Skip to content

Why is the misdiagnosis rate for multiple sclerosis so high?

Science Friday

Hosted by Flora Lichtman and Ira Flatow

21m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the surprisingly high misdiagnosis rate for multiple sclerosis, where experts estimate nearly one in five diagnosed individuals do not actually have the condition. A patient named Koda shares how she lived with an MS diagnosis for seven years, enduring immunosuppressant medication and a shift in personal identity, before a new neurologist abruptly told her she never had it. Flora Lichtman speaks with Dr. Maria Houchens, an associate professor of neurology at Harvard Medical School, to examine why these errors occur, looking at the complexity of the disease's biology, the limitations of diagnostic criteria, and the cultural pressures doctors face to provide definitive answers.

  • Patients who suspect their diagnosis or experience unusual symptoms should communicate openly with their physician rather than waiting months for their next scheduled appointment. 19:34
  • Neurologists should always examine actual MRI image scans themselves rather than relying solely on written radiology reports. 19:14
  • Patients questioning their diagnosis following public news stories or personal doubts can seek a second opinion from a specialist. 16:39

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Science Friday Intro & Sponsorships

    Hosts open the show, announce sponsors and introduce the episode’s topic.

  2. 1:09
    Koda’s Car Accident and Initial Symptoms

    Koda recounts the accident that led to unexplained symptoms and a neurologist visit.

  3. 2:35
    Koda’s Diagnosis Journey

    Koda describes the two-year testing process and the emotional impact of receiving an MS diagnosis.

  4. 3:08
    Revelation of Misdiagnosis

    Koda’s new neurologist tells her she does not have MS, sparking denial and anger.

  5. 5:03
    Expert Insight: Dr. Maria Houchens

    Dr. Houchens discusses MS basics, diagnostic criteria, and why misdiagnosis occurs.

  6. 12:13
    Biomarkers and Diagnostic Tools

    The conversation turns to current and future biomarkers, like oligoclonal bands, and their role in diagnosis.

  7. 15:37
    Specialist vs. General Neurologist Care

    The hosts explore the importance of specialist referrals and the potential for reducing misdiagnosis.

  8. 19:34
    Patient Advocacy and Communication

    Dr. Houchens offers practical advice for patients to engage with doctors and seek second opinions.

  9. 20:55
    Closing Remarks and Thank Yous

    Hosts thank guests, recap key points, and sign off the episode.

Highlights

  • 1:14

    A Seven Year Misdiagnosisstory

    After a car accident and years of testing, Koda received an MS diagnosis, only to be told seven years later by a different doctor that she never had it.

  • 3:08

    Abruptly Undiagnosedstory

    A new neurologist bluntly told Koda he did not believe she had multiple sclerosis, stripping away the diagnosis she had structured her life around for years.

  • 5:44

    Biological Basics of MSinsight

    Dr. Maria Houchens explains how MS involves demyelination, where the protective myelin insulation on nerve fibers is stripped away, slowing down neural signal conduction.

  • 9:39

    Cultural Pressure for Certaintyinsight

    Physicians often struggle to admit uncertainty to patients, leading them to commit to a likely diagnosis rather than saying they do not know.

  • 12:06

    Searching for Biomarkersdata

    While spinal fluid analysis uses oligoclonal bands as a biomarker, researchers are still working toward a simple blood test that can conclusively diagnose MS.

  • 17:30

    Risks of Immunosuppressant Drugsinsight

    Treatments for multiple sclerosis carry significant side effects such as unusual infections, making accurate diagnosis critical before starting medication.

  • 18:23

    Reading Radiologist Reportsstrategy

    Radiology reports often list ten different possibilities for an MRI anomaly, requiring neurologists to review the actual image scans themselves.

Quotes

  • “Experts say that nearly 1 in 5 people who are diagnosed with MS are found to not actually have the condition.”
    Flora Lichtman · 1:36
  • “I don't think you have MS.”
    Unnamed speaker · 3:11
  • “I think physicians probably need to be a little bit more forthcoming when they don't know something.”
    Unnamed speaker · 9:44
  • “They can cause damage whether or not you have MS.”
    Unnamed speaker · 17:30
  • “My advice to, to patients would be be very open with your physician.”
    Unnamed speaker · 19:34
  • MathWorks 0:00–0:16
  • Dell 0:16–0:59
  • Planet Visionaries 13:21–14:12
  • Audible 14:03–15:12
  • Alfred P. Sloan Foundation 15:12–15:36

About this episode

An estimated 1 in 5 patients diagnosed with MS are misdiagnosed. Why is that rate so high, and what happens with a diagnosis changes?

Transcript

0:00
21:21

3,563 words · 6 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • MS
  • Harvard Medical School
  • Mass General Brigham Neuroscience Institute
  • spinal fluid analysis
  • MRI
  • multiple sclerosis
  • Jane Goodall Institute
  • oligoclonal bands
  • immunosuppressant medications

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated