Skip to content

What Sociopaths Really Feel | Dr. Patric Gagne

The School of Greatness

Hosted by Lewis Howes

1h 47m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode features a detailed conversation with Dr. Patric Gagne, author of Sociopath: A Memoir, who discusses her diagnosis of sociopathy, the differences between primary and secondary psychopathy, and her path toward radical honesty. The guest and host explore how antisocial traits develop, why lying functioned as a vital safety mechanism during childhood, and how society's misunderstanding of psychopathy creates unnecessary stigma. They examine the nature of emotional containment, why traditional relationship models often rely on dysfunctional codependency, and how true self-awareness allows individuals to drop exhausting masks and build genuine internal security.

  • Dr. Gagne explains that psychopaths do feel inherent human emotions like happiness and sadness, but struggle primarily with social emotions such as empathy and remorse. 5:00
  • True healing begins with self-awareness, allowing individuals to recognize the root causes of their behavior rather than continuously acting out through destructive coping mechanisms. 49:24
  • Dr. Gagne argues that people pleasing is often a form of dysfunctional love where individuals outsource their emotional well-being instead of filling their own internal containers. 1:02:48
  • Setting clear boundaries and modeling healthy apologies are essential tools for teaching children how to develop genuine confidence and personal accountability. 1:10:36

Chapters

  1. 0:01
    Podcast Intro & Sponsor Ads

    The episode opens with a brief introduction and several sponsor advertisements before the main content begins.

  2. 3:20
    The Role of Lies and Self‑Awareness

    The conversation explores how lying became a coping mechanism, the internal conflict it caused, and the eventual decision to stop lying.

  3. 4:35
    Defining Sociopathy and Psychopathy

    The hosts discuss the clinical terminology, explaining that sociopathy and psychopathy are essentially the same, and describe primary vs. secondary psychopathy.

  4. 7:22
    Early Childhood and Emotional Development

    Gagne recounts her childhood experiences, the lack of emotional modeling, and how this shaped her ability to empathize and lie.

  5. 23:50
    Therapeutic Journey and Resocialization

    Gagne describes her path to therapy, the support she received, and how she learned to be a container for others’ emotions while working as a therapist.

  6. 41:05
    Behavioral Patterns and Moral Choices

    The hosts examine Gagne’s past behaviors—stealing, breaking in, and violence—highlighting the tension between impulses and moral reasoning.

  7. 49:24
    Healing, Awareness, and Future Outlook

    The episode concludes with a discussion on the importance of awareness, self‑healing, and the possibility of change for sociopaths and others with trauma.

  8. 51:07
    Defining the Term Sociopath

    The host asks the guest whether he still identifies as a sociopath, leading to a discussion of terminology, diagnosis, and personal history.

  9. 53:05
    Power of Words and Identity

    Exploration of how labeling oneself or others with terms like sociopath or alcoholic shapes identity and can justify harmful behavior.

  10. 57:12
    Coping and Emotional Regulation

    Discussion of how the guest has moved from emotional claustrophobia to honesty, learning to recognize impulses and seek support rather than act on them.

  11. 58:30
    Teaching Kids Emotional Awareness

    The host and guest discuss strategies for parents to help children recognize and process emotions, emphasizing listening, boundaries, and avoiding quick fixes.

  12. 59:44
    People‑Pleasing and Love Dynamics

    The conversation shifts to the concept of people‑pleasing, the difference between neurotypical and sociopathic love, and the dangers of seeking validation through relationships.

  13. 1:04:00
    Community and Empathy in Sociopathy

    The guest explains how finding a community of others with similar traits can reduce isolation and foster empathy, despite the lack of traditional social groups.

  14. 1:05:07
    Sociopaths, Narcissists, and Borderline Traits

    A deep dive into how sociopathy, narcissism, and borderline personality disorder overlap and differ, focusing on motivations, shame, and treatment challenges.

Highlights

  • 5:00

    Understanding Psychopathic Emotional Experiencesinsight

    The guest explains that psychopaths are capable of feeling all inherent emotions, such as sadness and disgust, but struggle specifically with social emotions like empathy and guilt which are typically learned through modeling.

  • 9:25

    Lying as a Safety Mechanismstory

    Dr. Gagne shares that during her childhood, lying about her lack of remorse provided an intense sense of safety and relief from punishment rather than serving a nefarious purpose.

  • 12:17

    Primary Versus Secondary Psychopathydata

    The guest breaks down the distinction between primary psychopathy, which is rare and biological, and secondary psychopathy, which is environmental and entirely treatable through proper intervention.

  • 25:17

    Serving As An Emotional Containerinsight

    The guest explains that because her feelings do not pollute the experience, she makes an excellent container for others in distress, allowing people to process heavy emotions without interference.

  • 49:24

    The Importance of Awarenessstrategy

    Dr. Gagne emphasizes that eighty percent of therapeutic work is simply awareness, noting that lasting personal change requires connecting current behaviors to past trauma.

  • 1:00:45

    The Danger of The Completion Mythinsight

    The guest challenges the cultural narrative of romantic partners completing each other, arguing that needing someone else for self-worth is a form of toxic codependency.

  • 1:47:52

    The Three Final Truthsinsight

    In closing, Dr. Gagne shares her three core truths: that limited access to emotion is not inherently evil, that actions matter more than intentions, and that fulfillment is already available when you stop operating from want.

Quotes

  • “Psychopaths can feel. We feel all of the inherent emotions. So everyone's born with those inherent emotions.”
    Unnamed speaker · 5:00
  • “I was never lying to myself because I always knew that it was a lie.”
    Unnamed speaker · 8:03
  • “The best job for me, because it's like, oh, wow, someone can be sitting in here crying right in front of me.”
    Unnamed speaker · 28:26
  • “I can breathe. Yes. So in that way, I was not only learning to lie, but I was also in internally rewarded for those lies.”
    Unnamed speaker · 9:37
  • “I always say that eighty percent of the work is in awareness. You have to be aware of a problem before you can solve the problem.”
    Unnamed speaker · 49:24
  • “I always will, because that's what I got. That, that was my diagnosis. I understand that that term is no longer used. I understand that it has evolved to be other things.”
    Unnamed speaker · 51:09
  • “Having that really helped. It was an anchor for me. It was like, okay.”
    Unnamed speaker · 53:54
  • “I don't have that claustrophobia anymore because I no longer conceal who I am, how I feel or don't feel.”
    Unnamed speaker · 57:26
  • “You have to know there's a problem.”
    Unnamed speaker · 50:17
  • “I have a soft spot in my heart for sociopath because it's, yeah, I know that word. And I remember in the research, looking at it and saying like, okay, well, this research calls it sociopath.”
    Unnamed speaker · 51:30
  • Stars and Honey 0:16–2:10
  • Indeed Sponsored Jobs 2:10–3:34
  • ChatGPT 2:17–2:52
  • Ring 29:57–31:06
  • Staples 30:52–32:01
  • Staples 55:56–56:47
  • Amica Insurance 56:21–56:47
  • LL Bean 1:29:13–1:29:51
  • US Bank 1:29:52–1:30:27
  • Bumbas 1:55:25–1:56:17
  • Atlantic Union Bank 1:56:18–1:56:46

About this episode

Dr. Patric Gagne, author of Sociopath: A Memoir, is a diagnosed sociopath and therapist who wrote her doctoral dissertation on sociopathy. Limited access to emotion is not inherently evil, and secondary psychopathy can be treated through awareness and re-socialization. Topics include the Psychopathy Checklist, the DSM, primary versus secondary psychopathy, the Society for the Prevention of Disorders of Aggression and The Body Keeps the Score.

Transcript

0:00
1:47:53

21,788 words · 3 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Sociopath
  • Target
  • Sociopath: A Memoir
  • PCL
  • Apple Podcasts
  • Georgetown
  • Society for the Prevention of Disorders of Aggression
  • Sociopath (memoir)
  • The Story of Growing Up Without the Emotions Everyone Expected Her to Feel and Learning to Live with Radical Honesty
  • Alice in Wonderland

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated