Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing Are Commodities Ready to Boom or Bust? About this episode Maggie Lake and Rick Rule discuss what’s driving the recent price action in precious metals before reviewing the portfolios of Real Vision members. This episode is sponsored by KraneShares’s KRBN ETF, the first, largest and most liquid carbon ETF. Please read the prospectus before investing at https://rvtv.io/krbn. Investing involves risk. Principal loss is possible. KRBN is distributed by SEI Investment Distribution Company (SIDCO). Disclaimer: Carefully consider the Funds’ investment objectives, risk factors, charges and expenses before investing. This and additional information can be found in the Funds' full and summary prospectus, which may be obtained by visiting www.kraneshares.com. Read the prospectus carefully before investing. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hey everyone. Today's Real Vision Daily Briefing is sponsored by Crane Shares. Learn about their K R B N E T F at cringshares.com/krbn. Now to the top analysis of today's markets.
0:23 Speaker 00 Commodities boom or bust? Hi everyone. Welcome to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. With me today is commodity investing legend Rick Ruhl. Hi Rick, it's great to see you.
0:32 Speaker 01 Maggie, thank you so much for having me back. I enjoy these conversations.
0:35 Speaker 00 Yeah, so do we, and we're lucky to have you. So it's a great time because we are getting a lot of questions about energy. A lot of people were bullish on it, and then a lot of people are looking at their holdings and thinking, what's going on? You know, there's so much sort of confusion and chop in the macro picture, which is why we kind of started with that question at the top. But broadly, how are you feeling about what's going on in the commodity complex and prices? You know, where do you think we're at?
1:06 Speaker 01 Mixed, to be honest with you. I don't think there's any doubt across a broad range of industrial commodities that absent a recession or depression, note I said absent a recession or depression, that we're going to have reduced commodity supplies five years from now, and hence a rise in prices. You can have reduced supplies if you have reduced demand due to recession and have no impact on price. So assuming that we don't have a fairly significant recession or depression, five years out, a broad range of industrial commodities will be in short supply, and the prices will go up. That short supply is due to very simple factors. There's more of us on earth.
1:53 Speaker 01 And all of us would like higher material living standards, but as a society, we've under invested in productive capacities around natural resources for 30 years, and those chickens are coming home to roost.
2:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:05 Speaker 01 We can talk about precious metals separately, but I would suspect that the wind too, at least in the intermediate longer term, is in the sails of precious metals for reasons that we can discuss.
2:17 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:17 Speaker 01 So I feel good about the conflict.
2:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, let's separate them out a little bit because you make a good point. And when I asked that, it was loaded because commodities is such a big space. So, but let's stick on the, um, on, on the first part, which I think is kind of connected to energy.
2:31 Speaker 01 Right.
2:31 Speaker 00 Uh, when you're, when you're talking about that sort of supply situation. So Andreas and David Rosenberg had a very interesting conversation yesterday as part of our festival of learning. They were talking about the economy and what we can expect from growth. Let's have a listen to a clip of that and then we'll talk on the other side.
2:50 Speaker 02 The Fed's telling you that they're expecting, the Fed isn't possibly telling you that they're expecting three quarters of negative growth, Q2, Q3, Q4. All this is saying that they're saying, they've been saying all along, we are prepared to tolerate. In fact, it's desirable to have a mild recession to kill the greater evil of inflation. Um, and to which I say to the Fed, we'll be careful what you wish for. Uh, but one thing I do know is that in recessions and the Fed cuts rates and they might be late. Uh, you know, he compares himself to Paul Volcker at every opportunity. You know, Paul Volcker did raise rates into the 1981, 82 recession. Uh, and then when he saw the whites of the eyes of the recession,
3:35 Speaker 02 he saw inflation come crashing down. He saw, uh, the resource gap and the labor market widen out. Uh, the greatest inflation dragon slayer of all time, Paul Volcker became the greatest interest rate dragon slayer of all time. Uh, and remember he raised rates in the early stages of that recession, just like the Fed's doing right now. Um, although I think for the time being, they're going to be on hold. In fact, I think they're done for the cycle, but the damage has already been done. Uh, the recession, you know, uh, we could be just quibbling over the timing.
4:08 Speaker 00 And you can catch that full interview with Rosie and all of the sessions from the Festival of Learning on our website. It was a fantastic discussion. It ranged across macro, psychology, and trading strategies. Great stuff. If you're not already a member, hit the QR code and get your free child. Really fantastic conversation. So Rick, when we think about that, I mean, certainly Rosie's been calling for recession for a long time, but a lot of people are concerned about the growth side. How do we balance the tension between demand, which seems front and center right now, and the supply situation that you just described?
4:40 Speaker 01 I think you assume, first of all, that you're never going to get it right.
4:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:45 Speaker 01 Life is not about certainties. It's about a range of probabilities. And I don't think in your own portfolio that preparation for the two is mutually exclusive. I wouldn't pretend to be an economist, particularly one of Rosenberg's stature. I've been a fan of his for many years. I'm more of an investor or a speculator. And in my earlier life, I would be described as a used money salesman. So what I would suggest is that there isn't the certainty that he hopes for. The idea, as an example, that you would take a politician at his or her word, seems odd to me. I think the way that the world sits now, that what they say is true, that
5:24 Speaker 01 they are willing to take a bit of an economic slowdown in order to tame inflation. But to the extent that they got pushback from major donors, or large voting constituencies, I believe they could and would turn on a dime. I also am not certain to the extent to which they can continue to raise interest rates, at least in a political context. I believe it's something that they should do. But suggesting that they will do what they should do, I think...
6:02 Speaker 01 Represents some form of naivete. You will look as a consequence of the banking problems about the fact that we have mismatch between mark to market in bank obligations that exceed the book equity of 100 and something banks in the United States.
6:23 Speaker 01 That only gets worse if interest rates are allowed to rise, although letting interest rates rise is the right thing to do. Is the Fed actually willing to do that? I'm not saying they're not, I'm just saying that the jury is out. From my own point of view, I need to play a range of probabilities. I need to play things like oil and gas, which I know will do well over five years. And I need to play precious metals, which will do well if the Fed loses its nerve.
6:52 Speaker 00 Yeah. You bring up a great point, and we've been discussing that a lot, you know, whether the Fed is backed into a corner. Anyone who hasn't checked out my chat with Luke Gromon, I encourage you to. Rouse has been talking about this a lot as well. So it sounds like you're aware of the probabilities, but you're really keeping your eye focused on that longer term structural story around supply shortages.
7:19 Speaker 01 Yes, I am. I'm doing that. I'm paying attention to that, which I think is inevitable, rather perhaps imminent. The other thing that I've learned in my own life is I make more money on the micro than the macro. Which is to say, even if the longer narrative is true, which I suspect it is, what matters most is how you allocate capital, you know, the companies that you buy. And I've learned a third thing, which is to say, I make more money investing in natural resources when the specific subsectors are out of favor than when they are in favor. The truth is that ours is a very cyclical business. And in natural resources, if you aren't a contrarian, you are very likely to become a victim.
8:04 Speaker 00 I like that. Well, you know a thing or two about being a contrarian, I know that. Do you see this, you know, we'll get a little bit more specific with this, but do you see this pullback as an opportunity then?
8:16 Speaker 01 Well, certainly in energy, I see it as a very large opportunity. You know, markets work. They're messy. Everybody wants to be a contrarian when it's popular, but that sort of defeats defeats the purpose. Uh, you know, during the COVID thing, when the oil price fell to $20, well, to zero briefly, nobody wanted to own oil, even though the rationale for owning oil was as simple as believing your car was going to start in five years. If the oil price didn't go back to 60, you wouldn't have gasoline. When that was obvious, nobody wanted to own it. When the price went to 100, the price didn't have to go higher. Uh, arguably it had to go lower. Everybody wanted to own oil.
8:57 Speaker 01 We have a situation now where in particular, the US domestic natural gas price has fallen from $12 a million BTU below $4 per million BTU. That makes it from the point of view of a foreign buyer substantially more attractive than it was before, and yet people hate it. Sometimes, I guess at age 70, they just make my life too easy.
9:19 Speaker 00 So everyone's late. They're late to it.
9:23 Speaker 01 Or early.
9:24 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:24 Speaker 01 Uh, you know, it depends on how you look.
9:28 Speaker 01 We can make the case in this interview that most of this market is under invested in natural resources. Uh, that might not be true for your listeners, but most of the market is under invested in natural resources. And in that case, they are early. For those people who loved oil at $100 and are having trouble with unrequited love at $70, all I can tell them is that, as an example, the oil industry on a global basis is under investing in sustaining capital by a billion dollars a day. That under investment means that assuming that demand even holds steady, the oil prices rise. It's as simple as that. It's a capital intensive business. If you don't apply the capital, you don't have a business.
10:12 Speaker 01 It really, truly is as simple as finding oil companies that are bucking the trend and making sustaining capital investments so that they maintain the free cash flows that they're enjoying today and then letting time do its work for you.
10:27 Speaker 00 Interesting. Hey, everyone, we're going to take a quick break right now to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
10:41 Speaker 00 So you mentioned precious metals as well. What are your thoughts around that space? We talked a lot about gold when you were last on.
10:50 Speaker 01 If the big thinkers of the world,
10:55 Speaker 01 the ones that Rosie describes, actually are successful in bringing down the rate of inflation while keeping nominal interest rates a little higher than they were, specifically if they are able to generate a real yield, that is to say, a savings yield that's ahead of the rage of inflation, they're going to clobber the gold price. I think the probability of that hovers somewhere around zero.
11:24 Speaker 01 If you look at the arithmetic around them being able to accomplish that, and I say arithmetic because the narrative is abundant.
11:33 Speaker 01 We have on-balance-sheet obligations in this country exceeding $32 trillion. We have net present value of off-balance-sheet obligations around $100 trillion. We salvage this debt problem, solve the debt problem with a budget that's in deficit $2 trillion a year. If you believe that this government is going to balance the budget and begin to pay down the debt, then probably you don't want to own gold. Let's look at some more arithmetic. Gold does well when people are concerned about the efficacy of savings instruments. Premier savings instrument in the world, premier security in the world is the US 10-Year Treasury. Let's look at the math.
12:17 Speaker 01 They pay you 375 basis points in a currency that they say is deteriorating in value at 7% compounded. In other words, the US government solemnly swears that they're going to reduce your spending power by 3% a year compounded for 10 years. Jim Grant calls that return free risk. If you believe that we're going to have a positive real interest rate, which is to say, if you believe that the rate of inflation is going to fall below the US 10-Year Treasury rate, you shouldn't own gold. If you're a skeptic and you don't take the politicians at their word, perhaps you should consider owning gold.
13:02 Speaker 01 Final piece of math, Maggie, and this one, well, this one's really compelling, I think. The market share of gold in the United States as a savings and investment asset is less than one half of 1%. The four decade mean is 2%. If negative real interest rates, debts and deficits, bond disintermediation, all the wins in gold sales come to pass, as I believe they will. I'm not trying to say that gold is going to win the war against the US dollar or win the war against the US Treasury. I just think that demand is going to return to the four decade mean. If that happens, demand for precious metals and precious metals related assets quadruples.
13:43 Speaker 00 Which is huge. I know people, whenever we talk about gold, we've discussed this. People are perennially disappointed, right? It's just like the narrative, the case is there, the arguments are there, and then it just never happens. Someone asking possible level 2,500 for gold on the high side. I mean, do you have a target or are you so long term that you're just betting it's going to go up?
14:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm too old for that, frankly. I've had a lot of targets over time and I've, there's so many variables that go into it. The trying to know a specific target is the same as trying to know the unknowable, which is really a waste of time. Here's what I can say. Expectations for gold were set in the 1970s, when the price ran from $35 an ounce to $850 an ounce. You know, I gotta say, I don't see a 25-bagger in gold. I think those expectations are stupid. For me, I segregate between owning gold, which to me is an insurance asset, and gold stocks, which are investments. With gold as an insurance asset, when I look back to the year 2000, I've been suited extremely well.
14:54 Speaker 01 Gold has protected my purchasing power. It's protected my purchasing power as well or better than any other asset class in my or anybody else's portfolio for 20 years. People who own gold as an insurance policy have not been disappointed, provided that they're sober.
15:14 Speaker 00 Which we can't promise on a Friday afternoon.
15:16 Speaker 01 That's right. That's right. I can only promise for right now. With regards to gold stocks as an investment class, they have disappointed me. The valuations of gold stocks, if you value them on a net present value basis relative to enterprise value are as inexpensive as I have seen them in 45 years. So I have been disappointed in the gold equities as an asset class. But I note that as an investor or a speculator, if there is an asset class that I'm attracted to, and the price goes down, it became more rather than less attractive from an arithmetic point of view. So I'm buying the gold stocks.
16:01 Speaker 00 Just a quick moment to remind you, today's Real Vision Daily Briefing is sponsored by Crane Shares. Learn about their K R B N E T F at craneshares.com/krbn. Now, back to today's analysis. So you're buying the miners? Is that right? Because we've gotten a lot of questions about, okay, if I want to have more exposure to gold, and we're going to jump into some more specific portfolio questions a little bit later in the show. So if you have some, jump in. Remember, this is Extended Friday, so hopefully it is happy hour wherever you are sitting. But we will certainly get in a little deeper into that, those sort of
16:46 Speaker 00 questions. But we've had broadly, a lot of questions about if I want to increase my exposure to gold, do I buy the physical commodity? Or do I buy the miners? And why are we seeing a different, different, you know, performance?
17:00 Speaker 01 That has less to do with the asset class than it does to do with the individual. What are you trying to cause to occur? What timeframes are you operating under? How much risk are you willing to endure? It's difficult for me to understand why anybody who has savings, who wants to maintain their purchasing power, would not own physical gold. Understand that it's an insurance asset. So perversely, you own it and then you hope it doesn't have a huge payout. Think about your life insurance. You don't get paid till you die. Are you eager to die so you can collect on the insurance policy? I don't reckon. Auto insurance, to make pay, you gotta have a wreck. Home insurance, your house has to burn down. That's why you own gold. You own gold so that you will do okay if something bad happens.
17:45 Speaker 01 Recognize the asset then for what it is.
17:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
17:49 Speaker 01 You own the senior gold stocks, the big producers. As an investor, you own them for market beta. You own them because you think that the companies that you buy will outperform other companies in the sector. And you think that the sector will outperform other asset categories. You own the juniors and the exploration companies as a speculator. You are looking to take much more risk, accept much more volatility, and you're hoping for alpha against the gold mining industry as a whole. For myself, I play the waterfront. I own gold because I'm interested in maintaining the purchasing power of my savings. I own the gold stocks because I understand them.
18:30 Speaker 01 I'm an investor and I think they will deliver substantial beta relative to the broad market. And they'll do it for several years to come. I own the speculations too, because I know enough about the sector and I'm disciplined enough as a human being that I can outcompete most of my competitors in a speculative arena. People who are not tolerant of volatility and people who aren't willing to do the work should not get involved in the juniors. They should leave it to people like me.
19:04 Speaker 00 Professionals, veterans. By the way, if you want to hear a little bit more about, I'm laughing as Rick said, I have tolerance. If you're tolerant for risk and being a contrarian, if you want to hear more about some of the specifics around that, go check out the podcast we did, My Life in Four Trades. Rick was on with me. It's some great stories about his past risk-taking failures.
19:29 Speaker 00 Triumphs, but it's it's pretty epic stuff, which explains why I introduced him as a commodity legend. And those who who know that market know that, you know, really interesting comment here. Dino's great, great comment in the chat. It depends on how you own gold. Hard to believe digital ownership is really 100% correlated with real gold. At first I was thinking he was talking about digital assets, but Dino, correct me if I'm not interpreting this right. But I think he's talking about, you know, what you trade and very few people get physical delivery of gold, right? So it's, there's a, there's an aspect of it that's, that's just in the markets and digital or paper, however you want to call it. Is that something we need to be worried about, Rick? I mean, do you think that there is a?
20:12 Speaker 01 I think it can be in several regards. There are several paper surrogates for gold that are represented but gram by gram with gold in physical storage that is not hypothecated. It's not a delivery receipt. It's not a promise to pay, it's pay, it's payment. Commercial, I'm the largest shareholder of Sprot. The Sprot Physical Precious Metals Trusts have their gold in the Royal Canadian Mint. The securities provided by NATO. They don't loan their gold to anybody. They only take physical gold and silver. They don't take deposit receipts. The physical ETFs, which I personally regard as pretty good products, are less stringent with regard to their inventory. They will take delivery receipts.
20:57 Speaker 01 They will take deposit receipts, which until they receive the physical gold, makes them semi-secured creditors of third parties, which scares me. The real problems come down to people buying gold from bullion dealers in unsegregated storage. What they really are is the unsecured creditor of the bullion dealer. So they better understand the bullion dealer pretty well. And of course, the fourth level is the new crypto gold, where various people are offering up tokens or other forms of really credit devices that are denominated in gold rather than backed in gold. In that sense, caveat emptor.
21:43 Speaker 01 Get to know your issuer very, very, very well. A promise to pay gold is not the same as gold.
21:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, excellent, excellent point and great question. We're going to take another quick break to hear a word from our partners. We'll be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
22:07 Speaker 00 So one, one issue, another issue that came up, and then we'll get to some questions is, but this is really important, that I think it came up with Michael Cow. We were talking about it and he's like, I would like gold, but I always have a hard time with it because at the end of the day, for the very reasons you think that you would want to have it as insurance, I don't know if central banks will be net buyers or net sellers of gold. And that, that just, that worries me. I can't reconcile that. What are your thoughts on that?
22:37 Speaker 01 Well, as a libertarian, or rather as an anarcho-capitalist, I'm very sad that the central banks bought gold because I think they'll make a lot of money. And I think that anything that causes central banks to make a lot of money is contrary to the interests of humankind. Getting my political point of view out of the way, I don't think that the future of gold will be determined by central banks. I think the future of the gold price will be determined by individual savers. The savers who have a choice between having some of their savings in an asset class, which has protected them against inflation for a millennia,
23:18 Speaker 01 or somebody who chooses to put their, their money in a US 10-year treasury, getting paid 3.75% in a currency that's depreciating by 7%. The arithmetic to me is completely clear. And the future of gold, from my point of view, does not rely on central banks. I think in the very near term, to me, I think near term is three years, four years. In the near term, I think you're going to see more central bank buying of gold. For two reasons, central banks outside the United States are tired of the imposition of American values in an extraterritorial sense. They're sick of the weaponization of the dollar, they're sick of the weaponization of SWIFT.
24:03 Speaker 01 And foreign governments have a difficult time with that arithmetic. Why would you store your wealth in a US Treasury when they guarantee that your purchasing power is reduced? At the same time that they see themselves as encouraging a bully who's acting in ways that is antithetical to their interest. So the question, I think, around central banks has a nuanced answer. In the near term, the central banks are going to be useful because they have to increase their gold holdings as a consequence of the weaponization of the US dollar and the horrible arithmetic around US long bonds. In the longer term, it isn't the central banks that will determine the price of gold.
24:47 Speaker 01 It will be the $760 trillion in wealth held by individuals around the world.
24:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, great answer. And Scott and Yo-Yo, I think that I asked it before I saw your question, so I think that addressed it. Fantastic. You guys are on fire today. Who said everyone's tired on Friday? You have so much energy with these great questions. So Charles asking,
25:12 Speaker 00 Rick, do you know what the total value of the gold price short position is globally? What would happen if paper gold derivatives were covered all at once? So I don't know, I mean, you may, knowing you, you may know the answer to that, but broadly, what does that setup look like and is that something that you're worried about?
25:33 Speaker 01 I was gonna say, the questioner has an inflated sense of my knowledge. I do not know the aggregate value of the short position against gold and silver worldwide. I can tell you this, that the gold and silver futures markets are heavily leveraged. It is not uncommon to see futures trade on a daily basis 100 times.
25:59 Speaker 01 The value of the gold and silver in vaults for physical delivery against those trades. Now, the vast majority of those trades don't settle for metal. You know, they settle for cash sometime before expiry. And it's also true that the major commodities and futures exchanges have put in place fail-safe measures, which is to say cash settlements. If you had a real short squeeze, what I suspect would happen is that the exchanges would not require physical settlement, but rather would require cash settlement. I don't think that matters. I don't think that the future of gold and silver investing and speculating, I don't
26:42 Speaker 01 think that the efficaciousness of that trade has to do with a short squeeze. I think if we had a circumstance that caused the threat of a short squeeze, that you would already be happy with the performance of your gold and silver. For those people who believe that there's going to be a short squeeze and that the people who are short gold aren't going to be able to cover, understand that according to the rules of the exchange, they don't have to cover. They can cash settle.
27:12 Speaker 00 Another question, again, I mean, this is, you guys are on fire. Amit asking, what do you think of CBDC-based gold?
27:22 Speaker 01 I hate it.
27:24 Speaker 00 How do we know Rick was going to say that?
27:26 Speaker 01 Central bank digital currency. Giving the government the ability to decide what sort of citizen you are and what you ought to do with your money. What could possibly go wrong with that?
27:45 Speaker 01 They say that is an advantage, that they can actually cancel your currency.
27:53 Speaker 01 Maggie, let's say that, I don't know, some group concerned with safe driving got in control of the White House and you got three speeding tickets. Not an unlikely event. Uh, if someone in a fit of peak because of the way you drove, decided to cancel 50% of your savings, how would you feel about that? Would you feel good about that? Uh, of all of the cockamamie dangerous ideas I've ever seen in my life, central bank digital currencies comes out very, very, very high. Irrespective of your political beliefs, would you like Trump in charge of your savings?
28:36 Speaker 01 Would you like Biden in charge of your savings? Would you like Xi in charge of your savings? How about Stalin? Mao? Hitler? Um, mercifully? No, I'll leave it alone. That's too inflammatory. Suffice it to say.
28:55 Speaker 00 I could see Rick like thinking about that.
28:58 Speaker 01 I don't like that idea at all.
29:01 Speaker 00 Well, I'm glad you have an opinion about it. We, yeah, I had a feeling that was going to elicit a strong one. Uh, so listen, I just want to give everyone a heads up and I'm going to continue with the questions. As you know, Extended Friday, we're going to flip over to the platform. I don't want to hear anybody crying about, uh, you know, the cutoff. Um, you're always welcome to come with us. QR code, free trial. So much great stuff to take advantage of and we got to keep the lights on. So, you know, you understand the way this works, but we hope you come with us. If you don't, have a great weekend. We're not going to go just yet, but when that happens, but do take advantage of it. Not only do we just have that huge festival of learning, there's just so much good stuff. And now is the time we heard from everyone, including Rick,
29:44 Speaker 00 that you really have to pay attention to what's happening with your portfolio. It's not just press a button and leave it alone for two years when we're in that ultra low interest rate environment. It's getting trickier. Um, and we're trying to help in any way we can. So come on and come on our learning tribe community, if you will. Thanks for joining us, everyone. Today's Real Vision Daily Briefing is sponsored by Crane Shares. Learn about their K R B N E T F at craneshares.com/krbn.
30:14 Speaker 03 What's up, revolutionaries? Thanks for tuning in to the Real Vision Daily Briefing. For more content like this, head over to realvision.com and get unfiltered access to the very best, brightest and biggest names in finance.
Previous We're at a Big Macro Turning Point Next Your Exponential Age Page updated October 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated