Chappaquiddick & The Real Reason Ted Kennedy Never Became President (with Pete Holmes)
- 1h 1m
- Transcript
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
Ed Helms and Pete Holmes revisit the 1969 Chappaquiddick incident, in which Ted Kennedy's car went off a bridge into Poucha Pond on Chappaquiddick Island, killing Mary Jo Kopecky, a speechwriter from RFK's 1968 campaign. Helms, who played Kennedy's cousin Joe Gargan in the 2017 film Chappaquiddick, walks through the night's timeline: the yacht regatta, the gathering of the Boiler Room Girls at a cottage, the car's plunge into the tidal pond, and Kennedy's ten-hour delay before reporting the accident. Holmes, a Bostonian, reacts to the details and offers his take on why the story still grips the public imagination.
The episode covers the political aftermath, including Kennedy's guilty plea to leaving the scene, his TV statement written largely by Ted Sorensen, and his successful appeal to Massachusetts constituents to keep his Senate seat. They discuss the 1970 judicial inquest, the absence of an autopsy, and multiple conspiracy theories ranging from Rosemary Keough's purse in the car to the claim that Kennedy and Gargan submerged the vehicle deliberately. Holmes pushes back on the diver's testimony that Kopecky survived in an air pocket for 30 minutes, calling it a claim made for magazine attention.
- Ted Kennedy's Oldsmobile was found upside down in Poucha Pond on July 19, 1969, with Mary Jo Kopecky's body inside and no evidence of illegal activity. 33:57
- Kennedy made a noise complaint at 3 a.m. and was seen having breakfast the next morning before finally reporting the accident at 10 a.m., a full ten hours after the crash. 42:08
- The 1970 judicial inquest determined the likely cause of death was negligent driving, a finding many viewed as institutional cover-up. 55:37
- Ted Kennedy authored over 2,500 bills during his Senate career, several hundred of which became law, and died in 2009 with a reputation as the lion of the senate. 59:19
- Diver John Farrar testified that Kopecky may have survived in an air pocket for up to 30 minutes, implying Kennedy's delay cost her life; Holmes dismisses the claim as made for magazine attention. 1:02:46
Highlights
- 7:59
Helms Reveals His Chappaquiddick Rolestory
Ed Helms discloses that he played Joe Gargan in the 2017 film Chappaquiddick, alongside Jim Gaffigan as Paul Markham and Jason Clarke as Ted Kennedy.
- 17:28
Pete Holmes on Pattern Recognitioninsight
Holmes reframes the Kennedy curse as the human mind's obsession with finding patterns and creating meaning, arguing that everything ripples out and changes history, not just curses.
- 25:17
The Boiler Room Girls Were Strategistsinsight
Helms pushes back against the easy assumption that the women at the party were floozies, explaining they were accomplished speechwriters and campaign staffers who had just lost RFK to assassination.
- 38:36
The Most Famous Passive Voiceinsight
According to Gargan's testimony, Kennedy told him only that the car has gone off the bridge and Mary Jo is in it, never stating he was driving.
- 42:08
The Three A.M. Noise Complaintdata
Hotel staff reported that Kennedy filed a noise complaint at 3 a.m. and was seen casually having breakfast the next morning, details that fed the theory he was building an alibi.
- 53:32
Punting the Resignation Question to Votersstrategy
Kennedy ended his TV statement by asking Massachusetts constituents to decide whether he should resign from the Senate, a strategy that succeeded and kept him in office.
- 1:00:12
Kennedy's Final Admission of Responsibilitystory
In his 2009 autobiography, Kennedy wrote that the night was different because he was responsible, a statement Holmes calls a scheduled email from a dead person.
- 1:02:46
The Diver's Thirty-Minute Air Pocket Claimdebate
Diver John Farrar testified that Kopecky may have survived in an air pocket for up to 30 minutes, implying Kennedy's delay cost her life. Holmes dismisses the claim as something made for magazine attention.
About this episode
Pete Holmes is Weird. In a good way! He's also a New England native, and perfectly attuned to today's Martha's Vineyard-set SNAFU involving the youngest Kennedy brother, Ted. What happened on the small island of Chappaquiddick, and why did it potentially sink his chances at a future Presidency run? Watch today's episode on our SNAFU YouTube channel: www.youtube.com/@SNAFUPod http://www.youtube.com/@SNAFUPod See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
12,141 words · 8 speakers
Topics
- Chappaquiddick Incident
- Ted Kennedy
- Political Scandal
- Mary Jo Kopecky
- Kennedy Family
- Cover-Up
- Judicial Inquest
- 1969
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated