Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Does the Fed's Framework Still Work? w/ Dennis Lockhart About this episode Stocks ended the week down on renewed concerns about the economy. Has the Fed reached its breaking point? Dennis Lockhart, former president and CEO of the Federal Reserve of Atlanta joins Maggie Lake to discuss the current state of the economy, inflation, the looming debt ceiling, and whether the Fed’s current framework is still effective. In the second half, we dive into the developing credit crisis and how it changes the Fed’s positioning. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:02 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. If you like this podcast, go behind the paywall to get privileged access to the smartest minds in finance. Visit realvision.com/rvpod and use the promo code PODCAST10 at PODCAST10 to get 10% off our essential membership for the first year. Join the Real Vision community and learn how to become a better investor. And now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:33 Speaker 01 Does the Fed's framework still work? Hi, everyone. Welcome to this extended Real Vision daily briefing. With me today is Dennis Lockhart, former president of the Reserve Bank of Atlanta. Hi, Dennis. Welcome.
0:45 Speaker 02 Hi, Maggie. How are you?
0:47 Speaker 01 I'm doing well. We're excited to have you because I feel like Fed policy is front and center. It's what the markets are focused on. And especially this week, we've really it's been dominated by inflation readings, including today's University of Michigan sentiment index, which showed that some of those inflation expectations are climbing when you look out over five years. So I'm just sort of curious, what is your sense of the dynamics around prices right now?
1:13 Speaker 02 Well, we've had inflation for now two years. That is a surge in inflation for two years. And it's not a surprise to me that the public is beginning to expect inflation. And so inflation expectations, as you pointed out, are rising. And this is a concern. The Fed takes expectations very seriously. And because expectations are a sign of inflationary pressures becoming embedded in the process of the economy, which of course, we want
1:52 Speaker 02 to avoid, almost at all costs, avoid that self fulfilling aspect of inflation. So the expectations numbers will certainly get some attention, it seems to me.
2:06 Speaker 01 Yeah. And they had been behaving well, right? That was the one thing that we could kind of rest on, even though those headline numbers were so, were so sort of shocking at one point. How much of the Fed rate hikes do you think have hit the economy already? Have we seen the effects of those hikes? Or are we still operating with a lag?
2:28 Speaker 02 I don't think there's a simple answer to that. You know, the orthodoxy within the economic profession is the expression long and variable lags. Monetary policy has its effect with long and variable lags. In my own view, there are certain sectors that respond almost immediately to higher interest rates, for example, auto loans or mortgage loans. And then there are others that take a long time and to some degree, there is a kind of cumulative effect of the higher rates that weighs more in the later months than in the earlier months.
3:10 Speaker 02 I think we're looking at a combination of short, medium, and long term, which is in a way of evading your question. But it's not as simple as just saying the lags are still at work and the effect of higher interest rate has not clicked in. I think clearly the effect of higher interest rates has kicked or clicked in.
3:38 Speaker 01 So how does the Fed wrap their head around that? If it's complicated and it's not clear, how are they adjusting policy? How do they know if they're going too far?
3:50 Speaker 02 Well, there are a whole lot of sort of guidelines or models that give some input into policy or are used in the policymaking process. An example would be Taylor Rule type of models that give you a sense of what the interest rate level should be, the policy rate level should be. So it's not any one answer to your question. The committee looks at a whole range of things. And I would say in the final analysis, each individual on the committee
4:35 Speaker 02 is making a judgment as to the appropriateness of policy.
4:40 Speaker 01 Yeah. Just a reminder to our listeners, by the way, if you have questions, put them in the chat and we'll get to as many as we can. Also hit the QR code and sign up if you would like to stay with us past the half hour. So Dennis, what do you think the conversation is right now around the Fed table, around the FOMC table? What are the governors and presidents most focused on? I mean, very few people get the opportunity to sit there. You know what it's like. It seems incredibly difficult right now. Every time we have this conversation, we kind of think we come back to the Fed really being between a rock and a hard place, just such a difficult, so difficult navigating this. What do you think the conversation is like right now?
5:19 Speaker 02 Well, there are several conversations that go on. There's a conversations among the governors in Washington who are co-located and mostly in the office, I would say. So they have a chance to compare notes on their assessment of the circumstances. And then the presidents of the reserve banks who are out in their individual reserve banks may or may not be having many conversations among them, among that group, but are talking to their economic staff almost every day to evaluate the situation. What I think is
5:58 Speaker 02 the focus at the moment would be first, sort of what is the core inflationary picture? What, what is the economy? How is the economy trending? And then second, what are the risk factors associated with the debt ceiling and the sort of on again, off again, small and regional bank crisis, or crisis may be too strong a word, small and medium bank liquidity issues?
6:30 Speaker 02 That is, it seems to be feeding a credit contraction, or at least a backing off of credit availability. Those are the things that seem to me to be on the table at the moment.
6:45 Speaker 01 You know, it just occurs to me, I'm not sure that everyone really understands the way, you know, the way it works. And the Fed presidents play a really important role in that dialogue, don't they? It's my understanding that you're really, I don't want to say boots on the ground, but have that view into the real economy in the region that you're operating in to get a sense of what's happening. Because the US is, it's an enormous economy. It has a lot of different, some areas are experiencing, you know, certain dynamics and others are not. I would assume that that information coming from the Fed presidents is extremely important in the decision making.
7:22 Speaker 02 Yes, I'd like to believe it's very valuable. And I think the governors, and I'm quite certain Chair Powell, values the input that they, that they all get from, from the various Fed districts. The process between meetings is a very important process. And the staff and the presidents of the reserve banks are engaging with business people and community leaders throughout their regions and asking the question, how are you experiencing the economy? What are you worried about? And what, how does it feel to you?
8:02 Speaker 02 You're going to get different answers depending upon the sector represented by the, the person being interviewed. But all of that is accumulated and synthesized into something called the beige book, which is really, is really a book of, or a, a report of anecdotal inputs. And those anecdotal inputs are often repeated at the table at the Federal Open Market Committee meeting and, and I think are a valuable input, even though.
8:38 Speaker 02 It's anecdote, it's not data, it's not hard numbers. It is still used as part of the inputs to the decision.
8:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely. I mean, what you're hearing from people, I think sometimes gives you, especially when you're starting to hear it from different regions, gives you a fantastic insight, I would think, into what's going on and maybe a little bit more in the moment than, you know, some of the data, which we know just by nature, the way it was collected, or at least it used to be, lags. So, so right now, you mentioned the problem, the concern that's probably
9:13 Speaker 01 going to be expressed after seeing that expectation number, because expectations matter so much. Fed Governor, prior to that, Fed Governor Michelle Baumann Baumann already came out warning that more rate hikes might be needed. Do you think that now, having seen that expectation data, do you think that the Fed's going to have to raise rates again in June? What are the options that they're likely weighing here?
9:39 Speaker 02 I think it's a complicated picture because you, I think you first start with
9:45 Speaker 02 the evolution of the inflation problem and the economy absent the banking situation, banking system situation, and absent the debt ceiling. So if you were just to isolate that and look at the probability of a pause versus the probability of another rate increase, it will depend largely on the inflation data. The data we received this week struck me as confirming a view of gradual disinflation, but not rapid disinflation. So, you know, the Fed is not getting the climb down the ladder that it's looking for.
10:29 Speaker 02 And that would argue that they would at least consider another rate increase at the, at the upcoming June meeting. Having said that, in the real world, they have these other two factors and we don't know today how they're going to play out. The trend of credit availability is, to some degree, evaluatable or assessable. And this week, we had the Senior Loan Officer Survey, which seemed to say that banks, for a variety of reasons, were raising their credit standards and at the same time, credit demand was declining.
11:12 Speaker 02 So it's a shrinking credit picture for more than one reason. The debt ceiling is a real wild card, it strikes me. And we will know, I hope, in the next few days, how that's going to be resolved. And I hope it is resolved with the debt ceiling being raised. But if it goes to the, just the 11th hour or more, it's risky. And in a default situation, I'm sure the committee would have to factor that into their decision. So, as I said, there's more than one factor at work here.
11:57 Speaker 02 Some of them are very contingent, some of them are more predictable. But, you know, at the end of the day, there are only probably two major decisions, either to pause or to continue with a rate increase. My own handicapping of it is that the committee is now in a position to pause if there are compelling reasons to do that.
12:24 Speaker 01 Hey, everyone. We're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
12:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I've got to think the two you mentioned are huge concerns. The, when it comes to the strain in the regional banks, I mean, won't another rate hike just exacerbate the situation?
12:52 Speaker 02 Well, um.
12:55 Speaker 01 I mean, we have people talking about bank walks. They're not talking about bank runs, but they are talking about bank walks. And there's a concern that that's just going to continue.
13:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think, I don't think you can deny that, that raising interest rates has, to some degree, caused this problem. And therefore, continuing to raise interest rates certainly doesn't make it better, even if banks are hedged, even if banks are relatively liquid. Raising interest rates doesn't make it better. So far, the committee has tried to separate the two issues, financial stability on one side and inflation and monetary policy on the other. That was their position coming out of the most recent FOMC meeting, that these are separable
13:49 Speaker 02 issues. And I think the committee will try to continue to do that. But the severity of the conditions that we're facing, you know, could very well force a greater weight on the regional bank and small bank liquidity issues, even in making a decision on monetary policy.
14:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, they, they, they would like them to be separate, but that, that doesn't seem very tethered in reality, um, you know, to say they're separate.
14:26 Speaker 02 Well, I think.
14:28 Speaker 01 You know, how do they continue to hold on to that line?
14:32 Speaker 02 If you roll the film back a bit.
14:36 Speaker 02 And you remember, we had three bank failures, actually Silicon Valley Bank, Signature Bank, and then with a bit of a lag, Republic National Bank. And I think Jay Powell was probably working from the best information he had, but in so many words in the press conference, he said, "The problem has been ring fenced and the deposit outflow of other banks has essentially ceased." That is what I heard him say in the press conference, and that could have been their assessment at that time, that this was a matter related to three banks, and that
15:19 Speaker 02 the problem was largely contained. In that state of the world, separating monetary policy from financial stability policy would make sense. You don't have to allow one to pollute the other. But we have seen this week, mostly in stock prices, we've seen a continuing pressure on some of these banks, and to some degree, that the declines in stock prices reflects a continuing questioning of their survivability or their solvency. And it's just a matter of how severe this problem continues to be and whether it cascades.
16:02 Speaker 01 Do you have any concerns about it being systemic?
16:07 Speaker 02 The banks, the individual banks themselves are not systemic in the way we thought about systemic risk back in 2008 and 2009. And what I mean by that is the failure of any individual bank is not going to bring down the system. But what we seem to be experiencing here is collectively, this size of bank, call it a medium-sized bank, a regional bank, collectively, if you had a succession of runs on these banks, that's a systemic event.
16:45 Speaker 02 It's going to really rattle the economy and could lead to something far worse that internationalizes or moves upstream to some of the larger, too-big-to-fail banks. So, you know, I do think you can argue that...
17:05 Speaker 02 What we have seen and what we may be seeing cannot be dismissed as not systemic. That's a double negative there, but I'm trying to be, I'm trying to be a little bit more subtle in the, in the choice of words than just say it's a systemic event.
17:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, no, I understand what you're saying. I mean, in the, you know, given the interconnectedness of the global economy, it's really hard for me to get my head around how anything's ring fenced. But this, this brings up a really good question that Colin has. How does the Fed check for accuracy of information? And I'm thinking of it in terms of the speed in which things happen. So we know when we've seen some of these issues, especially with Silicon Valley Bank, it was sort of a virtual bank run, right? I mean, it would, it happened in a way that we've never really seen before, given the fact that people now have bank apps on their phone. Is the Fed equipped to deal with that information and that kind of speed? Or is this something they're likely talking about?
18:07 Speaker 02 Well, I'm sure they're talking about it. Let me piggyback on something you said, and you referred to the, the nature of the bank run that we saw with Silicon Valley Bank. I think you can make the argument that we are in a new era of bank runs. It's not your grandfather's bank run. You know, it's, it's not, it's a wonderful life with people standing in line outside a bank. It's chief financial officers with unguaranteed deposits who are on their cell phones, moving literally billions of dollars around to find a safe
18:46 Speaker 02 haven. And it can happen extremely rapidly. So I think everyone learned in the Silicon Valley Bank episode, that, that there is simply a new, modern bank run, and it's different than maybe the way it had been conceptualized as a risk, even with recent years. And no one realized how rapidly this can develop. The impact of social media, for example, was not on anyone's radar screen that I'm aware of. Or if it was, it was a very, you know, academic, you know, in the background kind of recognition that maybe runs could develop with the help of social media.
19:31 Speaker 02 Well, we've experienced one now, and I think everyone is upgrading their real-time information gathering for accuracy and for speed. Speed, in some respects, maybe is as important as 100% accuracy. You can be 80% right and still make a decision that can forestall a problem.
19:54 Speaker 01 We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
20:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely. And when we're talking about, I just want to go back to the
20:12 Speaker 01 you know, the strains in the banking system and the credit crunch that's sort of happening as a result of that.
20:19 Speaker 01 We had a guest on earlier this week who was saying they're kind of estimating that it could be the equivalent of maybe three rate hikes. Some people have said as many as six. I mean, clearly, this is going to be a drag on the economy. How are you thinking about this? How, how much of an impact do you think it will have in terms of slowing the US economy?
20:40 Speaker 02 I think it's very hard to quantify in terms of 25 basis point rate hikes, one, two, or three. I think that's a, you know, that's a useful way of trying to make your assessment as scientific as it can be. But I just, I think it's, it's difficult. But what appears to be developing
21:05 Speaker 02 is the banks are pulling in their how shall I put it? The banks are raising their standards and becoming much more selective in terms of credit.
21:19 Speaker 02 And at the same time, the demand for credit is declining, probably driven by a gradually slowing economy, which is the result of the rate hikes we've had before. So In those circumstances, I think there is a trade off between the banks doing the job for the Fed and the Fed doing it itself by raising interest rates. In other words, I think the Fed can make a judgment, and I'm sure there will be different estimates of the impact of the credit picture voiced at the table in June, but make a judgment
22:03 Speaker 02 of the substitutability of bank credit contraction versus another rate hike. And I think they're probably now in a situation of being comfortable making that kind of judgment and therefore putting a pause on the table.
22:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, that'll be on that side of the ledger. I want to get to, we have a bunch of questions. I want to get to a couple of them before we flip over. And this is, this is an interesting one. Achilles, everyone keeps complaining that the Fed's not looking at the right data, but isn't the Fed aware of this? Because I'm pretty sure there are smart people in the Fed versus what people generally give them credit for.
22:52 Speaker 02 Well, yeah. My experience is there are a lot of smart people in the Fed, and I would not have survived from the job if I weren't surrounded by people who were a lot smarter than me and better educated, particularly in economics than I was. So yes, on the matter of data, the Fed does not have at least much of a stream of proprietary data, other than maybe the surveys and the anecdotes that are collected between meetings, as I referenced earlier. So the Fed is looking at the same data that Wall Street is looking at and that money
23:36 Speaker 02 management firms are looking at and that academic economists are looking at. It's the same data and, you know, no privileged information in the Fed. So the question really is how much confidence do you have? How much do you rely on the public data that come out mostly out of the government, but out of some private firms and other organizations that issue a data series of one kind or another? And the difference between the Fed and most other consumers of the data is the Fed has literally hundreds of economists
24:19 Speaker 02 who are following the data. So it's sort of more people working on it as opposed to something that's proprietary. And, you know, I think those people are extremely well qualified. They understand the underlying methodologies, which is important to know where the numbers come from and how the numbers are actually calculated and periodically are in touch with the statisticians who are the source of those data series. So that's the way I would characterize the, you know, they have enough smart people question.
24:58 Speaker 01 Yeah. And it's people who are doing it in depth all the time, you know, so they really, I think that really gives you sort of some sense of ownership.
25:08 Speaker 02 Just to give you a little bit more color, when I was at the Atlanta Fed and important data were issued, we would have a meeting any week of the seven, six, seven weeks between meetings. So it's a continuous process. We would have a meeting, talk about the data that had come out and what its implication would be.
25:37 Speaker 01 Benjamin asking, in terms of the banking situation, is it possible to solve these bank run risks simply by removing the reserve requirement for loans?
25:49 Speaker 02 No, I don't think that alone, that may help in the sense of just easing up a little bit in terms of available funds and so forth for the banks. But I'll answer that by saying, you know, in a bank run, no amount of relief from reserve requirements is going to save you from the kind of deposit outflow that, for example, Silicon Valley Bank saw.
26:23 Speaker 02 And this is me speaking here, I don't want to attribute this to anybody else's view.
26:32 Speaker 02 A bank is a fairly fragile edifice in the first place. Leverage of 10 to 1, basically. So a small capital base relative to total assets. Also, a tendency to borrow short and lend long, which is, obviously, is an insolvency problem waiting to happen if everything happened at the same time. Running a bank is reliant on the law of large numbers, that you have deposits coming in and deposits going out every single minute of every single day.
27:13 Speaker 02 But it all adds up to stability, providing there is confidence out there among depositors and the general public. So it is terribly reliant on trust and confidence. And when that confidence is shaken, the, I would call it, the intrinsic fragility of the structure of a bank gets under pressure. I mean, it just, or it begins to express itself. And that's, in some respects, what we're seeing.
27:47 Speaker 01 That's a fantastic description. Does that concern you massively when we, again, look at the ability for someone to tweet something and cause everyone to pick up their phone? How do you address the issue of confidence and trust?
28:02 Speaker 02 Well, I do think we may have seen a major change in the dynamics of that confidence and trust question, or we've experienced it with the recent bank failures. Because as you point out, it's just an influential tweet can start a bunch of market actions that conceivably bring down an institution that otherwise should be stable, that is more or less fundamentally in pretty decent shape and managing its problems.
28:41 Speaker 02 But social media can create just a panic that is all psychological, but it's real, it has its effect. So I do think we're in a somewhat different world, and I'm sure the regulators are evaluating, how do they operate within that kind of context?
29:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would think so. I was just going to say, I smell a white paper coming. I certainly hope someone's very quickly, very quickly looking into this. We have a bunch more really good questions. We have hit the bottom of the half hour, so if you'd like to continue with us, make sure you scan that QR code. For those of you who have to jump, have a fantastic weekend. Hope you get out, enjoy the beautiful weather.
Previous The "Boringest Exciting Market" Ever? w/ Jared Dillian Next How to Profit as the Dollar Fades w/ Larry McDonald Page updated October 24, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated