Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing The Present and Future of Chainlink About this episode 🚀 The Exponential Age is going to permanently change the world on every level, including your day-to-day life. Have it work in your favor - https://rvtv.io/3FAb8hjSergey Nazarov, co-founder of Chainlink, joins Ash Bennington to dive deep into the latest developments at Chainlink. From cross-chain solutions to defining the verifiable web, Sergey and Ash cover everything you need to know. Recorded November 8th. Check out The Exponenialist, Raoul Pal and David Mattin's new research service on how technology is reshaping our world and what the Exponential Age could bring us: https://www.realvision.com/thefutureUnlock the potential to showcase your brand to our global audience. Contact us at partnerships@realvision.com for advertising inquiries. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 People are going to lose their minds. This is a moment in history unlike anything humanity's gone through. It's a very different world for humans to come.
0:07 Speaker 01 Take a step back and see the broad picture, which is the way all these technologies are interlinked.
0:13 Speaker 00 Because this is all about exponentiality, and humans can't think in exponential terms.
0:17 Speaker 01 How consequential do you want to say machine intelligence is? It's almost certainly as consequential as writing. How long did writing take to disseminate through the human population? You know, hundreds, thousands of years. And we're dealing with it now on a scale of months.
0:33 Speaker 00 But in this kind of world, you're compounding 100% growth every year, and the numbers become astronomical.
0:40 Speaker 01 AI is going to spot patterns in the world that were just completely invisible to us.
0:45 Speaker 00 Even if you think that the AI and the robots are your demise, you might as well bloody invest in them and make some money out of it. If not, you're just going to be angry man shaking your fists at the clouds.
1:08 Speaker 02 Hey, everybody. Welcome back to Real Vision Pro Crypto. I'm joined today by Sergey Nazarov, co-founder of Chainlink. Sergey, welcome back to the show.
1:17 Speaker 03 Great to see you. Thanks for having me.
1:19 Speaker 02 Well, it's always a pleasure to have you here. I always enjoy these conversations because you're not afraid to go deep in the technology. And I know our Real Vision Pro viewers love to get a sense of what's going on under the hood. Sergey, it's been a while since we've done this. I know we've covered a lot of this material before, but big picture for folks who are relatively new to the picture, talk a little bit about Chainlink and the role that you see Oracles playing in the digital asset space.
1:43 Speaker 03 Sure, sounds good. So Oracles are an infrastructure that create consensus about various things that blockchains do not create consensus about. So blockchains create reliable transactions through consensus, through the ability to agree across a number of different systems, what that transaction is and to memorialize it across those systems. Blockchains create consensus on three things: private key signatures, token ledgers, and state machines called smart contracts. So that's the, those are the only things that blockchains create consensus and therefore cryptographic guarantees about.
2:23 Speaker 03 Everything else outside of blockchains, whether it's data, trust minimized computation, cross-chain communication, connectivity with any existing systems, basically all data, all computation, all connectivity, both between blockchains and between blockchains and existing systems, if you want that to be as secure and reliable as a blockchain, you need a system to do that. And the main system to do that, really the only system to do that, is oracle networks. And decentralized oracle networks is what Chainlink pioneered, which is basically an environment in which you can aggregate data that you feed into DeFi, you can do various computations that you can't do on a blockchain but still need
3:05 Speaker 03 to be decentralized and trust minimized, you can connect multiple blockchains to each other, you can connect existing bank systems to blockchains so they can use thousands of blockchains through one interface. All of these interactions need to be made as reliable as the blockchain itself, because they fundamentally control what's going on on-chain. And so if you leave the thing that's controlling the on-chain state insecure, easy to manipulate, easy for adversaries to access, then you break the security model, and you break the guarantees of those on-chain things. And so that's why Chainlink so far has processed approximately
3:47 Speaker 03 $9 trillion in transaction value through these decentralized oracle networks, because there are all these other things, whether that's data, or computation, or cross-chain connectivity, that on-chain contracts, on-chain things need in order to become more advanced. The parallel for the web world is that before you had the ability to connect applications to other systems, applications were very limited. So something like Uber couldn't exist until you were able to connect it to geolocation data about the user and the driver, or a text messaging system, or a payment system. You couldn't build Uber until you could connect it to all those other systems.
4:28 Speaker 03 That's what Oracle Networks do. They make all of these other systems available to blockchains, and they do some of the computations themselves, and they create connectivity among chains for these more advanced applications like real-world asset tokens, more advanced DeFi, actually all DeFi, insurance, trade finance applications. All of these more advanced applications require Oracle Networks, because they need that data, that additional computation, and/or that additional connectivity to other chains or to existing systems.
5:04 Speaker 02 Well, Sergey, I'm glad I asked. That's your simplest and most elegant explanation so far about what Oracles do. You know, in the simplest sense, what I hear you saying is essentially, this is about taking security that exists on-chain and finding a mechanism for connecting it off-chain. I think most people know, for example, the Bitcoin network has never been hacked, but this is about finding ways of connecting off-chain data in a way that is cryptographically secured by the properties of mathematics and physics to things that are off-chain. And I think that really is the core, sort of cornerstone of what you're talking about with Oracle Networks.
5:40 Speaker 03 And also across chains. So basically, anything going into or out of a blockchain, which is a lot more things than people think, and anything that happens between a chain, between multiple chains, to create what we call the Internet of Contracts, to create this kind of globally connected Internet of multiple chains, so that applications can exist across multiple chains, not just in one chain. It's both the connectivity in and out, which includes all data, all payments, all systems interactions, and the connectivity between chains. So anything that ever touches a blockchain, whether it's another chain, or whether it's a data source, or whether it's a bank system,
6:23 Speaker 03 or whether it's a payment system, or whether it's a central bank, digital currency system, all of those things need to be securely and deterministic connected, and basically made to be as secure and as reliable as the chain itself, because there are critical dependencies. They become dependencies that if those dependencies break, the chain's ability to execute its more advanced functions, like DeFi, like RWA, becomes basically impossible. And that's why more advanced functionalities of blockchains only appeared after oracle networks appeared. That's why DeFi was sub 100 million when Chainlink came into existence and it grew to over 200 billion.
7:07 Speaker 03 And Chainlink powered, you know, the vast majority of that and still powers the majority of that in different categories of DeFi. And so that's because you really can't make certain applications like DeFi without an oracle network. Because, for example, financial products, which is what much of DeFi is, is basically the conditions of an agreement, the financial conditions, and the data. So even your bank account that gives you a yield is basically the conditions under which you get the yield. And it's the data telling what yield to give, what is the current yield from the federal funds rate or whatever the data source is to decide the yield.
7:45 Speaker 03 And so all of that getting replicated on chain needs to happen at the high security standards of the chain. So that you have this kind of holistic application, this verifiable application that can act in this way throughout its operation, not just in the on-chain part, but in every part, other part of what it does.
8:09 Speaker 02 Yeah. And for people who are relatively new to the technology, this has been something of the Achilles heel of blockchains outside of the Chainlink world. Virtually every major sort of cross-platform bridge attack or hack that we've heard about in the last two years here, we've been covering it on Real Vision, Crypto and Real Vision Crypto Pro, has been about these, finding out the vulnerabilities that exist in cross-chain bridges, in smart contracts and other mechanisms where you're actually working off-chain in the major protocols.
8:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. All of these problems are actually the same problem. There are consensus and security problem about different types of data.
8:49 Speaker 03 So Chainlink began with market data, then it evolved into being the largest provider of market data and proof of reserve, then providing identity data, then doing computation, and now also to cross-chain. And cross-chain is also a data problem because the movement of a token is basically data. You're moving data about this token goes from here to here. And our system can also add instructions as another type of data to the token, so that when it arrives at the destination, it can actually trigger smart contract events without anyone having to integrate into that chain. And so the real challenge here is how to efficiently give smart contracts and verifiable
9:32 Speaker 03 applications, various types of data, various types of off-chain trust minimized computation, various connectivity, maintaining the highest level of security, and we have five levels of security that, you know, I hope we can cover about the different levels of what defines the security of systems like this. And then also making it easy for existing systems to integrate with all of that, so that you can accelerate the speed at which capital markets, asset managers, banks, trade finance, all of these existing sources of value can integrate with all of these chains together with all of this data, which is what they actually need to make their more advanced applications.
10:14 Speaker 02 Yeah, and this is what's really fascinating, what you guys are doing with CCIP and other technologies. I know folks' ears have just sort of perked up. If you're thinking about RWA, real-world assets here in crypto, not risk-weighted assets. I know my fellow legacy finance people think of it that way, but in the crypto space, obviously, we're talking about connecting real-world assets on-chain, which I think has the potential to really bridge these two worlds between traditional finance and decentralized finance. Sergey, you guys are doing some interesting stuff with some of the infrastructure providers in the space. I'm talking here about DTCC, I'm talking here about SWIFT. Talk a little bit about what you guys are doing and how it fits into the broader vision that you have for integrating the digital asset space and traditional finance.
11:02 Speaker 03 I think RWA is the place where a lot of capital markets activity, banks, asset managers, many of which hold multiple trillions of dollars in value individually. So there are individual firms. Some of the firms that we work with, like ANC Bank in Australia, has over a trillion dollars in assets under management. And there are others that have multiple trillions in assets under management. And basically, that's the whole size of our industry, just in one participant, in one market participant in that part of the world. And those folks are very good at generating various financial products. That's what they've been doing for, some of them for over 100 years. And basically, RWAs are a type of packaged financial product or asset of some kind.
11:46 Speaker 03 The main thing about RWAs is real world. And real world basically means connection to the real world, which necessitates data. Real world assets are actually defined by their ability to gain access to data reliably and to prove things about themselves. Like, I'll give you an example from the proof of reserves part of what Chainlink does with gold coins. Gold coins necessarily need to prove, if they're good, that they have the gold, right? That every unit of gold coin, every single unit on chain, represents a corresponding unit of gold off-chain. And ideally, you don't want to wait for an annual audit. You want that to happen in real time, which is what proof of reserves does, and Chainlink is the largest provider of that, of proof of reserves.
12:31 Speaker 03 So for real world assets, we're already the largest provider for the ones that exist, various gold coins and stable coins. And capital markets, banks and asset managers have a lot of experience with real world things, with basically packaging various things into financial products. So there's a very natural, it's a very natural place for them to start. It doesn't mean that they're making an advanced DeFi protocol. That's not the stage that that's at necessarily, but I think that that is, that's where we'll all go, that they will eventually have their own DeFi protocols, that they will work on together with the existing Web3 DeFi protocols. But if we just talk about RWA, I think you're right, that's a place where the intersection
13:12 Speaker 03 of this technology with capital markets is already happening, and where it will be valuable to both the other capital markets participants and to the Web3 users. Because I think that collateral, the real world assets that are generated by banks and asset managers will be valuable collateral to Web3. So in that context, the market infrastructures that you mentioned, like SWIFT and DTCC, definitely see significant demand. And all of these infrastructures, as well as banks and asset managers and various institutions, they are fundamentally driven by demand. And this is what I've been saying on your show, I think, for years. And what I've been saying in many other places for years is that the demand of their user base,
13:56 Speaker 03 the demand of their clients will fundamentally drive them to adopt blockchains as a superior format for value and transactions of certain types. And RWA is indeed a place where that transition is actively happening and moving towards production readiness. And we're in multiple conversations with large banks and asset managers that are in discussions with us about production. So not POC, not pilot, but production. Real value transactional usage of the system on a consistent growing basis for significant asset classes. The role that the market infrastructures that you mentioned have is to enable banks
14:40 Speaker 03 and asset managers to do those transactions in efficient and legally compliant ways. SWIFT is a very widely used standard for banks and asset managers to define their relationship with each other through a set of messages and actually kind of a definitional standard for what is a bond, what is an equity, what is a cash transaction, what are the properties of that transaction, what are the features that we want in our transaction? And everyone is kind of speaking the same language. SWIFT is kind of like the English of the financial world, where most banks and most asset managers speak it. And so the work that we're doing with SWIFT is finding a way to use that widely accepted
15:24 Speaker 03 standard that's already defined what an equity is, what a commodity is, what a cash transaction is. And repurpose it and use it for blockchain interaction. And the benefit there is that the SWIFT system, the SWIFT private key signing infrastructure, the SWIFT infrastructure that's been around for over 50 years now and has successfully processed quadrillions upon quadrillions of dollars can continue to be used by banks for interactions with blockchains. And then the benefit to the blockchain industry is that those 11,000 plus banks that are on the SWIFT system, which is the largest collection of banks on any system, are accelerated in the way that they're able to interact with blockchains,
16:07 Speaker 03 which means that their clients, their assets under management can reach blockchain sooner. Yes, they might reach private blockchains of that specific bank or of other banks that they're used to transacting with before they reach public blockchains. Yes, that will happen. But that is a critical incremental step. And the magnitude of the amount of money that we're talking about, you know, SWIFT settles quadrillions of dollars in value. DTCC on annual basis settles quadrillions of dollars in value. DTCC is basically the settlement infrastructure for the entire US securities industry. DTCC is also about efficiency, but it's largely around
16:50 Speaker 03 making transactions legally compliant so that those transactions can be settled and everyone can rely on their legal force.
16:59 Speaker 02 We're going to take a quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
17:08 Speaker 02 So the basic difference here is for, you know, and I think this stuff is so critical for people to understand, to understand the existing infrastructure that we have in TradFi today and where we're moving in the digital asset age. So I think of SWIFT as essentially as a standards body that defines the messaging formats. These are the technologies that are used to handle the interchange of information between banks globally. DTCC, Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation here in the United States settles something like 90% plus of US equities and I think 85 to 90% of all securities. These transactions, we're talking again, quadrillions of dollars, 10 to the 15. I mean, it's just an almost inconceivable magnitude, particularly relative to the size of the digital asset space.
17:51 Speaker 02 And building these infrastructure standards, while it may seem a little bit technical, this is about the fundamental basis of connecting the traditional finance system that we live in today to the blockchain-based decentralized system that many of us in this space believe we're moving towards. So it just, it could not be more important from a fundamental infrastructure perspective.
18:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, I think that's right. I think right now we have these two worlds. So we have the public blockchain world that we're more familiar with and we're longtime users of and believers in. And that has grown past the trillion dollars. It's continuing to go well past the trillion dollars. And I think it'll go to multiple trillions, just off of a user base like you and me and other random people and hedge funds and whoever, right? And that'll happen. But realistically, there's an entire other world with hundreds of trillions of dollars, which has traditionally managed value, has traditionally managed equities, commodities, funds, all these other vehicles where value is held and transacted in. And that part of the world does have a huge benefit from blockchains.
18:58 Speaker 03 They just have to move slower because they have so many requirements. They have security requirements because when you manage trillions of dollars, you have security requirements. They have legal requirements because when you manage trillions of dollars for over 100 years, there's legal frameworks you have to abide by or else you get shut down. And so the amount of boxes that they need to check really is quite large. And the force that leads them to check those boxes is the client demand. The client demand has been very high and it only continues to grow. And now I'm seeing multiple capital markets folks have dedicated digital asset teams. So the thing that I saw before, because I've been working with banks and asset managers and SWF for well over six, seven years now.
19:43 Speaker 03 And the people I was speaking with before were in the innovation group. And the innovation group is a kind of general launchpad for a number of ideas where ideas kind of begin. Now, the conversations we're having with every bank, asset manager, infrastructure, there are people with a digital asset title. So there's a head of digital assets, there's a digital asset tech lead, there's digital asset product managers, there's digital asset managing directors. So there are now dedicated teams. Some of these bigger banks, at this point, I think I've surpassed over 100 people across these multiple teams. And these teams are focused on digital asset adoption, digital asset products, digital asset implementation.
20:24 Speaker 03 And that is driven by the client demand that I mentioned a few years ago and even, you know, previously, I think, when we talked. And then the client demand is that's driving the banks and the asset managers to invest in these digital asset teams, to make these digital asset offerings, is then something the financial market infrastructures like SWIFT and DTCC and others look at to say, okay, this is a trend that I need to service. Because the financial markets infrastructures view the banks and the asset managers as their user base. So what we're doing is we're working with all of those categories of folks with CCIP, with data, with identity, with all these key building blocks.
21:07 Speaker 03 And we're allowing them to reach the point of doing production transactions. So for example, with RWAs, you can't make an RWA without something like proof of reserves. Then you need to add identity data if you want another bank or asset manager to purchase it because they need to comply with AML KYC and therefore they need identity information attached to the asset. And then you need to settle the asset's value daily through NAV or price or some other thing. So that's already three pieces of data, just to have one RWA. So we enable them to generate that RWA. But then, once they generate the RWA, their second problem is liquidity and access to the many different chains from which people could purchase the RWA.
21:52 Speaker 03 That's where CCIP comes in and allows the various other banks, asset managers, CSDs, all the other market participants to connect to that RWA. And because of the efficiencies created by how CCIP is designed, to gain access to that in a way that can keep them on their own systems. So they can stay in their system, they can stay on their own chain, and they can still access your RWA, even purchase it and have it returned to them. And by lowering this integration burden by all the customers that you would want to buy your RWA, we can rapidly increase the size of the market that can access your RWA, which is the fundamental thing that RWA creators want. They want a market that will purchase that asset.
22:35 Speaker 03 And then the third problem that gets, that needs to be solved and is getting solved with our help is once the RWA moves from the chain where it is created into the chain where it is purchased, you want it to remain updated. You want the real world asset to remain real world. And because the real world asset was created using a set of data standards that is compatible with the system that moved the asset. So namely, you use the chain link data standards like proof of reserves to make the RWA asset. The chain link identity standard to comply with the MLKYC. The chain link price standards to create a daily settlement price for the asset. And then you also move that over CCIP, which is compatible with all that.
23:19 Speaker 03 You're now able to get an asset that whether it goes to chain B and then it gets resold to chain C and gets resold to chain D, it will remain updated. It will remain what is known as a golden record. And so it's not just about making the better assets. It's about making them, connecting them to liquidity, connecting them to all the counterparties that want to gain access to them. And allowing those assets to remain connected to all the data, to all the systems, while they move across many, eventually hundreds of different chains, so that the asset can be resold and maintain its real world properties.
23:59 Speaker 02 Gosh, there's so much to talk about here in terms of the functional mechanics, but I want to talk a little bit about what's happening behind the scenes in these meetings and conversations that you're part of. I think often we hear about this sort of framed as a TradFi versus DeFi conversation. What you're saying is that there are significant teams on the ground at large banks in the standards-making body. In the clearing corporations that are connecting, running the financial plumbing. Talk a little bit about how you understand the status of those conversations and the framework that the people who are working at the world's largest financial institutes, institutions think about this technology and how it's going to change the world
24:40 Speaker 02 that they live in, in terms of the actual mechanics of how these things work.
24:47 Speaker 03 Sure, absolutely. Just to be super clear, my view is that TradFi is DeFi's biggest customer, eventually. That's just, that's just how the world's gonna go, in my opinion. It's, it's kind of an inescapable reality, because the only thing stopping it now is lack of legal clarity for how TradFi could use DeFi. But that legal clarity is gradually appearing. And DeFi, because it's in the public chain world and because it, it has a different risk tolerance, will consistently have higher returns. You will consistently be able to get larger yields on the same dollar, on the same set of assets in DeFi, because of the propensity to experiment, the ability to take risk and all this stuff.
25:30 Speaker 03 And in the TradFi world, you have a bunch of people that, that have a desire for more yield, even if there is more risk. And the, the size of that is, in my opinion, that even, even on the high spectrum of what people are willing to take on risk for, is in the tens of trillions. So, this DeFi versus TradFi thing doesn't really make sense, because they're all just trying to do transactions. They're actually very similar transactions, and all the transactions are motivated by basic economic laws of yield and supply and demand. And as long as the counterparty can be made reliable, which is the point of DeFi, right?
26:13 Speaker 03 The point of DeFi is not to have any kind of biased thing toward you or me or anyone else. It's to make the counterparty cryptographically reliable, cryptographically guaranteed, in a way that's better than TradFi counterparties. And if you just ask yourself, why, as a TradFi counterparty, would I choose a less reliable counterparty? Why would I choose someone less reliable to transact with? They wouldn't. And if you have a more reliable counterparty in the form of a DeFi protocol, and if you have the legal compliance clarity to do that transaction, and the yield and returns from that protocol is higher than the other TradFi counterparties you have,
26:55 Speaker 03 then you are now the, you are going towards that. So I think it's a kind of misunderstanding, and I think it's a thing where people think that the existing financial system is trying to mess, screw them over. In some cases, that does happen. There are cases where people maliciously use the existing financial system. But the existing financial system is just a big collection of a number of firms trying to make money. And if they can make more money by integrating with DeFi while still complying with the law, that's what they're gonna do. So that's, the DeFi versus StrayFi thing just doesn't make sense to me. It's all gonna be one big internet of contracts.
27:35 Speaker 03 And what we're doing is we've already created very widely adopted standards in Web 3, in the public blockchain world. That's the first stage of kind of the plan that we have. The second stage is getting those same standards adopted by the capital markets for data, computation, and cross-chain communications. So that when you're in Web 3 and you want to transact and you need a settlement price, you want to use the chain link price because it's the most reliable, secure price. When you're in the capital markets and you want to transact, you need the chain link price because it's the most reliable, secure price. You want to send some token to someone else? Okay, great. You know, you need a shared standard for that.
28:16 Speaker 03 That's the same standard ideally in Web 3, public chains and private chains. And then eventually, if both of these worlds are on the same standard, in stage 3 of the plan, once the legal barrier between them goes down, they can merge into a single global internet of contracts worth hundreds of trillions. So that's what I think is gonna happen there. In terms of the banks and asset managers, in terms of stage 2 of that, what I'm basically seeing is that there is significant demand for tokenized assets, real-world assets.
28:51 Speaker 03 That I think will lead to the next stage of demand for yield on those assets, which is also what I've been saying for years. So the banks will now create their own real world assets. And then they will seek to generate yield on those assets for their clients, the banks and the asset managers. So what I'm seeing with these infrastructures, what I'm seeing with the banks and the asset managers is that the client demand is there. And that is driving them to invest in more people, in more systems, in more connectivity to each other, in more RWAs, which will initially emerge in a way that works between two banks.
29:34 Speaker 03 But will eventually become the financial products that we all use on the Internet of Contracts. Eventually, what I think will happen is that you and me will be able to access institutional-grade financial products. We won't have to be a bank. We won't have to be a multi-hundred-million-dollar hedge fund. Because all of those financial products will be on-chain. And fundamentally, the banks and the asset managers want to sell more of them. So they will initially sell them to the counterparties that they know and they can transact with in a legally compliant way. Basically, because they cannot do it in a legally compliant way with the other counterparties.
30:17 Speaker 02 Right.
30:18 Speaker 03 But once they've done that enough, and because there is another market, a very large market, I eventually think you and me will gain access to tokenized private equity, tokenized carbon credits. We will be able to buy a token about the insurance cash flows, about a specific shipment of a specific type of good only. And the reason we don't have that now is because of all of the complexity of that.
30:47 Speaker 02 Right.
30:47 Speaker 03 But we are a market for that. And we are actually a market that will pay a premium for that over the banks and the more sophisticated people that buy that in volume. So it'll all merge into one big global Internet of Contracts, hopefully on the same set of standards provided by Chainlink for data, compute, and cross-chain connectivity.
31:10 Speaker 02 We're going to take another quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
31:21 Speaker 02 So let me just see if I understand this because these are some really big ideas that we're talking about here and people know I get excited about this technology but I think what we're talking about here is something that's truly profound. So what you're saying essentially is solving the counterparty trust issue upfront is the issue that you guys are working on right now. In other words, making sure that when there's a claim about, a claim on assets, that those can be cryptographically verified in ways that use the laws of mathematics and physics rather than trust. But beyond that, once that problem is solved, you essentially have the infrastructure in place to solve issues of transparency. People remember going back to the 2008 era, some of the challenges that we had with not knowing what counterparties had what, right? This was a huge challenge in the traditional banking system. It created
32:05 Speaker 02 a tremendous amount of fear. You saw things like spiking TED Spads, all of these measures of interbank, interbank illiquidity rising very dramatically. If you can solve these counterparty issues, you can solve the transparency issues and then you have essentially a permissionless network whereby the end users for this don't necessarily need to be banks. Essentially, what you're saying is you can expand that market to virtually anti-potential counterparty. This is just a huge quantum shift in the way that the technology gets done because essentially you're, you're creating all of the trust verifiable pieces that financial intermediaries provide today. It gets built into the network itself.
32:47 Speaker 03 That's right. At the end of the day, we're all going to end up at stage three and stage three is a single global internet of contracts that's just like the internet of today. The internet of today is about information technology. It's about the transmission of information. Even right now, this is the transmission of information. And when information technology began, there were separate siloed intranets, they were disconnected from each other, you know, information wasn't encrypted, so ecommerce couldn't happen because credit cards couldn't purchase things. There were all these problems, all these basic infrastructure problems. And it created this disjointed, disconnected internet thing without a lot of valuable applications. But eventually those infrastructures, infrastructure problems became solved. Credit card numbers
33:30 Speaker 03 were encrypted and were used in ecommerce. VoIP became a thing and people could communicate. Images, image compression improved and images went on websites and website load times went down and you had social media and all this stuff. What I'm talking about is the Internet of Value. I'm talking about a single global Internet of Contracts, where, just like on the current Internet, there are certain systems you can access and certain systems you can't access, unless you go through certain steps. But you're on a global, single Internet. You don't join the Goldman Sachs Internet to use the Goldman Sachs thing on the Internet, right? You're just on the Internet. And you can use Goldman Sachs, and you can use BlackRock,
34:15 Speaker 03 and you can use Fidelity, and you can use whoever, as long as you meet their requirements. And their goal is to keep those requirements lower and lower, so that they can get more users. Right. So what I'm saying is, we need a global standard like TCP/IP, what's for the Internet, which is what CCIP is, for those connections between the chains to happen. We need a set of data standards, so that when you and me want to transact, we can agree on a settlement price. We need a set of computational standards, so that when your contract is partly on-chain and partly off-chain, I can evaluate the security of your contract. And I can know that its security meets my standards, without having to read each line of code in your contract
35:00 Speaker 03 and each line of code of the off-chain system. And so, these standards appearing are what we've already done in the Web3 world, where the majority of those types of transactions are settled with chain link fees. And the majority of high-value automation computations happen on chain link automation, and so on. And now, we need to replicate that to this other, separate Internet of Contracts. So there will be these two separate worlds, which is the framing of our discussion, right? There's these two separate worlds. But those parallel separate worlds will eventually converge into one global Internet of Contracts that you and me will be on, that institutions will be on,
35:45 Speaker 03 that everyone and everything will be on. And it will all need to transact in a verifiable, cryptographically guaranteed way. And that verifiability and cryptographic guarantee will depend on the security of the system providing it. And that's what we're doing. We're generating all of that security, all of those standards, beyond what's in a blockchain, so that blockchains can achieve this level of connectivity and this level of advanced applications. Whether it's about equities, or commodities, or trade finance, or ad networks, or gaming, or anything, because they all have the same problem. It's the same fundamental technical problem. And that's also why so far, our system has processed, enabled the transactions of approximately
36:29 Speaker 03 nine trillion in value. I think that's a low number, based on the amount of value that's going to be flowing through all of these different tokens, all of these RWAs, all of these different DeFi protocols, trade finance, and so on. So I still think we're in the early to mid-stages, because now we're seeing the stage two, the capital market stage. When we get to the middle of the capital market stage, and a bunch of capital markets participants are on one set of standards like Chainlink for data and cross-chain, then we will accelerate towards stage three, where transactions between public chains, and private chains, and bank chains begin to happen. And then if those transactions are economically attractive, if they are attractive from the
37:12 Speaker 03 point of view of profit for the capital markets, and there is legal clarity as to how to do more of them, then the rate at which that transition to stage three will happen, in my opinion, should be very quick. Because the economic force, the economic demand is there. And that's what, that's the funny thing about all this. That's the same force driving both of these markets, but somehow, some people still believe that these markets will be driven in parallel separately forever, experiencing the same exact economic forces and preferences. And like, that just doesn't make any sense to me.
37:53 Speaker 03 What makes sense is they will converge into a single global market, ideally on a single set of global standards for data, trust minimized off-chain compute, and cross-chain, and that's what CCIP is, and that's kind of the body of work we're working on.
38:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, and it's fascinating, because ultimately what this means is decreased costs, rising system and network availability, and the ability to embed the logic of the systems within the network to end users, so that you can do all kinds of interesting things in terms of having non-third-party mediated contracts, for example, where you can have the trust built into the network, so that when conditions are met, payment gets made, or securities gets transferred. Essentially, you have a Turing-complete monetary system.
38:42 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's, that's right. So what you end up getting is the promise, the full promise of smart contracts. That RWAs represent and DeFi represents and decentralized trade finance represents and decentralized insurance represents. You arrive at that and the way that our infrastructure is being built is to take full advantage of that. And on multiple levels. So, so the first key design decision is security. And there are these five levels of cross-chain security where you basically go from a single server at level one. Multiple servers controlled by one key holder at level two. So that's distributed computing pretending to be decentralized. Level three being multiple independent nodes with multiple independent key holders.
39:27 Speaker 03 Chainlink started out at level three, about three, four years ago and quickly went beyond it to level four. Where you can make multiple separate networks and then level five, which is where Chainlink is now for things like CCIP. Where you have multiple separate networks generating a single lane or a single bridge. So the, the first key property to generate this programmatic future that you described where value can be put in is security. People need to know that the systems they're putting value into will be secure and reliable. And will continue to allow their value to exist and be safe. And be able to be transacted in a reliable way, even if it moves to another chain. Even if it's dependent on a piece of data, even if it needs to go do a computation that it can't do on chain.
40:12 Speaker 03 Even if it needs to interact with an AI, even if an AI needs to do something to it. All of these interactions need to be made safe and reliable. The second key property is actually using the programmatic properties of smart contracts in the right way. So for example, when you combine Chainlink data with Chainlink automation, you can actually trigger contracts with data. So you can use the programmatic automated properties of contracts together with Oracle Networks. To get more and more advanced programmatic functionality. Similarly with CCIP, what you're able to do is you're able to take an existing standard like SWIFT. You're able to, within that standard, define, I want to go to blockchain X.
40:54 Speaker 03 I want to go to smart contract Y and I would like to trigger smart contract function Z. Like the buy function. And then you're able to attach those instructions. To a token, to a blockchain token. And then that token reaches the chain where the smart contract is and where the real world asset can be purchased. It purchases the token and it sends it back to you without you having to integrate with that chain.
41:25 Speaker 02 Sergey, can I just ask you a question? I know we've gone into the weeds a little bit here on the technology, but I don't want to leave people with this view that it's all rainbows and bunny rabbits. There are some real challenges here and you mentioned one of them, which is the legal regulatory compliance aspect of it. We've got stuff like AML KYC OFAC compliance on the one hand, securities laws on the other. I know that you're not a lawyer, but give us a sense of how you see this unfolding because there are material problems that need to be solved before the technological challenges can actually be met and implemented in production. Talk a little bit about how you see that process unfolding at the high level.
42:02 Speaker 03 Sure, makes sense. You're right, that is one of the hurdles. That's why TradFi has taken so long to enter this market. And if you want to gain a sense of how quickly TradFi will be able to enter this market, one thing you could do is understand the parts of the world where there is more clarity about how to transact using blockchains. And the more clarity that appears, the more that barrier will decrease. But you're right, that barrier exists in different ways. There is an identity level to it where identity requirements are baked into the financial system as a hard requirement. And so Chainlink, for example, has systems like Deco where identity information can
42:45 Speaker 03 be verified, but you get back a zero knowledge proof and you don't have to share the identity data on chain, which is another legal requirement.
42:55 Speaker 02 Let me ask you a question because there's also challenges. We talked about the challenges from the legal regulatory compliance infrastructure on the TradFi side, but there's also the sort of the questions, I think, in the DeFi slash blockchain space. For example, if you go up to the Ethereum homepage and you command F for the words credible. Neutrality and and and uncensorability. You see that this is a major thesis here in the blockchain blockchain space, where folks are very reticent, hesitant about being included in AML KYC. This is kind of a culture clash type of issue. How do you how do you see that shaking out? Because I know that there's some skepticism about anything that interfaces with traditional finance system on the blockchain slash DeFi side.
43:42 Speaker 03 You don't have to do AML KYC if you don't want to. And and you'll just miss out on a certain class of products that already exists with centralized exchanges in the crypto industry. So if you don't want to use a centralized exchange, you're already going to have this problem. It's a common recurring problem already for our industry. Um, I think there will be protocols, RWAs, various assets that don't require that. I think there will be a market for people that want to interface with that. And as long as it complies with their local laws and their personal goals, then I'm fine with that. I have a very libertarian view on people being able to make choices about what's right for them. If there are parts of the world where that is a requirement, and that part of the world is able to generate high quality real world assets.
44:27 Speaker 03 And then there are counterparties that are willing to comply with that requirement in order to access those real world assets, then that's another example of choice. Right? So so my goal is is not to say the world has to work this way or has to work that way. My my goal is to help create infrastructure with a large and growing community of engineers, researchers, non-technical people, a whole bunch of great people, so that there are standards and there is a shared language between chains and there's a shared data standard. And there is a way to generate all these applications in a secure, reliable way. And then people can generate those applications on whatever meets their personal goals.
45:08 Speaker 03 So there will be certain applications that you can only access if you're a citizen of a certain country. And that'll just be the choice of the application. But that's not my choice and that's not our choice. That's the choice of that application creator. And then there will be other users that don't want to comply with that. Requirement, they don't want to disclose their identity, they don't want to do various things. And that's their choice and they will exist in their own universe of applications. And I believe that all of these applications can exist on the same set of fundamental low level standards. But the the real goal, I think, is to create the largest pie possible. To create the largest collection of all types of assets that appeal to all types of preferences from all types of users.
45:53 Speaker 03 And that's what the internet is, right?
45:55 Speaker 02 Right.
45:56 Speaker 03 That's what that's what we want the internet to be. That's what we say when we say we want the internet to become more decentralized. We don't mean we want only this type of world, only that type of world. We want a world where various groups can make various choices about how they interact with each other using information technology.
46:13 Speaker 02 Yeah.
46:13 Speaker 03 And and that's the same basic idea for crypto infrastructure. And there will be applications that some people will not be able to interact with because of their choice about the standards that they want to meet. And that's fine.
46:28 Speaker 02 And to your point, that's exactly what happened in the internet. You essentially have this infrastructure build out happening. You have these protocol stacks being built out. You have layers of availability of services. You can interact with them in ways that make sense based on the applications that you want to fulfill. Sergey, I know we ran long, we always do, but what a great conversation. I always appreciate you coming to join us. Final thoughts, key takeaways that you'd like to leave our viewers with from this conversation?
46:59 Speaker 03 I think our industry
47:02 Speaker 03 will decouple from the larger tech sector
47:07 Speaker 03 in a more and more meaningful way because people will understand that it is a
47:14 Speaker 03 failure resistant technology. So there are technologies that are not resistant to economic problems that are luxuries. And then there are technologies that help solve.
47:29 Speaker 03 Economic prices. I think we are moving towards some class of economic crisis in various economies. Because of, you know, really, really weird, but perhaps necessary, I can't tell. Economic decisions by various large actors, basically. And I think there will be a reckoning for all of that value and all of, all of that. And I do believe that.
47:57 Speaker 03 Blockchain technology will be gradually adopted. For its massive benefits, some of the benefits we discussed here. And it'll do well in a, in a market where everyone wants to interact with more assets. But I also believe that if there is a economic crisis. That blockchains will be the solution. To creating a more transparent, more reliable world. That doesn't depend on brands. But it depends on cryptographic proof. Such that your ownership is not guaranteed through a password to a database. But through an application that controls your private key on your phone.
48:38 Speaker 03 Or your reliance on an insurance company will not be based on the reliance that they have the logo above Grand Central. It will not be that they have the biggest building with the best logo. It will be based on cryptographically verifiable mathematical truths. That they can never deviate from. And that you can verify before you connect your value to their insurance policies. I think that.
49:05 Speaker 03 This world will occur. I've been talking about it for many years. I'm consistently wrong because I'm, I'm one of these kind of pessimistic people that doesn't understand why. The current global financial system keeps chugging along in the current state that it's in. I understand a little bit more now about why it does, and there are actually good reasons for that in certain ways. But I still believe that there will be a global connect correction back to reality. And that blockchain technologies. Like imagine if there's a bunch of solvency issues, imagine there's a bunch of big issues in the world. And then people ask themselves, well, how do we avoid these issues? How do I know your solvency reserves? How do I control my assets, private keys? How do I know that the financial product won't just take my money?
49:48 Speaker 03 DeFi, you know, this is the world that that I do believe we will end up in. It's just hard to tell at what speed and what will be the the order of the of the market dynamics, of the failures of existing systems or the demand for real world assets that will drive this sooner. But I remain convinced that it will happen. The timeline is not clear to me, but I remain completely convinced that it will happen.
50:15 Speaker 02 Sergio Nazarab, always a pleasure when you join us.
50:18 Speaker 03 Great, great to speak with you again. Thank you for having me.
50:21 Speaker 02 Thanks for watching, everyone.
50:28 Speaker 00 People are going to lose their minds. This is a moment in history unlike anything humanity's gone through. It's a very different world for humans to come.
50:35 Speaker 01 Take a step back and see the broad picture, which is the way all these technologies are interlinked.
50:42 Speaker 00 Because this is all about exponentiality and humans can't think in exponential terms.
50:46 Speaker 01 How consequential do you want to say machine intelligence is? It's almost certainly as consequential as writing. How long did writing take to disseminate through the human population? You know, hundreds, thousands of years, and we're dealing with it now on a scale of months.
51:02 Speaker 00 But in this kind of world, you're compounding 100% growth every year, and the numbers become astronomical.
51:08 Speaker 01 AI is going to spot patterns in the world that were just completely invisible to us.
51:13 Speaker 00 Even if you think that the AI and the robots are your demise, you might as well bloody invest in and make some money out of it. If not, you're just going to be angry man shaking your fists at the clouds.
Previous Is Inflation Finally Tamed? Next Is the Green Transition at a Crossroads? Page updated October 20, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated