Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast Bug Splat Galaxies with Mordecai-Mark Mac Low About this episode What type of planets orbit black holes? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Negin Farsad sit down with Mordecai-Mark Mac Low to crack open the mysteries of galaxy collisions, dark matter, and the massive planetary systems around black holes.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Negin, we learned all about colliding galaxies and the formation of planets.
0:04 Negin Farsad? I had no idea how much banging and colliding and smashing there was in this universe.
0:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All the time, coming right up on StarTalk.
0:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide.
0:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk begins right now.
0:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is StarTalk. Neil deGrasse Tyson here, your personal astrophysicist. This is going to be cosmic queries on the formation of planets in the universe.
0:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I got with me my co-host Negin Farsad.
0:47 Negin Farsad? Oh my God, hello.
0:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back.
0:49 Negin Farsad? I'm so excited. I have, I've, I've like peeped at some of these questions and they are.
0:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, yeah, because they're already.
0:56 Negin Farsad? Querylicious.
0:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, querylicious. I love that. Very good. And just a reminder, you, you still have your Fake the Nation podcast.
1:05 Negin Farsad? That's right.
1:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Comes out every week, every week. And it's a delight anytime I hear you on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me.
1:11 Negin Farsad? Thank you.
1:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's the NPR, right?
1:13 Negin Farsad? Yeah.
1:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a NPR mainstay.
1:14 Negin Farsad? An NPR mainstay. I've got a lot of tote bags to prove it. We have a good time.
1:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right. Let me introduce you to my guest today. He's a longtime friend and colleague, Mordecai Mark McLough. Mordecai. Well, hello, Neil. It's weird to. It's only been thirty-seven years that we've known each other. Yeah. So we, I mean, we came up together, you know, through graduate school, not at the same graduate school, but we're about the same generation. And it was, he's one of the earliest hires into our brand new department of astrophysics. Number one. Oh, you were the number one hire. I am number one. Okay, that's another way to say it.
1:58 Negin Farsad? Is that a way of saying that he's better than you?
2:02 Speaker 02 No.
2:02 Negin Farsad? Is that what I'm understanding?
2:03 Speaker 02 He founded the department.
2:05 Negin Farsad? Oh, gotcha.
2:05 Speaker 02 I was his number one hire.
2:08 Negin Farsad? Oh, gotcha, gotcha.
2:08 Speaker 02 Let's be clear here.
2:09 Negin Farsad? Okay, you're just better than everyone else here.
2:11 Speaker 02 Yeah, there we go.
2:13 Negin Farsad? But Neil was still better than you.
2:14 Speaker 02 That's what we're looking for.
2:14 Negin Farsad? Okay, got it.
2:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Number one means he was hired first, not that he's the number one guy. We're all number one here. And what was a delight in your research profile is that you just need a powerful computer and the universe succumbs to you.
2:33 Speaker 02 Well, it's a good sandbox.
2:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Tell me what you do, because most people's stereotype of the astronomer, astrophysicist, we're at the telescope, or maybe we're crunching numbers on, not numbers, but we're on a theorist's notepad, and you are in the middle of that.
2:51 Speaker 02 I'm a simulator.
2:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Simulator.
2:53 Speaker 02 So I do, I run computer programs that...
2:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That you write?
2:59 Speaker 02 Well, that I and my colleagues write.
3:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
3:01 Speaker 02 That, um, that describe how parts of the universe behave using mathematical equations derived by theorists, but using the computer to derive consequences that would be absolutely impossible to do with pencil and paper mathematics. So when things get hairy, we pull out a computer.
3:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mmm.
3:26 Negin Farsad? Do you ever like sim, use your powers of simulation for like, you know, a vision of a grilled cheese sandwich, or is it mostly just like space?
3:35 Speaker 02 Well, I would say that I may not do the grilled cheese sandwiches, but there is a simulator somewhere who does.
3:42 Negin Farsad? Does, okay, okay.
3:43 Speaker 02 And they probably work for Kraft or someone.
3:46 Negin Farsad? And they should be your next guest.
3:48 Speaker 02 There you go.
3:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, Mordecai, I remember when we were coming up, there was a catalog... Of galaxies, peculiar galaxies. In fact, it was called the Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies.
4:00 Speaker 02 Arpsworth.
4:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Arp, yeah, Halton Arp. And we all scratched our heads, wondering, how would nature make objects that look like this?
4:09 Speaker 02 Like bug splats?
4:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, the galaxies are just, what? What? And I think in our lifetime, bringing computers to bear on that problem, we would fully understand how you get a disturbed-looking galaxy.
4:28 Speaker 02 So that's actually an interesting story, because the very first simulation that was done of colliding galaxies that made a bug splat and reproduced these peculiar observations was done in the 1940s using lamps and photo detectors.
4:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hmm.
4:48 Speaker 02 And as an analog computer. Because the lamps simulated gravity, because light drops off in intensity just like gravity does. And that actually revealed the basic picture that you get these splats, these tidal tails, we call them. But then we came along and refined that insight.
5:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? With actual computers.
5:12 Speaker 02 Yes, but the first one was those photo detectors.
5:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Interesting. That wouldn't be Holmberg, was it?
5:18 Speaker 02 I think it was.
5:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Holmberg, yeah.
5:20 Speaker 02 You're right.
5:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I remember that.
5:21 Speaker 02 Yes.
5:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, so.
5:22 Speaker 02 You've written about this.
5:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But I was just a triumph of the simulation modeling universe. Where, so there was a famous astronomer in the day. He would say, a Lexus that's wrecked in an accident is not a different kind of Lexus. It's just a wrecked Lexus. And so a wrecked galaxy could have been a perfectly nice galaxy, but then it collided with another galaxy. And with your computer, you can check what it looks like at every step.
5:57 Speaker 02 That's correct.
5:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And then, and then look at the universe and find-
6:01 Speaker 02 Find those steps.
6:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And all of those steps-
6:03 Speaker 02 Yes.
6:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? -being taken by colliding galaxies.
6:05 Speaker 02 And that's how we learned that bug splats turn into beautiful elliptical galaxies. Smooth, uniform, homogeneous, because they get complete- They're disk galaxies that get completely blenderized. And that's the origin of the elliptical galaxies. Furthermore, every galaxy in the universe has collided with other galaxies. That's how galaxies are made.
6:34 Negin Farsad? Wait, so is it that like, when a ga- When two galaxies collide?
6:39 Speaker 02 Yes.
6:40 Negin Farsad? Is it sort of like-
6:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Say it more romantically, when two galaxies collide.
6:44 Speaker 03 When two galaxies collide.
6:46 Speaker 02 Come together.
6:48 Negin Farsad? But when that happens, is it that like, they're at a stop sign and neither of them is willing to go? So then they just smash into each other?
6:55 Speaker 02 Well, it's like this. Galaxies are made of stars and gas and dark matter. And stars are very widely separated from each other. So the stars just go by each other. Maybe they tug each other a little gravitationally, but basically, they're not gonna run into each other.
7:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If there were four bumblebees in the continental United States, flying randomly, there's a greater chance that two of them will accidentally bump into each other than two stars will collide.
7:27 Speaker 02 In galaxies. That's about right.
7:29 Negin Farsad? Oh, I'm hearing there's a lot of space.
7:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
7:31 Negin Farsad? Is that what we're doing? Okay, got it, got it.
7:34 Speaker 02 However, gas is space filling. And so the gas runs into each other and lights up, huge shock waves, dust clouds running into each other, new stars forming, all that goes on during the collision.
7:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I got a good analogy for colliding gas clouds.
7:50 Negin Farsad? Okay.
7:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Two hot marshmallows.
7:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When they hit, they're stuck. Have you done this? You look at me like, what is he talking about?
8:01 Speaker 02 I am too.
8:02 Negin Farsad? Have you roasted marshmallows and then like throw them at each other? Like, I have it, Neil.
8:08 Speaker 02 Neil, I don't know what kind of camping trips you went on. We ate the marshmallows.
8:13 Negin Farsad? He's looking at us like we're the weird ones. Okay, so no, but I like this. So they don't, they, they, they stick together and then that's it. They become one marshmallow.
8:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They become one marshmallow. And there's an edge between them and everything. So I, I, I'm bringing this up just as-
8:26 Speaker 02 But they don't emit X-rays.
8:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, they don't. Last I checked. So I, I'm bringing this up just as a triumph of the bringing-
8:33 Speaker 02 Numerical methods.
8:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Numerical simulations to understanding the universe. And you made a career of doing just that. One of the, another great mysteries that we had to figure out was weird galaxies that had weird things going on in their, in their centers. And they give off a lot of energy and a lot of different wavelengths. And we came up with the unpoetic name, active galactic nuclei.
8:57 Speaker 02 Or quasars for the brightest ones.
8:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Especially of late, this has been a big part of your, your, your objects of affection.
9:04 Speaker 02 It's one strand of my research, yes.
9:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, just one strand?
9:07 Speaker 02 Just one strand.
9:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so, so tell me about AGNs. What's the latest on them? Do they all have black holes?
9:15 Speaker 02 They all have black holes. That's what makes them so bright. Because black holes are the brightest objects in the universe.
9:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is where you come in and say, how could a black hole be bright?
9:25 Negin Farsad? Yeah, how could a black hole be bright? I, I don't understand.
9:31 Speaker 02 Thank you for asking.
9:32 Negin Farsad? And is there a way for the black hole in my soul to brighten up as well?
9:37 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, there is. Eat a lot. Because that's how black holes get bright. So you have gas. And we have already established that if you squeeze gas enough, it gets really, really hot. And if it's really, really hot, it emits a lot of radiation as the fourth power of the temperature. And so, what is better at squeezing things than a almost extremely tiny, extremely massive object, like a black hole? So, you have a black hole in gas, and particularly in the centers of galaxies, there's a lot of gas, because it all gets swept into the center, as you wish the vacuum cleaner would do, but anyway.
10:22 Speaker 02 So, here it is, all this gas falling onto the black hole, and there's not room for all that gas to fall in, so it gets squeezed, and squeezed, and squeezed, until it reaches a billion degrees Fahrenheit. And...
10:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was gonna clarify, is it Fahrenheit or Celsius?
10:40 Negin Farsad? Yeah, no, thank God, okay.
10:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You were wondering that too, right?
10:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, of course. So, when it's that hot, it's emitting in the X-rays, and the ultraviolet, and all that light is coming out, and that, a lot of it gets converted down into the visible, by running into dust clouds and stuff.
10:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just to back up on that, if you have an electric stove, when it's off, it just, it's just off.
11:03 Speaker 02 It's emitting in the infrared.
11:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, just mildly, but then you turn it up a little higher, and then it feels warm, it's emitting more infrared, and then it becomes visible.
11:13 Speaker 02 But it's deep red.
11:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, it's emitting visible light, but also still emitting all the more infrared than before, but it kind of stops there, at maximum.
11:22 Speaker 02 But if you keep cranking it up, it'll get orange hot.
11:25 Negin Farsad? Wait, so you could have like a black hole in your kitchen?
11:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, we're getting there, right.
11:29 Speaker 02 Not a good idea. X-ray emission is unhealthy for human beings.
11:34 Negin Farsad? Oh, got it, yep.
11:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, you keep turning it up, if you could, it would then glow white hot, then blue hot.
11:39 Speaker 02 Like a welding torch?
11:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, but then that's all you can see, but it'll keep, what's beyond violet?
11:46 Speaker 02 Ultra.
11:46 Negin Farsad? Ultraviolet, ultraviolet, ultraviolet, yep, you got it.
11:49 Speaker 02 And now you're getting your sunburns.
11:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and so, at a billion degrees, you are way...
11:55 Speaker 02 You're way off into the X and gamma ray.
11:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? X-rays and gamma rays.
11:58 Speaker 02 So, you don't want to be too close to one of these.
12:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so hence the word "active," in active galactic nuclei.
12:03 Speaker 02 So, these objects are literally the brightest objects in the universe, and so we can see them across the universe, out to, you know, 95% of the distance to the back, when you're looking across the universe, you're looking back in time, so 95% of the distance back to the Big Bang, we can see these things.
12:26 Negin Farsad? Showoffs.
12:27 Speaker 02 Totally.
12:28 Negin Farsad? The showoffs of the, of the milk galaxy.
12:31 Speaker 02 Of the universe.
12:32 Negin Farsad? Of the universe.
12:33 Speaker 02 The Milky Way does have a very massive, supermassive black hole in its center, but it doesn't get a lot to eat, so it's kind of a wimpy, dim little thing.
12:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But back then, were we that?
12:46 Speaker 02 Were we ever a quasar? There is actually evidence that quite recently, like just five million years or so ago, there was a much brighter outburst from our own galactic black hole. And there's now a shockwave like running out of the galaxy.
13:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's how you trace it, I guess.
13:04 Speaker 02 Yeah. It was first discovered using the Fermi gamma ray satellite.
13:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but, but do, is our black hole big? Do we have black hole envy here?
13:12 Speaker 02 Oh, yes. We only have a million solar masses. The biggest quasars can be a billion solar masses, a thousand times bigger.
13:20 Negin Farsad? So. Yeah, it's embarrassing because like, once you go big black hole, you really don't go back. And that's like something that every astrophysicist says.
13:29 Speaker 02 That's right. Black holes do not give up mass easily. Putting them on a diet takes a very, very, very long time.
13:37 Negin Farsad? Wait, can you do, can you tell me the size of these black holes in like the big, like continental United States analogy?
13:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, yeah, sure, sure.
13:45 Speaker 02 So, a billion solar mass black hole.
13:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's like the solar system, right?
13:49 Speaker 02 Is a little smaller than the solar system. A stellar mass black hole, like one solar mass, is, I want to say a kilometer or so?
14:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I think that's right.
14:02 Speaker 02 Yeah. A mile. A mile.
14:05 Negin Farsad? Got it.
14:05 Speaker 02 It's not as big as Central Park.
14:07 Negin Farsad? Okay.
14:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and if Earth were a black hole, which it would never be, but if it were, it would be the size of a plum.
14:12 Speaker 02 A marble.
14:12 Negin Farsad? Oh, gosh, you're busy. So compressed.
14:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, yeah, so compressed. But, but while this whole system is big, that's tiny compared to the whole galaxy. And gas clouds are way bigger than that.
14:22 Speaker 02 Oh, so much bigger.
14:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When you talk about funneling them down to something as small as the size of our solar system.
14:28 Speaker 02 I mean, your average gas cloud is, let's say, a million times as big as the distance from the Earth to the Sun.
14:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Space is big, big.
14:38 Negin Farsad? Yeah, space is like, like angeringly huge.
14:42 Speaker 02 Well, some people could think that they'd like their space.
14:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why do UFO sightings persist? Are at least some of them figments of our imagination? Or are we missing something? In my latest book, Take Me to Your Leader, I separate science from speculation. I actually explore what's possible in this universe, given the universal laws of physics. Because if the aliens are out there, the laws of physics will dictate how they find us. I also narrated the audiobook. So I'm duly informed that the audiobook and the print version are available now, wherever books are sold.
15:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You have not stopped there, of course. You have explored the formation of planets in these environments.
15:56 Speaker 02 So I started out by working on the formation of planets around normal, boring stars. And I went so far as to...
16:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Isn't that what we all care about?
16:06 Speaker 02 Well, I would think so, but you're bringing up weird planets.
16:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
16:10 Speaker 02 Okay. So I started out just thinking about the thing we care about. How did the Earth form? And I went so far as to hire a postdoc, Vladimir Lyra, to study this with me. And we were going along, perfectly happy, studying planets moving around in the protosolar disk. And he made the mistake, or maybe the very wise decision, to talk to some of our City University, CUNY colleagues, who were doing research here on AGNs.
16:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay.
16:43 Speaker 02 Okay. On the disks.
16:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because we have here in our department, we have many frequent visitors from nearby universities with resident interests.
16:53 Speaker 02 In particular, we have an NSF-funded partnership with CUNY...
16:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's official. NSF official.
17:00 Speaker 02 NSF official, to bring students and faculty from campuses across the city to do research here at the research-intensive American Museum of Natural History.
17:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is that what pays for the pizza every Thursday? Seven boxes of pizza come in.
17:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? People only think when we're eating.
17:21 Negin Farsad? Yeah, what's the favorite topping of the astrophysicist community? Is there like a way?
17:28 Speaker 02 I believe we may ensure that all diets have an option.
17:32 Negin Farsad? Okay, yeah.
17:33 Speaker 02 Okay, but back to AGMs, which are kind of like pizzas because they have discs, very flat distributions of gas and dust around them. Because stuff falling onto an object, if that stuff can cool off, like gas can radiate and cool off, it will form not a ball around it, but a flat disk. Same thing happened in our solar system.
17:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As a rotating disk.
17:55 Speaker 02 It's a rotating disk, not like a pizza, but like a pizza being made.
18:00 Negin Farsad? Or like a sushi conveyor belt.
18:03 Speaker 02 Hmm, let's stick with the pizza being made.
18:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I hate those because that means the sushi went in front of the nose and mouth of other people.
18:12 Negin Farsad? Other people, yeah.
18:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I don't know something about that.
18:14 Speaker 02 Big Japanese scandal.
18:17 Speaker 02 So you've got this flat disk, and there's stuff accumulating in the disk. It gets dirty and dusty, and that dust starts to stick together. And, well, if you're in a normal disk around a normal star like the sun, which isn't quite normal, it's bigger than average, there it makes planets, like, say, this one that I can observe under my feet. However, if you're in a disk around a supermassive black hole, a hundred million times as massive as the sun, there's an awful lot of dust in that disk, and it's awful large, and you don't form three planets or eight planets. You form a million planets!
19:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you made a million planet star system.
19:05 Speaker 02 Planetary system.
19:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Planetary system.
19:07 Speaker 02 Planetary system. Around a black hole. And this was a paper that we just had accepted a couple, like, two weeks ago.
19:15 Negin Farsad? Oh my god, breaking news!
19:17 Speaker 02 Yep.
19:17 Negin Farsad? Okay.
19:18 Speaker 02 Although I will say, so Bu Prender Mishra was the lead author on that.
19:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How many authors are there?
19:24 Speaker 02 Uh, let's see, I think there are six.
19:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this is typical when you have collaborations.
19:29 Speaker 02 Absolutely.
19:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And some of them are CUNY professors as well.
19:32 Speaker 02 Some of them are CUNY, Barry McKernan.
19:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? University of New York.
19:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, Barry McKernan and Savik Ford, Vladimir Lyra, who was a postdoc but now is a professor.
19:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Savik Ford is named for a character on Star Trek.
19:42 Speaker 02 Well, she named herself for it.
19:45 Negin Farsad? I was gonna say, wow, her parents really figured that out.
19:48 Speaker 02 No, no.
19:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Parents, no, she did. But I think it's official, I mean, I think it's official.
19:51 Speaker 02 Oh yeah, she publishes under that.
19:53 Negin Farsad? She's committed, okay.
19:55 Speaker 02 K E Savic.
19:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Savic, yes, okay.
19:57 Speaker 02 Anyway, we showed that if you take standard planet formation theory, and this is the same trick that Claude Berry and Savic did 15 years ago to realize that black holes could move around like planets. If you take standard planet formation theory and apply it to the dust, you find that it is very liable to go through all the stages that you would go through to make planets, except they're really big planets, because there's so much dust.
20:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So how big, how big are the solid planets?
20:28 Speaker 02 Jupiter mass, solid rock planets, except they're probably not rock, because they're probably degenerate in the centers.
20:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, so our Jupiter is big, but it's mostly gas?
20:38 Speaker 02 It's mostly gas.
20:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You can make a Jupiter-sized planet that's rocky?
20:41 Speaker 02 Out of silicates.
20:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Ooh, ouch.
20:44 Negin Farsad? So, does that mean also that its gravity is like extra annoying?
20:49 Speaker 02 Yes.
20:49 Negin Farsad? Got it. Extra annoying being like, strong.
20:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, no, we followed that.
20:54 Speaker 02 I understood that.
20:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, we totally understood you again.
20:56 Speaker 02 Totally.
20:57 Negin Farsad? You're so perfect, I just need to like, translate for this astrophysics.
21:00 Speaker 02 Right, because the gravity at the cloud tops of Jupiter, we won't call it the surface, but at the cloud tops of Jupiter is quite reasonable. It's not far off from Earth's gravity.
21:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It was like 10 times gravity.
21:11 Speaker 02 No, no, no, no, no.
21:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not even?
21:13 Speaker 02 Not even. It's close to Earth's gravity, because Jupiter's so big and low density. But the gravity at the surface of one of these monsters would perhaps be 10 times Earth's gravity. I don't know, I haven't done the calculation.
21:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's an easy calculation.
21:27 Speaker 02 But you're very, you're, you're the same density and, you know, 10 times the radius.
21:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We don't expect to find life on any of these, because there's no home star to give Uh, nourishing energy to-
21:40 Speaker 02 No, it's rather worse. There's a home center of the accretion disk glowing in X-rays and gamma rays. It will provide plenty of energy, but it might not be in a form conducive to life as we know it.
21:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Hostile to biology.
21:55 Speaker 02 That would be my suspicion.
21:57 Negin Farsad? Is there a biology that we don't know of that could maybe handle it?
22:01 Speaker 02 That is an excellent question that we don't know the answer to.
22:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, there is. The Hulk biology.
22:05 Negin Farsad? Yeah, yeah, yeah, there it is.
22:07 Speaker 02 The gamma ray biology, yes.
22:08 Negin Farsad? Can you add the Hulk into your simulator and see what happens?
22:14 Speaker 02 We're gonna have to get his specifications.
22:17 Negin Farsad? Yeah, yeah. I wanna see this.
22:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if all you need is dust, which are the larger molecules, a larger gathering of atoms-
22:25 Speaker 02 Minerals.
22:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
22:26 Speaker 02 These are silicates. These are dust like, kinda like we find on the earth, except it formed in space. Even though space is, as noted, very large, the rocky atoms of silicon and oxygen and magnesium tend to find each other, and once they find each other, they stick together. And so they form little tiny dust grains, like a nanometer in size in deep space. But when you collect all of them together, whether it be in a protostellar disk or a supermassive black hole disk, um, they can find each other and stick together. And actually, that's something else I've been working on recently, is showing that they might be a lot stickier than people have thought.
23:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So when they stick together, they stay?
23:07 Speaker 02 They appear to stay, well, until they get big enough, and then they break apart when they slam into each other. And that's actually a-
23:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a whole other process.
23:16 Speaker 02 That's a big question in planet formation theory is, how do you get them to stop beating each other up and fragmenting?
23:22 Negin Farsad? Yeah, cuz is it also, I mean, partially what you're describing almost sounds like a sandcastle, like they're sort of sticking together like a sandcastle.
23:30 Speaker 02 That is an excellent description of an asteroid. We call them rubble piles, but it's really a sandcastle.
23:35 Negin Farsad? But it's so that it's, so they're pretty vulnerable, yeah.
23:39 Speaker 02 They're totally fragile. How did we learn this? Back, oh, uh, thirty years ago, a comet swung too close to-
23:47 Speaker 02 Comet Shoemaker Levy nine, you're supposed to not just make faces.
23:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is the first ever observation of a comet slamming into one of our own planets.
23:59 Speaker 02 Yes.
24:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
24:00 Negin Farsad? Or do you memorize all of the comets?
24:02 Speaker 02 No.
24:03 Negin Farsad? Just the like popular ones, okay, got you.
24:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just the popular ones.
24:06 Negin Farsad? Cause I was very impressed if you had them all down, alright.
24:09 Speaker 02 No, no, no, there are thousands and thousands.
24:11 Negin Farsad? I am no longer impressed, go ahead.
24:13 Speaker 02 Very good, act as you were.
24:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And I have to just put in here, that duo, by the way, the Shoemaker Levy nine, okay?
24:22 Speaker 02 It's really Shoemaker Shoemaker Levy.
24:24 Negin Farsad? Was there eight other ones?
24:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Others that they're active bunch.
24:28 Speaker 02 Oh yeah.
24:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that collaboration had a leftover asteroid that they named in my honor.
24:36 Negin Farsad? Oh.
24:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
24:38 Speaker 02 Okay, I knew you had an asteroid, I didn't know it was a Shoemaker Levy asteroid.
24:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Shoemaker Levy, and the plaque is right up there on the, on the, on.
24:45 Negin Farsad? Sorry, quick question, who decides these things? Is it you?
24:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The discoverer, but it has to be approved.
24:53 Negin Farsad? Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah.
24:54 Speaker 02 He can't be rude.
24:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it was that, that duo, that's how, that's how.
24:59 Speaker 02 Trio.
24:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Trio, that's how fertile a discovery, a group that, Gene Shoemaker, Carolyn Shoemaker and.
25:06 Speaker 02 David Levy.
25:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And David Levy.
25:07 Speaker 02 Yeah.
25:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They've discovered comets and asteroids and all the kind of things.
25:10 Speaker 02 And Gene Shoemaker also in, pretty much was the originator of the theory of craters. Like, what happens when something, a big rock slams into a planet? It makes a crater. He described how. And so that's.
25:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It sounds obvious.
25:25 Negin Farsad? I know, I was just gonna say, like, I can also ask my seven-year-old daughter about the theory of craters, I think she'd come up with the same thing.
25:32 Speaker 02 That's how, that's how fundamental his work was. Because before Gene Shoemaker, people looked at the moon and saw volcano craters.
25:42 Negin Farsad? Right.
25:43 Speaker 02 Not.
25:44 Negin Farsad? Not, not, okay.
25:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Every crater was a volcanic caldera.
25:48 Negin Farsad? Yeah.
25:49 Speaker 02 Like Crater Lake.
25:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're not completely crazy to think so.
25:53 Speaker 02 Well, Crater Lake is a volcanic caldera.
25:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, they're not crazy to think so.
25:58 Speaker 02 They were just wrong.
26:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's possible to be, that makes complete sense, you're just wrong, okay? That happens in science all the time. It's very frustrating. But the reason is, the argument against them being asteroids, was every crater is a perfect circle on the moon. And no one is thinking asteroids are coming straight in. Surely some are coming at an angle. If you're coming at an angle, you'd expect an oval.
26:27 Negin Farsad? Right.
26:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Most of them should be ovals, but every one was a perfect circle. And so that's the tension between the two arguments and the two camps. And it wasn't until we had, like, we can model.
26:39 Speaker 02 Well, until Gene Shoemaker came along and said, no, they should be circles.
26:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, someone had to demonstrate on a computer, with a computer simulation, that a high-speed impact, when it hits, it explodes.
26:51 Speaker 02 It vaporizes.
26:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but that explosion makes a perfect circle, even if it comes in at an angle.
26:57 Speaker 02 Okay, but we're off the topic.
26:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
26:59 Speaker 02 Which is that when Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9 passed close to Jupiter, it felt gravitational forces from Jupiter. But it was coming by at a fair distance, and those gravitational forces were not strong, massive planet gravitational forces. They were forces equivalent to one-eighth of an inch of water in Earth's gravity. How much pressure does that put on your plate? Not much. That's all the force that tore that comet apart into 21 pieces. That's how weakly bound it was, and that's why I say it was...
27:36 Negin Farsad? Because sandcastle.
27:37 Speaker 02 Your sandcastle is exactly right.
27:38 Negin Farsad? Oh, I feel so smart right now.
27:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's so validated.
27:41 Negin Farsad? Yes, I love this moment.
27:43 Speaker 02 You're welcome.
27:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and so just to show, there's still a huge frontier for us to understand these objects.
27:49 Negin Farsad? Yeah.
27:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you got people, good people, working on it.
27:52 Negin Farsad? Including the guy that said, when a thing hits another thing, it forms a crater.
27:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
27:58 Speaker 02 Yes.
27:58 Negin Farsad? Which like, I can't believe somebody, yeah, somebody had to do it first, bless that guy.
28:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah. So we got questions from our audience, who've been specifically... Clued to your research profile.
28:10 Speaker 02 Okay.
28:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the questions will emanate from that. So what do you have here for us, Nagy? I haven't seen the question. You haven't seen them either.
28:15 Speaker 02 I have not seen them.
28:16 Negin Farsad? And I've seen them. I think they're great. Here we go. Tatiana here, from Ottawa, Ontario. I'm 15 years old and finally asking my first StarTalk question.
28:27 Speaker 02 Congratulations.
28:29 Negin Farsad? My question is, what are and how do supersonic turbulent flows and magnetic fields regulate star formation inside molecular clouds?
28:40 Speaker 02 How many hours do I get?
28:41 Negin Farsad? And then she's not done. Do they work together to stabilize the process? Or does their interaction create chaos?
28:50 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, and yes.
28:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, naively it feels like that would just mess up the whole thing.
28:55 Speaker 02 Absolutely.
28:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're getting coherent planets out of this, aren't you?
28:58 Speaker 02 Stars.
28:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Stars.
29:00 Speaker 02 Stars.
29:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
29:01 Speaker 02 Okay. Yes, the turbulence stirs things up. And it also squeezes some of the gas. And so the squeezed gas, gravity can take hold and start the collapse process. But the stirring prevents more gas from getting grabbed by gravity and collapse down to form stars. So it's both, both and. The stirring actually wins, so the more turbulence you have, the less star formation you have.
29:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, but when, when you have a little pocket that's slightly more dense, that attracts more material that makes it even more dense. And so it's a runaway.
29:38 Speaker 02 It's a runaway.
29:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Once you, once you.
29:40 Speaker 02 Once you get started.
29:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Once you get out of the starting gates.
29:42 Speaker 02 Yes.
29:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
29:43 Speaker 02 Now, then what happens is that as you start forming stars, the biggest, most massive of them pump huge amounts of energy back into the gas, whether it be through jets or ionizing radiation, or stellar winds, or ultimately supernova explosions. And that chases the gas away, and then you don't get any more star formation.
30:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, now how do you know all this?
30:08 Speaker 02 Uh, because I've done simulations of it. And then I compared those simulations to what observers saw.
30:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cause you have nothing to compare to.
30:18 Speaker 02 And they weren't so bad.
30:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if you didn't have observations to compare it to, you're just kinda presuming your results are real?
30:26 Speaker 02 I'm playing in the sandbox without any constraints.
30:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
30:30 Speaker 02 And then I can make...
30:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? More sandbox analogy here.
30:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm running with it here.
30:36 Negin Farsad? Do you, but you, like, so how much, like, what level of confidence percentage-wise is it?
30:41 Speaker 02 Okay, so, okay, so the, the, the point about constraints is important. Because otherwise, someone else can come along and say, "No, no, no, no, no. The magnetic fields are gonna hold everything up. And you're gonna have to wait for the neutral atoms to drift through the ions to ever, ever make a star." Without observations, we can't tell who's right.
31:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mm-hmm.
31:02 Speaker 02 Cause he can say, "Of course it works like this. I've written 20 papers on it." And I can say, "But my programs don't show that." But, well, you know, so I wrote my programs wrong.
31:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? One possible, um, you just went too quickly past that.
31:17 Speaker 02 I'm sorry.
31:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What you just said was that your, your naysayer could be right. And maybe you, your, your software had bugs in it.
31:27 Speaker 02 No, approximations. Approximations.
31:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
31:31 Speaker 02 We always, every model has approximations.
31:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We don't know until...
31:35 Speaker 02 Until you compare to the observations.
31:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There you go, okay. And...
31:39 Negin Farsad? And then you get a reasonable level of confidence in it.
31:43 Speaker 02 Then you, then you build up your, your confidence. And of course, then you argue about what the observations mean. And whether there was noise in the telescope. And, you know, what assumptions went into the interpretation of the observations. But ultimately, this is how science progresses. You come up with an idea, and then you have to, then other people come up with different ideas. You argue about it. And you settle it by reference to the real world.
32:07 Negin Farsad? A duel, oh, not a duel. Okay, sorry.
32:10 Speaker 02 We try to avoid that and most of the time we succeed.
32:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Somebody shot him in the buttocks. But, but it's evidence that arriving at what is objectively true in the actual universe is messy.
32:24 Speaker 02 Totally. So messy.
32:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So messy and the strength with which you argue your point ultimately is not the arbiter.
32:32 Speaker 02 No, unfortunately. It might be easier that way.
32:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it doesn't matter how articulate you are or how charismatic you are. We have the ultimate.
32:41 Speaker 02 Facts still have to win.
32:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Judge, jury and executioner is nature.
32:44 Speaker 02 That is the agreement that people doing science have made with each other.
32:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's an implicit agreement.
32:50 Speaker 02 One hopes it's explicit, but is that we will settle our arguments ultimately by reference to reproducible experiments and observations.
33:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes. So either I'm right and you're wrong, you're right and I'm wrong, or we're both wrong. It'll be decided by more data or better data.
33:10 Speaker 02 That's right.
33:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, okay.
33:11 Speaker 02 And that, that is the, the central tenet of science.
33:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Where does the magnetic field come from?
33:19 Speaker 02 The magnetic field comes from a dynamo. So dynamos happen when you get some sort of stirring of charged gas or charged things.
33:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay.
33:32 Speaker 02 So like a dynamo in a power station, the charge is running through wires.
33:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it's spinning.
33:37 Speaker 02 And it's spinning.
33:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, yes.
33:38 Speaker 02 And in the universe, or in, in the earth, the dynamo is turbulent swirling magma deep down in the earth that is kept molten by the pressure and radioactivity of the earth. And it swirls around and makes the earth's magnetic field and that's a dynamo. Well, same in the sun, except there it's plasma. In galaxies, the charged gas between the stars forms a dynamo stirred by supernova explosions and by gravity.
34:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if you didn't have the turbulence.
34:14 Speaker 02 You wouldn't get the dynamo.
34:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You wouldn't have a magnetic field.
34:17 Speaker 02 You would not have a magnetic field.
34:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So they go hand in hand.
34:19 Speaker 02 They, one is, one generates the other.
34:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
34:21 Negin Farsad? It's like they're in heat and then they give birth to this.
34:27 Speaker 02 Sure, maybe. I think you're stretching the field here. But if you stretch the field and twist it and rotate, you will get a dynamo.
34:37 Negin Farsad? Great, thank you.
34:39 Speaker 02 Okay, so the first dynamos happen when the very, very first stars form. And ever since then, we've had significant magnetic fields running around, getting stretched and twisted and folded to make more magnetic fields.
34:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There we are.
34:55 Negin Farsad? There we are. Shall we move on to the next question?
34:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you for that.
34:58 Negin Farsad? All right. Ismael Valdez here, asking my first question from Vina del Mar, Chile. Okay.
35:05 Speaker 02 Okay.
35:06 Negin Farsad? In regards to stars and gas giants, if Jupiter were sufficiently massive, would the pressure ignite, would its pressure ignite its lighter components?
35:17 Speaker 02 Yes.
35:17 Negin Farsad? Furthermore, do the sun or stars in general share elements with gas giants, like a rocky core, or is it fused gas all the way through? Which sounds like a tough meal at Taco Bell. I don't know. Go ahead.
35:31 Speaker 02 Okay.
35:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Let me modify that just a little bit. If we had the capacity to dump mass onto Jupiter,
35:38 Speaker 02 Sure.
35:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? could we ignite it one day?
35:40 Speaker 02 He had two questions. First question is, if you increase Jupiter's mass, does it ignite? And the answer is yes. If you increase Jupiter's mass enough, like, well, if you get it up to about, I want to say 10 times the mass of Jupiter, you get the deuterium burning, the heavy hydrogen with extra neutrons. And that lasts for a little while, but there's not a whole lot of deuterium in the universe. It's like, I don't know, a part in 100,000, a few parts in 100,000. So that's, you get a little flash of light, you know, for a couple of, maybe a million, a couple hundred thousand years, and then it's gone. And that's a brown dwarf.
36:24 Speaker 02 And they exist, and we've got one of the world's premier research groups on the topic right upstairs here, run by Jackie Farady, and...
36:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because we just went down the hall to get Mordecai, right?
36:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, yeah. I traveled a long way. I want my per diem.
36:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the Department of Astrophysics of the American Museum of Natural History.
36:46 Speaker 02 That's a brown dwarf. Now, if you keep piling mass on and get up to ba ba ba ba ba ba in Jupiter masses, um... Like eighty times.
36:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, that ma- that much?
36:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, eighty times the mass of Jupiter.
36:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a lot.
37:00 Speaker 02 Which is a little under a tenth of the mass of the sun.
37:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You could just drop Saturn onto it.
37:05 Speaker 02 No, not not.
37:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That would be amazing to watch.
37:07 Speaker 02 But not nearly enough.
37:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That still wouldn't ignite it.
37:09 Speaker 02 No, no, no, not even close.
37:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not even close.
37:10 Speaker 02 Not even close.
37:11 Negin Farsad? Well, so you, as you said earlier, like, something like that is just like a couple hundred thousand years. It's like dumb.
37:18 Speaker 02 That's what, that's the brown dwarf. Don't call brown dwarfs dumb around here.
37:22 Negin Farsad? Okay, no, I'm just trying to understand, because you made that sound like not nothing, like it was.
37:26 Speaker 02 It's not nothing, it's fusion, but it's not a lot of fusion.
37:29 Negin Farsad? Okay.
37:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Even what he's about to say.
37:31 Speaker 02 Wait, wait, wait, wait.
37:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a.
37:32 Negin Farsad? That's okay.
37:33 Speaker 02 It's a flash in the pan.
37:34 Negin Farsad? Got you.
37:34 Speaker 02 Okay, but if you get up to eighty times, then you can ignite hydrogen. And there's a lot more hydrogen, that's what Jupiter's mostly made of. Then you've got a very low mass star. And very low mass stars sit there and simmer for longer than the current lifetime of the universe. So that will keep going and going and going.
37:55 Negin Farsad? So that's way more than two hundred thousand.
37:57 Speaker 02 It's way more than the life of the universe. It's like ten times the life of the universe. No, a hundred times the life, current life of the universe.
38:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but, but question. Right now Jupiter has a rocky core.
38:07 Speaker 02 Yes.
38:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? What happens to that rocky core? Because it's kind of related to this question.
38:11 Speaker 02 Absolutely, yes, yes, let's go. Let's go, let's go.
38:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Bring it on.
38:15 Speaker 02 Okay, so what happens is, it gets completely overwhelmed by all the hydrogen and just gets mixed in, uh, because the hydrogen is sitting there fusing. So you have a little tiny rocky core. Now the sun, of course.
38:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Why doesn't it just vaporize the rocky core?
38:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's what I'm saying. Okay, it's not rocky anymore, but it is, the elements of the former, of the rock, uh, core formerly known as rocky are now part of the fusing vaporized hydrogen in the center of the object. Because it's now, you know, far hotter than anything, any rock has any right to withstand. So it's vape, it's rock vapor.
38:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It vaporized all the rock, got you.
38:51 Speaker 02 That's right. Um, now remember, the sun also has silicon and magnesium and aluminum and oxygen in it. It's just all mixed in with the hydrogen.
39:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right. So, you know, the sun, you might think would have a rocky core the way Jupiter did, but for that same reason, it's all
39:06 Speaker 02 It's too hot.
39:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It can't be anything other than
39:09 Negin Farsad? Plasmas.
39:10 Speaker 02 It lose ions and electrons even. Can't even be atoms, except on the very, very surface.
39:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? An atom is a nucleus plus electrons.
39:18 Speaker 02 Yes.
39:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All the electrons are gone.
39:19 Speaker 02 Yes.
39:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
39:20 Speaker 02 In the center, they're all gone. They're just roaming freely away from their parent atoms.
39:25 Negin Farsad? Got it.
39:25 Speaker 02 Here's your cue.
39:26 Negin Farsad? Yeah.
39:29 Negin Farsad? They're having a rebellious phase.
39:31 Speaker 02 Oh, they are long gone, never to return.
39:34 Negin Farsad? Never to return. They're not just like TP'ing their geometry teacher's house or something.
39:38 Speaker 02 No, no, no.
39:39 Negin Farsad? Okay.
39:39 Speaker 02 They have gone.
39:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's a trip. Toilet papering. Yes. Have you done that?
39:45 Negin Farsad? I have.
39:49 Negin Farsad? I TP'd once in my
39:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is stories you tell your offspring.
39:54 Speaker 02 I'm afraid we didn't do that in the center of New York City because a six-story apartment building is hard to TP.
39:59 Negin Farsad? You're just like doing, you're just doing toilet paper on someone's door and it's a lot less, you know.
40:04 Speaker 02 Satisfying.
40:05 Negin Farsad? Yeah. Can't imagine.
40:20 Speaker 03 I'm Nicholas Costella and I'm a proud supporter of StarTalk on Patreon. This is StarTalk with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
40:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Time for a few more questions. What do you have?
40:41 Negin Farsad? Okay, let's see. Hello. How is dark matter incorporated into your simulations? Random distribution or what?
40:50 Speaker 02 Okay.
40:51 Negin Farsad? Oh, sorry. And this question is from Ben Grund.
40:54 Speaker 02 Great question. And the answer is, um, any which way I can. So sometimes we actually put in particles in the simulation and watch them roam around under the force of gravity. And, well, they're very massive particles, but they still behave like dark matter because they don't interact with the gas, except by gravity. Other times
41:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, she just said, since we don't actually know what dark matter is.
41:19 Speaker 02 Oh, no, no, no. We're not even going there.
41:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, but, but you know it has gravity.
41:24 Speaker 02 Yes.
41:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Your simulation has to Get it somehow. So you sprinkle in, you invent a particle that interacts only by gravity.
41:33 Speaker 02 Yup.
41:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And has enough.
41:35 Speaker 02 Mass.
41:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Enough gravity to match.
41:39 Speaker 02 The observed dark matter.
41:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Observe dark matter. Okay.
41:41 Speaker 02 Yes.
41:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this is by, as they say, by fiat you do this. Does that?
41:45 Speaker 02 Uh, no. I mean, you could say.
41:48 Negin Farsad? If I understood what any of these things were, I could weigh in on if you used fiat correctly.
41:54 Speaker 02 I wouldn't say it's by fiat in the sense that the whole simulation by that definition is by fiat.
41:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
42:00 Speaker 02 Right? I've added in a field of gas. I've added in star particles. So I'm, it's just one element of the simulation.
42:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a way to get a source of gravity without having to worry about it after that.
42:11 Speaker 02 It behaves like dark matter.
42:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Great.
42:13 Speaker 02 The simpler way to do this, which I also sometimes do if I can get away with it, is to simply put in a gravitational field that reproduces the dark matter distribution and then let that handle it without having to actually do.
42:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Track particles.
42:27 Speaker 02 Without having to track particles and pay attention and do accounting and get bugs and all the rest.
42:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Alright, so is it smoothly?
42:37 Speaker 02 It's.
42:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's a smooth field.
42:39 Speaker 02 Well, it's smooth if you're on a subgalactic scale. But if you're on a, you know, a galaxy forming scale, it's very, very clumpy because the clumps are the galaxies. So in that sense, um, in, you know, when I'm simulating the formation of the first galaxies, um, then we're seeing big clumps of dark matter that the gas falls into and then you've got a galaxy.
43:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I've heard this, I think it's right, that dark matter, whatever it is, is so prevalent that when you just, when we look at and describe stars and galaxies, this is the froth on an ocean.
43:21 Speaker 02 Well, one-sixth of the mass of the galaxy is in anything visible. Stars, planets, gas, comets, all of that. One-sixth of the mass.
43:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So eighty-five percent of the gravity.
43:32 Speaker 02 Is from dark matter.
43:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's something you only know what is.
43:36 Speaker 02 We know it exerts gravity and we know it doesn't move at light speed. That's why it's cold dark matter.
43:42 Negin Farsad? Well, is there like an area like that doesn't have any, like how Wyoming doesn't have people? Like, is there an area of the galaxy where like there's no dark matter?
43:52 Speaker 02 Like Wyoming doesn't have people, voids don't have dark matter. While clusters have lots of dark matter.
43:58 Negin Farsad? Okay.
43:58 Speaker 02 And filaments have, well, intermediate amounts of dark matter. They're like interstates.
44:03 Negin Farsad? Okay. So yeah, it's not so evenly distributed.
44:07 Speaker 02 It's absolutely not evenly distributed, not in the universe.
44:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right.
44:10 Speaker 02 That's why we call it the cosmic web. Because it looks like spider webs, like with thin filaments and then big spaces in between.
44:18 Negin Farsad? Right.
44:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So web is, we'd say web now, but I remember when a cross section of a sponge. Does a sponge still work as a?
44:25 Speaker 02 Sponge still works, yeah.
44:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And sort of areas around it and places where you intersect?
44:30 Speaker 02 These days, we usually talk about webs.
44:32 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Web, okay, that's fine.
44:34 Negin Farsad? Ditch the sponge.
44:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was kinda into sponges, though.
44:37 Negin Farsad? I mean, I know, you really got into it.
44:38 Speaker 02 Well, that was an analogy for the interstellar medium, too.
44:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah.
44:41 Speaker 02 You know, Chris McKee and Don Cox arguing about, is it a sponge? Or is it little round clouds?
44:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I had a cameo in SpongeBob.
44:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I was Neil deBass Tyson.
44:52 Speaker 02 Oh.
44:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Astrofiscesis. So I just thought, I'm sticking to sponge.
44:59 Speaker 02 You got it.
44:59 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, thank you.
45:00 Speaker 02 You can have the dark, the cosmological sponge.
45:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, thank you, thank you. Time for a couple more, let's keep going.
45:08 Negin Farsad? Okay, let's see.
45:09 Speaker 02 We're on a roll here.
45:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, we are.
45:10 Negin Farsad? So Gavin Bamber from North Vancouver, please visit, they add. How long does it take to form a star or a planet? Is it the same process? We're both in the same stuff.
45:22 Speaker 02 Ooh. Okay. I believe the answer is yes and yes. And so how long does it take to form a star? The main formation phase, when most of this stuff comes down, is maybe 100,000 years, but it trickles along.
45:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That quickly, even?
45:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's like the main accretion phase. But it's gonna trickle along with a disk and accretion more mass and forming planets for a million, a couple of million years.
45:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you'll form a star before you form the planets?
45:57 Speaker 02 Well, that's an ongoing controversy. That was the, that was the idea, that used to be the idea.
46:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wouldn't that be the case, right?
46:04 Speaker 02 You would think. But nowadays, the more we examine the question, the faster the planets seem to form. And so now I would actually say that the first planets form during that main accretion phase, very, very fast. But then you continue to form planets and planetary-like things for several million years.
46:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And once again, you're forming planets in a disk.
46:28 Speaker 02 In a disk. It's all dust and gas in a disk.
46:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I have an accretion disk right here.
46:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah. If you wanna get brighter, eat more. Like a quasar.
46:37 Negin Farsad? That's, that takes so long. It just like, everyone has to be really committed to that planet for it to form, you know what I mean?
46:45 Speaker 02 Cause it takes a few million years.
46:46 Negin Farsad? Oh my gosh.
46:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, on the other hand, where are you gonna go? You're stuck in this disk going round and round and round.
46:52 Negin Farsad? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Let's get it going. Eventually we'll have an Arby's here, whatever.
46:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, well, now, the development of Arby's takes a lot longer. That's billions of years. Observably.
47:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, as Carl Sagan said, how do you make an apple pie? You start with a big bang.
47:14 Speaker 02 Go find the chicken.
47:17 Negin Farsad? Time for another question?
47:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, let's do it.
47:19 Negin Farsad? After all the model runs, how often do planets form with a satellite as large by percentage of mass of the planet as our moon?
47:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Good one.
47:29 Speaker 02 That's a very good one. And the answer is that the computer simulations aren't high enough resolution to really get a good answer to that yet. And so that is a current research question.
47:43 Negin Farsad? But you can't see the moons?
47:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, but we have all these planets with wimpy moons.
47:48 Speaker 02 Yes.
47:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right?
47:49 Speaker 02 Yes.
47:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So we already know.
47:50 Speaker 02 Well, observationally, we know in one planetary system with one set of initial conditions that moons like the Earth are pretty rare. And that's all we know. How many planetary systems do we know of?
48:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, it's growing now.
48:06 Speaker 02 Six thousand and counting.
48:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's growing.
48:09 Speaker 02 It's growing fast and it's gonna keep growing. And we don't know if any of those planets have moons because, observationally, we haven't been able to see them because it's really hard to see a moon around a planet. It's already really, really hard to see a planet, much less a moon. David Kipping up at Columbia thinks he's found a moon, but everybody else is staying on the fence and saying, maybe it's a moon.
48:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? David Kipping, we've had him on StarTalk.
48:35 Speaker 02 I'm sure you have.
48:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He's got a lab, the Cool Worlds Lab, which is kinda cool.
48:39 Speaker 02 And he's got a podcast.
48:40 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
48:41 Speaker 02 Which funds that lab.
48:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Cool Worlds.
48:43 Negin Farsad? So wait, your simulations will sometimes see like a hint of a moon?
48:49 Speaker 02 Uh, my, well, I don't do those simulations, but our simulations, the fields, you can make moons and we know, I mean, we certainly know how to make the Earth's moon, slam a Mars-sized planet into a proto-Earth. And that works shockingly well, as evidenced by the Apollo astronauts bringing back rocks that had the same composition as the Earth because they formed from that super collision.
49:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? To begin with.
49:21 Speaker 02 They left from the Earth to the moon.
49:23 Negin Farsad? The movie studio.
49:25 Speaker 02 Thank you.
49:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But that meant that the moon didn't form organically with the Earth.
49:33 Speaker 02 It formed afterwards.
49:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Afterwards.
49:36 Speaker 02 But now, what the Earth is made of, of course, is also a mixture of proto-Earth and I think they call it Aries, the Mars-sized object.
49:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no, it's, um...
49:46 Speaker 02 Thea?
49:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Uh, Thea. Thea.
49:48 Speaker 02 Isn't Thea the proto-Earth and Aries the proto-moon?
49:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh.
49:52 Speaker 02 I mean, the proto-moon.
49:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I think Thea is the proto-slammer.
49:56 Speaker 04 Confirming now, uh, being asked that the ancient proto-planet that we collided with was Thea.
50:03 Speaker 02 Okay.
50:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So shockingly successful is this model that we even named the object that doesn't exist anymore.
50:09 Speaker 02 That's right.
50:10 Negin Farsad? The impact object.
50:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Object, which is obliterated.
50:13 Speaker 02 Yes.
50:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And became part of the...
50:14 Speaker 02 However...
50:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We gave it a name.
50:15 Speaker 02 Yes.
50:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's kind of audacious.
50:17 Negin Farsad? A cool name.
50:18 Speaker 02 We can do those sorts of calculations for planets elsewhere, but to get the frequencies, that's going... that means a lot of calculation. We don't have enough computers to do that currently.
50:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, I love me my moon, because our moon is the same size on the sky as the sun, so we get beautiful eclipses.
50:36 Negin Farsad? Oh, I love it.
50:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Nobody else has eclipses like that. At Jupiter, it's got moons, but the sun is far, the moons are small, nothing matches up.
50:44 Negin Farsad? Yeah.
50:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The way our moon and our sun... So, what is it? The moon is 400 times closer and 1/400th the size.
50:54 Speaker 02 Yep.
50:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, everything ratios exactly.
50:56 Negin Farsad? Exactly to the... Yeah.
50:59 Speaker 02 And that's how you get eclipse chasers.
51:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah. It's the greatest spectacle of nature, a total solar eclipse.
51:05 Negin Farsad? Second only to Manhattan Henge, which is also something because...
51:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You got you some Manhattan, huh?
51:08 Negin Farsad? I love a Manhattan Henge!
51:10 Speaker 02 Oh, my gosh!
51:12 Negin Farsad? Thank you. Uh, that's because of you. Yeah, I followed your dates.
51:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, okay. So, Mordecai, time for one more question.
51:19 Speaker 02 Okay.
51:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We've been going.
51:20 Speaker 02 It better be a good one.
51:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you're a good question-answser.
51:23 Negin Farsad? Yes, this is great.
51:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And efficient.
51:26 Speaker 02 Okay, I will ramble.
51:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No, no!
51:30 Speaker 02 Lay the question on us.
51:32 Negin Farsad? Here we go. From Emil Rougeau, who describes himself as a man who has forgotten what curiosity is. As once said before by you, Dr. McLough, eight to 10 years ago, quote, "We live in a time where we have understood that the universe is far stranger than we would have thought. Have these thoughts changed over the years, or have they made more problems for you?"
51:54 Speaker 02 Um, I would have to say that if anything, these thoughts have intensified.
52:00 Negin Farsad? Okay.
52:01 Speaker 02 The universe is far stranger than we once thought and far stranger, possibly, than we can imagine.
52:10 Speaker 02 Why do I say that? Because we live in a universe that is expanding, that is accelerating, that is forming stars, planets, black holes. And it all came from a almost perfectly smooth, homogeneous, hot, very, very hot, beginning. That's not a story that someone 100 years ago would have told. None of it. So, yeah, strange.
52:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In fact, I have books, old books, that describe the universe as an ordered, majestic place. Everything in the right spot. Everything in stately orbits surrounding. And then we found out that things slam into each other. They blow up.
53:00 Speaker 02 It's full of turbulence and chaos.
53:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, I mean, it's just a mess.
53:05 Speaker 02 Yes. Thank you for that cogent description of the modern understanding of the universe.
53:11 Negin Farsad? Wait, so can I ask you both a question then? Now, you're both in the field of trying to understand the universe better. Right? Solving mysteries.
53:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Aren't we all, at some level, trying to understand the universe better?
53:23 Negin Farsad? I guess if, like, doing a tight 10 at the Chuckle Hudson Sheboygan makes, solves the universe in any way, I might be in that business. But, um, does it make either of you feel, I don't know, bad that, like, the more you study, the, like, more you find it chaotic? I don't mean, I don't-
53:46 Speaker 02 Let's just say it keeps me in a job.
53:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, I have a different way to answer that.
53:53 Negin Farsad? Yeah.
53:53 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If the universe were more and more chaotic, requiring equally as complex laws of physics to understand it, then what are we doing? But the real majesty is that it's just a few laws of physics.
54:13 Speaker 02 That generate all that chaos and mess.
54:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That generate all that chaos. It's just a few laws of particle physics that account for all the particle zoo that we know and love.
54:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Except for dark matter, we're not there yet. So.
54:30 Speaker 02 But we're working on it.
54:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If to understand the universe required a complexity of theorizing that matched it, then all bets are off. I'll just go home, you know, go to the Bahamas. Give up on it. But if foundational understanding, like Mordecai, you said all this without even mentioning that you're an expert in fluid dynamics.
54:53 Speaker 02 I implied it by discussing the turbulent dynamo.
54:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
54:57 Speaker 02 Which is absolutely an extreme fluid dynamics problem.
55:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, but fluid.
55:02 Speaker 02 Magnetized fluid dynamics.
55:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Look, he's got a face. He made a face. He was like, I'm angry. So, so fluid dynamics is the study of fluids, which can be gaseous or liquid, and.
55:16 Speaker 02 Kitchen sink.
55:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There's a whole set of rules just for fluid dynamics that works.
55:21 Speaker 02 Yep.
55:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In water flowing through pipes as it does.
55:25 Speaker 02 In stars.
55:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In stars. So that is.
55:29 Negin Farsad? Wild.
55:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That is the majesty of the universe.
55:31 Negin Farsad? Right, because you're, you're, you're settled on some, on the rules and now you're just like watching to see how these rules play out on a universe basis and it's fun.
55:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
55:41 Speaker 02 Yes.
55:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes.
55:43 Speaker 02 I get that.
55:44 Negin Farsad? I get that.
55:44 Speaker 02 We'll go with it.
55:45 Negin Farsad? That's your tight 10 at the Sheboygan chuckle hut.
55:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I, I, I, okay.
55:52 Speaker 02 He hasn't spent enough time in Sheboygan. Neither have I.
55:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mordecai, how will quantum computing help what you're doing?
55:58 Speaker 02 We don't know yet.
56:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Is there a problem that is intractable now that you think will succumb to quantum computers?
56:06 Speaker 02 Well, certainly problems in atomic physics, like say the million different transitions in the molecule water that all produce different amounts of radiation of different colors, different spectral lines.
56:21 Speaker 02 Those may well be better done by quantum computing than by the poor guy who came from banking into astrophysics and ended up having to do that for his thesis. But, um, most of the problems we have, we don't yet know how to compute on a quantum computer. Give it a hundred years.
56:42 Negin Farsad? A hundred? Oh.
56:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Or ten. I mean.
56:46 Negin Farsad? Yeah, I'm like, this is...
56:48 Speaker 02 I mean, look.
56:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A hundred years ago, we were only inventing quantum physics.
56:52 Speaker 02 Yes, we had already invented quantum physics, and we're still figuring it out.
56:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yes, we're still figuring it out, yeah.
56:58 Speaker 02 It took, when Newton wrote down his laws of gravity, it took a century before we could explain the orbit of the moon.
57:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, okay. That's all the time we have, Negin. Thank you for asking those questions. And Mordecai, brilliant answers, right on, right on brand.
57:14 Speaker 02 Well.
57:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And you have some groupies.
57:17 Speaker 02 Are you saying that I'm fusing here?
57:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I'm saying, plus you had at least one groupie there who was quoting your chapter and verse from ten years ago.
57:24 Speaker 02 I was impressed. Thank you.
57:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, no, we, we, our people, our people go back.
57:29 Negin Farsad? Yeah, no, they're like, no things, the listeners. Yeah.
57:34 Speaker 02 Right audience to have.
57:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, uh, thank, this might be our first interview with you.
57:38 Speaker 02 This is my first time in this chair.
57:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In that chair, but not your first time in my office.
57:43 Speaker 02 Not the first time in my, in this office.
57:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? He works just down the hall. All right. Negin, not your first rodeo here.
57:50 Negin Farsad? No, my first time.
57:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And look forward to your next time joining us.
57:52 Negin Farsad? Ah, such a great time. Thanks for having me.
57:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We'll find you on Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me.
57:56 Negin Farsad? If I'm in Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, if you're in Chattanooga, Tennessee, on June 24th, you can find me there too at the Comedy Cat.
58:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Oh, Chattanooga, Tennessee. We'll look for you. Uh, and that's, uh, June 24th.
58:07 Negin Farsad? June 24th, I'll be doing The Muslims Are Coming with Equally Threatening Friends, a night of stand-up comedy.
58:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay.
58:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Will that attract people or scare people away? If no one shows up in Chattanooga, Tennessee.
58:25 Negin Farsad? I need Dr. Maclow to do a simulation and see what happens.
58:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's all the time we have. So again, Mordecai, thank you.
58:34 Speaker 02 You're very welcome.
58:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thank you.
58:35 Speaker 02 Great fun to be here.
58:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This has been StarTalk: Cosmic Queries on the Formation of Planets with my friend and colleague, Mordecai Maclow. Until next time, keep looking up.
Previous Is Reality Really Real? With Donald Hoffman Next Cosmic Queries – Astro-lore with Moiya McTier Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated