Skip to content

The Woman Who Felt No Fear

Science Vs

Hosted by Wendy Zukerman

43m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Science Vs host Wendy Zukerman and science journalist Joel Werner explore the case of SM, one of the only living humans without a functioning amygdala, caused by Urbach-Wiethe disease. Dr. Justin Feinstein at the University of Iowa studied her for decades, testing whether she could feel fear. She could not recognize fear in facial expressions, could not be conditioned to fear through a loud boat horn paired with a blue square, showed no reaction to snakes at a pet store, and walked through the Waverly Hills Sanitarium haunted house on Halloween with amusement rather than dread.

The breakthrough came when Feinstein had her breathe a single breath of air containing 870 times more carbon dioxide than normal. Within seconds, SM waved her hands, tried to tear off her mask, and said, 'I have never felt anything like that before. I felt fear.' This finding, replicated in two twin sisters with the same condition, challenged the half-century assumption that the amygdala is essential for all fear, suggesting instead that interoceptive fear—triggered by internal body signals—operates through a different neural pathway.

The episode also covers the real-world dangers SM faced: a man holding a knife to her throat in a dark park, and a stranger pointing a gun at her head after she reported drug activity in her neighbourhood. In both cases, she felt no fear and did not flee, illustrating both the vulnerability and the scientific value of her condition.

  • SM could recognize anger, happiness, disgust, and surprise in faces but had a 'whopping deficit' in recognizing fear specifically. 12:59
  • A single breath of air with 870 times more CO2 than normal triggered genuine fear in SM, proving the amygdala is not required for all fear. 35:51
  • Feinstein concluded there is probably not one type of fear housed in one specific brain area, but multiple fear systems. 42:11
  • Traumatic events like a knife to the throat do not seem to leave a long-term imprint on SM's memory. 26:05
  • Chemoreceptors in the blood detect rising CO2 and fire a suffocation alarm that bypasses the amygdala entirely. 39:38

Highlights

  • 6:36

    Bean-Shaped Calcified Brain Patternsdata

    Feinstein describes SM's CT scan showing two bright white, almond-shaped patterns where the amygdala should be. Neurosurgeons were baffled that nature carved out only that specific nucleus while leaving the rest of the brain intact.

  • 12:46

    Fear Recognition Deficit in Facesdata

    In a classic face-recognition experiment, SM correctly identified anger, happiness, disgust, and surprise but had a 'whopping deficit' recognizing fear, confirming the amygdala's specific role in reading that emotion in others.

  • 15:46

    Snake Store Visitstory

    Feinstein took SM to an exotic pet store with about fifty cages of snakes, including some eight to ten feet long. She showed no fear, was extremely curious, and held a snake nose-to-nose until the employee told her to stop.

  • 17:54

    Haunted House on Halloweenstory

    Feinstein brought SM to Waverly Hills Sanitarium in Kentucky during its Halloween event, with dark corridors, chainsaws, strobing lights, and hidden actors. SM led the group through, gazed with amusement at the creatures, and even scared an actor.

  • 22:32

    Knife to the Throatstory

    SM recounts walking through a park at night when a man grabbed her by the hair and held a knife to her throat. She told him to go ahead and cut her, and he let her go. She walked home rather than ran.

  • 35:23

    CO2 Experiment Triggers Fearinsight

    After a single breath of air with 870 times more CO2, SM began waving her hands, tried to tear off her mask, and her eyes went wide. She said she had never felt anything like that before and never wanted to repeat the experiment.

  • 42:11

    Multiple Fear Systems in the Braininsight

    Feinstein concludes that SM's case teaches the scientific world that fear is not one all-encompassing type located in one brain area. Interoceptive fear from CO2 operates through chemoreceptors and a pathway that bypasses the amygdala.

About this episode

A group of scientists meet a very unusual woman. A key part of her brain isn’t working: the amygdala. This is the part of the brain that we think is responsible for feeling fear. And in fact, this woman does seem pretty fearless. Researchers test her fear response using some very unconventional methods, but she takes everything in stride. Then, finally, they stumble onto the one thing that makes the woman who can’t feel fear absolutely panic. We scare up some science with neuropsychologist Dr. Justin Feinstein. Find our transcript here: https://tinyurl.com/ScienceVsWomanWhoFeltNoFear In this episode, we cover: (00:00) Meet the Woman Who Felt No Fear (04:38) Fear and the Amygdala (10:27) Scientists Start Running Experiments With the Woman Who Felt No Fear (11:48) Scientists Try to Scare SM (12:59) Scientists Try to Scare Her With Snakes (16:08) Scientists Try to Scare Her with a Haunted House (19:58) The Risks of Feeling No Fear (25:46) Scientists Try a New Approach (34:20) How Breathing Too Much Carbon Dioxide Causes Fear This episode was produced by Wendy Zukerman with help from Ekedi Fausther-Keeys, Rose Rimler, Michelle Dang, and Meryl Horn. We’re edited by Blythe Terrell. Mix and sound design by Bobby Lord. Music written by Emma Munger, So Wiley, Peter Leonard, Bumi Hidaka and Bobby Lord. Thank you to all the scientists we spoke to for this episode including, Special thanks to Joseph Lavelle Wilson and the Zukerman family. Science Vs is a Spotify Studios Original. Listen for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Follow us and tap the bell for episode notifications. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
43:11

7,238 words · 8 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Fear Neuroscience
  • Amygdala Function
  • Case Reports
  • Interoceptive Fear
  • Brain Lesions
  • Urbach-Wiethe Disease
  • Panic Response

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated