Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Takeaways from the Miami Bitcoin Conference About this episode DB-June7,2021: Real Vision managing editor Ed Harrison and senior editor Ash Bennington sit down together on the Daily Briefing to provide their insights into today’s market price action and share their experience at the Miami Bitcoin conference from this past weekend. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:12 Speaker 00 Real Vision Daily Briefing, live without a net. I'm here once again with Ed Harrison. Ed, welcome.
0:19 Speaker 01 Looking good, Louis.
0:21 Speaker 00 Looking good. Billy Ray, I think. How are you, man?
0:25 Speaker 01 Good. I am very good. I haven't seen you since, hey, just Friday, in fact. We were together live for the first time in, what, 15 months, I think it is?
0:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, something crazy like that. It's great to see the world getting back to normal. It was great to actually get to be physically in the same room with you and to do a daily briefing. What day was that? I've lost track. You're saying it was Friday?
0:47 Speaker 01 That's right. Yeah, exactly. Because you were in Miami, now you're back in New York. It must be, feel pretty weird.
0:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, it was really great. It was great being in Miami. I just want to say at the top of the show, I was personally very touched to see how many people came up to me just to take the time out to say hello, to thank us for what we're doing. And it's really great to be able to do it. It's an honor to be able to do that and have so many people, obviously, watching what we're doing and hopefully getting some value from it. So thank you so much to everyone who came up and said hello. I'm going to be reaching out over the next couple of days. It was kind of overwhelming how many people came up to say hello. So we're going to be reaching out in the next couple of days to everyone.
1:28 Speaker 01 So, as you know, I'm the guy on RVDB who talks the least about crypto. I usually want to stick to global macro, but I want to talk about the crypto conference in that context, just because there were so many people from the global macro side moving over. I want to give you my take on what this means, how I'm thinking about it, and also get an understanding from you of, you know, what your takeaways were, because you were there for the weekend, you were there for longer than I was. And so I think that that could be a good way for us to think about the integration of crypto into the investing landscape.
2:07 Speaker 00 Well, that's exactly right, Ed. And I've been really excited to hear the macro guy who spent a couple of days at the crypto conference. I'd love to hear what your takeaways were.
2:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I was there on Thursday and Friday, Wednesday through Friday, actually. And so I missed a lot of the actual conference and stuff. In fact, I never went into the conference and you can talk to me about, you know, actually, you know, walking the floor and seeing what was there. But I went to a lot of the after-parties, the launch events, et cetera. And what I took away is that, you know, 99% of the people that I encountered were investors in the macro space, that is, traditional investors who saw an opportunity in crypto that they were moving over into. And interestingly enough, I would say, without a fail, no one was talking about the price
2:59 Speaker 01 action in crypto as something that caused them to get into the space per se. They were talking about crypto as a platform for the digitization of content. When I say content, the digitization of value. So things that they would have done or wanted to do in the analog world, moving over to the digital world. And the question is, is over what timeframe does that happen? What are the parameters around which that happens in terms of regulation? And, you know, who has first mover advantage? And does that first mover advantage actually accrue as a benefit in the way that, say, MySpace did not get a benefit vis a vis Facebook?
3:45 Speaker 00 Yeah. Tell us more about that. What do you think the future trajectory is? And what do you think those investors are seeing?
3:52 Speaker 01 So what I, you know, now I'm talking about institutional investors. I mean, when I think of the investors, I didn't really meet that many real retail investors. It was a lot of institutional investors who were making this move over. And what they were basically saying is, I spoke to one investor in particular who had a very good, I thought it was a very apt analogy. He said that, you know, I'm looking at crypto as a space where there are a multiplicity of different app stores. Each of these individual boxes, each of these individual currencies.
4:26 Speaker 01 Are a platform on which you can build your app store. You can do any and everything there. There are a sundry different things that that you can take away over time. Now, some of those app stores are better than others. And some of them, the network effects of the app store is going to make that particular platform have staying power. We don't know which of those there are. Some of them are going to be Nokia and they're going to go the way of Nokia or REM. And some of them are going to end up being Android and and the iPhone. And so what you're seeing now, both in terms of the layer two solutions, but also in terms of the cryptocurrency price is sort of
5:11 Speaker 01 what I would call a a gold rush mentality, where people are trying to get the first mover advantage to be able to scale, get those network effects and get in there. And then the question is, is what are the killer apps for the investment community? We're talking about derivative transactions. We're talking about bonds that can be trunched. We're talking about tokenization of existing types of securities that you see in the real world. All of those kinds of things are applications that will come to the future. They're waiting for that all to happen. And then the question is, is what are the parameters from a regulatory perspective?
5:52 Speaker 01 What's the regulatory umbrella that allows them, as regulated entities, to get into that playing field in a way that gives them comfort?
6:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's all extremely well said. I had a few key takeaways myself from the days that I was there. And I'll talk a little bit more generally about what I think the state of crypto is. But I wanted to just touch on a couple of the points that I took away very directly from this experience. The first was exactly what you said, Ed. We're 100% on the same page, spot on here. The fact that these folks, the institutional investors, were physically there on the ground at the parties, walking around. I saw some of them on the day of the conferences, walking through the events space themselves. was very interesting. The fact that they were physically present, these are people who have a very high opportunity cost on their time.
6:42 Speaker 00 And they showed up. By the way, you could often tell because they were the guys wearing the golf shirts with a sport coat over them in Miami. But there were quite a number of them, and that really was, I thought, a pretty powerful statement in itself, the fact that they'd taken the time out to come. This is something that I didn't see, even in the go-go heydays of 2017, the last massive bull market cycle. That was not something that I saw in those conferences. So I thought that was very interesting. The second point, one of the things that kept coming up in the conversations that I had, that you had with some of the folks who were institutional investors and in the institutional investing space was the concern about regulatory uncertainty,
7:24 Speaker 00 about compliance and governance uncertainty. This was a meta theme that came up around the folks that we were just talking about, and I thought that that was a really interesting one. The other thing that I thought was rather interesting was that I spoke to some people who had been in the traditional institutional investing space, people who were in businesses like market making. In other words, folks who spent a lot of time focusing on price action, and they thought it was a bearish signal that crypto prices did not hit 40,000. They didn't have a major upswing. Obviously, we had some announcements while we were there specifically about a country in Latin America coming aboard to use cryptocurrency as legal tender, El Salvador.
8:09 Speaker 00 This is something that was a big story, and yet it didn't really move the needle for prices of Bitcoin. I think it's an incredibly bullish story for Zach Mallers, for Jack Mallers and Zap, but didn't really move the needle on price for the broader space. So I thought that was very interesting. The other third takeaway that I thought was was was kind of almost amusing was the cultural aspect of it. I thought it was really interesting that they had, and you unfortunately didn't get to see this because you didn't get to go to the convention floor, but they had an art gallery set up, and it looked like a pop-up art gallery that could have been anywhere in Brooklyn or Jersey City or Soho, it was this really cool hip place where there were people who didn't look like they were institutional investors.
8:53 Speaker 00 They didn't look like coders. They were these cool artist people. And it's interesting to me that the space now is starting to bring into the fold. Some of those people, it's become a full fledged cultural moment in addition to a technology story, in addition to an investing story.
9:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, very interesting. You know, Ash, the question that I'm asking myself, and I think this is a global question is, what is this emblematic of? From where we are in the cycle, in the business cycle, because this particular business cycle is very different. We've had this pandemic, we have massive fiscal stimulus, we are continuing to have monetary stimulus, even though, you know, we've had gangbusters growth. And we also have some level of inflation. And what are the antecedents to this that we can point back to and think about in a interesting way? Now, if you think about this gold rush mentality, one thing that I've been toying with in terms of where we are is thinking about this as sort of
9:54 Speaker 01 the pandemic in a weird way as sort of a mid-cycle pause. I more akin in certain ways to the interregnum in 97, 98, when you had the Asian crisis and the LTCM crisis. In a sense that Alan Greenspan was talking about irrational exuberance in 1996. And it was only in 1998 that we were actually off to the races. We had five consecutive years of the S and P 500 going up 96, 97, 98, 99. Actually, I think it was 95 through 99, more than 20%.
10:35 Speaker 01 And it was early on in that Greenspan was musing about irrational exuberance. Potentially, you could look at what's happening now as this is, you know, when you look at the internet days, the equivalent of the consolidation phase where the next leg up is the leg that is sort of the blow off top. That's just something I'm thinking about in terms of what does it mean for assets writ large, you know, just from a general global macro perspective? And then what does it also mean in terms of the killer app for crypto? So to the degree that we're talking about the different. Cryptocurrencies as app stores and getting scale.
11:20 Speaker 01 What is the killer app for those market makers that you've met? For those individuals who are looking for a regulated environment to give them an umbrella under which they can act, you know, in a greater way in the crypto space. So that's kind of how I'm thinking of it now. And I think that it's interesting to think about the event that we had in terms of what it signals about where we are going forward, especially to the degree that you said that the price action was more representative of consolidation than it was of a breakout to the upside.
11:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think that's right. It's spot on, Ed. Such an important conversation to have. I love the way that you can tie this back, the crypto story to the broader macro story, which brings me to the question that we were talking about offline, which is about inflation and a topic near and dear to your heart, cycling.
12:16 Speaker 01 Yes, yeah, that was interesting. I saw this article, actually Jim Bianco sent it to me because he's a bit of an inflationista. And I joked in Twitter that it was a plant, but he was talking about a, you know, really expensive bicycle, hinting at inflation. And since I'm a cyclist, he's a cyclist, we talk about this, how there's this, this shadow used car market, a similar thing that's going on in the used bike market where you have massive inflation there. And the question is, is what does that mean for the broader economy? Because you see inflation everywhere and how, you know, how is this going to feed through
12:57 Speaker 01 both in terms of the Fed's new reaction function and also in terms of this broader sense of
13:07 Speaker 01 Are we still in the post, in the, in the post nineteen ninety seven, ninety eight scenario that I'm talking about? So that's how I'm thinking about the inflation. Is it that the Fed is going to crack down on it and therefore we could be closer to the end of cycle? No, it seems to me based upon the Fed's reaction, the new reaction function, which is waiting until you see the whites of inflation's eyes. Even though we have this transient inflation, we are not going to have any sort of tightening of policy, except to the degree that the bond market tightens policy
13:46 Speaker 01 as it did in Q1. So I think that gives room to run to a certain degree for risk assets.
13:55 Speaker 00 Yeah. So you don't, you simply do not see the Fed acting without enormous, enormous precursors that force their hand to do so?
14:03 Speaker 01 Yeah. So I mean, if you look at the NFP number that we got on Friday as an example, this is a case of bad news being good news. We didn't make the number. We did actually make the number on the unemployment level, which is five point eight percent versus the six point one percent that we had before, but it was because labor force participation had gone down. So all of that is relatively negative relative to expectations. But what it means is the Fed's going to be on hold, which means that we're still moving back to the baseline that we want to, but in a situation in which we have an accommodative monetary policy, you know, keeping
14:45 Speaker 01 things going. So from an asset price perspective, that is bullish. And then the only question is, what happens therefore to market, to market based levels of, of yields, like the ten year yield or the five year yield, given that the market is increasingly understanding that the, the Fed is going to continue to look through inflation levels? Do we have a run up to two percent, two point two five percent in the ten year? And then what does that do to asset prices? I think that's the sort of the near to medium term risk. But I think that really we're in a
15:27 Speaker 01 position now where people are increasingly thinking about a risk off environment.
15:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, very interesting points. Let me shift gears back to go back to the crypto space. And you know, this has been an interesting few days for me. I got a couple hours sleep last night. I got in very late this morning, early this morning. But I'm still sorting through all of my reactions to this particular conference, the people I met, the conversations I had, and just some of the reactions of frankly, this is the first time I've left Manhattan since 2019, I believe. So physically getting out and traveling again was really an interesting experience as well and has gotten me thinking through some of this stuff. So again, this is very raw. I haven't organized my thoughts yet, but I wanted to talk them through with you actually live on the air to get some of your reactions to it. You know, my first big picture takeaway, having been out of the house and physically
16:18 Speaker 00 doing stuff, is how manualized our world still is. The amount of paper that still exists when you physically print a boarding pass, you know, you scan your QR code and you print a boarding pass. Now, I know that there are some people who use their QR card, get directly on the airplane, but there's still a tremendous amount of manualized things in your life. The fact that you, you know, I physically came home and my doorman handed me a stack of mail to literally the guy in Miami that I handed a dollar or two to get a bottle of water. It's still an incredibly manualized world that we live in. We think about the digitization because that's what's new, but the reality is there's still a long way to run on this digitization trend because there's still so much legacy manual
17:02 Speaker 00 analog processes that we still do every day in our lives. And the second thought that I had is that big picture, you know, spending time in this space, in the blockchain space, in the distributed ledger space, in the Bitcoin space, it's clear to me, and I know that this is something that's somewhat controversial, we'll have to have Max Weethie on to debate me on this, which is that the decentralized world, decentralized solutions, solutions that are not owned by a particular company or government are unquestionably, in my view, the future. Now, that's not a statement about the price action, it's not a statement about the direction, it's not a statement about the sentiment of Bitcoin or Ethereum or anything else. It's just very clear that decentralized solutions, the decentralized world, it is
17:47 Speaker 00 what is rising very rapidly to Effectively become Web 3.0, that in the future, there are going to be fewer massive corporations that control our data because the architecture is being built that enables that to happen. Now, I know that Max and some others have said, "Well, why do we need this? This isn't something that I've ever wanted. This isn't something that I've asked for. I've never said, 'You know what I really need? I need an email system that's decentralized.'" And this has gotten me thinking in a very broad-based way about the future trajectory based on the past trajectory. You and I have been watching technology for a lot of cycles, very seriously, in both of our cases, since at least the 90s. And the thing that I'm most fascinated by is the idea that the solutions that we have,
18:32 Speaker 00 the way that we lead our lives today, were not "problems" that we wanted fixed because we didn't know that they existed. For example, when you and I were both young guys back in the 90s, and it was a big deal to have your first cellphone, and it was cool to be able to be at a party and step outside and take a call from your Motorola StarTAC Elite, no one said, "You know what I really need? A really efficient touchscreen way of being able to send SMS text messages to my friend." It wasn't a demand that anyone had. It wasn't a need that anyone felt. It wasn't an itch that anyone wanted to scratch. And yet, and yet, once the technology exists, it becomes absolutely indispensable to our
19:16 Speaker 00 lives, once we become adjusted to it, once we become acculturated to it. So I'm always very curious and thinking about this in a big-picture way, because I think that the way that we think about technological development, the way that we think about supply and demand, may be backwards. We hear, "Find a problem and solve it. Find a problem and fix it." But the reality is, it really is supply that drives demand. Once you have the solution, you realize that you want it or that you need it. And this is a very, sort of, much an inversion of the way that we typically think about things. And I wanted to just throw that out there to you and get your opinion and your thoughts on that.
19:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, a lot to chew on. I, you know, let me see if I can put it all in. All the things I was thinking about as you were talking about that. First, I was thinking about Steve Jobs and the iPhone and how it's exactly, as you say. And, you know, that's exactly as he sees it, that really the customer comes to you in certain ways. You're not necessarily going to the customer. You're not getting some sort of review from the customer focus group. And then therefore, let's go out and build this thing based upon what they said. Let's build some cool products and then let's market those products. And we'll iterate on that once the, once the customers adopt and tell us what about the new product they like or they don't like.
20:39 Speaker 01 That's right. I think that's much more in line with what you're talking about. And so to me, it sort of reinforces the land grab paradigm that I'm talking about. This gold rush mentality where basically you have a thousand different people out there doing a thousand different things or a million different things. And some of those things are going to fail. I mean, this is the essence of American entrepreneurial capitalism. This is that failure is not a badge of discredit. It's a badge of honor. When you fail, it shows that you tried. And eventually, some of those failures will turn into successes. We, sometimes you just don't know which ones are, it's going to be.
21:20 Speaker 01 I also think that, just going back to my first initial thoughts when you were talking about, we don't know what the killer app is. That's a positive in many ways. It says that we have a long way to go in terms of this digitization of value. When you were saying that everything's done in an analog way, in many ways. I'm using paper everywhere. Well, that tells you that there are, there's still a lot of things that can be solved potentially that, you know, crypto can be a part of. Yeah. The last thing is to take a slightly more weathy-ish line.
22:00 Speaker 01 I would say that there, with the institutional investors, in terms of the regulatory overhang of crypto. There was a lingering debate about DeFi versus C-Fi. That there were a lot of people who were thinking about centralized finance, moving over in a regulated way to a digital atmosphere. As opposed to the existing crypto world, which is decentralized finance and which is relatively unregulated. So these are people who almost invite regulation because they want a regulated environment to be able to say to their investors and to say to the regulated entities in their existing businesses,
22:45 Speaker 01 "Look, we're doing these things over here and they're completely above board and we are a legitimate company and these are legitimate actions that we're taking." An example that comes to mind for me is the article that just crossed the wires earlier today that I was sending you about the seizure of cryptocurrency paid by Colonial Pipeline to a Russian hacker ring. This was the first time that the US Justice Department has recovered such a payment. This is now making headline news that there's illegal activity going on that is creating infrastructure problems in the United States. That's how people are thinking about crypto in the mainstream.
23:29 Speaker 01 And when an institutional investor wants to get involved in the market, they want to make it so that people aren't thinking about that. They're thinking about a environment in which there is a umbrella of regulation that makes it legitimate and that allows them to innovate within the financial world. And that's the financial world, by the way, again, which is more centralized, more C-Fi than the existing crypto world, which is more DeFi.
24:02 Speaker 00 Yeah, boy, it's really intriguing. Ed, you and I are thinking about these issues in very similar ways, and we've come to some similar conclusions through some different routes, which I think is intriguing. You know, I'll touch on some of those points in a moment, but to get to your earlier point about innovation, there's a quote that is, I think it's twice apocryphal, it's a doubly apocryphal quote, but it is illustrative of the general point that we're talking about here. And the apocryphal quote is, Steve Jobs allegedly at some point in an interview in the 1980s, and no one's been able to find the sourcing on it that I'm aware of, if you do see the sourcing, please send it to me, I'd be interested to see it, quoted Henry Ford saying, "If people asked me what kind of car they wanted, I would have said, they would have told me to build a faster horse." And that really
24:46 Speaker 00 is the distinction here, this idea of discontinuity, of jump functions, of S-curves, of exponential growth, as Ralas talked about, the idea that individuals want incremental change, but the visionaries who see the future, who understand that people don't want what they don't know because they just haven't experienced it yet, is so much part and parcel, deep in the fiber of this space, and it makes it incredibly, incredibly difficult to pick winners. More on that later. But to your point about C5 versus DeFi, boy, I just think that's spot on. There are still civil wars raging in this space, and it was very clear to me, I didn't mention it at the top of the show because it's a trend that we've
25:30 Speaker 00 seen for a very long time, but there is ample evidence of it, in effect, in Miami, two of which are the points that you've touched on, which is those who have a sort of a very libertarian political bent, who don't want this to be regulated at all, who believe in electricity and mathematics, the principles of physics and math, to solve these problems, and those who say, "Look, this space, we want institutional investors to feel comfortable here. In order for that to happen, we need to have a robust regulatory, legal, and compliance regime that allows the institutional capital to flow in." This is still very much, very much, a hot argument.
26:12 Speaker 00 The space is very unclear to me how that sorts out, how it lands, how these very different camps manage to square those very different positions. So I think that's absolutely something that is completely on the table right now as an active debate and totally unsolved. And the second and a related point is the debate between Bitcoin and everything else. The Bitcoiners feel very strongly about the Bitcoin only position. In their view, in the view of some, I should say, I don't want to mischaracterize it. Anything that's not Bitcoin is a shitcoin. And therefore, something that as they term it, the immune system, the cultural immune system of Bitcoin,
26:53 Speaker 00 needs to go out and attack on Twitter, on Telegram and elsewhere. Again, this is something that is still very much an unresolved series of issues in the space. But it makes it very hard to speak with certainty when you see these groups, each of which has its adherents, having this argument. It is very much, I think, an open issue.
27:13 Speaker 01 You know, I want to attack the, that issue with regard, not the issue that you were talking about, but the CFI DFI issue with this Enigma party that you and I went to. And first and foremost, I want to say, I, we, we had some selfies that we were taking. Apparently, you took a lot more selfies than I did, but I had one selfie, I wanted to give a shout out to Nick from Canada, who I met at the Enigma party. That's the only selfie that I took. But this was a guy who, when I came to this Enigma party, he recognized me. We had, we struck up a conversation. He said he actually is now in Cayman, a Canadian guy. He met Rao. Rao spent like 45 minutes with him,
27:58 Speaker 01 just, you know, didn't even know him, was just very gracious. He just said, you know, Real Vision's been great for me. And, you know, I just, I'm excited at how approachable you guys are. So it was great to talk to him. Nick, shout out to you. But this Enigma party-
28:15 Speaker 00 I know that, I know that you had to run back to get back home, but if you had stayed those extra few days, been there for the weekend- It was extraordinary how many times that happened and we heard precisely the same thing. Really personally, just a pretty incredible experience. And by the way, Nick is very much the man about town at the Bitcoin conference. I ran into him at almost every party I was at. He was out.
28:37 Speaker 01 That is too funny. That is great. You know, so this Enigma party where I met him, I was looking up Enigma and, you know, I spoke to these guys at length. I had a dinner the night before that I went to, or two nights before. Enigma was born in 2017. I'm looking at their website, out of an international brokerage firm, Maker, in response to growing institutional demand for trusted access to digital asset trading. Okay, so that says it all right there. Now, what these guys told me is, look, what we're looking to do, vis a vis, let's say, the likes of Coinbase, is we're looking to take an existing world infrastructure that people are already doing stuff in. And then we're going to put crypto into that.
29:22 Speaker 01 It's all going to be one matrix that you can do things, you know, a soup to nuts place, where you can do your financial activity, including M and A, investment banking, blah, blah, blah, on the blockchain. So this is exactly what I mean in terms of C5 versus D5. No one from that existing space wants to engage with a counterparty that is not regulated. That there's, they're looking for some level of centralization. So I think there's that innate tension. As soon as you bring institutional investors into the space, as soon as you want to legitimize the space, you're going to run off against that tension.
30:05 Speaker 01 And my view is very strongly that this is a space that will eventually be, you know, co-opted into the existing institutional money environment. And therefore, there's going to be a very high level of centralization, C5, happening.
30:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, absolutely. And what we have right now is almost three steps in that process. You have the traditional banking system, the financial services system, what folks in crypto call fiat, but is actually obviously much larger than the than the digital ecosystem that we're talking about. And then you have the the BlockFi's of the world, obviously a sponsor of Real Vision Crypto and Celsius. I ran into Alex Mashinsky, the CEO at Celsius while I was at the conference. And then you have on the far extreme, you also have obviously the truly decentralized tokens, things like that happen on Uniswap and how some of these liquidity providers are working to gain to get do yield farming and some of the other functions. So again, still incredibly early in this space. I know we keep saying that
31:08 Speaker 00 over and over again, but it's such an important point to understand. And I think that whenever you're thinking about this, it bears in mind, understanding just how early it is, which makes it so exciting. But again, how difficult it is to pick the winners. Very, very difficult. Which brings me to something else that I wanted to talk to you about. Ed, have you heard of YAT? The YAT token?
31:32 Speaker 01 No, I have not.
31:33 Speaker 00 So this is, this is something that I was at a party on, I think it was a Saturday night, maybe Friday night, they all blend together at this point. But this was something that was getting a tremendous amount of buzz. Let me just say this at the very beginning. It's a very rare thing that I find myself at a party with Paris Hilton. This isn't something that happens in my day to day life. So it's noteworthy for that reason, but it does speak to this sort of the pop culture aspect of what's happening there. So here's what YAT is in a nutshell. What YAT is doing is they are coining and creating NFTs around emojis. Now, what does that mean? Well, what it basically means is if you want to use an emoji as your
32:14 Speaker 00 signature, stamp it on your business card, YAT will sell you an NFT. So for example, Ed, if you were a millennial, you might want to have avocado toast on your emoji, right? So that you'd have an avocado and a toast. Now, what's really interesting about this is the fewer the emojis there are, the more valuable the NFT is. For example, some of the double tokens, one thing and then another, like the magic ball and the mushroom, magic mushroom, sold for, I think, over $100,000. Some of the double tokens with two emojis were selling for higher than $200,000. I saw a real-time price feed that one of the investors showed me.
32:56 Speaker 00 Hundreds of thousands of dollars, multiple hundreds of thousands of dollars for these emoji tokens. And for the single tokens, you know, the ones that are just a single emoji, like you want to be the palm tree, the prices aren't even disclosed, they're being conducted in private sales. What's the potential utility of something like this? Well, the idea is that eventually YAT is going to strike up deals with the major platform providers to reserve those spaces as unique identifiers for members of the network. So, for example, if you're at a party, you could meet someone and say, "I'm Eagles Nest", and that would be where people could find you on Twitter, on LinkedIn, on Telegram, on
33:40 Speaker 00 email, on a series of other apps, all through the YAT token. Now, here's what I find interesting about this. My first reaction to this was, this is absolute insanity. We're going to look back on this YAT at, you know, five years out from now and think, "Boy, that was a bubble indicator. Ash Bennington at a party with Paris Hilton is clearly a sign that the market is overheated." But how do we know that? All right? How do we know? It sounds a little bit crazy if you're not in the space, but how do we really know that this isn't something that is going to become, you know, a highly desirable method of authenticating and identifying yourself? This actually solves a very real problem that people have, which is there's an incredible
34:23 Speaker 00 amount of fragmentation across all of these social networks. It's very difficult to identify people. I met up with someone who was a very well-known Bitcoin advocate, and he was giving me his Telegram, and he showed me his phone and said, "Look, here's an entire page of fake accounts purporting to be me for scammers who are trying to..." You know, basically get Bitcoin for people. Yat solves a very real problem. It sounds nuts. It especially sounds nuts if you're maybe over forty and you're not in the space. But this isn't something that I would ever bet against, right? I would never take, if you think about, you know, the idea of taking an unlimited, you know, position where you could lose money.
35:06 Speaker 00 If this goes parabolic to the upside, you'd have to be a maniac to bet against Yat. It's very difficult to tell in the early stages which ideas are crazy and which ideas have real resonance. I was talking to someone, a very seasoned investor. Go ahead.
35:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, I was gonna say to you, you know, the question I have actually from everything you said, because I'm definitely in the camp that says, why should I care? And, you know, there are some other people who are probably like, why should I care as well? Who are listening to this, they're like, I don't care about Yat. And, but, you know, as soon as you talked about the authentication of the account for this guy who was being potentially, people are being scammed. And now you know that this individual is, it's the real thing. I thought to myself, so how do we at Real Vision connect the global macro world and the crypto world in a way that's interesting? And that allows people to say, how do I make money out of this? Okay?
36:05 Speaker 01 If I'm a global macro guy and I'm looking for things that are legit and that are going to move the needle forward, how do I understand how this is going to be? Rather than just completely dismiss the space? So I think that it is interesting from an NFT perspective. You know, you know, how do we at Real Vision talk to, say, NFTs in a way that would legitimize the space for people who are skeptical and who are interested in markets and who want to make money? That's the thing that I'm asking, and I hope that we can solve that. And also, anyone who's listening to this in the comments can talk to that.
36:47 Speaker 01 Because, you know, to me, it's the intersection of traditional finance and this world that is going to move the needle in terms of thinking about where things are going.
37:00 Speaker 00 Let me ask you this, Ed. Does it necessitate a shift in mindset from the traditional investing space when you think about how quickly these things are moving forward? Do we get to a point where it looks like it's almost impossible to pick individual winners with something like Yat? And I'll give you an example. Someone who'd been around the investing space for many decades said to me when I expressed some skepticism about this, if someone had come to you, if you were a VC and someone had come to you and said, "I have a platform that's exactly like Facebook, except everything that you type disappears," would you have funded that project? And the answer, of course, was no. And obviously, in retrospect, we know that Snapchat became something that drew in millions
37:44 Speaker 00 of users, had obviously extremely high market capitalization at peak. So how do you begin to think about a mental framework where you can assess where the winners are and where the bubbles are? Is it something that's even possible to do? And if it's not possible to do, how does that influence the paradigms that you apply to your investments? To me, that's a very interesting question.
38:08 Speaker 01 It is, and I don't have the answer to that. But I would say that where I'm coming at it from is probably more Google than it is Snapchat. Because what I'm thinking about, here's a company that's proven. It bested a bunch of other companies. Let's talk about Lycos, or Ask Jeeves, Yahoo, a bunch of other companies. The question therefore is, is at what point do you, as traditional investor, non-internet person, back, let's say, 20 years ago, 15 years ago, do you say that Google's the winner and I need to get in on that? It's not overvalued at this level. The IPO just happened.
38:52 Speaker 01 I think that this company is going to win. I mean, that's how I'm thinking about it. That's where we can give the traditional global macro people an understanding of, you know, the technology is good, and it's so good that network effects are building to a point where you need to have exposure to this company. Same thing with eBay, PayPal. That's kind of how I'm thinking about it. And I don't see, other than money, I don't see yet the killer apps that are available. So...
39:30 Speaker 00 Yeah.
39:30 Speaker 01 We're, to me, we're still at the early phase in terms of understanding that. And so, you know, I'd like to see more in terms of, especially in the NFT space, getting an understanding of what that means for me, who wants to see more proof of the killer app.
39:50 Speaker 00 Yeah. You know, it's really interesting. I was thinking when you mentioned Google. I looked it up. Google was founded in September of 1998 and went public just over, just almost exactly six years later, in August of 2004. Here's what's interesting. Obviously, this six-year time horizon, and by the way, I remember the Google IPO extremely clearly, and there were people who then argued it was a bubble. It was incredibly overvalued, right? But what's interesting is that's a six-year time horizon. With an NFT, with a token, you can literally go from the ideation phase to the implementation phase to it being publicly traded in six months. So as those time horizons compress dramatically, how do you think about,
40:33 Speaker 00 how do you bring a framework to the table that begins to evaluate that stuff? I mean, that is a really difficult question to answer. And maybe it's thinking about things in different categories, in different ways, and trying to figure out what that looks like. We are really in a brave new world here, Ed.
40:51 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so, you know, just zooming the lens out again, I think that we need to continue to think about, you know, where we are in the cycle. What does this mean? You know, first of all, I want to talk about Bitcoin for a second, but just, globally speaking, I think that thinking about this as a 1998, 97 period, and then that there's still, you know, room for movement. But Bitcoin specifically, I think it's interesting that, you know, right as we got on, I was looking at Bitcoin, it had traded down slightly. It's at 35. It's been in this trading range ever since we came down from the 64,000 level,
41:33 Speaker 01 somewhere between 35 and 38,000. All of that is below The 200-day moving average, below the 28-day moving average, and support is really at the lower end now of the 30,000 range, potentially 29,000. So there is a significant air pocket down from here. To me, just in terms of the actual value of the currencies, and thinking about it from, is this a blow-off top already that we're experiencing? I think it is interesting to think about the possibility that even though we're consolidating, we don't know if we're consolidating to move higher or lower.
42:15 Speaker 01 It could legitimately be either one at this point in time.
42:19 Speaker 00 Yeah. I know we've run a little bit long, but I wanted to get in at least one question here. Actually, the one I was going to ask comes to us from Hugh Meyer, and you just answered that, Ed. He was wondering about your views and whether you were concerned about BTC price action. So I'm going to move on to the next one, which I think also is an interesting one that I'd like to get your view on. Comes to us, once again, from Prius Omega. And the question is, decentralization gets rid of a lot of middlemen, but institutional investors seem to demand some middlemen for peace of mind. Does decentralization put too much trust/responsibility on to individuals?
42:59 Speaker 01 Yeah, I don't have a view on that, but in general, the view I have is even with a centralized network, you're going to see middlemen just get absolutely hammered. You know, if you think about the analog world moving on to the digital world, let's use Napster and use Apple as an example. So when it first happened, music moved on. People started going on to torrents and they downloaded stuff. Napster was one of the places that they found centralized, actually, to find stuff, even though it was somewhat decentralized. There was a centralized node for Napster. Later, it became torrent.
43:38 Speaker 01 But the reality is, is that when Apple basically took Napster's model and got buy-in from the existing people, The studios, the price points went way down. Suddenly, you know, the the middleman, the Columbia musics of the world, the Warner musics of the world, were getting absolutely hammered in terms of the the share that they could take. So my answer is, is that on some level, it doesn't matter if it's decentralized or centralized. Digitization is by definition deflationary.
44:18 Speaker 01 And so we should expect a whole wave of new industries, think, you know, so the bees to be to get hammered as a result of this this whole process.
44:32 Speaker 00 Yeah.
44:34 Speaker 00 I'm not sure if some of our users are experiencing this, but it seems as though we may be having some problems with our YouTube channel. If everyone's experiencing those problems, we apologize. You know, my answer to that question is that's exactly the right question, and that's the civil war. And the answer is, it depends on who you ask. People who are truly believe in decentralization would say decentralization isn't or some form of this argument. I don't want to mischaracterize anyone's views, but it often looks something like this, at least when I ask them. Yeah, decentralization isn't perfect. There are going to be some bad actors, there are going to be some mistakes, but on balance, in their view, they believe that it is the best way to proceed forward and that the degree of efficiency,
45:17 Speaker 00 the degree of optimization and the degree of freedom that decentralization provides will compensate for any of the risks and the downsides. Obviously, people who have, you know, maybe are more on the institutional investing side feel very differently. And that's what we're witnessing here, and that's the one of the broad meta themes that we're watching shake out.
45:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I'm glad that we had this. This is probably the most I'll talk about crypto ever. And, you know, I still leave with the concept that I'm wondering, because I'm a global macro guy. I'm wondering, how can we bring these themes, cross them over in a real way so that people think?
46:01 Speaker 01 I actually want to get allocation not to a currency, but rather to an ecosystem that I think adds value. And this is the way that I'm going to get, you know, this is the Google of the new digital age, the crypto age. How do I get access to that? That's the question that I think we need to be able to answer. And I'd like to hear what other people think we need to be able to answer.
46:28 Speaker 00 Yes, please jump in the comments on YouTube on Real Vision's platform. We'd love to hear your views on this. And I would just say, Ed, not only is it the most I've ever heard you talk about crypto, I think this is probably literally our most raw, unfiltered conversation that we've ever had on the platform as we both think these ideas through. Haven't reached any conclusions yet, certainly myself. But it's really interesting to do it. In some ways, Ed, this was like the Saturday night's drinks that you and I didn't get to do because you had to get back home.
46:56 Speaker 01 Yes, yes. The DC cicada town called and unfortunately I had to leave. But hopefully we'll be able to do something like that again.
47:06 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Ed, thanks so much for joining us. I really enjoyed this conversation.
47:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, I loved it too, Ash.
47:12 Speaker 00 Thanks for watching, everyone.
Previous Jens Nordvig: The Death of Fixed Income Next QCP Capital: A Breakdown of Asia's Crypto Markets Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated