Pod Insights Revisionist History Welcoming Heavyweight About this episode We are thrilled to welcome the acclaimed narrative series Heavyweight to the Pushkin network. In each episode Jonathan Goldstein sets out to help someone confront their past and heal old wounds. Today we’re sharing their very first episode, “Buzz.”
And because we couldn’t only pick one segment to share, here’s a list of the Revisionist History team’s favorite episodes:
#2 Gregor https://open.spotify.com/episode/6LKrLVEAY3tsqHPURec6ke?si=3c9b2a6343374293
#33 Bobby https://open.spotify.com/episode/2YjgiZpS7tioIlL4y8QAA8?si=ed1b15bc3b6c4b8f
#46 Dan https://open.spotify.com/episode/5XByGT2bdEpqBYiP8h3Mfc?si=ff291046703c46a0
#52 Lenny https://open.spotify.com/episode/37LqKifjaPlVCtFT3lIPOT?si=5ebe4b3ed1234e00
#40 Barbara https://open.spotify.com/episode/2BZrL9n11cbetRKfpSuAC9?si=58d791cf4c394c66
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 7,046 words · 10 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:09 Speaker 00 This is Jacob Goldstein. When you're a business owner interested in expanding to new markets, there's a lot to consider and countless questions to answer before making the call. The most important one being, are you ready? That's where ChatGPT comes in. Give it a goal, add your files, and ask Chat to help you map out different scenarios for the future of your business. So when growth is on the table, you've got an expansion plan ready to implement. Get started today at ChatGPT.com.
0:37 Malcolm Gladwell? We spend hours deciding what to buy, but there's a split-second decision that can make or break a sale. Do you have the trust to hit buy now? Agentic commerce is testing that moment more than ever. And that's where PayPal comes in. With 25 years of checkouts, 400 million consumer accounts globally, and the benefit of purchase and seller protection, all of which make sure wherever a purchase starts, it ends with trust. Built for payments, growth, and agentic. PayPal Open: Built for All Business. Visit PayPalOpen.com.
1:14 Speaker 02 Purchase and seller protections on eligible transactions only. Terms apply. See PayPal.com/risk-management for details.
1:24 Malcolm Gladwell? Hello, hello, Revisionist History listeners. We're having a very exciting week here at Pushkin. You know that I'm Canadian, right? We actually fly a big maple-y flag here at Pushkin HQ. Well, this week, we added another Canadian. The great Jonathan Goldstein, native of Quebec, has brought his acclaimed narrative series, Heavyweight, to the Pushkin network. Oh, Canada, our home and native land. True patriot love in all our hearts command.
1:58 Malcolm Gladwell? Jonathan and the Heavyweight team represent everything we believe in here at Pushkin. The power of storytelling, the value of intelligence and emotion, the belief that Canadians can and should dominate all aspects of American culture. Heavyweight examines personal histories and resentments. It tries to heal old wounds and in the process reminds us of our shared humanity. Yes, it's that good. We're dropping the first ever episode here in the feed about Jonathan's quest to reconcile his father with his estranged brother Buzz. Enjoy, and there is much, much, much more to come. And if you want to listen to more Heavyweight, which I'm sure you do, check out the show notes for the Revisionist History Team's favorite episodes.
2:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, hello.
2:47 Speaker 04 From Gimlet Media, this is Jonathan Goldstein, your old pal.
2:52 Speaker 03 Is that what it's called, Gimlet? Gimlet Media?
2:55 Speaker 04 That's correct.
2:55 Speaker 03 It sounds like giblets, the inside of a chicken, like all the innards.
2:59 Speaker 04 Well, everybody loves giblets.
3:00 Speaker 03 Ew. Oh shit, they're my kids. Hey guys, I'm up here.
3:05 Speaker 04 Do you know what my new podcast is about?
3:07 Speaker 03 No, I don't know anything about it.
3:09 Speaker 04 Each week, I travel into people's pasts to help them repair something that's been troubling them.
3:14 Speaker 03 Mm-hmm.
3:15 Speaker 04 I'm sort of like a therapist.
3:17 Speaker 03 Like a therapist.
3:19 Speaker 04 So...
3:24 Speaker 03 Yeah.
3:25 Speaker 04 Do you find that funny?
3:27 Speaker 03 I just think supportive.
3:28 Speaker 04 That's the laughter of support?
3:29 Speaker 03 I think it's great. I think it's great.
3:31 Speaker 04 Do you have any questions for me about what my show is and what it's going to be like?
3:38 Speaker 03 What's the name of your show? What's the name of your show? Yes, we're going to go now, but Jonathan's just about to tell me the name of his new show. As soon as he tells me, I'm going to bang down on him in five...
3:47 Speaker 04 No, no, wait.
3:48 Speaker 03 Do you remember when we used to do that?
3:49 Speaker 04 Yes, hang up the phone on each other. Okay, ready?
3:52 Speaker 03 Yes, yes.
3:53 Speaker 04 The name of the show is Heavyweight.
3:56 Speaker 03 Heavyweight.
3:57 Speaker 04 You get it?
3:58 Speaker 03 Two, one.
3:59 Speaker 04 No. Hello? Hello?
4:08 Speaker 04 From Gimlet Media, I'm Jonathan Goldstein, and this is Heavyweight. Today's episode, Buzz.
4:18 Speaker 05 Hello?
4:19 Speaker 04 Hey Dad.
4:20 Speaker 05 Hi Johnny.
4:21 Speaker 04 Hey, how you doing?
4:22 Speaker 05 Good, you?
4:23 Speaker 04 Good, good. Good Yom Tiv.
4:25 Speaker 05 Shana Tova.
4:27 Speaker 04 Akse Meach.
4:28 Speaker 05 Akse Meach. What's that mean?
4:30 Speaker 04 I'm not sure.
4:31 Speaker 05 Oh, oh.
4:32 Speaker 04 This is my father Buzz. I'm calling him at his home in Montreal. And the reason we're talking crazy talk is because it's Yom Kippur, the Jewish Day of Atonement, which seems as good a day as any to talk with him about forgiveness. So, I wanted to, I wanted to ask you something, and I just wanted to gauge your interest.
4:53 Speaker 05 Yep.
4:54 Speaker 04 How, how would you feel about paying your brother Sheldon a visit?
5:01 Speaker 05 I have no feelings, I am not really interested.
5:04 Speaker 04 You're not?
5:06 Speaker 05 No.
5:08 Speaker 04 My father Buzz is 80, and his brother Sheldon, his only sibling, is 85. And for the past 40 years, they've pretty much been on the outs. My father lives in Montreal, and Sheldon lives in Florida. And the last time they saw each other, over 20 years ago, was at their mother's funeral, when they had a fight over the details of the arrangements. Since then, they've hardly spoken. It worries me, because there's not a lot of time left. And I don't want my father to have regrets. When the subject of his brother comes up, as it often has over the years, my father feels competing things. He grows angry or defensive, but other times he'll become sad and remorseful.
5:52 Speaker 04 And it's the sorrow and the remorse that I like best, because it's these feelings that I believe speak to his better self, the self I want to encourage. I'm not surprised that you're not jumping at the idea, but I'm a little surprised that you're as against the idea.
6:07 Speaker 05 Yeah, time's passed. He hasn't shown much interest. So I'm respecting that and I leave him alone.
6:13 Speaker 04 What he did do was he called you on your 80th birthday not so long ago. And you felt good about that.
6:21 Speaker 05 Yeah, of course, I called him on his 80th birthday.
6:24 Speaker 04 This kind of tit-for-tat accounting is what always gets in the way. There's been a competition between the brothers since I was a kid. I remember how in my grandmother's small New York kitchen, Sheldon and Buzz got into an argument about who could do the most push-ups. And the next thing I knew, my father was pulling off his shirt and dropping to the kitchen floor in his undershirt. My mother, not used to seeing the sight of him, stood over my father, flapping a dish towel hysterically, while begging him, to the point of tears, to please stop. "Now you go," my father said, rising from the floor when he was done. But Sheldon shook his head with a smile. It was like he didn't even think my father was worth the effort.
7:06 Speaker 05 You know what it is at this point with him? I'll tell you what it is. I don't think it's even anger. He's past anger and he's past any feelings of animosity. He's past that. He just doesn't care.
7:17 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:18 Speaker 05 You know, that's apathy. I mean, sometimes at least hate or love, they're emotions. Apathy is nothing.
7:26 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:27 Speaker 05 You know what? Johnny, as a child, even when I was 10, when I was nine and eight, I was crazy about him. We had a great-- you know, I loved him. He was the older brother. He was-- hello?
7:40 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm listening.
7:42 Speaker 05 You know, I just looked up to him. And he had all the friends. Sometimes he'd take me along with him and he was good. Somebody tried to call here, binging me here.
7:55 Speaker 04 Don't you see, Buzz? It's Father Time who is binging you here. And Buzz loses track of time. Air conditioners remain boxed all through July. And expired coupons from the mid-'90s make plump his wallet. So I worry he'll put off reaching out to Sheldon until it's too late.
8:17 Speaker 04 The most complicated question, the one I keep coming back to, is how did the bad blood begin? And there are many versions. An ill-fated trip to Montreal where Sheldon felt slighted about having to stay in my father's basement. An ill-fated trip to New York where my father felt slighted about having to stay in Sheldon's attic. Rude words spoken to each other's wives. In one version of the story, Sheldon's refusal to bring a table to my bris almost resulted in my being circumcised on an ironing board. But in the version being told today, my father was asked by Sheldon to pay more than his fair share for their mother's funeral.
8:54 Speaker 05 And I said, "You're always working some kind of an angle." So he got furious. He got furious. He started screaming into the phone, "Go to hell, drop dead, bah, bah, bah." That was how that ended. But I feel, he's the kind of guy that he got, he has angles like that, you know? He has angles. I always felt I was on the up and up with him, and he wasn't with me.
9:18 Speaker 04 If you got a stronger sense that he was interested in seeing you, then would you?
9:24 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
9:25 Speaker 04 You would be more inclined to see him?
9:27 Speaker 05 I wouldn't stay at his house, though. That's out of the question.
9:29 Speaker 04 OK, quick sidebar. Anytime I've ever raised the prospect of visiting Sheldon, no matter how hypothetical the scenario, my father always makes a point of insisting how no matter what, he would not stay in Sheldon's house, even if he was invited to. Which, I should point out, he never is.
9:48 Speaker 05 I wouldn't stay at his house.
9:49 Speaker 04 How come you?
9:51 Speaker 05 I wouldn't stay there. I mean, it's not my thing to...
9:54 Speaker 04 How come you always bring that up? I mean, normally, when someone goes to visit someone that they haven't seen in decades, they'll stay at a hotel, you know?
10:03 Speaker 05 I would stay at a motel or somewhere near his place.
10:05 Speaker 04 A motel. Yeah, no, we'd get a place with an ice machine and, you know.
10:10 Speaker 05 Why, you're interested in making a trip?
10:15 Speaker 04 I mean, I'm interested. Do you think that there's anything to be gained in seeing him?
10:25 Speaker 05 Hmm.
10:27 Speaker 05 I guess there's something, you know, you share your common experience and you talk about the old days and there are things that only he and I can remember, you know?
10:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
10:39 Speaker 05 You know, what you could do is you could call him
10:43 Speaker 04 Yeah.
10:44 Speaker 05 and see what his attitude is, you know? It depends on, you know, how you feel, what kind of reception you get.
10:52 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, I would. I would be happy to do that. My concern is that...
10:56 Speaker 05 I like your initial suggestion, that you call him, feel him out, and see what he's like.
11:02 Speaker 04 Okay, I didn't suggest that, but you suggested that.
11:06 Speaker 05 Yeah, I like that. Of course, you'll give me an honest reaction.
11:11 Speaker 04 I'm happy to do it, but, I mean, what are you looking for from... What do you want to hear from him?
11:19 Speaker 05 I miss my brother, I would like to see him.
11:21 Speaker 04 Okay.
11:22 Speaker 05 That's all.
11:24 Speaker 04 Okay.
11:25 Speaker 05 You understand? And you come back on me with an honest evaluation.
11:39 Speaker 06 Hello?
11:40 Speaker 04 Sheldon.
11:41 Speaker 06 Yes, speaking.
11:43 Speaker 04 Hi.
11:43 Speaker 06 I was quite a shock getting your phone call. You said, "John is..."
11:49 Speaker 04 Yeah.
11:51 Speaker 06 My hearing is not that great.
11:53 Speaker 04 Okay.
11:53 Speaker 06 And when I heard the first message, I'm saying, "Who the heck is that? I don't know anybody by that name."
12:01 Speaker 04 Sheldon now lives outside of Fort Lauderdale, but my few memories of him are from when he lived in upstate New York. I remember he lived in a trailer. I remember that he worked at a local prison, that he smoked cigars, that he looked a little like my father, but was hunched, like the world was weighing down on him. And he always wore this expression on his face that seemed to say, "You gotta be kidding me." You're keeping okay, you're keeping occupied?
12:26 Speaker 06 Yeah, I read a lot. I go to the gym, I go shopping, you know, here and there, little things here and there.
12:37 Speaker 04 And so you still go, how often you go to the gym?
12:40 Speaker 06 Three times a week.
12:42 Speaker 04 Wow, and what kind of stuff do you do there?
12:45 Speaker 06 Well, I do about 20 minutes of aerobics.
12:50 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
12:51 Speaker 06 And then I do a little weight training. I try to flirt a little with the women there.
12:58 Speaker 04 Oh yeah. My father also goes to the gym. That's a part of his routine also. He was happy to hear from you on his 80th birthday.
13:12 Speaker 06 Yeah, well, he didn't call me on my 85th though.
13:18 Speaker 04 Tit meet tat. Yeah, like, so, you know, maybe we could go out for dinner, I don't know, that kind of thing.
13:28 Speaker 06 Uh huh. Well, what kind of a timeframe are we talking about here?
13:46 Speaker 06 I don't know, our lives have been much different, I don't know how much we have to have in common anymore.
13:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
13:58 Speaker 06 We don't have, we don't have much in common anymore, except the fact that we're elderly and retired. Other than that, I don't know what we have in common.
14:09 Speaker 04 I guess you have your past in common.
14:13 Speaker 06 Yes. I'll tell you honestly, I'm not a very sentimental person. And I, and I, and being a pragmatist, I take things the way they are. I try not to dwell upon the past. And I try not to take people the way I remember them, but as they are.
14:42 Speaker 04 Do you think that makes things easier?
14:46 Speaker 06 Makes things easier for me.
14:48 Speaker 04 Yeah. Um.
14:52 Speaker 04 Do, do, do other people around you sometime, does it make it harder for other people around you? Ever?
15:00 Speaker 06 To be honest with you, um, I've been, in the last few years, I've been a loner.
15:08 Speaker 04 Uh huh.
15:09 Speaker 06 You, you would basically almost call me a recluse. I don't socialize with many people. And, uh, I really don't give a damn what anybody thinks.
15:23 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:25 Speaker 06 And, uh, contrary to popular belief, I like being alone by myself. I get along with myself very well.
15:37 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:38 Speaker 06 Look, uh, uh, I don't wanna be rude or anything, but I wanna go have my lunch.
15:45 Speaker 04 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, that's fine. It's fine. I, Sheldon, I appreciate your talking to me. And, um, you would be amenable to, um, to, to spending some time?
15:56 Speaker 06 Why not? Uh, we are brothers. I mean, we're not close or anything, but, uh, you know, uh, we're not gonna have a chance to see each other much in the future.
16:10 Speaker 04 Yeah.
16:12 Speaker 04 Uh, is, is that, is that anything that you think about?
16:17 Speaker 06 Not much, no.
16:22 Speaker 04 And so, I call my father back and let him know that Sheldon is amenable. And because I know that for my father, the days tend to pile up like unboxed air conditioners, I have my mother get on the phone to help nail down a firm travel date.
16:37 Speaker 03 And daddy wants to go?
16:39 Speaker 04 If dad wants to go, if he wants to go.
16:41 Speaker 03 Does he wanna go?
16:42 Speaker 05 Next weekend.
16:44 Speaker 04 We don't have to go on the weekend, we can go during the week.
16:47 Speaker 05 Yeah.
16:50 Speaker 05 Comes as, uh, you know.
16:54 Speaker 05 You caught me off guard.
16:57 Speaker 05 How about if, I'll call you Wednesday or Thursday, how's that?
17:02 Speaker 04 Today's Monday, or yeah, or even if you feel like calling tomorrow, you can call me.
17:06 Speaker 05 Yeah.
17:08 Speaker 05 Okay, I'll probably, I'll call you the, at the latest Thursday.
17:13 Speaker 04 Did you get to Thursday?
17:15 Speaker 05 At the latest.
17:18 Speaker 04 That's three days from today.
17:19 Speaker 05 Yeah.
17:21 Speaker 04 Okay.
17:22 Speaker 05 I have to think.
17:22 Speaker 04 All right, you do what you want to do. You call me, but.
17:25 Speaker 05 I'll call you Thursday.
17:27 Speaker 04 Coming up after the break, Thursday.
17:31 Speaker 00 This is Jacob Goldstein. With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. When you're running a business and looking to expand, you need a clear view of the landscape before making any decisions. ChatGPT can help you prepare. Connect your Google Drive, point to relevant files and reports, and ask it to research competitors, industry forecasts, and market signals. It can turn the findings into a strategic deck in your team's template that you can review before presenting to your leadership team. Growing a business is ambitious, and ChatGPT can help you do it with confidence. Get started today at chatgpt.com.
18:09 Malcolm Gladwell? We spend hours researching products online and deciding what to buy, but there's a split second decision that can make or break a sale. Do you have the trust to hit the buy now button? The way we discover and compare things is evolving, happening faster and influenced by new forms of intelligent advice. But the underlying trust question doesn't go away. If anything, it's more important than ever. That's where PayPal comes in. For more than 25 years, they've been a trusted way to pay. And now PayPal can make the agentic era of commerce work for merchants, letting them maintain control of their brand, their customer relationships. So even as the way we shop changes, the moment that matters most still feels familiar and deeply dependable.
18:54 Malcolm Gladwell? PayPal is built for all business. Get started at paypal.com/business. Purchase and sell our protections on eligible transactions only. Terms apply. See paypal.com/risk-management for details. The new Petivity Smart Feeder for cats turns everyday meals into meaningful health insights, helping you identify changes in your cat's habits and be more proactive about their health. My cat, Biggie Smalls, is the most demanding member of our household. He has specific mealtimes, or he lets out a massive howl last night. I introduced him to the Petivity Smart Feeder for cats.
19:39 Malcolm Gladwell? It took no time to set up. I downloaded the app, plugged it in, filled up the feeder with delicious kibble, and watched as my cat entered the digital age. "Biggie, look." "Meow." All curious at it. It's its first experience with high technology. Tiny, feline mind, blown. Check in on mealtime with a real-time video feed and dispense food on demand even when you're away. In multi-cat households, the Petivity Smart Feeder for cats uses facial recognition technology to track up to five cats. Visit P E T I V I T Y dot com slash cat feeder to learn more.
20:19 Speaker 04 And so on Thursday, possibly with a little nudging from my mother, Buzz agrees. And then my father and I are off to Florida to visit my Uncle Sheldon.
20:29 Speaker 07 Press "where to" and then type. Do you have an address?
20:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, I do.
20:33 Speaker 07 Okay.
20:34 Speaker 04 My dad and I meet up at the Fort Lauderdale airport. I flew from New York and my dad from Montreal. My father's all dressed up, wearing a faux suede sports jacket that I've never seen him in. We grab our airport rental and prepare for the two-hour drive to Sheldon. In the 90-degree heat, it's immediately made clear that faux suede might not have been the best fashion choice.
20:54 Speaker 07 It's like we're on a safari.
20:59 Speaker 04 On the road to Sheldon's, my father will experience a spectrum of feelings. As we first set out, there's excitement.
21:06 Speaker 07 You know, my brother was funny in a lot of ways. I could laugh. We're gonna have laughs with him. You know what I mean? He's a very funny man.
21:14 Speaker 04 A half an hour in, and there's bitterness.
21:16 Speaker 07 We invited him to your bonbon's and he returned a very cold card. "Sorry, we will not be attending." It was, you know, so mean. You know what I mean? Even the writing.
21:30 Speaker 04 An hour in, and how is Buzz feeling?
21:33 Speaker 07 I'm relaxed.
21:34 Speaker 04 Oh, good.
21:34 Speaker 07 Kind of old to get anxious, you know what I mean?
21:37 Speaker 04 A half an hour to Sheldon's.
21:39 Speaker 07 A little bit apprehensive now.
21:43 Speaker 04 Yeah. Ten minutes to Sheldon's, and Buzz is feeling?
21:46 Speaker 07 All right.
21:48 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:50 Speaker 04 He feeling a little, uh...
21:51 Speaker 07 No, it's gonna be strange.
21:53 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:53 Speaker 07 It's gonna be very strange. I mean, the man is a stranger to me now, and yet he's my brother. You understand? It's a very strange feeling.
22:02 Speaker 04 Yeah.
22:05 Speaker 07 I wonder if he's getting nervous.
22:07 Speaker 04 Maybe.
22:09 Speaker 07 Because he's waiting for us, right?
22:11 Speaker 04 Yeah.
22:16 Speaker 04 You all set?
22:17 Speaker 07 Yeah.
22:22 Speaker 07 Ooh, it's hot.
22:23 Speaker 04 It's really hot, yeah. Sheldon lives in the corner house on a quiet suburban street. Ring the bell?
22:30 Speaker 07 I guess.
22:33 Speaker 07 Is this his door?
22:35 Speaker 04 I'll double-check.
22:36 Speaker 07 Maybe it's...
22:37 Speaker 04 Oh, there he is.
22:39 Speaker 04 Hey! Hi.
22:43 Speaker 08 This is Jonathan.
22:45 Speaker 04 Nice to see you. Yeah.
22:47 Speaker 08 Come here.
22:48 Speaker 04 Thank you.
22:50 Speaker 07 I smell a good smell of cigar.
22:53 Speaker 08 Yeah. Lately, I've become a monk, me and my pussycat.
22:58 Speaker 04 Oh, you got a cat. After all the years and the worry and the dread, things seem to be going swimmingly. We sit down at Sheldon's kitchen table, and my father gets right into it.
23:08 Speaker 07 Now, there's things I want to know. You said that Rainy died?
23:12 Speaker 08 Yeah, she did.
23:13 Speaker 07 She did die?
23:13 Speaker 04 The dead are a good place to begin. As a subject, they're easily agreed upon and not likely to spark a fight.
23:20 Speaker 08 My uncle died.
23:21 Speaker 07 My uncle died? He was the youngest brother!
23:24 Speaker 08 Oh, he died long ago.
23:26 Speaker 07 He died, eh? Oh, you know who died?
23:28 Speaker 08 Who?
23:29 Speaker 04 Hoffman.
23:29 Speaker 08 Hoffman! A real prick.
23:31 Speaker 07 Yeah, I didn't know him that well. I didn't know him, yeah, yeah.
23:36 Speaker 08 Knish.
23:37 Speaker 07 Oh, that's shocking.
23:39 Speaker 08 Yeah, he was fat.
23:40 Speaker 07 He was fat. Redhead.
23:41 Speaker 08 Redhead, right.
23:42 Speaker 07 Yeah, yeah. Knish.
23:46 Speaker 07 Yeah. Remember Johnny? Johnny was a sex maniac.
23:48 Speaker 08 Johnny, oh. He would fuck a dog on the street if he saw a dog. He'd try to fuck the dog.
24:00 Speaker 08 Can I get you guys a cold beer? I'd like a beer.
24:03 Speaker 07 Yeah, sure. Oh, a beer. Thank you.
24:05 Speaker 04 Even though they're in their 80s, Sheldon and Buzz still possess voices and temperament suited to shouting out Brooklyn tenement windows, while my voice...
24:14 Speaker 07 Yeah, sure. Oh, a beer.
24:16 Speaker 04 ...is best suited to asking a waitress if there'll be a sharing charge.
24:20 Speaker 08 I defied...
24:22 Speaker 07 Forgot about that, sorry.
24:23 Speaker 04 Case in point: this is Sheldon accidentally swiping a portable microphone receiver off the kitchen table, and me trying to smooth things over.
24:32 Speaker 08 Take this off, will you? It's annoying.
24:34 Speaker 07 No, here, just put it in your pocket there.
24:36 Speaker 08 Just take it off, would you please? Thank you, thank you.
24:40 Speaker 04 Over the next couple of days, my testes will flee like frightened cockroaches, upward, ascending to heights not seen since the bar mitzvah that Sheldon was not attending. And while we're on the subject of testes, here's Sheldon reminiscing about the time he was examined for a rupture by their family doctor.
25:00 Speaker 08 Me and Wally Rosen were joining the weightlifting club, say, how to be tested for a rupture. I remember he put his hand under my balls. I started laughing so hard I pissed right in his hand.
25:19 Speaker 04 Over the years, I've seen my father in the role of husband, uncle, and grandfather, but I've never really seen him in the role of younger brother. How odd to see it now at 80. He sits beside Sheldon with this expression I've never seen on his face. It's wide-eyed, sweet, and deferential.
25:40 Speaker 04 But as the day wears on, Sheldon and Buzz begin to squabble over their memories, fighting over every little detail.
25:47 Speaker 07 Remember the halibut we had with the hair dyer? That heavyset girl?
25:51 Speaker 08 It's a manicurist.
25:52 Speaker 07 She was a hair dyer?
25:53 Speaker 08 Manicurist.
25:55 Speaker 07 No, she was a hair dyer. Here's what happened. She went over to Irving...
25:58 Speaker 04 They even argue over the death of their grandmother.
26:00 Speaker 07 I found her body.
26:02 Speaker 08 I did?
26:03 Speaker 07 I opened the door. No, no. My mother was across the street at Greenberg.
26:05 Speaker 08 I remember walking in.
26:06 Speaker 07 I looked in on her.
26:07 Speaker 08 And I knew she was dead, so I saw her.
26:09 Speaker 07 I never saw a dead body in my life, but I knew she was dead.
26:14 Speaker 07 Sure.
26:15 Speaker 04 So wait, so you found her, or you found her?
26:17 Speaker 07 I remember looking in on her room to see how she do. I said it was awfully quiet.
26:21 Speaker 08 I found her, but let him take the credit.
26:23 Speaker 07 No, I'm not, it's some credit.
26:30 Speaker 04 The whole afternoon is like this. Every subject, even their dead grandmother, somehow becomes fodder for another pissing match. They're burning up all this time with small talk, when what they need is some big talk. In particular, they need to address a story that I know holds a great deal of meaning for my father. It took place in 1939, on the day their mother left them. I've only ever heard the story from my father, never from Sheldon. I wanted to ask, what do you remember? What's your perspective?
26:59 Speaker 08 All I remember at that time was when Pop was smacking her around, and she ran out in the hall and her slip.
27:07 Speaker 07 Fighting in the hall?
27:08 Speaker 08 No, he was smacking her around. She ran out.
27:13 Speaker 07 Yeah, so what happened the next morning?
27:16 Speaker 08 The next morning?
27:17 Speaker 07 Yeah. Look in the closet, her clothes were gone, and she left.
27:23 Speaker 04 What happened after this, in my father's telling, is that his mother returned soon after she left, with a policeman in tow.
27:30 Speaker 07 And they came back to try to get you. They wanted you to come back with them.
27:38 Speaker 08 And where were you?
27:39 Speaker 07 I was there, but they were trying to drag you out of the house.
27:44 Speaker 08 They weren't trying to grab you?
27:46 Speaker 07 No, no, I could stay with my father and grandma and all that.
27:50 Speaker 04 This is the point of the story for my father. It proves, once and for all, how his mother loved Sheldon more than she loved him. Sheldon didn't move out with her, and after a year, their mother returned, and together Buzz and Sheldon grew up, under the same roof, in the same bedroom, often sleeping under the same blanket, each knowing who the mother had chosen, and each having to do their best to carry on and live life with the burden of that knowledge.
28:28 Speaker 04 A couple of times during the day, I ask them why they haven't spoken in so long, and they both insist, maybe out of embarrassment, that they do talk, just not often. But it isn't true. In fact, my father learned of Sheldon's wife's death many years after the fact, and then, only from me. Sheldon's daughter got in touch through Facebook, and we made a phone date where she caught me up on her life and Sheldon's. And a few nights later, while over at my parents' for dinner, I told my father of his sister-in-law's death. There was a terrible look that fell across his face, one of sadness, but something else too, maybe shock, over just how far he and Sheldon had drifted.
29:10 Speaker 04 I found out about Judy, about her death.
29:15 Speaker 08 Who?
29:15 Speaker 04 Your wife.
29:17 Speaker 08 I didn't know about it either until you told me.
29:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
29:20 Speaker 08 Didn't I tell you?
29:22 Speaker 04 Nope.
29:23 Speaker 08 You didn't know about it, no?
29:25 Speaker 04 We didn't know. We didn't know.
29:30 Speaker 08 She was sick about two years, Judy.
29:35 Speaker 04 Too bad.
29:36 Speaker 08 Well, when she got the diagnosis, she was already stage four.
29:44 Speaker 08 What did I know about cancer? So the surgeon, so I says, "Well, doc, how did the surgery go?" "Oh, he said it went very well." "What?" "The cancer's in her liver now."
29:59 Speaker 04 Oh, it's spread.
30:01 Speaker 08 I said, "It's in her liver." I said, "What?"
30:06 Speaker 08 And on top of that, I'm driving home. I'm all fucked up and I'm spaced out, and my driver window's open, and some kids pull up alongside me and flip a lit cigarette into my car.
30:31 Speaker 08 You know where I usually eat? Where I come in by myself, by the bar. They got a waitress there who always waits on me.
30:40 Speaker 08 She takes good care of me.
30:41 Speaker 04 For dinner, Sheldon takes us to a local Outback Steakhouse. As people walk by, he provides a running commentary of an elderly couple.
30:50 Speaker 08 Don't get like that couple, whatever you did. It's time for the execution.
30:55 Speaker 04 Of an overweight couple.
30:57 Speaker 08 Oh, they're fat.
31:00 Speaker 08 People are fat today.
31:02 Speaker 04 It's as though he's sharpening his whip, readying it for the main event, teasing my dad about Canada.
31:09 Speaker 08 I don't know how you could take Canada when you're around.
31:12 Speaker 07 Why? Because we got nice neighbors. It's nice. It's okay. Uh, what was I gonna say?
31:18 Speaker 08 You're living in the same place for how many years?
31:21 Speaker 07 Oh, about, uh, over thirty-five, thirty-eight years, something like that. I'm happy here. Yeah, yeah.
31:28 Speaker 04 For my father, I know this is a touchy subject, believing as he always has that Sheldon looks down on him for the dinkiness of his Canadian life and home. It's like a constant reminder of just who is second best. Later, my father will repeat Sheldon's words. "You're still living in that same place?" he'll say. "For how many years?" But just then, I watch my father clench and unclench his jaw as he does when he is brooding. I know he's trying to take the high road, trying not to ruin the evening.
31:59 Speaker 08 What, $230.30? I ain't kidding.
32:04 Speaker 04 Sheldon invites us back to his place for cookies, but my father says he isn't up for it.
32:18 Speaker 04 As we walk through the restaurant parking lot to the car, my father is silent. I find myself feeling protective of him. After midnight, lying awake in our hotel, my father insisted we stay at one. I lay in bed, thinking about that day in 1939, when my grandmother came back for Sheldon, not my father. For my father, not only did it push him away from Sheldon, making him feel jealous and resentful, but it also cast a shadow over the rest of his life, causing him to always feel passed over. He's mellowed with age, but as a kid, I saw it come out in all kinds of ways. Always sensitive to slights, ready for a fight at the smallest perceived defense. I wonder if there's a different way for my father to see things. If there is,
33:02 Speaker 04 the only living person in this world who can help is Sheldon. When their mom left, Sheldon was nine, my father, five. Sheldon would have understood a lot more than my father.
33:15 Speaker 04 Yesterday Buzz and Sheldon talked like a couple of kids who used to play stickball in the old neighborhood. Today, if me and my big fat meddling yap have any sway, they'll have a chance to talk as men, as brothers even. Because if not now, when?
33:35 Speaker 04 Day two.
33:37 Speaker 07 This is a damn good cigar.
33:38 Speaker 08 He sent me.
33:39 Speaker 07 Oh, Dominican Republic. They make a damn good cigar in Dominican Republic.
33:43 Speaker 04 Despite the difficulties of last night, the coin has flipped back to the good side. Sheldon offers my father a cigar. And with the cigar, some cigar talk. Some pretty foul cigar talk.
33:55 Speaker 08 We're riding on Queens Boulevard. Johnny's in the backseat with the whore. He's got his naked ass up in the air. And he's humping. The funny thing is, we had to stop for a light. And there's a truck driver sitting in the cab up high. He looked at the car, it was funny.
34:19 Speaker 04 Have you guys missed each other?
34:21 Speaker 08 What?
34:22 Speaker 04 Do you miss each other?
34:25 Speaker 08 You know, he asks the weirdest questions. What is he, abroad?
34:31 Speaker 04 No, I mean, I don't know, that's, you know. Eager to prove to my Uncle Sheldon that in spite of the fact I'm wearing my wife's travel deodorant, I am indeed not abroad, I allow them to return to more pressing matters: their prostates.
34:45 Speaker 08 The guy says, Jesus, he says, your prostate feels like the moon crater's in there. He said, I said, "Thank you, doctor." He was complimenting me.
34:56 Speaker 04 So if I could steer this away from the prostates, so my father said that it's significant to him to have come, what do you say?
35:03 Speaker 08 I agree with whatever he said.
35:06 Speaker 04 But what about you?
35:07 Speaker 08 I said, "I agree with whatever he said." Do you want a written contract?
35:12 Speaker 04 No, I'm happy for that. It feels like I'm getting a taste of what growing up with Sheldon might have been like. So again, I make my move. So I have some questions, just about, because there's stories that I know from my father, but I'm curious what your take is, because you were older. Do you remember what was going on when your mom, when your mother left originally? Like, what, why, and what was going on?
35:43 Speaker 08 Didn't you cover this ground before yesterday?
35:47 Speaker 04 But from my father's perspective, the way I understood it was always you were the favorite. Did you, did you feel that way? At this point, Sheldon's face suddenly softens.
35:58 Speaker 08 I always felt that I got the short end of the stick.
36:01 Speaker 04 Yeah, but you were, you were a kind of a favorite with my mom.
36:06 Speaker 08 Yeah, maybe with mom, because maybe temperamentally we were closer than I was with my father. My father never gave me spit. Did you ever get any money from my father?
36:22 Speaker 04 Can't remember.
36:23 Speaker 08 You never got a dime?
36:25 Speaker 04 No, can't remember.
36:26 Speaker 08 You never, one time I sprained my ankle so bad.
36:30 Speaker 04 I'll never forget that. That was terrible.
36:32 Speaker 08 I laid in that bed, my aunt, and she says to me, "You lazy bum."
36:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
36:39 Speaker 08 Man, he went off on me that time.
36:43 Speaker 07 He took Sheldon once. Sheldon happened to say the word "fuck."
36:49 Speaker 08 He came in with that fucking strap swinging. With the buckle.
36:54 Speaker 07 And you know, I can understand it leaving a feeling of resentment and dislike.
36:59 Speaker 08 He, that was his way of communicating with us. Smack, smack and then...
37:08 Speaker 07 What a way.
37:09 Speaker 04 Was he easier on you, you think?
37:12 Speaker 07 Uh, it wasn't that easy, but he was tough on Sheldon, wasn't he?
37:16 Speaker 08 I know you were closer to him than I was. A lot of things that went on, you didn't understand really what was going on.
37:26 Speaker 07 So you had a different take?
37:27 Speaker 04 Why, are you surprised by...
37:29 Speaker 07 But I was a kid, I didn't understand it.
37:31 Speaker 04 Well, you didn't know that Sheldon was getting it so bad?
37:35 Speaker 07 No.
37:37 Speaker 04 In Buzz's telling, their father was always a more or less benign childish figure, incapable of expressing his feelings, and so, given to temper tantrums. For Buzz, it was their mother who was the manipulator, the woman who played the brothers off each other. But hearing Sheldon's take, it sounds like maybe their mother didn't come to take Sheldon because she loved him best, but simply because he needed more protecting from their father.
38:09 Speaker 04 For the first time during our trip, I can see my father considering Sheldon's point of view, actually taking it in. I know it's intense for him, because he can't even meet Sheldon's eyes. Instead, he looks at me, addresses his comments to me.
38:25 Speaker 07 You know, it's sad that my father had such a negative impact on him, you know? Just awful. Because he had so much going for him. He was a wonderful son. He worked hard. He was a good boy.
38:38 Speaker 08 You're talking like I'm a failure in life.
38:41 Speaker 07 No, you weren't a failure. That's the thing that I'm saying. You weren't a failure, but all I'm saying is that emotionally, he left an impact on you.
38:49 Speaker 08 It took a long time for me to get out of that emotion. And now, I'm at peace with myself. I can talk about him and laugh about it. Now I want peace, quiet. I'm happy living by myself.
39:11 Speaker 07 Are you lonely, Sheldon?
39:13 Speaker 08 No.
39:19 Speaker 04 The last time my father saw my grandfather in full health, my dad was visiting from Canada. My grandfather asked my father to drive him to the cemetery to visit his parents' grave. And once there, my grandfather wept inconsolably. Later that day, he would succumb to a stroke and shortly after be moved to a nursing home. With Sheldon being more local, the burden of my grandfather's care fell mainly to Sheldon. It seems like a lot of the family's burdens fell to Sheldon.
39:48 Speaker 07 They put a lot of the responsibility on him that my dad should have been taking that responsibility. And he shouldered that.
39:56 Speaker 08 Who was gonna take care of you? Who was gonna take you to school? Meet you? I remember one time I was late or something. You stood outside that school. You were crying. I said, "Buzzy, I'm here, I'm here."
40:12 Speaker 07 He was good to me.
40:14 Speaker 08 A lot of times I was mean to you.
40:15 Speaker 07 Mean, you know. You were my older brother. You used to knock the shit out of me sometimes. But, you know, that's the way it is with brothers.
40:24 Speaker 08 Well, I was good in some ways. Some ways I was mean.
40:29 Speaker 07 Who was not? Who was not?
40:33 Speaker 04 So if you feel like you were compelled to see each other now because you knew that, you know, it's now or never kind of thing, then it means that it was important to you both, right? To see each other?
40:48 Speaker 08 You wanna take that from that?
40:49 Speaker 07 Sure, yes. Easy answer, yes.
40:53 Speaker 07 Yes, because we're not getting any younger. What's down the road? I'm 80, he's 85.
41:01 Speaker 07 I mean, because there was a lot of water under the bridge and we want to close that bridge now. I want to feel easy now. I want to say now, he's gonna be 86, I want to call him on his birthday and say happy birthday to him now. I'm not gonna stand in any fucking ceremonies anymore.
41:15 Speaker 04 As my father speaks, as per his brother's example, dropping F-bombs like he's in a Guy Ritchie film, Sheldon keeps his arms crossed and his eyes shut tight. He's quiet for several seconds, and then he reaches out to pet his cat.
41:29 Speaker 08 Should I leave you the cat in my will if anything happens?
41:33 Speaker 07 If anything happens, I'll take care of the cat. I'll take care of the cat. I'm happy I came to see you, that I am.
41:41 Speaker 08 I'm happy you came here. That's good, very good.
41:48 Speaker 08 If I ever want to buy a house, that one is for sale.
41:53 Speaker 04 When it's time to leave, Sheldon walks us outside, but before we get into the rental, he points across the lawn to his neighbor's house. He tells my father that it's for sale, and then he tells him the asking price, and my father says, "That doesn't sound bad at all." And Sheldon says that, "What with Canada being so bloody cold, my father should consider moving to Florida." And my father says, "Maybe he will." They don't get too emotional, they don't even hug goodbye, they just shake hands. And with that, it feels like Buzz has forgiven Sheldon, and Sheldon has forgiven Buzz.
42:28 Speaker 07 All right, you take care.
42:29 Speaker 08 Water under the bridge.
42:30 Speaker 07 Thank you.
42:31 Speaker 08 Take care, you too.
42:32 Speaker 07 Okay.
42:33 Speaker 08 Safe trip, both of yous.
42:34 Speaker 07 Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. We'll speak, we'll speak.
42:48 Speaker 07 Oh my God, it feels so different now. You know that? This is taking a lot off my shoulders, I, uh... You know?
42:59 Speaker 04 As we ride to the airport, my father says that the thought of Sheldon all alone in that house with just a cat makes him sad. "Do you really think he isn't lonely?" my father asks. I assure him that Sheldon seems OK with being alone, but my father doesn't seem so sure. After all these years, the burden of having lost his brother has been replaced by a new burden, one that might be heavier to bear.
44:39 Speaker 04 Heavyweight is hosted and produced by me, Jonathan Goldstein. This episode was also produced by Wendy Dorr, Chris Neary, and Kalila Holt. Editing by Alex Blumberg and Peter Clowney. Special thanks to Caitlin Kenny, Starlee Kine, and Rachel Ward. The show was mixed by Haley Shaw. Music in this episode by Christine Fellows, with additional music and ad music by Haley Shaw. Our theme song is by The Weaker Than's, courtesy of Epitaph Records. A version of this story appeared on This American Life, and we had a lot of help from the folks there: Ira Glass, Julie Snyder, Jonathan Menjivar, Sean Cole, and Robyn Semien. A very special thanks to Emily Condon. Follow us on Twitter at @Heavyweight. We'll have a new episode next week.
45:30 Speaker 08 We used to call him Mitchy Little Bitchy.
45:33 Speaker 07 Yeah, remember the older brother, the oldest one? He was comical.
45:36 Speaker 08 Hey, we're lucky we turned out as good as we did.
45:41 Malcolm Gladwell? We spend hours deciding what to buy, but there's a split second decision that can make or break a sale. Do you have the trust to hit buy now? Agentic commerce is testing that moment more than ever. And that's where PayPal comes in. With 25 years of checkouts, 400 million consumer accounts globally, and the benefit of purchase and seller protection, all of which make sure wherever a purchase starts, it ends with trust. Built for payments, growth, and agentic. PayPal Open: Built for All Business. Visit paypalopen.com.
46:18 Speaker 02 Purchase and seller protections on eligible transactions only. Terms apply. See paypal.com/risk-management for details.
46:28 Malcolm Gladwell? For I don't know how long, maybe 12, 13 years, I've worn a Whoop band on my wrist. I started doing it because I met the founder of Whoop at a conference. He heard that I was a runner and he said, oh, you'll love this. It's perfect for athletes. And he was right. I've worn one ever since. Every time I work out, I see how hard I worked, how long I need to recover. I wake up in the morning and I get a complete picture of how my sleep went, which helps me understand the kinds of things that lead to a bad night and the kinds of things that lead to a good night. It's sleek, long-lasting battery, and now with AI looking at all my numbers and coaching me. Whoop is a winner. New members can try Whoop with a 30-day free trial before committing to a membership.
47:13 Malcolm Gladwell? That's whoop.com for your free month of Whoop.
47:16 Speaker 09 This is Colin Cowherd from the Colin Cowherd Podcast. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. All starts with a great deal on an off-road Ready Tacoma or a half-ton Tundra to a Toyota's most capable and longest-lasting trucks. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. For a great deal today to a great value tomorrow. Shoptoyota.com. Toyota, let's go places.
Previous Malcolm Breaks Down the Perfect Break Up Song Next Revisionist History is Back Page updated November 4, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated