Pod Insights StarTalk Podcast A Violent Earth About this episode Japan was recently hit by a triple punch: a powerful 9.0 magnitude earthquake generated a huge tsunami, which then critically damaged a nuclear power plant.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome to StarTalk, your place in the universe where science and pop culture collide. StarTalk begins right now.
0:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Welcome back to StarTalk Radio. I'm your host, The Grass Tyson. I'm an astrophysicist and director of New York City's Hayden Planetarium. This week, we have a special edition of StarTalk where we focus on the violent Earth. Earthquakes, volcanoes, tsunamis. We want to give you the science that enables us to understand and interpret the reports we've been getting from the Pacific Rim. On March 11th, Japan was hit by a triple punch, an 8.9 magnitude earthquake, a tsunami that followed shortly after, and one of the scariest among natural disasters that you might imagine. The concern about a nuclear power plant right there on the coast, damaged
1:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? by the tsunami and the earthquake, is at risk of meltdown. We'll address the science behind each of these issues, and over the course of the show, we will bring in experts to find out and get to the bottom of what's going on in the science of the Earth. I'm joined this week by my colleagues at the American Museum of Natural History. One is a friend I've, for decades, Steve Soder. He's an astrophysicist. Steve, welcome to StarTalk Radio.
1:30 Speaker 01 Thank you.
1:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, and he's, happens to be an expert on Earth phenomenon as well as tsunamis throughout history. And I've also got Jim Webster. He's a geologist in the Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, and he has a specialty in volcanoes. Jim, welcome to StarTalk Radio.
1:44 Speaker 02 Thank you, Neil. It's great to be here.
1:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Thanks for coming on, and I want to just start with you, Jim. You're the geologist here, and so we all get to kind of blame you for these phenomena. What, can you tell me what an earthquake is and why we have them, and what's going on with the Earth?
2:00 Speaker 02 An earthquake is a release of energy in the outer portion of our planet.
2:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the energy's got to come from somewhere. Now, I know how to form a solar system. Well, I know how to describe the formation of a solar system. You start with a huge gas cloud. It's mostly hydrogen and helium. And there's a little bit of trace elements elsewhere. It forms a sun in the middle. And you have these other concentrations of mass that make the planets. And each of those planets will have some leftover heat. Some of the heat is because it was hot when it formed, others because as it collapses, it gets hotter for having collapsed. And Earth is still hot. It seems to me four and a half billion years should be long enough for this place to have cooled down. What's going on?
2:38 Speaker 02 Well, I like the fact that you focused on heat and energy. Because really, it's this release of energy that drives seismic or earthquake activity. And it's also what hopefully we'll talk about a little bit later, the volcanoes that are associated with earthquakes around our planet. Early on in the formation of our planet, there was the accretion energy of the various particles literally slamming into one another violently and generating heat energy.
3:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Right, so if you have energy of motion, and then you stop moving because you collided, that energy still has to go somewhere. And it's revealed in the heat of the object.
3:10 Speaker 02 So it starts heating this object, but the objects would grow over time. And eventually, the body was large enough and heavy enough that the more dense materials, iron, nickel, metal alloys, started sinking to the center under the force of gravity.
3:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you need a fluid object for this to happen. Otherwise, it'll just sit on the top as a rock. But the Earth at that time was liquidy enough, plasticky enough for heavy things to fall and light things to rise. That's what you're saying.
3:34 Speaker 02 Well, again, I love your choice of language. Because the word "fluid" may or may not be a liquid. I mean, a hot, solid material, if it's hot and it behaves slowly over a very long period of time, it will behave as a fluid.
3:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's not in a fluid and in any conventional sense, but given enough time, it'll move.
3:49 Speaker 02 Exactly. Or materials may move through it.
3:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? May move through it. So if you're heavy, you fall to the middle. So this is the way you segregate out heavy from light in the formation of the Earth.
3:57 Speaker 02 And we know that the core of our planet is largely iron-nickel. And it was the formation of that core that also generated a tremendous amount of energy that still resides, part of it still resides in our planet.
4:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Still resides. And so that energy manifests itself by... Violent activity on Earth's crust.
4:15 Speaker 02 Exactly, the most apparent thing for us is perhaps watching volcanic eruptions that surface, molten material being issued forth.
4:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is kind of a peek into the innards of the Earth. The Earth is revealing its insides.
4:25 Speaker 02 Exactly, and that's one of the few ways, one of the better ways that we can actually gather materials from the inner Earth because they're carried up by molten lava.
4:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So volcanoes aren't just anywhere. I tend to see them collected where you've got, sort of, where you also find earthquakes, right? And so these are related phenomenon, clearly.
4:42 Speaker 02 Exactly. Not to get too heavy into plate tectonic theory, but the surface of our planet consists of these brittle plates that float around this fluid, not liquid, but fluid medium. And in fact, it's where these plates converge and where they come apart, it really represents the great majority of the earthquake activity on our planet and the great majority of the volcanic activity, molten rock.
5:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So one of the most famous regions would be, what I've read about is called the Ring of Fire, which is basically the entire perimeter of the Pacific Ocean, isn't that correct?
5:12 Speaker 02 Exactly. If you want to start in the western portion of the Pacific and move up from New Zealand up through the various island chains along the western coast, excuse me, the eastern coast of Asia, and then up around the corals, the Aleutians to the north.
5:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The Aleutians of Alaska and come right on down the west coast to the North America.
5:27 Speaker 02 The north and South America.
5:28 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And South America, right on down to tip of Chile.
5:30 Speaker 02 And more than 400 active volcanoes around that ring.
5:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And this is what we call the Ring of Fire.
5:35 Speaker 02 Exactly.
5:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So when there's a volcano erupting or an earthquake in that zone, we shouldn't be surprised?
5:40 Speaker 02 No.
5:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not at all.
5:42 Speaker 02 Business as usual.
5:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Business as usual for Earth. So what kind of, I have a tweet from someone, let's say, to read the tweet, tweet names are always fascinating here, just call him Struber, why is it so hard to predict earthquakes when we know so much about plate tectonics? Because you sound knowledgeable, what's the problem here?
6:01 Speaker 02 Earthquakes are due to a very localized phenomenon in the upper portions of our planet. It may impact the larger areas.
6:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The crust, you mean the crust, the upper portions?
6:09 Speaker 02 The crust and then earthquakes actually are sourced in the mantle, that region.
6:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Deep down.
6:14 Speaker 02 That fluid portion below the brittle crust of our planet. Yes, earthquakes can start there as well, but they're a localized phenomenon to start, and to actually be able to predict at any given point in time what's going to happen in the immediate future becomes difficult.
6:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you can predict sort of statistically how many earthquakes you might expect in a zone or in a region, but for a specific spot, a city, a town, and a date, you can't provide that just yet?
6:38 Speaker 02 Without precursory information, exactly, that's what makes it difficult.
6:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Precursory information? That sounds like the information you haven't figured out how to get yet, is that?
6:46 Speaker 02 Well, that's what earth scientists and others are trying to acquire and try to interpret, to look for correlations between some precursor phenomenon.
6:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so now, so we have earthquakes, and now there's this scale that we use to measure them. When I grew up, they called it the Richter scale, but now it seems to be called something different. Steve Soder studied earthquakes throughout history and as they've affected cultures and civilizations. So what's the scale we're using today?
7:09 Speaker 01 Well, it's called the moment magnitude scale. The old Richter scale could not measure earthquakes that were of the highest magnitudes accurately.
7:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the scale was ineffective?
7:21 Speaker 01 It was ineffective.
7:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? At distinguishing really high magnitude from even higher magnitude earthquakes?
7:26 Speaker 01 Correct. And so a new magnitude scale based on what's called moment magnitude was devised in the 1970s. And that involves three factors. One is the area of the fault that breaks. A second is the slip along that fault.
7:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? How far it moves?
7:43 Speaker 01 How far it moves. And the third is the rigidity of the rock, how strong the rock is.
7:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So you can actually quantify the rigidity? So two extremes of rigidity, one might be rubber, and another extreme might be diamond, let's say?
7:57 Speaker 01 Yes. And those things can all be measured more or less for all earthquakes.
8:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so you come up with numbers, and now the numbers seem pretty simple, it's like one to 10 or something, but is there a limit to the scale?
8:08 Speaker 01 Well, actually, it's a logarithmic scale, which means that each number, going from a magnitude, say, seven to eight, is not a small change in energy. It turns out to be a change of a factor of about 33 for each magnitude.
8:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For each magnitude?
8:27 Speaker 01 Yes. So if you go up two magnitudes, it's 33 times 33, which is 1,000, in terms of the amount of energy which is released. So, for example, the earthquake that just struck Japan was a magnitude nine. The earthquake that struck in Haiti was a magnitude seven. The difference in the energy was a factor of a thousand.
8:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Factor of a thousand. And so, so if you look at earthquake magnitude scales, the last numbers I saw for Japan were eight point nine. I want to so round that to nine.
8:57 Speaker 01 It has been rounded by the US Geological Survey to nine.
9:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It has been rounded to nine. Okay. So that's good. So, I mean, not good. I mean, it's useful.
9:06 Speaker 01 Simplifies.
9:07 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Simplifies how we think about this. So that's interesting to know about the magnitude of that quake versus other quakes that we know about. And when I think about it, what, so where, what's the limit of quake power on the scale?
9:21 Speaker 01 It has to do with the size of the fault.
9:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because I once got a tweet from something. Is this, is it in this batch here? I'm looking at my notes here. The, yeah. Who is this? Someone named Corbett asked, I keep getting asked, would a 10.0 earthquake end the world? Because we've never had a 10.0 earthquake. It might be worth touching on, as millions are predicting no Christmas after that one.
9:43 Speaker 01 Well, the largest recorded earthquake was a 9.5. That was in Chile in 1960.
9:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's basically modern times. It's not some historical thing.
9:53 Speaker 01 It's only in modern times that we've been able to measure these things, to quantify these things with any degree of accuracy.
9:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Back to what year?
9:59 Speaker 01 Oh, about 1900, probably.
10:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Back to 1900. Okay. So that's a century of data we have going for us. All right. So you had a 19, a 9.5, where was it again?
10:06 Speaker 01 That was along the coast of Chile, South America.
10:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Here we are, Jim Webster in the Ring of Fire again. Exactly. Yeah. All right. So Steve, continue.
10:13 Speaker 01 Okay. Well, that earthquake was the largest that was measured instrumentally. How large could an earthquake be? It depends on the length of the fault. And faults cannot be indefinitely large. For one thing, it cannot be larger than the Earth.
10:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Than a circle around the Earth.
10:27 Speaker 01 Right. But just hypothetically, suppose that you considered the circumference of the entire Earth as a fault, and you made a slip across that that had the, the, the size of the slip of a very large earthquake. And we know the rigidity of the Earth. If you put those numbers together, you would get a hypothetical earthquake of magnitude 12. I mean, that would be the extreme upper limit.
10:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that'd be a really bad day on Earth.
10:49 Speaker 01 Yes. But of course, it's totally unrealistic, because there's no way that you could have a break along a fault.
10:56 Speaker 01 That wrapped entirely around the Earth.
10:58 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Now, if you start, so earthquakes, it seems to me, could, Jim, my resident geologist now, earthquakes ought to be able to trigger a volcano, is that correct?
11:08 Speaker 02 You know, that's an excellent question, because for years at the museum, we would hear these questions posed by the public, and honestly, initially, folks would scoff at the likelihood that there was some reaction between.
11:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When you say folks, you mean your colleagues of another era?
11:21 Speaker 02 Unfortunately, yes.
11:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, be specific.
11:23 Speaker 02 Well, I don't want to embarrass my colleagues, but yes, that was the typical response, but in the last several decades, we've seen data that seemed to imply strongly that there can be relationships, causal relationships. For example, after this earthquake that Steve was talking about in Chile in 1960, within 38 hours, there was a major eruption at Cordon Calle, about 380 kilometers away. And there have been.
11:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 380 kilometers is not far, given the size of these plates.
11:50 Speaker 02 Exactly.
11:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right. Now, in Japan, Fujiyama is a volcanic cone, isn't that correct?
11:56 Speaker 02 Mount Fuji, yes.
11:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mount Fuji, yes, and so, so, any chance that this earthquake will stimulate Fujiyama back into an explosion? Because when did it, Steve, when did Fujiyama last explode? Do you remember?
12:08 Speaker 01 I believe it's 1700.
12:11 Speaker 02 1707.
12:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? 1707.
12:13 Speaker 02 Right.
12:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, any chance of that happening again?
12:16 Speaker 02 Probably a very slight chance, not to worry the inhabitants of Japan that they're yet to suffer another tragedy, but potentially, if there is magma sitting in Fuji, charged with gases, waiting for some trigger, this could potentially provide.
12:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If it were primed for that trigger.
12:32 Speaker 02 Exactly, we require that.
12:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? If it's not primed, it's just another day in the life of a dormant volcano. After the break, we'll talk about what effect, if any, the universe has on the Earth.
13:11 Neil deGrasse Tyson? We're back to StarTalk. I have two special guests in the studio with me on this special StarTalk program where we're focusing on the violent Earth and what it's done to us in the past, what it might continue to do to us in the future, with special attention, of course, to the earthquake in Japan. Joining with Steve Soder, he's an astrophysicist, a longtime friend and colleague of mine, and Jim Webster, a geologist specializing in volcanoes, both of whom from the scientific departments of the American Museum of Natural History. Jim, I hand you your elements that you work with. You're actually a geochemist, specifically, right?
13:46 Speaker 02 I'm a geochemist on the mineral deposits curator at the museum.
13:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Mineral deposits, and so I can give you some of these minerals from the formation of the Earth. The base elements that make your minerals are part of the gas cloud that forms the solar system. And they don't really segregate out until we have this molten blob that would one day become Earth. Heavy things sink to the bottom, light things sink to the top. And over the break, you were telling me about what goes on on Earth to get these heavy elements sort of out from the lower regions to the surface where we can then mine them as ore. So what is that process?
14:17 Speaker 02 Well, in the context of our violent or active or dynamic Earth, it's not only earthquakes and volcanoes that are a consequence of energy from its interior, but these magma or molten bodies actually heat water. The water dissolves trace concentrations of metals like gold or silver or copper and many others, moves them and deposits them in fractures forming vein deposits in the crust of our planet.
14:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this is where we get these ores?
14:42 Speaker 02 They're beneficial to us, absolutely.
14:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? When I see a vein that is iron or gold or platinum, that used to be running water through that rock.
14:50 Speaker 02 A great many of them, yes. Because we know from just washing clothes at home, hot water is a better solvent. It does a better job of cleaning. Very hot water in the interior of our planet and across our planet dissolves metals.
15:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It does such a good job of cleaning, it cleans off the color from your clothes as well. Exactly. And so, not only have there been concerns about what's going on with Earth, there's been a lot of sort of misinformation, even pseudoscience regarding the forces of the universe and whether they had some effect on the earthquake itself. For example, there was a report, dare I say it was even advanced by a meteorologist suggesting that something called a supermoon might have had special influence on Earth's crust, triggering the Japanese earthquake. And a supermoon by that terminology would be a moon in its orbit around the Earth, which is elliptical, sometimes closer to Earth, sometimes farther away. The more colloquial term for that would be oval.
15:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So when the moon is very close, it has stronger tidal forces. So the tides that we all know and love at the beach, these forces are operating and are related to the moon's distance from us. But they're also related to the phases of the moon. Full moon and new moon have high tides. Quarter moons give you the neap tides, where the moon is actually competing for the sun, for who's going to raise the water and the water doesn't get raised at all. So if you combine full moon, new moon, with when it's closest, you get sort of a double effect. And there was worry and concern that the supermoon might have caused this. The problem was, for that concept, is that the earthquake took place during quarter moon. So it's not even a full moon, you're not even combining that.
16:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the supermoon that anyone would refer to took place on March 19th. And March 19th is, okay, so you have full moon, you'll have a close moon. If you look at the data, we have a lot of data on full moons in the history of the world. We know the moon's orbit from Newton's laws. You go back through time and you just correlate this with where and when earthquakes might have happened. And Steve Soder, what did we find?
16:53 Speaker 01 There's no correlation.
16:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? There is, there's no correlation.
16:55 Speaker 01 People have been looking for it for a long time to see if there's any. Correlation between the occurrence of earthquakes and the lunar orbit and the tides, and there's nothing significant.
17:04 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it's simply not there. And so, so people might say, well, it's got to have some effect. And what I always then tell them is, if it has any effect at all, what you really want to do is compare it with other things that might have an effect that swamps it, allowing you to completely ignore these other phenomena. And so, uh, when you look at other factors that can affect what's going on in the earth. For example, Jim, beneath the crust, there's this gurgling convection of moving magma all the time.
17:31 Speaker 02 In the mantle, that portion of the planet just below the crust that's fluid, most of it is not liquid, it's solid, but over geologic time, hundreds of millions of years, it's slowly moving, but it's driving the motions of the plates at the surface and, and leading to magma forming at the crust and volcanoes erupting, and again, most of our seismicity. But can I ask you a question?
17:52 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, sure, sure.
17:53 Speaker 02 And as you're talking about the fact of tides, we know that earth tides, the attraction of the moon, actually causes our planet to expand and contract roughly a meter.
18:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Yeah, yeah, not only the liquid, the liquid contents of the earth, the oceans, but also the physical earth expands about a meter every time you go through high tide. That's correct. This is happening all the time, twice a day, twice a day.
18:12 Speaker 02 And still we have no correlation with, with seismic activity?
18:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? No correlation, that's correct. Because we have two high tides a day, two low tides a day, that you'd think, by the way, just be, by the way, in the solar system, there are places where tides are totally wreaking havoc on their host objects. For example, tides from Jupiter are squeezing and pumping energy into the nearby moons to Jupiter. Io is one of them, Europa is another. These moons are much, much hotter for the effects of the tidal forces. In fact, surely you know, Jim, that the most active volcano in the solar system is Jupiter's moon Io. It's got volcanoes there, and where is it getting its heat? It's a tiny little object. It's getting pumped by the tidal forces of Jupiter.
18:57 Speaker 02 They have unusual volcanoes, sulfur emitting volcanoes on Io.
19:00 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You don't want to be there for that. Right? And so, so the point is, Steve, then, then if there were a correlation, it would have easily revealed itself in the data, because we have centuries, millennia of data.
19:11 Speaker 01 Yes.
19:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Of, of earthquakes and lunar phases.
19:14 Speaker 01 That's right.
19:15 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So I just want to dispel that myth. Whether or not it has happened or can happen elsewhere, our moon doesn't do it to Earth.
19:22 Speaker 01 That's correct.
19:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Period. Okay, so not only that, we have people concerned about what effect the earthquake has on our axis. And that's a fun one. It's fun to calculate that, Steve, so what can you tell us there?
19:34 Speaker 01 Well, when there is a major earthquake and the motion of plates, there's a displacement.
19:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Steve is motioning with his hands. It's kind of cute, it's like a little dance thing here, okay.
19:42 Speaker 01 Okay, but there's a slight redistribution of the mass of the Earth. It's very slight on the scale of the entire Earth, but it's enough to make a change, a very small change in the length of day and the tilt of the Earth's axis, but they're really trivial. They're nothing that you would notice or would have any consequences of practical...
20:01 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because I've got a question here, there's another tweet that says, "Is it common for large earthquakes to change Earth's axis and will the Earth correct itself or is each change permanent?" That's a great question.
20:10 Speaker 01 Well, the changes are random and so they act in different directions. They won't correct themselves, but it is common. It's just that the effects are extremely small.
20:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So if they're random, it means some earthquakes can speed up the rotation of the Earth and others can slow them down.
20:24 Speaker 01 Exactly.
20:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So the net effect might just be nothing over a long enough baseline of time.
20:29 Speaker 01 That's right.
20:29 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All right, and so, but so the actual basis of that phenomenon is that your rotation rate is related to how the mass is distributed in your body.
20:40 Speaker 01 It's like an ice skater, meaning holding weights at arms length.
20:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And in their case, their weights are just the weights of their hands.
20:46 Speaker 01 Right, pulling them in slightly.
20:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They're changing the distribution of their mass.
20:50 Speaker 01 And so you spin up.
20:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? They spin up.
20:51 Speaker 01 To conserve angular momentum, as it's called, and the Earth can do the same thing.
20:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so if plates start moving, so Jim, plates move over each other, under each other, sideways to each other?
21:00 Speaker 02 Well, in the process of subduction, the more dense but thinner ocean crust...
21:05 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's an actual word, subduction.
21:06 Speaker 02 Subduction.
21:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Sounds very X-rated.
21:07 Speaker 02 Gejargon.
21:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Gejargon, go for it.
21:09 Speaker 02 But the ocean crust, because it's more dense and thinner, is actually thrust or subducted beneath nearby continental crust.
21:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so you're changing the distribution of mass on the earth.
21:18 Speaker 02 You're changing distribution.
21:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So it has to either speed up or slow down in response to that.
21:23 Speaker 02 So in the case of the Japanese earthquake, Japan moved towards the east about eight feet, and it was in the same direction that the earth was spinning, correct? So that's why the earth is spinning up.
21:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Well, actually, it would have to, it would relate to whether mass moved towards the pole or away from the pole, because then that's where you're getting closer to the rotation axis or farther away. So then, so this would be the, the, the, so we can ask, how much of an effect did this have? And so, Steve, what was?
21:49 Speaker 01 It's negligible.
21:49 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Negligible. Is that your quanti, how you quantify it?
21:53 Speaker 01 Yes, of no practical consequence whatsoever.
21:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It is true, however, that we track and monitor the rotation rate of the earth. The tides raised on our surface by the moon, the sloshing of these tides back and forth on our continental shelves creates friction and actually slows down the rotation of the earth systematically. So in fact, we've had, what, we're up to 23 or so leap seconds added to the calendar to compensate for our slowing down simply because of the tides.
22:19 Speaker 01 The day is getting longer because of the tides.
22:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Day is getting longer, and that's been going on forever.
22:25 Speaker 01 Since the moon was there.
22:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So here's another quick question in the, in just the couple of minutes we have left before our next break. If we drill into the earth's crust, pulling out oil and ore and replacing it with water, what effect does that have on the stability of the crust, Jim?
22:40 Speaker 02 That has no real effect. We, we do know that there's subsidence in places like the Phoenix area where groundwater's withdrawn has caused local areas of collapse and this very local, very shallow levels of collapse.
22:50 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Collapse of land.
22:51 Speaker 02 And land, but not in the larger plate tectonics, large crustal process.
22:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But Steve, wasn't there some plate, some measured earthquake levels from this activity?
23:00 Speaker 01 Well, there was injection of fluids into the crust of the earth in, I think Colorado in the 1960s that began to trigger lots of small earthquakes, and when they stopped...
23:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Small would be on what level?
23:10 Speaker 01 Oh, magnitude four, something like that.
23:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Four, so Jim, magnitude four, do you even feel that? I remember when the World Trade Center collapsed, I lived nearby them. I made careful notice of what it felt like as they collapsed. It was about on the level of a subway rumbling underfoot. And then I read the earthquake scale. 4.5 is about that. It'll rattle your dishes a little, but there's no ever any damage.
23:30 Speaker 02 That's about right. So it was the lubrication of these fluids being injected in Colorado along the fault surface that allowed the slippage to increase and cause these small earthquakes.
23:37 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what you're saying is that if you have friction, holding it together and then you start pumping...
23:42 Speaker 02 Locking them up.
23:43 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's basically locked by friction.
23:44 Speaker 01 You're weakening the fault when you inject a fluid into it.
23:46 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're lubricating the fluid.
23:48 Speaker 01 Exactly.
23:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? You're lubricating the fault. And so you can actually trigger earthquakes by this method?
23:53 Speaker 02 Yes.
23:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's amazing. We're gonna have to get back to that in the fourth segment. But in the third segment, we'll go straight to my interview, which I had this afternoon with nuclear physicist Michio Kaku to talk about Japan's nuclear power plant and the disaster risks involved. We'll see you at the end of the break.
24:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? StarTalk Radio, our special Violent Earth edition, inspired by the tragic earthquake and tsunami in Japan. We're gonna go straight to my interview with Michio Kaku, professor of physics at the City University of New York, to chat about Japan and the nuclear risks that are posed by the reactors. Check it out. So Michio, when we think of nuclear power, there's fusion, there's fission, but all power plants in the world are fission, right?
24:57 Speaker 03 That's right. Fusion power is the engine of the universe. It what drives the stars, the galaxy, all of it, because we fuse hydrogen to create helium. But on the earth, as far as we can tell, only on the earth do we use uranium. So instead of fusing the atoms of hydrogen, we split the atom of uranium. Now, believe it or not, Mother Nature does not use fission. Only in bombs and nuclear power plants do we use fission.
25:21 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the whole universe?
25:23 Speaker 03 Could be. There's only one naturally occurring reactor that we think can go back to paleo times. But other than that, we see... No example of a naturally occurring fission process.
25:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, we know of all these sort of bad byproduct of fission, and this is the physics of the nuclear bombs. But so why don't we just use fusion? Is it because we don't know how to control it yet?
25:43 Speaker 03 Well, it's relatively easy to create a fission plant because uranium will split up all by itself. So you do nothing, and then you can get a fission process going. Of course, you have to purify it. Fusion, on the other hand, you have to concentrate with enormous pressures and temperatures to get the fusion process going. That's why Mother Nature can do it because gravity is for free in outer space. Hey, you get gas, you compress it, boom, bingo, you got a star. When I was in high school, by the way, my advisor was one of the founders of this nuclear energy, Edward Teller. Nuclear energy, he said, does not belong on the surface of the earth. It belongs underground. Because if it's underground and you have a tsunami, you simply put the manhole cover on it and walk away. Now, the fundamental difference between fusion and fission as far as health and safety
26:28 Speaker 03 are concerned, is that fusion is clean. Helium gas is actually commercially valuable. Hydrogen to helium, very clean, very little nuclear waste.
26:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Helium is the byproduct of fusion going on in the sun every day of the week.
26:40 Speaker 03 But fission creates fission products. In other words, you split the uranium atom, you get cesium, strontium, iodine, all the radioactive products that come spewing out of a nuclear accident.
26:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And these very same chemicals can be absorbed into the body in bad ways.
26:54 Speaker 03 That's right. Take a look at the thyroid gland. The thyroid gland can absorb iodine 131 with a half-life of eight days and give you thyroid cancer. In fact, thyroid cancer was one of the main byproducts, health byproducts, of the Chernobyl accident. People drank milk. Iodine occurs in water soluble form, gets into the milk, concentrates in the thyroid gland. Strontium-90 concentrates in the bone marrow. And cesium-137 will concentrate throughout the body. The half-life of strontium and cesium are about 30 years. And that means that if you ingest this into your bones and your muscle, your body will become radioactive and will be radioactive for centuries. Long after you're dead, your grave will be radioactive.
27:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Japan is no stranger to national disaster. They've been in an earthquake zone ever since the culture set foot there. There's also, of course, the nuclear bomb blast from 1945. And there's no shortage of the films that show Godzilla and other sort of creatures leveling cities. So can you comment on how well Japan is taking this?
27:55 Speaker 03 In the Japanese language, we have something called gaman. That is, suffer quietly. And that's what they've done throughout their history. 1923, the entire city of Tokyo was leveled. 140,000 people died in that massive Kanto earthquake. And yeah, you live with it. Every time I go to Tokyo, you kind of feel the earth shake underneath your feet. And so you realize that even though we have satellites in outer space and we can see in outer space, we cannot even see an inch below your own feet. You can't predict them. There's no way to X-ray the earth. And as a consequence, we're children when it comes to predicting earthquakes.
28:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? My view on this is the disasters thus far doesn't seem to be much worse than anything that's happened before, such as in Chernobyl. Is this a day to celebrate how safe Japan has made itself in the face of what it knew would be ultimate disasters?
28:49 Speaker 03 Well, some people think that the situation is, quote, "stable." Well, that's like hanging in there on a cliff on your fingernails. Yes, it's stable. But if your fingernails start to break or start to get tired, you are toast. And so that's the situation here that as long as the radioactive byproducts don't penetrate the containment, then you're okay, like Three Mile Island. Three Mile Island was the Class 5 accident. 90% of the core disintegrated, but the vessel held the radioactive material.
29:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The vessel intended to do that by design.
29:21 Speaker 03 That's right. In fact, the rods, which are very clean and vertical, looks like a box. At Three Mile Island, when they opened up the reactor to photograph the state of the core, they found that it looked like a bowl of granola, totally fragmented and disintegrated.
29:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? But nonetheless contained.
29:35 Speaker 03 But contained. Now, we think that this accident is Class 6 in the sense that it's contained but seeping out.
29:41 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Not explosively, but just through...
29:43 Speaker 03 Steam explosions and hydrogen gas explosions. Xerconium interacts with water to create hydrogen gas. You light a cigarette, you light a switch and boom, you have hydrogen gas explosion. And we had three of them in Japan.
29:55 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Many people thought those explosions were radioactive.
29:59 Speaker 03 It was a chemical explosion, but it blew the roof right off the containment structure. And at Chernobyl, we had a class seven accident. An accident that ruptured not just the core, not just the vessel, but the building itself. And shot about 25% of the fission products right into the air, into people's backyard.
30:17 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And all I'm saying is at Chernobyl, it was unprovoked by nature.
30:20 Speaker 03 Right, and Chernobyl, it was human error. People disengaged the scram safety mechanism.
30:25 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And meanwhile, in Japan, that plant's been around since the early 70s, right?
30:28 Speaker 03 That's right. It's a very old 1971 design, the Mark I General Electric boiling water reactor.
30:33 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So why doesn't the reactor just cool down all by itself? What is driving the heat source that puts it at risk of melting?
30:39 Speaker 03 A nuclear meltdown is forever, in the sense that you have all this nuclear waste. Once you shut off the chain reaction, power is reduced by 90%. But it's that last 10% of power that lasts for tens of thousands of years. And that causes the meltdown. It's called decay heat. Decay heat very slowly goes away. But that decay heat, the 10% of the original power, is enough to melt the containment, is enough to blow the entire reactor apart, and we saw that at Chernobyl.
31:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So this is the heat that it would generate on its own?
31:10 Speaker 03 Right. People say, well, why didn't they simply hit the off switch, right? Why didn't they simply turn it off? You cannot turn off Mother Nature. You cannot turn off nuclear fission. So once you scram the rods, that is, you stop the chain reaction, decay heat keeps on going for an extended period of time at Chernobyl. Do you know that it's still hot at Chernobyl? That was a 1986 explosion. When it rains, water seeps into the sarcophagus of concrete, heats up. The chain reaction slowly builds up again.
31:36 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Water is an excellent source of coolant, so what's the problem? There's no shortage of water, obviously, especially in the face of a tsunami.
31:43 Speaker 03 Think of driving a car. The car is out of control. What do you do? You hit the brakes, but the brakes don't work. Then the radiator starts to overheat and the radiator explodes. So your brakes don't work, the radiator explodes, and then your gas tank is about to catch on fire. What do you do? You head for the river. The river will cool down the car, cool down the radiator, and make sure that you don't explode. Well, that's what's happening at the reactor site. First, the emergency core cooling system didn't work because the tsunami knocked it out. No brakes. Then hydrogen gas bubble blew up the containment structure, blowing up your radiator. And then what they do? They pump seawater into the reactor site.
32:20 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Next best thing available.
32:22 Speaker 03 Right, like driving it into the river. But the problem is that it is away from the oceans. You have to pump it in. There's no electricity. The pumps don't work. The generators don't work. And the crew there is being reduced from 800 people down to 50. You're talking about essentially a suicide squad that know that they could get a lethal dose. So there's not enough manpower to make sure that seawater is covering everything, even as the seawater boils off. But I tell you, at a certain point, even they will leave. And at that point, we'll have to abandon ship. And when you abandon ship, you're gonna have three meltdowns right in a row. That's the nightmare scenario. And the spent fuel pond, which is adjacent to the three reactors, is open to the sky. There's no cover. There's no vessel.
33:06 Speaker 03 It's just an open swimming pool of hot rods containing more waste than in the core of a nuclear power plant. Hollywood likes to focus in on the core, the meltdown, but it is the lowly waste dump that could actually cause the most damage. And that's what is now separating President Obama from the Japanese Prime Minister. President Obama's people are saying, hey, you got no water on that spent fuel pond. It could explode. It's dangerous. And the Japanese government is saying, no, no, no, things are stable. Well, I think the meltdown that we are seeing is the meltdown of the credibility of the Japanese government.
33:38 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So what is the future of nuclear fission?
33:42 Speaker 03 Well, the future of nuclear fission is a Faustian bargain. Faust was the mythical figure who sold his soul to the devil for unlimited power. And nations like Japan that have no coal, oil reserves are reaching for this Faustian bargain. The price you pay is you have a tremendous amount of fission products, which are quite hot. These fission products can be released in a nuclear accident. And as a consequence, you have to take care of your nuclear power plants very carefully if you undergo the Faustian bargain. But now, in light of this Japanese accident, many nations, including Germany, are rethinking the Faustian bargain. Unlimited power, the only price is your soul.
34:22 Neil deGrasse Tyson? One of the problems Japan also faces is where it is located geographically on Earth. It's part of the Ring of Fire. So if they're trying to make their own energy without the natural resources of coal and oil, and they do it by nuclear, then they've got a nuclear power plant on fault zones.
34:36 Speaker 03 That's right. Ninety percent of all earthquakes on the Earth are in the Pacific Ring of Fire. It's the same fault line that leveled San Francisco in 1906. My grandfather was in that earthquake. He was part of the cleanup operation. It leveled Tokyo in 1923. It's caused some of the greatest tragedies in human history, the Pacific Ring of Fire.
34:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So your family and ancestry has been in the United States for more than a century, then?
35:00 Speaker 03 That's right. About 100 years my family's been here. But we have relatives in Japan. And one of the things that our relatives are debating right now is whether to evacuate.
35:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? For good.
35:10 Speaker 03 Well, until they can bring the reactor under control and until they can make sure that there's no contamination. However, Chernobyl realized that some of the land will be a dead zone for maybe centuries to come. Because you have to multiply the half-life by 10 before it becomes relatively safe. So Chernobyl released cesium and strontium, half-lives of around 30 years. So in 300 years, parts of Chernobyl area will be usable.
35:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So that's where the radiation level goes below what people have determined to be safe.
35:39 Speaker 03 That's right. In fact, you have a piece of Chernobyl in your body. I have a piece of Chernobyl in my body, of course, in a microscopic form. But it circled the Earth, and the radiation from Japan is not dangerous to the United States, but it is already in the United States. We've got to take a quick break, but more StarTalk when we return.
36:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Startalk Radio, our special violent earth edition, inspired by the tragic earthquake and tsunami in Japan. Japan, of course, is a leader in earthquake-resistant building. They're no stranger to earthquakes. They know, they live in the Ring of Fire. The culture is industrially advanced. And I think it's worth commenting that surely many more people would have died from the earthquake and tsunami were it not for the earthquake-proofing of the physical infrastructure of that region. Steve, Steve Soder, joining me on Startalk, yes?
37:01 Speaker 01 Not just the earthquake-proofing of buildings, but also the training and the education of what to do when there's a tsunami warning. Most of the people who would otherwise have been drowned headed to high ground as soon as they heard the warning.
37:13 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And some of the high ground are just buildings that would survive the earthquake at first and the rushing water in its lower levels afterwards.
37:19 Speaker 01 Correct, but even just the foothills. And many more people would have died had this population not been educated.
37:26 Neil deGrasse Tyson? This is an 8.9 earthquake. Not long ago, there was an earthquake in Haiti, and that was a 7.0-ish. And can you compare these energies?
37:34 Speaker 01 Well, the energies, by two orders of magnitude in the earthquake magnitudes, actually translates to a thousand-fold increase in energy of the Japanese earthquake compared to the Haitian one. The difference was that...
37:48 Neil deGrasse Tyson? The difference in the death toll, because in Japan, the death toll will likely settle out in around 15,000, between 10,000 and 20,000.
37:56 Speaker 01 Probably something like that.
37:57 Neil deGrasse Tyson? That's correct. Whereas in Haiti, it was a quarter million people.
37:59 Speaker 01 That's correct. There was, first of all, the earthquake, even though it was a weaker earthquake, was almost right under the capital city. Second, there was essentially zero earthquake preparation or education or construction to withstand earthquakes.
38:14 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And not only that, you go back to 2004, you get to the Indonesian tsunami. Jim, there was an offshore earthquake. What was the magnitude of that one? Do you remember?
38:25 Speaker 01 That was in the nines.
38:27 Neil deGrasse Tyson? In the nines, so that was huge, unfortunately. And so that was a tsunami that just rolled through, it was another quarter million people down.
38:33 Speaker 01 Yes.
38:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so we look around the world, so it's remarkable that the numbers could be as low as they are in Japan. And so, so now we have a tsunami, and Steve, you've studied tsunamis in the history of human culture. In particular, there's an ancient Greek city, Heliiki, that you studied. And you judge the end of that city to have been from a tsunami?
38:54 Speaker 01 Yes, well, according to the ancient writers who described the demise of the city of Heliiki, which was on the Gulf of Corinth in Greece, it was destroyed by an earthquake and a tsunami, and then it was submerged. And that's one of the earliest descriptions of a tsunami that we have, but the city seems to have been wiped off the face of the earth.
39:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So unlike Lisbon in 1755, which was destroyed by earthquake, fire, and tsunami, that city was rebuilt.
39:17 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:18 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Heliiki, after all was said and done, was underwater, is what you're saying. Permanently underwater.
39:24 Speaker 01 Yes.
39:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So big was the shift in the plates of the earth.
39:26 Speaker 01 Well, it was probably not the plates so much as local subsidence of the sediment.
39:31 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Land sinking.
39:32 Speaker 01 It was soft material, it was unstable.
39:34 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Unstable.
39:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:35 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And so, how does an earthquake make a tsunami? Is it just the obvious, it shakes the water?
39:40 Speaker 01 Well, the main thing is, there's a change in level where the earthquake happens, on the seafloor. And so the water is either displaced or fills in to make up for that, and then because water is fluid, it will be unstable and will form a wave.
39:54 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A wave of energy to move vast distances.
39:57 Speaker 01 And another way it can happen is, sometimes an earthquake will trigger an underwater landslide, and that will displace a lot of water.
40:03 Neil deGrasse Tyson? All you gotta do is displace water and you're done.
40:05 Speaker 01 And that will make a larger tsunami than the earthquake alone.
40:08 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So, from Brian Okoa, did I get the pronunciation of his name right? From our Facebook page, Facebook is StarTalkRadio.
40:16 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Finest StarTalk Radio. And we're also, our website is StarTalkRadio.net. He asked, "What kind of advances have been made in predicting and detecting tsunamis?" Jim, NOAA, the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration, don't they have buoys across the ocean?
40:35 Speaker 02 Yeah, especially in the Pacific Ocean, given the fact that it's making up the core of the Ring of Fire, and especially after the Indonesian earthquake in 2004. There are buoys that can actually measure wave height changes, and this information's transmitted to satellites, and therefore transmitted to tsunami warning centers.
40:51 Neil deGrasse Tyson? I've seen the Pacific Ocean, the waves are jumping up and down all the time. So how is it going to know whether it's a tsunami wave versus just some turbulence in a local storm?
40:59 Speaker 01 Well, I think that there are patterns, and in the wavelength and the timing, there's a regularity, that you can sort that out.
41:06 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so you need, obviously, more than one buoy to do this?
41:08 Speaker 01 Yes, you need a network.
41:10 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A network of buoys, so that's the catch here. And so, when you have a network, you can actually measure things like the speed of the tsunami moving across.
41:18 Speaker 01 The height of the wave.
41:19 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And the height of the wave. So in mid-ocean, how high is a tsunami wave?
41:21 Speaker 01 Well, it's actually not very high, maybe a foot or something like that.
41:24 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Just a foot, so if you're a ship at sea, when a tsunami rolls under you, you wouldn't even know.
41:28 Speaker 01 You would hardly know it, because the wavelength is enormous.
41:30 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Wavelength is the distance from peak to peak of this wave.
41:33 Speaker 01 Right, that could be like hundreds of miles, and it's passing, it might take an hour to pass, or there'd be a slow rise and fall of your boat, you wouldn't even know
41:39 Neil deGrasse Tyson? it.
41:40 Speaker 01 You wouldn't even know it. But as that wave goes into the shallow areas, it slows down.
41:44 Neil deGrasse Tyson? As it comes near the continental shelf, and so you have to come to the shoreline where you're sea level.
41:48 Speaker 01 Right, and as it's slowing down, as it's getting shallower, at the leading edge of the wave, the water coming behind it is moving faster, so it piles up and it rises.
41:56 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And it rises, and it reaches a point where it just overtakes the shoreline and just keeps moving in.
42:01 Speaker 01 Yes.
42:02 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Because that energy is, so people think of a tsunami in mid-ocean as moving water in mid-ocean, but it's not really that.
42:08 Speaker 01 It's moving energy.
42:09 Neil deGrasse Tyson? It's energy manifested by this bump that transfers from one location to the other completely across the Pacific. How fast does the wave move?
42:20 Speaker 01 I think it can be hundreds of miles an hour, depends on the depth.
42:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Okay, so in this case, if I remember correctly, it was 500 miles an hour, like it's fast as a jetliner. Because I was looking at the times where they predicted when it would hit the west coast of the United States, and I said, "That's about how long it takes to fly." Steve, we were discussing earlier offline that the Pacific Northwest is at risk to tsunamis?
42:41 Speaker 01 Well, there is a subduction zone, a place where the Pacific Plate is actually diving under North America, along the coast of Northern California, Oregon, Washington, British Columbia. That is capable of making large earthquakes, and there's geological and actually historical evidence that there have been massive earthquakes there with a repeat time on the order of something like 350 years. The last one was in the year 1700.
43:07 Speaker 02 Now, this evidence is debris deposits, is that right?
43:10 Speaker 01 Yes, there's debris deposits, there's sunken forests.
43:12 Neil deGrasse Tyson? So debris from a tsunami that came far into land?
43:15 Speaker 02 We're seeing images, unfortunately, of the debris off the coast of Japan. So this is natural debris, is that right?
43:19 Speaker 01 Yes, but there was also subsidence, and so there's a drowned forest, for example.
43:23 Neil deGrasse Tyson? A drowned forest?
43:24 Speaker 01 Yes, where the trees were all killed, and from the tree rings you can date that event exactly to the year, and it corresponds to a tsunami that was recorded across the Pacific in Japan in the year 1700. So the source of that tsunami was along the coast of Northwest United States.
43:42 Neil deGrasse Tyson? And that was a tsunami headed back the other way?
43:44 Speaker 01 Exactly.
43:45 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Back west?
43:46 Speaker 01 Yes.
43:47 Neil deGrasse Tyson? Steve Soder, Jim Webster, thanks for coming on the show. You've been listening to StarTalk Radio, and I've been Neil deGrasse Tyson. As always, keep looking up.
Previous Cosmic Cuisine Next Are You Out of Your Mind? Page updated September 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated