Pod Insights The Real Estate Espresso Podcast Slow and Steady with John Casmon About this episode John Casmon is based in Cincinnati where he invests in multi-family apartments. On today's show we are talking about how their investment thesis has shifted to meet market conditions. To connect with John, visit https://casmoncapital.com/, check out their podcast at Multifamily Insights on all of the major podcast platforms. Also download their 7 Questions Guide for investing in multi-family apartments. ------------**Real Estate Espresso Podcast:** Spotify: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/3GvtwRmTq4r3es8cbw8jW0?si=c75ea506a6694ef1) iTunes: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-real-estate-espresso-podcast/id1340482613) Website: [www.victorjm.com](http://www.victorjm.com) LinkedIn: [Victor Menasce](http://www.linkedin.com/in/vmenasce) YouTube: [The Real Estate Espresso Podcast](http://www.youtube.com/@victorjmenasce6734) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/realestateespresso](http://www.facebook.com/realestateespresso) Email: [podcast@victorjm.com](mailto:podcast@victorjm.com) **Y Street Capital:** Website: [www.ystreetcapital.com](http://www.ystreetcapital.com) Facebook: [www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital](https://www.facebook.com/YStreetCapital) Instagram: [@ystreetcapital](http://www.instagram.com/ystreetcapital)
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Real Estate Espresso Podcast, your morning shot of what's new in the world of real estate investing. I'm your host Victor Manash. This is the weekend edition where we interview notable people from the world of real estate investing. Today is no exception. We have a great guest all the way from Cincinnati. Welcome to the show, John Casmon.
0:18 Speaker 01 Hey Victor, thank you for having me.
0:19 Speaker 00 Great to have you here. Now, John, you're based in Cincinnati, you've been at this game a while, and I'm excited to get an update on your strategy because it has shifted. But maybe before we dive into the details, perhaps give a little bit of your backstory and how you got to this point in your journey.
0:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, man. So I'm also a podcast host myself. My show's called Multi-Family Insights. We've been doing that for, I don't know, about maybe eight or nine years now. And I've had the pleasure of talking to a lot of great individuals, not you yet. So I'm excited to get you back on the show as well. But I've been investing in multifamily apartments for about 12 years now. Started off with a duplex and a house hack, then slowly started to build my portfolio, learned about, you know, working with other people's money and raising capital. And I've been doing syndications for, like I said, about 10, 12 years now. And that has changed dramatically, especially over the last few years where the rising costs of interest rates have shifted, you know, the profitability on some of these deals. It used to be, you know, pretty much every deal worked out and people
1:15 Speaker 01 made money. And now most deals are, you know, maybe not living up to expectations. And we've been fortunate enough to have most of our deals pan out, especially our local deals. And we have shifted our approach. You know, we really think the opportunity in the market today is buying local. And that may feel like a no crap Sherlock situation. But again, I think right now, the more you can control, the tighter you are with your operations and your market, the better, the better off you are. So that's our focus right now. And we can dive into a little bit of that more, but our focus is really trying to control what we can't control in our backyard.
1:52 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Of course, there's many different factors. There's macro factors. There's things like capital costs, obviously, which is if not the number one, it's certainly within the top two in terms of overall costs. And then, of course, real estate is hyper local. Through the pandemic, a lot of people Just relied on the rising tide to lift all boats because virtually every market went up to the up and to the right. And so it was easy to make money like you said, and today that's not necessarily true. Cincinnati as a market is, I wouldn't say that it's growing dramatically. It might even be just kind of going sideways. To what an extent is population growth core in your opinion to having that sustained excess of demand and shortage of supply?
2:37 Speaker 01 I think it's critical and you know, to your point, you know, it's a market that we love and we've loved it for a number of years and it hasn't shifted much and I think that's the story, you know, very often as investors, we want to want to ride the wave. We want to go to markets that are trending upwards, right? Run run into Phoenix when we're seeing double digit growth. And that's awesome, but when you see that growth, you got to understand what's on the other side of that. And Cincinnati, the Midwest as a whole, but Cincinnati in particular, uh, you're not going to get the highs. You're not also not going to get the same levels. So for us, it's a steady market and as investors, steady means more predictable. It's not to mean that everything is going to be easy, but we want to remove as much risk as we can.
3:17 Speaker 01 And understanding the market dynamics makes it a little bit more of a fair game as far as what we can expect. Certainly we all have to deal with rising interest rates. We all have to deal with uh, some of the economic challenges that happen. But we understand the demand in our market, you know, Cincinnati is never going to see a year of double digit population growth or anything crazy there. But the people who live here want to live here. They're here because they grew up here, they got family here, they went to school here. Um, you know, they they come back because maybe they went to, you know, Chicago or Ohio State or some other place. And now they want to come home and raise their family, right? So people are here because they want to be here. It's not like they're chasing high tech jobs or high paying tech jobs. And then if something happens to those jobs, now they don't want to live there, right?
4:02 Speaker 01 So for us, we like that aspect of it. Um, it is growing, it's growing, you know, slow but steadily. And that is something where we can kind of see what's happening in the market. And again, we can take it to the next level. Very often investors, you want to focus on that surface level uh, research, but really the the juice is really in that next level, right? Understanding the sub market data, understanding what the city and what the region is looking for, understanding where the infrastructure is being developed. When you understand that and you can, you know, get really close and nuanced with where that development is taking place. I think that's where the opportunity lies.
4:37 Speaker 00 Now, when you focus on multifamily apartments, are you segmenting the market further in terms of is this workforce housing? Are you going after more of the luxury segment? When I have conversations with investors and sometimes even tenants' rights groups, who say, "Well, we need more affordable housing." Well, affordability is a function. It doesn't matter who owns it. It's a function of what is it cost to build something? I don't care what the finishes are. That's just the thickness of the icing on top. The core cost is what it is. And so, at a certain point, the only choice becomes either to buy older products, so you're buying it with last year's dollars that have been devalued to some extent, or you really have not much choice but to go at the higher end of the market.
5:21 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's a great point, right? So I think part of what we have seen is there's great opportunities when you're local. When you're not local, you kind of have to have a really crystallized investing strategy. And certainly, we have that, right? Our thesis has not really shifted much over the last 10 years. We like B-class value-add apartments. With that said, you know, I can say that to 10 different people, and you can get 10 different interpretations of what that means.
5:44 Speaker 00 Sure.
5:44 Speaker 01 So for us, when we talk about B-class, we're talking stuff that's built in the 80s, the 90s, the 2000s. You know, if it's an older project, then we want to see some of the upgrades being made, particularly to the infrastructure, right? To the plumbing, to the electrical, to the roofs. So we want to go in and really focus on the value-add component, not saving an old infrastructure project where we're going to put a lot of money into the things that don't drive the rents. We talk about affordable housing. Again, that's another thing that a lot of people can interpret differently. There's a difference between low-income housing. There's a difference between government-backed properties versus simply having workforce housing that's available. And the workforce is not the same as affordable. So to understand these nuances, for us,
6:28 Speaker 01 we want to live in places and own in places where people pay their rent. It is workforce housing. It's housing that is desired. So we are not necessarily relying on government grants or handouts necessarily. We are focused on areas where people want to live. These are blue-collar workers. It's the backbone of America. The teachers, the firefighters, police officers. These are the people who service this country. Those are the ones who keep this this place going. We want to provide quality housing for these individuals. So that's kind of our focus. Now, whether that is the nineteen eighty-five built a hundred and fifty unit apartment complex, or that's a two thousand twenty's built eight unit apartment building. We want to have the flexibility to invest in the right opportunities based on the business plan that presents itself.
7:11 Speaker 00 I often have the conversation with with folks that are looking to add value to existing. And of course, as you know, you can get Excel to lie to you many different ways. You might come up with a thesis that says, I don't know, we're going to add washers and dryers to the units, and that'll drive an extra fifty bucks a month in rent. And so you make the investment, and it doesn't always play out the way you planned. What's that experience been like for you? Have you ended up with some stranded improvements? Or how do you make those decisions?
7:44 Speaker 01 You're you're spot on, right? And it's funny you said the washer and dryer because it's exactly what we had on one of our projects. We bought a property out in Louisville, hundred four units. We planned on adding wash and dryers to it. Well, guess what? We found out as we did our deeper research that most of the people own their wash and dryers, which was different than what we saw in Cincinnati, right? I know a lot of times we think these Midwest markets are very similar, but in Cincinnati, it's not the case. In Louisville, it is. Most of those people buy, and they just move with their wash and dryers. So we thought we'd have higher adoptance, or higher acceptance there, and that just wasn't the case. So as we decided and looked at all the numbers, we actually just realized that, you know what? The return on the investment's not there. You know, we're going to spend a thousand dollars putting in wash and dryers to make fifty bucks.
8:27 Speaker 01 And what we actually found was a better investment. And that's part of, I think, your job as an investor, right? You really have to be an entrepreneur. And too many of us are thinking about it based on that spreadsheet and making those numbers line up to say, okay, we can get this, you know, I R fifteen percent I R R, or whatever it is. But the reality is you got to find opportunities, right? You got to solve problems. In this case, we knew we wanted to make the properties a little bit nicer. And the way we were able to do that is actually through backsplashes. We were able to just do some very collective upgrades, adding a backsplash. Well, the backsplash cost- Lost us a few hundred dollars to put in, but it actually generated a sixty five dollar rent premium. Because it looked newer, right? It looked great in the pictures. It it it felt more elegant for the residents.
9:08 Speaker 01 So that was something that we did and had a greater return on investment than we ever underwrote into our plan. So I think part of it is as investors, you go in certainly with a business plan, but you have to step back and ask yourself, does this actually make sense? Is the market buying what I'm selling or do I need to pivot and where else can I create value? You don't want to just invest in something because you put it onto a spreadsheet. If it's not going to deliver the ROI that you're anticipating. Oftentimes, there are smarter investments that we can make, but we have to have our return metrics. I don't know about many of your investors, one thing we like to do is when we make those improvements, we will test it and we'll see, okay. What are we actually getting? Are we getting the rent bumps we expected? Are we getting the feedback from residents that this is something they're looking for?
9:52 Speaker 01 Or is there something different? And we can always pivot after we go through a couple of unit changes to understand what the market is really looking for and adjust our business plan accordingly.
10:01 Speaker 00 A lot of older properties are lacking the infrastructure to install some of the latest technology, whether it's smart building features. Facial recognition at the entry doorways, all those sorts of things. And yet, if you can provide that in, say, a nineteen eighties or nineteen nineties building. It really changes the the the residents' perception that they're living in a modern property because it has modern features. Have you experimented with retrofitting that? And how's that? If so, how's that gone?
10:31 Speaker 01 Not as much, partly partly because though, you know, when rents were going up so fast over the last few years. You didn't have to do any of that stuff, right? So for for us, it makes sense to make the investments. Some of those things are great, but the ROI is still kind of up in the air for some of these properties. And ultimately, I think we have to understand what are people going to pay for? What do they really, really want? Some of those features are really cool. We had a property where we did a smart package, right? We did a, you know, smart locks and smart sensors and all these different things, right? Smart, smart lights and you could turn them off when you were away. And that was great, but we kind of forced people to pay. For that. And that was the, you know, we got some pushback from some of the residents who were like, that's cool, but I don't think it's worth what you're charging me for, right?
11:15 Speaker 01 So I think this comes back to understanding your audience. When you're talking about teachers and you're talking about post office workers. Yeah, that's cool. But are they going to pay a premium for that? Or do they really just want a quality unit? Do they want it to look clean? Do they want the countertops to look nice? Is it a place where they feel great inviting their friends? Uh, if you're doing a larger complex, then I think some of that makes sense, right? You've got a 300 unit building. Then it makes sense if you've got a swimming pool and other amenities. But when you're, you know, kind of that hundred unit and less range, you want to be really mindful. And I think the more important thing is the living space itself. Make sure it's a quality living space that someone wants to live in. And then you can start to focus on some of those additional features.
11:57 Speaker 00 Love it. Well, John, if folks want to connect, if they want to learn more, what's the best way?
12:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, listen, two things. One, we've got our podcast, Multi Family Insights. If you like this shot of espresso, uh, maybe want to go a little bit longer. Our typical episodes are about 30 to 40 minutes. Check out that podcast anywhere you listen to podcasts. But then also I've got a free guide. If you are looking to scale your portfolio, if you have questions and just trying to be a better investor, it's seven questions you must ask before investing in apartments. I have found that it's not really about the deal versus people missing out on asking the right questions. Some of these questions are questions you're asking yourself, because if you've never done apartment syndications or you've never developed a property, but you're going to do that next, you usually aren't that critical of yourself, right? You're critical of other people, but not yourself.
12:43 Speaker 01 Ask the right questions. Sometimes you got to ask them yourself. Sometimes you have to ask it of your team, the market, the opportunity. This is seven questions you must ask before investing in apartments. You can get that on our website, casmoncapital.com/7questions.
12:56 Speaker 00 John, this is great. Uh, for the listeners home, you definitely want to connect with John Casmon at casmoncapital.com. As well as check out his podcast, Multi Family Insights, and definitely from his website, go download his seven questions guide at casmoncapital.com/7questions. The links will be in the show notes. And in the meantime, have an awesome rest of your weekend. Go make some great things happen. We'll talk to you again tomorrow.
Previous Healthcare Could Drive Your Investment Thesis Next Why Rates Will Fall Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated