Pod Insights Short Wave Did Scientists Find Alien Life Or Just Controversy? About this episode Recently, a group of scientists claimed they found possible signs of life on a planet called K2-18b. The news made headlines. Researchers said they'd detected sulphur-based gases that, on Earth, are strongly associated with life. But the research caused an uproar in astronomy circles because other scientists don't think the data is strong enough to celebrate an alien find just yet. In fact, they have some real issues with how this whole thing went down, and a new analysis casts further doubt on the findings. NPR science correspondent Nell Greenfieldboyce https://www.npr.org/people/4494969/nell-greenfieldboyce is here to wade into the controversy — and tell us what all this means for the future of searching for life beyond our solar system.
Want to hear more about new science research? Let us know by emailing shortwave@npr.org mailto:shortwave@npr.org.
Listen to every episode of Short Wave sponsor-free and support our work at NPR by signing up for Short Wave+ at plus.npr.org/shortwave http://plus.npr.org/shortwave.
See pcm.adswizz.com https://pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.
NPR Privacy Policy https://www.npr.org/about-npr/179878450/privacy-policy
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This message comes from Capella University. That spark you feel? That's your drive for more. Capella University's FlexPath learning format lets you earn your degree at your pace without putting life on pause. Learn more at capella.edu. You're listening to Short Wave from NPR.
0:20 Regina Barber? Hello, fellow Earthlings. Regina Barber here. And today, we're going to talk about some recent science news that made a big splash. The claims that possible signs of life have been found on a planet called K218b. This made headlines everywhere, including NPR, where it was reported on by none other than our old pal, Nell Greenfield Boyce. Hey, Nell.
0:41 Speaker 02 Hey there.
0:41 Regina Barber? So, Nell, this was new research done with the James Webb Space Telescope. And basically, researchers said that they detected a couple of sulfur-based gases that on Earth are strongly associated with life, such as marine microbes.
0:54 Speaker 02 That's right, like phytoplankton. So, think alien phytoplankton.
0:58 Regina Barber? So cool.
0:58 Speaker 02 The researchers said this planet could be an ocean world, just teeming with life. A press release called their results, quote, "The strongest evidence yet that life may exist on a planet outside our solar system."
1:10 Regina Barber? Yeah, and all of this created quite the uproar in astronomy circles.
1:13 Speaker 02 I think some astronomers and planetary scientists were just taken aback at how all this landed in the public's eye. Like, I was talking with Ryan McDonald. He's at the University of Michigan.
1:23 Speaker 03 For a lot of astronomers, the very first thing that we heard was a message from a family member or a friend. "Oh, hey, have you heard that aliens have been found?"
1:33 Speaker 02 Spoiler alert: he and other astronomers do not think that aliens have been found. And they have some real issues with how this whole thing went down.
1:43 Regina Barber? Today on the show, what happens when a team of scientists claim to have found hints of alien life? We look at what the researchers said, how everyone reacted, and what all this means for the future of searching for life beyond our solar system. You're listening to Short Wave, the science podcast from NPR.
2:06 Speaker 00 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
2:10 Speaker 04 This message comes from BetterHelp. Your brain has limited storage, so why is it still holding on to that embarrassing moment from years ago? BetterHelp is an online therapy platform that gives you space to talk about what's taking up too much of yours. BetterHelp is now in-network with more than 125 health plans, with mini co-pays as low as $15 for eligible members. And if you don't have eligible insurance, you can still get 20% off your first month. Visit betterhelp.com/npr. Cost and coverage may vary. Discount cannot be combined with insurance. This message comes from Capella University. You know that feeling when there's a spark building inside you, that you were meant for more? That's your own drive, pushing you
2:54 Speaker 04 towards what's next. Capella University gets that. With their FlexPath learning format, you can set the pace and earn your degree without putting life on pause. You've built experience and know what you're capable of. Now, this is your time to turn that momentum into more. The only real question is, what can't you do? Learn more at capella.edu. This message comes from Mint Mobile. Ditch overpriced wireless and get premium wireless for less. Go to mintmobile.com/switch to see which plan works for you.
3:30 Regina Barber? Okay, so now, let's start out with just like some basics about Planet K2-18b. Like, what is this place?
3:37 Speaker 02 So it was discovered about a decade ago, and not much is known. So it orbits at a distance from its star that would make it kind of moderate in temperature. So, you know, maybe liquid water is possible there. This planet is bigger than Earth, but smaller than Neptune. And that means we don't really have anything like it in our solar system. So, no one really knows what it's like. And some people think it could be entirely covered in water and ocean world. Other people say, you know, it could be covered in magma.
4:06 Regina Barber? Ooh, this is fascinating. Okay, but how far away is this planet?
4:10 Speaker 02 So 124 light years.
4:13 Regina Barber? So that's far.
4:14 Speaker 02 It's far, yeah. I mean, in cosmic terms, maybe not, but yeah.
4:17 Regina Barber? Yeah, exactly.
4:18 Speaker 02 As far as human terms go, that's far away. And the James Webb Space Telescope can't see the planet itself because the tiny amount of light it reflects is just overwhelmed by that of its closest star. We can only find these planets because we can see their effect on the stars and all the telescope can see is light from that star. So when the planet goes around the star, it passes in front of it, getting between the, you know, the star and the telescope, the starlight changes. Some of the starlight interacts with its atmosphere, kind of filters through the atmosphere.
4:49 Regina Barber? Yeah, so the idea is that you can like analyze the starlight to get clues about the atmosphere and like what gases are inside of it.
4:56 Speaker 02 Exactly, yeah. And the gases might tell you something about what's on the planet or what's going on there. And so that's what this team of researchers tried to do. And the work was led by Nikhu Madhusudan. He's at the University of Cambridge, which held a press conference for reporters. And he said what they'd found was just huge.
5:15 Speaker 05 These are the first hints we are seeing of an alien world that is possibly inhabited.
5:20 Regina Barber? Wow. I mean, that's, that's a strong statement. Like, what did they find? Like, what were these hints?
5:26 Speaker 02 Basically, he said when they analyzed the starlight, they found signals that could come from two related sulfur-based gases, DMS and DMDS. And so these gases are found in Earth's atmosphere because they're produced by life, by microbes. And because these gases on Earth are closely tied to microbes, they've long been seen as potential biosignatures, hints of life.
5:48 Regina Barber? And these like sulfur-based gases aren't made by anything else?
5:52 Speaker 02 Well, in the atmosphere, I mean, not that people are aware of, that I know of. I mean, there is some recent work in the laboratory showing that it is possible to produce these gases with no life.
6:02 Speaker 05 We cannot, at this stage, make the claim that even if we detect DMS and DMDS, that it is due to life. Let me be very clear about that.
6:12 Regina Barber? Okay.
6:12 Speaker 02 He said there needed to be more lab work and more modeling of possible things that like could be going on on this planet that might make this stuff.
6:19 Regina Barber? Like geologic processes or like something that didn't require life?
6:22 Speaker 02 Yeah, and he also said the detection itself needed to be confirmed with more telescope observations to make sure that this gas or combination of gases was really there, you know? But even though he made those cautious remarks, overall, he was just extraordinarily enthusiastic.
6:39 Speaker 05 Frankly, I think this is the closest we have come to seeing like a feature that we can attribute to life.
6:47 Speaker 02 And he said at a personal level, it was like a shock to the system.
6:50 Speaker 05 When you're faced with potentially one of the biggest landmarks in the history of science, and I know this, you know, sounds grand, and it's not my intention to make it sound grand, but there is no other way to put it.
7:04 Regina Barber? Yeah, I mean, this would be a huge deal, not just like in the history of like science, but the history of like humanity. But you said other astronomers were a little skeptical.
7:13 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, it would be a huge deal if it was true. And that if is pretty important. So one of the first people I called up was Laura Kreidberg. She studies planetary atmosphere. She's at the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy in Germany.
7:27 Speaker 06 I think this is one of those situations where extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and I'm not sure we're at the extraordinary evidence level yet. I think we need another look to get all the way there.
7:40 Speaker 02 Well, let's start at the basics. Do you believe that they have detected these molecules in these quantities?
7:46 Speaker 06 Not really. If I'm being straight with you, not really.
7:50 Regina Barber? Wow.
7:52 Speaker 06 I think that we are in the very early stages of learning how to interpret the data from the James Webb Space Telescope. It's a tricky business. These are really, really small signals. We've just been at it for a couple of years.
8:04 Speaker 02 She says that this kind of measurement is just incredibly, incredibly hard. And, you know, she wasn't the only skeptic. Another astronomer told me he really wouldn't be surprised if the signal just disappeared when people did independent analyses of the data.
8:17 Regina Barber? Oh, wow.
8:18 Speaker 02 And then Ryan McDonald, that astronomer from the University of Michigan, quickly wrote up this little critique of the research paper, and he posted it on the Blue Sky's social media site.
8:26 Speaker 03 And it gets into super nitty gritty statistics, but the The signal is just not strong enough to say there's anything there in the atmosphere with these observations.
8:34 Regina Barber? So that's a few critics, but like, how did this land overall?
8:38 Speaker 02 From what I can tell, there's a general consensus that the strength of the evidence did not warrant the kind of enthusiasm that surrounded it. And, you know, already there's been more than one reanalysis of the data put out there. Like, the first one I saw was from Jake Taylor at the University of Oxford. His study sort of said there's too much noise in the data to reliably find any kind of signal of these gases or anything else for that matter.
9:01 Regina Barber? So what did the original researchers say in response? Like, obviously, they felt like something was there.
9:06 Speaker 02 Well, I reached out to a couple of them about Jake Taylor's analysis, and Niku Madhusedan said the model Jake used was too simplistic and not relevant. But Jake, of course, disagrees, saying it's a tool that's commonly used to just kind of quickly check telescope observations to see if there's anything worth following up on. And then there was this other analysis that's just been posted online by another group. It found that numerous other models that don't have biosignatures at all are also compatible with the observations.
9:33 Regina Barber? Oh, wow.
9:34 Speaker 02 So, you know, it's not looking good right now, I gotta say.
9:37 Regina Barber? And this is the way, like, science goes. Like, this is gonna go on and on for months.
9:40 Speaker 02 Yeah, but, you know, the headlines have already been out there about possible signs of life being detected on another planet. And that really rankles some astronomers, like Ryan McDonald.
9:50 Speaker 03 And for many of us, it's felt like damage control, to be honest, because we don't want people to think that the ultimate and most important, one of the most important scientific discoveries potentially this century has kind of already been made, just for it to ultimately turn out not to be true.
10:09 Speaker 02 There's been a lot of hand wringing about this whole episode and how to prevent something like this in the future.
10:14 Regina Barber? I mean, like, short of a, like, UFO hovering above Times Square and, like, aliens coming out of it, the discussion about this stuff is going to be contentious, right? I mean, like, this is how science is done. Like, somebody makes a claim, somebody else has to check it to see if it's true or if it can be disproven.
10:29 Speaker 02 Sure. I mean, it's not like there haven't been similar episodes in the past.
10:32 Regina Barber? Right.
10:33 Speaker 02 Like, what about phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus a few years ago? Do you remember we talked about that one?
10:37 Regina Barber? Yeah, it was very similar, right? Like, it's another gas associated with life that was detected in a planet's atmosphere. It made headlines. And then, like, people debated whether the detection was even real. And if so, like, whether it could have been made by, like, some other process.
10:52 Speaker 02 Exactly. I mean, Venus has clouds of concentrated sulfuric acid, right? So Venus is known to be extremely, extremely inhospitable. And if I recall talking to the researchers then, they were pretty skeptical about the life angle. You know, even as they said they couldn't think of any process that could make this gas on Venus. You know, it was more like, we don't really know what's up with Venus. Or like, what could there be besides life that could produce this gas? This is a mystery that we'd like to solve. This is kind of bizarre and unexpected. We don't know what to make of it. You know, it wasn't like, this is the strongest evidence for life beyond our planet.
11:25 Regina Barber? Yeah, whatever happened with that, by the way?
11:27 Speaker 02 My understanding is that the whole thing, like, the detection and what it means, like, it's still debated.
11:33 Regina Barber? Oh, wow.
11:33 Speaker 02 You know, I mean, you'd need a mission to Venus to settle it, which we could plausibly do. Because Venus is close by. It's literally the planet right next door.
11:41 Regina Barber? But K218b, not so next door.
11:44 Speaker 02 Yeah. I mean, we're not going to go visit a planet beyond our solar system anytime soon. And, you know, here's the thing. There's going to be a lot more research in the years ahead, trying to tease out information about very, very faraway planets. And I think what this episode is about is scientists talking about how they can do that work and communicate it all to the public. Like, how to convey the excitement of it without overselling it or hyping it. Because there could only be one time that humans discover life beyond Earth for the very first time. And to many scientists, that's almost like a sacred thing.
12:20 Regina Barber? Nell, if that does happen, we expect you to come right here and talk to us about it.
12:25 Speaker 02 Well, I frankly hope that I am alive. And that NPR is.
12:29 Regina Barber? Yeah, me too. Thank you so much.
12:31 Speaker 02 Thank you.
12:33 Regina Barber? This episode was produced by Burley McCoy, edited by our showrunner Rebecca Ramirez, and fact-checked by Tyler Jones and Nell. Maggie Luther was the audio engineer. Beth Donovan is our senior director, and Colin Campbell is our senior vice president of podcasting strategy. I'm Regina Barber. Thank you for listening to Short Wave from NPR.
12:58 Speaker 04 Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
Previous What Can Minecraft Teach Us About Learning? Next Science Can Make You More Creative! Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated