Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Breaking Down "The Exponential Age: Crypto's Fast and Furious Rise" About this episode DB-Apr16,2021: Real Vision senior editor Ash Bennington welcomes Real Vision co-founder and CEO Raoul Pal to discuss his Expert View, “The Exponential Age: Crypto’s Fast and Furious Rise,” released today. Ash and Raoul will be contextualizing this piece for macro investors and more. Please visit this link to watch the video just by adding your email address. The Exponential Age: Crypto’s Fast and Furious Rise, Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:12 Speaker 00 Happy Friday, everyone. Welcome back to the Real Vision Daily Briefing, live without a net with Ralph Powell, CEO and co-founder of Real Vision. Back to back, two weeks in a row. Welcome back, Ralph.
0:24 Speaker 01 I'm like everywhere right now. There's my, my pieces on the crypto part, my pieces on Real Vision. I'm on the daily briefing. I'm everywhere. You can't avoid me. I'm omnipresent. I'm part of the exponential age.
0:36 Speaker 00 Indeed. Talking of which, rhetorical question, Ralph. What are we talking about today?
0:42 Speaker 01 Should we talk about the bond market?
0:46 Speaker 00 Take a nap.
0:47 Speaker 01 No, I, you know, what I wanted to do, I put that video out on Real Vision, which is really a Real Vision crypto piece, but it's, it's broader than that. It's actually for Real Vision itself because I wanted to get across that learning journey that I've just been on and I'm still on. I mean, it's reminding me, I learned something entirely new this morning alone that has blown my mind yet again in where this is all going. But I wanted to at least plant the flag because people have seen me on other podcasts on Real Vision, writing stuff. I wanted to put it all together and say, right, here's my big picture view. This is what I think is going on and where we're going. And it is very hard to keep up with because it is exponential.
1:33 Speaker 01 So exponential, you kind of in your mind think, okay, well, I know how fast this is. And I, I'll just think it goes forwards like that, but exponential gets exponentially faster. So it gets harder and harder to keep up with how fast it's going. If we go back a year, let's settle ourselves back into pandemic. We're now, this time we're in lock, we're all in lockdown all around the world, thinking what the hell's going on? The markets have fallen apart, just finding a base. And we all start talking a bit about Bitcoin and what the central banks have to do. And we start figuring it out. You know, at no point are we having conversations about.
2:08 Speaker 01 NFTs and DeFi and all of the protocols going on and the metaverse and gaming and all of the stuff that's coming in the 12 months afterwards, but it's just like hit nuclear, how fast this is all exploding. And it's fascinating, you know, obviously price has been a good part of that. And, you know, many of us have participated in this whole thing, but it's, it's, it's more than just about price. It's about an adoption or a migration to this new world. And that is happening at a speed, even I'm surprised at.
2:44 Speaker 00 Yeah. If I had to sum up that, that recording in three words, it would be Bitcoin is macro.
2:54 Speaker 01 Yes, but not only Bitcoin. When the entire world's financial system and structure of money and value is changing at lightning speed to something else, it is the most macro thing you're ever going to live through. And I said that about the pandemic, but this is like an equal and opposite reaction. So we have the worst ever recession, pretty much in world recorded history, followed by this, a complete accelerated rebuild of
3:33 Speaker 01 an entire millennia old system of value. I mean, really? And it's not about, oh, I don't like Bitcoin, you know, prefer my goal. It's nothing to do with that. It's, it's to do with everything. I mean, I mean, now you're trading equities that are listed on crypto exchanges because they trade 24 hours a day. Why would you not? We're now seeing instant settlement rails. We're, we're now seeing all of these worlds colliding so fast.
4:08 Speaker 01 That that everything we understood up until this date of finance is changing.
4:17 Speaker 00 Yeah. So maybe software is macro and it has eaten the world.
4:22 Speaker 01 Software is macro. You know, that's that is that true statement that I never believed I'd say. Because I thought that was a different world.
4:31 Speaker 00 Right.
4:31 Speaker 01 And yes, I could understand that. Technology was driving productivity and efficiency and other things.
4:40 Speaker 01 But I thought that.
4:43 Speaker 01 Part of it was the issue of the financial system itself and the mess that it was in was a bigger offset to that. And now we've kind of got that technology stuff that's going on. And we've created this parallel financial system at the same time that's going to free us of this other one. Now, it won't feel like that for a bit and there will be a bit of a battle, but the battle, I think, is slowing the speed of migration to the new world. I keep saying it. It's like people have discovered the Americas. And how fast you populate it, what do you populate first? That's what's going on. People are migrating there as fast as possible.
5:19 Speaker 00 Yeah. So what does that migration look like as it starts to unfold? How do you envision that occurring?
5:26 Speaker 01 Well, I mean. The answer is I don't know because it's going to happen to different people in different ways because the people buying the NBA NFTs. Many of them aren't even thinking it's crypto. Many people are exchanging tokens in games. They're not thinking in terms of, oh, that's a cryptocurrency. So crypto is just something underneath the surface for some of this.
5:53 Speaker 01 When people have remittance payment rails, it doesn't matter that it's on crypto. Crypto happened to be the better solution for it all. So a lot of people will come into this world without even knowing about it.
6:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:06 Speaker 01 Others have come in purposely with that sense of mission of the change of the system. Others have come seeking return on capital or protection of capital. So different people will come or others have come for the intellectual journey. So people are migrating for a number of reasons, but interestingly enough, around it, people are leaving the financial system and rebuilding in the digital world at rapid pace. So, you know, Sam from FX is a great example. Traditional finance guy, complete crypto guy. And I could give you thirty of those now. So many of the world's most famous billionaire hedge fund managers, they're just completely moved to crypto now.
6:49 Speaker 01 And I know I keep mentioning that, but I get more and more of them all the time. So they're all migrating. So whether it's the student, whether it's the billionaire, whether it's the guy building his business, it's the developer, they're all moving.
7:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
7:03 Speaker 01 And so it is really something quite profound.
7:07 Speaker 00 Yeah. By the way, one of the interesting things, you and I came to the same conclusion separately, independently, and I completely agree with you, is this idea about NFTs. NFTs are not about collectibles. NFTs are not about CryptoKitties 2.0. You said it extremely well in the exponential age. It's about the tokenization of everything.
7:30 Speaker 01 Yes, I've been bleating on this for about three or four years. Just it's slow to come and we've got tokenization of real estate to come. And what that means is you can infinitely slice an asset to allow many more people to participate and have equal rights. But that doesn't really happen in the world. So I could have a, you know, the amazing mansion in Bel Air and somebody else can't afford it. But when you tokenize it, everybody can have a participation in it. So.
8:03 Speaker 01 But everything is going to get tokenized, and that's everything from IP rights to communities, from insurance to rare assets, from supply chains to, I mean, I mean, everything. It's the exchange of all value. And again, if these, even I, when I heard that statement, the exchange of value, didn't really understand it. But the more you think about it, it's like the software is eating the world thing, the more you think about it, the more profound it is, and the more you sit down with a glass of wine going, oh, my God, I can't get my head around this any longer, because the more it unpacks. And it's the exchange of value. That is what it is doing. It's allowing something to connect to the digital world that now is transferable and
8:47 Speaker 01 tradable. Whatever that is, could be anything. It's, it's.
8:52 Speaker 00 And creating trust in a trustless system.
8:55 Speaker 01 Exactly. Because authenticity, trusted authenticity on an asset is basically the creation of value. Now, there are other elements to that. So, you know, a, any piece of random artwork put on a blockchain and made an NFT is not valuable. The NFT itself is not valuable. The actual thing has to be valuable. The NFT is a mechanism by which you can exchange or store or transfer that value.
9:25 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, I have to say, my screen's lighting up with questions already. Usually, they don't come rolling in until about the halfway point.
9:32 Speaker 01 Well, before we go into questions, so I'm going to tell you about, so I've just laid out for an hour and forty minutes, my whole, like, this is where we are. I get up this morning and somebody, the Real Vision Bot guys.
9:46 Speaker 00 Yes.
9:47 Speaker 01 They put this, does anybody know how to build a website like this? And showed the website of family office of one of the founders of Nintendo. Right, and it's this like mini metaverse. So I'm like, oh my god, of course. And then I mentioned in an internal Slack message and somebody said, well, you need to go and have a look at the Crypto Voxels uh metaverse. So they send me a link and the link is a coordinate. This is what people need to get across. So people watching this, the web link is a coordinate to a place in that metaverse. It happened to be at a record store, a vinyl store, which has music playing, vinyl and you're selling NFTs.
10:29 Speaker 01 So I'm in a physical place in the digital world that somebody sent me to. And then it made me realize, and I could walk around and talk to other people and meet people in that. And it's, it's amazing. Everybody should go to Crypto Voxels, V O X E L S, and just walk around and move to places, find out what events are going on. It's kind of literally mind blowing. But, and everyone hit bored of me saying mind blowing, but my mind is being blown quite a lot. What I realized is in 10 years, there will be no websites in the way that we have websites. Course not. You're going to give coordinates in a metaverse. So you can create a perfect place for your guests to come to. So you come to visit a website. Well, if you want to come to
11:10 Speaker 01 visit the Real Vision website, well, we want to show a cool merch store and here's some video playing. And hey, you want to meet some of the guys here? You know, all of this stuff. Oh, and here's our community. Is physically represented in these things, much better than a 2D website. So I've just realized that every single website is going to change over time as well. To coordinates in the metaverse, there's so much going on. And that's, you know, Crypto Voxels, it is built on crypto platforms. It's all exchange of value NFTs. So OpenSea and all the NFT platforms all operate in it. So do your wallets. It's unbelievable.
11:49 Speaker 00 Yeah. And I should add, the exponential ease, Crypto's fast and furious rise, released today, now available on Real Vision Essential and also on Real Vision Crypto, uh which means it's available to everyone for free. Uh if you just go to the Real Vision website and sign up on the crypto tier, full access.
12:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, all you need is your email address. You get everything. And if you haven't signed up to Real Vision Crypto, I know I've mentioned it a few times, it's crazy. It's the world's best content on this whole new world. It's being laid out, given to you on a plate. All you need to do is give your email address and be delivered to you. And you'll get the distillery every week to tell you what's been going on, because it's hard to keep up.
12:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, extremely hard to keep up, even for those of us who just do this for a living. It's hard to keep up.
12:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, impossible.
12:31 Speaker 00 Yeah. So, Raul, my screen's been lighting up on Dogecoin. What are your thoughts on this? I'm very curious to hear.
12:39 Speaker 00 Let me just throw some statistics out for you, by the way. Now over $40 billion, same market cap as Barclays, up 400% in seven days.
12:55 Speaker 01 I don't know. This is either a stupid bubble or something we don't understand. And I'm going to give those two things equal weighting.
13:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
13:08 Speaker 01 And when I say don't understand.
13:15 Speaker 01 What happens if somebody decides to use that chain?
13:19 Speaker 01 To connect to community and they decide to use. Maybe somebody has.
13:26 Speaker 01 Maybe somebody bought a whole load of this stuff to basically control an entire crypto chain. Because they can do it and you can use it for community tokens or whatever. I don't know. It's possible. It's possible that even Tesla have decided to use Doge as their crypto.
13:45 Speaker 01 Tokenized system. Just hell of it for the fun of it, for the meme-ness of it. I don't know. Or maybe it's just rampant speculation and it's all stupid. I have no idea and I'm learned not to pass judgment on this stuff. Because really, most people are generally wrong.
14:06 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, here's what's interesting to me. You know, whenever you look at the valuation of any asset, you always have, you know, indicators that are pro and indicators that are con. But the fascinating thing about the crypto space and with Doge specifically is the complexity of evaluating these. Look, here's the anti-Doge case. It's very simple. This is a coin that was created as a joke, right? Literally, it's a meme coin. It's up dramatically. It looks like hockey stick growth and it's inflation. Missionary by design, right, is the opposite of what Bitcoin is. And the top 10 Doge addresses, according to some coin metrics quoted by CoinDesk,
14:45 Speaker 00 41.3% of all circulating Dogecoin are held by 10 individual addresses. Highly concentrated. These are some very, very, very negative signs. That said, to your point, you know, do you reach a point of scale on this where someone just jumps in? It's so widely held that someone wants to do something interesting with it? You can't rule that out.
15:11 Speaker 01 You can't because network effect generally needs two parts. It's not just people buying it. It needs to have application developments and it needs to be an ecosystem. Right? This has one side of the ecosystem. It has a lot of people owning it.
15:25 Speaker 00 Right.
15:26 Speaker 01 Okay, well, that's very powerful. As you rightly say, if you can be the other side of that, meaning not the guy who owns these coins. Sure, those guys might be doing something, but it's can you apply this community to something else now? That's really interesting. A reverse takeover? Chain?
15:46 Speaker 01 Maybe.
15:47 Speaker 00 That said, the only use case right now is that someone might want to buy it back from you at a higher price tomorrow.
15:54 Speaker 01 Well, that's most things really, same as a piece of art.
15:58 Speaker 00 True.
15:59 Speaker 01 You know, I, I don't know. So I will, I will amuse myself by watching it, but I will not make pass comment on it because I, I don't know. Because things, too many things are changing, too many economic models are, are being completely rewritten in front of our eyes. That anybody who thinks they understand what's going on is lying to themselves.
16:19 Speaker 00 Yeah. You know, I'm definitely a skeptic on Doge, but I have to say this space in general.
16:25 Speaker 01 And I'm a skeptic on Doge, but I'm not going to say, well, I don't know what the hell it is. So I'm just skeptical in terms of, it's not for me.
16:35 Speaker 01 Do your own homework, kids. You understand that this is a something that has in the usual construct no value, but maybe we're the chumps and before you know it, Taylor Swift turns it into her community. I have no idea.
16:51 Speaker 00 Right. Yeah, two points. The first is that there are a lot of people out there, retail investors who are speculating in this, and they will often say, well, you know, Elon Musk owns this and Mark Cuban owns this. I can assure you that if Doge goes to zero, neither Elon Musk nor Mr. Cuban are going to have problems paying their rent. They're not going to have to send the email to the landlord saying, I'm very sorry, I'm going to be a little late this month.
17:14 Speaker 01 And the speculative part of this cycle is now starting to really get underway.
17:20 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:20 Speaker 01 And there will be a lot of FOMO. I mean, I'm struggling with it myself. I mean, everything is going to go up and it's going to go up, overusing the word, exponentially. And people are going to be shocked at what's about to happen and people will make mistakes with their money. And, you know, it's all well and good. There is a money-making opportunity in all of this. There really is. But just don't take risks you can't run because you think it's your one chance. It's not the one chance. There's a whole universe that's being built in front of us. You don't need, you don't need to make all in one trade. So take the risks you're comfortable
18:00 Speaker 01 with. Participate in the glory of a full speculative frenzy in the middle of an exponential rise of an asset class. You know, it's, it's a, it's a beautiful moment in time, but realize that speculation will run riot. There will be, there will be the downward counteracting move to that speculation, which is a bust, and then we'll start all over again.
18:22 Speaker 00 Yeah. You know, to that point, in terms of concentration, and it's not a one-trade type of situation, Kathy Wood, Arc F, the fintech innovation ETF run by Kathy Wood, invested in CoinDesk, 0.25% of her portfolio.
18:40 Speaker 01 In Coinbase?
18:43 Speaker 00 In Coinbase, yes.
18:46 Speaker 01 And when was that? Now or?
18:49 Speaker 00 Two days ago, when the trade report came out at the listing. Well, we don't know. We just know the trade report said Coinbase 0.25%. So the point is, when professionals make bets, they're very careful and very thoughtful about their positioning.
19:07 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:09 Speaker 00 And their sizing.
19:10 Speaker 01 Yeah.
19:13 Speaker 01 Look, it's the Wild West. And it's not the Wild West because everybody's a scammer. It's the Wild West because none of us have been here before. It's a new discovery of this new world. And it's gonna get crazy for a while.
19:25 Speaker 00 Yeah.
19:25 Speaker 01 Just don't be too stupid.
19:27 Speaker 00 You know, in many ways, the flip side of exponential growth is radical uncertainty, radical unpredictability, and radical humility required to understand and participate.
19:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, as everybody keeps pointing out, Amazon has been an exponential curve since it started. And it's had so many kind of 80, 90, 30, 40, 50% pullbacks. It's ridiculous. It's a function of it.
19:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, absolutely. So, Raul, what else is on your mind?
20:00 Speaker 01 I don't know. We're gonna have some questions. What about the questions?
20:02 Speaker 00 All right, let's hit them up.
20:05 Speaker 00 While I find the document, I have to ask you, what are your thoughts on the price right now of Bitcoin and Turkey? Turkey banning cryptocurrency payments, not the possession of cryptocurrency, but use as a payment mechanism. In many ways, this is the Ray Dalio fear scenario about how governments can intervene to prevent people from using assets like Bitcoin on a regular basis. By the way, I should say, Turkey's latest inflation print last week, I believe, 16% macro meets crypto.
20:39 Speaker 01 Exactly. And don't forget, why is Turkey doing this? Turkey's doing it because there is capital flight and they can't fund their deficit.
20:49 Speaker 01 Capital flight is money leaving the country using crypto rails. So they're just trying to stop it. I understand why.
20:59 Speaker 01 It's them trying to reassert their authority over the capital markets. But as we've learned, with a distributed network that is digital and owned by nobody and everybody, it's very, very difficult to stop. I would never get China's gone down this route. India's tried this route. Turkey's gone down this route. I mean, everybody's had a go at it. But, you know, you can't, you cannot break a network. You can't.
21:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, I guess it's the service code. If something should have died many times in the past and it hasn't, you need to look at it and figure out why.
21:31 Speaker 01 And maybe that's what I mean by Dogecoin as well. I'm not joking.
21:36 Speaker 01 It hasn't died. Why?
21:39 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:39 Speaker 01 I could be dead wrong.
21:42 Speaker 00 Interesting. So our first question comes to us from Bumble. The question is-
21:46 Speaker 01 I don't recommend Doge, by the way. Let's be absolutely clear and I don't recommend it. Carry on.
21:51 Speaker 00 Full disclosure made. First question comes to us from Bumble. The question is, in Raul's presentation, he said he did not expect to see inflation. Can he please explain why? Is it demographics or something else?
22:05 Speaker 01 So I explained it in the video and I've explained it numerous times before. There was some massive waves that stop wages increasing. Wages, the lack of wage increases generally means that purchasing power is not able to increase prices in the generalized economy. So what is doing that is the fact that record number of people, baby boomers, came into the workforce at the same time. Then, forty years later, their kids came in. Or how really, seventy, sixty years later, their kids came in.
22:45 Speaker 01 Basically, we got two largest demographic bulges in all of history in the labor force at the same time. Net result, wages don't go up.
22:54 Speaker 00 Right.
22:54 Speaker 01 Then you add, oh, and by the way, you guys, all of you massive pool of people fighting for jobs, you need to compete with those Chinese guys, those Indian guys and those Brazilians. And while you're doing it, while you're all fighting over these jobs and the wages, that robot over there wants a job too. And that AI software.
23:15 Speaker 01 And we're going to make it a little more difficult to you. We're going to give you a massive amount of debt as well.
23:23 Speaker 01 So you're really constrained by this huge amount of debt whilst not seeing your salary go up and competing against all of these people and the robots and the AI.
23:34 Speaker 00 Right.
23:35 Speaker 01 That is why the world is so goddamn deflationary.
23:38 Speaker 00 Yeah.
23:39 Speaker 01 So what we're seeing now is cyclical inflation based on supply issues. Whether it's in agricultural commodities that are in structural plummeting, ongoing bear market. That's been going on for decades.
23:56 Speaker 01 Metals, copper is being changed into this new narrative around EV because of the globalized mandates. You don't have enough copper. That's going up. Is that inflation? Or is that a different demand source for an asset? It's not a generalized inflation. So there's stuff like that. There's mixed narratives. So I think cyclical inflation, of course, you're at the point in the cycle where you'll see some inflation pick up. I do not believe it can stick unless something dramatic changes.
24:26 Speaker 00 Yeah. So many excellent points, so well said. AI is a topic we're going to be hearing about a great deal more. It's so interesting. You know, the last wave of automation, one of his factories and robots. You saw the consultants and the finance folks saying, oh, this is just the way the economy works. You need to adapt and you need to adjust. And now it's their jobs on the table. So we're going to have to see how that narrative unfolds.
24:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, everybody's jobs are on the table. And all of the Chinese workers or Indian workers who are undercutting their jobs too.
24:57 Speaker 00 Right.
24:57 Speaker 01 So as technology is moving, we'll say again, at exponential speed. AI by definition is exponential. It's exponential in the speed that it learns. It's exponential in the speed that it gets adopted. The more, the faster it gets adopted, the faster it's going to displace jobs globally. People cannot get their heads around the speed of change that is happening right now. It is going to create economic miracles and economic problems of which we will have to solve by a new global, new infrastructure that has to deal with this. Whatever that means, and I don't even know what it means. But exponential AI, exponential robotics.
25:39 Speaker 01 Put into a globalized workforce, which is non exponential, is a huge change.
25:45 Speaker 00 Right. And by the way, with regard to EM, the same path, the same infrastructure, the same processes that led to workflows being able to be offshored, being able to be outsourced, now being used to feed the work into these AI algorithms. So for folks in EMs, it's the technology giveth and the technology taketh away.
26:07 Speaker 01 Yes, but what's also happening is many of these EM emerging market economies are starting with less of the existing creaky infrastructure. They're like the world 20 years ago. So their adoption of this stuff is fast. Like you can't chance on Bloomberg, like the Indian adoption of mobile phones. I mean, it is insane how fast that went. I mean, insane from like 1995, where there was like 30 per capita, 20 per capita. It went to 125 per capita in like 15, 20 years.
26:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
26:49 Speaker 01 Um, that's 1.3 billion people. Incredible. And then top of the network, this is network effects again, on top of the network, they then built a digital money system, a digital payment system, a digital authentication system for ID. All of this is coming. And if you've been following on Twitter, Bellagio has been talking a lot about this. All of the stuff that's happening within India and digital India, it's gigantic. And that happened because of the network effects of mobile phones have built multiple network effects. And as I've talked about before, one guy basically owns it all, which is Reliance and Mukesh Ambani. You know, I cannot see a world where that Reliance is not worth a trillion
27:34 Speaker 01 dollars in five years. I can't imagine that world because he owns, he owns the data, the mobile phone networks, he owns.
27:45 Speaker 01 The applications layers, I mean, just literally everything, and he generates electricity as well, as far as, well, he generates refining, but it's a huge, huge part of all of this. And, yeah, we can see that, and that's going to be played out in every country in the world.
28:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, and so much faster, the adoption curve than here in the United States because there wasn't the legacy infrastructure, it was a leapfrogging effect.
28:08 Speaker 01 Exactly, exactly. So, you know, don't forget, India went to this digital payment system, nobody else can do that yet, the US just simply can't get there, but India just did it overnight.
28:20 Speaker 00 Right?
28:21 Speaker 01 And, and it works, yeah, UPI works fantastically as an instant transfer system with no middleman. It's amazing.
28:30 Speaker 00 Right.
28:31 Speaker 01 And it's not.
28:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, talking of which, on a related point, here's a great question from MKS. During the Great Depression, an increase in savings was partially to blame as it took money out of the circulating supply. Could something similar happen with Bitcoin and the hodlers?
28:47 Speaker 01 My issue with this, I think this is a very interesting question, is in the end, Bitcoin is deflationary.
28:54 Speaker 00 Right.
28:54 Speaker 01 Why it's deflationary is, right now, and this is a point I've been trying to make, is there is no point owning any other asset because Bitcoin is outperforming everything. So what is it doing is creating money that I don't want to put into anything else. So it's creating a super deflation in Bitcoin in terms of everything. And yes, it will take money out of the system, but it's not big enough yet. Yeah, it's how much of actual savings versus, you know, price appreciation is in there. My guess is there's like a few hundred billion of new capital and, you know, a trillion and a half of, of, um, of price appreciation because of the limited supply, um, construct
29:39 Speaker 01 of Bitcoin and the market, so, so.
29:44 Speaker 01 Throw in a trillion dollars or two trillion dollars starts to become a meaningful source of savings that can be an issue for the global economy.
29:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, here's another great question from Ben picking up on the point earlier about Turkey. Will other countries join Turkey to ban crypto purchases or transactions? Will that develop into a full all out ban? And if so, what happens to the crypto verse? I know you have some thoughts about this, about it being sort of in brought into the system. Tell us, what are your thoughts?
30:13 Speaker 01 Well, I don't think it's gonna happen, but let's assume it does, right? Let's move away from my world, which is I think they're happy to have a another units of accounts or savings vehicle. So let's go to the world where everybody bans it. So global ban, Bitcoin cannot be used. Right. So how do you stop it? Right. So we've all got a Bitcoin in our wallets. We just be quiet about it now for a bit. They're not taking it away. They can't take it away. They can't figure it out. There's nobody to take it to prison. There's nothing you can do, right? So the network goes quiet for a bit. And then somebody over there goes, maybe they're Russia, we're not gonna ban it. Come over here. The water's lovely.
30:58 Speaker 01 And then capital whoosh.
31:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:01 Speaker 01 Oh, no, come over here. The water's lovely. Somebody in behavioral incentives make it very difficult and game theory makes it very difficult to globally ban as one of the largest, fastest moving groups of capital on earth.
31:14 Speaker 00 Yeah. And by the way, all you need to do is keep your seed phrase in your head and there's no way to stop you crossing the border with it. You don't have to soak diamonds into your shoes or stuff your suit filled with gold bars. You just walk across the border.
31:28 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly.
31:29 Speaker 00 Yeah.
31:30 Speaker 01 And you know, there's enough layers of privacy that can be had in that ecosystem.
31:37 Speaker 01 That it would just drive underground. So I think it's a preposterous thing. Yes, different nations will ban it for different times because they have to. It's like saying, did you see Turkey banned gold? Yes, for the same reason. Did you see that Turkey banned bank transfers out? Yes, for this reason. It's not a picking on crypto. It's like, please don't blow up our currency. We're running out of money. That's what's going on. It's not a crypto thing. It's just, please don't destroy our currency.
32:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, you could say it's just an emerging market capital control story.
32:08 Speaker 01 Of course it is.
32:09 Speaker 00 Yeah. From Solage, could this crypto cycle last longer than the previous one since there's been huge exponential growth and public awareness this time?
32:21 Speaker 01 Yes, I think it may go further in price than people expect. That's one potential. Because of the dynamics of the limited number of sellers and the massive amount of buyers. I mean, what world happens if the ETF comes whilst most of the institutions get get approval to trade it? I mean, it's going to get disconnected in price. I don't see any way around it. There's no way of changing that mechanism. So you're going to get discontinuity discontinuity in price to the upside. So I think it probably goes further. Does it go longer?
33:00 Speaker 01 I have no idea. Probably just suck as many of us in as possible before it then rolls over again. And thrash us for being for thinking there was no cycle. So I don't know. You know, the good thing about the crypto space is kind of everybody knows there's a cycle.
33:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
33:17 Speaker 01 And I have to laugh at the fact that you're never going to pick the top. You will probably you'll either get out early. Or you will lose a bunch of what you thought was money is now not because you've given it back. And people are pretty prepared for it. And the more people get familiar with the fact that it goes up and down a lot over time and that there are cycles. The better people are prepared for the risks that they're running.
33:39 Speaker 00 Yeah. And this is one of the reasons why you and some of the other macro guys have been so on point in this space because decades, you see these cycles, you see them in different asset classes, different geographies, different permutations, and you know that it's going to rhyme.
33:54 Speaker 01 Well, in most, what's bizarre is in most asset classes, the cycle is driven by supply and demand dynamic. You know, shale oil was a classic example. You know, world was running out of oil. They suddenly then, so the oil price is up at a hundred and forty dollars. Shale comes along, oil price reconnects down to thirty bucks and then to zero. And then what happens is a bunch of shale people come out and the price start coming. That's commodity cycle. Old as money, probably. The crypto cycle, what's interesting, why the macro guys love it? It's built into it. It's like, really? It's actually built in. So it's tradable and
34:36 Speaker 01 predictable and understandable. Does it mean we get a cycle the next time around? Does it the end of this? I don't know. But it kind of works like magic. And it's hilarious because it's a cycle that everybody knew was coming. It's like, oh, start investing on this day, and then take your money out on this day, and you'll make fifty X. I mean, it's ludicrous. I'm sure it will never work like this again. But kind of just laugh at the fact that it has worked so spectacularly.
35:03 Speaker 00 One of the things that's so fascinating about this space is that seems completely obvious to you, might not be so obvious to someone on the computer science side, and vice versa. Things that seem obvious to them in terms of the way that networks work, might not seem obvious to you. And that's what's so fascinating about this space, is that it's this weird, just kind of like, it's like the, it's like the Star Wars bar, right? You get all of these just people who are totally different backgrounds, and you come together, and these amazing things get spun up.
35:31 Speaker 01 Yeah. And you can see that people don't really understand what each other's talking about. But they kind of respect that they probably know something about something they don't know. That's what I love about this space. It's like we've all walked into this new world, but like, what are you doing? Oh, that sounds interesting. Well, I do this. And the other person goes, oh, that's interesting. I have no idea what that is. But we're all here together. What do you fancy doing? Drink? I mean, that's what the crypto world is. It's brilliant. Brilliant.
35:58 Speaker 00 Yeah. And in many cases, brilliant people on both sides of the conversation.
36:01 Speaker 01 I can't believe what's going on to me. I mean, like, I'm a music fanatic. I end up, and I'm not going to reveal any names, but I'm now having conversations with some of the biggest artists in the world and their management. Because I spoke about NFTs, about the music industry, and now everybody wants to speak to me about it.
36:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
36:22 Speaker 01 Because I'm now suddenly an expert. It's hilarious. And I love it. The world has become one degree of separation from literally anybody in this thing. Because every single person I speak to is like, okay, this is a game changer. Who do I need to speak to?
36:34 Speaker 00 Right.
36:35 Speaker 01 Because I don't know. I've turned up in this new world. I don't know where to go. I don't know who to talk to. I don't know what anybody does. Can you help me? And everybody's doing the same. It's amazing. It's amazing.
36:44 Speaker 00 Yeah. Bankers, bass players, and celebrity reality television stars hanging out in the same virtual space. It's pretty cool.
36:50 Speaker 01 And I've spoken to all of those this week.
36:54 Speaker 01 And billionaires and students. All this week.
36:58 Speaker 00 Just a week, a week in the life.
37:00 Speaker 01 A week. Maybe even last two days.
37:04 Speaker 00 Here's a question from Dirk that I wish I was smart enough to answer. In what ways will AI and crypto converge?
37:16 Speaker 01 I don't know.
37:18 Speaker 01 But of course they will.
37:19 Speaker 00 Right.
37:21 Speaker 01 Because when you've got a system that learns things, and you've got a network of money, it is obvious that those two are going to go together. Now, whether that's trading strategies, of which AI is standardly employed in many.
37:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
37:36 Speaker 01 Or whether it's behavioral strategies.
37:41 Speaker 01 Who the hell knows? But somebody will figure it out. There'll be some guy at Stanford or MIT now going, no, obviously, this is what you do. We're building a platform to do this. I don't know.
37:51 Speaker 00 Yeah. Well, it's already converged on the trading side, certainly. But I think to your point, you know, the two things I would say is, one, it's a certainty that it's going to happen. And number two, it's going to happen in unpredictable ways. And that's what's so fascinating about the space.
38:03 Speaker 01 And it's probably going to happen in the metaverse.
38:05 Speaker 00 It's probably going to happen in the metaverse.
38:08 Speaker 01 And again, I urge people, I've said it before, crypto voxels and some of these other metaverses, I think you'll be surprised how advanced they are. How many buildings are up? How many experiences are going on? Parties are going on? People you can talk to? You're walking around the streets, meeting people. It's kind of weird. And right now, it all is novel, but my guess is it won't be very novel in 10 years. It's like when we first saw webpages, they were like, wow, this is interesting. And they were a bit crappy, didn't quite work. And now we're using a browser to walk into a metaverse that connects to another metaverse.
38:48 Speaker 00 And by the way, the people who were building those webpages in the 90s, while the rest of us were maybe not as engaged as we should have been, were saying, this is the future you don't understand.
38:57 Speaker 01 What does piss me off that I think this space is going to sell is Epic Games. Epic Games, you know, Pierce Kicks told us about Epic Games. They're one of the big players. They've just raised another billion dollars and none of us are going to get a look in. And it's going to go public like Coinbase did. And by the time Epic Games goes public, it'll be like a quarter of a trillion dollar company. And we will not participate. And that is not right, that it accretes to VCs who only can run money for accredited investors and larger pools of capital. This has to change.
39:38 Speaker 01 It's not fair that we can't participate, but this is where crypto is becoming more interesting because you can participate. And this should not happen. I'm sorry, but whatever you think the securities laws are doing, you are making the rich richer and the poor poorer for not being able to participate in stuff like this. You know, we don't get a look in. And what the VCs have been doing has been going public later.
40:04 Speaker 01 So they've been going public later so the public buy Coinbase at 110 billion dollars. Now, could Coinbase be worth half a trillion dollars in a year's time or 10 years' time? Sure. But somebody's extracted zero to 110 billion out of this. And that is not right. And, you know, when I look at, you know, stuff like FTX and even Binance, there are ways of participating. They're not pure equity. They're not straight. I understand that Binance, you know, basically forked Ethereum, did stuff, but there's, but you're participating in the ecosystem. And there needs to be more ways for people to do that because you cannot do that. You cannot extract 110 billion of value before you give it to the public. That's criminal.
40:49 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, and to precisely your point, companies were going, would go public far earlier. And now that there are these vast pools of VC capital out there, they don't. And so it's something that there's probably going to be a technological component, which is going to involve almost certainly tokens. And there's probably going to be some legal and regulatory reform as well.
41:05 Speaker 01 I mean, guess why Andreessen Horowitz are all in on this, on tokens? They changed the structure of the firm around this. They know it too. The VC model is going to implode very fast because of what's about to happen. Again, it's not this cycle, but it's coming. And there will be no reason to have VCs, who basically are the networkers between capital and businesses, when you have public markets for it, and it's called crypto market.
41:38 Speaker 00 Yeah, very well said. Here's one that comes to us from Paul. As NFTs are enabling a new way for content owners to monetize content, are we going to see a repricing of firms who own a lot of content? And this is an interesting one. An example would be AT&T, which owns WarnerMedia. I suspect Paul knows that you were a little bit bearish on AT&T.
41:59 Speaker 01 Well, interestingly enough, they may or may not have reached out to me to talk about NFTs, as have several big media companies, because I think everybody is realizing that there is a back catalog. But again, just because you've got a back catalog and you've got an NFT, doesn't change the value proposition. Right? Because you can just sell it on a website. It doesn't change the value proposition. What changed the value proposition is if you create scarcity. So if you were to restrict Jungle Book to only 1,000 people, how much is Jungle Book worth to you?
42:41 Speaker 01 It might be worth a lot of money to somebody, you know? So people are thinking this is a way that we can just monetize our back catalog. You can do that anyway. So I'm not sure. I'm not sure. I think people are thinking of NFTs wrong.
43:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, these are such great questions, Rob. Obviously, people who-
43:03 Speaker 01 Time Warner packaged all of the rights to their back catalog, turned it into an NFT to monetize it and participate in that. Then that'll be interesting. But single pieces of content, I don't think it's going to move the dial.
43:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's such great questions. You know, and obviously, people who are really listening to the Real Vision content, thinking it through and framing their own questions based on the the context and the discussions that we're having on Real Vision Crypto and on Real Vision.
43:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, also, I mean, brilliantly, there was a, I haven't watched the whole one yet, but a bunch of guys on the exchange, which is, you know, where people get together and create the Hive Mind. I mean, three people that interviewed, had a three-way chat about NFTs of which, you know, there's real experts in that space. I don't know if you saw that today that came out. Again, fantastic content, nothing to do with Real Vision, but in our world, a brilliant stuff. And Weston relentlessly drives engagement in the exchange. I think his new Hive Mind is out this week, which is a great publication. So if you haven't been to the exchange, check it out. Always something interesting going on. Lot of questions being answered.
44:21 Speaker 01 It's the place to go to get the kind of questions you're answering me today. You get a whole Hive Mind community to answer for you, or you can help answer questions that other people are asking.
44:30 Speaker 00 Yeah, sure is. By the way, I sat down with Weston and did a conversation with someone from Israel involved in the Israeli tech scene to talk about the startup nation phenomenon in Israel from an Israeli tech culture perspective. Really fascinating, something that you've probably never heard before on the exchange now. And then, to cap it, Weston and I did a 20-minute conversation on top of that, where he compared Japan and some of the challenges that Japan has had over the last 30 years to the successes that Israel has had with their startup nation philosophy. That's content you're just not going to see anywhere else.
45:03 Speaker 01 No, it's great. I love it. Love all that stuff. And there's always something going on, so it's really enjoyable.
45:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, so talking of great questions, Rob, I've got to ask you. It looks like we're starting to run overtime here. I know we're probably going to have to wrap it up soon. Anything else that you wanted to discuss that we haven't hit on yet?
45:21 Speaker 01 No, I think one of the things that, you know-
45:25 Speaker 01 I'm thinking about some of these broader opportunities and again, I've now brought, this is the third video I've brought to Real Vision about the carbon futures market in Europe. And what I'm trying to do by bringing three videos is say, listen, guys, this is a really good opportunity. Not only is it good to make money because it's structured to go up in price, but it also does good for the world as well by reducing carbon and changing stuff. And I brought the leading team at Citibank, then the leading trader in the world in it,
46:05 Speaker 01 Pierre-André, and then this week I did a live Q and A with the leading analyst, the thought leader they all look up to, Lawson, in the space yesterday. So when you see something like that, I'm trying to introduce a narrative that I think that you really should focus on. And again, there's ways of trading it like KRBN, which isn't perfect. There's, I think it's GRN in Europe, and then there's the MODEX futures, the actual EU ETS futures. So what is going on is there is an adoption effect of EV that is going on globally that
46:46 Speaker 01 is going to accelerate over the next nine years as we go into some of these Paris Accord agreements and the EU mandates to 2030. So EV is going to be a big story.
47:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, boy, I'm so glad you asked that because that was a question that Daniel had asked. That was in the hopper that we didn't get a chance to get to. So I'm glad we covered that.
47:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a really important thing. It's a great trade. I think it's a stunning risk reward. So have a look at it.
47:13 Speaker 00 Well, we're gonna let people go so that they can get home and hang out with their families, not gonna keep them on a Friday night.
47:17 Speaker 01 Absolutely. It's getting soon to wine time. So it's fair, I still got my mum over, so I'm going to cook for her tonight.
47:26 Speaker 00 Oh, very nice. Impressive. I didn't know you could cook, Ralph.
47:29 Speaker 01 Of course. Really? It's a creative pursuit, so therefore I love cooking.
47:35 Speaker 00 But of course.
47:38 Speaker 01 Doesn't every man?
47:39 Speaker 00 No. My refrigerator is completely empty. There's like a pint of Gatorade in the door and it's completely empty. Other than that, I could use it to store finance books.
47:53 Speaker 00 Raul, have a great weekend. Have a great weekend, everyone. Thanks for watching.
47:56 Speaker 01 I'm just thinking, what kind of person you are. And I'm not sure I want to go there.
48:03 Speaker 00 We'll see when I come out of hibernation. I'm not sure I remember.
48:06 Speaker 01 I'm just worried there's like dead cats in your fridge or something. Who knows?
48:10 Speaker 00 No, it's immaculate. It's just empty.
48:14 Speaker 00 Completely empty. You know, my mother came to visit me once at college and she was looking to go and grab a glass or something to get water out of the sink. And she opened up one of my kitchen cabinets and like a cascade of books fell on her.
48:29 Speaker 01 Are you, you haven't seen them. Have you seen the series Humans?
48:34 Speaker 00 I have not.
48:35 Speaker 01 It's fantastic. It's basically.
48:40 Speaker 01 It's basically the, the, the story of the singularity, essentially, or moving towards it. And the, the humanoid called synths. One of the things you can tell about a synth is they don't eat.
48:54 Speaker 01 So maybe you are a robot and maybe you are a synth. Maybe you're one of these beings that has been created that now doesn't eat. Hence the empty fridge, because that's what you'd notice in a synth. You'd open their fridge. Your cupboard books come out. That would be a thing to do.
49:11 Speaker 00 It sounds like a perfect conversation for the exchange.
49:14 Speaker 01 It's a good, it's a really good series as well. Actually, it makes you really think about it. It's well done. First one starts off a bit like not sure. And then by the time you get through humans, you're okay, that was really interesting. Explores every avenue of the moralities, the thoughts, how society acts, what it means about this whole concept. It's great.
49:30 Speaker 00 Yeah. So Raul, you've had so much to say this week. I want to give you the last word. What would you leave us with?
49:38 Speaker 01 No, I'm not going to say it.
49:42 Speaker 01 I'm not even going to mention buying Bitcoin. So I'm just saying, have a great weekend, everyone.
49:46 Speaker 00 Have a great weekend, everyone. Thanks for watching.
Previous Portfolio Construction: Beyond Bitcoin and Ethereum ( w/ Jeff Dorman, Joey Krug, Raoul Pal and Ari Paul ) Next Uranium: "The Most Asymmetric Trade I've Seen In My Life" (w/ Lyn Alden and Marcelo Lopez) Page updated October 29, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated