Pod Insights Rosebud with Gyles Brandreth More Rosebud - Tariq Ali About this episode Tariq Ali is one of the most famous and recognisable figures of the revolutionary student movements of the 1960s. In his distinctive red Aquascutum mac he led marches, gave speeches and galvanised opposition to the Vietnam War and other big issues of the time. Born in Lahore just before Partition, he grew up in a prominent family of politicians and became interested in radical politics from a young age. At only 16 he organised his first strike, among the latrine-wallahs in the hill station where his family holidayed. At 18 he was sent to Oxford University, where he became president of the Union and impressed people with his brilliance at public speaking and debating. He tells Gyles about all this and about some of the amazing people he met along the way - including Mick Jagger, John Lennon, Marlon Brando and Malcolm X. If you aren't familiar with Tariq Ali's story, this is really worth listening to for a fascinating insight into the radical and optimistic days of the late 60s and early 70s, when anything seemed possible.
Tariq's memoir, You Can't Please All, is out now, published by Verso.
https://www.versobooks.com/en-gb/blogs/authors/ali-tariq?srsltid=AfmBOorNoyy2ZaKtYHa5Zay30ii1E1ieQJ76ERKTHvDgvfIEB9t-zreO
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy https://acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Welcome to 215 Maple Drive. We just put this property on the market.
0:07 Speaker 01 Love the crown molding.
0:08 Speaker 00 Oh, wait until you see the walk-in closets and the bathroom tile.
0:12 Speaker 01 Does it have Verizon FiOS? You know, 100% fiber internet.
0:16 Speaker 00 No FiOS, but it looks like it's got cable. Let's check out the kitchen.
0:19 Speaker 01 No FiOS? Yeah... no thank you.
0:23 Speaker 00 Don't you want to see the rest? Okay, bye-bye.
0:25 Speaker 02 Get Verizon FiOS, because when you're moving, it's 100% or nothing.
0:30 Speaker 03 At Humana, our Medicare Advantage plans are easy to understand and easy on your wallet. They're offering more benefits than you'd get from original Medicare alone. And including dental, vision, and hearing coverage in every plan. And the best part is, every plan has a $0 or low monthly plan premium, which makes it easier to save, too. So this Medicare planning season, plan well with Humana. Learn more at gethumana.com. Humana is a Medicare Advantage HMO and PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
1:02 Speaker 04 I'm Gyles Brandreth, and this is More Rosebud. Cue the music.
1:25 Speaker 04 Welcome to More Rosebud. Regular listeners will know that on a Tuesday, we drop More Rosebud, and it's a bit different for a variety of reasons. One is, you get to hear my producer and friend, Harriet Jane.
1:40 Speaker 05 Hello.
1:41 Speaker 04 It's good that you're here, Harriet. Now, normally, Harriet, you bring me lots of emails and things that you want to talk about. But this week, I've got such, I think such, an interesting guest that I want to give him as much time as we can spare. Now, when I suggested him to you, did you recognize his name?
2:05 Speaker 05 I did, but I... And I knew what he looked like, because he's actually really striking looking, isn't he? Tall and elegant with this amazing white hair. But I didn't know as much about him as I should have, and it was really interesting finding out about him.
2:21 Speaker 04 Well, he was born in October nineteen forty-three, which means he's eighty-two. He was born in Lahore, then the Punjab, British India. And he, when I was a student at Oxford University in the nineteen sixties, he wasn't just famous in Oxford, in the United Kingdom, but literally around the world. He was a student revolutionary. He is called Tariq Ali. And people of my generation, everybody of my generation, will remember that name. And there was a kind of international feeling in the late nineteen sixties that maybe we were in a revolutionary era.
3:04 Speaker 04 On the streets in England, universities, there were people revolting students, but they were happening in other countries as well. I remember nineteen sixty-eight going to Paris. I went to interview the Al-Ghakkan, as it happens, for the University Magazine, but I didn't realise there was a revolution going on in France. And my taxi being taken to see the Al-Ghakkan, it was students, we were going along the left bank, stopped us and were shaking the taxi from side to side. I lowered the window and said, je suis étudiant aussi.
3:37 Speaker 05 Were you frightened?
3:39 Speaker 04 I was a little bit. I'm afraid physical cowardice has been my weak spot throughout my life, so I was a bit of a coward.
3:46 Speaker 05 Well, that does sound, it could be a bit worrying.
3:48 Speaker 04 The person we're going to see here now, I don't think was frightened. He seemed to me to be fearless. I became president of the Oxford Union, the debating society, a few years after him, but we overlapped at Oxford, and I knew him a little bit then. And I found him charming, though a revolutionary. And of course, we were very different because I was a young conservative and he was literally a young revolutionary.
4:17 Speaker 04 He has known, well, let's not muck about, let's press the tape. You happy to hear about him now?
4:23 Speaker 05 Looking forward to it very much.
4:24 Speaker 04 This is a little bit different. It's a trip down memory lane. You may not have heard of this person, but take it from me, he really made such an impact in those days. It was extraordinary.
4:47 Speaker 04 This morning, I was at, this morning, the television programme. And I was telling one of the young researchers about my special guest today. And I was trying to describe him when I first knew him and how famous he was nationally and internationally. And she was getting a bit confused. And then I said, in his own way, he was the Greta Thunberg of his day. And she immediately understood, oh my, oh, how amazing, how exciting. And that's what he was. And I first met Tariq Ali, well, fifty-five years ago. I'm a year or two younger than him. We were both at Oxford University at the time. He was at Exeter College, I was at New College.
5:32 Speaker 04 He had been president of the Oxford Union, the debating society at the university. And I became the president of the Oxford Union. And the last time we met, and Tarek, I will forgive you for not remembering, the last time we met, we had tea in the Oxford Union. And I remember sitting down with you and you ordered anchovy toast. And I thought, this is my kind of a revolutionary. I'm ready to back this revolution. The man enjoys tea and anchovy toast. Do you remember those days? Do you remember the fame of those days?
6:04 Speaker 06 I'm afraid I don't, but I do love anchovy toast. That is true.
6:10 Speaker 04 But do you remember how famous you were at the time?
6:15 Speaker 06 Yeah, I do. It, you know, I'm not allowed to forget it too much because people interview me all the time, students writing PhDs on that period. So it, it never goes away. And yesterday, when Mary Ann Faithfull died, she was a friend, and I got a note actually first from Mick Jagger telling me that she died. So we exchanged words and then more phone calls from France, from here, from there. Could you say a few words about her? And the last time I met Mary Ann was in Toulouse at a book festival. And we had a great talk
6:59 Speaker 06 about the past and how things were so different and how everything had gone. The usual talk elderly people have, how worse things have got. And young people can't even remember now how good they once were, just in the sense of ordinary life, everyday life, living. So, yeah, that period doesn't go away.
7:24 Speaker 04 Well, we're going to explore that period in a few minutes' time, that those extraordinary revolutionary years when we thought the world was changing from 1968 onwards. And you've already mentioned Mick Jagger, Mary Ann Faithfull. I know John Lennon will be on the cast list today. But I want to go right back to the beginning. And I want to ask you, Tariq Ali, what is your very first memory?
7:47 Speaker 06 My first memory is when I was just under four years old. I was in Lahore, a cosmopolitan northern Indian city, which was now about to become Pakistan, when my family servants said, we've got to go out. We're a new country today. And I went on an old family servant's shoulders to a big celebration. I think Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the founder of Pakistan, was passing. And a lot of kids were being brought to wave Pakistan flags and shout,
8:32 Speaker 06 Pakistan Zindabad, long live Pakistan. I used to joke in later years with friends, saying, I think that's the first and last time I ever said that.
8:45 Speaker 04 So here you are on the shoulders of a family retainer waving your Pakistan flag and welcoming the the change that came with partition. You obviously came from a political family and from a well-to-do family. Who who were your grandparents? Start with them.
9:00 Speaker 06 My grandparents, the family of course goes back a very long time and in a very beautiful part of the country, not far from the border with Afghanistan. A nest of villages in a valley with freshwater streams, natural fruit orchards. And the story goes, a family story, that Alexander's army, when it passed through that region.
9:32 Speaker 04 This is Alexander the Great?
9:33 Speaker 06 Yeah. The Greek soldiers he brought with him couldn't find anything to eat except green raw bananas. And Alexander finally banned the eating these in states which later became my family's on the grounds that too many were dying of constipation.
9:57 Speaker 04 Well, there we are. We have we have we have gossip going back to the third century B.C. This is as it should be. So but you're a more immediate family?
10:10 Speaker 06 My more immediate family, both my grandfathers were senior administrators and politicians.
10:21 Speaker 04 Yes, your one of your grandfathers was actually the prime minister of Punjab.
10:25 Speaker 06 My maternal grandfather was Prime Minister of Punjab, elected in nineteen thirty seven. And my paternal grandfather, his first cousin, was in his cabinet as the Minister, Finance Minister. So it's a family that's been involved and engaged in politics for a very long time. And in nineteen forty two, August, my grandfather, whose prime minister, was called for an emergency summit in Cairo with Churchill and Lord Wavell, who went to discuss the future. Singapore had just fallen, the Japanese were on the march, and the British felt that if
11:10 Speaker 06 we lose India, we've had it. And Churchill felt that my grandfather was the only serious politician in the Punjab who he could trust. And so at this summit, the future was discussed. And I think that was the first time my grandfather realized that the subcontinent might be divided. And he was not in favor of it. He had his own plan for India, which was largely a sort of confederal plan. But so that is the family.
11:51 Speaker 06 And we grew up with all these stories from the time of Alexander the Great right down to
11:59 Speaker 04 Can I say, I mean, I thought I was quite a name dropper, but I can't compete with you for a moment. Alexander, from Alexander the Great to Mick Jagger via Winston Churchill. You're not doing badly. So who are your parents, though? We have this great man who is your grandfather. He is, he has children?
12:18 Speaker 06 His first wife died young when he had three children and he married again and had six with her. So it was a family, they used to see a cricket team. Five brothers and five sisters who did go and play cricket matches with rivals
12:42 Speaker 06 My mother was one of them. She was very political from a young age. India was in the thirties, late twenties. Very radicalizing country. Movements were developing for independence. People were on the streets a lot of the time and she, of course, was very protected, but still she went to the school in Lahore for upper class young women and was expelled because she said to the principal, who asked for suggestions at a general assembly, saying, who should we invite as our guest speaker? And my mother, aged sixteen, said Joharul Al-Nairu.
13:30 Speaker 06 Nehru was a cult figure with young people, very good looking, a brilliant speaker, demanding independence, educated at Harrow and Cambridge, very gifted guy.
13:44 Speaker 04 And very attractive. He's the one rumored to have had the romance with Lady Mountbatten.
13:50 Speaker 06 It's more than a rumor.
13:53 Speaker 06 He fell in love with her. The only woman he ever loved in his life was Lady Mountbatten.
13:59 Speaker 04 And she, of course, was the wife of Lord Mountbatten, who was the last viceroy of India and sent there to really oversee the partition when it happened in 1947.
14:08 Speaker 06 Well, let's say that relations were so close that the opposition parties objected and said there's a bias in the Mountbatten family for the Congress because of Nehru's closeness to Lady Mountbatten.
14:25 Speaker 04 And the word Congress was apt as it happened.
14:31 Speaker 04 So your mother is...
14:32 Speaker 06 My mother is okay, says at school at the age of 16, let's invite Jawaharlal Nehru. And Miss Cox, the principal, says, this is a parda school, meaning, you know, girls' heads are covered. It's for girls only. We don't invite men here. So my mother, instead of sort of backing down, says, really? But we had Ramgopal, the dancer, dancing in front of us quite suggestively. All Nehru is going to do is to speak.
15:09 Speaker 06 So the head asked her to apologize. She refused. Her father was informed that, you know, could you take your daughter back? She's a disruptive influence. And so the Prime Minister's car arrived with maid and chauffeur in tow and packed her clothes and she went home. And that was that. Not even the Prime Minister of the province could order a school principal to take his child back. Um. So that's what happened. She then fell in love with my father, who was also her second cousin, was a communist.
15:52 Speaker 04 How how come he was a communist?
15:54 Speaker 06 He went to college and there was a very large Communist Party Students' Federation, very active in the movement for independence. He was, you know, he was very studious and a sort of quite a character in many ways, the backstroke champion of India, selected for the thirty six Olympics in Berlin, dreaming that if by some chance he won the gold medal and Hitler or Göring or one of these rogues giving the gold medal award, he would kill them. He said, I really did think that.
16:30 Speaker 04 His view would have been very different, wouldn't it? My goodness.
16:34 Speaker 06 Uh, mercifully, mercifully, the Indian team, swimming team had to be dumped because they were so bad that they they leave alone winning a gold medal, they had to be chopped for financial reasons.
16:51 Speaker 04 Can I say that, of course, we wouldn't have had you, which would have been a shame, but if he had managed to kill Hitler, I mean, that really would have been an achievement. I think, I mean, not that we're in favor of this sort of thing.
17:03 Speaker 06 No, but you know, sometimes. But nonetheless, I think we have to. These things can make a difference. And, uh, of course, he wouldn't have survived, so I wouldn't have been.
17:12 Speaker 04 No, exactly.
17:13 Speaker 06 Yeah, so I used to, when he used to tell me these stories, I said, but aren't you pleased that none of this happened, except in your fantasies? Because we wouldn't be here. And he said, sometimes one has to make sacrifices for the greater good. And it would have been much better.
17:32 Speaker 04 And did he earn his living as a journalist? Well, how did he earn his living?
17:37 Speaker 06 Pakistan was in a new state and a bunch of leftists got together and said a new state needs new newspapers. So a whole group of them, you know, with the approval of Jinnah and the government, set up a chain of newspapers which educated a whole generation. An English Daily, an Urdu Daily, and a cultural weekly, the Progressive Papers Limited. My father was editor of the Pakistan Times.
18:06 Speaker 04 Well, these are clearly remarkable people, your parents. How did they get on with each other? Did the the love that they had when they were young and first met, that last?
18:14 Speaker 06 Yeah, they fell in love. When my mother came back from expelled from school, they began to meet secretly and decided they wanted to marry each other. My grandfather said that he did not want his daughter to marry a communist.
18:33 Speaker 04 Hmm.
18:34 Speaker 06 Now, this created huge tensions because the first time that someone had put politics above class
18:43 Speaker 06 in this large family outfit. And they, I mean, it's, they kept meeting secretly. They eloped, they got married secretly. And my grandfather wasn't having it. Dramatic scene, he arrived with all the full prime ministerial regalia, armed men, jeeps, to take her back, saying, my daughter's been kidnapped. It was a big brouhaha, as you can imagine, and the talk of the town. I mean, this is what's going on. And the family then said to him, you really can't behave like this. The kids love each other. It's rare enough in this world.
19:28 Speaker 06 You know, normally we just marry them off. They like each other. Let them do it. What's your problem? If he's a communist, well, it won't last. You know, these were very people who knew the world. And it's, we don't understand you. And then another of his cousins, my grandfather's cousin, said, look, set some conditions. So my father was summoned and told that
19:56 Speaker 06 I'll let you marry her. The Second World War was going on. Provided you join the British Army and go and fight. So the wedding pictures of my parents are my father looking very jaunty in military uniform as he prepares.
20:13 Speaker 04 In a British Indian army.
20:14 Speaker 06 In a British Indian uniform. To go and fight in Monte Cassino in Italy. That's where he fought.
20:22 Speaker 04 Ah. Alongside my father was Monte Cassino, absolutely. One of the big battles of the Second World War.
20:28 Speaker 06 Yeah.
20:38 Speaker 03 Network freedom and flexibility. That's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to build Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
21:11 Speaker 04 So, obviously, they had a comfortable life because of the money that was in the family. Were you conscious as a little boy, you were being comfortably brought up, that there was great poverty in your part of the world? How did you become aware of that?
21:26 Speaker 06 I was not only aware of it, I was made conscious of it by my parents. There were two types of people who came to our house, family, family, friends, but also trade union leaders, peasant leaders, radical poets, et cetera. So of these two sort of groups of people, I gravitated towards the latter because they were more interesting, had more fun things to say, didn't respect authority, made fun of everyone, made us laugh a lot as kids. It was from them that I learned what the state of the world was really like. My mother did a lot of work with working class women, teaching them hygiene, how to
22:11 Speaker 06 keep homes clean, taking medicines. I used to go with her from a very young age, seven or eight. So I knew how other people lived, and that radicalized me. And then the... Summer months, we used to go into the mountains and the sort of foothill of the Himalayas. And in those days, of course, there was not a sewage system. You had sweepers and cleaners who came and cleaned the toilets. This was a hill station, which was, you know, where lots of families of senior civil servants and military officers came.
22:51 Speaker 06 All the people who worked cleaning the toilets happened to be Christians. One day, a guy I was talking to who cleaned our bathroom, I was talking to him and he was looking very sad and upset. I said, "What's the matter?" They said, "Look at them. We do the same work as other people of our grade in the lower echelons of the government departments. They've given wage rises to the same group of people continuously every three years, and that's fine, but not us." I said, "Why not you?" So he said, "Because we're Christians." I said, "Don't be ridiculous."
23:35 Speaker 06 He said, "I'm telling you, sir." So I said, "Who was your main leader? Bring him along." I thought about sixteen or seventeen. And the guy came, "Hi, Saddam." "Saddam," I said, "What's the matter?" He said, "It's true." So I said, "You're in a very strong position." He said, "What?" I said, "Go on strike." He said, "What?" I said, "Go on strike. Don't clean the toilets of the rich. Let the thunderboxes fill up with their excrement. And I promise you, within forty-eight hours, they'll be on their knees." He said, "I don't have the nerve to do it."
24:19 Speaker 06 So I said, "Bring your other people along." So they came, and I convinced them to do it. And we issued a little leaflet in English to the people living there, saying, "You know, these poor guys are not being given their due wages because they say they are Christians."
24:40 Speaker 06 And they're going on strike. And they went on strike and they said, but your house we will clean. I said, you will not. You will not clean any house for forty eight hours. It didn't take that long. Within twenty four hours, senior civil servant rang up some junior and said, what's going on? And they got their pay rises. So that was my first and only successful strike.
25:10 Speaker 04 You should have quit then, and you were about sixteen. What sort of school were you at?
25:15 Speaker 06 I was actually, my father didn't send me to the school where all my cousins went, which was a school that was once called Chiefs College, for the son and children of chiefs and the nobility. But my father said, I don't want you to constantly mingle with the same world. So he sent me to a Catholic school, run by Irish brothers called Saint Anthony's School, which had its merits, but also more than a few d merits. They beat us up quite a lot.
25:56 Speaker 04 Who's your first best friend at the school?
25:58 Speaker 06 I had two. There are three of us used to hang out together. One was Salman Tahir, who later became governor of West Pakistan, and demanded that a woman arrested for blasphemy was released. She was accused of, you know, having burnt the Quran. Complete nonsense. Some bunch of embassies wanted to steal her family's land, and blasphemy is the easiest way. So Salman defended her and his own bodyguard shot him dead. I did get a shock. We hadn't remained friends.
26:39 Speaker 06 I mean, occasionally we'd run into each other when he is sort of becoming a politician and a businessman. And I said to him, why did you become a politician? Just stay a businessman. He said, no, I can be an honest politician because I won't have to bribe myself.
27:03 Speaker 04 Who was your other best friend at school?
27:06 Speaker 06 My, my other best friend was Shahid Rahman, whose father was a justice of the Supreme Court. And we all used to hang around together, chase girls together. One day, the Americans had done something quite atrocious globally. My parents were abroad and these guys were staying with, at my house. And I said, let's go and paint Yankee Go Home on the bridge in the military cantonment.
27:40 Speaker 06 Nothing better to do than.
27:41 Speaker 04 Did you do that?
27:43 Speaker 06 We did do that.
27:44 Speaker 04 Wonderful. You mentioned girls and chasing girls. Was that, is that allowed? Was that?
27:49 Speaker 06 Of course it's allowed. I mean, you know, it's. All these countries today which claim to be ultra-religious, all these things happen. And when I was young and, you know, teenager or college students, there was not the sort of religious atmosphere that came into being after General Zia. This was Buddha's years, but there were no restrictions. I mean, there were, but no more than you'd find here with mothers and saying, who are you going out with? Why are you going? You know, I'd sometimes tell my own children that when I was growing up, of course, the only instrument of communication we had was the pen and paper to write letters,
28:32 Speaker 06 which we sent to sort of fake addresses where they were picked up. The telephone was difficult because, you know, it was a house telephone. So we could only use the phone to call girlfriends or vice versa. And it happened that both our parents were away. So that couldn't be too, wasn't too frequent.
28:54 Speaker 04 Do you remember your, you remember your first kiss?
28:57 Speaker 06 Yeah, I remember my first kiss. It was on a side street in Lahore and she'd nipped out of her house. Uh, just for the first kiss and it was all very exciting and nice. But there were not too many of those because she was married off pretty soon.
29:15 Speaker 04 Oh, frustrating.
29:17 Speaker 06 Hmm.
29:17 Speaker 04 But I love the idea of you writing little love notes and then having to hide them in different sort of places.
29:22 Speaker 06 We either sent them to a common friend. It was sort of organized, we'd get addresses and write to you, sometimes directly. I used to get letters from girlfriends directly. And one day I came home from school for lunch. And my mother was in a tiny bit of a state. I said, what's happened? She said, that last girl who wrote you a really stupid letter. I said, why are you reading my post? These mothers we had may be very progressive on many levels. My mother certainly was. But she still insisted, without telling me, on eavesdropping on my mind what was going on.
30:06 Speaker 06 What was I thinking? Nervousness that I would be trapped into something I didn't want. I said, that'll never happen.
30:15 Speaker 04 So how did you come to go to Oxford? Was it assumed that a British oriented family like yours, well educated in Pakistan, would go to a British university? And was Oxford the obvious one?
30:30 Speaker 06 No, it wasn't obvious at all because I didn't want to come. I was very active politically. And one day my maternal uncle, who was a Brigadier in military intelligence, made sure that I wasn't at home and walked into our house and said to my parents, this is how big the phylon him is, holding his two hands from a distance, at a distance from each other, and he's only eighteen. I won't be able to keep him out of prison. Some of the stuff he's been doing is quite serious.
31:07 Speaker 04 And what was this beyond that initial strike? What were you doing when you were still in Pakistan, when you were sixteen, seventeen, eighteen?
31:14 Speaker 06 You know, martial law was on place, the military ruled. No public meetings, no demonstrations, no politics.
31:25 Speaker 06 And when Patrice Lumumba, the first leader of independent Congo, was murdered by the CIA in Kinshasa, this is nineteen sixty-one, I think. And I read it in the papers, Patrice Lumumba murdered. Of course, most people in my college had no idea who Patrice Lumumba was. But I did, so I called a meeting at the college. And about four, five hundred kids turned up. And I spoke and I said, look, this is a newly independent African country. The guy has barely been in power a few months and elected.
32:10 Speaker 06 Unlike in our country, he's elected. And we can't just be quiet about this. People said, would you? I said, I suggest we break the law. March out into the streets to the American consulate and protest. And one guy, I remember, can still see his slightly scared face, but that. Are you sure it was the Americans? I said, oh, yes, I'd place a bet on that. But you don't have evidence. So I said, the evidence will emerge. Do not doubt me on this. So we did that. And we were so amazed that we hadn't been stopped. People were so surprised that we'd done this.
32:54 Speaker 06 The police didn't know we were doing it, nobody knew. And on the way back, we got so carried away by our own sort of bravery that a few of us started raising slogans saying we want democracy in Pakistan. Elections now, and that anchored them. And that, it was after that event that my uncle called and said, time to get him out.
33:24 Speaker 04 So you applied for Oxford, you got in.
33:28 Speaker 06 Yeah.
33:28 Speaker 04 You arrived and you became this public figure quite quickly. Because by the time I arrived, towards the end of the sixties, you were a household name. So you brought your revolutionary zeal to Oxford. And what were the causes there that you espoused?
33:50 Speaker 06 The Vietnam War.
33:52 Speaker 04 Ah.
33:53 Speaker 06 I honestly couldn't think about anything else. I was so horrified by what was happening to that country. At that time, the images were coming thick and strong from Vietnam on American television and British television. The Senate Foreign Relations Committee in DC consisted of some very courageous senators, difficult to imagine today, but they existed. William Fulbright in particular. And every day during the hearings of this committee, he would lambaste public officials. Robert McNamara testifying, you know, Fulbright going for him. I mean, don't want lies told here, truth.
34:38 Speaker 06 So we were quite radicalized by all that, and later that night, the BBC would repeat these shows.
34:45 Speaker 04 So you took to the streets and you joined people at the time, also, it was the ban the bomb era as well. There were people like Cameron Collins, Vanessa Redgrave, all of that was going on?
34:57 Speaker 06 Yeah. Yeah, that was, it was the tail end of the campaign for nuclear disarmament. And we set up the Vietnam Solidarity Campaign, which soon won over many, many young people all over the country. So I found myself in the strange position of having visited more English and Scottish and Welsh towns than most of my contemporaries, because I was going and speaking at meetings and in different towns. So I got to know all the towns, Birmingham, Glasgow, Manchester, Cardiff. I, I, I went to speak at meetings to mobilize people to come and march against the war
35:42 Speaker 06 in Vietnam.
35:43 Speaker 04 And what was your hope that you would achieve?
35:45 Speaker 06 Our hope was that we would actually create a movement worldwide that would make it very difficult for the United States to continue. And that was the aim. And when the United States erupted...
36:04 Speaker 06 An American young people came out in force. We knew we were going to win this one. Because there was conscription in the United States, every family was affected by the war. So even totally apolitical families from different class backgrounds, sitting at breakfast, reading the papers, see what's going on in Vietnam because their son had been conscripted. That was a very deep radicalizing force, the involvement of families in the war because their kids were out there. And so when the movement erupted in the United States at its peak,
36:48 Speaker 06 I think it was 1971 that the GIs who had fought in Vietnam and been wounded, won medals, cripples, some without arms, some without legs, called the GIs Against the War demonstration outside the Pentagon. Tens of thousands of soldiers, ex-soldiers, current soldiers, marched out in front of the Pentagon, which is amazing in itself. One of their chants was, "Ho, ho, ho, Chi men! The Vietnamese are going to win." The general sitting inside
37:32 Speaker 06 knew this was trouble because their army was getting infected. And that put big pressure on them to think about ways out.
37:51 Speaker 00 Welcome to 215 Maple Drive. We just put this property on the market.
37:57 Speaker 01 Love the crown molding.
37:59 Speaker 00 Oh, wait until you see the walk-in closets and the bathroom tile.
38:03 Speaker 01 Does it have Verizon FiOS? You know, 100% fiber internet.
38:07 Speaker 00 No FiOS, but it looks like it's got cable. Let's check out the kitchen.
38:10 Speaker 01 No FiOS? Yeah, no thank you.
38:13 Speaker 00 Don't you want to see the rest? Okay, bye-bye.
38:16 Speaker 02 Get Verizon FiOS because when you're moving, it's 100% or nothing.
38:21 Speaker 03 Network freedom and flexibility. That's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals. No kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to bill Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
38:54 Speaker 04 And you were meeting interesting people at this time, weren't you? Because though you were only in your early twenties, you were coming across older people who were also joining the cause. I mean, who are the people you remember from that time?
39:06 Speaker 06 There was one debate my last year at Oxford. It was the first televised cable transatlantic event. And so the CBS, the American network, rang and said, "We want an Oxford versus Harvard debate on the Vietnam War. We want you to lead the Oxford team. Could you recommend a contemporary and an older member of the university?" So I recommended a colleague of mine, Stephen Marks, very, very good debater. And for the older member, I chose Michael Foot.
39:48 Speaker 06 They had two undergraduates and an obscure, slightly incomprehensible young academic called Henry Kissinger.
40:05 Speaker 06 And so we hadn't heard of Kissinger. And that was my first encounter. I don't, you know, want to boast too much, but even Niall Ferguson said that we had the better of the debate. Basically, we smashed Kissinger's arguments into the ground. And the American press reviews of this event were by and large saying the Oxford team had it. You know, this young mustachioed Pakistani guy.
40:39 Speaker 06 Were really laid into kissing. So I had for the first time in my life fan mail arriving at Oxford from the United States. Thousands and thousands of letters, literally. So my friends and my girlfriend, we all opened them and have a look and I wish I'd kept them all, but we never did. That was on the, you know, meeting a person we regarded as a baddie. It's on the good side, the most interesting person was Marlon Brando.
41:13 Speaker 04 Oh.
41:14 Speaker 06 I got a phone call at the Oxford Union. I still remember her name. Uh, and the, the, uh, Leslie Croft, who was the steward of the.
41:26 Speaker 04 I remember the steward, I remember Leslie Croft, yes, of course I do.
41:28 Speaker 06 He said, Miss Rowley, there's an American lady on the phone for you. She says she's Marlon Brando's secretary. I thought it was a friend pulling my leg, you know, so I said, okay, hi, I'm so and so. She said, oh, hi, I'm Manuela Sanchez, Marlon Brando's secretary. I said, Paul, the other one, she said, excuse me?
41:53 Speaker 06 I said, which of my friends has put you up to do this?
42:00 Speaker 06 She said, Miss Rowley, I promise you, I put the phone down, she rang again.
42:05 Speaker 04 No.
42:06 Speaker 06 She said, don't put the phone down. I said, okay, hang on, and Brando took the phone.
42:14 Speaker 04 Good grief.
42:15 Speaker 06 And said, hi, it's Marlon Brando. I said, I thought this was a joke, he burst out laughing. He said, no, no, I want to invite you to dinner, I'm filming. And I'm staying at a house in Chelsea, Manuela will send you the details. Come and have dinner with me, I saw you on that television debate where you hammered the Harvard kids uh, out of their skulls and I just want to meet you. So I said, okay. When I told my friends, they said, are you kidding us? I said, I'm not kidding you unless it's a joke on a very huge level, someone's playing on me. So. I went along to Brenda's house and who did I meet there?
42:59 Speaker 06 The Tynans, Ken Tyne, the great theatre critic at The Observer, Eleanor Braun, who was on a satirical show with with others. And, wait for this, Giles. Suddenly, just before dinner, there were about ten guests. Ursula Andrus walked in.
43:26 Speaker 06 Well, we were young and polite, but it's very difficult to keep one's eyes off her. Especially as she'd just been in that James Bond movie.
43:38 Speaker 04 Emerging from the.
43:39 Speaker 06 Emerging from the waves like a sort of modern Venus.
43:47 Speaker 06 So she was introduced and everyone tried not to look. Hi, hi. And, you know, after supper, there was dancing, et cetera. And Brenda took her by the waist and danced half the night away. Then he said to me, how are you getting back to Oxford? So I said, well, I don't know. So he said, why don't you stay here? We can talk some more over breakfast.
44:15 Speaker 06 So Kentine stepped in very neatly and said, Tarek, come and stay with Cathy and me. He, I don't know why, he said, I thought you'd be embarrassed. I said, no, fine. So I stayed, spent the night at Ken and Cathy Tannen's house and they became dear friends. So it was like networking on a rather strange level that had started with that debate, which is why I told you about debating the Oxford Harvard debate on Vietnam.
44:51 Speaker 04 I I seem to remember when you were president, one of the guests you had was Malcolm X. If I misremembered that?
44:58 Speaker 06 No.
44:59 Speaker 04 And how did you get hold of him? And who was he at the time? I mean, he was, again, world famous.
45:04 Speaker 06 Malcolm X at the time was a, you know, very impressive black leader. And.
45:13 Speaker 06 We talked, he came up to me first because my name was Tariq Ali. And Malcolm did, when he arrived at the Union, gave me a hug and said, "Muslim brother." I said, "I am a Muslim by birth, Malcolm, but to dispel any illusions, I am a socialist and an atheist." He said, "I've just returned from the Arab world and so many people have said that to me." I said, "You know, when you live in a Muslim country, the last thing you think about is what your religion is." And I said, "Obviously, in the States, for you and your generation, becoming Muslims are an act of defiance."
45:56 Speaker 06 He said, "You can say that again. I became a Muslim and I got talking to blacks in prison." And we did it because we had got better food if we'd said we're Muslims.
46:09 Speaker 06 So we chatted away, and then I met him again that night.
46:15 Speaker 06 I remember thinking to myself at the time, "Either this is a very great man, or he's a hustler."
46:27 Speaker 06 But he turned out to be a very great figure in American consciousness. And when we were leaving, I said, "Bye, Malcolm, I've got to rush." I said, "I hope we meet up again very soon," and he shook his head. He said, "I don't think we will." I said, "Why?"
46:47 Speaker 06 He said, "I think they'll kill me before that." I said, "Who will kill you?" He said, "Either the US government or the state, or my black Muslim, ex-black Muslim brethren, who I've broken with now." Because he was moving more and more away from a very crude black nationalism. At the Oxford Union speech he made, he came out for the first time and said, "I am in favor of blacks uniting with whites. I am in favor of blacks and whites intermarrying." Things which surprised many of his followers.
47:29 Speaker 06 I remember coming back home and saying to my girlfriend, you know, I can't believe that this will happen. He was probably exaggerating a bit. This was in October, November. The following February, I picked up my guardian on Frontpage, Malcolm X assassinated. A number of us went into the pub that afternoon and just wept, you know, saying, how come? And the whole of Oxford did mean he'd got a standing ovation at the Union.
48:01 Speaker 04 Were you ever frightened yourself? Because people will find it hard to believe now, how famous you were and how, to some, you were a hate figure because you were, you were trying to, well, encourage revolution. And it was a time when people were very fearful. I remember 1968 going to France, and there were, there was real fear that the French Republic was going to be overturned. And so you were seen as a leader of all this. Did you feel fearful for yourself ever?
48:30 Speaker 06 I never was. I mean, I'd received a lot of death threats, all the time, and some of these were published in the Daily Mail. To be honest, you know, one was so young then, Charles, and I never took them so seriously. And I remember my way of thinking was, if someone is going to bump me off, they're not going to announce it in a letter.
48:56 Speaker 04 Yes. Talking of people being assassinated, one of your friends was John Lennon. How did you come to meet people like John Lennon? You mentioned earlier Mick Jagger. Was it the same sort of period because you had this?
49:08 Speaker 06 Well, we were from the same generation. They were, you know, ultra-famous rock stars, but they were very involved in opposing the Vietnam War.
49:20 Speaker 04 So that's how you met John?
49:21 Speaker 06 That's how-
49:22 Speaker 04 Was he with Yoko at that time? Was that his-
49:24 Speaker 06 He had just got together with Yoko a year before. And he rang me up. Said, "Hi, it's John Lennon. Here, we are arguing in your magazine about whether Revolution One and Two were good records and your music correspondents attacking me. So I thought I'd ring you. Why don't you come and have lunch? Let's talk." So we became friends and I was one of the few people who said, "John, don't move to the States." He said, "Why?" And I said, "There are too many kooks in that country, John. It would just take a kook, not a conspiracy, for some imbecile to think, 'Why don't I have a go at this guy?'"
50:10 Speaker 06 And he said, "But Tariq, I'm going to be living in the heart of Manhattan. Who the hell is going to come there?"
50:23 Speaker 06 I said, "Well..." Anyway, he said, "Yoko can't stand it here anymore. The tabloids are attacking her non-stop, sort of anti-Japanese racism and just they're so crude. And she says, 'This is a piddling little island anyway. Why don't we go to somewhere bigger?'" I said, "No, I understand that. It's just that where you're going makes me nervous." And there were two attempts on lives that day. An assassin tried to knock off President Reagan. And another, you know, in New York, tried to knock off John. We always used to say, "They got the wrong man."
51:04 Speaker 06 You know-
51:05 Speaker 04 Are you still in touch?
51:06 Speaker 06 It was very upsetting, actually. Going into London shops and every shop, playing Imagine.
51:13 Speaker 04 Are you still in touch with Yoko?
51:16 Speaker 06 We exchange emails and I haven't seen her because she invites me to these huge events she does, or she used to, and I never show up. And the reason I don't show up is it costs a hell of a lot to fly to wherever she's having an event, nor do I ask for a ticket, but you know, we remained.
51:40 Speaker 04 Now, explain to me why you didn't eventually become the president of Pakistan, or indeed the leader of a political party in this country. I recall my last encounter with you, when we were in the Oxford Union, having the anchovy toast together. I thought, because I didn't really know you very well, but I thought this is, this is a revolutionary, the reason he's so successful, he's so articulate, but the reason I like him is he's so charming and so self-deprecating. I thought, he's just going to go there. And later, of course, we both knew Benazir Bhutto, who did return to Pakistan and did become president.
52:20 Speaker 04 Why did your, that, those five or six or seven years, when you really were everywhere, and you knew all these people, you had the great golden gift, you were so articulate, why did that, was it a matter of choice, or what happened that you didn't actually have a political career?
52:38 Speaker 06 I did go back to Pakistan during the big uprising in sixty-eight, sixty-nine, but they kept me on a very tight leash, and my parents were very worried. My father said to me very bluntly, you can stay, we'd love that, but just look at what's going on. And, you know, they won't even need to do it legally, they can just say, you're an atheist and some idiot can come and shoot you in the head and blame it onto a religious fanatic. It's up to you. So I said, well, it is tempting, because I was being, you know, this was when Benazir's
53:21 Speaker 06 father was campaigning as well, and I knew him, and he'd say, join my party.
53:29 Speaker 06 And you know, we'll win, we're going to win, and I need a foreign minister, and you're the perfect person to go and take these Westerners on, you know them so well. I was quite tempted at that time, you know, I didn't have any kids or any, no responsibilities. But my parents, my father in particular was quite nervous, and my mother, she said, we want you to stay alive, you're not going to be able to do too much here anyway. I said, it's very unlike both of you, very political people. She said, we know. And I didn't have sort of any sort of ambitions to be a head of state. I didn't see how I
54:12 Speaker 06 could be. But it's funny you say that about Britain, because once I was debating, many years later, Douglas Hogg at the Oxford Union, and he's a government minister.
54:24 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
54:25 Speaker 06 And he said, have you got transport back to London? I said, no. He said, I didn't think you had. Can I give you a lift in a ministerial limo? I said, you may. So he, we travelled back to London together and were chatting, and Douglas said, tell me something, why didn't you just join the Labour Party? You'd have been, you know, completely, he said, when I listen to the people on the Labour front bench, I often think of you and say, God, why did, I said, they wouldn't let me in.
55:03 Speaker 04 Ah.
55:04 Speaker 06 Which is true. So he said, oh, well, that answers that one. So it just happened like that, and quite honestly, Giles, I wasn't that interested in being a political figure as such, you know, who just sort of wandered around pontificating and couldn't really do anything.
55:25 Speaker 04 We're coming towards the end of our conversation. What is your first recollection of joy in your life? A moment of sheer bliss, happiness?
55:47 Speaker 06 I think, uh.
55:53 Speaker 06 Oh.
55:57 Speaker 06 I think the happiest day for me was April nineteen seventy five. The Vietnamese entered Saigon. The US left and the Vietnamese flag went up on the US embassy. And James Fenton, the poet who was there, said to me later, I did think, Tarek, you'd have enjoyed it. I entered Saigon on a Vietnamese tank. I said, yeah, lucky you.
56:32 Speaker 04 Because he was a contemporary of ours as well.
56:34 Speaker 06 Yeah.
56:35 Speaker 04 You went to Vietnam though, didn't you?
56:37 Speaker 06 Yeah, I did.
56:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
56:38 Speaker 06 That was, I went to Vietnam in sixty six, sixty seven. Uh, you know, and lived there for six weeks and seeing children being butchered by the bombs and buildings being destroyed. I was reminded of that with the Gaza business. I'd seen it before, you know, and I couldn't bear it. And the Vietnamese said to me, you know something? It's awful, but you do get used to it. So please remain calm, don't get too upset.
57:14 Speaker 04 Do you feel nostalgic for the sixties? Do you think the world's a better place now, sixty years on?
57:19 Speaker 06 No.
57:20 Speaker 04 No.
57:22 Speaker 06 And honestly, when I hear children and grandchildren talking about the world they live in, I mean, so much has gone. You know, we wanted to change that world for the better. But the world we got instead, the generations that came after us, saw all the achievements that had been made. The consensus of 1945, you need a health service. You need people, less well-off people, to be looked after. You need income taxes. You have to have a protected sphere in society
58:06 Speaker 06 that is available to everyone, not just the wealthy. All that way of thinking has virtually disappeared. So that, you know, I hear children, some of my grandchildren, saying, "Wonder how long the NHS is going to be."
58:24 Speaker 04 What finally is the lesson you have learnt? What will you share? Extraordinary life you've led, amazing people you've met. What do you want to say? What do you want to share with your grandchildren? And the now people who are hearing you today?
58:41 Speaker 06 I always tell my grandchildren not to be cowed by anyone and to tell the truth. Just live a decent life. I said, you know, more than that, I can't say because God knows what's going to happen to this world. But as long as you're not ashamed of anything you do, I'll be very happy.
59:12 Speaker 04 I've been very happy to have your company. Thank you very much, Tariq Ali. And I hope, we're speaking at the Grosvenor House Hotel, I hope they can rustle up some anchovy toast for us because it is 55 years since we last shared it.
59:29 Speaker 04 Harriet has just taken Tariq Ali downstairs here at Groovenow. As it turned out, there wasn't any anchovies today, but they did say if we gave them sufficient warning, they would certainly get some ready for us. I have to say, not having seen him literally in fifty five, fifty six years, I was charmed by him. How did you feel, Harriet?
59:53 Speaker 05 Oh, yeah, I really enjoyed meeting him. Yeah, as I said to you, I didn't really know what to expect, but I tell you what I loved about him, which I didn't know, was his giggle and how much he laughed and made me laugh. I kept catching his eye while he was telling some of those stories and they were genuinely funny and I wasn't expecting it to be funny.
1:00:15 Speaker 04 I'm going to get his book now. You know, he mentioned his book a couple of times. It's called You Can't Please All: Memoirs nineteen eighty to twenty twenty three, and it's published by Verso because, my gosh, he tells a good story, doesn't he?
1:00:30 Speaker 05 Hmm, amazing, amazing people that he's met.
1:00:33 Speaker 04 Yeah. Who and when you were at Oxford, when were you at Oxford? What decade was it?
1:00:37 Speaker 05 Early nineties.
1:00:38 Speaker 04 Early nineties. Any of the figures of your day who stand out then, who are stand out still?
1:00:43 Speaker 05 Well, one of them's been on the podcast, Rory Stewart.
1:00:46 Speaker 04 Oh, of course.
1:00:47 Speaker 05 Mm hmm. In fact, my college, so the college I went to, Boris Johnson had been there.
1:00:55 Speaker 04 Dalio College, yes.
1:00:57 Speaker 05 So it's been, it's responsible for a few people, but now it seems mainly responsible for podcasters because it's, yeah, Rory Stewart and then one of the hosts of The Rest is History, Dominic Sandbrook, was there as well.
1:01:13 Speaker 04 And we've had, we had his fellow host as a guest, didn't we?
1:01:16 Speaker 05 Tom Holland.
1:01:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, he was interesting.
1:01:18 Speaker 05 Hmm.
1:01:19 Speaker 04 And actually, funnily enough, somebody the other day said, I listened to Boris Johnson on your podcast, don't like Boris Johnson, but actually he did say some things I hadn't heard before. So, that's it. If you want the odd surprise, come to Rosebud. Twice a week, and we love having your company. Thanks for being with us.
1:01:38 Speaker 00 Thanks.
1:02:24 Speaker 04 That was more Rosebud with music by Phil Leopard, production by Harriet Jane, and in the chair, me, Giles Brandwood. Thank you for listening.
1:02:38 Speaker 00 Welcome to 215 Maple Drive. We just put this property on the market.
1:02:44 Speaker 01 Love the crown molding.
1:02:45 Speaker 00 Oh, wait until you see the walk-in closets and the bathroom tile.
1:02:49 Speaker 01 Does it have Verizon FiOS? You know, 100% fiber internet?
1:02:53 Speaker 00 No FiOS, but it looks like it's got cable. Let's check out the kitchen.
1:02:56 Speaker 01 No FiOS? Yeah, no, thank you.
1:03:00 Speaker 00 Don't you want to see the rest? Okay, bye-bye.
1:03:03 Speaker 02 Get Verizon FiOS, because when you're moving, it's 100% or nothing.
1:03:07 Speaker 03 Network freedom and flexibility, that's what you want in a healthcare plan. With a Humana Medicare Advantage PPO plan, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, including specialists. No referrals, no kidding. Learn more at gethumana.com. See any doctor who accepts Medicare and is willing to build Humana. Humana PPOs may not be available in all areas. Benefits and costs share may vary. Humana is a Medicare Advantage PPO organization with a Medicare contract. Enrollment in any Humana plan depends on contract renewal.
Previous Sir James Dyson Next Sigourney Weaver Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated