Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing When Will the Green Shoots Narrative End? About this episode U. S. equities were flat today as investors weigh dual uncertainties: earnings season and a potential recession. Meanwhile, energy and interest rates both closed in the red, and business conditions contracted in January for the fourth month in a row, according to the latest S&P survey. Andreas Steno Larsen sits down with Eric Johnston of Cantor Fitzgerald to discuss the latest price action and hear why he believes there’s “very little upside” for stocks in the near-term. Plus, we’ll hear from veteran economist and strategist David Rosenberg, on why a rapid collapse in inflation could lead to a drawn-out recession. You can watch that entire interview here: https://rvtv.io/3DaMUt6 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privileged access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 at PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:31 Speaker 00 Hi everyone and welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. My name is Alessino from Real Vision and I look forward to sending live for you the next 30 minutes here on Tuesday, the 24th of January. And today we're going to ask the question whether the shoe narrative will end soon. And I'm joined by an equity bear today and also probably the guy with the best hair in finance, Eric Johnston, the head of Equity Derivatives and Cross Asset Strategy at Cantor Fitzgerald. It's good to see you on the show again, Eric.
1:05 Speaker 01 Thanks for having me. Happy to be here and appreciate the compliment.
1:09 Speaker 00 Eric, we've had quite of a wobbly day in equity markets. We've had PMIs out of Europe and the US bouncing a little bit from lows, but still sideways to slightly negative price action, both in European equities and US equities. What do you make of the price action after the rally that we've seen so far this year?
1:28 Speaker 01 So one of the things that's happening is that people are being somewhat dragged into this rally. So the CTA community, which I think is a really important driver and has been for years, and a lot of the short-term moves that we get, has been in buy mode. So they have their momentum triggers. Right now, we're about a percent or so above their medium-term trigger. And so they're buying approximately $2 to $3 billion a day. And right now liquidity in the equity markets is extremely poor. So we're seeing volumes that are down, you know,
2:10 Speaker 01 Fifteen to twenty percent relative to the hundred day average. And even on the days on Friday and Monday, when we had those two big rallies, where we saw, you know, very large moves in the market, which just, you know, creates uh trading going on in the futures market. Volumes even then were still quite low, which just shows you at any point liquidity is very low. So when you have CTA is buying that much each day. Um, and although buybacks are in, um, you know, some are in are in blackout right now, but many are still alive. And you add in that flow, um, it's creating this dynamic that is then dragging in um hedge funds to cover shorts.
2:52 Speaker 01 It's dragging in mutual funds to reduce their uh some of their cash cash levels, which which have been uh, you know, very high. And so
3:06 Speaker 01 situation where um people are buying, not because they think that we're necessarily going higher, but because they feel like they they have to and they're being uh and they're being dragged um dragged into it. So I think we are in sort of the probably seventh inning to ninth inning of this trade. Um, the crowded hedge fund short basket is up over twenty percent this year. And the momentum index is down uh very significantly this year. And, you know, a typical uh long short hedge fund is obviously short the crowded names and uh is typically long momentum because you're typically long, high quality and short low quality. And the low quality stocks are ripping.
3:48 Speaker 01 So you've had this one big pain trade squeeze that I think is driving uh driving things. And for that matter, also driving the narrative.
3:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, before we went on air, Eric, we talked about how price tends to lead narrative in the mainstream media at least. And I've seen the phrase green suits being used by some of your colleagues in other investment banks to sort of describe this small rebound that we've seen in economic sentiment. For example, in purchasing manager indices and other sentiment indicators. What do you make of this green suits narrative? Is it fake news?
4:25 Speaker 01 I think it's fake news.
4:29 Speaker 01 There are so many indicators out there that that suggest that the economy is going to erode throughout the year.
4:42 Speaker 01 And then we can go through a few of them, you know, if you look at the, if you look at the yield curves, for example, you've got the three-month, 10-year, which is at a 35-plus year, you know, inverted level. The 2s 10s curve has been inverted for about nine or 10 months so far. It's been inverted, it's gone inverted about 10 times over the course of the last 70 years. In eight of those 10 times, we had a recession within 24 months. It's been 10 months so far. And the other two times, it happened a year and two years, you know, after that. So that, whenever you have, you know, you have a 10-year yield that's 150 basis points
5:27 Speaker 01 below what is likely to be the peak Fed funds rate, that's telling you something, I think, very powerful, because the Fed is not going to cut rates if we have a soft landing, the S and P's at 4,000, and everything is fine in the markets. They're going to cut rates if things are bad. You look at some of the economic data we're seeing, the leading economic indicator's been down 10 months in a row. If you look at the times since 1970, when it's gone negative for, for more than, you know, two readings, more than two months, there's been a recession every time. And we've now had a number of readings below zero. We last, you know, printed negative 7.4%.
6:12 Speaker 01 And if you look at some of the ISM numbers around the new orders relative to inventories, some of the weakest levels, you look at retail sales, it was, you know, minus 1% in December, minus 1.1%.
6:25 Speaker 01 In this most recent reading from the other day, we haven't had two months in a row like that, ex COVID, since the financial crisis. And so, and there are so many others. And so I think one of the things that is holding up this economy right now is that the unemployment rate's three and a half percent. And the consumer, at the moment, is still strong because they're still employed and they still have some excess savings. But when I look at the forward-looking indicators for the consumer, it's not favorable at all because excess savings are, they've been coming down for about a year, year and a half in a straight line. They're likely to hit zero sometime in the middle of this year. Credit usage
7:07 Speaker 01 has been surging and the savings rate is at a 70-year low. And so, right now, like I said, they're employed. So as soon as employment starts to turn, it doesn't need to turn, you know, that much, I think the consumer is really going to start to erode. And that's where you could really see the downside acceleration in the market.
7:32 Speaker 00 If we turn back time, just say, six weeks, to just before Christmas, in the middle of December, we had a terrible December, one of the worst Decembers in, in history in the US stock market. And everyone seemed to agree that the economy was slowing clearly, that the recession was unavoidable during 2023, etc. So what has changed since then? Given that we've now seen a rally almost since New Year's?
8:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's pretty incredible, the, the change in the view from the market, where it's gone from, you know, we're almost for sure going to have a recession, to now, the most likely outcome being a, being a soft landing. And, you know, I think, and, and as we said earlier, price is certainly, you know, price of equities are certainly a, a part of that. I think that-
8:29 Speaker 01 You know, when you look at the outlook, this because the unemployment rate is so so low, I think that this process is going to be just that, a process, and it will take time. And we may not get those that think the economy is really going to roll over. You know, you need to be patient because it's not going
8:49 Speaker 01 we're going to fall off a cliff. We don't have a large leverage problem, you know, in the system. And so it's not like we're going to fall off the cliff right away. But the indicators are all such that I think there's a high likelihood that it is going to, you know, to happen. But I think the longer that it takes, the more people will start to think that, okay, since it hasn't happened yet, we're going to have the soft landing. Now, I think what's really important is that ultimately this economy goes in cycles, right? It's happened since the beginning of time. And the best barometer of the economy is the unemployment rate. So when the unemployment rate is three and a half percent, you're probably towards the top of the cycle.
9:34 Speaker 01 When the unemployment rate is eight, 10, 12%, then that's almost by definition is the bottom of the cycle. And you want to own equities towards the bottom of the cycle, and you want to sell equities towards the top of the cycle. And the, when you look at the returns in history, the data proves that out, meaning that returns go higher as the unemployment rate forward returns go higher as the unemployment rate goes goes higher. And so as we think about cycles, if in fact, we get a soft landing in 2023, which by the way, I think is possible, like, you know, you can't, nothing is 100%, not even close.
10:16 Speaker 01 And I do actually think it is possible, not likely, but possible. Then that doesn't mean we're out of the woods. It's not like we've then gone to a 8% unemployment rate and we can start the next cycle. The narrative and the multiple that I think the market will put on earnings will be lower because if it doesn't happen in 23, people are going to think it's coming in 24 because we are towards the end of the cycle, not the beginning.
10:43 Speaker 00 We're going to take a quick break and be right back with more of today's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
10:54 Speaker 00 Eric, I wanted to show you a tweet from earlier today. It's from a friend of the show, Jim Bianco, who points out that the S&P 500 has sort of breached a negative trend channel to the upside. I know that you're not a technical analyst. I'm not a technical analyst either. But is it something that worries you when you are bearish? That you see such a break to the upside of a trend channel that we've seen forcefully in place throughout 22?
11:24 Speaker 01 So I would say that for my three to six to nine month view, it has, it has no impact. For, you know, the view, or if I should say for the outlook that I would have over the next couple of weeks. Yeah, I think that's something to certainly take note of. I think what gives me so much confidence that a breakthrough there is not going to cause, you know, some five to eight or 10% rally is because the market is already pricing in, in my view, that soft landing and that valuations right now to me are, and based on the data, very extended.
12:05 Speaker 01 So right now we are trading at about 18 times the earnings estimate for 2023, which is about $223 a share. And so when you think about the alternatives that are out there right now, and we'll take the very simple money market fund, money market funds yielding 4.5% approximately. So if you're going to hold equities for the next year, the break even price for where it would make sense to own equities, not taking into account, of course, that equities are much riskier. But the break even point would be somewhere around 4,200, which is somewhere around 19 times earnings.
12:49 Speaker 01 So if you buy equities today, you have to have the view that you think the multiple is going to go above 19 times earnings. And based on all the data that I've studied throughout my career and that we're studying in the real time, there is no justification for that. We have quantitative tightening going on. We have rate, a Fed funds rate at 5%. We have
13:18 Speaker 01 You know, overall 10 year yield that's well above average. We have real yields that are positive 150 basis points of 14 year high and I could go on. There's no justification for it to be above 19 times earnings.
13:35 Speaker 01 And I would point to the last 30 years, there's been two times where the multiple's been higher than 18 times. That was post-COVID when earnings estimates got crushed. So they were trough earnings, interest rates were zero, QE was 4 trillion and fiscal spending was 3 to 4 trillion in excess. And then the other time was in the late 90s when the internet was literally invented. Outside of that, 18 times has been the peak. And so I feel, that's why I feel so confident that over the next 3 to 6 months, although we could break through that trend level that you were referencing, I don't think we're going to see some large rally from that.
14:13 Speaker 00 I want to get back to the discussion on how to position for this potential recession in just a second because I want to play a soundbite for you from a discussion between my colleague Sam Burke and David Rosenberg, a veteran economist who's from time to time rightfully labeled a permabear. And they discuss how to position for a pending recession. So let's listen to David and get back to that discussion.
14:46 Speaker 02 Nobody's a perfect market timer. I think that, you know, the way I see it,
14:54 Speaker 02 if you're going to want to turn bullish on equities, and although I have this title or label as the permabear, I'm dying to turn bullish on stocks. I'll tell you right now, my pledge is that I will be the first one out there with the pom poms on the sidelines when the time comes.
15:16 Speaker 02 The yield curve has to pivot. The Fed has to pivot to pivot the yield curve. That has to happen. So what I'm telling my clients, what I'm telling the viewers here is that there is not a snowballs' chance in hell that the stock market puts in a fundamental low. And all these rallies are bear market rallies. There's not a snowballs' chance in hell we hit the lows in the stock market in advance of a big rally in bonds. And this happens every cycle.
15:48 Speaker 00 The entire interview with David Rosenberg from our three idea series is available already today for subscribers on the Real Vision platform. Back to you, Eric. David is crystal clear in his communication here. There is not a snowballs chance in hell that equities will put in a fundamental low until the Fed is able to pivot the yield curve. Do you agree?
16:14 Speaker 01 I would agree with that. I mean, when you look at the current situation for equities and what you have lying ahead of you, there is, there's a lot to get through. You, the yield curve is where it is because of the view around the economy. And, and then so I think we have a very sort of treacherous time ahead from the, from an economic perspective. We have a very tough time ahead from a earnings estimates perspective, right? When you want to own stocks, when estimates, earnings estimates are rising, you want to own individual stocks
16:57 Speaker 01 when earnings estimates are rising. Owning a stock as the incremental information you're getting is negative has just never, has never worked. And I don't expect it to happen this time. And then even though the Fed is, you know, likely going to be, we're going to likely see their last rate hike in the next, you know, one to three meetings, QT is going to still, is still going to be there. And as we all know, you know, all the charts that people were showing from, you know, 2010 onwards around the correlation between at that time when the Fed was adding to their balance sheet and stock prices was very high.
17:41 Speaker 01 And the degree to which it's going in reverse is of proportions, 1.1 trillion dollars a year. And, you know, so far, I think the market has been somewhat, I think complacent around that. You know, so far, 550 billion has been drawn down on their balance sheet. However, it's been offset by the Treasury.
18:12 Speaker 01 Pulling money from their deposits at the Fed to the tune of, you know, 300 to 400 billion, depending on when you start looking and it's down 600 billion from the top. So that's been a significant offset. Those deposits are now below their target rate and can only, they can't go below zero. So there's only a certain amount that that can be drawn down further. So this is going to be a headwind that even when the Fed does stop hiking, quantitative tightening is going to continue. And so you have all these headwinds in front of you. And if the S and P was trading at, you know, 13, 14 times earnings, then I would argue,
18:55 Speaker 01 okay, maybe, you know, maybe it's all priced in, maybe some of it's priced in. But at 18 times earnings, it's actually the exact opposite where not only is it not priced in, it's actually pricing in some sort of, you know, market environment, et cetera. That's the exact opposite around what we're currently in and what is ahead of us.
19:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I can add that as long as the US Treasury adds dollars to the financial system, the Fed will essentially have to keep quantitative tightening running for longer, which is something to consider now that the debt ceiling is back in force. Eric, I want to talk about earnings. You briefly mentioned earnings yields in relation to the yield on money market funds. And if you look at the current earnings season, I would argue that it's not that bad yet. So what's your take on what we've seen so far from the earnings season? I think Microsoft is reporting right as we speak here. Have you been surprised to the upside and what's the outlook for the next quarter or two?
19:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I think that so far, you know, as you noted, earnings have been, I would say, mixed to fine, you know, the barometer.
20:08 Speaker 01 That I look at is, you know, where are forward estimates moving post, post the earnings reports and they've, they've trickled lower. We started January at around $226 for 2023. Right now we're about 22340. So they've only come down a, a small amount. You know, my outlook, we still have, you know, the next week and a half, we're going to get most of the S and P reporting, which is the capitalization. And I do expect those numbers to continue to come down and I don't think it's going to be a friendly, a friendly earning season. Now, one
20:45 Speaker 01 of the things that companies are able to do is initially is to cut expenses, benefit from the falling dollar. And so it's not going to be a cliff for their earnings. I think it's going to be a drag that is going to play out over a number of quarters. And we're going to look up at the middle of this year and instead of the earnings for this year being 22350, they're going to be, you know, 208, 210, 206, something like that. But it just may happen over the course of, of six months. And I think that the expense
21:26 Speaker 01 cutting is something that clearly is going on and is going to buffer, which it typically does, that initial drop in unit sales. And we saw this during prior recessions where, you know, I, I point to, you know, the year 2000 where estimates really didn't fall until we were, you know, really into 2001 and the market was hitting a high in September of, of 2000. And same thing with 07. Estimates really didn't get hit until 2008 and the market was hitting a high in October of 07. So these, you know, we're all looking at
22:08 Speaker 01 the markets every single day and every day feels like a lifetime. But if we take a step back, you know, we have to realize that these things, they do take, they do take time.
22:20 Speaker 00 Eric, if we look at the positioning across sectors heading into 2023, I noted how, for example, Bank of America's monthly investor survey showed that most investors had overweight positions in defensive sectors such as utilities, healthcare and consumer staples. And I also noted how such three sectors traded at pretty rich levels from a PE perspective heading into this year. So what do you make of defensive sectors, which by the way are rock bottom on the leaderboard so far this year, from a pricing and valuation perspective into such a recessionary scenario?
22:59 Speaker 01 So the defensive sectors are tough, and they're tough for a couple of reasons. As you noted, that they've been crowded, people playing the recession trade. And as you noted, part of that reason, as a result of that, have really underperformed this year as the narrative around a soft landing starts to take hold, and cyclical stocks have done very well. And so money has come out of some of the mega caps at the end of last year, have come out of defensives this year, and have gone into cyclicals. The reason why they're tricky is because, you know, they typically benefit from their
23:38 Speaker 01 dividend yields. And right now, though, their dividend yield just looks very small relative to the money market yields that are currently out there. And this is a dynamic that is really new, meaning that money markets have been yielding, you know, somewhere around zero for a good part of the last 15 years. So, you know, that makes them tricky. What also makes them tricky is that with inflation falling, it's not all positive. Clearly, it helps the Fed outlook, but the earnings outlook becomes challenging because your wages stay
24:17 Speaker 01 sticky, your fixed costs stay sticky, and you have challenges then on the revenue side. And companies, including consumer staples, have benefited from inflation, where prices of their goods have been rising faster. Then their cost structure and they've been able to take those margins. Well, now those are going to be going into reverse. They have competition on the dividend to rate front. And as you noted, they are, they still remain somewhat of a crowded long. So the outlook there is, you know, is, is pretty, I would say, challenging.
24:57 Speaker 00 We're going to take another quick break and be right back with more of today's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
25:07 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I can add that we received the news today that Walmart plans on increasing the wage for the average worker at Walmart. Anecdotal evidence that you're right, that the wage component will be sticky in companies such as Walmart in the consumer staple basket, even though prices have started to at least fade from a momentum perspective in the U.
25:34 Speaker 00 Eric, if we look at the other end of the leaderboard so far this year, we have cyclicals, as you rightly point to, but also consumer discretionary. And tech stocks are high on the leaderboard, right? Even Tesla is back in fashion, at least very short term here. So what do, what do you make of the positioning in the stocks that were so much in fashion through 2020 and 2021, such as tech stocks?
25:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, so tech stocks really, you know, have moved, moved quickly at the end of last year. Yeah, there was a really a big liquidation that was going on. And so it really reduced a lot of that exposure and a lot of that money has gone into cyclicals, which has caused industrials, financials, materials to really outperform sharply over the past few months. And so you've had the, you've had the tailwind from a view that the China reopen, opening is going to help those cyclical sectors. And then you had the money flows out of the fences and out of.
26:42 Speaker 01 And then this view that we could have a soft landing. I think one of the great trades out there is to take the other side of this cyclical rally. And I think it's going to play out over the course of the next, you know, six to nine months, where if you're, if we're heading into what I think is the likely scenario of at best, a zero-ish growth economy for the next year or two. And then, of course, at worst, something, you know, far worse than that. The last thing you're going to want to own are cyclicals. And the fact that right now they are close to local highs relative to the market.
27:27 Speaker 01 At the same time, the yield cover is doing what it's doing. And some of the data points that we're getting around the economy. To me, that's one of the, of the great trades that lies, you know, in front of us. And, and I would just say also that one of the beneficiaries of that is that investors could really embrace secular growth. And as people are looking for growth in a very difficult, you know, economic outlook, they could be, they could benefit. And a lot of those names have now been somewhat washed out from this, you know, trade,
28:11 Speaker 01 this popping of the bubble. And I think that when you think about the difficulties with defensive sectors that we described, difficulties with the cyclical sectors, secular growth could actually be a, I think probably will be an outperformer.
28:31 Speaker 00 Eric, we haven't touched upon the energy sector yet. It was more or less the darling of 2022 for many investors. And it was right about the only performing sector through the turbulence of, of 2022. So far this year, it's been flatlining, basically. I think it's up a percent or so since New Year's. What do you make of that sector in the context of this growth discussion for the next quarters?
28:59 Speaker 01 So with energy, I don't really have a, I don't really have a strong view there. I think that there is, there's a, there's a push-pull dynamic. I think on the one hand, Based on where commodity prices currently are, energy stocks for the most part are cheap. And they are printing a lot of cash. They've been very disciplined. And disciplined around capital spending. And so when you look at them as actual fundamental vehicles, they look, they look, they still look attractive. The issue is that, you know, what's the outlook for the commodity?
29:40 Speaker 01 And there are, the positives are remain a supply issue. And I think that will remain. There's a tailwind from the SPR that is a buyer at some level. On the other hand, if the economy does what I think it's going to do, that's going to be a significant offset to those potential supply issues or demand from the ultimate demand from the SPR. So I think it's really a, I think it's a tough, I think it's a tough picture. And I don't really have a strong, I don't really have a strong view there.
30:22 Speaker 00 Absolutely fair.
30:25 Speaker 00 Let's go to a couple of questions from our great members of Real Vision. We have a question from a loyal member, Paul, asking you about a viewpoint from Julian Brixton. He said on one of our shows that he expects the US to underperform Europe and emerging markets over the coming period as a consequence of a weaker dollar, but also as a consequence of weaker tech stocks. What do you make of that in the context of a recession?
30:54 Speaker 01 So the, the issue, so I would agree with that. However, I think the entry point on that trade is not great. Meaning that, you know, the US is underperformed by a lot over the course of the last few months. As, you know, the dollar's gotten hit, Europe has, looks like they're going to escape. You know, the issues this winter around around energy and you know, people are looking at the valuation discrepancy. So the my issue with it is that a lot has already been priced in. And so I think that I guess my view would be that I would look for I like that trade broadly.
31:37 Speaker 01 I just I'm not sure that from a tactical perspective, that now is the entry point. I think you're going to get a better entry point for that trade.
31:49 Speaker 00 I would tend to agree with that. Also, given how aggressive a rally that we've seen in my part of the world in Europe so far this year, and I can guarantee you that we are not out of the woods yet. At least I need some more confirmation before I I dare say so on the show. Eric, always a great pleasure to host you. You're just a wealth of knowledge around equity sectors and current pricing. If I am to sum up today's discussion, essentially, the rally that we've seen so far this year is a consequence of the very stretched positioning heading into the year, and we just needed that little one trigger from China to get things going. But as of now, the risk reward has clearly turned again. The risk is on the downside for equities over the
32:34 Speaker 00 next six to nine months. The yield curve essentially tells you to be on the watch for such a scenario. And if you were to pick one sector or one part of the equity markets watch out for the most, it would be cyclical. Anything to add to that summary, Eric?
32:51 Speaker 01 I think it's a I think it's a great summary, and I enjoy being here.
32:55 Speaker 00 Good stuff, Eric. Thank you so much for joining us on Real Vision Daily Briefing. Before we leave you out there, we have the meme of the day, and it's giraffe eating a couple of green shoots, asking whether that was all. Seriously, guys, was that all? Potentially, it was, at least if we listen to Eric Johnston from Cantor Fitzgerald. A great pleasure to host you, Eric, and my colleagues will be back with more tomorrow at the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
33:27 Speaker 03 What's up, revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest, and biggest names in finance.
Previous Is This Stock Breakout a Fake-out? Next The Options Market Has a Message Page updated October 27, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated