Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Cosmic Jazz, with Wayne Shorter and Herbie Hancock About this episode Neil deGrasse Tyson gets his improv on with legendary jazz musicians Wayne Shorter and Herbie Hancock. Featuring Chuck Nice, Sean Ono Lennon, Stephen Tyson, Mona Chalabi, Charles Limb, and the Columbia University Jazz House.
NOTE: StarTalk All-Access subscribers can listen to this entire episode commercial-free. Find out more at https://www.startalkradio.net/startalk-all-access/
Transcript 7,596 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk. Your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to the Hall of the Universe of the American Museum of Natural History. I'm your host Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and tonight we're gonna talk about the art and science of jazz, featuring my interview with jazz greats Wayne Shorter and Herbie Hancock. So let's do this.
0:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Who's my co-host tonight? Do I get a Chuck in the house?
0:46 Chuck Nice? Yes, you can, my friend.
0:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck Nice!
0:49 Chuck Nice? How are ya? Good to be here, Neil.
0:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good. Welcome back. Thank you, thank you, man. Tweeting at ChuckNiceComic. That's right, baby, ChuckNiceComic. He's feeling the jazz already. That's my jazz voice, man. That's my jazz voice. Now, we need some, like, artists...
1:07 Chuck Nice? We need some cred, man.
1:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We need some, we need some street cred. So we went out and found Sean Ono Lennon. Sean Lennon, welcome to StarTalk. I got the street cred. I'm gangsta.
1:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's a musician, a deep thinker. I think of him as a philosopher, because I've talked to him, and it's like, this guy's brain is everywhere it needs to be to make sense of this universe. Yeah. Wow, thank you.
1:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Who else do we have? We need, we need some art, artsy folk to do this show. And we also have art historian and artist Steve Tyson. Steve, welcome. Glad to be here. Yeah. You're also quite the jazz enthusiast. Oh, yeah, absolutely. So, with my interview with Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter, they both played for the legendary Miles Davis Quintet.
1:57 Chuck Nice? That's right.
1:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Wayne Shorter's a saxophonist and composer.
2:00 Chuck Nice? That's right.
2:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's won 10 Grammy Awards. Herbie Hancock, a pianist, a keyboardist, a composer. He's got 14 Grammy Awards. And it's some of the all-time greats in the field. And I sat down with them recently at Wayne Shorter's home in Hollywood. And at first I asked Wayne how he got started on his path to music. As I always do, I want to know what the tracking is of people's lifelong love. Let's check it out.
2:29 Speaker 02 I was playing hooky from my classes at our side school.
2:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, you never amount to anything if you play hooky.
2:34 Speaker 02 Right. And they caught me. And they caught me. And the vice principal had my mother and father in the office and all that. He said, "What, why didn't you go into class? Let's see where you went when you played hooky." I said, "I went to the Adams Theater around the corner from the school." And saw Jimmy Lunsford, Dizzy Gillespie, Lyle Hampton, and all that. Charlie Parker. He said, "Oh." So what she did, she called the music director and put me in his class.
3:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, there it is.
3:08 Speaker 03 What a great teacher you had.
3:10 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, rather than wrap you over the wrist, they're saying, "There is an energy here to be harnessed."
3:17 Speaker 02 Right.
3:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So not energy, curiosity to be harnessed. That's what we need here.
3:22 Speaker 03 But those are the great mentors that we've had the opportunity to experience that have recognized something. And instead of taking the naysayers' kind of standard, say, standard viewpoint.
3:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, right.
3:37 Speaker 03 They wanted to find out something. And as a consequence, we have a Wayne Shorter.
3:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Steve, you glad we have a Wayne Shorter?
3:47 Speaker 04 I'm very glad we have a Wayne Shorter.
3:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What I wonder is the contingency of life. Because if that didn't happen, if it's enough in him, maybe it might have still expressed itself? I just wonder that. Because you're an artist, you've been an artist as long as you can remember in your life.
4:03 Chuck Nice? So did you play hooky? Don't answer that.
4:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that's a yes face.
4:10 Speaker 04 No, no, not really. But, yeah, what would have happened if the teacher hadn't said, you know, "Let's take that energy and let's see where it can be applied."
4:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do you think he would have never become a musician were it not for that moment? Or that there's enough other possible contingencies in life that it would have manifested?
4:28 Speaker 04 I think it's hard to say.
4:29 Speaker 05 I think it's because mentoring in those days was kind of a requirement for being a jazz master. I mean, Miles taught so many people and brought in young players like Tony Williams and Herbie when they were like teenagers. And, you know, there's not really a culture of that. There's almost like a philistinism now where there's like an anti-cultural, anti-learning...
4:47 Speaker 05 You know, trend in, in the world and I feel like musicians don't mentor young people in the same way that they used to and I think that's why there aren't as many great jazz musicians as there used to be.
4:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did you ever play hooky?
4:58 Speaker 05 I actually was thinking about that, um.
5:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's another, yes, that's a yes.
5:03 Speaker 05 I didn't have to play hooky because I had a Walkman and I remember listening to Bitches Brew in class and getting in trouble.
5:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That, that counts as playing hooky.
5:10 Speaker 05 Yeah, so, um.
5:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Your brain was nodding.
5:12 Speaker 05 Mental hooky, for sure, yeah.
5:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mental hooky, that's a whole other thing.
5:16 Speaker 05 Yeah, so Wayne Shorter was on that record, he basically ruined my academic career.
5:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Steve, how did you know you wanted to be an artist?
5:25 Speaker 04 My father would sit us down and he would take out a pen and he would start drawing and I started seeing that, that wow, this is like a family experience here and he is expressing something and we would look at what he created and I said, well, let me start doing some drawing and by the time I got to high school, uh, the High School of Music and Art, it was music and I was drawing and painting to music, so that further stimulated the interest of this fusion of arts.
5:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, did I say that he's my brother? Did I, did I say that?
5:57 Speaker 04 Yeah.
5:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because I've only ever known you to want to draw. I've, I don't know another Steven Tyson but that one.
6:08 Speaker 04 I loved drawing. That was, that was my vehicle of expression. Simple as that.
6:12 Chuck Nice? And somebody encouraged that for, for you?
6:14 Speaker 04 That's right. And, and having that kind of support system, you know, where our parents would said, you know, well, we can see where the energy is going, we'll support that.
6:24 Chuck Nice? See, I might have been an artist too, but instead they arrested me for my art because they were like, "You cannot spray paint the side of people's garages." That is called destruction of property.
6:35 Speaker 05 Yeah, but that was vandalism then, but now there's a lot of really famous, you know, graffiti artists like Basquiat and stuff. You just needed to break through.
6:42 Chuck Nice? I was ahead of my time.
6:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Steve, you did graffiti too?
6:44 Speaker 04 Yes.
6:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
6:47 Chuck Nice? Yeah. Don't worry Steve, the statute of limitations is up.
6:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Wayne got his path playing hooky, but we had to, how about Herbie? Got to find out Herbie. I asked Herbie too. Let's check it out.
6:59 Speaker 03 There were a couple of reasons I got into music. One of them is that my mother recognized that when my best friend, LaVester Corley, had a piano that his parents had bought him, she noticed that I seemed to like the piano because every time I would go to his apartment, the first thing I'd say is, "Hey, can I play your piano?" Well, I couldn't play the piano. I don't know what I'd play.
7:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Can I bang on your piano?
7:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, right, exactly, exactly. So she said, "Well, he seems to be interested in the piano." So she told my father, "We gotta get this boy a piano." So that was the first thing that happened. But even before I got the piano, even before I went to LaVester's apartment, you know, to ask him if I could play his piano, even before that, I was already taking watches apart and clocks and trying to put them back together because I was always curious and I wanted to see how things worked.
7:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I noticed what you said. You were taking them apart and trying to put them back together.
7:56 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah, yeah, right.
7:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I caught that.
8:01 Speaker 03 That was well and good.
8:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was always with the parents.
8:03 Speaker 03 Right. Well, that was well and good until I tried to take apart my Lionel electric train. Then I got a spanking for that.
8:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, that's got some extra stuff going on.
8:12 Speaker 03 That was when spanking was allowed.
8:15 Speaker 03 Today, that wouldn't happen here.
8:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's been suggested that the next generation, their curiosity is not fostered in exactly that way because nothing can be taken apart. You don't take apart your computer to meddle with its parts. You don't take apart your watch. You don't even have a watch, and if you did, it's digital. So this whole world of the tinkerer, learning how things work, it might be a lost era.
8:40 Speaker 03 There is tinkering in music. And all kids love music.
8:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sean, do you tinker?
8:51 Speaker 05 I am a tinkerer because, I think it's because my dad was famously self-taught, that I always thought when I was young I had to be an autodidact, you know, just teach myself. And, you know, I think I actually would have benefited from some more mentoring, because I was always like, "I'm gonna learn myself." But yeah, I would tinker, taught myself piano, taught myself guitar, taught myself drawing and all that stuff. But, um, it was sort of like a pride thing, like, "I'm gonna do it like my dad did." But in a way, I regret, you know, not studying more seriously.
9:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And Steve, isn't doodling a form of tinkering, right? It is. It's the artist's version of, you know, a proto-engineer taking apart the radio.
9:23 Speaker 04 Absolutely. You know, it's looking, testing things out, trying this, trying that, you know, seeing what feels right, what fits right.
9:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I know in science, we can tinker in many ways, physically with objects, but of course, in the mind.
9:36 Speaker 04 Mm-hmm.
9:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Albert Einstein famously had thought experiments, in German Gedanken experiments, where you just, that's kind of, that's intellectually tinkering.
9:44 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
9:45 Chuck Nice? When you talk about the engineering, if you listen to his music, you can hear the engineering and the structure of his music. Like, one of the favorite songs that I have from him is a song called "Watermelon Man", and the opening sequence is like, a bunch of, like, tropical bird calls made with different...
10:18 Chuck Nice? But, that, when you look at that...
10:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do I get a fist bump too?
10:23 Chuck Nice? But when you look at that, the structure...
10:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Were you actually on that album?
10:28 Speaker 05 You know how they did that with the water bottles, right? That African percussionist, he had two different water bottles and he's going...
10:37 Speaker 05 He's singing and blowing on the bottles. I mean, talk about engineering, right?
10:40 Speaker 04 And it sounds like a really weird pan flute, the way he does it.
10:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So here's the thing.
10:46 Speaker 04 Super cool.
10:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here's the thing, if you're genius, you can see things that are there that no one else noticed. But that ability of the mind has a flipside. And that flipside is like, adjacent. It's like, right there. Because if you are so good at seeing patterns in nature, or anywhere... You could be so good that you'll end up seeing patterns that aren't really there at all.
11:09 Speaker 05 Sure.
11:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And this is crossing over into madness.
11:12 Speaker 05 Sure. Are we talking evil genius here? Well, no, I mean, I was, I was reading about how, um, you know, savants who have a kind of autism, but like a successful reinvent type of autism. It's because they might be missing certain regular parts of the default mode network or their, how most brains work. And so they are forced to create novel neural connections, which are basically insights. And, you know, I know with brain scans, you can see the difference between an insight versus a linear puzzle solving. So if you're given like a math problem, sometimes you can just see the answer, which is inspiration. And then sometimes you just methodically solve it. And insight is what genius is, right? And where that's what creativity is.
11:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's where you're assigned to genius.
11:53 Speaker 05 Exactly. Thank you.
11:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're featuring my interview with jazz greats Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter. And while in Wayne Shorter's home, I found something special when I was rummaging around his house. Check it out.
12:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This, what is this?
12:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Dated 1949.
12:16 Speaker 02 1949. I saw a movie called Rocket Ship XM.
12:21 Speaker 03 That's the first, first book I ever read.
12:24 Speaker 02 Yeah.
12:24 Speaker 03 Robert Heinlein.
12:25 Speaker 02 Robert Ship, yeah.
12:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so I look at it, so this is.
12:29 Speaker 02 And I sat.
12:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What, what, what is, what? Did you draw these?
12:34 Speaker 02 Yeah.
12:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is a comic book.
12:37 Speaker 02 Yes.
12:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With rocket ships.
12:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah.
12:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You even had the, the bullet shaped ship that was common at the time.
12:44 Speaker 02 Yeah.
12:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This was designed, that concept is derived from the V2 rocket.
12:49 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
12:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That was used in the Second World War. Because that rocket left the atmosphere before it re-entered and hit its target. And anyone at the time knew that the future of space exploration is going to have to have something that looks like that.
13:01 Speaker 02 Yep.
13:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because we'd never sent anything outside of the atmosphere before. So in the 1940s, the 1950s, everybody who drew a spaceship, the spaceship looked exactly like this.
13:09 Speaker 02 Yeah.
13:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, did we, how old were you?
13:14 Speaker 02 I was, uh, let's see, 15.
13:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is out of control.
13:19 Speaker 02 Yes, and in 15.
13:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wayne!
13:21 Speaker 02 You start looking at the anatomy of girls.
13:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, there's some curvy linear shapes in here.
13:31 Speaker 02 And when I was drawing and my parents would walk through, I sit in a big armchair and they walk through the room. I was drawing and I do like this.
13:40 Speaker 02 Put my hand.
13:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, cuz.
13:41 Speaker 02 My mother, she knew what was happening. She just.
13:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's incredible. These are some shapely people you're drawing here.
13:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
13:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so. Plus the balance is incredible, right? It's just perfect. Wayne. Wayne.
13:56 Speaker 02 And when I made a mistake, I would make some landscape and I was thinking, there's no such thing as a mistake.
14:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I love that.
14:03 Speaker 02 You can't go back. You gotta, gotta.
14:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, Chris, it's just in pen.
14:07 Speaker 02 That's why I drew with an indelible pen to make, to, to kind of parallel. You can't go over anything. Gotta keep going forward.
14:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Keep going forward. That's. Transforming the negative into the positive.
14:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
14:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm still reacting to it. That is super cool. Steve, you drew comics as a kid, I remember.
14:28 Speaker 04 Yes, I used to like drawing comics a lot. I think a lot of it had to do with wanting to tell a story. You know, observing life and wanting to tell a story and, and nobody's a greater storyteller than Wayne on his saxophone.
14:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
14:41 Speaker 04 And the fact that he could sustain a story for 54 pages.
14:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In his, in his book.
14:48 Speaker 04 In his book, yeah. I mean, that's incredible. That's incredible. And his skill at, at the age of 17 or something.
14:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 15.
14:56 Speaker 04 15? I mean, it's amazing.
14:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The man's got some talent.
14:59 Speaker 04 Right.
14:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it also captured his science interest cuz he could have drawn just landscapes or something. Right. But there's a rocket ship. There's, there's, you know, planetary surfaces and I'm always enchanted when I find artists that have been touched in any way. Excuse me? By science. Oh, sorry.
15:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Wayne Shorter's interest in science, it manifests in so many ways. Perhaps birthed with that series of comics he drew, but there's more to come. Let's check it out. So Wayne, you've got space-related titles. For, I got the, I've been looking at the list. Orbits, On the Milky Way Express, Supernova, Universe, Pegasus. These are constellations, concepts, ideas.
15:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
15:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So are you a closet astrophysicist? That's what I'm really, that's the whole point of this interview, to find out.
15:53 Speaker 02 Yes, when I went to NYU, I wrote a piece called Universe. You know, my first year, first freshman year.
16:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you and the universe go way back.
16:02 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I can talk about the universe, but if an artist is touched by cosmic themes, it enables us all to feel the universe. That's why I like it when I see it, I'm just saying.
16:20 Chuck Nice? All right.
16:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so I wonder, Sean, how does science influence your music?
16:25 Speaker 05 Well, I think I'm especially dorky in that I have quite a few songs that contain science-inspired lyrics. I could tell you some if you want.
16:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What, your latest album is titled what?
16:35 Speaker 05 My new band is called The Delirium and our album is called The Monolith of Phobos, which was inspired by the C-SPAN Buzz Aldrin clip where he reveals to us-
16:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was on C-SPAN, no one saw it.
16:45 Speaker 05 I know, I don't know. I don't know, I thought, but you know, he reveals that there's this monolith on Phobos, essentially, which is the moon of Mars. And I'm not saying it's an artificial structure, but it's odd that it's there, let's put it that way.
16:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do you have other scientifically-inspired lyrics?
17:01 Speaker 05 Yeah, I do. I actually, since this is a jazz-themed show, I thought I'd mention, I wrote the lyrics for a John Zorn song. He's a famous jazz musician from New York. And they're pretty science-inspired. They're like, "The sun is a selfish lover 'cause the moon's often left half-full, and stars always stare at the gutter 'cause even light has to bend some rules. Man will fly farther and farther to escape woman's gravity, but there is a hole at the heart of every galaxy."
17:31 Chuck Nice? Yo, that is hot!
17:34 Chuck Nice? You like that?
17:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I love that. All right, coming up, how would you explain jazz to aliens? That's next when StarTalk returns.
17:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk from the American Museum of Natural History. We're featuring my interview with jazz legends Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter. I asked them, what is jazz? Check it out. An alien just arrived from Mars, and they're curious, and they have a sense of hearing, and you need to tell them what jazz is. What are you gonna say?
18:17 Speaker 03 I would, I would take them to hear the music.
18:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
18:23 Speaker 03 And then, if they had some questions after that, uh, I would respond to the question.
18:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, so you wouldn't try to explain it up front?
18:32 Speaker 03 No.
18:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just take them to the club?
18:34 Speaker 03 That's no fun.
18:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Take them to the club.
18:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, right.
18:37 Speaker 02 You know what I'd do?
18:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What?
18:39 Speaker 02 I'd put them in front of a mirror.
18:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh.
18:43 Speaker 02 An Earth mirror.
18:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you say that's jazz?
18:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Jazz is you.
18:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, jazz is you.
18:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Even when you're an alien?
18:52 Speaker 03 It's very hard to explain it.
18:56 Speaker 03 So maybe Wayne's on to something.
18:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, consider that the bar scene in Star Wars, they're playing jazz. How's that for intergalactic?
19:06 Speaker 03 There we go.
19:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're not playing classical music, it's not a ballad, nobody's singing anything, the aliens are jamming.
19:13 Speaker 03 Yep.
19:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? On their, on their alien musical instruments, but it was clearly jazz.
19:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think there was no question about it.
19:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, something I don't understand. Steve, you know, I happen to like jazz, I was a latecomer to the genre, but there are people who hate jazz. And can you explain that?
19:38 Speaker 04 No.
19:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. Shaun, could it be that improvisation has an unpredictability that creates discomfort in us? That we need the confidence that what comes is something we expect, rather than something we don't?
19:54 Speaker 05 I don't think so, because people like blues, and that's an improvised form of music, and there's a lot of soloing in blues, you know. I think it has to do with being ready for, you know, stretched harmonies and dissonance and chords that are more dense and complex than, you know, simple triads, which is what rock and roll and blues is usually about. Jazz has more complex geometries that are harder to appreciate if you don't have a sort of foundation to get it, I think.
20:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It just makes me wonder if human spontaneity, the edge of creativity and freedom, everyone else, whatever you've just discovered there, nobody else is ready for it yet. It's gotta sort of work its way in and create a level of comfort within us.
20:33 Speaker 05 But in the 30s and 40s, I mean, even like the early bebop, you know, everyone loved jazz. It's just now, people aren't as into it, because, you know, they'd rather listen to Bieber or something, they're believers. And I think it has to do with the-
20:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Believe like Justin Bieber?
20:46 Speaker 05 Yeah, I think it has to do with the culture, you know, because I don't think jazz was so unpalatable when it was, you know, it's the golden era.
20:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, Steve, what is jazz to you?
20:55 Speaker 04 Well, jazz is an expression of the human spirit.
20:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I brought an alien. A Martian is not human, so are you gonna tell the Martian is an expression of the human spirit? They're not gonna get it, for sure.
21:11 Speaker 04 Well, to the extent that the human spirit is an expression of life, and the alien is a living thing, then I would say that that's where the connection is.
21:20 Speaker 05 What you gonna do with that? Snap! Yeah, but if they're not human, who's to say that they would even hear the frequencies of music that we play music in?
21:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because I prefaced my question that they have audio sensors.
21:31 Speaker 05 Okay, of course.
21:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
21:33 Speaker 05 Take that! I agree with Herbie, I mean, you know, Frank Zappa said that writing about music is like dancing about architecture, so I feel like there's not much you can do other than just, you know, jam with them or show them a jazz show, you know?
21:48 Chuck Nice? All I know is I don't know what to believe anymore. Wayne Shorter and Herbie Hancock don't know what the hell jazz is, and I just found out his father was in a rock and roll band.
21:59 Speaker 05 You don't like Def Leppard, man? Come on.
22:02 Speaker 05 What's wrong with you?
22:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wait, Chuck, do you have any insight as to why the French love jazz more than Americans do?
22:09 Chuck Nice? Because the French love anything that we don't like. They're doing it to spite us. You don't love your own America, awesome? Good for you. We love it.
22:20 Speaker 05 Do they really like it more?
22:22 Chuck Nice? You know, I think jazz is celebrated all around the world more so than it is here in America.
22:27 Speaker 05 I think in France it's because they didn't have segregation and there was still segregation in America, so a lot of jazz musicians were able to tour and thrive there, so they were touring there a lot.
22:34 Chuck Nice? That's a very good... But how do you explain Japan, then?
22:38 Speaker 05 Japan? Well, Japan, they, you know, they're into lots of different things.
22:44 Speaker 05 Seriously, they love all kinds of music.
22:46 Chuck Nice? Yeah, this is true.
22:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, so I tried to get Wayne Shorter to express sounds of the universe through jazz, through his saxophone.
22:55 Chuck Nice? Okay.
22:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I prepped him for a cosmic phenomenon to see how he... Can he roll with it?
23:02 Chuck Nice? Uh-oh, this is gonna be deep.
23:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let's check it out. I want to describe something astrophysical to you, and I'm wondering if you could convert that to a musical expression. In the center of the sun, energy is created by fusion, and a photon of light is born. This photon of light, careening back and forth, eventually escapes the sun. That takes hundreds of thousands of years for that photon to get from the center of the sun to its surface, and it takes...
23:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Eight minutes to get from the sun to earth.
23:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is there music in that?
23:48 Speaker 02 Yeah.
23:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Can you feel the photon?
23:54 Speaker 02 Feel the photon?
23:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Feel the pho- I like that. Feeling, that's an album title right there, Feeling the Photon.
23:59 Speaker 02 The photon fears nothing.
24:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
24:13 Speaker 02 And if I move in any direction other than that,
24:18 Speaker 02 I think thi- this one thing incorporates a tone that's really, like, incorporates all of the movement and struggles and everything like that, and all of the short-term goals and stuff like that that other people be looking for. And this photon is wrapping around that whole thing for millions and millions of years. And something else is wrapping around that. And that's us.
25:01 Chuck Nice? Okay, now we know why people hate jazz.
25:07 Chuck Nice? What the hell was that? Did you see your face in that clip? He was like, "Huh!" You were like, "What the hell are you doing? What are you doing, Wayne Shorter?"
25:22 Speaker 05 Well, you know, Herbie and Wayne are Buddhists, man. It's like the sound of one hand clapping. That was the sound of one photon rocking, you know?
25:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not even Shaun Livingston can clean it up.
25:34 Speaker 05 I tried.
25:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, I want to hear another take on the sound of the photon's journey from deep inside the sun.
25:42 Speaker 02 I think we all do.
25:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And we've got a band called the Columbia University Jazz House to help us out. Guys, can you give it a shot?
26:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think that was Wayne's note.
26:40 Chuck Nice? That was Wayne's note. Who knew he was right all along?
26:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Do you think maybe he had that whole piece in his head?
26:53 Chuck Nice? No, I don't.
26:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then just the note was the last expression of it?
26:56 Chuck Nice? Yes, that's exactly what happened.
27:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sean, is that your take on it?
27:05 Speaker 05 Yeah, I think that his brain is like the sun in that piece. And it took many years for the thought of the photon to escape his neural network. And then by the time we heard it, it was escaping his brain as a single note, which is like the eight-minute travel to the earth.
27:26 Chuck Nice? So what we heard was the eight-minute journey to earth, but not the hundred-thousand-year struggle?
27:34 Speaker 05 Exactly.
27:35 Chuck Nice? Right on.
27:36 Speaker 05 Exactly.
27:36 Chuck Nice? Now the whole thing makes sense.
27:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, talking about curiosity and creativity through the lens of the great American innovation called jazz.
27:50 Chuck Nice? Yes.
27:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And right now, it's time for everybody's favorite segment, Cosmic Queries. There we go. This is where we answer questions from our fans. And tonight, we took your questions about the math and physics of jazz.
28:06 Chuck Nice? And our first question is from Jessica Schaffner from Detroit, Michigan. She says, "Songs written in major keys tend to be more happy and uplifting, while minor keys tend to give feelings of melancholy. Is there a possible biological reason, or is this a learned trait?"
28:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sean?
28:26 Speaker 05 I think it's partly cultural, because if you look at Indian music, which is microtonal, and Middle Eastern music, there's a lot of minor thirds that are sort of celebratory lyrically. So I don't think that minor is physically inherently sad, although I do think it's more common in cultures to associate the major third with a happy feeling. But certainly, I do think there are examples of a minor third being happily sung.
29:00 Chuck Nice? So Jessica, your answer is yes and no.
29:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Next.
29:08 Chuck Nice? Thank you, sir. Our next question is from Matt Snyder from McConaughey, Pennsylvania. And he says, "When humans travel to Mars, would they be able to play and hear music outside of their shelter? Or is the atmosphere too thin?"
29:25 Chuck Nice? Now, that is a real question.
29:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, it is. I got this. Bring it on. Well, you may remember from your physics class that there's one of these great demos where they have a ringing bell inside of a jar, a glass jar, and they evacuate slowly the air out of that jar. And you're listening to the bell ring, and as the air comes out, the bell gets weaker and weaker and weaker. But it's still hammering away, and there's a point where you can hear nothing at all. It doesn't mean there's no air in there. It means there's not enough air to communicate the vibrations of the bell through a medium, through the glass, and then through the regular air in the room.
30:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So there's a thinness of air below which you're not gonna hear any acoustic sounds. And Martian atmosphere is like, it's a fraction, a small fraction of Earth's atmospheric pressure. So I'm thinking you're not hearing much noise at all.
30:21 Chuck Nice? Oh, very cool.
30:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Chuck.
30:23 Chuck Nice? Yes.
30:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not only do you read me cosmic queries.
30:25 Chuck Nice? That is correct.
30:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You are also our senior sidewalk science correspondent.
30:29 Chuck Nice? Yes.
30:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what do you have for us tonight in math and music?
30:33 Chuck Nice? Well, I actually dropped in on the guys of the Columbia University Jazz House at their dorm.
30:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Really?
30:42 Chuck Nice? Yes, to see if they could make math into music.
30:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, let's check it out.
30:48 Chuck Nice? I can hear the guys playing right now. See? Jazz House Jam Session. Come on, guys.
30:57 Chuck Nice? Stews are playing in the kitchen. What's up, guys?
31:03 Chuck Nice? So I'm here with Kevin and Andy, the brass section of the Jazz House.
31:06 Speaker 06 She's our woodwinds, so.
31:07 Chuck Nice? I don't appreciate your tone, Kevin. All right, guys, so if music is math and math is music, can you play this?
31:14 Speaker 06 Oh, yeah, of course.
31:15 Chuck Nice? Yeah?
31:15 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah.
31:24 Chuck Nice? No, that's not, that's not the song. That's not the song. That's not the song. That's not the song. That's not the song. But I hear some more music. Ah, who do we have here?
31:37 Chuck Nice? What's up, man?
31:38 Speaker 07 Hey, how you doing?
31:38 Chuck Nice? All right, what's your name?
31:39 Speaker 07 David.
31:40 Chuck Nice? David, how are you, buddy?
31:41 Speaker 07 I'm doing great.
31:41 Chuck Nice? Is this your dorm room?
31:42 Speaker 07 This is my room, yeah.
31:43 Chuck Nice? Get a lot of jazz action happening? Lot of, lot of improvised and going on in it?
31:48 Speaker 07 No.
31:49 Chuck Nice? Okay. How important is math to music?
31:52 Speaker 07 Uh, math is absolutely essential to music, in my opinion. Uh, it's the, it's the foundation of everything that we know about rhythm and harmony.
32:00 Chuck Nice? Beats and measures, measures and beats.
32:02 Speaker 07 That's right.
32:03 Chuck Nice? So let me ask you, if math is music and music is math, can you play this?
32:09 Speaker 07 Of course, it's one of my favorite tunes.
32:10 Chuck Nice? Really?
32:15 Chuck Nice? Really? That is not, that's not the song. Like, I don't know that song. But I hear some drums. I hear some drums. Nice. Alright. Who do we have here? My name is Daniel. Daniel, can I ask you a couple of questions?
32:32 Chuck Nice? Alright, Daniel, if music is math and math is music, can you play this? Give me a week. I don't have a week, man. It's our show. Alright? Do my best. Do it.
32:47 Chuck Nice? That is not it. That's not it. That's not it! That is definitely not it. How about you guys? Can you guys? Can you guys play this? That's what I love about the jazz house. There's musicians everywhere.
33:04 Chuck Nice? Yeah. That's it. I think that's it.
33:10 Chuck Nice? Yeah! That's what I'm talking about!
33:20 Chuck Nice? Yeah! That's it. That's it. That's it! That's it! Yeah, Neil! You see that, Neil? That's music and math, baby!
33:36 Chuck Nice? Shout!
33:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, up next, jazz greats Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter explain what it takes to be creative on StarTalk.
34:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're back for StarTalk, right here at the Rose Center for Earth and Space. We're featuring my interview with jazz legends, jazz greats, Herbie Hancock and Wayne Shorter. And I asked, what do they do as creative artists to overcome any forces in society that might constrain their creativity? So let's check that out.
34:25 Speaker 02 You get a lot of resistance from the practical business world. We cannot sell this because it's not a viable product, too ethereal, something like that. And then we will blame, there's a tendency to blame these marketing people and everything for not marketing what we call, something called art. And they stand as resistance. But when we get on a path of enlightenment, we know that the resistance, we have to investigate what resistance means. If we take the example that an airplane cannot take off without resistance, what does that mean?
35:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In fact, the airplane takes off into the wind.
35:11 Speaker 02 Yes.
35:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because only into the wind does it achieve maximum lift.
35:15 Speaker 02 Yes.
35:16 Speaker 03 So you need that resistance.
35:17 Speaker 02 The resistance that people present, instead of money, power, and fame that they want, their real function is to be the resistance that's needed for the creative process, whether they know it or not.
35:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Did he just justify all the naysayers that are out there? Saying the creative people in the world need the naysayers? Did I just hear him say that?
35:44 Speaker 03 We actually do, we have a phrase in Buddhism that is turning poison into medicine.
35:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
35:51 Speaker 03 And much of it comes, I think, from a misunderstanding of the relationship between you as a human being and external circumstances. And if you understand that that relationship is really a symbiotic relationship, and that much of what happens to you that you blame for your suffering.
36:16 Speaker 03 Actually has to do with a much deeper part of your own life. In Buddhism, we call it the fundamental darkness. You know, and we also have our fundamental enlightenment. And so, actually through doing this practice, you strengthen the fundamental enlightenment part of who you are, and that really helps you with the idea of stress and understanding.
36:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because there's always forces that will stress people out. So it's not so much, I suppose, of getting rid of stress. It's dealing, knowing how to navigate the stress.
36:50 Speaker 03 You navigate. That's Buddhism.
36:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay. I'll be Buddhist for the day.
36:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
36:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Sean, you have constrainers in your music business?
37:02 Speaker 05 I do think what they're saying is true, that, you know, resistance, the metaphor is beautiful. Resistance is what makes an airplane fly. I mean, they're obviously Buddhists and very philosophical, those guys. But, you know, for instance, Bach...
37:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I thought it was just physics.
37:16 Speaker 05 Some of Bach's most beautiful... But some of Bach's most beautiful pieces are very constrained, like fugues and cantatas. And, you know, for example, there's the Crab Canon that Bach wrote, which is a Mobius shape, and it's a palindrome. And, you know, that's very restricted. It has to be completely symmetrical. But it's a very beautiful piece to listen to. So I think there is a direct relationship between rules and constraints and creativity. It's sort of like a balance. It's a tug-of-war.
37:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it turns out you could actually bring some science into this conversation of creativity in music. Because after all, this is StarTalk, and we find science in every nook and cranny it could possibly hide. So we found someone who studies what playing jazz looks like in your brain.
38:04 Speaker 03 Nice.
38:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nice. Dr. Charles Limb is a neuroscientist and jazz musician at the University of California, San Francisco. And he's standing by live on video call. Drew, can you bring him on? Dr. Lim.
38:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you're a surgeon, a neuroscientist, a saxophone player, and as I understand your profile, you've carried out research on the neural basis of musical creativity.
38:34 Chuck Nice? When are you gonna do something with your life, man?
38:38 Speaker 08 No, that's right. I've been studying how the brain enables us to not only hear music, but also make music. And, you know, it started for me as, like I said, an obsession with sound. And then turned into the idea that I should actually use something like neuroscience to address the topic and learn more about it.
38:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So tell me about the images of people, was it playing or listening to jazz? What's going on in their brain? What have you found?
39:01 Speaker 08 Sure. So we used a functional MRI to look at jazz pianos' brains while they're playing, improvising, and we compared the improvised brain from the memorized brain. And we found a pretty interesting thing, which is that the prefrontal cortex of the brain was shutting down when musicians were improvising in comparison to memorizing. And this is a big portion of the brain, responsible for a lot of things. But to some extent, conscious self-monitoring might be the most important role of the brain that gets shut down during improvisation.
39:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So just so I understand, there's the improvisational brain that you observe, and then you said the memorized brain. So that would just be sort of aping something that you've learned and try to get it perfect?
39:44 Speaker 08 Yeah, we basically had musicians memorize a standard and play that tune, and then improvise on it. It was just the blues. And we looked at the difference between when they were soloing on the blues and playing a memorized blues melody, and that the brain changes radically.
39:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what can we learn? I mean, so that's just factual information. Now what does that mean?
40:04 Speaker 08 So I think it means that creativity is kind of a novel combination of ordinary processes in the brain, meaning that the brain is basically shutting itself off in order to allow for an unrestricted flow of ideas during improvisation. It's the brain doing something that it's very well-equipped to do in order to come up with a new idea.
40:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Except some people are better at it than others.
40:24 Speaker 08 Absolutely.
40:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But can we assert that creativity?
40:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is hardwired into the brain? Or do you have to train your brain to be creative? Because we agree, not everyone is equally creative. And some people are not creative at all. And some people are leading us into the future by virtue of their creativity.
40:45 Speaker 08 I think that humans are inherently creative. It's just that there are multiple forms of creativity. Some of them that are in the art realm and some of them that are in a very mundane realm. So this conversation is creative. When you're driving home from work and you're zipping through traffic, you're improvising. I think that the human brain is hardwired to create because that's how we survive as a species. One thing is for sure, though. We as scientists understand very little about how humans are able to be creative. And when we think about all of the capacities that human beings have, the one, the capacity for creativity may be the most important thing that we've had as a species. And so to be able to examine the creative brain as it's real time generating new ideas may be one of the most important things for us to understand how it is that we're able
41:29 Speaker 08 to generate novelty and how does it will come up with new solutions for problems in the future. And I think that one way to view this is that artists may be our creative experts in our society and they're sort of trained to generate new ideas. This is what they do for a living. And I think that in the case of the jazz musician or the freestyle rapper or any other artist who does spontaneous improvisation as their main craft, they've essentially trained their brains over many years of study to be able to improvise on the fly. And this is not something that you just sort of wake up and can do all of a sudden. You really have to practice this craft. And I think that these people that have devoted their lives to these kinds of arts have certainly figured out a way to get their brains to generate ideas in a way that we did not previously know how to do.
42:12 Speaker 08 And maybe by looking at how they're able to do these things, we can understand some of the basic fundamental mechanisms of how the brain is able to create.
42:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right. Thank you, Charles.
42:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're talking about creativity and art and in science. And it turns out, there's extra insight we can get into what it is to get extra insight. Because we've got Mona, who's got some data for us. Mona, can I get some data, please?
42:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is Mona Chalabi, she's a data journalist with The Guardian. What do you have, Mona?
42:47 Speaker 09 Thanks, Neil. I wanted to look at this connection between music and math. And what I found was a study that was published in the journal Nature, where people were asked to listen to Mozart Sonata K448 for about 10 minutes before taking a test. And what they found was that people...
43:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Before taking a math test?
43:04 Speaker 09 No, it was a test of spatial reasoning skills, right? And those are skills like the ability to visualize an object and then try and build it out of Legos. They're skills that are related to problem solving, so they're relevant to subjects like physics or math. And again, these people demonstrated better spatial reasoning skills after taking the test. In another study, they actually found that rats who had listened to Mozart Sonata were able to navigate a maze faster than rats who hadn't listened to the music.
43:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whoa!
43:30 Speaker 09 I know, it's incredible, right? Loads and loads of studies have found this, but there is a bit of a snag. They call it Mozart's effect, but it only seems to improve spatial reasoning skills for about 10 to 15 minutes. So it doesn't really hang around too long.
43:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you have to listen to Mozart continually?
43:45 Speaker 09 Oh, I don't think that will do it.
43:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, wait, so we have, in New York City, in our subway, we have street musicians, some of whom play Mozart. So that's why the rats navigate the subway tunnels really well.
43:56 Speaker 05 I was gonna say, like, that's the last time I'm listening to Mozart in my house, because I don't want to encourage the rats to get any smarter. Yeah, exactly.
44:04 Speaker 09 But anyway, the research might help explain why Herbie Hancock developed an early interest in science and music.
44:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wow.
44:11 Chuck Nice? Super cool.
44:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Very cool.
44:13 Chuck Nice? So now, what happened to those rats when they listened to hip-hop?
44:18 Speaker 09 I don't know.
44:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That study hasn't been published, they're still working on that one.
44:21 Speaker 09 The controls in that experiment were compared to white noise or no music at all.
44:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
44:27 Chuck Nice? And what is white noise?
44:30 Speaker 05 That's a...
44:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Chuck is very sensitive.
44:34 Chuck Nice? I'm sensitive to race, I don't like, I don't see color.
44:36 Speaker 05 White noise, yeah.
44:38 Chuck Nice? To me, white noise is just like, "Oh, God, turn that down."
44:41 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's when Donald Trump's audience claps, that's white noise.
44:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So Mona, I'll explain to Chuck what white noise is.
44:47 Speaker 09 Okay, thanks very much.
44:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you, Mona.
44:48 Speaker 09 Take care, thank you.
44:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, there's some famous people where the art and the science was one and the same. And at the top of that list is, of course, Leonardo da Vinci. And there was nobody like Leonardo.
45:03 Chuck Nice? Yes.
45:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I mean, to him, how could you possibly say, "Tell me about your art distinct from your science"? No, it is the one and the same. No difference. And then you have other places where engineering has affected art and art has affected engineering. You look at the design of Apple products and you say, "Well, there's not only the beauty of the design, but the functionality of the product." And Herbie Hancock is definitely thinking about this connection. So I asked Herbie, just to see his take on this, especially given his background in engineering. Let's check it out.
45:40 Speaker 03 The scientific community created this technological age. Where did that impetus come from? If you ask many of the people like Larry Page, it was music. He said it was music.
45:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Larry Page was one of the co-founders of Google.
45:58 Speaker 03 Yes. There are many people who we revere in the scientific community. Einstein played violin, and I've seen that happen over and over and over again. So if these people who have this attachment to the arts created this technological age that we're living in, then in order for it to thrive, we need the arts the same way they needed it. To me, the arts are like the heart. And I think it's a crime, really, to dismiss the value of the arts in the human experience.
46:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You know, when I think about creativity and art and science, I see what's similar and then I also notice what's different. And what's different is, if Beethoven were never born, nobody would ever compose the Ninth Symphony. That came out of him and nobody else.
47:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Whereas if Einstein were never born, somebody would have eventually discovered relativity. He was kind of ahead of his time, so it would have taken a little longer. Might have been a combination of scientists. But he is discovering a pre-existing thing in the universe.
47:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the creativity of the scientist is wrapping our head around a pre-existing reality. Whereas the artist has no pre-existing reality. They can create a reality. And maybe it's a little too far for whoever's looking at it to understand it at the time. So we all sort of drag behind it and eventually say, hey, wow, they were on to something. Because that's the true moving of a frontier forward. Did what you do kind of leave people behind and they got to run and catch up after you? So while both fields are deeply creative, in science, the universe is the judge, jury, and executioner of our creativity.
48:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In art, in music, the ultimate judge is the human spirit and the human soul. And that's what it looks like from the cosmic perspective. Guys, take us home.
48:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You've been watching StarTalk. I've been your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson. As always, keep looking up. Thanks, Chuck. Sean. Brother Man Steve.
Previous #ICYMI: Cosmic Queries: Tennis Special Edition Next #ICYMI: The Immaculate Reception Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated