Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing The Next Big Trade - Nick Halaris Explains Why He’s Still Bullish on the U.S. Housing Market About this episode Here’s a full-length episode from Real Vision's original series, The Next Big Trade - be sure to subscribe. The U. S. housing market boomed during the COVID-19 pandemic. Demand surged, as low interest rates fed a desire to find more space. What happens now, with the average 30-year mortgage rate up to 5.5% from 3.0% at the beginning of 2022? Nick Halaris of Metros Capital believes the market will remain resilient, and he explains why in a fascinating episode of The Next Big Trade. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,726 words · 3 speakers
0:03 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, you should check out the full finance journey at realvision.com/nextbigtrade to get the full view of what Real Vision is all about. A video on-demand platform you can watch anywhere. Our members get daily videos and analysis, plus access to more than 3,000 videos for beginners and experienced investors alike, and live events online. You'll join the most thoughtful community in finance. More than 300,000 people who trust Real Vision to be the anchor to truth in the financial world. To get started, visit realvision.com/nextbigtrade and use promo code NBT20 to get 20% off our Plus membership for your first year. Enjoy the show.
0:46 Speaker 01 The American dream, which was supposed to be about giving people the opportunity to rise up, the social status or the class status, whatever you want to call it, has now become the main channel by which wealth and equality is proliferating across the country. If you own a house in the right place, you just do better and better and better. And if you don't, you do worse and worse and worse.
1:12 Speaker 02 Hi everyone and welcome to the Next Big Trade. I'm your host, Harry Malandrew, from MI2 Partners. On this program, I'll talk to some of the world's foremost traders about current trends in markets and what they believe is a smart bet. We'll hear about their career journeys and of course, find out what they're targeting as their next big trade. Enjoy the show.
1:33 Speaker 02 Welcome to the Next Big Trade and thanks for joining us. This week, I'm talking to Nick Halaris. Nick is a founder and president of Metros Capital, a company dedicated to investing in and developing transformative real estate projects. Prior to Metros, he was a co-founder and president of AH Capital, an opportunistic real estate investment company which invested more than 150 million in residential and multifamily assets. Nick writes a newsletter called Profit. Um. He's active philanthropically and cares deeply about homelessness and the promise of low-cost higher education. Uh. Nick, how's it going? How are you?
2:12 Speaker 01 I'm doing great. Thank you for that generous introduction and thanks for having me on the show.
2:16 Speaker 02 Uh, no, thank you for coming. Uh, so before we start talking about all the stuff we're going to talk about, I always like to ask, what is it on your mind at the moment? What's in the news that's grabbing your attention? Apart from your investment thesis.
2:33 Speaker 01 Sure. That's an interesting question because there's a lot going on these days.
2:38 Speaker 02 Right.
2:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I've been paying close attention to this war stuff. I'm a big sort of history buff and read a lot of history, so the geopolitical stuff always gets me interested and.
2:52 Speaker 02 What what are you thinking on that? Because me too, I am like all of my work, I have to remind myself to like, look at what I meant to be looking at and not look at all this Ukraine war stuff instead. What exactly is grabbing your attention?
3:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think the risk of it is something that scares me. I have young kids. You know, my two boys are six and four.
3:14 Speaker 02 Uh, you're not, you're not a big fan of the nuclear war thing. Okay.
3:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. Not a big fan of this kind of aggressive behavior from a nuclear power that appears to be in a major sort of decline, secular decline.
3:30 Speaker 02 Now, let's, we should clarify which one are you talking about there?
3:33 Speaker 01 The Russians.
3:34 Speaker 02 Other Russians.
3:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah.
3:36 Speaker 02 I I I spend way too much time looking at propaganda, uh, Russian, evil Russian propaganda. Um, and they say exactly the same thing about the United States. They say exactly the same thing.
3:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, super interesting. Yeah, the the other thing back to the Ukraine war. What's super interesting about it again is this fog of war thing, like, the one thing that no one expected to happen, which is like, hey, the Ukrainians could like win this thing, looks like it's happening or could happen, which is kind of fascinating, but also I think kind of dangerous. It's almost like I I I don't want. The Ukrainians to lose, but if they win too, if they win too well or win too quickly, it just increases that risk for the world and that really scares me.
4:22 Speaker 02 I definitely, yeah. So as I said, I am like twenty percent made of Russian propaganda at this point. Uh, with eighty percent, some sort of a adipose lipid type tissues, you know. Um, and when I look at the same stuff I'm looking at, it looks, so I'd be absolutely terrified if that were true. If the Ukrainians were winning, I would be terrified because I think the Russians are all in. And they will stop at nothing to make sure this is a war of an existential threat to them as far as they're concerned. As to whether they should think that way is another matter, but that does seem to be the way they're talking about it. Um, and the other side of this is what I'm reading and it's, as I said, it's
5:05 Speaker 02 because I'm reading way too much stupid ass propaganda that I shouldn't be reading. But if I, I like to look at both sides of the argument all the time. And when I look at the other side of the argument, the Russians are arguing they're make, they're making inroads. They're, they, it looks to me as if they're definitely going to win this battle in the east. And the question you've got to ask yourself is what happens with the west of the country going forward? And I, I don't have a good answer to that. I really, really have no visibility on what will happen next after they take the Donbass. So scary times, right?
5:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, very scary times. Yeah.
5:42 Speaker 02 So I, I was looking through some of your material. And I noticed you said one thing that caught my attention. You said, it's something you wrote. You said, I have been in business now for almost twenty years. And the whole time I've been fascinated by one question, how can I be a great investor? And mate, I've got to tell you, I want to know the answer to that one too. I, uh, it would really, really help if more of my trades worked and I made more money. You got any advice?
6:09 Speaker 01 Yeah. How much time do we have?
6:12 Speaker 02 Let's give it three minutes.
6:14 Speaker 01 Yeah. No, it's it's such a fascinating topic and I think it's it's so it's such an interesting art, the art of investing and it's the the reason why it's fascinating is because it's basically impossible to answer that question with a with a clear sort of simple absolute answer. Because investing is about psychology. And so for me, for me to be a good investor is different than for you, because we come to the art with a completely different sort of psychological makeup.
6:47 Speaker 02 So true.
6:48 Speaker 01 And so, yeah, so there are some people who are who are phenomenal at trading. They could see these and they love to find these opportunities, these little arbitrage opportunities and, you know, scalp trades. And there's some people who are great at, you know, riding these big waves, these bull waves. And there's some people good at picking bottoms and some people who are good at using their creativity. So it really kind of depends what kind of person you are. And I think a lot of the, you know, to make it in this business is trying to find that match, finding a strategy that actually matches with your psychological makeup and then experimenting with it. You know, you're always going to be learning. You'll never have the answer. But if you can, you can play within the bounds that makes sense for you, you can do well.
7:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think that's absolutely right. Once you know yourself, like you've got a much better better chance of finding an investment strategy that will work for you. Don't try and trade like somebody else if that isn't what's going to work of your psychology.
7:47 Speaker 01 Yep, it just doesn't work.
7:49 Speaker 02 So we should transit on to the investment thesis here because I know that Frank, who produces this podcast, is heavily invested in this question. And I think Frank's not not alone. A lot of people are invested in this question. Can you talk to us about your investment thesis? What's the next big trade?
8:10 Speaker 01 Sure.
8:12 Speaker 01 I find myself unexpectedly bullish on the US housing market. And I say unexpectedly because, look, mortgage rates just like ripped higher by a significant percentage. You know, went from the high twos to call it the mid fives today. House prices just appreciated twenty to forty percent, depending on what city or jurisdiction you're looking at. And the market looks like it's crashing. So you add those three things up and look at housing and your first reaction isn't, wow, I'm excited about US housing. But yet, as I, you know, that is my day job is to be involved in the housing market. So I have a lot of data, personal data.
8:55 Speaker 01 But as I looked at the bigger data, I kind of got convinced that this is actually a really interesting time to be bullish about US housing. And there's, there's a few reasons for it. I think, you know, starting with the demand side, I think something really fascinating happened with COVID in the, in the nature of demand for housing, which it kind of woke up. So there was this period after the crash where housing demand in the US was, was there, but it wasn't like it was in the early 2000s. You know, in the years leading up to the crash, it was kind of, kind of slower than that and different. And there was all these stories about how, you know, the millennial generation in particular was, they had a different view, a different dream.
9:38 Speaker 01 They, they liked choice, you know, they liked the ability to, you know, move at the drop of a hat.
9:45 Speaker 02 Experiences, they were big into experiences.
9:49 Speaker 01 And, and they were big into the sharing economy and co-living and all this stuff, right? Like this is pure fantasy. This, this is just a function of like a hangover, a psychological hangover that, that was caused by the, the crash. You know, the, this generation suffered through or saw their parents in many cases suffer through. It's pretty stressful times when, when the housing market did actually crash and house prices declined significantly in a, in a short period of time. But something changed and that we started noticing it in our business at Metros Capital. Like, right in the very beginning of COVID, people started to think about housing differently and their risk appetites for housing changed in my view in a fundamental way. And so where households were content to kind of wait until they had the perfect financial
10:34 Speaker 01 picture to buy a house, now they're stretching and willing to take risk and willing to do things like, you know, we saw this a lot, like, ask their parents for money, ask their friends for loans. So the psychology went from, you know, maybe just patience to impatience. And I think that that change is here to stay. COVID scared all of us. It scared the whole country. And housing became really, really important and people are not going to compromise anymore on housing. That's kind of thesis number one. Number two, there's this demographic argument, which, again, demographics is difficult to hang your hat on because it's
11:16 Speaker 01 for all of its data is, in my view, is kind of an inexact science. But there is this big millennial generation and they're coming of age in the sense of reaching points in their career where they're making more money and more importantly, having children. And so there is sort of this demographic tailwind to housing, which I think is here to stay for the next five to 10 years. And then you couple that with a really crazy supply picture. And it's crazy for a number of reasons. One is the housing crash absolutely ruined American housing production. Now, American housing production was never great, but it got absolutely destroyed and it never really recovered. So if you kind of look at a chart
12:00 Speaker 01 of housing starts, like, we're barely getting back to where we were in the pre-crash era. And meanwhile, the political environment locally has gotten really, really bad for housing production. And so there's this structural headwind, a massive structural headwind to the actual production of new supply, which is creating this crazy storm where you have, you know, changing demand, which is real. And then you've got this supply, which is kind of stuck. It doesn't look like it's changing anytime soon. And so I think there's this long term recipe where there's going to be a lot more demand than there is supply, which is supportive of higher prices. So that's the, that's the high level of the thesis.
12:46 Speaker 02 So a couple of things come to mind, although I recognize the picture you paint is one that I can, I can easily kind of recognize part of the story of, because, you know, everybody involved in markets is looking at housing in 2008, because 2008 was the nexus of the crisis. And in fact, if you had any sense, you were probably looking at it in 2006. I remember going in to see Ben Bernanke in, I think, yeah, it would have been late 2006, early 2007. Back then, you could go in and chat to Fed officials if you're an investor.
13:22 Speaker 02 If you grovel enough, and I'm good at groveling, you can tell. Right. So I went in to see him and I asked him what his views of housing were. And he said to me, no, I don't think there's a bubble. And I got to tell you, my mouth dropped. Even in the meeting, I couldn't quite hide my surprise at that position. And I, you know, I still remember it very clearly that that completely, you know, the Fed did not see that housing bubble coming. And I, and God knows how, because like, it was pretty obvious to anybody who was paying attention, including people like Josh Rosner and stuff like that, who I used to work with. So anyhow, so that's one thing. The first part of your thesis is to me, the most interesting
14:06 Speaker 02 question. Why did people's attitudes to real estate change around COVID? Why, why would people reach then when they wouldn't reach before?
14:16 Speaker 01 Yes, it's a hard question to answer because the decision or the change is being made at the level of the psychology of the individual households. But from what I can infer from the activity that we've seen selling houses at Metros Capital and just observing market dynamics across the country. I suspect that it's a function of the need for the feeling of safety. So COVID kind of woke people up to what kind of neighborhood they were living in. And they thought they thought differently about it in many cases. And so you've seen this great migratory reshuffling.
14:56 Speaker 01 People started moving all over the place, right in the early part of the pandemic in the summer of 2020.
15:04 Speaker 02 I can see how watching unprecedented events unfold in front of you might have made you wonder whether you were going to be locked into Brooklyn or Manhattan or downtown Chicago. All of a sudden, you realize that you had a problem. We used to live on the Upper West Side in Manhattan and we moved out here to Andover 2017. And my wife still says, what if we hadn't done it? What if we were still in a two-bedroom apartment with three kids in the Upper West Side of Manhattan? We have no access to the parks because the parks were shut down.
15:43 Speaker 02 So I can see how a lot of people would have gotten a real stick somewhere the sun don't shine to get to get that life plan sorted out.
15:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, I get it. And I think people did. I think people did get stuck and it really like shocked them. So having that that sort of cramped environment, like my friend in Shanghai, who was 62 days in his two-bedroom apartment, like he's had, he's in the middle of that situation right now. And then when you, when you move or you see your friends move and they start talking about these sort of more spacious suburban opportunities that are often significantly cheaper than the Upper West Side, you start to have like a Almost like a self referential moment like Hamlet. Where you're like, oh, wait a minute, I was in this game that maybe I shouldn't have been in that game. I got the whole time I could have been over here.
16:35 Speaker 01 You know, experiencing life in a completely different way. And I I think that happened to a lot of people. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but it's it's. Thousands and thousands of people had that kind of thought and they started moving around. So it was about security, it was about lifestyle. And then it was also about, I think there was. This one's harder to prove, but I I think it's true. I think there's a sense in which. Non homeowners in particular, so if you're an urban renter in March of twenty twenty. But you're making good money, but maybe you just don't have enough money to buy a million dollar house or millions of dollars houses in New York or L A. There was a sense at the beginning of COVID where you you started to feel like left out.
17:20 Speaker 01 Cause you didn't own a house, didn't have the benefit of owning a house. And people are starting to see, you know, I I think in in the twenty twenties, people are starting to see like. America is divided on on a very clear line of demarcation, like. If you own a house. You're somewhat protected from inflation in a different way than if you're not.
17:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, you've locked your rent at some, you you're renting your a a piece of real estate to yourself. And that means if the rent were to go up, you could just pay, you know, you you pay yourself more rent. You're you're hedging out that exposure.
17:57 Speaker 01 That's right. Yeah. And if you look at this chart, like I saw some chart floating around Twitter the other day, basically looking at. The rise in household net worth attributed to. Home home equity essentially from twenty, I think it was from twenty nineteen to twenty twenty two, it's it's massive, I forget the number, but. It makes the point, it's like, if you owned a house going into COVID, COVID was a gift. Because you your net worth, your balance sheet just looks forty percent better than it did before.
18:26 Speaker 02 Sure.
18:26 Speaker 01 And that's the way which there's this ironic thing happening in in our lifetime where the American dream, which was. Supposed to be about giving people the opportunity to rise up the the social status or the class status, whatever you want to call it, has now become the main channel by which wealth and equality is proliferating across the the country. If you own a house in the right place, you just do better and better and better. And if you don't, you do worse and worse and worse. And I think, you know, for many reasons, housing is becoming this meta issue of the American democracy. You know, it's not just an American problem, but it's it is an American problem because we're we're so focused psychologically on housing.
19:11 Speaker 02 It's definitely not just an American problem. You you know, obviously, I'm from the UK originally. Uh, I'm British in most respects, really. And I can assure you, I is familiar with London real estate prices going ever higher. I'm wondering why the hell I didn't buy a bigger house back in nineteen ninety two or whenever. The the the differences in these. Now, the question is why that happened? And then the next question is whether it will continue. And I think your, if I've understood your basic investment hypothesis, it's go buy a house. But I'd like to know why you think that trade is going to continue to work, because I could
19:55 Speaker 02 give you good, strong counter arguments about why it's over.
19:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, and just to be clear, like, I think there are some macro scenarios where this trade doesn't work that well. My base case forecast right now is that the world evolves to a place where there is a recession. And the recession that happens globally reduces the pressure that's causing the the headline inflation numbers to look the way they look. And the central banks around the world are able to essentially kind of thread the needle. So that that's my base case macro view, because there's other views where like. If the central banks can't thread the needle and they actually have to keep raising
20:41 Speaker 01 rates, then all bets are off. I think that's a very dangerous environment for all assets, including American houses. But I I kind of don't think that's going to happen. I'm a little more optimistic. I basically think they're they're going to get lucky. They're going to induce this little recession. And China is basically inducing its own recession right now. You know, I think it's going to be a massive GDP surprise from China, maybe not so much of a surprise. And that maybe that's on purpose. And that drives the inflation out. And the central banks can raise a few times and then declare victory, because the headline numbers look better, and get back to a more accommodative stance. And so if that happens, then you know, that's sort of the backdrop that has to happen for my thesis to really make a lot of sense. If you get a massive deflation, caused by the stock
21:26 Speaker 01 market going down ninety percent or something, or China, you know, crashing or losing their currency, that that's a different environment.
21:33 Speaker 02 You know, the language you're using, it's it's it's really interesting. So first of all, if you're right, and we the scenario you paint where they thread the needle, is the same scenario we've had every time we've had some kind of uptick in inflation, you growth slows down, the Fed gets to say whoops, too much, cuts rates, and we can all go back to buying expensive houses because interest rates keep falling. And in in in both nominal and real terms, right? And the what bothered me about the way you express that is, I'm not a hundred percent sure that you want to get some guy who's a little bit older
22:16 Speaker 02 than me threading a needle, right? If you've ever seen, I know what I'm like when I'm threading a needle now, is as a metaphor, it's it doesn't suggest confidence to me. Like, a picture of Jay Powell wiggle it with a needle and a piece of thread, trying to get the needle. No, these guys are not to be trusted to thread any needles at this point in this in any econ, you know, with economic trends and cycles. So I'm a little nervous. In fact, this isn't like the old days. And in fact, Greenspan's put is deep out of the money on the S and P, like below three thousand, because that next inflation print could easily be nine percent, not eight and a half. I've seen where diesel's going.
22:58 Speaker 02 Everything you consume, let's say on the West Coast mind, but a lot of stuff in the center of the country is is basically. You know, got a big diesel component to it because it gets delivered, right?
23:13 Speaker 02 There's no obvious reason with with what happened in Shanghai and what happened, what is happening in hydrocarbons and refined product. The inflation comes down soon. So this could get uglier before it gets better, and that makes me a little nervous. But so that's that's a monetary policy backdrop. But I mean, from when you were discussing the the kind of broad bones of the trade, sounded to me as if you thought there was a big supply constraint, that we're just not going to get a supply response, and there's just an underlying shortage of housing in the US.
23:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, for sure. So your your point's a great point, and it's something that investors need to be wary of because there are outlier, what I what I'm calling outlier macroeconomic environments that would make doing anything, you know, very risky. So like, there's the hyperinflation scenario, and there's a deflationary bust. And we're in, we live in a world where either one of those is possible. You know, so like I I listened to your discussion with Rosenberg the other day, like, yeah, that's possible. That's possible to get disinflation or maybe even deflation, given where we are. We could also get hyperinflation, you know, to your point about some of the things we're seeing in commodities. And so,
24:36 Speaker 01 you know, put those to the side for a second and think, okay, maybe maybe we're not going to have a disaster. We'll have something in between. It's one of those two disasters.
24:44 Speaker 02 Sure.
24:44 Speaker 01 What's interesting about the housing market is that it really is structurally undersupplied. I mean, it's it's really, it's a mess in this country to to get anything built, and it it's been getting increasingly harder for years. And now we have this sort of new dynamism in the market where people are moving around. So I'll I'll give you a sense of of of this by giving an example. So I was looking for the the latest piece I wrote for Profit about the housing market. I was looking at some of these sort of hotter markets that have done well during COVID.
25:21 Speaker 01 And I looked at Denver. So the data on Denver is fascinating. Oh, from 2019 to 2022, 100,000 people, households moved to, uh, I think it's people, actually, sorry. 100,000 people moved to the Denver area. And in that time period, they sold like 14,000 new homes. So just looking at that differential, right? If you were to say like, if every one of those 100,000 families bought a new house or had to buy a new house, like they're just woefully undersupplied. It's like 5X, 7X, something like that. Now, it's not the case because there's existing home sellers and there's renters. But the point is, is that when you get population moving around to, to these jurisdictions,
26:05 Speaker 01 it exacerbates the supply problem. Because these, these states and cities, they can't, they can't handle population. So if you look, look at these numbers anywhere, you look at these cities in Florida that have been booming, or you look at Nashville, it's, it's the same thing. They're basically 5X to 10X undersupplied in terms of new, new housing. And I have this thesis that the whole country is going to look like California very quickly. And what I mean by that is if you look at California history, there was periods of time, you know, before the war, but mostly after the war, where millions of people moved here. And the state, no matter how business friendly they could try to be, could never build millions of units.
26:51 Speaker 01 So they were undersupplied for decades. And you walked into the 2000 era where California, many of the most expensive cities on, on, in the country are in California. And I have this feeling that if the migratory reshuffling that we're seeing as a result of COVID continues, every other city that's popular is going to look exactly like that. They're going to get this massive influx of people. House prices are going to be out of reach and they're never going to recover because the local political environment is so anti-housing. And the, and the political, uh, debate has evolved on this line of housing, where you have the, the people who are NIMBYs and then you have everybody else. But the NIMBYs have all the money and they have all the influence over the city councils and local jurisdictions who make zoning decisions.
27:36 Speaker 01 So we're in this kind of crazy world.
27:38 Speaker 02 So I'm a NIMBY. I, I definitely do not want but someone building some house which damages my asset value. And I definitely wouldn't want to transfer of real estate value from me to a real estate developer nearby. Now, because I'm not particularly well-connected locally, and I really ought to try harder, right? But if you've got a personality like mine, it's difficult to make friends. So I really ought to try harder locally and get on committees and become, you know,
28:09 Speaker 02 integrate myself into the community more.
28:13 Speaker 02 The community, of course, has its own views on that, but
28:18 Speaker 02 it's always going to be the case. Nimbism is not new. Nobody wants a transfer of real estate value from them to someone who's a developer, whatever. So that's always going to be the case, and it's a consistent phenomenon all over the place. Other countries, everywhere you look. And where nimbyism doesn't happen, it's because you have some other body that's in control, that can impose costs on the buyers of real estate, you know, and just cram it down. So you know what, you're building on the Upper West Side, we're going to put a building right in front of your Hudson River View. Block it off, and that will be transferred across. And that's why you have air rights and situations like that in cities like New York.
29:01 Speaker 02 So nimbyism is an underlying problem that won't go away. There is another problem here, though, isn't it? These people are coming, I know my wife, who's from the Massachusetts area, has family and friends who have moved to Denver. Denver's a happening town, there are a lot of jobs and wage rates are high. That makes real estate prices high. It's easy to move to get to get a job in Denver, it's hard to get a place. And the real estate guys are the guys who are intermediating that economic rent, if you will. If you wanted to move to Cleveland, no problem. You've got all the real estate in the world for you there. And Denver's just one example, right? Boise, Idaho, why the hell is Boise, Idaho so hot? Austin, Texas.
29:47 Speaker 02 Um. The three cities area in the Carolinas, Nashville, you mentioned, San Antonio is pretty hot, too. If you follow Rick Palacios, you can see what's going on in these locality. These are growing areas. I suspect Boise is hot precisely because there's a whole bunch of old farts like me, who bought in California, squeezed that market by not allowing any development. And now they figure they'd like to cash out, sell their $2 million home, buy a $750,000 home in Boise, ski a little bit while they still can, and use the rest of the money to live on. So I think there's a flow, that this flow continues for a while, and these places can keep getting more and more hot, more and more expensive.
30:33 Speaker 02 And I don't think there's any good solution for Frank, who is listening in on this, and trying to figure out whether he'll ever be able to buy a home in the DC area.
30:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think you're, I think you're right. Like, I know several people, some of my original investors in my first real estate venture, who literally fit that demographic. They sold their millions of dollar houses in California, moved to Nevada. They didn't move to Boise, but they moved to Nevada.
30:59 Speaker 02 It's a dry heat.
31:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, lower taxes and whatnot. The other thing, too, that I, I should have mentioned earlier, I think this remote work thing is also part of the demand story. So remote work, and the extent to which remote work remains a phenomenon, or continues to maybe even grow as a phenomenon in this country, is also another factor that is driving sort of this migratory reshuffling. And there's a paper that somebody referenced just the other day on on Twitter that the National Bureau of Economic Research put out, and essentially, the authors of this paper were attempting to isolate the price, the extent to which the price increase we've seen in this country is related to remote work.
31:44 Speaker 01 So they were trying to like cancel out migration, the stuff that I was just quoting in Denver. And their estimate is that 50% of the price move is attributed to demand changes resulting from remote work. So essentially, it's like
32:00 Speaker 01 People moving within cities just to the suburban part of it because they can have a better lifestyle.
32:10 Speaker 01 Rather than moving, you know, from California to Boise, for example. So it's, that's an interesting point, and I do think there's something to it, to that part of the demand and remote work is probably here to stay. And that will, that will continue to put pressure on these local jurisdictions, these, the Nashvilles of the world and the San Antonio's, the Boisys. If, if I'm concerned about one, one kind of market, it's the kind of market like Boise. Where it doesn't really have the strong job growth or, or dynamism that you could find like. Nashville is a fun city. Atlanta is a fun city. These places, they were growing no matter what, you know, Boise is maybe fun, but it's not fun like, like Nashville or Atlanta.
32:53 Speaker 01 So tho- those are probably the most at risk cities in the, in the country.
32:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, you know, to my mind, you, you compare two different markets and we should distinguish between them. So Atlanta is a really strong real estate market and it's one, you know, I do a little investing in real estate. I probably shouldn't because I may be, who knows if I'm any good at it, but what I can say about Atlanta is the rents are so much lower than anything in the Northeast. And that makes me relatively bullish Atlanta, right? It's got a decent housing stock. It's got low rents. That means that for people like Frank, they're paying away less of their income to their landlord or their bank when they buy real estate.
33:38 Speaker 02 Remote working out of Atlanta, that makes a lot of sense because you're paying a quarter the rent you'd pay in New York City. And, but no, it doesn't make sense to remote work from the Bay Area to a job in New York.
33:54 Speaker 01 No, it's an interesting point and it's one of the parts, the parts of this story. That doesn't actually make a lot of sense, right? So like, I'll give, I'll give you an example, a couple of examples. So Los Angeles County lost something like a hundred and sixty thousand people. In, in the last year or something like that.
34:16 Speaker 02 When did that last happen? Did, does Los, Los Angeles County lose people generally?
34:22 Speaker 01 No, I mean, that's like the cumulative total for the previous decade.
34:26 Speaker 02 Wow.
34:27 Speaker 01 Yeah, like it it's a big change. But what's wild about it, and it it speaks to this sort of problem in the market. Not only this for sale market, but also the rental market. The rental market's on fire. It's up twenty, thirty percent from the pre-COVID numbers. And the for sale market's, you know, as good as any market in the country in terms of price appreciation. And you you lost population. And so it's it it speaks again to this structural issue. You know, there there was something, New York City is a fascinating example. There was, there was a report that Bloomberg put out earlier this week, I think, where essentially they were like bashing Airbnb.
35:08 Speaker 01 Cause there's, there's more Airbnb listings than there are actual apartments available for rent. That's what the story was about. There was like thirteen thousand Airbnb listings and seventy-five hundred apartments available. And of course Airbnb came out and said, well, that's not fair. But the point, the point is like, there's no supply in New York. New York occupancy percentage is like ninety-nine point five percent, something crazy. And so rents are actually going up. And it wasn't that long ago when, you know, prominent people were saying the cities are dead. New York's never coming back. Well, rents are higher than ever. And on even if you look at the cities, like the big cities, what's fascinating about the this sort of post-COVID era is that
35:50 Speaker 01 their rental inflation trajectory is at a higher sort of angle, a steeper path than the pre-COVID. So whatever's going on, uh, is bullish for rents as well. Atlanta's, Atlanta's interesting because Atlanta is one of these, I have a ton of experience in Atlanta. We, we owned a bunch there and bought a ton over the last decade. And I've seen rents go from, you know, our first deals rents were like six hundred. And now they're, now they're like sixteen hundred.
36:19 Speaker 02 What happens to change this? What's going to change?
36:22 Speaker 01 So part of the reason why I'm bullish on the housing market is I don't think it's really going to change. I think essentially we have this perfect storm brewing in this country where the demand is going to be there for housing and there's just not going to be enough supply. And I feel like that is here to stay. And as long as we don't get one of these outlier macro situations, the US housing market is going to do fine. There's going to probably be a period this summer, for example, where the statistics don't look as good as they have, you know, the acceleration of house prices is going to come down. Volume is going to come down, but that's a function of just the general uncertainty that's caused by you know, what's happening in markets across the world, really.
37:08 Speaker 01 And then I think we get back, we get back to an environment where housing does well. You know, at least in terms of its value, its value, its price.
37:18 Speaker 02 So I kind of share your broad prognosis, but I can imagine how bad things happen. And, you know, let me give you the California example. You talked about LA County's population dropping by, was it 100K? Over 160K. Well, quite often, these kind of statistics, they're auto-correlated. There's a persistence in that number because if there's a net migration out, then the people, it reflects demographic trends. People, a demographic bulge hits a certain age and starts to adjust its choices. It would not shock me if you get a demographic flow out of places like California
38:03 Speaker 02 for places that Californian retirees like to move to, like Arizona, like Nevada, like Boise.
38:11 Speaker 02 And it would also wouldn't shock me if that resulted in budget problems for California, which exacerbated the flow and also job problems for California, which exacerbated. You you build up, New York City is a great example, you build up costs based around a certain population, a small drop in population makes those costs untenable. And before you know it, property taxes have to rise to to a point which drives people out and you get into a vicious circle. So it would not shock me if we got to a demographic point where high rent states
38:52 Speaker 02 started to experience population declines relative to low rent states as young people move out and start up a new life in Georgia or Carolina or wherever their rents are lower and they pay less of it to landlords. And that might be bad for real estate prices in the areas which are experiencing the population declines, just at the same time as areas which are experiencing population increases have really strong real estate markets.
39:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think you're right that it's a that's a risk for the big cities.
39:29 Speaker 01 But I remain pretty bullish even on the on the big cities, at least in a certain type of of real estate, like the sort of higher end. So imagine like kids, kids coming out of school that get good jobs, like the apartments that they live in, I think those are going to continue to do well because if you rewind the clock a little bit and look at like the the time period from two thousand to March of twenty twenty, what was happening in the big cities was that they they didn't have great overall net inflows in terms of migration, so domestic migration. So California was was basically on a downtrend before COVID in terms of if you just looked at
40:13 Speaker 01 like ins and outs of of Americans. But what was driving increases in population in the in the urban centers was that there was a health, a very healthy amount of foreign immigration.
40:27 Speaker 01 So the statistics were positive. So the population was positive. And in that dynamic, you know, from the little research I've done, like, that was pretty true of a lot of big cities around the world, not just American big cities. Any any jurisdiction that was like remotely open to immigration, Canada is a good example of this, like. The cities that were open to immigration, they saw like great populations growth. Despite the fact that many of their their citizens were were choosing, especially when they reached the age where they started having children. Were choosing to relocate because of all the reasons that we've discussed in this conversation.
41:01 Speaker 02 So how are younger people going to live something akin to their parents' American dream? How is that gonna happen?
41:09 Speaker 01 It's something I've been thinking about a lot. Actually, when I first started my newsletter, it was about two years ago. And that one of the first articles I wrote was actually about the American dream. I I went back in in time. And I looked at the original articulation of the American dream, the idea, American dream. It came from this historian who wrote a book in like the nineteen twenties and he was. Basically looking back over American history up into that point. And the takeaway from that book is that. The American dream is never static. It changed over time and it is still changing. But what it was was. It really was more of an idea about mobility and less about real estate.
41:54 Speaker 01 Even though America really is in many sense like a giant real estate story. Psychologically, the American dream is essentially this idea that. There is a frontier. Of opportunity. And when the American dream feels good is when that frontier of opportunity feels viable. So it was always basically a lie. The American dream was always a lie. But as long as it was something that some people, enough people believed in. America could progress forward and and, you know, try to manifest this dream.
42:31 Speaker 02 A politically and economically convenient lie.
42:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
42:35 Speaker 02 Yeah.
42:35 Speaker 01 And and what's happened in in our lifetimes is that because of the the financial instability.
42:43 Speaker 01 Starting with the tech crash and followed with the big banks almost, you know, taking the whole banking system down and now here we are with COVID and whatever's happening today is that the believability of that frontier is like really being questioned. And housing is an area in which that sort of debate or that discussion is happening. Because the dynamics of all the policy decisions that we've made in response to the financial instability have been very supportive of asset prices. And so house prices have gone crazy, right? And multifamily rents have gone crazy. And so it's a consequence, it's a generational consequence of the policy choices that we've made.
43:27 Speaker 01 And I think that unfortunately, it's probably not going to change. Like unless we get one of those outlier macro situations, I think we end up pursuing the similar kind of policies that are pro, very pro inflationary for real estate pricing in both in terms of housing and in terms of rents. Because that's the easy thing to do.
43:48 Speaker 02 So I'm with you 100% on this. As a general rule, I want to position myself so that the politics of a given situation, I get to hide behind the marginal voter. Because I am not a simpatico figure. The government doesn't care whether I do well, but the average American voter, it cares whether they do okay. So I definitely want to hide behind those guys. Because if you put more than 5% of the American population out of their house, there is no way you're getting reelected, right? There is absolutely no way. They're going to remember, you'd be lucky to be able to eat out in public without getting something bad happening to you.
44:32 Speaker 02 So I find it hard to believe that the US politicians are going to allow a bigger than, say, 20% decline in real estate to take place.
44:44 Speaker 02 Regardless of what our central bankers are saying about credibility. The only thing that bothers me is I'm not sure they have control over something which looks to me like cost push inflation. I don't think they have any control over this for the next couple of years. So it wouldn't be so difficult to get a situation where everything's fine, we're even rallying on bonds, rates are coming back down, it all looks fine. And then we print nine, 10% on CPI. And everyone suddenly realizes that Jake Powell is in trouble and is meant to hike again. If he's, if we're meant to believe anything he ever says.
45:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think that's one of, one of the possibilities. And it's that kind of environment. You got to think if, if we, if the world evolves in that direction, there's no place to hide.
45:36 Speaker 02 Right.
45:37 Speaker 01 Asset prices are in trouble.
45:38 Speaker 02 Everything's going down, guys.
45:40 Speaker 01 It's all going down. Yeah, and, and that will create the conditions for a deflationary bust. And then, and then who knows how we reset from there. It's that, though, I'm not sure how to game theory that out.
45:53 Speaker 02 I, I will bet you that unless, if the thing isn't caused by a political crisis. But if we don't have a political crisis prompting it, we'll reset in exactly the same way we've had, played the game for the last 40 years. So if you're, if you've got cash, then that's a good time to buy. Other, I'm more interested about whether or not American younger people are going to rebel. Cause this is a transition, right? There's a whole bunch of people who did have real estate and did have stocks and did have Google.
46:25 Speaker 02 And they're getting on a bit now, they're, they spend their times in their summer homes. Uh, and they, they have my two vacations a year. They're going to be leaving their money to their 2.4 kids or their point six of a dog or whatever, or cats in many cases. And those guys will be fine. They will inherit two and a half houses or whatever. They will have been to high school with other kids who will not, who, you know, inherit anything. They will not be fine. And the question is, how will that destabilize politics? Will that make the political situation troubling in the next five years?
47:05 Speaker 02 And I, I think it should, but I, I've assumed it should for 20 years and nothing ever happened. Right? It's never been like that, you know, no real significant revolt. Closest thing to it was January 6th, right? So I don't know. The US usually is a pretty stable place politically. Probably pretty stable going forward. What do you recommend people do with regard to a trade? Should be, I mean, did you look at the house builders? Should they be buying house building stocks? What, what's, what's the trade here?
47:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, I've got three or four ideas about this. I think idea number one is that if you have the, the stomach for it and the expertise. I, I believe that buying, just buying houses, well, well-located houses in hot places that are having, you know, robust population growth, like in Atlanta or Nashville or whatever. That's a good, good trade.
48:02 Speaker 02 It's basically the southeast of the US. You like the low-rent southeast. Is that the idea?
48:07 Speaker 01 No, I like, I like LA. There's a lot of places where this works. No, yeah. Basically, anywhere where they, there's like a great long-term dynamic economic story. So I would steer clear of these outlier markets like Boise, like we talked about earlier. So trade, trade idea number one is buy, buy houses and buy them with fixed price debt. It's a great trade. It's the classic real estate trade. You buy an appreciating asset. You borrow, you can still borrow, believe it or not, you can still borrow at less than CPI. So even though mortgage rates has blown out to 5.5, CPI is coming in at what? Eight, eight or nine?
48:46 Speaker 02 Thirty-year fix is 5.5. A while ago, someone told me you could get 10-year, 10-year one-arm at two and a half. That struck me as a better deal. I don't know where I'm going to be in 30 years, probably under the ground.
48:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, look, ten year fixed, I'd be comfortable with that too, but thi- this is how real estate people make money. It's it's like this secret. It's not so it's not so secret, but it's a very straightforward game. Borrow money at fixed price and you have an asset that's either going up or the rent structure is going up and you get this free money essentially. And now it's even doubly free because CPI is running at higher than your borrowing cost.
49:22 Speaker 02 So I tell everybody that ultimately the big secret is that inflat- money goes down in value. That's the main thing you've got to know. Money goes down in value over time.
49:31 Speaker 01 So that's that's trade number one. And then I think there are two or three other trades that you could start to put on now even. But I would be cautious because we're we're living in this crazy volatile time. So thi- this isn't like back up the truck and buy as much as possible. But the the other ideas I have are, I think the home builders themselves are probably a decent bet to start accumulating. So like something really basic, like just buy the ETF that cl- that has a basket. I haven't really done the the work to say like whether Lennar is better than Pulte or or DH, but buy the XHB or slowly accumulate the XHB. I think that's a decent trade.
50:13 Speaker 02 I I you know, I gotta, I'm gonna have to quibble with you on this. I looked at this a couple of times because the company I work for is, you know, is putting out recommendations on this question because we have, you know, ferociously bearish price movements, not the underlying market, which is like super tight. But this, you know, if asset markets go down, the price appreciation will disappear for a little bit. And I don't think you're arguing against that. I think, you know, I think you want to buy the dip, not not not pay top dollar right here, right now. But when we looked at these ETFs, damn things are stuffed full of Home Depot and the other DIY shops, right? So and it's a huge component of the return.
50:56 Speaker 02 So if you look at Pulte or Lennar or D R Horton, these things are on really low P E. So the perspective P E is like Three and a half, four and a half, in that range. Um, effectively, this thing looks like they've anticipated some kind of real estate apocalypse in, in those, in the home builders. The problem with the ETF is that you don't have home builders on their own. You have a whole bunch of stuff. So.
51:26 Speaker 01 Okay, that, that's interesting. I hadn't, I hadn't really dug into that, but that, that is. I'm, I'm definitely not advocating to buy a bunch of like consumer related.
51:35 Speaker 02 You're not a, not a, you're not home, you're not bullish Home Depot.
51:38 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah. So, so maybe, maybe then why don't we, with, with the benefit of your, uh, intel, why don't we just adjust this recommendation to pick a basket of these home builders and, and buy them directly or start to buy them? That would, that would be the trade recommendation because this is, uh, th- these companies have learned from the crash, like how not to behave in the market. So that they really got beat up in the crash.
52:04 Speaker 02 They are remarkably averse to taking risk. They just don't take any risk as far as I can see.
52:10 Speaker 01 They don't. And, and another dynamic, which a lot of people who are not in the industry don't understand is that the crash, not only did it sort of like crush the risk appetite for the publicly traded home builders, it destroyed one of the main sort of entrepreneurial vehicles that was, was good for the housing market in the pre-crash days, in the sense that there was all of these private home building companies and private land developers that would take the risk. And so the, the essential function that these companies played was they buy land, in many cases, raw land, they put it together, they get it past these pesky local city councils, they get the zoning that they need to do the housing,
52:53 Speaker 01 they package it all up and then they sell it to Lennar and Pulte and make a huge profit. Well, a bunch of those companies got destroyed, like bankruptcy, because land went down in some cases, like out here where I live in the inland empire, land went down 90%. During the crash.
53:08 Speaker 02 Ninety percent strikes me, there was a bit of spec in that price, a bit of froth in that price to start with, right?
53:14 Speaker 01 Totally. They were way out over their skis, but a ninety percent drawdown will take a private company to bankruptcy and it crushed a lot of people. And the market has been recovering, but it never really developed that dynamic force like it had in the pre-crash days. So that's one of the reasons why the market is still structurally undersupplied is because that that group of people doesn't exist like it used to. So home builders, they learned, they don't take that much risk and, you know, they've been, their balance sheets are pretty good. Like you said, they're in decent shape.
53:50 Speaker 02 The way I see it, that there's this increasing difference between the spec home build, sorry, I shouldn't say spec, because they're not even spec building. These guys are generally building to order, pretty close to. Anyway, they option land, they don't buy the land, they option it these days. And then they build to order. But the thing that strikes me as disconcerting
54:17 Speaker 02 is there, the land, there's no land for sale in any of the big development areas. If you want to buy large blocks of land, you ain't doing it in the Northeast. And you're not doing it in the LA County area, you're doing it outside in marginal areas. And you're going to be doing it where people are going to have very long commutes. Or you've moved to Florida, you've moved to the Carolinas and places like that where you can still build big tract houses. And with good margins. And even then, those don't work as well because of supply chain issues. Because you can't get the pipe off the boat in time to me.
55:00 Speaker 02 So it's tricky, but I will, I agree with you that for these home builders, there's not, there's a lot of bad news is in the price of those stocks.
55:10 Speaker 01 Yep.
55:10 Speaker 02 A lot. Not that we recommend individual trades to retail investors, because that would get me in prison, I think, if I do that. And I'm too good looking for prison, I think.
55:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, for sure. You don't want to end up in there.
55:28 Speaker 01 But so the the home builder is interesting. The other thing that I'm interested in, and I I think it's another way to express the same kind of bullish, if you're bullish structurally on on US housing. An interesting avenue would be the um buy for rent platforms. Or the build to rent platforms like Invitation Homes or American Homes for Rent or Tricon Residential. Companies like that have an interesting business model that I think continues to work.
55:59 Speaker 02 I, you know, I've got to tell you, I don't know much about it. What's so interesting about the business model?
56:04 Speaker 01 So essentially, what they're they've been doing, they started doing this in the, and I think right around like twenty twelve is when this business really took off, basically just building massive portfolios of single family rentals. So houses that are, American houses that are rented instead of bought to sell. And they've developed a very large portfolios, you know, in some cases, hundreds of thousands of units. And developed the management capabilities over the last decade that you need to like profitably deal with that much real estate dispersed all over the place. And they they they've been doing really well. I mean, up until the the recent market correction that we're going through, like they they're
56:48 Speaker 01 one of the best performing real estate stocks uh has been these kind of rental, single family rental companies. And I I think they continue to do well.
56:56 Speaker 02 Where where do they, where do they operate? What what geographic locations are they dominant in?
57:02 Speaker 01 So they're dominant primarily in places where there's large, like suburban stock. So many of the jurisdictions that you just kind of riddled off, like Texas and the American Southeast and Florida. But they're also, you know, portfolios, the Carolinas, but they're also portfolios that they have in in like suburban Los Angeles, for example. That's a strategy that works as well.
57:29 Speaker 02 I I'm gonna step, stay away from that one for the time being. I should remind myself to look at it, just in case the thing gets softer. Um, because this one hasn't, it's if it's two thousand and twelve, we haven't really tested the business model all the way through the cycle. Um. Me personally, like, I'd I'd love my my sense of irony, and I, you know, it will be triggered if they run into local government issues, because I can see how, I mean, there you get this interesting lobbying question. Local government might hate your guts, because, you know, you may, you maybe you maintain them to a certain standard. Maybe you go down in standard because of financial pressures, at which point
58:12 Speaker 02 towns may well have an issue with how you're running your business. So I I can see how this could, you know, go wrong or go right. Depend. And then, of course, there's this question about solvency of municipalities, like property taxes is an internal cost of all these businesses. Um. So what's to stop a town saying, hey, guess what? We've decided to push our pension pensions up, and you're going to get a bill for this much. You're fifteen percent of our housing stock. Thank you. We the we the citizens, thank you so greatly for your kind contribution to our pensions. So.
58:46 Speaker 01 Yeah. Yeah, I I think that's a very good point. I there there's already wins, you know, political wins that suggest that local jurisdictions and maybe even states might try to regulate against institutional ownership of single family houses. So there's been talk about everything from sort of making it difficult for LLCs and corporations to own single family houses, to just banning it, trying to ban it outright. And and it's unclear whether you could constitutionally do that. And um, there's just garden variety, like, political backlash, like there there's been some high profile trades in that industry where
59:27 Speaker 01 one of these buy for rent or build to rent platforms has come in and bought like an entire subdivision from from one of the home builders who we discussed earlier. And that really has negative press, because it's like, it's good for it's good for the home builder, because it's like, okay, here, take my four hundred homes. But it's not good for the story of the neighborhood, like this is supposed to be for first time home buyers or whatever the story was.
59:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, now you're you're you're first time home renter for the foreseeable future.
59:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
59:57 Speaker 02 I got I got bad news, Frank.
59:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, but you know, the the reason I'm I'm bullish on it is that I think. If you looked at some of the outlier macro scenarios that we've been discussing, the single family rental space looks really good then because in, you know, let's say we get a big jobs recession. It's going to destroy the, the credit quality of the marginal first time home buyer. And so there's going to be more renters than there are buyers. And so
1:00:27 Speaker 02 Sure.
1:00:28 Speaker 01 It, it's, there, there's a, there's sort of a defensive nature to that strategy. And then the other thing that got me, that really piqued my interest, I was talking to a friend of mine who manages a lot of money for Asian pension funds.
1:00:41 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
1:00:41 Speaker 01 And the last 10 years, they, he's been investing almost exclusively in Asia. And now none of them want to be in Asia anymore because of, uh, you know, whatever's happening in China. So their number one, he told me their number one most excited asset class is American houses, single family rentals. That's their number one most excited place to put their money.
1:01:03 Speaker 02 Interesting that, uh, yeah, because it's hard to see how it really breaks. You could, you can see how you might lose 10%. It's really hard to construct a case where you lose 60%.
1:01:13 Speaker 01 Yep.
1:01:14 Speaker 02 Hmm. You know, uh, so this has been a fascinating discussion, but, uh, I think, uh, we've probably pushed the edge of the envelope. I should call it into it here for the time being. Maybe we can discuss another time.
1:01:26 Speaker 01 Sure.
1:01:27 Speaker 02 Um, thank you so much for coming on, Nick. Um, where can people find your work if they'd like to, to kind of follow what you're writing and follow your thoughts on all this?
1:01:37 Speaker 01 So people can find me, it's really easy. Just nickhilaris.com. So just my name.com. And I have a newsletter that you can subscribe for. And I, and I set it up where it's, it's kind of on the, the donation. You can sign up for free or you can choose to donate. And, uh, I'm also on Twitter at Nick Halaris. And then I appear and work regularly with Real Vision. So subscribe to Real Vision. Check out my, I've, I've been both an interviewer and an interviewee and have a couple of things in the pipeline. So.
1:02:09 Speaker 02 Excellent. It's a pleasure, Nick. Uh, let's do it again sometime.
1:02:13 Speaker 01 Yeah, really fun. Thanks.
1:02:15 Speaker 02 All right. That's a wrap on the next big trade. Be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. And as always, head over to realvision.com for financial insight you won't find anywhere else.
Previous Things Are Even Tougher All Over Next The Reality Is Higher Rates Slow Growth Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated