Pod Insights Science Vs Vaping: Does It Really Cause Cancer? About this episode Headlines have been screaming about a new study suggesting that vaping could cause cancer — and that vaping could be just as dangerous as cigarettes. And if this were true, it would be a HUGE deal. We’ve been hearing for years that vaping is a safer option — and can help you quit ciggies. But the new paper has run up against angry criticisms from other scientists, with some calling the paper "misleading" and "problematic." So what’s going on?? Do scientists still think vaping is safer than cigarettes? How well do vapes actually help people quit smoking? And could Big Tobacco be behind the scenes, clouding the truth about all of this?? We get help sorting it out from Professor Bernard Stewart, Professor Lion Shahab and Professor Becky Freeman.
Find our transcript here: https://tinyurl.com/ScienceVsVapingCancer
In this episode, we cover:
(00:00) Vaping world set alight by new study
(02:50) Why Some Scientists Have Linked Vaping to Cancer
(07:45) Why Some Scientists Pushed Back Against Vaping-Cancer Claims
(17:51) Is Vaping as Dangerous as Smoking?
(25:15) Do Vapes Help People Quit Smoking?
(30:52) Big Tobacco Is Funding Vaping Research
This episode was produced by Wendy Zukerman and Rose Rimler, with help from Ekedi Fausther-Keeys, Meryl Horn and Michelle Dang. We’re edited by Blythe Terrell. Wendy Zukerman is our executive producer. Fact checking by Erica Akiko Howard. Mix and sound design by Bobby Lord. Music written by Bumi Hidaka, Peter Leonard, Emma Munger and Bobby Lord. Additional music from Parry Music Library / BMGPM. Thanks so much to the Australian science media centre and all the scientists who responded to our emails on this — we asked a lot of you!. A big thanks to Joseph Lavelle Wilson and the Zukerman family.
Science Vs is a Spotify Studios Original. Listen for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us and tap the bell for episode notifications.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 6,562 words · 11 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Wendy Zukerman? Hi, I'm Wendy Zukerman, this is Science Versus.
0:04 Wendy Zukerman? The show that pits facts against fumes.
0:13 Wendy Zukerman? Groundbreaking new research has confirmed a deadly link between e-cigarettes and cancer.
0:18 Speaker 01 Vaping is likely to cause lung and oral cancer.
0:22 Wendy Zukerman? Headlines have been screaming about a new paper that's rocking the vaping world, claiming that vaping is more dangerous than we thought. We're hearing that not only is it likely to cause cancer, but also that something that scientists have been telling us for years is wrong.
0:40 Wendy Zukerman? So is it safer to vape than smoke? Well, now the science is in. New research has found vapes are no safer than conventional cigarettes.
0:50 Speaker 03 The conclusion is unavoidable. We can hardly say that e-cigarettes are somehow safer than conventional cigarettes.
0:58 Wendy Zukerman? Vaping is as bad as cigarette smoking? Now, if this is true, it is a huge switcheroo for science. And also for Science Versus. For literally a decade, we've been telling you that vaping is a safer and better alternative to smoking. In a past episode, we even played you a song written by a bunch of researchers about it.
1:32 Wendy Zukerman? So did we lie to you? Prue Song? Will we fall on our own betad? I mean, will we be hoisted on our own petard? Well, the thing is, while some nerds have been supportive of this new paper that's sparking all these headlines, others are not. And in fact, right after the paper was published, a bunch of scientists wrote angry responses, calling the paper misleading, problematic, and saying it has little credibility. So what's going on here? And getting this right is a big deal. Millions of folks, including kids, have picked up vaping around the world.
2:13 Wendy Zukerman? So today on the show, we are asking, one, does vaping cause cancer? Two, is vaping as bad as smoking now? And three, could picking up a vape ever be good for your health? When it comes to vaping, there's a lot of...
2:33 Wendy Zukerman? No, no more songs until we work out what the devil's going on here. And it's all coming up just after the break.
2:47 Wendy Zukerman? This episode is brought to you by Chase Sapphire Reserve. On this podcast, we sort fact from fiction. So here's a quick truth for you. With Sapphire Reserve, you can spend all around the world. Not only that, but you can earn four times the points on flights and hotels, book direct, and three times the points on dining. Plus, enjoy access to award-winning airport lounges and exclusive restaurant tables. Learn more at chase.com/sapphirereserve. Cards issued by JP Morgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval; terms apply.
3:26 Speaker 04 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies; 18+.
3:53 Wendy Zukerman? Hi, Wendy here. Today, we are finding out, is vaping more dangerous than we thought? And with me to sort all of this out is senior producer, Rose Rimmler.
4:03 Speaker 05 Hi, Wendy.
4:04 Wendy Zukerman? Hello, Rose.
4:05 Speaker 05 I don't think I've ever heard that song before in my life. Do we play that?
4:13 Wendy Zukerman? We played it.
4:16 Speaker 05 So memorable, seemingly.
4:17 Wendy Zukerman? I've had it in my head all week. In the middle of the night, this acoustic guitar would just start ringing. Oh, all right, let's jump into this new study that's setting the vaping world alight, igniting all these news reports. It is quite interesting and the implications are super, super important. So I want to look at what's going on. What's this science fight all about?
4:41 Speaker 05 Yeah.
4:42 Wendy Zukerman? So to get to the bottom of this, Rose, you and I, we read this paper. And then I called up one of the lead authors, Professor Bernard Stewart. He's at the University of New South Wales in Sydney.
4:53 Speaker 03 Good morning.
4:54 Wendy Zukerman? Morning. Now Bernard told me that basically his entire career has been using research to figure out whether various things in our environment cause cancer. So a decade ago, he was part of this big international team that looked at the characteristics that a substance has to have for it to be considered carcinogenic. He's looked at PFAS, you know, forever chemicals.
5:18 Speaker 03 Microplastics, pesticides in soil.
5:22 Wendy Zukerman? But when he was watching the data coming out on vapes or e-cigarettes, he told me.
5:27 Speaker 03 This to me was a far greater worry.
5:31 Speaker 05 Out of curiosity, did he ever find evidence that something didn't cause cancer?
5:36 Wendy Zukerman? Yes. Yes, he did. And he actually, he specifically told me, you know, we have this idea that everything causes cancer, but he said, that's not true.
5:45 Speaker 05 Okay, that's good.
5:46 Wendy Zukerman? And in that context, he was worried about vaping causing cancer. So he and his colleagues pulled together studies published from 2017 to the middle of last year that were looking for a link between vaping and cancer. And they wrote it up in a review paper. And so now I kind of want to go through the case that Bernard is making that vaping causes cancer. So we know that some of the chemicals found in vape aerosols, I'm thinking acrylamide, benzene and various metals, they can cause cancer in humans. But there was this question of when you use a vape and inhale that stuff, do you just breathe it out again?
6:31 Wendy Zukerman? Or does it go into your system where it can then cause damage? And so scientists have tested the blood and urine of vapors for these kinds of chemicals. And here's what they've found.
6:42 Speaker 03 Those chemicals are detectable. In other words, they have been absorbed into the body and not just exhale.
6:51 Wendy Zukerman? So, strike one.
6:53 Speaker 05 Uh huh.
6:53 Wendy Zukerman? There are also studies in cells where scientists expose them to vape liquid. And then they can see that these cells pick up DNA damage and oxidative stress, which we know can lead to cancer.
7:05 Speaker 05 Yeah.
7:06 Wendy Zukerman? On top of that, scientists have exposed rats and mice to the vapor from e-cigarettes. And they can see markers of inflammation in their lungs. And this is worrying to Bernard because we know that inflammation, when it's chronic, in other circumstances, can lead to cancer. One study in particular exposed mice to vape fumes for almost a year, which is a long time in the life of a mouse. And a bunch of them developed lung cancer.
7:34 Speaker 05 Mm hmm.
7:35 Wendy Zukerman? So then finally Bernard's team point to a few case reports. So here he is on that.
7:41 Speaker 03 Individual dentists say, I saw a patient with oral cancer. And this patient never smoked, which is the well-known cause of oral cancer. But he or she did vape. And I suspect the vaping was connected with the cancer.
7:59 Wendy Zukerman? Now, it's messy because in the four case reports that Bernard cites, two of those people did have a history of smoking as well.
8:09 Speaker 05 Like real regular cigarettes. Yes, I noticed that.
8:12 Wendy Zukerman? Yes. Still, but when Bernard looks at the totality of the evidence, here's what he thinks.
8:18 Speaker 03 So all of that data, the laboratory data, the biomarker data, the animal data, the case reports, all of that taken together, lead us inexorably to the conclusion that vaping is likely to cause oral and lung cancer.
8:37 Wendy Zukerman? So that's, you know, in the case of vaping versus cancer, that is the case that Bernard is making. But Rose, you were gonna play defense on this, right?
8:49 Speaker 05 Yes. So there were a lot of scientists who were pissed off by this paper.
8:54 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, yeah.
8:55 Speaker 05 And I wanted to find out why. And so we called up one of them, Professor Leon Schaub. He is a vaping expert at University College London. And Leon didn't think the review was put together in a systematic way. He didn't like that.
9:10 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah.
9:10 Speaker 05 But he said that's not the only reason that he's skeptical.
9:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, the concern is further deepened by the fact that this review includes several papers that claim evidence that eases cause cancer, but that have themselves been heavily criticized.
9:24 Wendy Zukerman? Tell me more.
9:26 Speaker 05 Well, so you mentioned the rodent studies, like the one where some of the mice that got exposed to vape aerosol got lung cancer.
9:35 Wendy Zukerman? Yes.
9:36 Speaker 05 In that study, the mice were living in a chamber that got filled up with the vape fumes. Basically, they were being hotboxed with vape.
9:46 Wendy Zukerman? Yes.
9:47 Speaker 05 That's how they do these, right? And they got hotboxed for four hours a day, five days a week.
9:53 Speaker 06 They were basically enveloped in a cloud of vapor. It doesn't seem like a realistic use condition for a human.
10:00 Wendy Zukerman? Isn't it? I mean, obviously, you're not living in a cloud if you vape, but you are breathing it in directly from the vape, right?
10:09 Speaker 05 Sure, but you're not sitting in a chamber of vape clouds for hours and hours.
10:15 Wendy Zukerman? Unless you truly are a vape lord.
10:18 Speaker 05 I mean, most people I know don't do that. And I've never seen vapors lick the vape off their body, which is what mice might be doing, because, you know, rodents groom themselves.
10:29 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, right. So they'd be licking their fur that then has the vape.
10:35 Speaker 05 Crap on their Which would have gotten some extra exposure, a different route of exposure. It's just a criticism you can make about these studies. You know, I emailed the author of the paper, that paper about the mice, some questions. Yeah. And, yeah, he said, like, we tried carefully to create conditions that are as natural as possible to what vapors might get exposed to. But even he was like, yeah, ultimately, it's a study in mice. He said, this is a, quote, "The major purpose of exposing mice in an inhalation chamber is to determine the effect of e-cigarette aerosols in mice." So like, of course, we can't say the same is going to be true for humans. Of course, it's step one, it's step one. Yeah. So, the other point that Leon made, and this has to do with, I think the first thing
11:20 Speaker 05 you mentioned, Wendy, about how like, oh, it turns out the toxic chemicals, the carcinogens, they like actually get in the bodies of the vapors, you can find them in their pee. Mm-hmm. And that is certainly not a good thing. Leon and other experts who commented on this paper, they pointed out that like, well, these amounts of carcinogens that we find in vapors' bodies, they're actually kind of low. And, as Leon puts it-
11:47 Speaker 06 The dose makes the poison, right?
11:50 Speaker 05 And that's just sort of a general rule in epidemiology, that the more you're exposed to something that has some kind of risk, the more likely you are to develop that disease, you know? And so with vaping-
12:02 Speaker 06 It's unclear whether this lower level of exposure, that's quite small, represents an actual risk for cancer formation.
12:10 Speaker 05 Now, I mean, Leon did say, he agrees, it's totally possible vaping could have a risk of causing cancer. He just doesn't think that we currently have the evidence to support saying that for sure, yes, we know now vaping does cause cancer. Mm-hmm. And one reason is, we actually don't have much data in actual human beings with actual cancer. Yes. And I really went looking for other evidence that didn't make it in Bernard's review of people who vape getting cancer. And I did find some studies, and they find things like people who vape are more likely to have lung cancer, for example. But in all the studies that I could find, a lot of the vapors also smokes, or used to smoke. Right.
12:54 Speaker 05 So we don't know if the cancer came from the vaping or the smoking. It's messy. And that makes it a real mess, yeah. And so without more like evidence in people actually getting cancer, I don't think that these authors should have said that they have produced the, this is what they said in a press release, they call it, "The most definitive determination that those who vape are at increased risk of cancer compared to those who don't." I think that is an overstatement.
13:22 Wendy Zukerman? Hmm, yeah. I mean, I did ask Bernard about some of the heat that this paper's been getting. Nobody intended. You must be aware there's some criticisms of the paper that have been floating around. Do you mind if I just get your thoughts on them?
13:36 Speaker 03 Yes, the criticisms are absurd and I treat them with complete contempt.
13:44 Wendy Zukerman? Whoa, that's a strong word. Is he mad at me? Oh no. I mean, I think he was bristling at some of the criticisms he's been getting about how there's nothing new in this paper. You know, it's a review, but ultimately he said, "If you've got problems, write a letter to the editor."
14:03 Speaker 05 Does making a podcast count?
14:06 Wendy Zukerman? I think he would treat that with contempt. No, but seriously, he did, he told me, you know, of course he knows that this is not rock solid evidence. We don't have a study in thousands of people where you see that those who vape have higher rates of cancer than those who don't vape. You know, like you mentioned, Rose, part of that is because of this messiness that a lot of vapers, and particularly older vapers, are smokers too, or they used to be smokers. But the other issue here is also time. Bernard estimates we'd need around three decades before you might see that cancer signature, because cancer takes a really long time to develop, even for cigarette smokers.
14:49 Wendy Zukerman? And vaping was only invented in the, in the 2000s. That's actually why they call it the naughties.
14:55 Speaker 05 Hmm, that's not true, kids. Don't let Wendy do revisionist history.
15:01 Wendy Zukerman? No, okay, so I asked Bernard, "And why not wait for better evidence before making this claim?"
15:09 Speaker 03 You're serious? You're saying, you're saying we wait around until enough people are dead from lung cancer before we do anything? Is that what you're suggesting?
15:19 Wendy Zukerman? Well, I want you to explain it so that we have, we can take to our audience.
15:23 Speaker 03 Look, the definitive, the definitive proof will take decades, okay?
15:30 Speaker 03 It took just on a hundred years to definitively prove that cigarettes caused cancer. Cigarettes by that time had become the major known cause of cancer in the world.
15:47 Speaker 05 I mean, I see his point, though, like,
15:50 Wendy Zukerman? Of course.
15:50 Speaker 05 It's like the precautionary principle, right? You know, better to be safe than sorry. At the same time, you doesn't really give people license to get out over their skis and say that we have proof that we don't have. It's bad for science more broadly.
16:05 Wendy Zukerman? I mean, the truth is, a lot of the team, the whole team at Science Versus struggled with this. And so what we did, we know our limitations. We're podcasters. We don't write letters to editors. So we surveyed a bunch of researchers who study vaping and tobacco control to see what they make of all this. We asked them outright, does vaping cause cancer? We heard back from 35 scientists and the results were kind of all over the map. But I would say the majority said, we don't know, but it's possible. And some who were then in that, ah, maybe, we don't know, camp, said, all right,
16:47 Wendy Zukerman? if vaping does cause cancer, then the question becomes, how much does it up your risk of cancer? Is it like breathing in asbestos or eating a salami every now and then?
16:58 Speaker 05 Yeah.
16:58 Wendy Zukerman? And we definitely don't know that.
17:02 Speaker 05 You know, if there was no potential benefit to vaping, it would be very easy to close the book on this, to say like, okay, this is enough evidence to just assume it does and tell people, quit it, don't vape. It'd be like, of course, if there is evidence that this thing, you know, playing the kazoo. Is potentially carcinogenic and we have animal studies. We have petri dish studies. We have kazoo players have higher levels of this chemical that causes cancer. That everyone's not playing the kazoo. I think that would be, even though we don't have studies saying kazoo players get tons of cancer and die.
17:40 Wendy Zukerman? It's a irritating sound as well. So that would be great.
17:45 Speaker 05 And it irritates people around you with its secondhand kazooing.
17:49 Wendy Zukerman? Yes.
17:50 Speaker 05 But this is totally ignoring the fact that there is a potential benefit of vaping and that's for people who smoke. And so if you're evaluating vaping as its own thing, ignoring the fact that its major purpose is as a smoking cessation device to get people to stop smoking when it's very hard to do that, you're missing like a huge part of the argument here.
18:14 Wendy Zukerman? So Rose, we are going to look at that huge pot of the argument and see if it's about to all go up in a puff of smoke after the break. Coming up.
18:44 Speaker 04 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
19:09 Speaker 07 When you're building a company, you learn that trust is what closes deals. You may have the best product, but buyers won't sign without proof that your product is secure, especially if it has AI. Vanta gets you compliant fast with SOC 2, ISO 27001 and more, and keeps you secure with continuous monitoring. Hyperbound, a YC-backed startup, used Vanta to unlock the Fortune 100 in under a year. Snowfire got audit ready in a month and closed a multimillion dollar deal. Trust matters. Get started at vanta.com.
19:41 Wendy Zukerman? Welcome back. Today on the show, we are looking at the new science on vaping. Rose Rimla is here with me.
19:49 Speaker 05 Hi Wendy.
19:51 Wendy Zukerman? Now, we're going to look at this claim that vaping is just as dangerous as smoking. And as I mentioned at the start of the show, if true, this would really be a huge turnaround for science, which absolutely happens. We get more data, we find out new things, we change our mind. That is the glory and the frustration of science.
20:11 Speaker 05 Right, yeah.
20:12 Wendy Zukerman? It's why we love it. She's a feisty beast. So there were all these news reports recently, particularly in Australia, saying that vaping is not safer than cigarettes, off the back of Bernard's paper, right? But what's interesting is Bernard's paper was really not comparing vapes to cigarettes. In fact, the whole point of the paper was to say that vaping, in its own right, is harmful. Forget about comparing it to cigarettes. And yet, did you notice this? In the very last, it's just in the very last line of the paper, it's almost kind of tossed
20:52 Wendy Zukerman? out, they say, quote, "Cancer aside, a range of diseases are attributable to vaping, which can no longer be caricatured as safer than smoking."
21:03 Speaker 05 Wild claim. That's where scientists put their wild claims, is in the last line of their last paragraph.
21:09 Wendy Zukerman? Correct. It almost, I don't know if you had this feeling, but it was almost as if for the whole paper, the scientists are breaking up with vaping, and then they turn around and walk away, but then toss off, "Oh, and you're bad in bed, too." "And you're just as bad as smoking." Do you know what I mean?
21:29 Speaker 05 Yeah. It is like, I noticed that, too. I was like, whoa.
21:33 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, and the reason that it is so, whoa, so shocking is because of just how bad cigarette smoking is. So to remind us, here's Professor Becky Freeman. She's a public health researcher who focuses on tobacco control and vaping at the University of Sydney.
21:50 Speaker 08 Two out of three people who continue to smoke, so if you're not able to quit, two out of three people who are unable to quit will die as a result of their addiction. There's just something, it is so uniquely harmful to health. It is so deadly.
22:05 Wendy Zukerman? So, could vaping really be that bad? Given that there's, you know, we've just talked about these unknowns around vaping and cancer. What do we actually know here? I mean, could vaping be as dangerous as smoking?
22:20 Speaker 05 So I looked into that claim. And what's interesting is that there are other scientists who say we should rethink this idea that vaping is flat out better for you compared to smoking.
22:29 Wendy Zukerman? Really? So where are those researchers coming from?
22:33 Speaker 05 Well, I mean, in Bernard's paper, one of the things he cites to make this case that vaping is really bad is a review paper that came out a couple of years ago. And this one was looking mostly at heart and lung problems in people who smoke or vape. So for that, we do actually have studies in real people. And this review paper concluded that smoking and vaping are equally bad for cardiovascular disease, stroke, and metabolic dysfunction.
23:04 Wendy Zukerman? Wow.
23:05 Speaker 05 That's stuff that can lead to like diabetes and stuff.
23:07 Wendy Zukerman? Wow.
23:08 Speaker 05 And that's a pretty big deal. And if so, from Bernard's perspective, if he's pretty sure that vaping is on its own cancer-causing, and this other body of research says vaping on its own is heart disease-causing, boom, like death to vaping.
23:24 Wendy Zukerman? Why is vaping so bad for your heart?
23:26 Speaker 05 One reason is that nicotine itself is a vasoconstrictor. So it could like tighten your blood vessels. And you can imagine how that would be bad for your cardiovascular system.
23:35 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, and vapes have a surprisingly high amount of nicotine in them.
23:39 Speaker 05 Yes, and getting higher all the time. Like, there are studies that have found that the cartridges in vapes are bigger and contain higher percentage of nicotine than they used to.
23:50 Wendy Zukerman? Whoa. Yeah, wow. Okay, yeah, that's helpful for the bottom line, isn't it?
23:58 Speaker 05 Yeah. And so like Wendy, I have to tell you that this review paper I just mentioned did also get a lot of criticism.
24:05 Wendy Zukerman? Right.
24:05 Speaker 05 All kinds of things people said about like, oh, they didn't account for the fact that people might have been former smokers and switched to vaping because they got sick and they needed to switch.
24:17 Wendy Zukerman? Right.
24:18 Speaker 05 The authors do argue back like, hey, we tried to adjust for a lot of these things and da, da, da, da. We think we've seen something real here.
24:24 Wendy Zukerman? So we're kind of stuck in this scientific limbo land.
24:28 Speaker 05 Yes. So vaping is clearly bad for your heart. Whether it's as bad as cigarettes, I mean, I think that's a little bit remains to be seen. But where the case that smoking is still the worst option is very strong is when it comes to cancer.
24:46 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah. I mean, of course, because we know smoking causes cancer and we're not even sure about that with vaping, right?
24:53 Speaker 05 But that, yeah, but that's not even the, that's not even exactly what I'm talking about here. Also, when you look at the amount of carcinogens that people are exposed to when they vape versus when they smoke, it's just so much higher in smokers.
25:05 Wendy Zukerman? Hmm, right. All of these DNA damaging chemicals, so much higher in smokers.
25:11 Speaker 05 So for example, there's this chemical, it's called, a group of chemicals, they're called tobacco-specific nitrosamines, and they're well-known to cause cancer.
25:19 Wendy Zukerman? Mm-hmm.
25:19 Speaker 05 They're present in the pee of vapors at five times the levels they're in the pee of non-vapors.
25:25 Wendy Zukerman? Five times higher in vapors.
25:27 Speaker 05 But when you look at smokers, these tobacco-specific nitrosamines, they're in the smoker's pee 220 times as much as, you know, your goody-two-shoe that doesn't smoke or vape.
25:40 Wendy Zukerman? It's way higher.
25:42 Speaker 05 Way higher.
25:43 Wendy Zukerman? Yes. And when we go back to our survey of scientists, remember those cautious fence sitting nerds?
25:50 Speaker 05 Uh-huh.
25:51 Wendy Zukerman? Well, on this question of is vaping more dangerous than smoking, they were much more clear-eyed. 90% said smoking is more dangerous than vaping.
26:03 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
26:03 Wendy Zukerman? And the rest said probably?
26:07 Wendy Zukerman? One person said, it's hard to say. So, you know, 90%, that is like dentist recommended Colgate.
26:16 Speaker 05 Uh, rock solid.
26:17 Wendy Zukerman? I think we can say vaping is still safer than smoking. And we did not lie to our audience in song.
26:24 Speaker 05 Great. We can sleep at night now. I'm so glad.
26:26 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, gosh, I know. And I, so I think the broad message around vaping, when compared to smoking, hasn't changed that much. I mean, when Science vs. did our first episode on vaping, one of the key scientists I interviewed said, quote, "Because the danger of cigarettes is so stratospherically high, it's like comparing the 15th highest mountain in the world, that would be vaping, to Mount Everest." And the joke I made back then, which I still think is pretty good, is that climbing Mount Gayatungking is still pretty tricky.
27:00 Speaker 05 Is that the 15th tallest mountain in the world?
27:02 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah.
27:05 Speaker 05 Well, no one said they didn't learn anything from this episode, because they did.
27:10 Wendy Zukerman? That's right. Um, okay. But seriously, though, this has made me wonder, why are we comparing vaping to smoking? Why are we doing this mountain comparison? Because, you know, even if we get more data that vaping is bad and it becomes, I don't know, Gashabrum 2, the 13th highest mountain in the world. What if it even gets so bad that it's Gashabrum 1, which is the 11th highest mountain in the world?
27:44 Wendy Zukerman? I mean, the, I mean, the broader point is that currently, at least, when we compare vaping to smoking, vaping looks good. Still, despite these headlines you hear, vaping looks good.
27:57 Speaker 05 Right.
27:58 Wendy Zukerman? But if you look at vaping just on its own. Vaping looks bad. And so the reason that we have been making this comparison is because vaping was brought on the scene as this tool to help people quit smoking. So it's very important for you to know as a smoker, wait, should I switch to this healthier thing or not?
28:21 Speaker 05 Yes, that's what I was trying to say earlier. Yeah, yeah.
28:24 Wendy Zukerman? Which leads us to our next question, which is how well do vapes actually help people quit smoking?
28:32 Speaker 08 It's actually a really tiny number of people who successfully quit smoking using vapes.
28:37 Wendy Zukerman? Here's Becky Freeman again, the public health researcher.
28:40 Speaker 08 Even in the best clinical trials, it's about 10%. So it's a 90% failure rate, right? This is not a miracle cure. This is not some sort of tech bro solution to the smoking epidemic that we have.
28:54 Wendy Zukerman? Wow, I'm surprised it's that small. Yeah, yeah, no. So that number comes from a Cochrane review, which pulled together a ton of trials, looking at thousands of people, and ultimately concluded that for every 100 folks who use nicotine e-cigs to stop smoking, eight to 11 of them might successfully stop, which is where you get that 90% failure rate. It's worth pointing out, according to that review, vapes don't look too bad when you compare it to the other stuff. So six out of 100 people might successfully quit smoking when they use patches or gum. Four out of 100 might successfully quit if you do other things, like you go cold turkey.
29:36 Speaker 05 You were kind of surprised, right, that it doesn't work that well? How come? Well, I know a couple of people who have quit smoking and vapes instead. In general, I feel like I've seen that work, but I think also I didn't know that the other methods were so bad.
29:53 Wendy Zukerman? But here is why, because I can hear people really holding on to this, particularly if you want to keep holding on to your vapes. Here is why experts will say, try all that other stuff first before going for vapes. One is, well, let's say if you're just using patches, you are not breathing in that vape crap. But also because people who use vapes to quit smoking, like the friends in your life, keep vaping. They then pick up the habit.
30:30 Speaker 05 Keep smoking?
30:32 Wendy Zukerman? No, they keep vaping. They pick up the habit of vaping.
30:36 Speaker 05 They've become vapors, yeah.
30:38 Wendy Zukerman? Whereas people who use patches, gum, stuff like that, they eventually manage, they've got a much higher chance of quitting their dependency altogether. So for example, one randomized control trial found that 80% of the people who quit cigarettes using vapes were still vaping a year later, 80%.
30:59 Speaker 05 Right.
31:00 Wendy Zukerman? While only 9% of those who did stuff like patches and gums were still using those products.
31:07 Speaker 05 You know what's so funny? I wasn't even thinking of the fact that you're supposed to stop vaping. I don't know anyone that's stopped vaping.
31:13 Wendy Zukerman? I know, I know. But, okay, so here's where we are at. Most scientists agree that vaping is safer than smoking. And that means that if you are a smoker and you wanna quit, vaping may help you. But for all the reasons we just talked about, try using other stuff first, like gum, like patches.
31:39 Speaker 05 Yeah, and I guess like if we're wondering, why are we comparing vaping to smoking? In 2026, it's not even relevant for a ton of people. They aren't vaping to quit smoking, they're just vaping to vape, right?
31:52 Wendy Zukerman? Well, yeah, exactly. I mean, one survey of thousands of Americans found that over half of established vaping young adults never regularly smoked. So if that's you, I mean, who cares if vaping is safer than smoking, right? And now we have a new generation of people addicted to vaping. And in fact, Becky Freeman does this study where her and her colleagues will talk to thousands of young people. And she has actually seen vaping go from this funzy thing to a full-blown addiction.
32:32 Speaker 08 A few years ago, when we first started this research, young people were like, oh, vaping's fun. It's something I do socially on the weekend. It's no big drama. And then over the years, it's become more of, I'm so addicted, I need to vape in the middle of the night. I can't go a day at work without having a vape. I try leaving it in my car and all I do is think about it.
32:49 Wendy Zukerman? So vaping's bad for you. Smoking, worse for you, also bad for you. Mm-hmm. But there's still so much doubt and confusion in the public, I think, to our listeners. And I am wondering if at least part of that is thanks to big tobacco being up to their old tricks again. Is this the conspiracy theory portion of the episode? Maybe, maybe, but hear me out, okay? Uh-huh. The major international tobacco companies own many of the top vaping brands, right? Mm-hmm, yes. Okay, and it is well documented that big tobacco wrote the playbook on spreading
33:34 Wendy Zukerman? misinformation. Mm-hmm. It is the playbook that big oil reads to spread misinformation about climate change. And so one of the key tactics that they learned really early on is so effective at allowing them to keep selling their cigarettes in the face of all this science about lung cancer is using doubt. Are the scientists sure about what is going on? Uh-huh. In this case, we can see doubt all through. This episode, right? Oh, vapes that bad?
34:10 Speaker 05 Yeah, the study had this issue.
34:12 Wendy Zukerman? Yep. And doubt, creating doubt amongst science is so damn easy, right? Because well-meaning scientists will nitpick at each other's research to get to the truth.
34:23 Speaker 05 Yeah.
34:24 Wendy Zukerman? Making it so handy for Big Vape to say, "Look, the scientists are fighting."
34:29 Speaker 05 Yeah.
34:30 Wendy Zukerman? "Let's just keep vaping until they work it all out."
34:34 Wendy Zukerman? You know? But of course, in the playbook, it's not just about leaning on the doubt to sell your product. Big Tobacco is also actively funding science. And a lot of that science helps their cause.
34:48 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
34:49 Wendy Zukerman? So, for example, today you can find the Foundation for a Smoke-Free World, whose goal is the end of tobacco use achieved through funding research and promoting innovation.
35:06 Wendy Zukerman? What could create a smoke-free world but a vape-filled world?
35:12 Speaker 05 Wow, that's bleak.
35:14 Wendy Zukerman? They are entirely, entirely funded by Big Tobacco. And just a couple of years ago, they changed their name, by the way, to Global Action to End Smoking. And this is just one of these groups. Other companies that sell these products are out there funding science, too.
35:36 Speaker 05 Wow, dang. Do you think this, like, really corrupts the majority of this research? Like, how big of a problem is this?
35:43 Wendy Zukerman? Yes, that is what I wanted to know. Okay, so around 10 years ago, a researcher in Denmark did one of the first systematic reviews on the health effects of e-cigarettes, which looked at almost 100 studies. And then she analyzed all the conflicts of interest. Do you want to guess what percentage of the studies had some industry conflict of interest?
36:06 Speaker 05 50%?
36:08 Wendy Zukerman? It was 35%.
36:10 Speaker 05 Okay, that's still pretty high.
36:12 Wendy Zukerman? And there's other studies that have kind of looked at this problem in slightly different ways. They find that maybe it's one in four, so 24%, had disclosed industry funding.
36:22 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
36:23 Wendy Zukerman? Which, you know, one in three, one in four.
36:27 Speaker 05 Yeah.
36:28 Wendy Zukerman? Studies in this space are industry-funded. I mean, that's, it's not good. And of course, unsurprisingly, research shows that studies that are industry-funded in this space are more likely to say things like vaping is either harmless or be pro-vaping more generally. So you say things like, wow, they look pretty good compared to cigarettes.
36:52 Speaker 05 And that makes me think of that paper that we talked about, about like, oh, vaping is just as bad as smoking when it comes to heart stuff. And then I was like, it got a lot of critique and criticism. Some of it quite feisty, actually. You know, and I did look at some of the declarations, conflicts of interest, and about something like half the responses that I found declared at least some kind of tie to tobacco or getting some funding or some money from a tobacco or vape company. So I've seen it too.
37:22 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah. I mean, by the way, more than 90% of the people that we surveyed in our, you know, little science versus survey, they didn't get any industry funding, not even from pharmaceutical companies. And I also talked to Becky about big tobacco and how it's muddying the waters here. And here's what she said.
37:43 Speaker 08 There is a lot of misinformation that benefits the bottom line of transnational companies that we're also up against. My budget, the health department's budget, pales in comparison to that of big tobacco and big vape.
37:56 Wendy Zukerman? You know, and meanwhile.
37:59 Wendy Zukerman? We are getting more and more evidence that vaping on its own is bad, right? Even if it, we don't know if it causes cancer yet. We know it messes with your lungs. We know it increases your risk of asthma. We know it makes it more likely that you'll cough or wheeze. More and more evidence showing it's not good for your heart.
38:15 Speaker 05 Well, Wendy, that is a real bummer. So, thanks, I guess.
38:19 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, I'm sorry. You know, but the good news is that there's a, you know that song that we played for people that we didn't lie to them with?
38:29 Speaker 05 Uh huh.
38:31 Wendy Zukerman? The, the end of it is, uh, is really quite prescient. And so, you know, do you want to hear it?
38:38 Speaker 05 Yeah, let's, we'll play me out.
38:53 Speaker 05 The prophecy came true.
38:55 Wendy Zukerman? The prophecy came true.
39:05 Wendy Zukerman? John asked me how many citations are in this episode?
39:07 Speaker 05 So Wendy, how many citations are in this episode?
39:09 Wendy Zukerman? There's 78.
39:10 Speaker 05 Thanks so much for telling me.
39:16 Wendy Zukerman? If people want to see them, they can go to our show notes. There's a link to the transcript. You can read them in all their glory. Thank you, Rose.
39:24 Speaker 05 Thanks, Wendy.
39:25 Wendy Zukerman? If you're thinking of switching to vaping.
39:29 Speaker 05 Do it!
39:30 Wendy Zukerman? Probably try gum or patches first. That's my kazoo.
39:38 Speaker 05 You said it was your kazoo, but you made a motion like it was a truck. What do you think a kazoo is?
39:51 Wendy Zukerman? Bye!
40:00 Wendy Zukerman? Science vs. is a Spotify Studios original. Listen to us for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. If you are listening on Spotify, you can follow us and tap the bell icon so you get episode notifications. If you like this show, give us a five star review, write a comment, say hello. This episode was produced by me, Wendy Zukerman and Rose Rimler, with help from Akedi Foster Keys, Merrill Horn and Michelle Dang. We're edited by Blythe Sherrell. I'm the executive producer. Fact checking by Erica Akiko Howard. Mix and sound design by Bobby Lord. Music written by Boomihidaka, Peter Leonard, Emma Munger and Bobby Lord. Thank you so much to the Australian Science Media Centre for all your help with this episode. Also, thank you to the scientists who responded to our emails on this.
40:44 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, my gosh, some of you wrote the most lovely and thoughtful emails. We really appreciate you responding to us. A big thanks to Joseph Lavelle Wilson and the Zukerman family. I'm Wendy Zukerman. Back to you next time.
41:03 Wendy Zukerman? You know, it's kind of like, do you need to watch seven seasons of Young Sheldon? Or Star Wars: The Phantom Menace?
41:13 Speaker 05 Wait, which, that analogy, which is vaping and which is smoking?
41:17 Wendy Zukerman? I think the more painful is Young Sheldon because it's seven seasons. Either way, you don't have to do, you could do other things with your time. You don't need to do either is the point.
41:27 Speaker 05 Yeah, point extremely clearly made. Can't think of, I can't think of a better public health message than that.
41:34 Wendy Zukerman? Would it help if I said, Misa, no need to...
41:39 Speaker 05 It wouldn't help actually, no.
41:48 Wendy Zukerman? You know what Becky Freeman has actually watched as...
41:51 Speaker 05 Watched all seven seasons of Young Sheldon?
41:57 Wendy Zukerman? Rise, I'm trying to make a serious point here. Okay.
42:02 Speaker 09 When you spend enough time around great companies, you notice that the best ones treat trust as a growth strategy, not a box to check. Vanta helps companies build and prove trust from day one. Its Agentic Trust Platform connects compliance, risk, and trust at enterprise scale. Vanta delivers a 526% return on investment over three years and pays for itself in just three months. Learn why over 16,000 of the fastest-growing companies use Vanta at vanta.com.
42:33 Speaker 10 If you're building AI agents, you should check out Strands Agents. It's an open-source SDK for Python and TypeScript. The idea is simple. Give a model some tools, let it decide what to call and when, and loop until it's done. No chain configs, no graph orchestration, and works with any model provider. It's also open-source and built and tested for production agents. Get started at strandsagents.com.
Previous Running: Will It Wreck Your Body? Next Boredom: Is It Good For You? Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated