Pod Insights Real Vision: Finance & Investing #1031 - Will Inflation Send Commodities Higher? with Doomberg | Energy, Semiconductors & China About this episode 🔥 Start your "The Exponentialist" trial for $1 https://rvtv.io/4b6OY4nDoomberg, pseudonymous author of the Doomberg Substack newsletter, joins Ash Bennington to discuss what recent inflation data means for the commodities sector, how geopolitical tensions in the Middle East impact energy markets, and China's plans to take over the semiconductor industry. Unlock the potential to showcase your brand to our global audience. Contact us at partnerships@realvision.com for advertising inquiries. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Picture yourself on a beach, retired early and enjoying financial freedom. If this is your dream, then now's the time to level up your investing game and Real Vision can help you. We arm you with the knowledge, the tools and the network to succeed on your financial journey on your own terms. Take control of your future and visit realvision.com/free. That's realvision.com/free.
0:37 Speaker 01 Will inflation send commodities higher? Welcome to Real Vision Daily Briefing. It's Tuesday, May 7, 2024. I'm Ash Bennington, joined today by Doomburg Head Writer of the Doomburg Substack. Welcome.
0:51 Speaker 02 Hey, Ash. Great to be here. I gotta say, crosses off a key item on my bucket list to be interviewed by Ash Bennington on Real Vision. I mean, who could ask for more?
1:00 Speaker 01 Do you worry? I feel exactly the same way. It's like, you know, longtime listener, first time caller. I've been watching on Real Vision and it's just a pleasure to have you here and to have this conversation with you today. Before we get into the weeds, I want to, since this is your first time having a conversation with me, let's start at the 50,000-foot level and talk a little bit about the way you currently see energy markets, big picture.
1:23 Speaker 02 You bet. So, we like to say the single most important thing a macro analyst should, should answer to themselves is, is the global market for primary energy well supplied or in short? And if it's long, that informs a certain set of views. And if the energy markets are short, supplies are tight, commodity prices are high, that informs a different set of views. And if we look across the primary energy spectrum today, we see coal trading between $125 and $150 a ton, which is relatively affordable, let's say, compared to historical averages. Natural gas in the U.S. is in the middle of a glut.
2:08 Speaker 02 You can't give it away in some parts of the U.S., which we'll probably talk about. And the one primary energy input that stands out when you correct for energy content, when you sort of normalize dollars per million BTU, is oil. And oil is trading at a relatively substantial premium to the other primary energy commodities. And one, two things you should ask yourself about that is, how can you estimate that premium? And what is the genesis of it? What is the source of it? So our preferred view to try to get a thumb-in-the-air estimate of the geopolitical risk premium in oil is to multiply landed natural gas prices,
2:53 Speaker 02 as quoted in dollars per million BTU by six, and compare that to WTI and Brent. And if we look today, natural gas landed in Europe or in Asia is about $10 a million BTU, which makes it roughly the equivalent of $60 a barrel oil. And we see WTI trading around 80, and Brent a little higher, which means some portion of that $20 to $25 difference is as a result of the, we think, the ongoing kinetic conflicts, both in Ukraine and in the Palestinian Gaza-Israel-Iran nexus. And in our view, if peace were to miraculously and spontaneously appear, we think oil could easily head south of 60 and below.
3:38 Speaker 02 Because we do believe, at the highest level, commodities are pretty well supplied. You have, you know, OPEC holding back a couple million barrels a day of production. Interesting to see how that discipline maintains itself as things progress. But by and large, there's plenty of natural gas in the world. There's plenty of coal in the world. In the physical markets, there seems to be more than enough oil to be had. And the only real standout metric that we see on the board today is this geopolitical risk premium in oil. And so we view the price of oil as a proxy for the market's assessment of risk of the war expanding. And that's our view today.
4:20 Speaker 01 So let's take that view and talk a little bit about how you express it in terms of positioning. WTI, I know, is something that folks here at Real Vision watch quite closely. I think most people have a rough idea of what that chart looks like, you know, heading down to essentially zero, I don't know, below zero during the depths of the pandemic in the spring of 2020, shooting up during the reopening in, I guess, May, June, July of 2022 to just shy, I believe, of 120 bucks a barrel, now trading on my screen, 78.45. Talk a little bit about how the thesis intersects with price and how you think about expressing.
4:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, so the sweet spot for oil, oil is not a freely traded commodity, right? I mean, we have like an overt cartel that has an expressed desire to help manage the price. It is highly inelastic, so a million barrels a day or 2 million barrels a day of supply swing can radically change the price, as we saw when it traded for minus $37 a barrel at the height of the COVID crisis because of basically running out of places to put the stuff, and traded up to $130 a barrel, I think Brent touched, at the apex of the initial outbreak of war in Ukraine as a result of Putin's invasion of that country. And so another example is President Biden released a million barrels a day, 1% of global daily
5:43 Speaker 02 demand for a period of six months, and he cut the price of oil in half. That gives you some indication of the sensitivity of the price of the commodity with respect to supply deficits for supply excesses. And so the sweet spot for OPEC is between 70 and 90 dollars a barrel today, which on an inflation-adjusted basis, back to like $1980 is $25 a barrel. I mean, oil is still incredibly cheap today for all the talk of peak cheap oil and all that nonsense. There's plenty of it, and it's dirt cheap, considering its utility for, you know, humanity. So 70 to 90 dollars a barrel is where OPEC would like to manage the price. Anything below that, and they begin to see budgetary stresses, and anything above that, and they begin to concern themselves with economic
6:28 Speaker 02 contraction and inflation-causing, you know, pullbacks and things like that. And so we're kind of in the middle of that sweet spot right now. I think when we saw The initial reports that Iran was lobbing a couple hundred missiles and drones into Israel, you saw oil spike. And then when Iran preemptively said, even before the missiles had landed, that this was the end of their conflict in their view, oil prices collapsed and gold prices collapsed and so on. And so the one thing that we need to keep an eye on as investors, whatever your views on on positioning, is Biden's extreme attention to the price of gasoline in the US. He's an old school politician. We personally interacted with his staff when he was a senator from Delaware, which we used to jokingly say, you know, Joe Biden,
7:11 Speaker 02 D comma DuPont, because he knows the commodity industry quite well. He's acutely aware of the price of gasoline at the pump and how that affects the future runway for politicians. There's talk just today that they might tap the SPR again, the Strategic Controlling Reserves, to try to manage oil prices down ahead of the election. And so when you look at the fact that oil is trading at a substantial premium to the other primary inputs and the president would like oil prices to go down, it sets up sort of a short term scenario where we view the risk to be on the downside. I will close by mentioning a new Substack author, Jack Johnston, who's a really great commodities trader, and I think he's retiring and now
7:55 Speaker 02 starting to write more broadly on Substack, had a really great note this morning, JJ745, I believe is the Substack handle, talking about how the risk of 60 seems more likely to him than the risk of 90 or 100.
8:08 Speaker 00 We're going to take a quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
8:18 Speaker 00 Do you share that view?
8:20 Speaker 02 I do. Yeah. Yeah. I think, look, if we if if we could broker a ceasefire in Israel.
8:27 Speaker 02 And you know, the Russians reached the the Dnieper River and and hostilities come to a close there. And we have some form of a North Korea, South Korea situation where the West claims that these borders haven't moved and Russia is just going to occupy the place and dare somebody to do something about it. I think we could see downside risk to the price of oil. And on top of that, look, when you have natural gas trading for as cheap as it is, and we should say, Henry Hub has since recovered off the lows, which we had thought might have been in at $1.50 per million BTU, Henry Hub. But just last week, it was a pipeline, Kinder Morgan Pipeline declared force majeure and the price of natural
9:08 Speaker 02 gas at the Waha Hub in the Permian Basin is minus $4 million BTU today on the screen as we're talking. That's a spot price, of course. But they're giving away natural gas in the beating heart of the US oil and gas and commodity infrastructure in Texas. And that is, eventually, people will just switch the engines. Like, they're not going to burn diesel with with WTI at $80 or 78 as it is today, when they can burn natural gas and do the same work at a fraction of the price. And so the markets will close that arbitrage over time. In a glut, arbitrages tend to close down. In a supply crisis, arbitrages
9:49 Speaker 02 tend to close up. And we have so much natural gas, especially in the US. And and the thing that people perhaps don't understand is that the production of oil and the production of natural gas are linked in the US. And so this geopolitical risk premium in oil is driving the glut in natural gas because it is co-produced, especially in the Permian, as an unwanted byproduct. And you can't give it away. The reason why they're paying people to take natural gas in the Permian is because they want to sell that oil for $80 a barrel because that's above their breakeven price or their, you know, their profit zone. And so, perversely, war will eventually be the undoing of that of that that energy arbitrage, when you correct the content.
10:34 Speaker 01 This is so fascinating for me, Duneberg, because I'm barely a tourist in this space where you are a permanent resident, but it's fascinating to me and it's really interesting. I want to talk about natural gas in just a minute, but I also want to ask you something about something because it's generally in the news for political reasons. You mentioned the SPR, the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. I am, again, just a visitor in this space, but I'm looking right now on the EIA website. This is the U.S. Energy Information Administration at the SPR Reserve stocks. And what I see here is a peak, it looks like around 2010, at just shy of 3/4 of a million barrels, staying relatively constant, rolling down in 2020 to maybe 630,000 barrels.
11:16 Speaker 01 And now we've cut that in half since President Biden has tapped that. What are the risks in doing so if we get below, say, 1/4 of a million barrels?
11:26 Speaker 02 So, need to correct you by 6 orders of magnitude. It was 3/4 of a billion barrels of oil, and now there's some 300 and change million barrels of oil.
11:39 Speaker 01 All right, it's expressed in thousands. This is how you know I'm a tourist.
11:43 Speaker 02 Well, actually Bloomberg has this crazy, they express it in thousand barrels, but then the chart is in millions. So it's 0.365 million thousands, and I don't know why they just don't say 365 million.
11:54 Speaker 01 I can't, Duneberg, I can't imagine why I would be confused.
11:58 Speaker 02 Exactly. But nonetheless, one of the things that people need to realize about the Strategic Petroleum Reserve is it was constructed as a consequence of the supply crisis as a result of the oil embargo of the 1970s, the Yankapul War. And back then, the main U.S. political establishment thinking was that Herbert's peak was right and the U.S. had reached peak oil production. It was already a major importer of crude and would forever be.
12:33 Speaker 02 And what has changed in the intervening period is the shale revolution. So we filled the strategic, we built and filled it when we needed it because we were net energy importers and by a wide margin, but the shale revolution has made the US a gig of power in energy. We produce 20% of the world's oil and petroleum products. We produce 30% plus of the world's natural gas. We're still the net exporter of coal. We have some 95 nuclear reactors operating with really great capacity factors. We have an abundance of food and fertilizer and the ports to export them. We are a superpower in energy today, unlike the world has ever seen. I believe, and I quote Lou Roman in this regard, that
13:14 Speaker 02 we've added two and a half Saudi Arabia's worth of BTUs since the advent of the shale revolution. And so the
13:22 Speaker 01 Is that now, is that total energy production capacity, including natural gas?
13:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, gas and oil, two and a half.
13:28 Speaker 01 That's not like a BTU normalized.
13:29 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. And then, by the way, we have a, unlike most petro-states, we have a relative, still, despite China's best efforts to hollow it out, we have a relatively robust manufacturing sector that can feed off of that natural gas and do quite well for themselves. You know, if you're a fertilizer maker in the US who gets to price your, your product on, in the global markets, you're pretty happy to have somebody pay you to take natural gas so that you can make your fertilizer. Whereas, you know, if your competitors are paying $10 a million BTU for landed LNG, then you're going to win in that market. You know, you're going to climb the cost curve quite well. So when the SPR was built, we needed it and we were short and now we're long. We're net exporters. We have more refining capacity than we need. We're net exporters of refined goods like gasoline and diesel.
14:13 Speaker 02 In parts of the country, we still have to import because of various insanities like the Jones Act, which doesn't allow us to like ship, you know, diesel from the Gulf Coast of Texas to New York because unless, you know, it's a US flagship and we don't have any such ships because we're not in the marine business anymore. So, but nonetheless.
14:35 Speaker 02 We have this this abundance of of of energy in the US and so it it it seems reckless. It is certainly political, like it's overtly political. So I can understand why people who might be Trump supporters think it's a dirty deal for Biden to empty the SPR ahead of the midterms to save a few house seats and now ahead of the presidential election, but he's going to do it. And on the pantheon of risks that the US is taking, that's relatively small compared to the fact that we've allowed, for example, China to hollow out our manufacturing sector, especially in the military supply chains. In fact, we in our doom zoom presentation for our pro tier this month, we we half jokingly called China the new arsenal of democracy because all democracies have outsourced their military supply chains to China and we just
15:20 Speaker 02 assume they'll keep giving us these critical goods when when when we go to war with them. It's insane. But I digress. The SPR will be emptied ahead of the election if Biden needs it. It will be overtly political and it'll work. It will swing a few percent of voters because people care about the price of gas.
15:36 Speaker 01 But interestingly, what I hear you saying is compared to the other risks that you see in the economy around energy, around supply chains and elsewhere, you believe that the new supply dynamics in the United States makes emptying the Strategic Petroleum Reserve, though it is in your view an overtly political act, far less dangerous than it might seem on the surface because of the productive capacity of the energy sector in the United States.
15:57 Speaker 02 Correct. I mean, again, if we were net oil importers and we were at the behest of the Saudis, it would be a different story. Now, look, if you're Europe, you're still in that situation. But, you know, Europe has got its own insane energy policies to deal with. The US is an energy giga power today. It does not. There is never been a country more powerful, more prolific from an energy perspective than the United States of America in 2024, period. And that has to be the first input into geopolitics, into economics. Well, things that like puzzles us. You know, we wrote a piece early this year called slick landing, where we predicted that it would be highly unlikely that the US would slip into a recession. And we tried to explain why we thought that was. We all know.
16:42 Speaker 02 That if oil goes to $150 a barrel, we're probably going to see recession. In fact, last time it peaked out in that range, we saw the great financial crisis of '08, '09. We also know that if oil spikes $150 or $200 or $300, we're going to see inflation. And we also know that Germany screwed up its energy policy and it is undergoing massive deindustrialization and struggling with a recession. Why would it not be then that the exact opposite of those things? We're swimming in cheap hydrocarbons. We can't give away natural gas. We produce more than enough of the oil that we need. We were net exporters of coal. We have the world's best nuclear and largest and best nuclear power fleet still until China laps us.
17:22 Speaker 02 Why wouldn't it be that that concoction would be something that might insulate us against a recessionary impulse, especially when you have Congress wastefully spending so much money and running these large deficits and you have an overtly political Fed that has an eye on the election and everybody in Washington DC wants to keep the orange man out of the White House? Like, how is this a recipe that's going to bake a recession cake? I don't see it. We don't see it. We made the call. We'll see if we're wrong. We'll try to figure out why and we'll admit it. But, you know, I think lots of people have a political lens when they try to view sort of macroeconomic numbers. They want Biden to fail. They want oil prices to go up. They want gasoline prices to go up. That's just not in the cards. Like, I just don't see it.
18:07 Speaker 02 You have to be... The difference between an analyst and advocate is you try to read the numbers on the screen and do your best to interpret them. And that's our view. Look, we came to some prominence during an energy crisis, but that doesn't mean we're permanent energy bulls. Like, the very most important question you have to ask is, are we short or long energy? And the very nature of that question is there are two possibilities. And once you convince yourself of one or the other, you have to go with it. And we think the world is long commodities today.
18:34 Speaker 01 Gosh, that's so well said. Advocacy just seems like it's bleeding into everything in 2024 on both sides of the aisle, and it's a real challenge. And it's one of the reasons why we're so happy to have you here on Real Vision to cut through a lot of that noise. By the way, Duneberg, before we move on to the next segment, I wanted to give you the opportunity. You mentioned the Pro Tier. Tell folks if they're interested in hearing more about what we're talking about right now, where they can find you, where they can find your content.
18:58 Speaker 02 Sure. All our work is at Duneberg.com. We recently ejected a squatter from that domain name at no small cost. I suppose that's a compliment that we had to pay up to get rid of said squatter, and they made a good investment. But we're now Duneberg.com. We're still a Substack site, and we are partners with Substack. We have two tiers. We have an annual subscription tier where you get all of our articles, and you get to comment on all the pieces and interact with us. And then also, we have this Pro Tier for perhaps wealthier, or even some people who work on Wall Street to get additional access to Duneberg. And that tier also gets a monthly webinar from us, either a presentation we put together
19:39 Speaker 02 or a high-profile guest. And so those are the two tiers we have. But basically, you know, this is the work of our lives. We publish seven or eight pieces a month, and one doom-zoom a month, as we call it for our Pro Tier. And this is all we do, and it's really a blast.
19:55 Speaker 01 I can't even imagine publishing seven or eight pieces a month.
19:58 Speaker 02 You know, we were joking before we went on the air, we're a very small team. But when you find what you're meant to be doing in life, you just keep doing it. And these pieces just sort of come to me. And then we research, write, edit, publish, promote, defend, all of them. And sometimes we're wrong, and we admit it, and we learn. And we have this amazing network. We're approaching 230,000 subscribers on the Duneberg platform, which means we have this vast network of experts to tap into for ideas and consulting on pieces as we're working them. And, oh, this person that I know works in the utility industry in their very senior position at such and such a company, let's reach out to them off the record and find out whether we're characterizing this right, and so on.
20:40 Speaker 02 And so, and then we have a cascade of really interesting story ideas coming to us every day via email, and we try to respond to every subscriber. And so it's just really fun. You know, again, like when you find what you're meant to be doing. You know, good Lord, just keep doing it. And that's our plan. And so back to the whole advocacy versus analysts thing. Look, an energy crisis would be great for Doomberg as measured by our subscription business, for example. We're not cheering for an energy crisis. We are trying to analyze the markets and call the balls and strikes as we see them because our goal is just to be doing this in 10 years. Right. And the more credibility you build with your audience by calling it as you see it. Now, look, we get things wrong. We were early to the European energy crisis and we were, we hung on to that thesis too long.
21:23 Speaker 02 But then we were pretty quick to call the coming glut in natural gas, which I think we got right. And we were certainly dead stone, right? You know, dead to nuts right on the sanctions policy and that it would backfire. And so we've gotten some big calls right. We've gotten some big calls wrong. Nobody bats a thousand in this business. And as one of our subscribers who appreciates our authenticity and our, and our analysis said to us, the only thing worse than being wrong is having no opinion. Give me your opinion, show me your homework and I'll do the rest. And so that's our view.
21:51 Speaker 01 We're going to take another quick break and be right back with more of the day's top analysis on the Real Vision Daily Briefing.
22:02 Speaker 01 Very well said. Talking of which, I want to take a look at another view. This is Andreas Steno Larson, and we'll talk about his view when you get back. He's called, What If The Fed Holds Rates Steady? This is from today, 5/7/2024. Let's take a look at that clip.
22:17 Speaker 03 When you see such a decline in the input price of everything from energy to chemicals to food, you typically see a tendency towards increasing order books because of falling prices. So basically the opposite of what an economic textbook will tell you. But what happens when prices decline is that a lot of people assess that this is a good timing to buy and load up on inventories. And that's essentially what we're seeing the first signs of now. And if I'm right, that's a very positive sign for the overall commodity cycle during the rest of the year.
22:53 Speaker 03 And when we pair that real world reflation or inflation with easy financial conditions, I still think financial conditions are pretty easy, especially in the US, we probably still have an inflation problem down the road.
23:08 Speaker 01 Jim Berg, I think you may have a slightly different view from Andreas Del Larson. Let's give you a chance to respond.
23:12 Speaker 02 Sure. First of all, a big fan of Andreas, love his work, always try to catch him when he's when he's out there and I watched that clip with interest. I think one thing that's really important for people to differentiate is you might be in the commodity sector, but you are either a producer of commodities or a user of commodities and where you're drawing that commodities line. So if I look at that chart that Andreas showed, you know, the chemical industry, for example, which is one we know quite well, they are in the US benefiting greatly from cheap natural gas. And so of course, global investment is going to come to the US and perhaps stay away from Europe or Asia because we have this natural gas advantage and that is a key input into the chemical sector. The chemical industry
23:56 Speaker 02 is dotted with cogeneration facilities. The two things you need to run an integrated chemical plant like BASF or, you know, pick your favorite is you need electricity, you need steam, you need industrial grade heat and get both of those from a natural gas-fired power plant. And so if you're a producer of natural gas, you're in the commodity sector. And if you're in the chemical industry, Wall Street investors think they're in the commodity sector, but in reality, they are benefiting from this natural gas glut. So you always have to ask yourself, when you're analyzing an industry or a stock or a company, what are their inputs and what are their outputs? What are they paying for their inputs? What are they, what do they, what do they get to charge for their outputs? And so if you
24:41 Speaker 02 look at the fertilizer companies, like we mentioned earlier, like you want to be in the US today if you're making fertilizer because fertilizer is a globally traded commodity. Fertilizers are globally traded commodities and your inputs basically are natural gas. And so if you're at $2 a million BTU Henry Hub, but you get to charge ammonia global prices out of Tampa for export, you're going to be printing cash, like literally a license to print cash. And if you're an ammonia producer in Germany, right, you're in the Hurt Locker. And so I think you have to drill down into regions and integration. So how back integrated is this particular company?
25:22 Speaker 02 And broadly speaking, is the fertilizer industry in North America better situated than the Chinese? Take Mexico, you know, Mexico has a huge advantage right now because it has hard pipes overland to the Permian. And they're getting natural gas in abundant supply at dirt cheap prices. And if you're looking at the power sector in Mexico, or you're looking at the chemical industry in Mexico, or you're looking at the automotive industry in Mexico, which is a great consumer of electricity and energy. You can see that when you have this dirt cheap natural gas plus access to the North American market via NAFTA, and then you have this foreign investment because of those two factors,
26:02 Speaker 02 you could see and begin to understand why it is that despite challenges with sort of the Mexican government and the drug cartels and so on, that we're seeing this boomlet in Mexico. And so the last thing I would say is I think commodities drive inflation, not the other way around. And so back to our original question of is our commodity markets well supplied? If they are well supplied, that's generally not a, well, it's a headwind for inflationary spikes. If you have negative natural gas in the Permian Basin and you have oil relatively well tamed and coal pretty cheap, this is not, you know, conditions that are ripe for inflation with the big exception of, you know,
26:45 Speaker 02 the shipping issues in the Red Sea and other hotspots and so on. And that would certainly drive some inflation. But in our view, commodities lead inflation, not the other way around.
26:58 Speaker 01 Gosh, Duneberg, I would love to have you back for a full hour deep dive just to hear you talk about the natural gas business here in the United States. That would be fascinating.
27:06 Speaker 02 Anytime. Two hours.
27:09 Speaker 01 I'm gonna take you up on that, man. That would be awesome.
27:11 Speaker 02 You bet. Happy to.
27:12 Speaker 01 Fantastic. All right, let's see if we can do a speed round here. We got a lot of questions coming in. Let's just see if we can hit as many of these as quickly as we possibly can. So I know that folks want to hear from you. First one comes from Nick C. Hi, Duneberg. Part of Ralpal's thesis is that we will have to move to more nuclear or have innovation in the energy sector to be able to supply the energy needed to support the new demand that AI will need. What companies, where are you looking for innovation in the energy sector? Great question. Where are you looking for innovation?
27:39 Speaker 02 So first of all, I agree wholeheartedly. We've written about this quite favorably, one of the best titles of our pieces, which was supplied by Grant Williams called Fission Ships. We believe that the need for both increased electricity and quality of electricity makes nuclear power uniquely situated to supply that increasing demand. We have this view that the sort of Kurzweilian computing exponential growth curve will always be hit, that humanity will rearrange its economies to do so. And just this sort of a gut feeling as sort of a conjecture of how the economy will work. That has held true for several decades and certainly since Kurzweil wrote his famous The Singularity is Near book,
28:21 Speaker 02 which if you haven't read it, I suggest you buy it and at least read the first chapter, after which you will probably put it down and go for a long walk. The nuclear renaissance will be driven by the need for super high quality baseload power that only nuclear power can provide. Now, expressing that view, the easiest way to do it, just get long uranium, I suppose, the Sprott Physical Uranium Trust. There are other companies in the space. The nuclear industry is notoriously difficult to invest in because it's been overlooked for so long. Sprott also has an ETF which combines a basket of uranium companies as well as some exposure to the Sprott Physical Uranium Trust. I believe it's UNRM is the ticker.
29:05 Speaker 02 I would take a look at that, but do your own due diligence and all those things. I think there is significant tailwind in the nuclear sector. Physics will ultimately not be denied, and you cannot grow. Electricity capacity without a substantial nuclear renaissance. And we're seeing that today. And full credit to the Biden administration for recognizing that fact and we think trying to get ahead of it. Although, we would say the recent passage of the uranium import ban from Russia seems rather risky. Certainly bullish for uranium and the whole complex, but we shall see how that will work out.
29:39 Speaker 01 Doomberg, I've said when physics and feelings collide, physics always wins.
29:42 Speaker 02 Yeah, physics is undefeated in the battle against platitudes. That is our preferred expression of that same feeling.
29:49 Speaker 01 Perfect. That's perfect. That just answered John Ayers' question. He wants to know nuclear growth long term in the US. I think you just answered that. Here's one from Paul English. Doomberg, won't the US fiscal quagmire brought on by unrestrained spending along with the Fed and Treasury moves eventually drive the market for hard assets? PM's commodities, including oil?
30:11 Speaker 02 Yes. I mean, there's no other way to say it. But it's just a matter of timing and your own horizon, right? So our narrow analysis of between now and the US election is different than 10 years from now. I mean, we are clearly on an unsustainable path. I mean, a trillion dollars every 90 days in the US debt pile. Nobody believes that's going to be repaid. I mean, we're at the refinance, kicking the can down the road stage of the fiscal dominance crisis. And I think, again, it boggles the mind that we're like, you know, going around the world picking fights with nuclear superpowers when we're running massive deficits and accumulating debt that nobody believes will ever pay back.
30:52 Speaker 02 But it is what it is. Again, like in the medium term, absolutely terrible. I mean, we see a crisis coming. In the short term, I think we'll be able to extend and pretend and punt it down the road and get through the election.
31:05 Speaker 01 A.J. Steninger, so would this scenario you are describing be bullish or bearish for oil refiner stocks? What are the refiners based on this thesis?
31:14 Speaker 02 Sure, refiners are a little more complex because you're one step down and China has excess refining capacity. You know, for all to talk about China importing oil that exports a lot of finished goods, you know, China has this way of occupying critical choke points and supply chains that make analysis like this a little bit more tricky than just the headlines would allow you to believe. I would say the most valuable thing to have is a grandfather permit to operate a refinery in the United States. Like, we're not billing anymore. We occasionally expand, you know, big sites if the government allows you, but I tell you, if you own a permit to operate a refinery or a chemical plant or other major heavy industry
31:56 Speaker 02 in the United States, that is extremely valuable. And we're not, we just, we don't know how to build these things anymore, and we just don't. And so what we're seeing, even nuclear power, these plants, you know, we had Mark Nelson on and recorded him for our Doom Zoom Pro, which we'll release in a bit for May. Nuclear power plants are basically immortal today, and these chemical plants, these refineries that have permits that nobody wants to see shut down and environmentalists occasionally complain about, if they have the permit and they're there, that's a license to print cash for a very long time. And so by and large, over the cycle, refining is a pretty good business.
32:36 Speaker 01 Duneberg, I have to say, this 30 minutes, you've absolutely crushed it. I don't think I've gotten this, unignorant, this fast in 30 minutes ever in my life about energy. This has just been a fantastic conversation. Come back and do a deep dive with me, man. I would love that.
32:50 Speaker 02 Anytime. You know how to find us, and I really enjoyed it. And I must say, Ash, you know, I get cross this off my bucket list, Real Vision Daily Briefing with Ash Bennington. You know, Maggie, love Maggie too. So, but I'm happy to have participated with you today, and I really appreciate the questions from the audience. And Duneberg.com if they want to find out more.
33:07 Speaker 01 Dumeber, before we go, final thoughts, key takeaways. We've covered a lot of ground here. What would you like to leave folks with?
33:11 Speaker 02 I keep an eye on the price of gold and the price of oil as it pertains to the Middle East. That is the one thing on the board. And I do think people are perhaps underestimating the seriousness with which Russia is taking all this talk about NATO troops in Ukraine. Totally underreported story is that Russia called in the ambassadors of France and the UK yesterday and basically gave them a pretty severe dressing down. We'll see what happens in Russia. I think we're going to lose the war in Ukraine. And the big risk on the board is NATO's response to losing that war. And I don't like to want to uncork a whole can of worms here in the last 30 seconds. But keep an eye on Ukraine, keep an eye on the Middle East. And if peace were to break out there, then I think oil goes down, commodities, stocks
33:56 Speaker 02 go up, everybody cheers. But just keep an eye on those two things because those are unpredictable. We're one misunderstanding away from $120 oil. I don't want to be like totally bearish oil. The geopolitical risk premium is there for a reason. It could go both ways. The way in which it resolves will be determined by factors that have nothing to do with the physical supply and demand of oil.
34:18 Speaker 01 Spectacular conversation, Dumeber. Really enjoyed this one.
34:21 Speaker 02 Thanks, sir.
34:22 Speaker 01 Before we go, Raul Powell has said, "The economic singularity is coming. We have six years to make as much money as possible," in Raul's view. If you want to hear more about Raul's thinking on this, get ready for The Exponentialist. Start with your $1 trial today at realvision.com/theexponentialist. That's realvision.com/theexponentialist to get more of Raul Powell's views on all things future. Thank you so much for watching. Thank you for listening to Real Vision Daily Briefing. We'll be back again tomorrow, same time, same place. See you then. Have a great afternoon, everybody.
35:00 Speaker 04 We hope you enjoyed this episode. At Real Vision, we arm you with the expert knowledge, time-efficient tools, and a powerful network to help you succeed on your financial journey. Get a taste of financial freedom with our free offer at realvision.com/free.
Previous #1030 - Are Dollar Bears About to Roar? with Brent Donnelly | The Fed, U.S. Dollar, & Japanese Yen Next #1032 - Are Crypto Markets at Risk? ft. Jeff Dorman | Ethereum, Bitcoin, and the SEC Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated