Pod Insights Science Vs Telepathy: Is It For Real? About this episode A popular podcast called The Telepathy Tapes claims that telepathy is real — and tons of people are convinced. So we open our minds to the possibility of mind-reading and ask: Could this be real?? And if not — what might be going on here? We dive into the science (yes — there is science!) with Dr. Katharine Beals, Prof. Jim Todd, and Prof. Chris French.
Find our transcript here: https://bit.ly/ScienceVsTelepathy
In this episode, we cover:
(00:00) Extraordinary Claims of Telepathy
(08:28) What Could Be Going On Here?
(32:27) 50 Years of Science on Telepathy?!
This episode was produced by Rose Rimler, with help from Wendy Zukerman, along with Ekedi Fausther-Keeys, Meryl Horn, and Michelle Dang. We’re edited by Blythe Terrell. Mix and sound design by Bobby Lord. Fact checking by Erica Akiko Howard. Music written by Peter Leonard, Emma Munger, So Wylie, Bumi Hidaka, and Bobby Lord. Thanks to all the researchers we spoke to for this episode, including Dr. Zoltan Kekecs, Prof. Stefan Schmidt, and Janyce Boynton. Special thanks to Enrique Perez. Science Vs is a Spotify Studios Original. Listen for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 8,974 words · 18 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Wendy Zukerman? Hi, I'm Wendy Zukerman and you're listening to Science Versus.
0:05 Wendy Zukerman? This is the show that pits facts against feeling like you can read someone's thoughts.
0:15 Wendy Zukerman? Today, we are talking about telepathy. And here with me is Science Versus senior producer, Rose Rimler. Hi, Rose.
0:23 Speaker 01 Hi, Wendy. So by telepathy, we mean the concept of beaming thoughts directly into someone else's brain, or being able to read other people's thoughts.
0:32 Wendy Zukerman? Mm-hmm, yes.
0:33 Speaker 01 That's an idea that's been around for centuries, but it's having a bit of a moment right now, probably because of this very popular podcast called The Telepathy Tapes.
0:42 Wendy Zukerman? Yes, I am hearing a lot about this podcast. Yes, yes, yes, and telepathy with it.
0:48 Speaker 01 Yes, it was the top podcast on Spotify earlier this year. It actually knocked Joe Rogan off the number one spot briefly. And it's all about how telepathy is real.
0:58 Wendy Zukerman? You know, a very clever friend of mine texted me about this show and she thinks telepathy is real now. Exactly, it's very convincing.
1:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, if you look at the comments, you'll see people saying, "This is revolutionary. This has moved me to tears. I'm a believer. My life has changed because of this podcast." And so, you know, I was very curious and so I listened to it. I listened to the whole thing. Wendy, I know that you haven't listened to it.
1:23 Wendy Zukerman? No, that's right. We decided I wouldn't listen, so hopefully I can stand in for those of you who also haven't listened.
1:32 Speaker 01 Okay, so let me tell you the premise. This show is about a very specific group of people. This is people with autism who are very limited in how they communicate and who require a lot of support.
1:42 Wendy Zukerman? Right, right.
1:43 Speaker 01 And the show says that people in this group are able to communicate telepathically, with their family and with teachers and other people. And in fact, here is the show's tagline. They play this at the beginning of every episode.
1:58 Speaker 02 For decades, a very specific group of people have been claiming telepathy is happening in their homes and in their classrooms. And nobody has believed them, nobody has listened to them. But on this podcast, we do.
2:10 Wendy Zukerman? Okay, that's a podcast talk.
2:12 Speaker 01 It really is. So Kai Dickens, that's the host, that's who we just heard from. She is typically a documentary filmmaker, but she heard about this phenomenon and she wanted to study it, document it. And so she ends up visiting a lot of people who have had this experience with autistic people in their lives. Here she is again on the podcast.
2:33 Speaker 02 And what touched me the most is these parents were grappling with something that they believed to be absolutely impossible. But here they were. They were watching something unfold that had no rational explanation.
2:44 Wendy Zukerman? And so, Rose, as you were listening to this podcast, what were you thinking?
2:50 Speaker 01 Well, the stories were interesting and honestly, really intriguing. Obviously, there's been skeptics here saying that something else is going on to explain this.
3:01 Wendy Zukerman? Uh huh.
3:02 Speaker 01 So I wanted to find out what exactly was happening. And I got especially curious when I heard a scientist interviewed on the show say this.
3:11 Speaker 03 Over the last 50 years, and there's been a huge amount of research on telepathy, published in peer-reviewed journals, which has proved to be repeatable and seems to me irrefutable in that it's showing that telepathy really happens. The problem is that the critics simply aren't interested in the evidence because their belief system is that this is impossible.
3:34 Speaker 01 And I was like, wait, what? 50 years of research in peer-reviewed journals, repeatable, irrefutable. I was like, I gotta look into that. Like, that's what I want to pull up, that 50 years of research in peer-reviewed journals.
3:52 Wendy Zukerman? A hundred percent, a hundred percent.
3:54 Speaker 01 And that's what I've been doing. So the last, you know, month or so, and it's, you know, it turns out scientists have been studying this for some time, and I learned a lot of really interesting stuff. Wendy, like, this has just been so fascinating to work on. It's been surprising. It's been infuriating. Sometimes it's fun. So there's like a lot to unpack here, and I'm just like excited to tell you about it.
4:18 Wendy Zukerman? Great. It's all coming up after the break.
4:27 Wendy Zukerman? This episode is brought to you by Chase Sapphire Reserve. On this podcast, we sort fact from fiction. So here's a quick truth for you. With Sapphire Reserve, you can spend all around the world. Not only that, but you can earn four times the points on flights and hotels, book direct, and three times the points on dining. Plus, enjoy access to award-winning airport lounges and exclusive restaurant tables. Learn more at chase.com/sapphirereserve. Cards issued by JP Morgan Chase Bank and a member FDIC. Subject to credit approval; terms apply.
5:05 Speaker 04 Are you looking for support in your weight management journey? Zepbound Terzepatide may be able to help. Zepbound is a prescription medicine used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity to help adults with obesity, or some adults with overweight who also have weight-related medical problems to lose excess body weight and keep the weight off. Zepbound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15-milligram injection. Zepbound contains Terzepatide and should not be used with other Terzepatide-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if Zepbound is safe and effective for use in children. Don't share needles or pens, or reuse needles. Don't take if allergic to it,
5:48 Speaker 04 or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer, or if you've had multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop Zepbound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gallbladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes before scheduled procedures with anesthesia. If you're nursing, pregnant, plan to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking Zepbound with asylphonal urea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979, or visit zepbound.lily.com.
6:40 Wendy Zukerman? Welcome back. Rose is here to talk about telepathy, inspired by this hugely popular podcast, The Telepathy Tapes, which has really brought this topic back into the zeitgeist. So Rose, where do we begin?
6:56 Speaker 01 OK, so first, we're going to talk about some of the specific claims made in the show, The Telepathy Tapes. Then we're going to zoom out and talk about the body of research that scientists have done on telepathy.
7:08 Wendy Zukerman? Great, let's do it.
7:10 Speaker 01 So the show is about people with autism who are nonverbal or who speak very little. And what you hear over and over again on this podcast is that their family can never speak to them or really communicate with them until they learn this method of communicating where the nonverbal person points at letters on a board or picks at keys on a keyboard. And essentially, they learn to painstakingly spell out words and communicate that way.
7:37 Wendy Zukerman? OK.
7:38 Speaker 01 And then, all of a sudden, this is where the telepathy comes in, they start spelling out things that they shouldn't know. So they'll like tell their parent, "Oh, I know that you went to Target today." But the parent's like, "I never told them that I was at Target today." Or they might say, "I know that you brought me cookies for a snack, but you left them in the car." And that person's like, "I never told you I was going to bring you cookies. I didn't tell you I left them in the car." How do they know these things? And they start thinking, "This person can read my mind."
8:12 Wendy Zukerman? Huh.
8:12 Speaker 01 So if that was all the podcast offered, these like little anecdotes, or there could be a million little explanations, or coincidence, or luck, you know?
8:20 Wendy Zukerman? Uh huh.
8:20 Speaker 01 That wouldn't be that interesting.
8:21 Wendy Zukerman? OK.
8:22 Speaker 01 But where it gets really interesting is that the host of the show doesn't just take people at their word for this. She goes and she specifically does tests to test that they are, in fact, telepathic.
8:34 Wendy Zukerman? What kind of test?
8:36 Speaker 01 Well, so for example, in the first episode, she goes to visit a young woman from Mexico who is supposedly telepathic with her mom. And so like I described, this is a nonverbal autistic person who communicates by pointing at a board with letters and numbers on it.
8:50 Wendy Zukerman? Right, right.
8:51 Speaker 01 And so this is the kind of test that Kai sets up. So she'll show something only to the mom, make sure the daughter can't see it. And then she asks-
8:58 Wendy Zukerman? Like a cat, a picture of a cat.
9:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, or like in this example, a picture of a pirate.
9:03 Wendy Zukerman? OK.
9:04 Speaker 01 And, you know, the daughter can't see it. Sometimes she's blindfolded or they'll put a partition between the mom and the daughter. So the daughter can't see the picture. But then the mom says, OK, what am I looking at? Read my mind. What am I looking at? And we hear, and I'll play a little bit for you. The daughter, even though she can't see the picture, she starts pointing at letters. And she slowly spells out, remember, this is a picture of a pirate or pirata in Spanish. P. I. R. A. T. A.
9:40 Speaker 05 Pirata.
9:44 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
9:45 Speaker 06 She clearly types P I R A T A, which spells pirate in Spanish. I love this moment because the crowd just goes wild. At this point, everyone in the room had had their mind blown.
9:56 Speaker 07 I mean, I wouldn't do it as a skeptic. I'm generally a skeptic in my life.
10:01 Wendy Zukerman? Who's this talking?
10:03 Speaker 01 This is the cameraman.
10:04 Speaker 07 Seeing this, I can't, it's hard for me to not believe this stuff, I think. I'm looking at everything. I'm watching her, I'm watching the mom, I'm watching, I'm watching everything. And for me and my perspective, it's real.
10:24 Wendy Zukerman? Aha, that is impressive.
10:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, hearing that cameraman's reaction is pretty compelling because you're like, wow, he was actually in the room and looking carefully, right? And he said it seemed real.
10:35 Wendy Zukerman? Mm hmm.
10:36 Speaker 01 But the thing is, when autism experts hear about this, they immediately see a problem.
10:42 Wendy Zukerman? OK.
10:43 Speaker 01 And it goes back to the, how people are communicating and the history of people trying to communicate with those who can't speak. I talked about this with Catherine Beals. She's an adjunct professor at the University of Pennsylvania and elsewhere. And I talked to her specifically about this case. So, so does this impress you?
11:02 Speaker 08 No, it's just, I find it extraordinary that anybody thinks it's a compelling instance of telepathy.
11:08 Speaker 01 Well, she's kind of the perfect person to talk to about this.
11:10 Speaker 08 I started out as a linguist. That was my PhD. And then I had a child with autism. The particular situation I'm in is actually kind of the perfect storm.
11:19 Speaker 01 The perfect storm to see what's actually going on here. And Catherine says, we got to go back a few decades. Actually, the story starts in Australia, Wendy. You'll be happy to know.
11:32 Wendy Zukerman? I feel right at home.
11:34 Speaker 01 Someone there had invented a special way for people who can't speak to communicate. And in the 90s, this technique spread from Australia to the US. And it really took off here. It's a bit different from the way people are communicating in the telepathy tapes.
11:49 Wendy Zukerman? With the letterboard.
11:50 Speaker 01 The letterboard. This is called facilitated communication. Here's how it works. The non-speaking person sits in front of, you know, some kind of keyboard.
11:58 Wendy Zukerman? Right.
11:58 Speaker 01 Next to them is a facilitator who gently holds their arm or their wrist and helps them select the letters on the keyboard that they want to select.
12:08 Wendy Zukerman? Mm-hmm. So it's a bit faster than them having to do it all by themselves. Is that the idea?
12:14 Speaker 01 Not exactly. For some of these folks, they actually need someone to help guide their hands to the letters to use the keyboard, or they don't do it at all.
12:21 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, OK.
12:22 Speaker 01 And so, once this method started being used more and more, these incredible things started happening.
12:28 Speaker 08 The claims were pretty extraordinary because these individuals who appeared to be completely nonverbal and maybe not attending to people speaking and language in general were suddenly able to produce grammatically well-formed sentences, perfectly spelled in many cases, and quite sophisticated in many cases. In some cases, poetry, sophisticated vocabulary. So it appeared to unlock what was, people were thinking was, an intact or fully-developed intellect in terms of having learned somehow to read, having mastered language, and so on.
13:11 Wendy Zukerman? This idea that they can't speak beautifully, but locked inside their brain is this huge mastery over the English language that, until now, they were not able to express.
13:29 Speaker 01 Exactly.
13:30 Wendy Zukerman? Sort of this idea.
13:31 Speaker 01 Yeah. And this, as you can imagine, that's a huge breakthrough, right? And it got a lot of attention. It was all over the news. It was on TV. There was a primetime live episode. It eventually won an Emmy. Diane Sawyer reported on this as like this breakthrough. And you can hear how powerful this seemed.
13:51 Speaker 09 And now, a story about hope. For decades, autism has been a dark mystery, a disorder that seems to turn children in on themselves, against the world. Tonight, however, you are going to see something that has changed that. Call it a miracle, call it an awakening.
14:08 Wendy Zukerman? I mean, so hopeful if you're a parent to be looking at your trials and thinking, wow, if there's so much in there, if only I could find a way to communicate.
14:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, your child has never spoken to you, has never said, "I love you." And now there's this thing that says, there's a lot going on in their head and they can tell you about it.
14:26 Wendy Zukerman? I do have to say, as hopeful as this is, I am getting a Ouija board vibe here.
14:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, that is a concern that people were actually, people from the beginning, some people did have that concern because you're holding someone's arm and potentially moving it for them, even if you don't think you are. So it could be that the facilitator is controlling what this person is typing.
14:51 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, not, not, not meaning to necessarily, just wanting to move through it faster. And they're like, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. D O, you probably mean dog.
15:01 Speaker 01 Exactly, that kind of thing. And there are always a little bit, there's always some skeptics out there. But for a while, because this is just so cool to people, they just kept chugging along. But then the cracks started to show in these very dramatic ways because in some cases, people were spelling out very disturbing messages. Some of their stories were told in a frontline documentary. It was called Prisoners of Silence. It came out in 1993. And here they are talking about a teenage girl with autism named Betsy.
15:32 Speaker 10 One day, using a letter board, Betsy and her facilitator wrote that everybody in her family, her father, mother, grandparents, and brother, were sexually abusing her.
15:43 Speaker 01 Social services were called, Betsy was taken out of her home, put in foster care. An investigation was started. But the people working this case were like, mm, can we really trust these allegations? They came from this unusual technique. Someone else is holding Betsy's hand and helping her point out letters, type. So what they wanted to know was, who is writing the messages? Is it the autistic person or is it the facilitator? So they set up tests for Betsy. And Catherine described the kind of tests that they did.
16:15 Speaker 08 You might have a divider between the facilitator and the person they're facilitating. And the person they're facilitating sees a picture of a hat. And the facilitator sees a picture of a shoe.
16:25 Speaker 01 This is the telepathy type test. Kind of, with a key difference. They're showing two different pictures. They're showing one picture to the facilitator. So in this example, a picture of a shoe. And one picture to the person with autism. In this example, a hat.
16:39 Speaker 08 And then you ask the person with autism, what do you see here?
16:42 Speaker 01 What you would want them to write would be hat.
16:45 Speaker 08 Yes. And if they type shoe, then, then where did that come from?
16:50 Speaker 01 Very fishy. That's because that's what the facilitator saw, not what they saw.
16:53 Speaker 08 Yes, yes.
16:55 Speaker 01 Ah. In the telepathy tapes, the person with autism is being asked to spell out what someone else sees. And here, they're being asked to spell out what they themselves see. Hmm, right, right, right, right. The Frontline documentary is really useful because it actually shows what these tests were like. And they talk about what happened when they ran tests like this with Betsy.
17:17 Speaker 10 When Betsy was shown a picture of a dog, she didn't type dog, but sneakers. What the facilitator saw. When Betsy was shown a boat, she didn't type boat, but sandwich. What the facilitator saw.
17:35 Speaker 01 And that happened in every test they tried. Every single test. Of Betsy or in studies as well? In studies as well. Every single test? Yes, there was an autistic program in, in New York that had been using facilitated communication with 12 of their autistic students. Getting good results, they thought, but they said, oh, maybe we should test this, make sure. They tested each student in the same way. I asked Catherine what happened.
18:04 Speaker 08 And they didn't get a single correct response.
18:07 Speaker 01 Not one?
18:09 Speaker 08 Yeah.
18:09 Speaker 01 And this has been repeated many times.
18:11 Speaker 08 There were a whole bunch of studies that came out in the 90s that, that just one after another, after another, were showing failure.
18:18 Speaker 01 How often do they find it was, in fact, the person with autism who was doing the communicating?
18:22 Speaker 08 In well-designed studies, not at all, never.
18:25 Speaker 01 Never?
18:26 Speaker 08 Right.
18:26 Speaker 01 Wow. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Yeah, so in the case with Betsy, the investigators concluded that the sex abuse allegations were totally unfounded. And so, do we know?
18:40 Wendy Zukerman? Why the facilitator was doing that?
18:43 Speaker 01 Yeah, in the Betsy case, we do know what's going on here because the facilitator like came out and talked about it, wrote a paper about it.
18:52 Speaker 01 And she explained that, you know, she'd had some doubts in the beginning, like, oh, am I really, am I moving Betsy's hand, or is it really Betsy? It's kind of hard to tell. But there was so much momentum and it was so exciting to think that she was making breakthroughs with her student that she kind of let herself believe in it.
19:08 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, OK, so it's almost like this subconscious response? The facilitators, I mean, if they're not actually doing it on purpose, I would have thought it was just really just trying to help, trying to communicate.
19:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that's usually what people think is going on. It's actually called the idiomotor effect, the Ouija board. You don't, everyone thinks they're not, well, I don't know, I would sometimes move the planchette on purpose, but many of us
19:33 Speaker 01 just think we're not moving it, but then it does move and especially it might move to a letter that makes a lot of sense after the previous letter. And how does that happen? There's also something called the Chevrel pendulum illusion, where you're, you think you're holding the pendulum steady in the air, but when you think about moving it to the right or to the left, or up or down, suddenly it starts moving that way. And you're like, I'm not even doing that. But it's just like the, your brain is sending these very tiny signals to your hand. And, and that is enough to make very small movements that can have very big consequences, you know?
20:03 Wendy Zukerman? Aha, so can we go back to the telepathy tapes now?
20:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, because just to be clear, these abuse allegations we're talking about, that's part of the frontline documentary, not the telepathy tapes.
20:12 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, yeah, OK, so then to go back to that pirata example, the pirate.
20:18 Speaker 01 Exactly, yeah, so that's the question, right? Is that what they're doing?
20:21 Wendy Zukerman? What, did the kid have a facilitator on hand?
20:25 Speaker 01 Yes, in every, in all of these cases, the person with autism is speaking via facilitator. It varies in exactly what the facilitator is doing and how they're communicating, but there's always somebody else there that has to be there. It's not fully independent. And it's typically the parent who's the facilitator.
20:44 Wendy Zukerman? Oh.
20:45 Speaker 01 Yeah.
20:45 Wendy Zukerman? So the?
20:46 Speaker 01 The one who's supposed mind is being read.
20:49 Wendy Zukerman? The mom is looking at the pirate and also holding her kid's hand?
20:54 Speaker 01 Well, yes and no.
20:57 Speaker 01 So what they're doing in the telepathy tapes is not technically facilitated communication in the classic sense, because they're not literally holding the person's hand and hovering it over a board. What they're typically doing in the telepathy tapes, they hold up a letter board, and then the person with autism points, and then they call out P-I-R. And in fact, the host of the podcast, she said, she just said at one point, like, oh, there was this controversy with facilitated communication, but this is different, this is different. And the big thing that they point out is, we're not really touching the kid in the same way that they were touching them before. This method is often called spelling to communicate, or just spelling.
21:40 Wendy Zukerman? Hmm. So what does Catherine say about that?
21:43 Speaker 01 Well, she points out that, you know, it's problematic that the facilitator is also the transcriber of the message. Like, if you're holding a letter board, A, you can move it around slightly, and B, you can say, oh, you've selected the letter P. Oh, now you've selected the letter I. That gives you a lot of latitude in deciding where exactly the person's finger went.
22:06 Speaker 08 So they will decide when a letter was selected, and they'll decide in an ambiguous case which letter was selected.
22:14 Wendy Zukerman? Because someone could be pointing in between the letters F and G.
22:18 Speaker 08 In between, and in some cases, believe it or not, nowhere near. And so there are videos where you can actually, the person is using a transparent letter board, so from watching from the other side, you can see letters sometimes being called out that we're not pointing to at all.
22:33 Speaker 01 And also, they are often touching. So like, there's a hand on the back, or in the case of the mom and the daughter from Mexico, the mom is often touching the daughter's forehead, or holding her chin.
22:45 Wendy Zukerman? In the telepathy tapes, did you watch the videos?
22:48 Speaker 01 I did. So there are videos available for some of the tests. You have to pay a small fee and become a member, but it's on their website. And I did watch them. In fact, I watched some of them with Catherine. I didn't see any obvious examples where you see someone pointing at a T and the facilitator calls out P or something like that. But it's clear from these videos that typically the facilitator is really involved in one way or another. So we watched one where the daughter is sitting next to the mom, but they have a partition between them. The mom is shown a random number generator on someone's iPad and this random number 978 is generated. Here I'm watching it with Catherine. The mom sees that the number is 978.
23:31 Speaker 01 They take away the partition. She's kind of gently touching her on her forehead. Yeah, and here she's got the letter board up.
23:40 Speaker 08 Yeah, so what you could clearly see was that the mother was touching the girl, just not, didn't happen to be her finger, and that there were changes in how hard she was, in her pressure, the pressure that she was exerting on the daughter's temple and cheek. And so that might have been all that was needed to chew the girl about when to actually make a selection.
24:03 Wendy Zukerman? And this, I mean, it doesn't need to be intentional, right? I mean, you could be doing this without even realizing it.
24:12 Speaker 01 Easily. We know that's true. And actually, the fact that this could be subconscious really explains a lot, I think. If the person facilitating is spelling out their own thoughts but doesn't realize they're spelling out their own thoughts, that explains why they might genuinely think, oh, my God, this person is reading my mind.
24:30 Wendy Zukerman? Hmm, of course.
24:36 Speaker 01 But there was one case that didn't really make sense, and I couldn't figure out how it was possible. This is a young autistic man and his mom. He seems to be able to read his mother's thoughts by typing them out independently on a keyboard. So in this case, no one's holding up a letter board for him. Kai describes them as not touching. And I watched the videos online, and that's true. There's nobody, they aren't touching. So their telepathy really does look pretty convincing. So for this, I called up Jim Todd. He's a professor of psychology at Eastern Michigan University.
25:12 Speaker 11 And I teach conditioning and learning in general.
25:17 Speaker 11 The basics of behavior, the kind of basics of behavior that you kind of need to know to parse some of this stuff out.
25:24 Speaker 01 Like with Catherine, I watched one of these videos with him. Can you see my screen?
25:28 Speaker 11 I can see your screen, yes.
25:30 Speaker 01 So in this video, the son is sitting next to the mom. And he has like an iPad sort of device that when he touches the letter, the device says the letter out loud in like this robot voice.
25:41 Wendy Zukerman? Uh huh.
25:43 Speaker 01 So in this test, the mom has shown an image. The son can't see it. It's a picture of a crocodile.
25:48 Wendy Zukerman? Okay.
25:49 Speaker 01 And the son is asked to spell out what his mom can see. And we can see him pick out letters on this device. And the computer starts spelling out, "crocodile."
25:56 Wendy Zukerman? Ha, ha, ha, ha. G. I. Ha, ha, ha. L. E. Crocodile.
26:05 Speaker 11 Well, it's mom is moving her hand and her body in sequence with the letters. It's just signaling.
26:15 Speaker 01 Do you want to see the tape, Wendy?
26:16 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, I want to watch it.
26:17 Speaker 01 Okay.
26:18 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, yeah. Okay. So Kai shows the
26:22 Speaker 01 The mom.
26:23 Wendy Zukerman? A picture of a crocodile.
26:25 Speaker 01 Did you see it? Did you see what Jim is? What Jim saw?
26:30 Wendy Zukerman? From the mom.
26:32 Speaker 01 Uh huh.
26:32 Wendy Zukerman? Just play it again.
26:33 Speaker 01 Okay. And look at the mom, not the son.
26:35 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, yeah, she's moving her hand.
26:39 Speaker 01 Every time he moves a
26:40 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, my gosh.
26:41 Speaker 01 He selects a letter just before that she has moved.
26:43 Wendy Zukerman? She's moving her hand and in a very deliberate way, whether she is conscious of that deliberateness. But it's just not, it's not if, yeah. Why, oh, yeah, for sure. Did you ask Kai why didn't she move them away from each other, knowing what she clearly knew about facilitated communication?
27:00 Speaker 01 I did reach out to Kai to ask specific questions like that.
27:03 Wendy Zukerman? Mm hmm.
27:04 Speaker 01 But her team said that she was too busy working on season two of the celebrity tapes and making a documentary about it as well.
27:10 Wendy Zukerman? Mm hmm.
27:11 Speaker 01 So she couldn't get back to us.
27:13 Wendy Zukerman? Wow, that's very frustrating.
27:15 Speaker 01 Yeah. I also reached out to the mom in the crocodile video and I didn't hear back from her either.
27:20 Wendy Zukerman? Okay.
27:21 Speaker 01 So, I don't know. I don't know. I mean, I will say, in the episode, they say a lot of stuff about how, oh, we can do this across the room. And then they start to do that, but then the son becomes uncomfortable and doesn't cooperate. And so they say, well, he needs to sit next to his mom for the emotional support.
27:41 Speaker 01 So stuff like that happens.
27:43 Wendy Zukerman? Hmm. I mean, what's
27:48 Wendy Zukerman? What's sort of, I guess, interesting is there is some lovely communication happening between the parent and the child. It's not telepathy, but clearly they have learnt a language with each other that when the parent touches the kid or makes this signal with their hand, they point to a letter. I mean, they have a language together and that there is sort of something lovely about that, I guess.
28:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, you can make that argument. I mean, in that video we just saw, it does seem like the young man is having a good time, like enjoying being with his mother. But I've seen plenty of other videos from other sources that showed this technique where it doesn't really go that way. And Catherine has too.
28:39 Speaker 08 A lot of the time, the child doesn't look like they really want to be doing this.
28:42 Speaker 01 You know, I have noticed that, but I don't really understand necessarily what I'm seeing. I don't know much about people with severe autism. So when you see someone like, like kind of trying to get away or calling out or saying, "I'm sad," there was a video of a girl who was doing this. She went, "I'm sad."
28:57 Speaker 08 I've seen it.
28:58 Speaker 01 Is that what they're, like, that seems like she's saying she's sad and she doesn't want to be doing that.
29:02 Speaker 08 Yeah, it certainly does.
29:03 Speaker 01 And in fact, a professional organization called the American Speech Language Hearing Association has explicitly said, "Don't use these methods of communicating, this facilitated communication, the newer ones that are sometimes called like spelling to communicate or rapid prompting method, don't use them."
29:21 Wendy Zukerman? This stuff happening on the telepathy tapes.
29:23 Speaker 01 Yes. And one reason why is that they say, "These methods strip people of their human right to independent communication."
29:30 Wendy Zukerman? So, does this put a cap on the telepathy tapes then?
29:34 Speaker 01 Well, yeah. As far as the whole people with autism are telepathic thing, because, you know, the show goes on to say a lot of other stuff, extraordinary stuff. But all these extraordinary claims, they're all hinging on this supposition that the folks with autism can send messages to their parents or their teachers. But we know now that the way they are doing this is with these like letterboard methods or similar methods that are totally bunk. And we can't trust that it's the kid's message coming through. In fact, we shouldn't expect that to be the case based on all we know
30:16 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah.
30:17 Speaker 01 about how unlikely this is to work.
30:19 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, it's like the, uh, the fruit, the podcast keeps creating more fruit, but the, the tree is rotten.
30:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
30:28 Wendy Zukerman? Uh huh. Well, I can't wait for season two then.
30:33 Speaker 01 I don't know if I'll be listening.
30:35 Wendy Zukerman? Correct.
30:36 Speaker 01 But, you know, this doesn't put a cap on our episode because there is a lot more to talk about. When it comes to the, the science of telepathy, um, there's a lot to tell you. I did promise you that, right?
30:47 Wendy Zukerman? That's right. The, the, all of these repeatable studies over decades of research.
30:53 Speaker 01 Yeah. And I looked into that. So after the break, I'm going to tell you about the pretty like bonkers way that scientists have tried to test for telepathy and the results that are actually quite surprising.
31:05 Wendy Zukerman? Coming up.
31:15 Wendy Zukerman? Today's Ask Wendy Anything, Ask Me Anything, is brought to you by Amazon. Whether it's delivering medication to your door with Amazon Pharmacy or 24/7 virtual care with Amazon One Medical. Thanks to Amazon, healthcare just got less painful. So for our little Ask Me Anything, senior producer Rose Rimmler has come to me with some listener questions that have been gathered through social media. Hey, Rose.
31:44 Speaker 01 Hey, Wendy. Our first question comes from Kelsey on Instagram and she asks, how do you wade through all the misinformation and inaccurate information to get to the truth?
31:53 Wendy Zukerman? Ooh, love this question because I feel like we do so much homework on this show that no one gets to see. So when someone asks this kind of question, I'm like, yes. For me, when I'm making an episode, my first step is to go online and try and understand what is the misinformation, or at least what people are saying about a particular topic. A diet, for example. You'll start to see, you know, people are saying that it makes them smarter and gives them all this energy and makes their body look a certain way. And so I'll start to turn that into scientific questions. Does this diet affect your brain? How does it affect your body? And then I'll just dive into the scientific research and start chatting to scientists.
32:36 Wendy Zukerman? And I won't stop until I feel like the answers have really started to coalesce, where I feel like I've got the scientific consensus, or as close to it as possible, and now I can start to build an episode.
32:51 Speaker 01 Sounds good. Someone named Nishala, also on Instagram, she asks, "Have you ever considered doing stand-up? There is talent here."
32:59 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, thank you. So I actually did stand up a couple of times.
33:07 Speaker 01 Wow.
33:08 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, when I was doing a job I didn't really like, and I wanted to put some fire up my [BLEEP]. Yeah, just [BLEEP].
33:17 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
33:18 Wendy Zukerman? Here is why I do not do stand-up comedy anymore. Because, Rose, would you like to hear the one joke that I remember?
33:26 Speaker 01 From your routine?
33:27 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah.
33:28 Speaker 01 Yes, I do.
33:29 Wendy Zukerman? Was something like this, was something like this. Okay, so, um...
33:35 Wendy Zukerman? Tuna are so amazing. Aren't they these amazing creatures? They're just so majestic in the ocean, just so beautiful. And it's amazing that evolution created this creature that swims in a little capsule with lemon and pepper all in there. So it's so convenient that we could just eat it all out.
34:02 Speaker 01 That's five out of 10, I'd say, maybe.
34:09 Speaker 01 We'll let Nishala be the judge of that one.
34:11 Wendy Zukerman? All right, let me know. Did I make the right call sticking with science journalism? Thanks, Rose.
34:17 Speaker 01 Thanks, Wendy.
34:19 Wendy Zukerman? Today's Ask Wendy Me Anything was brought to you by Amazon. Thanks to Amazon, healthcare just got less painful.
34:30 Speaker 12 This episode is brought to you by Petivity. Cat parents are basically mealtime detectives. Who actually ate? Did they finish? Was that less than yesterday? The new Petivity Smart Feeder for cats turns everyday meals into meaningful health insights, helping you identify changes in your cat's habits and be more proactive about their health. Plus, you can feed them from anywhere. Take the mystery out of mealtime. Visit petivity.com, P-E-T-I-V-I-T-Y.com/catfeeder to learn more.
35:00 Speaker 05 Plan B is a backup birth control option that's there for you when things don't go according to plan. It specifically works after unprotected sex and before pregnancy occurs by temporarily delaying ovulation. Plan B is available nationwide, at all major retailers, and through delivery apps like DoorDash. No ID, prescription, or age requirement. It's the number one OBGYN recommended brand of emergency contraception, and it won't impact your future fertility. That's freedom to be. Use as directed.
35:29 Speaker 13 I used to wonder what I missed any time I stepped out of the shop. But with AT&T Business Wireless, my signal stays strong no matter where the day takes me. Like right now, I'm meeting a photography client
35:43 Speaker 13 out here.
35:45 Speaker 13 But I still have a reliable connection, even though I have no idea where I am right now.
35:50 Speaker 14 Keep your business connected with AT&T Business Wireless. Visit att.com/5GNetwork. When the connection matters, it has to be AT&T.
36:00 Speaker 15 I don't know what I'm doing. Need a break. Forget it, I quit.
36:03 Speaker 16 Escape to Pluto TV.
36:05 Speaker 05 This is objectively fantastic.
36:07 Speaker 16 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free. Shwing! Even our news is uplifting.
36:13 Speaker 07 You stay classy, San Diego.
36:14 Speaker 16 Watch Tommy Boy, Crazy Ex Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more. We're not worthy! The best things on TV really are free.
36:24 Speaker 05 You just have to know where to look.
36:26 Speaker 16 Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
36:34 Wendy Zukerman? Welcome back. Rose just told us why we really can't believe the telepathy you might hear about on the telepathy tapes. But now we're gonna broaden out to the land of how science has tested telepathy, Rose?
36:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, I talked about this with emeritus professor of psychology, Chris French. Until recently, he was the head of the Anomalousity Psychology Research Unit at Goldsmiths, University of London.
37:04 Wendy Zukerman? Okay.
37:04 Speaker 01 Anomalousity psychology means stuff outside the norm, maybe even the paranormal.
37:11 Wendy Zukerman? Right, right, right.
37:12 Speaker 17 I accept that there are some really interesting and challenging ideas out there for skeptics. I mean, some of the evidence isn't easy to dismiss. And certainly, when you get skeptics who say there is no evidence for the existence of telepathy or precognition and so on, that's just nonsense.
37:33 Speaker 01 Chris has spent much of his career looking at paranormal stuff in a rigorous way. So he tries to figure out if it's real or if there's a more mundane explanation. So you're a professional party pooper?
37:47 Speaker 17 I am indeed, yeah. I don't get invited to, well, I don't get invited to parties at all because of my overwhelmingly negative personality.
37:56 Speaker 01 Okay, so one common way to test for telepathy involves something called the Gansfeldt Protocol.
38:02 Speaker 17 It's based on the idea that if there is such a thing as telepathy, it may well be that it's a very, very faint signal in comparison to all the background noise.
38:13 Speaker 01 So the Gansfeldt Protocol, and by the way, Gansfeldt is German for whole field.
38:17 Wendy Zukerman? Okay.
38:17 Speaker 01 So the experimenters set someone up in a very controlled, very subdued environment so that the telepathic signal has as much of a chance as possible to come through.
38:26 Wendy Zukerman? Uh huh.
38:27 Speaker 01 So the people in the experiment will wear headphones with white or pink noise playing. They make sure there's nothing for them to see by putting on these goggles on their eyes. They look like...
38:39 Speaker 17 Half ping pong balls, one over each eye. And you, obviously, light could still get in there through the gaps. So you use cotton wool just to plug that up. And then you tape over the eyes. And then you have a red light bulb. So if they open their eyes, all they'll see is red. So it's not that, you've got no sensory input, but you've just got a uniform sensory input. And it basically, it's a very, very nice, comfortable, relaxing situation to be in. And people typically report that after a while, they relax and their head begins to fill with imagery, you know?
39:14 Wendy Zukerman? Hmm, mhm. And at this point, someone sends... An image of a pirate crocodile.
39:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. So someone's in another room.
39:25 Wendy Zukerman? In another room.
39:26 Speaker 01 In another room, and they're looking at an image or maybe a video clip. And they're really focusing on it, and they're really trying to send it to the other person.
39:37 Speaker 17 And the sender would try to concentrate on that target image and send the information to the receiver.
39:43 Speaker 01 Just by thinking about it really hard.
39:45 Speaker 17 Just by thinking about it real hard, exactly.
39:48 Speaker 01 So then, after some time, the person takes off their silly ping pong goggles, comes out of the room. They're shown four images or four video clips. And they say, which is the one that was being beamed to you? So they pick one. And so if you were just picking by chance, you would get this right 25% of the time.
40:04 Wendy Zukerman? Right.
40:05 Speaker 01 But lots of these studies find that people pick the right image or the right video clip more than 25% of the time.
40:10 Wendy Zukerman? How much more?
40:12 Speaker 01 32% of the time.
40:16 Wendy Zukerman? Okay.
40:18 Speaker 01 That number comes from a meta-analysis that came out just last year. They looked at over 100 experiments done in the Gansfeldt condition over the last 50 years.
40:28 Wendy Zukerman? Uh huh, uh huh.
40:29 Speaker 01 It includes some studies on clairvoyance and other psychic phenomena tested using the Gansfeldt Protocol, but it's mostly tests of telepathy. And the authors concluded that there was a small but statistically significant effect here.
40:42 Wendy Zukerman? That is intriguing.
40:44 Speaker 01 That's not all. You can find something similar with other tests that have been done, like these telephone telepathy tests. You tell people that they're going to get a phone call from one of four specific people, and they have to guess as the phone is ringing, which of these four people is the one calling them. By chance, they should get the right person 25% of the time. A lot of studies find they get it right more often than that, 30 or 40% of the time.
41:08 Wendy Zukerman? So what do you, what does, what does Chris make of this?
41:13 Speaker 01 Well, so this meta-analysis, this Gansfeldt one, it made a big splash among the telepathy crowd.
41:20 Wendy Zukerman? No doubt.
41:21 Speaker 01 It was definitely referenced on the Telepathy Tapes podcast. And so I asked Chris about it. Did it rock your world?
41:26 Speaker 17 No, because I've had my fingers burnt with meta-analyses before. I mean, meta-analysis, I think is, you know, is a very useful tool, and I think we should take this latest meta-analysis seriously. But whether or, whether I'm going to say, yes, okay, I'm convinced now, I'm going to hold back a little bit because there have been so many twists and turns in this tale.
41:46 Speaker 01 Yeah. This isn't Chris's first radio, and it's not his first Gansfeldt meta-analysis claiming a 30% hit rate.
41:53 Wendy Zukerman? Okay.
41:55 Speaker 01 He said that there was actually something very similar back in the 90s. He was younger, more naive then, right?
42:01 Speaker 17 And I read that and thought, oh my God, wow, this really looks like very powerful evidence.
42:06 Wendy Zukerman? So what are these analyses doing wrong?
42:08 Speaker 01 Well, there's a few funny things that are going on here. So we know that in studies about paranormal stuff, if the test is done by a believer, they tend to find an effect. While if it's done by a skeptic, they tend not to find an effect. Like, imagine that you're more of a skeptic, like Chris, and you run one of these telepathy experiments, and you find that people guess right 25% of the time. As a skeptic, when you get a result like that, you might say... Oh, OK, all right. No effect here. Done, right? If you're a believer, you might look at that and say, "Mm, I'm gonna go look through the data again." I would have expected something else to happen. So I'm gonna go and I'm gonna look through the raw data. Maybe I'll get rid of some outliers.
42:50 Speaker 01 Maybe I'll find a piece of the data and I'll just look at this subgroup.
42:55 Wendy Zukerman? Bob wasn't really concentrating during the experiment.
42:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm gonna throw out his data.
42:59 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, exactly.
43:00 Speaker 01 And vice versa. You know, if you're a skeptic and you get a result that says telepathy is real, you might start combing through that data very carefully, you know?
43:08 Wendy Zukerman? Right, yep.
43:12 Speaker 01 So to avoid this, there has been a movement, and this is especially true in psychology research, to preregister your study. So you basically publish a protocol ahead of time, saying, "This is how I'm gonna do the study. This is how I'm gonna analyze my data." And then that can't happen, right? This like tweaking and nudging after the fact.
43:32 Wendy Zukerman? Well, less so.
43:34 Speaker 01 Less so.
43:35 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah.
43:35 Speaker 01 And when you look at that meta-analysis, they're not looking specifically at studies that were preregistered. So it's really hard to know if we can trust them.
43:43 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, no. This makes me so sad. I'm like, scientists, do your job properly.
43:48 Speaker 01 I know. Well, funny you should mention that because not long ago, there was a very concerted effort to do a proper study on psychic phenomena.
43:59 Wendy Zukerman? OK.
44:00 Speaker 01 So specifically, they were trying to replicate a study from 2011 on precognition. So like predicting the future, basically?
44:07 Wendy Zukerman? Yes, yes, yes, yes.
44:08 Speaker 01 The way this study worked, they had a computer program they were showing to people with a picture of two curtains. And they asked people, "Of these two curtains, which one has an erotic image hiding behind it?"
44:24 Speaker 01 So the people would guess, and then, only then, would the computer program assign the erotic image randomly to one or the other slot.
44:32 Wendy Zukerman? Oh, so this was... You would try to, oh, predict what the computer would do. And unknown, and unknown, basically.
44:41 Speaker 01 Yes.
44:41 Wendy Zukerman? OK, wow.
44:44 Speaker 01 In the original study, people got this right more than 50% of the time.
44:49 Wendy Zukerman? Mm-hmm.
44:50 Speaker 01 Which the author suggested could mean they were actually predicting the future.
44:54 Wendy Zukerman? Sure, okay.
44:56 Speaker 01 There was a lot of attention on this study at the time.
44:58 Wendy Zukerman? No doubt.
44:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, and skeptics said, you know.
45:02 Wendy Zukerman? Can I just ask, if you got it right, did the curtains open and then you got to see the willy?
45:07 Speaker 01 I believe so, yes. Or what I, or they actually controlled for people's sexual preferences. So if you wanted to see a willy, you might get to see a willy. If you wanted to see a booby, you might get to see a booby.
45:22 Wendy Zukerman? Okay, so they replicate the study?
45:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, so because a lot of skeptics said like, ah, we don't like this part of your methodology, or this thing you did about your stats. What basically happened is that the skeptics and the believers got together, designed a new research protocol, designed a new study they both agreed on. They pre-registered it. They said, this is the protocol we're gonna use.
45:42 Wendy Zukerman? Great.
45:43 Speaker 01 This is, and this is how we're gonna do it, and how we're gonna analyze it.
45:46 Wendy Zukerman? Yes.
45:47 Speaker 01 It took five years, it took 10 labs participating, 30-ish authors. Skeptics and believers working together to look to see, is there an effect here?
45:58 Wendy Zukerman? Wow, a new future is possible. And what did they find?
46:03 Speaker 01 When all this was said and done.
46:06 Speaker 17 It produced absolutely no effects whatsoever to support the existence of precognition.
46:11 Wendy Zukerman? Okay, that's the suggestion being if we were to rigorously test telepathy, putting the skeptics and believers all together, perhaps we would see the same effect, but I guess we don't.
46:23 Speaker 01 We don't have the same exact thing for telepathy, but a lot of the issues that this precognition study were confronting are very similar to issues that people have with telepathy research. So, I don't know, I think it's pretty damning to telepathy as well, but would love to see a similar group effort.
46:40 Wendy Zukerman? Yes.
46:41 Speaker 01 Doing one of these, some of these studies.
46:43 Wendy Zukerman? Can I ask, what is the mechanism, the purported mechanism of telepathy? Like, how?
46:50 Speaker 01 I was hoping you wouldn't ask me that.
46:53 Wendy Zukerman? Yeah, are they reaching for quantum physics here?
46:56 Speaker 01 Yes, they are. Quantum entanglement specifically, which is about like this weird connection between subatomic particles where they seem to influence each other. And it doesn't matter how far apart they are.
47:07 Wendy Zukerman? Mm hmm.
47:08 Speaker 01 And I did, actually, I did talk to a physicist who I was referred to by someone who's who's sort of telepathy friendly as a physicist who's also telepathy friendly. He's open minded about it. And I asked him, does quantum entanglement, could that explain how telepathy works? And he said, no. And I said, do we have any known physical explanation for how telepathy could work? And he said, no. And he's like, look, maybe it happens, but if it's happening, it's happening outside of physics as we understand it. And I'm open to that. I'm, well, that's what I'm open to. Like, there's stuff about the spirituality we don't understand.
47:44 Wendy Zukerman? So where does this leave you, Rose?
47:49 Speaker 01 All right. So especially considering that there's no known mechanism that this could work. Looking at the research, the Gansfeld, the telephone telepathy stuff, you've got to believe one of two things. One is that the telepathy vibes are there, they're just very weak and very fickle. Or you can believe that there are no vibes. What do you think, Wendy? Weak, fickle vibes or no vibes?
48:18 Wendy Zukerman? I mean, I think that the vibes, when people say they're experiencing something like telepathy, are like intuition and other human vibes that are not paranormal, is what I would, whether it is a parent who loves their child, their nonverbal child so much, and there is some communication there and there's something nice being shared, it's just not paranormal. And when two friends, you know, one calls the other and one says, oh, my God, I knew you were gonna call, they probably haven't spoken in a long time and they love each other and there's some intuition there, which is beautiful.
49:03 Wendy Zukerman? And we don't need to reach for... The we don't need to reach for quantum physics or telepathy. We could just reach for our common humanity to explain this.
49:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, which I think we underestimate when we come up with a paranormal explanation. The human mind, the human body, common shared humanity, you know, whatever that is. Like, that is impressive enough to produce a lot of these incredible things that happen between people. And that's good enough for me personally.
49:35 Wendy Zukerman? Do you want to try, all right, we've been working together for a long time. Do you want to try send me, think of an image, think of an image.
49:43 Speaker 01 OK, I'm looking, how about this, I'll look at a painting on my wall.
49:47 Wendy Zukerman? OK.
49:48 Speaker 01 I'm looking at it really hard. Wendy, I want to send this image to Wendy.
49:52 Wendy Zukerman? OK, OK, so the first thing going through my head is what image would Rose have on her wall? But that's not, because then I'm immediately thinking, da, OK, OK. Jellyfish, bird, um, OK, but, all right, what image is, all right, I'm going to close my eyes. I don't have ping pong balls, but I close my eyes. OK, what? Are you thinking about it really hard? I don't think you're thinking about it hard enough, Rose. You're thinking about other things.
50:17 Speaker 01 I'm furrowing my brow.
50:18 Wendy Zukerman? OK, is it, um, is it an ocean view? Um, no, no, no, no, a cat, a cat.
50:24 Speaker 01 No, but you know what's so funny?
50:26 Wendy Zukerman? It's an ocean?
50:28 Speaker 01 No, you mentioned a jellyfish, you mentioned a cat. I do have pictures of both those things in my apartment. I just am not having, that's not the one I'm looking at. I'm looking at a, a, a painting of flowers, poppies.
50:40 Wendy Zukerman? Oh.
50:43 Speaker 01 The cat picture's right here. So if I'd happened to look this way, you would have gotten it right. And we would have been like, well, holy [BLEEP].
50:49 Wendy Zukerman? All right. How many citations in this week's episode?
50:52 Speaker 01 Uh, this week we have 51 citations.
50:53 Wendy Zukerman? 51, and if people want to see them in all of their glory, read more about telepathy. Where should they go?
50:59 Speaker 01 They can click on the link to our transcript. That's where all the citations are, and that link is in the show notes.
51:05 Wendy Zukerman? Excellent, and if anyone wants to send us any curtains and let us try and guess what kind of erotic image is behind them.
51:15 Speaker 01 Did you just ask people to send us dirty pictures?
51:19 Wendy Zukerman? Curtains, Rose. I've asked them to send us pictures of curtains. Pictures of curtains, alright. Find us on Instagram at science underscore VS.
51:32 Wendy Zukerman? You can say hello to me on TikTok. I'm at Wendy Zukerman. Thanks, Rose. Thanks, Wendy.
51:44 Wendy Zukerman? This episode was produced by Rose Rimler with help from me, Wendy Zukerman, along with Akedi Foster Keys, Merrill Horn and Michelle Dang. We're edited by Blythe Terrell. Mix and sound design by Bobby Lord. Fact checking by Erica Akiko Howard. Music written by Peter Leonard, Emma Munga, So Wiley, Bumi Hidaka and Bobby Lord. Thanks to all of the researchers that we spoke to for this episode, including Dr. Zolton Keketj, Professor Stefan Schmidt and Janice Boynton. Special thanks to Enrique Perez, Isabel Lura, Lindsay Chana, Lily Kim and Lauren Silverman. Science Versus is a Spotify Studios original. Listen to us for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. But if you are listening on Spotify, you can follow us and tap the bell icon
52:29 Wendy Zukerman? so you get episode notifications when new episodes come out. And if you like what you're listening to, please give us a five star review because it helps people find the show, which is awesome. I'm Wendy Zukerman. Back to you next time.
52:49 Speaker 13 I used to wonder what I missed any time I stepped out of the shop. But with AT&T Business Wireless, my signal stays strong no matter where the day takes me. Like right now, I'm meeting a photography client
53:02 Speaker 13 out here. But I still have a reliable connection, even though I have no idea where I am right now.
53:09 Speaker 14 Keep your business connected with AT&T Business Wireless. Visit att.com/5gnetwork. When the connection matters, it has to be AT&T.
53:19 Speaker 15 I don't know what I'm doing. Need a break. Forget it, I quit.
53:23 Speaker 16 Escape to Pluto TV.
53:24 Speaker 05 This is objectively fantastic.
53:26 Speaker 16 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free. Shwing! Even our news is uplifting.
53:32 Speaker 07 You stay classy, San Diego.
53:33 Speaker 16 Watch Tommy Boy, Crazy Ex Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more.
53:39 Speaker 15 We're not worthy!
53:41 Speaker 16 The best things on TV really are free.
53:43 Speaker 05 You just have to know where to look.
53:45 Speaker 16 Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now? Pay never.
Previous Fluoride: Is Your Water Safe? Next Measles: How Worried Should We Be? Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated