Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing The Fallout from the FED's Dot Plot About this episode DB-JUN 21,2021: Real Vision senior editor Ash Bennington welcomes editor Jack Farley and managing editor Samuel Burke to the Daily Briefing to discuss Bitcoin’s recent decline, FED policy implications, and American Airlines. The trio will analyze China’s crackdown on Bitcoin mining as well as increased regulation of cryptocurrency services for China’s largest banks. Additionally, they will cover American Airline’s logistical problems as travel demand returns and explain the differing inflation outlooks highlighted in the FED’s dot plot ahead of Chair Powell’s meeting with Congress on Tuesday. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:12 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. I'm Ash Bennington. I'm joined once again by Samuel Burke and of course, Jack Farley. Welcome, gentlemen.
0:21 Speaker 01 Good afternoon.
0:23 Speaker 00 Big story of the day. Risk on, way on. Equities up across the board. More on that later. Jack Farley, what are you looking at today? What's on your radar?
0:33 Speaker 01 Well, Ash, I'm looking at Bitcoin. It took a tumble today, down as much as 11% for the day to $32,500, dragging Ethereum and much of the crypto world with it. Samuel, what are you looking at? Jack, all weekend long, I've been following American Airlines as they've been cancelling hundreds of flights due to maintenance issues, but also staffing problems. They're not the only airline facing this, and we're going to be looking at what it can tell us about labor inflation. Ash?
1:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, so back to our top story today. Everything is rising across the board right now in US equity markets. 95% of the S&P 500 stocks are up today. Just to give you a sense of a context for how broad-based this rally that we're seeing is right now, let's run through the closing numbers here. Dow Jones Industrial Average up 1.76% on the day, settling down at 33,876. S&P 500 up one spot, 4%, closing at 4,224. NASDAQ up 14,000, NASDAQ up closing at 14,141. That's up roughly 0.8% on the day. And the
1:47 Speaker 00 big gainer, the Russell 2000 Small Cap Index, closing at 2,286, up 2.16% over 2% on the day. You know, basically, anything out there that is sensitive to economic growth is catching a bid in this environment. It's a truly interesting day to see this rally. Guys, what are you thinking about this? I know you're watching equities as well.
2:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, if I may, Ash, I actually think we have a few charts to that point. So as you said, the Russell 2000, the small cap stock in this is absolutely exploding. And it was really the industrials, the energy stocks, the cyclical stocks that are leading the way, and the Nasdaq is still up, but on the back foot relative to the other places. And then you look at the different sectors, you'll see that energy absolutely exploded higher. I believe the XLE ended up over 4% for the day. You really don't see that every day. And you look at just which stocks are leading the charge, it is those energy stocks. Marathon Oil up 7%, Hess up 7%, Devon Energy, Halliburton. So the energy is really leading
2:56 Speaker 01 the way. You said a total reversal from the price action of Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday. And then you look at the laggards, who, which stocks are down in the S&P? Which are the 5%, Ash? You said 95% are up. Which are the 5% that are down? Well, it's really a who's who among the tech sector. It's Netflix, it's Amazon, it's Nvidia and the like. Samuel, what are you looking at? Well, it's really the tech stocks for me. You know, I follow tech for years. And so two things really stand out for me when I look at the tech scene. Netflix announces this huge deal with Steven Spielberg Studio, and yet they're still down. And then you look at Amazon today, it's Amazon Prime Day across the next two days. And even with that,
3:38 Speaker 01 they couldn't get any momentum from that. A lot of that has to do with shipping charges that are going to be a lot heavier from China. And so I think at the end of the day, I'm really still looking at what the players are saying and how it doesn't seem to be affecting the markets. I mean, you have former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, rather, talking about how he actually thinks the Fed is doing the right thing by doing what they've done, by giving the indicators that they've done, but they really need to step back and take a much more serious view about how they got it so wrong. How did they get the forecast so dramatically wrong? And so when you have voices like that, Ray Dalio talking about this knock-on effect that the economy is going to feel as a result of what's
4:22 Speaker 01 happening in the markets, I would say that a lot of people are looking even more hawkish than last week. And yet, in spite of that, here we are today, Dow up over 500 points.
4:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's exactly right. You know, James Bullard out today with comments suggesting that we may see a rate increase in 2022 because economic activity is picking up so strongly. I had to chuckle when Jack said Nasdaq on the back foot. Today, Nasdaq on the back foot means it's up almost 8 tenths of 1% on the day. But as you point out, Jack, relative to what we're seeing on the Russell 2000, even the Dow, with these cyclical industrial stocks where you see that the smaller cap stocks rallying in a much greater pace certainly looks on the back foot today. I have to say, one other thing, a little bit of a deeper dive on U.S. equities that I'm watching that I thought was really interesting. There's
5:14 Speaker 00 a new note out, a research note out from UBS, and basically the note concludes the following. If the Fed withdraws its yearly $1.4 trillion in quantitative easing spending, which is certainly the rate path to normalization that we seem to be on, the path to normalization we seem to be on with the balance sheet, S&P earnings earnings would decline 3% based on this UBS projection. Now, this is significant and interesting because the blended earnings projection for the S&P 500 analyst consensus is 10% per annum over the next two years, so more than 20% in aggregate on a compounded basis. This is absolutely very significant
5:56 Speaker 00 to see a report that suggests that the earnings growth is going to be so dramatic. And remember, if you think about stocks in the most elemental or fundamental level, what you're pricing is future earnings growth. It's kind of the definition of what a stock valuation is if you look in the finance textbooks. So to me, this is really interesting, seeing where we are with this path to normalization, seeing this rally today. I'm curious, do you guys have any thoughts on that?
6:24 Speaker 01 Samuel, you want? No, I mean, for me, one, I would like to know was that report concluded before the Fed made their comments, but I mean, it does get back to this bigger picture that in the bigger picture, you know, what the Fed did last week is about the short to medium term and obviously it's taking a much broader view, though I doubt that that was moving markets. But again, how much are they taking into account the inflation that we could see in the short to medium and possibly long term, if you're listening to people like Larry Summers, you know, how much is that a factor, given that there's no consensus about where we are, whether this is transitory or not, this inflation that we're experiencing? Jack?
7:06 Speaker 02 Ash, that's really interesting. I think that so much of the stock appreciation, the increase in the S and P 500 has been rising analyst expectations, which have risen as earnings have actually materialized. I remember from the first quarter of 2020, you know, Apple had something like a, you know, hundreds of billions of revenue and profit, and it really was off the charts. I wonder what the mechanism exactly is for a reduction in quantitative easing to how that will impact the earnings, but it is an interesting report.
7:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think it's about runoff on the balance sheet and the absence or the tapering down of incremental new purchases on the on the U.S. Treasury side as well as the agency debt side.
7:57 Speaker 02 Yes. Well, Ash, speaking of Treasuries, we had some pretty intense action today. Going into last night at 11:00 PM, going into midnight, yields were sharply falling, the 30-year actually going below 2%, which is a key level. But since then, they've rallied about 15 basis points. You had a pretty epic reversal and the 20, excuse me, 30-year is now standing at about 2.1%. And I think that you can directly link that to the surge in energy prices and energy stocks as well as technology stocks being on the back foot relatively. So I think it really is all about duration.
8:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, and we should also probably point out WTI trading at 73.54 here today. Obviously, obviously, rising. If you look at that chart, it's just been up and to the right consistently since effectively November. Obviously, there was a little bit of a bulge in March. It tapered off a little bit, but what we're looking at here, the rise in WTI, basically since May, up at a 45-degree angle.
9:03 Speaker 02 Yes, sorry, go ahead, Samuel.
9:07 Speaker 01 It's just incredible, the whiplash. When you look at it from oil to the dollar to markets, when I woke up this morning here in London, looking at what had happened in Asia, thinking that might be how the day would go, and everything from from stocks to oil to the dollar, just in the course, not even of 24 hours, how much it changed in the course of 12 hours.
9:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, DXY backing off a little bit here, below the 92 level now, trading at 91.86.
9:34 Speaker 02 Yes, actually, I'm putting up a chart of that right now. You can see that the dollar weakened a little bit as yields rose, and that proved to be fertile ground for the commodity rally, which, as you mentioned, Ash, earlier, WTI crude oil now standing above 73. That must be a absolute high for the year. I'm almost positive it is. And then earlier to what Samuel was alluding, the Asia opened very weak with the Hang Seng, the Australian stock indices up, excuse me, down a little over 1%, and Nikkei, the Japanese Nikkei 225, was down a whopping 3.3%. So, yeah, we saw Asia bleed early in the morning, but fortunately, in US markets, it's a risk-on appetite.
10:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, you're absolutely right. That is a that is a high on the year or thereabouts, maybe some intraday, but close to a high on the year on the close. And precisely to that point, for people who don't know, by the way, that one of the reasons why you see an oil and other commodities rallying on dollar weakness is because oil, of course, is denominated in US dollars. And so when you see the US dollar falling DXY in this case, and other cross currency pairs, it's logical and reasonable to expect to see that oil is going to rally at the same time.
10:52 Speaker 02 Yes, Ash, perhaps should we move on to assets that did not go up today, but actually had a tremendous tumble? Of course, I'm talking about Bitcoin, Ethereum, and much of the crypto universe. So I have been studying the charts. I've been looking at the price action. Samuel, you, I believe, have been taking a look at what's actually going on with China. And then Ash, of course, you are the generalist crypto editor of Real Vision, the expert. So Bitcoin declined from about 36,000 earlier today to 32,500. And that by itself, it's down about 40% over the past two months, and down just about 50% over almost half since its highs when it was at 64,000.
11:37 Speaker 02 So if this were a stock market, it would easily be in a deep bear market.
11:42 Speaker 00 Hey, Jack, can I jump in on that on price? Because I think you raise some really important points there. And just for a little bit of context, and just to show how incredibly volatile this asset is. So Bitcoin, I'm looking right now, I've got a spreadsheet that I built over the weekend that's showing this across different time horizons. This is really striking. So Bitcoin is off about 9.3% on the day. A week to date, it's off 8%. One month, off about 8%. Year to date, year to date, up 12%. One year to date, percent change, up 250%. Now, when you see those different time horizons moving in different directions
12:24 Speaker 00 with the different percent returns, you know, pretty striking. You don't see that in other asset classes. And that's just a function of the wild mood swings that we've seen in the Bitcoin market. It's a feature of the asset class.
12:37 Speaker 01 And today's news is really being driven by one story, and that's the fact that China is clamping down on Bitcoin mining in certain regions. And so they're worried that some of these places will close up shop and flood the market with the Bitcoins that they do have. And that, of course, has a knock on effect for Ethereum. But I think at the end of the day, your point is 100% valid here. This is a one day story. And as we've reported on in the past, what could be bad for Chinese Bitcoin miners might be great for American Bitcoin miners. Maybe they'll flood the market temporarily, but then this could mean other places will be able to pick up some of this work. So I think the big picture, which you're drilling down on there, Ash, is incredibly important. Probably a one-day story.
13:21 Speaker 02 Yes, but it's a one-day story, I'd add, Samuel, not just for Bitcoin, but for Ethereum as well. I've got all the crypto coins listed by market cap. And the top 20 are all down today. Binance Coin down 11%, Ripple down 12%, Dogecoin down 28.5%. For a long time now, almost pretty much since its inception, the inter-asset correlation between the different crypto coins has been a mainstay of the crypto world. And today is proof, at least for the day, that that remains the case.
13:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's trading like a risk-off crypto day, isn't it? You know, look, to just add, by the way, Samuel, I agree with everything you said. Very well said as well. I would say, to drill down a little bit here into the context, what's happening is, obviously, China has been imposing significant limitations on particularly mining, as you said, but also trading of these assets for allegedly macroprudential reasons, is the stated reason. PBOC, the specific driver of today's price action, and in the consternation that we're seeing in these markets, the specific driver is this language coming out of the PBOC. That's the People's Bank of China. This is the Chinese Central Bank.
14:32 Speaker 00 And the wording was, or at least the language that we've gotten in the translation in English, is that banks need to, quote, "strictly limit", close quote, "strictly limit" their involvement with this, and they need to strictly adhere to the guidance the Chinese Central Bank has provided. Now, this is true across the massive state-owned commercial banks in China, and also places like Ant Financial's Alipay. So this is a very broad-based bit of guidance. We know here in the United States, if you're a bank and your regulator tells you that you need to do something and that you need to strictly adhere to policy guidance, they probably mean that seriously. And so what we're seeing in the price action is perhaps, perhaps, some of the backdrop coming off that PBOC guidance.
15:17 Speaker 01 And it's interesting to see governments around the world really get nervous here in Europe today, or I should say the EU, we're not in the EU anymore here in the UK. What we saw is actually the EU coming out with a digital version of the euro. Now, it's not crypto, but it's this unease that so many banks, central banks around the world, and so many governments around the world feel that they're losing control of their currency. They have control of the cash, but as crypto pushes more and more into their territory, they're feeling the need to step things up. Now, no matter what side the debate you're on with crypto, you could say that's a positive, and certainly people have been moving away from cash.
15:57 Speaker 01 But doing a credit card transaction in euros is not the same as a digital euro. So we're really seeing incredible shifts around the world as a result of Bitcoin.
16:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, I should probably add on a technical factor here in the price of Bitcoin. We saw a so-called death cross today. That's the 50-day moving average falling below the 200-day moving average. Obviously, a bearish sign to see the more recent data trending below the 200 days, the longer-term average now above the shorter-term average.
16:29 Speaker 02 Yes, Ash, we actually are looking at that chart now, and it is a key technical indicator, people believe that. So it would be chart negligence to not let people know of that. I will say, however, Ash, that, you know, there, some people think that technical analysis is sort of drawing lines in the sand. And, you know, for those people who, the bullish signs didn't make them be bullish on Bitcoin on the way up, this bearish sign shouldn't make them be a bear on the way down. It's just something as a way I see of describing historical price action rather than predicting future price action.
17:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, I would say, you know, two things. First, as we all know, even those who are most skeptical of technical analysis will say that if you draw the line in the sand and enough people believe it has meaning, it does in fact have meaning. And I should also tease shameless plug, the book I'm working on that's about to be released with Harry Krishnan, who's a gentleman who is much smaller than me. ...than I am, background as an academic mathematician. We reviewed some data looking at positioning risk and it suggests, it suggests that there are some additional factors that could come into play that support technical analysis from a fundamental perspective in terms of understanding the positioning risk,
17:47 Speaker 00 credit risk at key levels in markets can play. So I'll just tease that a bit.
17:52 Speaker 01 Well, if you're going to tease it, you might as well give us the full tease. Any other details you can tell us about the book, Ash?
17:58 Speaker 00 Coming, coming soon, and I believe we'll be talking more about it on the platform in the coming weeks.
18:03 Speaker 01 I don't want to put you on the spot, but I just want to go back to the headline that I think is driving all this. And it is the bigger picture in China, not just the clamping down on mining today. But as I was talking about those opportunities in the United States, I'm just curious, with all the work that you've done in crypto, Ash, where, what, where do you think are the other places that can benefit? If China's going to continue pushing mining, crypto mining out of China, is the US the main benefactor in your estimation, based on all the factors that you've seen in your reporting?
18:37 Speaker 00 It's such an interesting question. In fact, interestingly enough, I was actually talking to someone in the VC space on the West Coast today, a few hours before this call, and we were talking about this. I said, effectively, it benefits, I think, people in a couple of key geographies. Number one, anywhere where energy is cheap. And number two, places where the climate permits cooling of these massive ASIC rigs that are used to actually do the mining. And I also said, I think that this could be potentially, potentially bullish for clean energy development here in the United States. So what's interesting about Bitcoin is that the mining aspect of it is that the mining basically, well, what's happened for Bitcoin mining is what's just happened to all of us in the last 12 months.
19:21 Speaker 00 It's totally virtualized. It can geographically be distributed anywhere in the world. So you don't necessarily have to have power generation near, for example, population centers. We see this in places like Iceland that has a lot of geothermal energy. Great deal of Bitcoin mining that's happening there. But if other renewables, solar, wind, tidal energy can be harnessed for this, they can literally be anywhere in the world where you can have high-speed fiber optic connections to the internet backbone that the miners can be connected to. So it's potentially something that we could see here in the United States. And I hope, and I think it's something that I would definitely be looking for beyond just the sort of emotional hope, to see this potentially spurring
20:04 Speaker 00 more clean energy development, renewable energy development, carbon-neutral energy development here in the United States. Obviously, US is a world leader in technology, and hopefully, we can get there.
20:15 Speaker 01 It's certainly not the headline that's captured so much of the world. You know that I've been looking closely at El Salvador adopting Bitcoin as an official currency alongside the US dollar. And so much of the pushback that the president of El Salvador was getting from his own country was over the environmental concern. So I think the more that that view comes to light ash, it could change the discussion around crypto, because some of the people who would be natural supporters are pushing back because of the environmental concerns.
20:46 Speaker 02 I've got a question I'd like to pose, which is, to what degree is this beneficial for people who mine Bitcoin who are not located in China? And I'm specifically talking about the profitability of the enterprise. For example, I had a friend in college who, in his college dorm room, mined Bitcoin. Would he benefit from this? Would he see that? And obviously, mining Bitcoin can be a very complicated and cost-intensive affair. Would this be good for someone like him? Would this perhaps be good for these stocks like Marathon Digital Holdings, perhaps? I don't know, that sort of own Bitcoin mining rigs?
21:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a really interesting question. Unfortunately, the days of hobbyists being able to easily mine Bitcoin on their desktop computers are probably something that's a bit in the past now. These are being done with massive mining pools using ASICs. Those are the application-specific integrated circuit cards that you see in these massive miners. I'm not really sure that hobbyists benefit from this just because of the scale that's required to do this.
21:47 Speaker 02 Am I showing my age, Ash?
21:50 Speaker 00 I'm sorry, Jack, I missed that one more time.
21:52 Speaker 02 Oh, I said, am I showing my age by how old I am?
21:55 Speaker 00 Jack, if you're showing your age, I'm in trouble.
21:58 Speaker 01 But Ash, it must be those competitors, not the hobbyists, but the big competitors that you're talking about in places like Iceland, must be rather happy today when you have such a huge competitor like China continuing to clamp down on the mining there. They must be celebrating, no?
22:12 Speaker 00 Yeah, I would think so, absolutely. And I should say, I haven't done a deep dive into who those competitors are and in terms of their relative apportionment across the globe. But look, bottom line, China has somewhere around 50% of the Bitcoin hash power for mining. When that is coming offline and is certainly appears to be doing, that's clearly good for everyone else elsewhere in the world who's in that space.
22:36 Speaker 02 Just a final point on crypto, Ash. I understand that tomorrow you have a piece coming out with Jim Bianco and I forgot the gentleman, the other gentleman, but it's sort of a...
22:48 Speaker 00 Jimmy Song.
22:48 Speaker 02 Jimmy Song. It's a lively discussion between about DeFi and Bitcoin. Tell us a little bit about that.
22:55 Speaker 00 Okay, so this is a conversation. It's a, you know, these are two, two guys who are obviously long-term friends of Real Vision, Jimmy Song, who is a Bitcoiner, and Jim Bianco, who is someone who's coming to us. Originally, he's been in space in the capital market space, macro investing space for many years, many decades, who's recently gotten very interested in the DeFi space. So this is really like an intense clash of worldviews. The conversation gets a little spicy, but it's very substantive, because what you're seeing really is this, this collision of different ways of seeing the world. As I've said before, for people who aren't in the cryptocurrency space, I think the single
23:35 Speaker 00 largest schism in the space isn't between the people who are advocating cryptocurrency and the so-called no-coiners, who are the, who are the neobudites who are opposed to cryptocurrency. It is the conversation, the debate, the near civil war within the space between the Bitcoiners and everyone else. And this conversation, I think, is so powerful. Powerful because you see two people who really are really brilliant avatars of their side of the debate. Jimmy Song, I believe, wrote the O'Reilly's book on programming Bitcoin, for those non-nerds out there. O'Reilly is the publisher that does like the reference books of choice for the really hardcore people in the space. Jimmy Song is about a deepest thinker
24:20 Speaker 00 on the technology, as you're going to find. Jim Bianco, on the other side of the coin, is about as deep a thinker as you're likely to find in analyzing and thinking about broad-based capital markets. He's an independent shop, so unlike, for example, research that you would see out of a sell-side bank, Jim Bianco is looking across asset classes, across currencies, across commodities, equities, basically thinking about the world in a holistic way that you would very rarely see from sell-side research. So you have these two kind of titans in their space, and they absolutely collide fundamentally because their worldviews, their perspectives, their understanding of what this revolution is about is so radically different. I think it's must-see.
24:58 Speaker 01 You're full of great teases today, Ash, but if it compares anything to your pomp, Mike Green, the best Bitcoin debate ever, then it really will live up to all the hype that it's getting behind the scenes here at Real Vision.
25:12 Speaker 00 I think it has some shades of that, definitely. And I think that, you know, in some ways, it's a slightly more technical debate. It's a debate that's a little bit more focused on financial markets rather than the broad sort of conceptual question of is this technology good or is it bad? Both debates, I think, are fantastic in their own way. I think you really have to see this one to make up your own mind about which is better.
25:32 Speaker 01 We'll be watching.
25:33 Speaker 00 Watch it tomorrow. I think it goes live at midnight tonight, is that right?
25:37 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think it does. So, Ash, you know, everyone talks about Bitcoin as a hedge against inflation. With the rise in yields, it seems like people are maybe getting a little less certain that inflation is going to be transitory. But Samuel, I understand that you've been tracking a certain market which is very related to inflation. Tell us a little bit about the airline sector, which has been at the epicenter of these supply shocks that have seen tremendous price increases.
26:03 Speaker 01 Well, the headline is American Airlines canceling hundreds of flights Saturday, Sunday, as well as today. Of course, I've got to fly to get back home to Arizona, so I'm always watching those American Airlines flights very closely. But listen, here's the deal. This is a perfect storm, insiders are telling me. You have a number of issues going on. You have maintenance of planes happening, or not happening in this case, but you also have staffing issues. Basically, what happened, of course, the airlines had to lay off hundreds, actually thousands, of workers, and they're rehiring them back little by little. They've had cheap prices, so lots of people are flying now, vaccinations are going well, and all of
26:44 Speaker 01 a sudden, they don't have enough staff, they don't have enough airplanes. You had pilots who were training on certain airplanes and newer airplanes, and now there's actually been an imbalance. So that's all created this perfect storm. But it really gets to this tale of inflation. And so I just want to put up on the screen one of the comments that we have from inside one of the Facebook message groups among airline staff, and what we see from one woman saying, "We are short agents, short flight crew. We've used all of our reserves, 90 ramp crew quit, and the new hires are quitting. 870 daily departures out of Dallas-Fort Worth. We cannot handle. Every day is insane," and I mean that literally.
27:29 Speaker 01 I think sometimes these little reporting bits can give us an incredible snapshot into what's going on in a particular industry. Now, I don't want to overexaggerate this when we talk about inflation, but I think this does give us a window. Certainly, airlines are unique. They have to go through a big training process for their employees. It takes months to onboard even the calling agents that you speak with when you're reserving a flight. A lot of people are overwhelming the airlines because people are trying to figure out what the COVID regulations are. They're very complex, state to state, country to country, as I know all too well, trying to fly from the UK to the US. But at the end of the day, I think we can extract a lot from this story because it's not just American Airlines. Delta...
28:15 Speaker 01 They had 21-hour wait times when you were calling that airline this week. And United, they're having issues hiring baggage, folks. Then you have the TSA offering $1,000 signing bonuses for anybody who signs up to be a TSA agent. I think the backdrop gives a very clear picture about what's going on with hiring in the United States. It's not easy, and so I think it comes all the way back to our discussions about the Fed, inflation, and labor inflation. When you have all these airlines, Delta, United, American Airlines, for me, it just paints a very clear picture.
28:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, if you look at the TSA check put-through rate, it absolutely plummeted during March, and it just was barely grinding higher. And the airlines were barely holding on, and it's possible that, you know, perhaps they could have gone bankrupt if it were not for the ample support from both the Federal Reserve as well as the US government. I might point out that airlines is one of the most dangerous and least profitable industries that you will find. And, you know, airlines frequently went bankrupt up until, let's say, about five years ago. In fact, American Airlines went bankrupt in 2013. I'll point out, Samuel, that American Airlines was initially down on the day, trading on those negative headlines that you talked about, but it actually ended up up on the
29:38 Speaker 02 day because it was lifted by the short-duration trade. And all the other airlines, United, Southwest, Delta, were up, but I believe American Airlines was up slightly less. Samuel, I have my own story, which is, you know, you've been doing your reporting very factual. My story is a little more anecdotal, but it comes from my sister, who last night flew from California back to New York, and she was on a Delta flight, and her flight was oversold by 26 people. Now, overselling is a common tactic used by airlines because less than 100% of people who buy tickets actually show up. But clearly, they did that a little bit too much, as they were basically bribing passengers
30:20 Speaker 02 with $800 Best Buy gift cards to stay in a hotel for free and get on a layaway because they overbooked by 26 people. So you're seeing that these supply shocks really are impacting the airlines.
30:33 Speaker 00 I guess the $64,000 question, or maybe the $23 trillion question, is just how widespread this is. How much of this is a function of broader labor markets? And how much of this is a function of, for example, the rebound effect that we see in travel? And perhaps just the dysfunctional cartel that is the US airline industry? You were talking about bankruptcies. I remember very clearly being at the trading floor at BB and T, and I think it was 2005, and hearing one of the guys on the desk shriek, "NWAC filed!" And then 30 seconds later, in an increasingly shrill tone, "Delta files! Delta files!"
31:15 Speaker 00 And all the traders ran back because they had positions in those bonds. I mean, this is an industry that has been fraught with peril, fraught with bankruptcies, dare I say, at times mismanaged over the last 20-plus years. And I'm sure far back beyond that, before I was watching these markets.
31:34 Speaker 01 Well, and of all the government stimulus that came out as a result of the pandemic, there's one number that really stands out to me. There was one economist who calculated that the airlines had been given $1 billion too much. If you look at where they were before, and the money that they got, and how they spent it, of course, that will depend on who's doing the numbers. But it was actually somebody who was in favor a lot of this stimulus coming to this conclusion. But at the end of the day, look, if you're wanting to invest in these companies, it's telling you one thing. There's certainly demand and not enough supply. You'd have to think that they're going to be able to get those pilots onto the right planes, that they'll get those employees trained up. So it does come back to this issue about will they be able to staff people at what price?
32:20 Speaker 01 Will they have to offer more in salary to people? More signing bonuses? And will that have an effect on how much the three of us and the people watching the daily briefing have to pay to get onto an airplane?
32:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's interesting, Samuel. I believe American Airlines actually has the majority of its operations, or a disproportionate amount of its operations, on domestic travel, which is essentially free to go. I mean, you know, maybe sitting on a certain seat, if it's less than full, you should not sit directly next to someone, but there's essentially
32:52 Speaker 01 Oh, you guys have no idea in the United States how loose things are compared to here in Europe. Flying here is almost impossible, literally because of so much of the lockdown that we're still under here. But all the testing that has to go on, all the quarantining that has to go on, the day two, day five, day eight testing. Once I get to the United States, it's free flying from there compared to all of the rules we live under here in Europe.
33:17 Speaker 02 Oh, yes. Samuel, you know, because you are in London. So, yeah, in terms of strenuous, like, the US is here, and then within domestic Europe, between Europe, it's here. But international travel is, I think, an even higher bar. And if you ever go back to Arizona, you definitely will see that. So it's interesting to me that American Airlines is struggling despite the fact that it's sort of oriented towards a sector that should be, on a relative basis, succeeding, domestic travel.
33:44 Speaker 00 For sure. I'm just relieved that as of this weekend, I no longer have to wear a mask while I'm in the elevator in my apartment building. So that's my benefit story. Hey, by the way, talking about international, I was just flipping through some of the comments, and I see Oliver Williams has just said, "Can we please use Sam joining the team to talk more about international markets?" I suspect the answer to that question, Samuel, is yes.
34:09 Speaker 01 Absolutely. Well, on that note, inflation. We heard Christine Lagarde today say that she expects moderate inflation. She certainly didn't sound as nervous as some in the United States. But, you know, here in the UK, I've already said here on the daily briefing that because of Brexit, we'll feel some inflationary pressure because we don't have as many immigrants, although they were migrants because they were part of the EU before. So there's certainly some inflationary pressure here as well, but we don't have as much control of it. But certainly, we will be covering a lot more international stories, and not just here. I spend a lot of time in Latin America, so expect to see a lot of that, and a lot of interest from me, as you've heard, about El Salvador moving to use Bitcoin.
34:52 Speaker 00 Fantastic. Talking of viewer comments, let's go to the questions because we're lighting up here in our document. This one comes to us from Prius Omega, a regular viewer. I'm going to throw this one to Jack and Sam will dive in. What's the deal with the US 10-year bonds, real yields and gold? The inverse relationship is busted the last couple of trading days.
35:15 Speaker 02 Okay, well-
35:16 Speaker 00 That's a really technical question.
35:18 Speaker 02 Yeah, no, no, I can handle it, but I think saying a correlation is busted for a few days. I think that correlations exist within regimes and regimes do change, but I think that you have to give them a little weight. And I've actually run the correlation between real rates and gold, real rates being inflation adjusted. So you take the nominal rate and then you incorporate the, what the market is pricing for inflation, that's called the inflation breakeven. And it actually works pretty well. For example, one reason that gold essentially traded sideways over the past decade is that we had very muted inflation and inflation breakevens themselves were muted. So rates were, you know, actually
35:57 Speaker 02 positive. Now they are deeply negative and that accelerated into the beginning of this year, but they actually have risen slightly. So I don't know if you can say that they have been busted because what I assume, you know, let's see, rates surged and breakevens declined. So, and yeah, okay, I see what he's saying, but I think you've got to give it a little more time.
36:24 Speaker 00 Hey, Jack, can I just ask, that was a terrific technical answer to someone who obviously has a very strong financial background in Prius Omega and you yourself look at these data sets every day. Let me ask you this, though, Jack. What did you just say for people who may be new to the bond markets and commodities? Give us the 50,000-foot overview, less technically.
36:44 Speaker 02 Okay.
36:46 Speaker 00 I know it's a technical question, but give us the broad base.
36:49 Speaker 01 I like it. I like the way you're putting them on the spot, Ash.
36:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, I like it. Let's hope-
36:54 Speaker 00 It says something, by the way, that the harder question for Jack is to try and explain it in natural language. He understands the deep concept.
37:01 Speaker 02 Yeah, so let's see. So- Gold has no yield, right? Gold's not going to pay you a 1% dividend. It competes with the world of fixed income, which does pay you dividends. So if bonds pay you 3% and gold pays you nothing, that is a differential of 3%. So gold's maybe not looking so hot. But then you have to take into account inflation, which is what you're being paid in is being devalued. There's being a fiat devaluation, if I can use that phrase. So it's not like you're being paid in something that is eternally fixed. A $19 in 1970 is worth a lot less now. So you can actually be paid in,
37:46 Speaker 02 you could still be losing money, even if you're being paid, if the currency at which you're being paid is depreciating more rapidly than the rate of interest itself. So if rates are negative as they are now, the argument, oh, you shouldn't own gold because it has no yield, may not hold as much water because you're actually losing money, even though you're being paid in interest, when you take into account inflation. Did I do it okay, Job?
38:13 Speaker 00 Check, check. That was perfect.
38:15 Speaker 02 Very nice.
38:16 Speaker 00 Absolutely perfect.
38:16 Speaker 01 And it all comes back to inflation today on the Daily Briefing.
38:19 Speaker 02 Yes.
38:20 Speaker 00 Yeah. Here's a question that comes to us from Lee. Before BTC came to be, I was saying there would come a day when there would be a Titanic struggle over the definition of money between central banks and the free market. Do you think this is beginning to play out? And can, in your opinion, governments stop the crypto juggernaut? Wow, this is a great question. Let me just jump in and take it. The short, the really short answer is yes and probably not. So to the questions, is there something that's happening right now? This Titanic struggle, as Lee phrases it, about the definition of money between central banks and the free market? Absolutely.
39:05 Speaker 00 And we're seeing that, I think, increasingly get exacerbated as central banks seem to consistently fall perpetually.
39:14 Speaker 00 Further and further behind the curve in trying to manage their dual mandate. What the Ed Harrison used to call the Scylla and Charybdis in these markets. So I think that is definitely very much a reckoning. And part of the challenge, I think, this is a very big topic, obviously, but I would say in order to really understand it, you have to make this big topic even bigger, even broader. The reality is that we have real challenges in Western democracies in particular, which are the markets that I follow most closely here in the United States. And that problem is political division. We have the greatest level of polarization that I've ever seen in my life in this country. And so what that means is it's very challenging, whichever side of the political divide you
39:55 Speaker 00 come down on, it's very challenging for the Congress of the United States to get stuff done. And what that means fundamentally is that if you have a Congress that's deeply hamstrung by these partisan divisions, then the kind of, the kind of sort of blocking and tackling work of government becomes harder and harder for them to do. I have a friend who's a former New York Times reporter who likes to say, it doesn't matter if you're a Democrat or a Republican, when you're a mayor, somebody's got to fix the potholes. And the reality is, there's this increasing sense that I have, again, totally nonpartisan statement, that the potholes just aren't getting fixed. And what winds up happening is that central banks then have to do progressively more
40:40 Speaker 00 and more of the heavy lifting. And there's a limitation to what these central banks can do. You know, central banks make great, perhaps the metaphor might be firefighters, when there's a fire at three o'clock in the morning, you can pick up the phone and call the central bank and they put it out. But they're not able to do the work of building inspectors, making sure that buildings are up to code, making sure the economy is fundamentally sound. So this is a challenge that we are going to see increasingly, I think, as we go forward in all aspects.
41:09 Speaker 01 And if you think there's a logjam in the United States, imagine what people in places like Venezuela are feeling. El Salvador, I'm not comparing El Salvador to Venezuela by any stretch of the imagination, but it's somewhere where government has been inefficient and gangs have taken Over at times where governments can't govern. So when you're in one of these places and you have the possibility of another currency that could be more stable when you look at a place like Venezuela, or that could make transactions between the United States and El Salvador easier. It certainly has, at the very least, a lot of appeal to broad swathes of the population.
41:47 Speaker 01 So forget about the potholes. The holes are much deeper in other places of the world that are really turning to crypto as a possibility at the very least.
41:56 Speaker 02 So many great points from you both. If I may, just go back to the core of the question, what is money? If you read an economics textbook, what almost every single textbook will tell you is that money evolved as a more efficient way to conduct barter. So Ash would make shoes and Samuel, you would fish and Ash, you would trade your shoes for Samuel's fish. And then gold coins sort of became a more efficient way to do that. I think an increasingly large number of scholars, whether it's anthropologists, economists, or numismatists or people who study money, actually think that it was money evolved as a way to cancel debt.
42:37 Speaker 02 And I think that Mike Green, actually I believe Ash, in a conversation with you earlier this year, put it that way. Money is that which cancels debt. And I think there is no shorter and more concise way to describe money than what Mike Green says. Money is that which cancels debt. And the original debt is taxes. So if you can pay taxes in Bitcoin or in crypto, then it is money. And we see that El Salvador recently made those strides. So yeah, it definitely is something to, that is currently evolving and it would be very interesting to see how it continues to evolve.
43:12 Speaker 00 Boy, Jack, that's a wide swath from the double coincidence of want to the foundational ideology of MMT.
43:19 Speaker 01 And just to circle back to a point that I was making earlier about the Eurozone, I should say, announcing a digital Euro. I mean, I could really just hear them twisting themselves into what sounded like pretzels nearly, trying to explain how it would be anonymous, only if it were under 75 euros, anything over 75 euros. I mean, you can really feel the way that there is unease from so many governments, as what money is, is being redefined in some ways as a result of crypto. In spite of those long-held definitions, there's a lot of competition in the marketplace.
43:59 Speaker 00 Yeah, I wrote a piece about a decade ago when I was a reporter at CNBC about the Eurozone and the European Union. I think the headline was something like, "Forget Too Big to Fail: Is the EU or EZ Too Complicated to Succeed?"
44:14 Speaker 01 Ooh, good point.
44:17 Speaker 00 By the way, speaking of too complicated to succeed, I wanted to just circle back to the end of Lee's question, because this was a really interesting point, and it's something that I'm actually a little bit out of consensus on, and it's a bit of a controversial take that I have on this, which is unusual for me. And the question is, do you think that, in my opinion, governments can stop the crypto juggernaut? I think in the short term, it's very unlikely that they can. However, and this is an out-of-consensus opinion, I really do believe that it is possible for large, powerful nation-states to begin to put significant pressure on cryptocurrency. There's this phrase that gets bandied about a lot in the crypto space, which is that Bitcoin is unstoppable. It's totally uncensorable. And I think that's true using today's technology, but you can imagine a future, whether it's
45:01 Speaker 00 five or 10 years ahead, where there was embedded hardware that was specifically intended to censor, impede, report, analyze what's happening in networks. Now, this is a very controversial opinion, and certainly probably beyond the scope of today's conversation, but I really do believe that nation-states, particularly a coordinated action by supranational organizations and nation-states, actually has the potential to restrict, if not, let's say it in the most general sense, to restrict the flow of cryptocurrency.
45:36 Speaker 01 But when we look at the story out of China today, I mean, you brought up the point about the directives that places like Alipay are getting. I mean, let's say, just a theoretical, Ash, that China completely stops all interaction, outlaws, any interaction with any type of cryptocurrency. Do you think that that would stop crypto? I have a feeling you would say no, but wouldn't it dent the industry so much? And I mean, the industry, when I say the industry, without a juggernaut like China?
46:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think that's exactly the right question, Samuel. This question of what can be, what happens, what's the impact if there are these draconian sort of laws that could potentially restrict the flow of Bitcoin by outlawing it. And I think that China is certainly the nation that is best positioned to do so. Obviously, we know that they have considerable control at the main access points for the internet. They have the so-called Great Firewall of China, which is able to, for example, restrict Western social media websites from being served to their billion-plus population. So it's certainly possible that China has the technology, perhaps the will and the central control, to be able to, at
46:54 Speaker 00 very least, begin to impede the flow of it. And as you say, dent the industry, that would be a major hit to price. Would it recover? I think it's likely that it would. I don't think that the technology exists today in 2021 to shut down the Bitcoin network. In fact, the network itself is probably nearly impossible to stop. But you could severely restrict the on-ramps and the off-ramps, which would have a significant impact, precisely as you suggest, Samuel, on price and on the industry more broadly.
47:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, Ash, you know, go ahead, Jeff.
47:26 Speaker 02 You know a lot more about the technology than I do, but I would agree, it is functionally impossible to shut down the network in that Bitcoin can exist in that, Ash. You can go over to your house and give you a hard drive, and then you can give me, you know, currency. But are hedge fund managers going to be plowing into this thing if, you know, one of the largest economies on earth, China, bans it outright? Probably not. So I think Bitcoin, as we know it, can be shut down, but Bitcoin as a network cannot be shut down.
47:55 Speaker 00 I agree with you, Jack, in what you said about your fundamental view of the way that the network works. I don't know. I think hedge fund managers might be interested in continuing to invest in it. Look, at a price, there's probably a bid for it. I don't know that China leaving the ecosystem in and of itself would be enough to sort of decimate the price. I think it would be certainly a bearish sign for the industry, but I don't think it would be enough for institutional investors to want to back away from it. Would be enough for institutional investors to want to move away from it would be significant or draconian legislation in the US, in Europe, that would restrict or begin to look as though it was moving or making
48:39 Speaker 00 inroads toward outright prohibition. But I just don't foresee that happening.
48:44 Speaker 01 And I just have to say that when you look at something as decentralized as Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies at large, and we look at China, which is arguably the most centralized unit in the entire world, it's just very hard for me to see how the two go head together, crypto and China. When you look at the amount of control, I mean, you just talked about it online, but when you can look at the amount of control they exert over people using those online tools, especially in a post-COVID era, we're not quite there yet, but we'll get there. In a post-COVID era, the type of draconian measures they've used to track people and to really put that apparatus more in place, the type of control that China has over its
49:25 Speaker 01 people, that centralized nature that it has over its people at current time, it just slaps in the face of Bitcoin. So I have a very hard time seeing how those two move forward together.
49:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, well said, and probably a good note to end it. Gentlemen, we appear to have run over time once again on this show. Shocking. I'm sure none of our viewers will believe it happened once again. Any final thoughts? Jack, first to you.
49:49 Speaker 02 Well, my final thought would be I wonder if global central banks and global governments would prove less hostile to other forms of cryptocurrency such as Ethereum that maybe are a little more friendly, less decentralized than they would with Bitcoin because to sort of go back to my anthropological argument, I don't think governments want digital value being stored in a temple that can be locked away. I think they want it in circulation, being used to fund the projects and something like Ethereum or other coins may be more friendly to that. I know that's a very, you know, that's very provoking thoughts, so it's not really much of a closing thought, but yeah.
50:31 Speaker 00 Well, China already has DCEP, the Digital Currency Electronic Payment Network, which is a highly centralized cryptocurrency-like central bank product coming out of PBOC. So I expect we'll probably see more of that in the months and years to come. Samuel, to you, final thoughts?
50:49 Speaker 01 Well, I'm just going to go back to what billionaire investor Ray Dalio signaled today in that conference in Qatar. And he just said that there is so much liquidity in the market that it's really put everything out of whack from him, to put it simply. And so when I look at a day like today, when you have the Fed presidents from Dallas to St. Louis, former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers and Ray Dalio, all saying that this is a, that they're hawkish about the situation with inflation, moving away from transitory comments. When you have that and the market has the day that it did today, it really makes you wonder, not wonder, it really makes you think about those comments from Ray Dalio and how he sees liquidity in this market.
51:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, all eyes on the CPI next month.
51:37 Speaker 01 Absolutely.
51:39 Speaker 00 And all eyes on liquidity. Thank you so much, gentlemen, for joining us.
51:42 Speaker 02 Thanks, Ash.
51:44 Speaker 01 Good evening from London.
Previous What Currencies Are Saying About the Sell-Off ( w/ Andreas Steno Larsen ) Next Bitcoin Crashes as Stocks Flirt with All-Time Highs Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated