:25 Charles Liu? Ooh. Hundred percent. Yeah. Um, Neil, you want to explain neutrino oscillations to people?
31:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so neutrino, they're different species. It's like.
31:35 Eugene Mirman? Call. I like the answer of yes. And then I'm like, no, yeah, but I wonder, other than on Star Trek where you create a net and then you can see the invisible alien, but how else does it work?
31:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So neutrinos is one of the, are one of the fundamental particles of the universe. Uh, neutrinos don't decay into some other kind of particle, so that's, we consider them fundamental. And there.
31:57 Eugene Mirman? Would you have enough to use the, to as energy at the end of the universe?
32:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, because once you decay to the lowest energy neutrino, you're done. So we have, there are three different families of neutrinos, and the neutrino oscillations is a fancy word for saying, a neutrino moving through space can actually transmogrify into another species of neutrino. So it'd be like I toss you a basketball and you. Caught a football.
32:19 Eugene Mirman? Right.
32:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. And that story has an interesting past, uh, history because we made a prediction of what rate the sun should be producing neutrinos based on our understanding of how the sun works. And we were not measuring those neutrinos. So either we were completely wrong with our understanding of thermonuclear fusion, or the neutrinos was, were misbehaving. And that's what we found. We didn't know the neutrino would turn into a different species between being formed in the center of the sun and reaching us here on earth and our detector.
32:49 Eugene Mirman? And there's no transfer of energy between it changing from a basketball to a football?
32:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, generally you lose energy. What happens there? You, you?
32:56 Charles Liu? Yeah, you do change energy.
32:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. It's an energy state.
32:58 Charles Liu? The missing neutrino problem was precisely that because I realized that the detectors that we were trying to use to find the neutrinos from the sun were only sensitive to one kind of neutrino at a certain energy level and not to the other kind.
33:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, right. Exactly.
33:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're listening to StarTalk Radio. Stay tuned. More up next.
33:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back. Here's more of StarTalk.
33:37 Eugene Mirman? James Kultus from Twitter asks, what are some of the most exciting astrophysics discoveries we've made in 2015?
33:43 Charles Liu? Oh, well, the new horizons flyby of Pluto.
33:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Pluto. Pluto was rocking the whole year.
33:48 Charles Liu? Dawn's flyby of Ceres. And on September 14th, 2015, there was a gravitational wave that came through earth.
33:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So yeah, so that happened in September. So that was good. Keep going on the list.
34:00 Eugene Mirman? Oh.
34:00 Charles Liu? More?
34:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, yeah, yeah. You gave three things. Go on. Anything else?
34:04 Charles Liu? Duh. Gee.
34:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I got one. Uh, I got one. I, I think this counts. SpaceX successfully relanded the first stage of its rocket. Which opens up a reusability of rockets for the future. It's a, it's a commercial technological achievement, but I think we shouldn't, uh, we shouldn't underestimate what potential value that can have in inexpensive spaceflight going forward.
34:28 Charles Liu? Yeah, Blue Horizons did something like that too, right?
34:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
34:31 Charles Liu? Or, excuse me.
34:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, but it didn't go into orbit.
34:33 Charles Liu? That's right.
34:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. This one orbited, deployed satellites, came back and landed safe.
34:37 Charles Liu? The, the first stage came down.
34:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? First stage, and the rest of it went up to orbit, that's correct. But in this other one, I don't think anything went into orbit.
34:44 Charles Liu? Right, it just went up to the hundred kilometer level.
34:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, the, the atmosphere edge, yeah, yeah. So, good question there, okay, keep it coming.
34:52 Eugene Mirman? Uh, B Damari asks, uh, can dark matter be 3D matter in another dimension? Maybe it fell into a black hole?
35:01 Charles Liu? Uh, it could have, but the thing is, we know so little about dark matter, it can literally be anything.
35:07 Eugene Mirman? That's why we call it dark matter.
35:08 Charles Liu? Cosmologist Rocky Cobb likes to say that dark matter is a model in search of a theory, which basically means, almost like, uh, millennia ago, when people designed things like epicycles and, and retrograde motion explanations, uh, that we're almost at that stage. So, it could literally be anything, it's not likely to be certain things, but it could be anything.
35:29 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
35:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I gotta go with Charles on that.
35:31 Eugene Mirman? Yeah, me too. We're, all three of us. Uh, Jacob Saber asks, uh, when the sun becomes a red giant, what will happen to the asteroid belt and surviving planets?
35:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, nothing.
35:46 Eugene Mirman? Though.
35:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nothing. Yeah, so the red, the sun becomes a red giant, and it'll make a very beautiful nebulae surrounding a very dense core, but, uh, that, the red giant is not going to reach the size of the asteroid belt in the red giant stage, it's not. And so, the, the asteroid belt doesn't know, or care, that the sun...
36:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Swelled up, it's the same amount of mass centered at the center of the solar system. So, uh, now the, the heat distribution among the planet, the, the family of planets and comets and asteroids will be different. Earth would have been burnt to a cinder. Mercury would have been vaporized deep within. Uh, same with Venus. So, yeah.
36:26 Eugene Mirman? Is there a planet we could move to that would be maybe equivalent of what Earth is?
36:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, Charles, I think we can move to Mars, can't we?
36:32 Charles Liu? Uh, no, I'm afraid not.
36:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is it too close?
36:35 Charles Liu? Mars is still too close.
36:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, one of the moons of Jupiter then.
36:38 Charles Liu? You might do alright in the moons of Jupiter, but there is still a big solar wind, right? Remember that the process of becoming a red giant takes hundreds of millions of years. And so in that process, as it grows, more solar material will slough off. And if there's too much of that, it will still blow away atmosphere and things like that. But, uh, once we get out to Titan or maybe Triton, the solid material should be able to hold together at least for a time.
37:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, and we mentioned the moons of Jupiter because Jupiter itself offers no surface on which to land.
37:07 Charles Liu? Right.
37:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But, of course, the moons do.
37:09 Eugene Mirman? Maybe we go to those moons and then as we do that and then we move to the next place. I mean, it's not ideal.
37:14 Charles Liu? But you know, that's five billion years from now.
37:17 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
37:18 Charles Liu? Five billion years of evolution, if we're still needing to be in spaceships to go somewhere solid to live and survive, I think we're in deep trouble evolutionarily.
37:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
37:26 Eugene Mirman? Meaning you think we'll be energy beings?
37:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's kinda what he said.
37:29 Eugene Mirman? Fly, fly around solving crimes?
37:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's kinda what he said, we'll be...
37:33 Charles Liu? I'd appreciate that, sure.
37:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
37:35 Eugene Mirman? Yeah.
37:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright.
37:37 Eugene Mirman? Anybody you think it'll take time, like I can't do it in the next year or two?
37:39 Charles Liu? Let's just say it's something to look forward to. I wouldn't change my retirement plans.
37:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Next question.
37:43 Eugene Mirman? Okay. Um, Terry Carter asks, uh, is there presently any living thing on Earth that could live on the moon or Mars?
37:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, not on the surface, I don't think on the surface, but you can probably hide stuff in the subterranean caverns of Mars. What do you think, Charles?
38:01 Charles Liu? Yeah, it, I think, uh, you know, tardigrades have been big in the news lately as far as extremo tolerant organisms are concerned. These are little mites that live... For example, in places like your eyelashes, right? Uh, they can survive the vacuum of space for a period of time, certainly in, if we go into low earth orbit and then bring them back down, they have been shown to be able to survive the rigors of space for a while. If you can dig them down into, say, Mars, where there's quite a bit of frozen water and maybe occasionally that frozen water becomes liquid, those tardigrades could survive. They probably wouldn't like it, but they could survive.
38:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But probably not the moon, we're saying.
38:39 Charles Liu? Yeah, uh, we don't know enough about the subsurface environment of the moon to really know whether they could survive there. I imagine maybe there are some microorganisms that could, but.
38:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But let me, let me broaden that and say, everything we know about complex organisms tells us we're hosed.
38:56 Eugene Mirman? The cats would not. No, no chance.
38:59 Charles Liu? Right, not, no.
39:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No cats. We're under the five-minute warning.
39:03 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
39:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And with this, we're now the lightning round, okay? Charles, it's, uh, uh, we're, it's soundbite answers. We're gonna get it made through. Okay, ready, go.
39:11 Eugene Mirman? Okay, Thomas asks, if a W-hole entrance exists within an object sphere of influence, does it affect objects on the other side?
39:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know. Charles, go.
39:22 Charles Liu? Yes, but we don't know how yet.
39:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
39:24 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
39:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Next.
39:26 Eugene Mirman? The Teen Poet asks, is it possible to use gravity to manipulate the flow and speed of light and therefore outspeed it?
39:34 Charles Liu? No.
39:35 Eugene Mirman? Okay.
39:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I agree with that. You can't beat a light beam anywhere unless you.
39:40 Eugene Mirman? Not even if you're riding, you're a light beam riding a gravity wave?
39:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, you could, you know, if you ride, uh, you can't surf a gravity wave to go faster than the gravity waves.
39:48 Charles Liu? No. The universe can expand faster than the speed of light overall, but anything in the universe in spacetime cannot go faster than a beam of light going through that same spacetime area.
39:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, the light wins every, every time. Okay, next.
40:00 Eugene Mirman? Okay, Jeffrey wants to know, do you think we could put small asteroids in an orbit around the sun to use as a midpoint to get to Mars?
40:08 Charles Liu? In about sixty or seventy years, I think. What do you think, Neil?
40:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't see the need to have, have a midpoint. What you would want are filling stations along the way and doing a midair or mid-space refueling because you can have energy of motion to get you from Earth to Mar- to Mercury. And that energy, you don't want to compromise that energy. You want to stay with it all the way and ride it in.
40:28 Eugene Mirman? You want to have moving gas stations.
40:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Moving gas stations, exactly. Filling stations. Uh, next.
40:33 Eugene Mirman? Okay, uh, if you had the equivalent money that we spent for Apollo today, what would your goal be?
40:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, uh, that would, in today's dollars, it's about a hundred billion dollars.
40:44 Eugene Mirman? Mm-hmm.
40:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And, I don't, Charles, what would you do with a hundred billion dollars?
40:48 Charles Liu? I would try to stabilize the carbon dioxide emissions in our atmosphere.
40:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Charles, that's so responsible of you. I mean, come on.
40:59 Eugene Mirman? And then, once that was done, would you go to Mars?
41:02 Charles Liu? Oh, a hundred billion isn't enough to go to Mars with modern technology.
41:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know what I'd do. Okay, let me, I would try to be more noble than Charles was. I would use the hundred billion dollars to make all seven billion people on Earth so scientifically literate that any next decision they make
41:18 Eugene Mirman? Alright.
41:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? will involve going to Mars. Because they'll know the wisdom of it.
41:23 Eugene Mirman? And they'll
41:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And they'll fix, and they'll solve the problem. Next.
41:26 Eugene Mirman? Okay, what are some tips you would give to someone studying physics in college?
41:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, take the hardest classes you can. Don't worry about whether it's an A or B in your grade, because at the end of the day, people will beat a path to your door for accomplishing things that no one else could, because that's what it means to take a hard class. Take an easy class and get an A, you show people your grade, but that's the grade everyone else got. And you're no longer distinguished in the marketplace.
41:51 Charles Liu? Neil, that is the most eloquent explanation that I've ever heard of that correct phenomenon.
41:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, says the man who knew nothing but straight A's his whole life. But go, go.
42:02 Eugene Mirman? Why, why do all the planets orbit the sun in the same direction?
42:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, so, uh, back in the mid seventeen hundreds, this is a, this, we think, that was solved by some great philosophers back then. One of them, was it Laplace? Uh, yeah, yeah, it's Laplace. So, it's called the nebular hypothesis. You have a huge cloud out of which you will make the solid stuff from collapsed pockets within it. It rotates. Everything in the universe rotates. And as this cloud collapses, it speeds up. pockets form and therefore everything that forms from that cloud will rotate with the same sense of direction as everything else and so so so potent is that understanding that when something is moving in a weird direction relative to it that tells us it has a different origin and it's interloping through our own solar system and it's really
42:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? really cool I think that Charles do I get your amen on that?
42:53 Charles Liu? You're right unless maybe something in the solar system whacked something else in that solar system.
42:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah you can get whacked in the solar system.
42:59 Eugene Mirman? If a moon hits another moon something could go it could go differently.
43:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I didn't know you worked for the Sopranos yeah okay.
43:04 Charles Liu? Hey.
43:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah you get whacked yeah for example uh uh is it Neptune uh you know Uranus its orbit is flipped completely the other way doesn't rotate in the same rotate in the same direction as everybody else.
43:14 Charles Liu? Oh really?
43:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think something knocked it on its on its ear. You're listening to StarTalk stay tuned for another segment. Welcome back to StarTalk here's more of this week's episode. We're back StarTalk and this is the how tweeted is part of the show Bill Nye joining me here.
43:48 Bill Nye? So good to be here.
43:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good to have you and you tweet at Bill Nye.
43:51 Bill Nye? I do.
43:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very nice so I posted a tweet out not not that long ago just came upon these are like brain droppings each day so but I know you've thought about this so here it is proud to be homo sapiens a curious species with DNA compelling us to explore even if doing so puts your own life at risk.
44:09 Bill Nye? Apparently.
44:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why? If people are ready to kill themselves.
44:13 Bill Nye? Well the word kill themselves are willing to take risks because taking risks well when you take a risk there's a chance you'll succeed at least when I take risks.
44:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know it's interesting because that's not how I think of risk I think when you take a risk there's a chance of you dying.
44:27 Bill Nye? Yeah well there's but there's.
44:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's fascinating.
44:30 Bill Nye? On zero.
44:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a fascinating other way to think about risk.
44:32 Bill Nye? It is a one sum game that which does not kill you what you presume would leave you alive and the risk is taken to in the with the chance of enriching yourself and let me just put it this way everybody you could you're a woman you're a female.
44:49 Bill Nye? You could go with the accountant there in the cave, in ancient cave days, Og and Oggett back there. Or you could take a chance on, uh, on the guy who's a little wild, who goes over the hill and maybe will invent PayPal and just get crazy rich. And so if you put your cards in with that guy, put your lot in with that guy, there's a chance that you will also succeed.
45:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What are you saying about accountants?
45:15 Bill Nye? I'm saying the accountant's a steady guy, but he may not strike it rich. So, uh, there's some value in the striking rich scenario.
45:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, but if that were the case, there'd be no accountants?
45:27 Bill Nye? Oh, no, because everybody's got a passage. The guy who goes over the hill may get killed. There's lions and tigers and bears and parasites.
45:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That'd be three different continents, actually.
45:36 Bill Nye? Uh, uh, all that aside, I was trying to cover them all. There are penguins, uh, and, uh...
45:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You just added a continent, right?
45:45 Bill Nye? And then there's some, there's some new world monkeys that are trouble.
45:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, the point is...
45:50 Bill Nye? Plus, in Australia, everything's venomous.
45:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so, but the guy that goes over the hill gets the, attracts the female, then the male that stays in the cave doesn't reproduce, is that right?
46:03 Bill Nye? No, well, it depends on what choice certain females make. I'm saying there's value in the guy taking risk.
46:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
46:10 Bill Nye? Not that accountants don't take risk, but comedy is based on stereotypes and so, or expectations, which are based on stereotypes. So, my feeling is that the ancient cave accountants were more conservative than the ancient cave over the hill, let's go forward explorers.
46:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, and so the over the hill, let's go forward explorers who never came back, the accountant had all the women.
46:30 Bill Nye? Yeah.
46:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, that's how, the male accountant had all the women, okay.
46:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for listening to StarTalk Radio. I hope you enjoyed this episode. Many thanks to our comedian, our guests, our experts, and I've been your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson. Until next time, I bid you to keep looking up.
Previous The Promise and Peril of the Genomic Revolution Next Extended Classic: Cosmic Queries: Human Impact on Earth with Dr. FunkySpoon Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated