Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Raoul Pal: Ask Me Anything About this episode Did you miss Raoul Pal's Live AMA on YouTube? Well, you're in luck, because today we're releasing the whole thing. Sit back and enjoy a community coming together for a deep conversation. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,922 words · 2 speakers
0:11 Speaker 00 Raul, es genial estar de nuevo contigo. Hemos reunido a la banda de nuevo una vez más en YouTube. Raul, bienvenido.
0:18 Speaker 01 Es genial estar aquí, Raul. Será un montón de diversión, en realidad. No hemos hecho esto con una audiencia tan amplia en YouTube durante mucho tiempo. Es muy agradecido.
0:27 Speaker 00 Lo sé, de hecho. Por cierto, Raul, hablando de eso, démosle a nuestra audiencia un poco de contexto. ¿Qué estamos haciendo hoy y por qué es tan importante?
0:35 Speaker 01 Bueno, mira, nuestra visión y misión es democratizar el conocimiento financiero de la mejor manera. Y no se trata solo de los miembros de Real Vision. Se trata del mundo más amplio. Queremos cambiar las vidas de la gente a escala, darles la información que los profesionales en los mercados financieros logran nivelar el campo de juego. Y YouTube es algo muy importante. Tenemos 650.000 suscriptores en YouTube. Queremos llegar a un millón porque queremos construir una audiencia más grande al añadir el mayor valor a YouTube posible, porque es realmente importante para nosotros. No podemos creer en nuestra misión si en YouTube, que es nuestra audiencia más amplia, no entregamos productos increíbles. Y tenemos una serie increíble que está lanzando en YouTube. Tenemos mucho de atrás detrás de la pared de pago
1:20 Speaker 01 que llega a YouTube. Algunos de ellos, ya sabes, se retrasan un poco para que los miembros lo obtengan primero. Pero queremos asegurarnos de que todos los fans de YouTube tengan esta increíble experiencia y se interactúen con nosotros. Así que no es como el hijo de la etapa que se queda a la izquierda. Es como que queremos que seas parte de nuestra comunidad central. Realmente queremos ayudar, realmente queremos escuchar y queremos ayudar a crecer este canal de YouTube en el canal que todos quieren que sea.
1:47 Speaker 00 Sí, es tan importante conocer a la gente donde sea que estén, ¿no es así?
1:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. Which is why we do Twitter Spaces. You know, I've done stuff on LinkedIn before and we need to start doing more on YouTube because it's really important because, you know, things like the Daily Briefing have big audiences and some of our contents had three, four million views on YouTube. So we want to make sure that we're giving people the access to this information. What's amazing about the YouTube audience is how global it is as well. I mean, we've got people all over the place. One of the reasons we set up Real Vision India, which we're just starting and people will hear more about, is because there's a huge number of people who are in India. And Indians are the biggest YouTube users in the world and we want to make sure we get content for them and the right kind of shows.
2:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's also interesting as we add more value behind the paywall that we're able to then put more content on YouTube for free to bring in more of an audience to create greater engagement and greater community.
2:41 Speaker 01 That's right. I mean, you know, we're working on a lot of things in the background that's happening at Real Vision, some huge changes of the kind of value you get behind the paywall as well. But right now, I don't want to focus behind the paywall. I want to focus on what we can give for free to really help people, give them the information they want, the broad perspectives that Real Vision has. You know, we don't have one narrative. My narrative can be entirely different to somebody else's and we embrace that. You know, you see a lot of shit fighting elsewhere between people like, well, you know, he's wrong, he's an idiot. No, nobody's idiots. We're all trying our best to figure it out. And it's really important to hear all the perspectives. So the audience themselves can make up their mind, what makes more sense for them? How do they see the probabilities lie?
3:25 Speaker 01 What is the framework that they want to build for their investing? Or just to understand the economy and the world around them.
3:31 Speaker 00 Well, you know, Ralph, talking of large audiences, we have over a thousand, excuse me, over 1,300 people joining us right now. So let's jump right in, talking of thesis and talk about the thesis. U.S. equities down three days in a row. Nasdaq and SPX closing at the lowest level in a month. Where are we right now? What's the big picture thesis in the wake of that Jackson Hole speech on Friday?
3:54 Speaker 01 So my big picture thesis is...
3:59 Speaker 01 From my forward-looking indicators, I do a lot of work for Global Macro Investor and also in Real Vision Pro Macro, two of my research services, on the global business cycle. And I particularly focus not on the data that's out today, you know, where we are in GDP growth, but where we're going. Where we're going in inflation, where we're going in unemployment. My forward-looking indicators, which are like financial conditions that I've built based on the rate of change of the dollar, the rate of change of interest rates, the rate of change of commodity prices, from whether it's PPI, whether it's... There's so many things. They are pointing to the fastest deceleration of data
4:44 Speaker 01 that I think I've ever seen in the shortest period of time. So what we're facing is a recession, which most people know. But I think the speed at which it happens is much faster than people expect. So we're starting to see some of the regional Fed surveys falling apart. But what I'm really looking at is the ISM survey, the Institute of Supply Management. That's a survey of basically buyers in large corporations and industrial companies about how they see conditions. They tend to do a very good job of tracking the business cycle. GDP follows it. Now, there's this magic number, which is 47.
5:25 Speaker 01 Forty-seven is the level at which it has 100% chance of recession. Now, we're still in the 50s, low 50s. But all of the forward-looking stuff is going down to 47 for the shorter-term stuff, i.e. the next couple of months, we should go 47 and maybe below, maybe 45. But the forward-looking stuff gets down as low as 35. So we're talking negative 2.5, negative 3% GDP prints. And that would be, it should be bottoming by my work by about February, March next year. So the economy is about to go off a cliff.
6:07 Speaker 01 And I don't think the market is yet prepared for it. So let's go back to this Jackson Hole thing. What did they tell you? They didn't tell us anything new. They said, we really want to get to four percent and hold it there depending on the data. Well, the bond market, if I look at, if I look at Eurodollars or Fed funds, they're already at four percent. So the market's priced that. So there's nothing new. So I think, okay, there's nothing new there. So if the economy starts getting weaker because the Fed said they will be more data dependent, then we'll see the bond market starting to price in lower rates in the future. So I'm looking at that.
6:48 Speaker 01 And then the Fed said, well, they will change their mind if inflation comes down a lot and unemployment goes up. So the forward-looking inflation data is already falling fast. My work suggests it could go negative in eighteen months, which is something I've been talking about a while when I've been looking at, for example, the example of nineteen forty-seven, when people all came out of World War Two, went back into the labor force, much like the pandemic. We had no supply because nobody was making everything because everybody was at war. We had this, prices went up twenty percent, eighteen months later, negative three percent. Then it had a rebound effect and then balanced out. I think we've got something similar playing out now, which is contrary to the narrative that we've got sticky inflation. Everyone looks at the nineteen seventies, that's what
7:33 Speaker 01 we're doing again. Unless the Fed crush it, there are the burns and we're going to ruin it. Well, in the nineteen seventies, we had this massive demographic boom that kicked in just at the wrong point, which was the baby boomers entering the workforce. We have the opposite. We have in two thousand and twenty-three, the record peak number of people hitting sixty-five in the US labor force. And that means peak retirees. So we've got peak retirees happening and we've got demand destruction driven by this economic cycle. So the forward-looking inflation data to me looks like if I look at commodities, I look at a bunch of things like new orders versus inventories in ISM, that they go negative.
8:17 Speaker 01 Okay, that's the extreme. That's actually my base case. Maybe I'm wrong. But inflation's coming down significantly and very fast. So the next part is the employment question. And again, when I look at forward-looking employment stuff, just the housing surveys alone, housing is the fifth largest employer in America. It looks like that they will start laying off workers pretty fast because they've got massive inventories. Everybody from Amazon to Walmart said we've got too much inventory. They're all laying off staff. Everybody's starting to lay off staff. All the tech companies are laying off staff. So I think we're going to start to see unemployment and inflation falling, the economy falling sharper than people expect. We're already seeing oil weak. We've seen all the commodities
9:01 Speaker 01 weak. Many of them are now negative year-on-year or close to it. So we've got this storm where bond yields are still high. They're actually, most assets year-on-year map the ISM really well. It's amazing. The business cycle's like this voodoo magic. And many people can see my threads on Twitter. I write about this a lot. I talk about it in Real Vision a lot, is the year-on-year rate of change of the S and P, the NASDAQ, bond yields, copper, oil, emerging markets, credit spreads, that all map the ISM. So right now, where are asset
9:40 Speaker 01 markets pricing? Well, interestingly, bond yields are pricing the ISM at 63. So they're way above where the market-
9:49 Speaker 00 What does that mean, Ralph, for people who don't follow fixed income and ISM?
9:52 Speaker 01 It means that the bond market is pricing inflation plus growth way far higher than the ISM survey itself. Now, okay, but that's not consistent with anything else. The S and P is pricing it at 45, full recession. The NASDAQ, 42, bigger recession. Growth technology stocks, 35, big recession. Copper, 40, 45. The dollar, which year-on-year rate of change also maps, is pricing growth at-
10:31 Speaker 01 Forty or just below forty now. So most asset prices are pricing in a sharp recession. The bond market is not yet doing so. The only other one that's lagging is oil, which is in line with current ISM and not future ISM. Everything else is pricing future ISM, i.e. recession. Oil's not pricing in a recession yet and the bond market's kind of in la la land. Now, I usually say the bond market is the truth, but at turning points, it can often be wrong. And it tends to lag because this inflation narrative digs its heels in. And we've seen that in 2000, 2000, we saw it in 1990, we saw it in 2008, we saw in 2018,
11:16 Speaker 01 the bond market deviates from ISM, ISM starts falling and then this wily coyote moment and yields start collapsing. Now, why do I care about yields collapsing? Well, I've just told you that asset markets are actually pricing in a full recession. And I know there's a narrative out there that the markets need to price in a lower leg from earnings. But when I look at it in my terms, using the business cycle, I think it's already price lower earnings. So if bond yields start to fall, then financial conditions are easing. And the chances are the growthier end of the world, NASDAQ, crypto,
11:58 Speaker 01 growth technology plays will start outperforming. And we've seen many of those bottom a while ago, when bond yields topped. Now, we need to see that play out. Tomorrow, day after tomorrow is the ISM survey. I'm expecting it to be weaker than expected, but it could play out the following month. You know, economic data, one month to the next isn't a lot of data series or wiggle room. So let's see what happens. For the next couple of months, I'm expecting it to be signaling a full recession and we'll get to the tipping point where bond yields start to fall. It'll start affecting asset markets. So I'm not a believer we go to new lows.
12:40 Speaker 01 I've done surveys after surveys and seen all the surveys on Twitter. Seventy percent of all respondents in crypto and macro think equities go to new lows.
12:51 Speaker 01 Now, if that is the case, then most people are positioned for it. So therefore, the path of pain is the opposite. And I think the markets price that in.
13:00 Speaker 01 So I think there's no certainties in this world. I can be wrong, but my view, the balance of probabilities are for me that the risk asset market, equities, crypto have bottomed. We are having a retest. And as the economic data shifts and bond yields come down, that'll drive that further and it'll be a further hated rally because nobody will understand. We're going into recession. Why are equities going up? Well, because they already priced the recession. It's their job to be forward looking indicators. So that's kind of the big picture framework.
13:34 Speaker 00 Well, I've got to say it right now, now that you've laid out the big picture framework, given a little bit of taste of what we're doing here on this channel. Smash that like button, smash that subscribe button for these kinds of daily breakdowns on YouTube and stay up to date on everything that's happening in markets and at Real Vision.
13:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, look, it's really important because like Real Vision Daily Briefings, they're all the content. If you just hit the subscribe button, you will get notifications of the content. You won't miss any of this stuff. And we will do more of this kind of stuff here as well. So just make sure you hit the subscribe button and the like button because it drives the algorithm and helps us out. So we appreciate that too.
14:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, Ralph, talking of which, we've got over 2,000 people on this stream right now. And lots of really great questions are streaming in. I know you have other things that you want to talk about. Ralph, is there anything else you want to cover before we jump in and start hitting the live questions?
14:25 Speaker 01 Yes, a lot of people are going to ask about crypto as well. So what is the macro driver of crypto? Well, inflation doesn't help because it's taking money from your pocketbook and not allowing you to allocate money into crypto because it's a retail driven market. It also creates a lack of liquidity because the Federal Reserve to stop,
14:47 Speaker 01 to stop the inflation have been taking liquidity out of the system. So that means institutions and hedge funds have less liquidity to put into the system and therefore less flows into risk assets like crypto. I found the best approximation to be money supply growth M2 year on year. And year on year M2 is, looks like it's potentially turning up global M2. We're already seeing that China is going to start picking up M2. We're already seeing that Europe is going to start stimulating through the back door, which is they're going to have to offset the electricity prices, the difference in electricity and gas prices. And they're also giving direct transfer payments to people to pay their electricity bills.
15:30 Speaker 01 So I think that monetary policy changes. It also lags ISM. It's kind of a weird thing and it tells me the M2 bottoms right about now, which is what the crypto markets, I think have been telling us, they're trying to find this bottoming process. And if I'm right, the economy slows down, liquidity is going to come up and crypto is going to rally from here. Let's see. But again, I think crypto is put in a low. I think the ETH merge is a very big deal.
16:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:04 Speaker 01 I think it's going to drive inflows. Yes, there'll be volatility. Yes, it won't be a straight line, but I think over time it's going to put some security into the space because it's done and out of the way. Let's see, let's hope there's no risk around this. It'll die some of the FUD narratives that are currently building as we move into this, which is only normal and people should question it. And then we'll see on the other side, when you've got this yielding asset that is a giant in the space, what that unlocks in terms of DeFi, the opportunities for institutions to invest and other opportunities that come from a different asset. Also the ESG credentials.
16:45 Speaker 01 You know, we all know that Bitcoin ESG credentials are not what the ECB or others will tell you. But that's the narrative that's won the institutions now that Bitcoin bad.
16:58 Speaker 01 But proof of stake, good. So I think all at the margin, it helps people allocate.
17:04 Speaker 00 Well, Ralph, you really just described this kind of key inflection point, almost this macro moment. You mentioned M2. I know that we have folks joining us from sort of across the spectrum of their learning journey. M2 is a broad measure of the monetary base that includes cash, check deposits and securities that are easily convertible to cash. Give us a little bit of a context for people who may be curious to understand your framework there. What does that mean and why is it so important in the broader?
17:30 Speaker 01 It's this magic term you hear all the time, liquidity.
17:35 Speaker 01 How much money is available or how much is not available? So when the amount of money is growing, well, there's money everywhere. We can do stuff. Now, it means that it's easier to borrow money from your bank. It's easier to get a mortgage. It's easier to do all sorts of other things. But it also means that businesses have easier access to capital. Banks are not hoarding capital as much. So it means that money flows throughout the financial system. We're a system based on leverage and liquidity. So when money supply is shrinking around the world at the same time, it means that it's going to pull down all assets.
18:17 Speaker 01 And in fact, when we look at it, the bond market has lost $19 trillion in value globally. The equity market's lost $21 trillion in value, let alone real estate, crypto, all of these things. We've lost something like 40% of global GDP in this pullback. I mean, that's a lot of wealth that's been destroyed. And that's without interest rates getting very far. I mean, the US interest rates are 2.5% and bond yields are at 3%. But that's the problem of a leveraged market. So when you take liquidity away from a leveraged market.
19:00 Speaker 01 If you're paying the interest on your loans and you've not got enough money, so imagine you're trying to pay your mortgage, but your salary keeps going up and down. So either the amount of money you've got is suddenly less, which is what's happening with inflation. It's harder to pay your mortgage. So you won't borrow or spend as much money. That's what liquidity does. So it's M2 is liquidity. Liquidity going up is good for assets. Liquidity going down is bad for assets. Liquidity negative where it is now has been particularly bad for assets, which is why we've had a bear market and we're pricing in a recession.
19:37 Speaker 00 So before we jump into questions, two quick points that I wanted to touch on. I read your research today and it's really interesting to me. And these two points especially struck me. You mentioned 4% and the Fed and how you don't think they're ever going to get there. That's number one. And second, of course, in the backdrop of all of this is the dollar. Give us a little bit of sense on those two points, which I know you've been thinking a great deal about, Ralph.
20:00 Speaker 01 So, look, I know the Fed want to get to 4%, but my work suggests that the economic data will fall apart too fast for that to happen.
20:09 Speaker 00 This is federal funds rate for people who aren't following this as closely.
20:11 Speaker 01 That's right. So that's the official interest rate from the Federal Reserve. I don't think they will potentially get there because the economic data will fall apart faster. So maybe they do 50 basis points in September. And then they're kind of like, do we do 25? Do we just wait and watch the data? Because they've said they'll go data dependent. And if the data falls apart, yeah, two months is not a lot of time. So maybe they get two rate rises in, maybe they only get one in. I think it's going to be difficult, if I'm right, if I'm right about the economic data this month, I think it's going to be really hard for them to do 75. I think they'll go 50. They've already said it's 50 50 anyway, whether they'll go 75 or 50.
20:55 Speaker 01 And then we should start to be getting to the grips of the massive slowdown in the economy that I foresee. And therefore they might not get to the 4%.
21:06 Speaker 01 But they will pause and wait. They're not going to cut immediately. That's not going to happen. But they're going to pause and wait. The euro-dollar market and Fed funds market says they start cutting next year and it keeps moving around when they start that. But that's what they're thinking. The other big part of the equation is the dollar. The dollar is the key asset of all assets. It is eighty percent of all world's trade is priced in dollars. So if the dollar goes up and down, it matters. The dollar is driven by global liquidity as well. And there's not, there's massive dollar borrowings around the world. More people borrowing dollars than any other thing. So when liquidity is
21:50 Speaker 01 drawn away, people scramble to pay back their loans and then countries go bust, like Sri Lanka did, and places like Colombia have been running into trouble. So the dollar has been on this screaming bull run. It's now the second biggest bull run since nineteen ninety-six. I'm not sure it's yet peaked. It will do when monetary conditions back off significantly. But we're not there yet. Even, even if rates come down a bit, it's not clear the dollar will do it because Europe is a big drag, China's a big drag. There's some real issues out there in the global economy that means the dollar is still
22:31 Speaker 01 the kind of shiniest currency and the one that people want to own. But the dollar moving up and down drives asset prices a lot because most things are denominated in dollars. So the dollar going up is bad for the rest of the world. So it's good for the US because you import more goods than you export, therefore the prices of goods goes down. For other countries, it's kind of inflationary. But what happens is they export stuff. So Asia is the big exporter. If their currency is weaker, it's also going to bring down the rate of inflation over time. Because they're selling goods. If the dollar goes up twenty percent... Automatically, they're goods are 20% cheaper.
23:14 Speaker 01 So if you're importing them into the US, they become cheaper. Importing into Europe or whichever countries. So it is good for lowering inflation. It's bad for asset prices. It's slightly complicated. And because of the amount of dollar debts, people need to be very careful of the dollar going too strong, too fast, because it blows shit up.
23:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'm not sure if we can show a chart of DXY on screen. I just tweeted the one-year chart of DXY. And as you say, it's just screaming up. By the way, I'm looking right now at a max chart of DXY. The only time when it's higher, looking on this max chart going back some 50 years, is two. One, it's the collapse of the dot-com era. And two, and some of our younger viewers are going to have to look at this on Wikipedia. It's the Plaza Accord days. I mean, this is historic stuff.
24:01 Speaker 01 It is historic stuff. And I tweeted out, people can look at my Twitter, I think on Sunday, showing the parabolic trend. Currency should not go parabolic, especially the largest currency in the world. It's a bad thing. And, you know, I'm guessing that this is going to become a talking point for G7 nations. It's like enough is enough. It's a big problem. You know, considering, for example, Europe imports oil. Japan imports oil. India imports oil. China imports oil. Oil is priced in dollars. And so they earn local currency and need to pay dollars. It's harder and harder to pay for. So it's bad.
24:45 Speaker 00 Yeah. Ralph, what do you say? Should we jump in and start doing some questions?
24:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, let's do it. This isn't Ask Me Anything, after all.
24:51 Speaker 00 Tons of questions.
24:52 Speaker 01 Just to listen to Ralph bleat on about his own view.
24:55 Speaker 00 Well, we got lots of questions streaming in live from YouTube. I think about 2,500 people watching us right now. First one comes from Alex Humphries, who asks, so what does Ralph think about where stocks are headed?
25:11 Speaker 01 It pains me to say it because it doesn't feel like it and everybody calls me an idiot. I think they're going higher. Now, I don't really have that bet on, so it's my hunch, not my bet.
25:25 Speaker 00 Hmm. I'm sorry, this is the question from Alex Humphries, which is an even better one. What does Rao get up to on his days off?
25:33 Speaker 01 Um, read a book by the pool if I'm in Grand Cayman or go to the beach or go out for a long lunch with friends.
25:43 Speaker 00 Wait, Rao, we we get days off? That's a thing?
25:48 Speaker 01 Well, Sunday, maybe, if we're lucky.
25:53 Speaker 00 From Sebastian Albeck, your view on the China-Taiwan situation. Will it be a black swan event?
26:01 Speaker 01 It can't be a black swan by the very understanding that we all know about it. Black swans are risks that we don't understand. So for us, at best, it's like, when does it happen? Sorry, at worst is at worst is when does it happen? At best is maybe it doesn't happen. So we all understand the risk, but it's geopolitics. We have no idea how this plays out. I understand that the Russian situation put it to the forefront of people's minds, and it's definitely a possibility. But I don't think China wants to cut itself off from the world, and I don't think the US wants to cut itself off from China yet. So I don't think it's in anybody's interest.
26:44 Speaker 01 It's kind of this stalemate situation where it kind of rises up. It's like North Korea, South Korea. It's not a solution where anybody actually wants to pull the trigger, but they want a position until maybe they can find an opportunity, one way or the other, to resolve it. How? What that means? I don't know. Could the Chinese invade Taiwan? For sure. Does it happen in the next six months or 15 years? I have no idea.
27:16 Speaker 00 Here's a great question from Paul. This is a great Real Vision question. Everyone likes to compare the current recession to past recessions, but no past recessions are exactly the same. What do you think will be the fundamentally different aspects of this recession? You touched on this a little bit earlier.
27:32 Speaker 01 So I think the feature of this recession is there is no bogeyman in the closet. You know, we had a global macro investor roundtable, my research service, in the Cayman Islands in May, and we had a bunch of very smart, you know, well-known investors all together. And we debated this for a while. What is the shoe that drops? And the answer came out, the economy. It feels like this is more likely to be an economic event, but everybody's looking at it as a credit event. And there's nothing going on really in credit markets to give us that fear. Yes, they're not great, of course, because the economy's slowing down and there's liquidity tightening. I don't see that one moment.
28:13 Speaker 01 Now, the one thing that's different about this one to the last one since maybe 1990 is there is a supply issue. So we've got high prices. Now, we had a demand issue in 2007 in commodity markets because China had come in and massively bid up the price of all commodities. And that helped slow the world down because the commodity prices were too high and inflation was high. 1990 saw similar. And then really, it's somewhere between, I think the closest is 1947, 1948. There are elements of 1974. There are elements of 1990. And there are some elements of the 80s.
28:56 Speaker 01 Now, everyone uses the 80s as the big example, right, that the Volcker years, right?
29:02 Speaker 01 The reality was, the S and P fell 27%.
29:07 Speaker 01 We've already done, we've pretty much done that then. In 1990, it fell 20%. 1990 was a pretty common garden recession. We had the savings and loan crisis. We don't seem to have a credit event on the horizon. Now, I know other people have thought maybe it's to do with commodity hedging. Well, most of the commodity price had gone down, so that that fear has been alleviated. I don't see it. I think it was just the unwinding of the excess liquidity from the pandemic, and we returned back to where we were back in about 2018.
29:40 Speaker 00 Well, here are the year-to-date numbers. SPX minus 16.4%, NDX, that's Nasdaq 100, minus 24.3%, Nasdaq Composite off, 24, almost flat.
29:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, and they've been down lower, right? So they're up from the lows anyway. So they've all, as I said, they've priced in a very significant move, much like 1980, 81 did, much like 1990 did. People look back immediately and go, well, look, look what happened in 2008. Your 2008 was a very unique event. That was a massive credit event. 2000, well, the economy didn't go down a lot, but there was massive, massive speculation in equities. We haven't seen the same. We've had excess liquidity, some excess speculation, but not of the scale of then. Most people who comment on that didn't live through it. I lived through it. I was running a hedge fund at the time. I was all over it. It's
30:37 Speaker 01 very, very, very different environment. We saw elements of it last year. You know, at the very peak of the markets, we saw elements of that, but it's still extremely different.
30:49 Speaker 00 A huge number of questions flowing in right now, live on YouTube, as people are hitting smash and subscribe, they're asking questions.
30:56 Speaker 01 I hope they are. Before I'm going to answer a question, subscribe to the channel because you get more of this kind of stuff. We're going to start using this more, and there's some amazing updates. So just please hit the subscribe button and also hit the like button. That'll be really helpful.
31:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, it also feels really cool and it's fun to be doing this live when there are people actually interacting with us. And we're seeing right now the the stream just scroll by in terms of live comments and people are putting comments in on Twitter, on Instagram, via email and a whole bunch of other places. But it's really cool and it's fun.
31:25 Speaker 01 I think you should read out the biggest insults as well because there'll be a few on there.
31:28 Speaker 00 I'll keep an eye out for them. So here's a great question from Muhammed Kasawat. And the question is something you touched on earlier, Raoul. Muhammad wants to know what's happening with the bond market?
31:43 Speaker 01 The bond market is confusing me right now, to be honest. I'm expecting yields to come lower. We've seen the economic data come lower. We've seen the oil price come lower. We've seen inflation numbers come lower. We've seen the equity market come lower and it's been stubborn.
31:59 Speaker 01 And I think it's based on narrative. Also, I have a suspicion it's something to do with the student loans and some hedges around that. I don't know. That's speculation.
32:09 Speaker 00 How does that work, Raoul, for people who?
32:11 Speaker 01 I don't really know, Ash. I've been trying to figure it out. What is driving this flow? Because it's really inconsistent with everything else.
32:18 Speaker 00 Right.
32:18 Speaker 01 And I'm thinking, if you wipe off a debt, there's the other side of that. And there's usually a hedge. Usually these things are spread. So if you're selling, if you're lending people money against it, you'll buy a bond as a hedge. So you have the difference in interest rates between the two, as opposed to worrying about the bond market going up and down. If you just wipe off one side, you've got an open leg, which would have been the long bond leg, which would have been sold. I don't know if that's the case, but that's what it feels like. Maybe it's happening by the Treasury General Account. I don't really understand, but it feels like there's an opposing flow that's going on because it's just not consistent with anything else, which is why I'm really focused
33:01 Speaker 01 on the bond market because it seems the best risk reward in all of macro land right now. You know, I have not been as certain of my economic forecast since before the pandemic. And this is the most certain I've been. Yeah, those two times, the most certain I've been in my entire career. But the bond market is not confirming it. And, you know, I want to see the markets confirm. It's great to have an economic view, but if the markets don't do it, you can't invest in it. So, you know, I'm waiting for the turn. I'm expecting weak economic data for the market to give up the ghost. Positioning is pretty much second all time record short, bonds as well. The equity market pretty much is record shorts.
33:43 Speaker 01 So we've got all this setup where everybody, I think, is set up the wrong way. And those trades get unwound if the economy doesn't follow through.
33:54 Speaker 01 Mark Ritchie, the second was talking about this yesterday on the daily briefing. It's like when the market isn't doing what you expect, like 70% of people think the equity market should be going to new lows. And it doesn't, there's usually informational value in that. Now, could there be informational value in the bond market not?
34:15 Speaker 01 Possibly, but then it would be confirmed by other assets and it's not been confirmed by anything. So the relationship is weird.
34:23 Speaker 00 Yeah. Here's a great question that comes to us from Vishnu Vardhan. What breaks first in a bubble market? Great question.
34:31 Speaker 01 Well, what broke first was the long duration stuff. So, you know, particularly with inflation and taking liquidity away. Well, the first things that go are the things with that are priced for future growth. Cause you basically lower future growth by.
34:49 Speaker 00 Well, explain that for people who have not had the benefit of being locked in a bank and doing DCF analysis. What does that mean?
34:55 Speaker 01 Well, it means that as you raise the discount rate. Your future expected cash flows are worth less. Now, the issue is if you have no cash flows, it's worth a lot less. So we find that these long duration things, crypto and growth equities. They got smashed the most. They were the ones that benefited the most. Now, that's not to say, again, we'll go through this in due course. Crypto is not correlated in the longer term to any of these things. It's correlated in the liquidity cycle to liquidity. But if you look at the chart of NASDAQ and crypto over the last 10 years, I mean, they look nothing like each other.
35:38 Speaker 01 So those are the things that get destroyed first. They've already been destroyed. As I said, the long end of growth has priced in about 32 in the ISM, which is would be the lowest ISM print. Since 1974, which when it got down to 30. So it's been very much priced in the inflation shock, the growth shock. So that's really what's going on there. And then you have to wait around to say, okay, what other shocks are there? Then you start watching credit spreads. If somebody borrowed too much money and they can't pay it back. We haven't really seen a lot of that. Yes, we've seen credit spreads. We've seen Europe having a bit of a struggle, Italy.
36:19 Speaker 01 But the ECB came in as ever and said, we will not allow this to happen. And I kind of believe them. Because when you've got an unlimited balance sheet, you can stop anything happening by buying all the bonds, much like the Japanese do. So where is the big risk? I don't know. I think it's households. It's, you know, everyone's spent all their savings. Everyone's run up credit card debt. And people are going to start losing jobs and they've lost real earnings. Because their earnings have gone up, but inflation's gone up more. So the purchasing power of everybody's wages have taken a haircut. We've had terrible negative wages and that's, that's been a bad, bad shock for people.
37:03 Speaker 00 Yeah. So one of the things that we're really passionate about here at Real Vision is education. You've talked about ISM, Institute for Supply Management. Numbers here a couple of times. Give viewers a sense of, you talk about this almost sort of spooky uncanny ability it has. To presage some of these terms of the economy. Talk a little bit about what ISM is, Raul, and why it's so important.
37:24 Speaker 01 So it is my guide to the business cycle is what I build my six month to two year, eighteen month framework around. Basically, a general economist will tell you.
37:38 Speaker 01 Will never predict a recession. Why? Because they use linear modeling. They put inputs in, make a few assumptions, linear model. You show a small child a chart of GDP and they go, well, it goes up and down, obviously. Right? Not one fucking economist does this. It's insanity.
37:58 Speaker 01 So back in the late nineties, I started realizing that the business cycle was the predominant driver of asset prices. And just by transposing it to year on year S and P versus the ISN.
38:12 Speaker 01 It unveils the whole world. So you know how to make asset allocations once you've learnt this simple trick. Again, go to my Twitter feed, have a look at it, it's plenty there. So the ISM survey is, as I said earlier, for people who've just joined us, it is the Institute of Supply Management Survey and we're asking the buyers at all of these giant corporations, industrial companies, what they think of economic conditions, employment, orders, new orders, prices, everything. And it becomes this composite index and guess what? It goes up and down, just like GDP, but it's like a monthly version of GDP. Right. Tends to lead a bit too, because GDP takes a while for accounting. Right.
38:56 Speaker 01 So now we've got this monthly variation of this. If you want, you could use the ECRY. And you can get that off the ECRY's website, the Economic Cycles Research Institute website. The weekly indicator is a weekly version, very good, works very much like ISM. Those things, what you're looking for is turning points at the peak. Then you know that the rate of change of growth is slowing down. However, many people, and I've made this mistake in the past, at peak turning points, you start thinking, well, things are going to slow down. Actually, the rate of change of asset prices still goes on for a long time. When it crosses 50, generally the rate of change of asset prices starts going negative. Or if the market starts forecasting that in advance,
39:41 Speaker 01 which is why the S and P is already pricing ISM at 45. 47 is the level that has 100% guaranteed chance of recession since 19... I think it's 1952, whenever the ISM started. It's a long time ago. So it has a perfect track record. And so that's why I use it because once you start going, you start seeing your forward-looking indicators of ISM, which are usually the subcomponents of ISM, plus other stuff, like freight rates and shipping and car sales and whatever it is.
40:21 Speaker 01 What happens is you can start to predict when markets will act in a certain way with more confidence. Nothing is perfect. Things fail, things change, there's other parts of the equation you miss. But it gives you a really much higher probabilistic odds, which is why I'm really comfortable investing in the six month to 18 month time horizon versus the one week, the three months, because I find the economy the best driver. Now, it's also a great arbitrage because almost all the capital in financial markets and all of the models and systems and algos and hedge funds are all working on the intraday to one to three month time horizons, because that's when they have to report to their investors.
41:04 Speaker 01 Now, if you extend your time horizon by using the business cycle, which is how old school macro used to be, you can generate significant returns over time. But because you're dealing with longer term time horizons, you have to deal with a bit more volatility too. So you need to think about how you size things accordingly. And you get points in the cycle like we're coming now, where we probably get to an acceleration point in the bond yields if they start falling. I might really add to that position if I start to see the price go in the favor of what the economy, what the forward looking indicators and what the RSM is saying. So to me, it's the single most important indicator for the average person to understand
41:49 Speaker 01 is the economy growing. Now, even if you want to simplify it, you kind of know that when it peaks, probably around two years later, you're going to have a recession. And when you get to the bottom, you probably know that in another two years' time, three years' time, the time horizons aren't perfect, you're going to have a boom. And that, you know, that just simple tool stops you feeling like you're not in control of what's going on, that you don't really understand. So I urge everybody to use the RSM survey or go to the Equi website, look at their weekly leading indicator, it's very useful too.
42:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, extremely well-framed, Raul. Two points to add some color there. First, Real Vision subscribers will know Lakshman Akutan, who runs the Ekri, one of our good friends, who's been on the platform many times, conversations with you and with me. The second point about ISM, what's so interesting about it to me, is in many ways, it's the difference between top-down and bottom-up, right? You know, you have economists who, I don't know, massage their temples and try and come up with this number through a series of different formulas. What's interesting about ISM is that the supply managers are basically talking about their own business. It's very difficult to predict the economy, but if you're running a business and you're a competent manager, you have a pretty good sense of whether business is going to be up or down the following month, and by how much.
43:10 Speaker 01 Well, I've talked a lot about this. The power of the hive mind is more than most people realize. So you've got a bunch of smart people in a position of knowledge. When you amalgamate their views, you've got something very powerful. And, you know, that's the value of the Real Vision community. You know, we've got everybody is super smart. So the amalgamation of those views, super interesting. And that's what this is. You're taking a bunch of experts, putting them all together. There's a great book on this called Super Forecasting.
43:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
43:39 Speaker 01 And, you know, they start adjusting themselves once they start realizing their forecasting errors as well. So they tend to get better over time.
43:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, we should get Philip Tetlock on the platform. That would be an amazing conversation.
43:51 Speaker 01 Yeah.
43:53 Speaker 00 By the way, talking about community, Raul, we're up to about almost 3,000 viewers on this stream right now, and almost 1,000 likes right now in this conversation. So go ahead and smash.
44:01 Speaker 01 Firstly, we need 3,000 bloody likes. There's no excuse. And I want to see 3,000 new YouTube subscribers, because you're going to get more of this content. So I want to see those numbers go up, please.
44:13 Speaker 00 Raul, many of them are probably already dedicated YouTube subscribers. Like, how many? It's like, vote early and vote often.
44:19 Speaker 01 Exactly. Even if it just helps the algorithm rise to the surface, you're helping Real Vision.
44:24 Speaker 00 Raul, here are two questions. One from Yaren and Pehoe Kelon. I'm going to aggregate these together. Both are interested in understanding what's happening right now in the housing market, obviously something that's been greatly discussed the last few months. What's your take there?
44:39 Speaker 01 I've been talking about this for a long time. Housing inventories got too high because people extrapolated peak demand from 2020 and 2021. And what's happened is because of interest rates rising, mortgage rates have gone up the most in a kind of year-on-year rate of change in history. And inflation is etting to people's real earnings. People stopped buying houses. Meanwhile, we've just made massive inventories of houses. The only way for that to clear is prices to come down. So prices are likely to come down. Look, it's not 2008. This is not an over-leveraged massive bust. But house prices can be soggy for a while. But don't forget, they just went up like 25%. So if they pull back a
45:21 Speaker 01 bit, maybe house prices come down 10 to 15% net-net. You know, it's still up from where it was. But, you know, if you're looking at buying a house, you'll probably get it cheaper. But if you're looking at buying a house, you probably can't afford it right now because your mortgage has gone up and you're not earning as much money. So, you know, and also worry about unemployment. That will, that will not help the housing market. So the housing market is going to cool off.
45:46 Speaker 00 Yeah. Here's a very serious and witty macro question from the White Knight. Love your chair, Ralph. Is that Al Capones?
45:55 Speaker 01 This is a reformed 1950s barber's chair that I found on Etsy and brought in from California. For no reason that I just thought it was quirky and cool. And I sit in there and listen to podcasts with a glass of wine in my own peace and quiet. So I love it.
46:12 Speaker 00 Here's a fun question from Practical. And it's a Practical question. What legalities does one have to go through in order to start a hedge fund?
46:23 Speaker 01 Firstly, you need to raise money. That's the hardest part.
46:26 Speaker 00 Right.
46:27 Speaker 01 Then you need to go and see a bunch of lawyers who will charge you a fortune for basically boiler template stuff.
46:35 Speaker 01 Which is a legal agreement, you need to incorporate a company, a bunch of legal agreements, a bunch of registrations. It's a painful bloody process. I think it's going to be disrupted by tokenization. We're already seeing the rise of platforms like Enzyme where people can launch kind of asset management on-chain. It's not available for most investors yet, but nor are hedge funds. You know, you have to be a credited investor. So I think if you're looking at it and you haven't raised a lot of money, go look at on-chain variations. I think that's interesting.
47:03 Speaker 00 You know, let's jump around here a little, Ralph. We've got people coming to us on all different platforms. I wanted to take one from Instagram. This one comes from George Lagadotris Jr. And the question is, why buy now if recession is certain?
47:19 Speaker 01 Because the market's job is to forward look. If I can see the turn in the data already in liquidity conditions in February or March of next year, the market can too, even though most participants can't, which is why the market always confuses people. The market generally bottoms before a recession. It's normally three to six months. Sometimes it's been a year beforehand. Other times it's been in line with the economy. So my guess is the market has seen the low and it lies ahead. I short sharp recession and therefore the market is already looking through,
47:59 Speaker 01 which is why the euro-dollar market is trying to price the turn of when the Fed have to start easing.
48:07 Speaker 00 Now, one more question from our friends at Instagram. This comes to us from Janai Ilamaki. How do you manage stop losses and how do you know when to exit a winning trade? Great question.
48:19 Speaker 01 And this is a really complicated question. So how I, I'm not a big fan of stops because I'm not a short-term trader, so I need wiggle room for my, so I tend to use more idea stops. When am I, when is it feeling wrong? When is the larger trend change? So not short-term. But the best advice I've got is
48:42 Speaker 01 If you run like five or 10 positions and you give yourself a stop for all of them, let's say you're a shorter term trader than I, if you give yourself a stop, work out what percentage of your NAV are you going to lose for that stop? Then add up all of your stops together. So maybe that one's 1%, that one's half percent, that one's 5%, whatever. Then you've got the overall risk you're taking in a worst case scenario. Now correlations may help you, other things may help you. But what you're doing is saying, how much can I lose? That is the single most powerful thing you can understand is how much risk you're running. And what you tend to find is the closer your stop loss,
49:27 Speaker 01 the less risk you run unless you use leverage. So you can use leverage, but you have to run a tighter stop loss because leverage has increased the size of your position, you'll lose more of your original capital because leverage is the extra capital on top. So stop losses are different for different people. I'm not a big stop loss. I'm more of like this trade is not working. I allow myself a lot of wiggle room because I'm longer term. Only what I'm really applying to a trade where I'm going all in will I then start thinking about, okay, I need to be more careful here because I've got a lot of risk. And so therefore I think of stop losses for part of the position, all the position, take profits, all of that kind of stuff. The hardest part is not stopping out of a trade, it's actually taking profits.
50:12 Speaker 01 It's bloody hard, particularly in long-term trades. It's just, to mindset, there's a ton of this in the Real Vision Academy. I can't give it justice here. A lot of people have different perspectives, but the Real Vision Academy covers this in great detail.
50:27 Speaker 00 Raul, what is Real Vision Academy for people who may be joining us for the first time on YouTube?
50:31 Speaker 01 So Real Vision Academy is our education platform. It's part of the Real Vision Plus tier. So Real Vision Plus, you get all of the content of Real Vision and this gives you all of the education and it's basically taught by the most famous people in financial markets. It's like being taught acting by Robert De Niro. You know, it's crazy who's there teaching you everything from how to build a macro framework, how to look at the business cycle, how do economic indicators work, what's the psychology of investing, what are the pitfalls I'm going to make, how do I run risk, what are stop losses, how do I use technical analysis? And not only that, then we dig into, well, here's three of the most famous technical analysts in the world like Peter Brant and Tom DiMark. They're going to teach you how they do it. It's unbelievable and it's fun, it's engaging,
51:13 Speaker 01 it's not a written course, it's videos and it is just groundbreaking and mind blowing. And considering courses like this usually cost three and a half thousand dollars plus and nobody's got a course like this of this quality with these kind of people. And it's all part of the, it's free as part of the plus tier, which is $550 for all the other content, you know, events and all the other stuff you get there. So it's a hell of a deal. And again, we want to help as many people as possible. If you can't afford $550 on an education, you shouldn't be in the financial markets.
51:47 Speaker 00 Ralph, you said smash the like button. We've just jumped up to 1300.
51:51 Speaker 01 There we go. Good people. Thank you.
51:54 Speaker 00 By the way, I think one of the coconut girls has just sneaked into the shot. I think she's trying to upstage you, Ralph.
51:59 Speaker 01 She's just coming from her walk.
52:02 Speaker 00 All right, let's jump around here a little bit because we've got questions coming in from just about every possible platform right now. This one comes to us from Twitter, from JJ Be Present. Does Ralph think TLT is a good investment? And if so, what's the whole period? We should say iShares 20-plus year Treasury bond ETF.
52:22 Speaker 01 I like bonds. That's a decent way of playing it. You know, manage your own risk. You run your own trade. I run mine, but...
52:33 Speaker 01 I think the time horizon I'm looking for for interest rates to fall, it usually goes through recession and through the other side. And so I would imagine that it's a decent trade for nine months. But we need confirmation that this bloody bond yields are turning or the TLTs turning and we're just not getting it yet. So it's frustrating as hell for me right now, but let's see. But I like it. Overall, I like it.
53:00 Speaker 00 I also wanted to hit some questions coming in from email. First one comes to us from Mutscher Hussain, and the question is, how important is the upcoming election for US markets? How much is already priced in? Great question, Mutscher.
53:14 Speaker 01 I don't know. A lot of people look at this stuff. I don't really look at it. You know, are we going to get this paralysis of policy? If we do, it kind of means the Federal Reserve have to do everything because there's no fiscal, which is why they're trying to jam through some fiscal now to try and see if they can win more votes coming on the other side. I don't really know. Generally, split House midterms are very good for markets because the market, you know, the policymakers don't get in the way because they can't. So in which case, the only people to drive the bus are the central banks. So generally speaking, it's pretty positive if the Democrats lose, you know, part of this, whether it's the Congress or the House.
54:01 Speaker 00 Here's one that comes to us from Alejandro Rodriguez. Ralph, you said Spain has Europe's best food. What's your next vacation destination? And he says, he adds, you better try South American food.
54:13 Speaker 01 So I'm planning some holidays right now. I already got a holiday booked to a kind of wellness retreat spa in Mexico. So that's Latin America. I am.
54:26 Speaker 01 Trying to get to Argentina for Christmas and New Year. Still negotiating around mom who wants to come here for Christmas, for New Year Christmas. Trying to see, well, would you fly down to Argentina instead? I don't know, there's family negotiations going on, but I want to get to Argentina. I'm going to go to Buenos Aires and Mendoza. So that's what I'm, that's what I'm trying to do.
54:49 Speaker 00 Here's one from Life of a Forty Something. Ralph, what are you drinking?
54:54 Speaker 01 Right now I'm drinking a La Croix Tangerine flavor. It's, it's still 525, so it's not glass of wine time yet, but I will have a glass of wine after this. And I think I've got an open bottle of Palini Montrachet, which is a lovely, one of my favorite white wines in the world come from Burgundy. These are white Burgundies made from Chardonnay grapes, but not like the heavy oaky Chardonnays that we get all else in the world. In Burgundy, they're uniquely special. They've got this minerality, this cleanness, this crispiness, but this richness and butteriness. And Palini Montrachet is kind of up there with the very best of those. And now there's different producers, more expensive ones.
55:38 Speaker 01 This one's not particularly, you know, fancy one, but that's, that's what I'm looking forward to. And I'll probably have it with some toasted almonds, salted toasted almonds that I will roast in the oven.
55:51 Speaker 00 That sounds perfect. Ralph, I know you've got a heart out at 6:30, but I wanted to just give our viewers a summary. Key takeaways from this conversation. We've covered a lot of ground here today.
56:02 Speaker 01 My key takeaway is I think the economy falls very fast. I think that the asset markets have pretty done pretty much a good job of pricing this in. I do not necessarily see another leg lower in equities, another leg lower in crypto. I think we're in that process where we're doing the retest, the head fake. I could be wrong. So I'm giving myself a 60% probability. I'm not like, there's a hundred percent probability, 60% probability or so. In crypto, I don't really care if it goes lower because I'll just buy more into this because as the liquidity cycle turns, we know how it works.
56:44 Speaker 01 I think the bond market is mispriced and yields will come down much faster than people expect. I think inflation will come down, unemployment will go up. I think the dollar continues higher for a bit and then starts weakening and will have a corrective cycle that may last a year, two years, three years maybe before we still keep going because we've got too much dollar debt. So every time the global economy slows down, you're playing musical chairs and the dollar screams higher because everyone's trying to pull the chairs away because they need the dollars. So I don't think that that whole game is done. So that's kind of how I'm looking at this right now. I'm focused really on two key areas. Crypto, which I've been allocated to allocating to because I really think we're at the turn.
57:29 Speaker 01 And I think Ethereum merge is a bigger deal than people expect. I think a lot of people have just been washed out again. Now, Tom DeMark tells me, you know, he thinks that Bitcoin makes a new low at seventeen, seventeen thousand. Hmm. Maybe that's right, too. So, and I don't think ETH will confirm. I don't know. You know, and I'm saying to me, it doesn't really matter, but just people paired, you know, I'm not saying with all the certainty. It's why I think the balance probabilities is, I think the same with equities as well. But for that really to be the case, and you see bond yields come lower and the economic data come lower. So it's kind of really in the
58:08 Speaker 01 point where we should start to see things change and narratives change fast. That's what I'm really focused on. This next two months of economic data, if it's not a lot worse than expected, then every single, I mean, I produced in that GMI, you saw it's like fifty, no sixty charts, all showing the same thing. I've never seen anything like this before. For them all to be wrong would be simply staggering. So we'll see.
58:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, Bitcoin trading right now is shade below twenty thousand, nineteen thousand, eight forty eights. Interesting call from Tom DeMark on that from a technical perspective. Ralph, I know we said with the last question, but we've got one final question because it's a good one. And also because it comes from Frank Fowler's dad, who is our crack podcast producer here. So we got to get this one in. And Frank's dad wants to know how serious are the economic issues in China, one of our key themes here on Real Vision?
59:00 Speaker 01 They are very serious. And this is a slow, slow story. When you've got a managed economy. Crisis rolls slowly. Don't forget, China, Japan's still unwinding its demographic bust and its bubble from nineteen ninety, because it's quite managed in how it does things. So the Chinese economy is an issue. You know, there's been excess leverage, excess capacity built at every level, and they're going to have to manage this. And what they want is a managed decline. They know it's a problem. Chinese economists, central bank, politicians are a very smart bunch. They understand their economy very well. They understand the issue
59:42 Speaker 01 that they've got. But at margin, firstly, it's going to create stimulus because they're going to have to stimulate. So that's going to be positive at the margin for risk assets. But also, it's going to keep the Chinese economy from not demanding as much stuff. You know, China's never going to go back and build the same amount of bridges and apartment buildings again, unless it knocks them all down and starts again. Those days have gone. Yes, there are big demand, but there's not, it's the rate of change that matters, and the Chinese rate of change of demand is not going to go up. India, that might be different, but that's kind of not there yet in terms of a massive new construction wave. There's building tons of roads and other stuff. So, but India is something to keep an eye on.
1:00:26 Speaker 01 It's the most positive I am on any global economy over the next ten years. It's got a demographic age of twenty-eight. It's, it's completely digitized, large parts of its economy. It's got some world-leading companies like Reliance, which are creating network effects upon network effects. And we are seeing a massive boom in entrepreneurism, VC capital, capital allocation, all happening in India. So it's one of the most exciting setups I've ever seen. Feels like some combination of the US in the late, mid-eighties. Yeah, it feels like the US in the mid-eighties and also a little, yeah, around that kind
1:01:11 Speaker 01 of thing where you start to get the, you know, Indians don't have debt.
1:01:16 Speaker 01 They have high savings, they have a 20% savings rate and no debt. So you've got none of the impediments. The West, old populations, high debt, no savings. India, 28 years old, no debt, high savings, about to go into peak earnings. That journey from 28, and everybody who's older than that knows, but by 30, you start to earn a bit of money, you start to get pretty serious in your career by 35. By 40, you're into the, where you're starting to earn some serious money if you've got a good career, that the whole Indian population is going to go through.
1:01:58 Speaker 01 So the amount of investment boom, the capital markets, Indians are investing in the stock market, all of this is coming. People setting up businesses, the opportunity set. So I'm super bullish India.
1:02:10 Speaker 00 Ralph, incredible conversation again, as always. Really nothing left to say except smash that like button, smash that subscribe button.
1:02:18 Speaker 01 That's right.
1:02:19 Speaker 00 Let's keep doing this, Ralph.
1:02:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, let's do it. It's fun. It's kind of different to Twitter Spaces because we can all see each other, which is nice.
1:02:27 Speaker 00 Yeah, we're just going to be doing lots more of this in the future. Ralph, this was a pleasure. Hope we can do it again soon.
1:02:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, loved it. Thanks everybody for watching. I hope I added a bit of value and didn't confuse you too much.
1:02:38 Speaker 00 Thank you again, everyone, so much for watching. This was a lot of fun to do. Thanks again.
Previous Bulls vs. Bears: Who Wins This Epic Showdown? Next How To Make Use of Volatility Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated