Pod Insights Radiolab The Good Show About this episode The standard view of evolution is that living things are shaped by cold-hearted competition. And there is no doubt that today's plants and animals carry the genetic legacy of ancestors who fought fiercely to survive and reproduce. But in this hour that we first broadcast back in 2010, we wonder whether there might also be a logic behind sharing, niceness, kindness ... or even, self-sacrifice. Is altruism an aberration, or just an elaborate guise for sneaky self-interest? Do we really live in a selfish, dog-eat-dog world? Or has evolution carved out a hidden code that rewards genuine cooperation?
Sign up for our newsletter!! It includes short essays, recommendations, and details about other ways to interact with the show. Sign up (https://radiolab.org/newsletter)!
Radiolab is supported by listeners like you. Support Radiolab by becoming a member of The Lab (https://members.radiolab.org/) today.
Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @radiolab, and share your thoughts with us by emailing radiolab@wnyc.org. Leadership support for Radiolab’s science programming is provided by the Simons Foundation and the John Templeton Foundation. Foundational support for Radiolab was provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.
Transcript 10,850 words · 29 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Wait, you're listening?
0:03 Speaker 01 Okay. All right. Okay. All right.
0:08 Speaker 02 You're listening to Radiolab.
0:11 Speaker 01 Radiolab.
0:11 Speaker 02 From?
0:12 Speaker 01 WNYC. See? Yep.
0:20 Speaker 03 This is Radiolab. I'm Latif Nasr. It's the holidays, and as usual, at this time of year, everyone's become so nice all of a sudden. Giving gifts, donating to charities, showing up with a plate of cookies. Everything feels so warm and gooey and selfless. But where is all of this goodness coming from? This week, we're bringing back an episode from 2010 that asks a simple question. Why do we sometimes help others even when it hurts us to do so? It feels like the right episode for right now, not because it's a holiday story, although there is a little Christmas parable in there,
1:03 Speaker 03 but because it asks what generosity is, where it comes from, and whether it truly exists at all. Here it is, the good show.
1:15 Speaker 00 All right. Okay, so let's just do the open. All right. Hey, I'm Jad Abumrad. I'm Robert Krulwich. This is Radiolab. And today, we're going to be talking-- well, let's do it this way. Which way? I was at the 92nd Street Y in New York City. A big gathering spot for cool people with new books. And that particular week-- Is Richard Dawkins. Richard Dawkins.
1:38 Speaker 00 They like him. Mm-hmm.
1:41 Speaker 00 Don't make it so easy for him. I decided to begin-- This is a real problem for a lot of people. By quoting him to him. You write, I don't know if it's in this book or some other, "The total amount of suffering per year in the natural world is beyond all decent contemplation. During the minute it takes me to compose this sentence, thousands of animals are being eaten alive. Others are running for their lives, whimpering with fear. Others are slowly being devoured from within by rasping parasites. Thousands of all kinds are dying of starvation, thirst, disease. It must be so. If there is ever a time of plenty, this very fact will automatically lead to an increase in population until the natural state of starvation and misery is restored."
2:30 Speaker 04 Darwin was worried by the same thing. I mean Darwin recognized the total horror of the suffering in nature. It was one of the things that actually made him lose his faith. But he also realized that it's not just a fact that it happens. It's intrinsic to natural selection that it must happen. And when you look at a beautiful animal like a cheetah that appears to be beautifully designed for something, like a cheetah is amazingly well-designed apparently for catching gazelles. And gazelles are amazingly well-designed for escaping from cheetahs. But they are the end products of a sort of evolutionary arms race in which thousands, millions of animals have died.
3:15 Speaker 04 The shaping, the carving of the shape of a cheetah or a gazelle has come about through millions of unsuccessful gazelles being caught and the successful ones making it through, only to be caught later probably, but after reproducing and passing on the genes that helped them to escape. So the sheer number of deaths that lie behind the sculpting of these beautiful creatures is horrifying and at the same time it's got a kind of savage beauty.
3:53 Speaker 05 Wow. Why did you blame this exactly?
3:55 Speaker 00 Well, because I was sitting there thinking, I know the cheetahs chase and eat antelopes, but wasn't there a nice cheetah once? That went over to the antelope and said, hi, have a sandwich together? And that maybe something about the cheetah and the, had something to do with an act of kindness? I can't imagine.
4:14 Speaker 05 Oh, so you're thinking that maybe it's not just meanness that can sculpt, but maybe niceness can sculpt too?
4:19 Speaker 00 Exactly. Niceness as a scalpel.
4:29 Speaker 05 Niceness is a scalpel. Ooh. I want to listen to that show. All right.
4:37 Speaker 05 Wait a second, we are that show. We should do it then. Let's do it. Today on Radiolab.
4:44 Speaker 05 Goodness. Kindness. Selflessness. Altruism. If the world is so cruel, how do you account for it? Yeah. How should we think about it? And when you do see generosity, how do you know it's really generous?
5:09 Speaker 05 All right, so we're going to start the show with a story that sort of embodies the last question you asked, about a guy named George Price, who was a mathematician we'd never heard of until our producer, Lynn Levy, told us about him. She heard about it from an author, Orin Harmon, who wrote a book called The Price as in George Price of altruism.
5:30 Speaker 06 You know, this is a high school photo.
5:32 Speaker 02 So, OK, so the people on the radio can't see the picture. So describe what he looks like.
5:36 Speaker 06 Well, I tell you, he looks a bit like sort of some kind of Scandinavian prince in the 17th century. Good-looking guy.
5:44 Speaker 02 Totally. Definitely something about this guy's eyes.
5:48 Speaker 06 His eyes.
5:49 Speaker 02 Yeah.
5:49 Speaker 06 This was described to me by a number of people who knew him. He had a gaze that you sort of walked away from at your own peril. There was something that, you know, he sort of knew things.
5:58 Speaker 02 You could start George's story anywhere, but let's start in 1943. George graduates from college, and he's this-
6:06 Speaker 06 Very kinetic kind of guy.
6:07 Speaker 02 Really athletic.
6:08 Speaker 06 He'd swim and surf, and he did a lot of rock climbing.
6:11 Speaker 02 And by all accounts, he was-
6:13 Speaker 06 Incredibly brilliant.
6:14 Speaker 02 And right after college, he starts to kind of bounce through history.
6:18 Speaker 06 He was all over the place.
6:20 Speaker 02 First place he ends up is-
6:22 Speaker 06 The Manhattan Project on uranium enrichment. So he was working as a chemist on the atom bomb. When he was done with that.
6:30 Speaker 02 After a couple of years.
6:31 Speaker 06 He made a 90-degree turn and started working at Bell Labs on transistor research. Solved some very basic problems there and then disappeared like a phantom. Started working at a medical center on oncology research.
6:45 Speaker 02 Meaning cancer.
6:46 Speaker 07 And I remember going to his lab, playing hide and seek, all these bottles and Teps tubes.
6:51 Speaker 02 By this time, George had a wife and two kids.
6:53 Speaker 08 You'd look under the microscope at slides of blood.
6:56 Speaker 02 Anna and Kathleen, but he never really saw them that much.
6:59 Speaker 06 He'd work 56 hours straight without sleeping on benzodrine.
7:03 Speaker 08 And I remember he was always.
7:05 Speaker 06 Stuff like that.
7:06 Speaker 08 Gone a lot.
7:07 Speaker 02 Hmm, when the kids were still pretty young.
7:09 Speaker 08 We were like five and six.
7:11 Speaker 06 He.
7:12 Speaker 02 Left his family.
7:14 Speaker 06 Yeah.
7:15 Speaker 02 Just left.
7:16 Speaker 06 Turned another 90-degree corner and began working on computer-aided design.
7:23 Speaker 06 In fact, he invented computer-aided design. He was firing in all directions.
7:27 Speaker 02 What do you think was driving him to keep moving from thing to thing?
7:30 Speaker 06 He just wanted to succeed at any cost. It made no difference in what field. And at one point in time, he was corresponding with about five Nobel laureates, each in a different field. He wanted to have one great discovery that would make his name.
7:46 Speaker 02 So that's, that's George.
7:48 Speaker 05 Wow, quite a guy.
7:49 Speaker 02 Very interesting guy.
7:50 Speaker 05 So what happens next?
7:51 Speaker 02 So next, what happens is he gets on a boat and he, he goes to London.
7:56 Speaker 05 When was this, by the way?
7:57 Speaker 02 It's November 1967. And in London, that's where things, for our purposes, start to really happen.
8:04 Speaker 05 Boy, what happens in London?
8:05 Speaker 02 Well, he starts looking for this question. He goes from library to library. There are 13 libraries that he would hang out at. And the question that he finds for himself, which is weird considering his personal history, is.
8:20 Speaker 06 Why family?
8:22 Speaker 06 Like, why do people have families?
8:23 Speaker 02 Well, like, why do families stick together?
8:25 Speaker 06 There are a lot of sort of dynamics within the family where it would make more sense for an individual to sort of break out.
8:32 Speaker 02 You know, go it alone.
8:33 Speaker 06 Um.
8:34 Speaker 02 Like he had.
8:35 Speaker 06 And yet, family persists. And there should be a good reason for it.
8:39 Speaker 02 He even wrote about the question to his daughter.
8:41 Speaker 07 Dear Kathleen, my big paper will be on the evolutionary origin of the human family. In most species, the father just mates with the mother and she does all the child-rearing herself. But in the human species, the dominant pattern has involved care by adult males toward their own children. Why did our species evolve this way? It just brings back what kind of a father our father was towards us. And basically, there was kind of this benign neglect.
9:16 Speaker 02 Hmm. But this question, why family, was only the beginning. Why family led him to a bigger question, which is, why does anybody help anybody?
9:28 Speaker 06 Huh. Well, what do you mean?
9:31 Speaker 02 If you think about Darwin's idea, survival of the fittest. Think about what that really means. It means if you are a creature, you have two big, important jobs.
9:41 Speaker 06 You've got to survive and you've got to be fit.
9:42 Speaker 02 Right.
9:43 Speaker 06 Whatever that means.
9:44 Speaker 02 Fitness really means, how many babies can you make? How many babies are you making? And so if you do some stupid, you know, harebrained thing, that means you can't stay alive and/or you can't make babies. That doesn't make any sense.
9:56 Speaker 06 Right. And yet, wherever you look in nature...
9:59 Speaker 02 You see creatures doing this.
10:00 Speaker 06 From bacteria...
10:02 Speaker 02 To insects.
10:03 Speaker 06 Birds. Bees. Ants and wasps. Fish. I'll give you an example. There's a species of amoeba called Discotelium discoidium, which usually, the amoeba sort of lives on its own, it's a single-celled organism, in the forest. But when resources are low, what it does is it sends out this chemical signal.
10:23 Speaker 06 And all the other amoeba, who are also single-celled.
10:25 Speaker 02 They start sending out signals.
10:27 Speaker 06 And they start sort of crawling until they all meet. And they become one slug, which is now a single organism.
10:34 Speaker 02 And this slug begins to sort of move along until it finds a place that's windy and sunny. At which point...
10:41 Speaker 06 It stops. And the top 20% of the slug, the top 20% amoeba in the head of the slug, begin to create out of their own body a stalk.
10:59 Speaker 06 Which hardens.
11:02 Speaker 06 And they die while doing so.
11:08 Speaker 06 But the stalk allows the bottom 80% to climb up the stalk and to create an orb at the top of the stalk.
11:15 Speaker 02 And from there, all the amoeba that aren't, you know, dead, they can catch a wind.
11:21 Speaker 06 To better pastures.
11:23 Speaker 02 It's like a dandelion.
11:25 Speaker 06 So what's happened is that the top 20% have really sacrificed themselves for the back 80%. And that's an amoeba. So you figure, what the hell is happening here? This was a great mystery to Darwin, and Darwin said, "This is in fact the greatest mystery and the greatest riddle, and if I can't answer it, then my theory isn't worth anything."
11:44 Speaker 02 And for 100 years, when people talked about evolution, this thing, altruism, was the elephant in the room.
11:54 Speaker 05 So we were curious about this. How might you take this elephant, this niceness thing that seems to be everywhere, and shove it back into the mean old theory of evolution? There's gotta be a way. And so we called up Carl Zimmer, who's a journalist we have on the show quite often, who writes a lot about evolution. And he told us that in the 1960s, just as George Price was starting to ask these questions, some scientists came up with a new way of thinking about altruism, a thought experiment, which he ran us through.
12:20 Speaker 09 Okay. So, okay, so Robert, do you have siblings? I have a sister. Okay, you have a sister. Sarah. Okay. Let's just imagine that you guys are like home from college, say. Okay. And there's a flood at the Krulwich Manor. And the water's flooding around, and you can see that your sister is about to die.
12:46 Speaker 09 If you save your sister's life and you die in the process, your genes, Robert Kralwich's genes, are gone.
12:53 Speaker 00 Yep.
12:54 Speaker 05 Right, this is the problem.
12:55 Speaker 09 Yes. But you and your sister have the same parents.
12:59 Speaker 00 Yes.
13:00 Speaker 09 So your sister has 50% of your genes.
13:03 Speaker 00 So if I rescue her, then half my genes survive?
13:06 Speaker 09 Right, 50% move on.
13:07 Speaker 05 Ah.
13:08 Speaker 09 And if you had a sister and a brother,
13:12 Speaker 09 and you save them both, they'd each have 50%.
13:15 Speaker 05 So it's a wash.
13:16 Speaker 09 And so effectively, it's like saving Robert Kralwich in his entirety.
13:22 Speaker 00 Mathematically speaking.
13:23 Speaker 09 Mathematically speaking, right.
13:24 Speaker 05 Can you do this with cousins?
13:25 Speaker 09 Yeah, actually. If you step it back to cousins...
13:29 Speaker 00 What percentage? That's a quarter in the case of the first cousins? That is?
13:33 Speaker 09 It's an eighth.
13:34 Speaker 00 So I have to have eight first cousins to equal my full genome?
13:38 Speaker 09 Right. Yeah.
13:39 Speaker 05 Do you have that many?
13:41 Speaker 00 I have 32 third cousins, and that's why I always round them up in a rodeo every year.
13:46 Speaker 05 And you place them all together just in case?
13:48 Speaker 00 You guys stay here in case something happens to me.
13:50 Speaker 05 But here's what I don't get. Like, how does this actually operate? Like, Robert's not gonna sit there while the manor's flooding and be like, "Well, let's see. Hmm, I have a cousin that's an eighth and a second cousin that's a 32nd."
13:59 Speaker 09 No, you understand. The math has already been done.
14:02 Speaker 05 The math has already been?
14:03 Speaker 09 The math has been done by evolution on genes. And those are the genes you've got.
14:08 Speaker 05 Oh, so you're saying that evolution has turned the math into an instinct?
14:13 Speaker 09 Yeah, you got it.
14:16 Speaker 00 I don't think I get it. Like, so what is the instinct here? The "I know I want to save my sister."
14:21 Speaker 05 Yeah, well, so here's how I understand it. Since sis has half your genes...
14:25 Speaker 09 Yep.
14:25 Speaker 05 And since second cousin only has a 32nd, theoretically, your instinct to save your sis should be 16 times stronger than your instinct to save your...
14:34 Speaker 09 Oh, no, that's actually roughly proportionally correct.
14:38 Speaker 05 Really? But keep in mind, this was just an idea. It's just a thought experiment. Until our guy, George Price, comes along and writes an equation which shows mathematically how an instinct like this could evolve.
14:50 Speaker 09 It's very powerful. Okay, so, well, do you want me to just read the letters?
14:54 Speaker 05 Yeah.
14:55 Speaker 02 What is the equation? What equals what?
14:56 Speaker 09 Okay.
14:57 Speaker 06 Okay, so it's, uh...
14:59 Speaker 09 W times delta z.
15:01 Speaker 06 Equals the covariance of W i comma z i. Plus?
15:07 Speaker 09 E.
15:08 Speaker 06 We call it E.
15:09 Speaker 09 W i delta z i.
15:11 Speaker 06 Oh, of course.
15:12 Speaker 09 There you go.
15:14 Speaker 05 A little complicated. I mean, it was simple a second ago.
15:16 Speaker 02 No, it's, yeah, it sounds a little complicated. He's not just dealing with like a simple setup. It's like he's got the traits and how they affect the different groups and how things change over time. So it's a big, there's a lot going on in there.
15:28 Speaker 05 Okay.
15:29 Speaker 02 Yeah.
15:29 Speaker 05 All right. Do you understand what you just said?
15:32 Speaker 02 Not, eh.
15:33 Speaker 08 So here, this is a really interesting letter. We should read it.
15:37 Speaker 06 When he did write the equation, he walked off the street into the university.
15:41 Speaker 08 In university college of the University of London.
15:46 Speaker 06 In London, complete unknown.
15:47 Speaker 08 Complete unknown.
15:48 Speaker 06 Had just moved from America. No one knew who he was.
15:51 Speaker 08 I went to talk to a Professor Smith.
15:53 Speaker 06 And he showed the equation to the professor and said, is this new?
15:57 Speaker 08 I felt sure that someone must have discovered it before.
16:00 Speaker 06 The professor looked at it and, after a very, very short amount of minutes, gave him an honorary professorship.
16:08 Speaker 08 Keys.
16:09 Speaker 06 And the keys to an office.
16:13 Speaker 06 One of the best genetics departments in the world.
16:18 Speaker 02 So George is sitting in his office, which, by the way, is on the site of Darwin's old house.
16:23 Speaker 06 Whoa.
16:23 Speaker 02 Yeah. And he's made this big discovery and he's thinking.
16:30 Speaker 02 Thinking. Thinking.
16:32 Speaker 06 Thinking philosophically about what it all meant.
16:36 Speaker 02 Thinking.
16:38 Speaker 06 If I can write a formal, mathematical treatment of the evolution of a trait like altruism, what it means about the trait is that the trait is never really purely altruistic.
16:54 Speaker 02 If making a sacrifice helps me in the end or helps my genes...
16:59 Speaker 05 Sort of like selfishness in disguise.
17:01 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:01 Speaker 06 If that's true, the world is a terrible place.
17:07 Speaker 06 Because it means that there's no true self, there could never be true selflessness in the world. My math means that there cannot ever be true selflessness. And I can't accept a world like that.
17:19 Speaker 05 Why could he suddenly not accept a world like that?
17:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, I don't know. Orin thinks it might be because-
17:25 Speaker 06 Precisely because he had been so selfish for most of his life. And so he decided in his own life to embark on a program of radical altruism that would prove that there was true selflessness in this world. And that's what led him to the streets of London. In search of homeless people, derelicts, down and outs. And he began by sort of just walking up to them, introducing himself. Hello, my name is George. What's your name? How can I help you?
17:55 Speaker 05 To random people on the street?
17:57 Speaker 02 Yeah.
17:57 Speaker 08 Everywhere I go, I keep running into down and out alcoholics to whom I give when I have anything and with whom I sit and drink from their bottle if they offer me a drink.
18:07 Speaker 06 He'd buy people sandwiches or give them a few pounds.
18:10 Speaker 08 Whether it's by giving them money, cleaning a filthy kitchen-
18:13 Speaker 06 And then it got bigger.
18:16 Speaker 02 He started giving out keys to his place-
18:18 Speaker 06 Inviting these guys into his home.
18:20 Speaker 02 People were coming and going. He was giving them food, clothes. And after a few months of charity like that, he was out of money.
18:27 Speaker 06 There was one letter that he had written to John Maynard Smith, another great biologist of the era, which said, "John, I'm down to my last 15 p. And I can't wait to get rid of the last 15."
18:38 Speaker 02 Huh.
18:38 Speaker 06 He thought he was proving his equation wrong.
18:42 Speaker 05 So by getting poorer and poorer and giving away all this stuff, he was somehow negating the thing his math seemed to say was inevitable? The selfish instinct?
18:51 Speaker 02 Yeah. You know, he had this self-preservation instinct. And he was going to fight the self-preservation instinct and he was going to win.
18:58 Speaker 06 To sort of beat the mathematics that he himself had written.
19:00 Speaker 02 So he was approaching it almost like a math proof.
19:03 Speaker 06 Yeah.
19:07 Speaker 02 When he ran out of money, George moved out of his apartment and into this abandoned house in a part of London called Talmors Square.
19:14 Speaker 10 Which one does the volume for my headphones?
19:16 Speaker 02 Which is where he met Sylvia.
19:18 Speaker 10 It was rough. There were just, because there were just poles holding the walls up. Some places had walls.
19:25 Speaker 02 She was a young artist, also squatting at the time.
19:27 Speaker 10 And the buildings are crumbling, you know. People had made makeshift staircases.
19:32 Speaker 02 And George had like a room?
19:34 Speaker 10 Well, a few clothes on the floor. Not much. But, you know, you could see he was always thinking. He would go around asking other people, does anybody have shoes they don't want? So and so needs a pair of shoes. You know, that would be part of it. But it might also be like if somebody was sick, getting them to a doctor. Because if you didn't, if you were homeless, it's very hard to have a doctor. But like I say, all this is going on at the same time. He was getting thinner and thinner. A thin little neck and then these clothes, it just hung around him.
20:12 Speaker 02 He began writing letters to his daughters.
20:14 Speaker 06 Apologizing, weeping.
20:17 Speaker 10 Dear Henry, sorry I deserted you like that. And I'm sorry I was such a poor father to you.
20:21 Speaker 06 Yeah, I've been a terrible father.
20:23 Speaker 10 Looking at your picture now makes me wish I could do it all over again. Maybe where I come into the picture is he wanted to begin again.
20:32 Speaker 02 She says George asked her to marry him over and over.
20:35 Speaker 10 First I thought it was kind of a joke. I was saying, George, we can't get married, you know.
20:42 Speaker 02 She said no each time. And at a certain point, he gave up.
20:46 Speaker 10 It's hard to really, really remember. But it was colder as the winter came on.
21:00 Speaker 10 You wouldn't see George as often. He became quieter, I think. I just remember,
21:12 Speaker 10 I'm quieter.
21:14 Speaker 02 One morning, this guy that was sharing a squat with George.
21:17 Speaker 06 Name is Shmuley Katia.
21:19 Speaker 02 He was heading out the door.
21:20 Speaker 06 He found beneath the door, as he was going out of the building, he found beneath the door a letter. And since they were living in a squat, he was afraid that this was some kind of eviction notice or something like that. And he didn't read English. He couldn't read English. So he ran up the stairs and knocked on George's door because George was the only one who could read English. And when he knocked, the door sort of, kind of, went in a bit. And he could see in the aperture that there was blood all over the linoleum floor. When he had enough of an opening, he could see that George was sitting there with no blood left in his body.
21:58 Speaker 05 He killed himself?
21:59 Speaker 02 Yeah.
22:00 Speaker 06 He took a pair of scissors and cut through his carotid artery, which is a very, very sort of terrible death. Poor George.
22:24 Speaker 05 Thanks to producer Lynn Levy. For more on George Price, be sure to read Oren Harmon's book, The Price of Altruism. And thanks also to Carl Zimmer. His latest is Microcosm. We'll be right back.
22:43 Speaker 11 This week on The New Yorker Radio Hour, will House Democrats try once again for impeachment?
22:48 Speaker 12 Let's not make a fetish out of impeachment. Let's not make a taboo out of impeachment. We understand it's not a panacea, but it is an essential tool in the constitutional toolbox. That's always there.
22:59 Speaker 11 Congressman Jamie Raskin joins us next time on The New Yorker Radio Hour from WNYC. Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
23:14 Speaker 05 Hey, this is Radiolab. I'm Jad Abumrad.
23:16 Speaker 00 I'm Robert Krulwich.
23:17 Speaker 05 Our topic today is?
23:19 Speaker 00 Goodness.
23:19 Speaker 05 Goodness, selflessness.
23:21 Speaker 00 So, we've done the math. The math leaves me a little on the cold side.
23:25 Speaker 05 I wonder why. So, you know what? Forget the math. Forget it.
23:29 Speaker 00 Let's go to the people who do the deeds.
23:31 Speaker 05 People who do amazingly brave and heroic things.
23:34 Speaker 00 Yeah.
23:34 Speaker 05 No math required.
23:35 Speaker 00 And maybe find out, I don't know.
23:38 Speaker 05 What makes them different than the rest of us?
23:40 Speaker 00 Yeah.
23:43 Speaker 05 That question led us?
23:46 Speaker 13 Walter Rikowski.
23:47 Speaker 05 To a guy named Walter Rikowski.
23:49 Speaker 13 And I'm the executive director and secretary of the Carnegie Hero Fund Commission.
23:52 Speaker 05 Cool. Well, thanks for doing this.
23:53 Speaker 13 OK.
23:54 Speaker 05 Can you just give us a little background on the Hero Fund? What is the Carnegie Hero Fund?
23:59 Speaker 13 The Carnegie Hero Fund is a private operating foundation that was established by Andrew Carnegie in 1904. And what we do is recognize civilian heroism throughout the United States and Canada by giving an award called the Carnegie Medal. And accompanying the Carnegie Medal is a financial grant.
24:17 Speaker 05 How much?
24:18 Speaker 13 Well, currently, the amount is $5,000.
24:21 Speaker 05 Wow. And how do you guys choose your heroes?
24:23 Speaker 13 We judge the heroic acts against a list of requirements.
24:28 Speaker 00 So, then you have to have some kind of definition of hero, which includes some and excludes others?
24:33 Speaker 13 Yes.
24:34 Speaker 05 Perfect.
24:35 Speaker 13 A basic definition, which is a civilian.
24:38 Speaker 05 One.
24:38 Speaker 13 Meaning, no military. Who voluntarily.
24:41 Speaker 05 Two.
24:42 Speaker 13 Leaves a point of safety.
24:43 Speaker 05 Three.
24:44 Speaker 13 To risk his own life, or her own life.
24:46 Speaker 05 Four.
24:46 Speaker 13 To an extraordinary degree.
24:48 Speaker 05 Five.
24:48 Speaker 13 To save, or to attempt to save, the life of another human.
24:52 Speaker 05 Six. And how about seven? Why?
24:54 Speaker 00 Can you read that one more time?
24:55 Speaker 13 OK. I wasn't reading. That just came from memory, so the...
24:57 Speaker 05 Oh, OK. Like, what is it that happens in a person's mind at that pivotal moment when they decide to voluntarily.
25:03 Speaker 13 Voluntarily.
25:04 Speaker 05 Leave a point of safety.
25:05 Speaker 13 Leave a point of safety.
25:05 Speaker 05 And risk their life to an extraordinary degree.
25:07 Speaker 13 To save the life of another human.
25:09 Speaker 05 That's what we wanted to know.
25:12 Speaker 05 Should we just jump in?
25:13 Speaker 13 Okay.
25:13 Speaker 05 So the first one we have on our list is Laura Shreik.
25:16 Speaker 13 Okay. That's file number 73546, and the award number is 8005.
25:22 Speaker 14 I am Laura Shreik. I'm from Mattoon, Illinois, and I currently live in Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
25:29 Speaker 05 Oh, wow. Laura spoke with our producer, Tim Howard. Okay, so we're going back a little bit here.
25:33 Speaker 14 Yeah, 15 years.
25:34 Speaker 13 Back in the mid-'90s.
25:36 Speaker 14 1995.
25:37 Speaker 13 I was a 21-year-old college student.
25:39 Speaker 14 And I was driving through the country, and I saw a woman getting mauled by a bull in a pasture.
25:48 Speaker 13 So she stopped to see what was going on.
25:49 Speaker 14 Jumped out and started yelling at her to see what I could do. The woman was on the ground, and the bull was...
25:57 Speaker 13 950-pound Jersey bull.
25:59 Speaker 14 Tossing her in the air and back on the ground.
26:02 Speaker 13 Wow.
26:03 Speaker 14 She was clearly struggling.
26:04 Speaker 13 And where were you?
26:05 Speaker 14 I was right on the other side of the fence, but the fence was electric.
26:12 Speaker 05 So here's the moment that we find fascinating. At this point, Laura can either go forward through thousands of volts of electricity toward an angry bull that will likely maul her too, or she can stay safe.
26:33 Speaker 14 I went ahead and just climbed through the fence. And I don't remember ever feeling the electricity.
26:39 Speaker 05 She says by the time she got through...
26:40 Speaker 14 crazily enough.
26:41 Speaker 05 A neighbor had shown up and threw her a piece of pipe.
26:43 Speaker 14 Maybe about two feet long.
26:45 Speaker 13 So she approached the woman.
26:46 Speaker 14 Who was still conscious. The whole time, she's yelling at me, "Hit the bull in the face as hard as you can and don't stop."
26:53 Speaker 13 So Miss Shreik went up to the bull and beat it repeatedly with this two-foot length of tubing.
27:03 Speaker 14 I think it distracted the bull enough where she was able to get out from under him. And as soon as we were outside the fence, looking back into the pasture, the bull was literally right there at the fence.
27:17 Speaker 13 Kicked the ground a few times and snorted.
27:19 Speaker 14 He was not happy.
27:23 Speaker 05 To our question.
27:24 Speaker 15 When you were there at that fence
27:26 Speaker 14 Mm-hmm.
27:27 Speaker 15 and you had the choice to either stay put or to go through it, what was going through your mind? Was there a calculation there?
27:35 Speaker 14 No, I can't really say that. I mean...
27:38 Speaker 15 You didn't weigh your options or anything like that?
27:40 Speaker 14 I did not, no. It was just, here's the problem. Here's what I need to do. And something needed to happen.
27:48 Speaker 15 Huh. So there was no choice moment?
27:51 Speaker 14 Not that I recall. No. If nobody came to this woman's rescue, she would die.
27:58 Speaker 05 Unfortunately, this is the usual explanation, says Walter. No explanation.
28:03 Speaker 13 I couldn't stand there and not do anything. I was compelled to act.
28:09 Speaker 14 I didn't really take the time to think about what else could happen.
28:12 Speaker 16 I can't say I ever really thought about my own life at that time.
28:15 Speaker 05 OK, we just jumped ahead because we thought we'd try again. That's the voice of the next Carnegie hero that Walter told us about.
28:21 Speaker 13 Yeah, William David Pennell.
28:23 Speaker 16 My name's William Pennell.
28:24 Speaker 13 Who is the 8,362nd person to receive the Carnegie Medal.
28:30 Speaker 05 Our producer Lynn Levy tracked him down.
28:31 Speaker 02 Bill, can you hear me?
28:32 Speaker 16 Yeah, I can hear you.
28:33 Speaker 13 William David Pennell was 37 years old at the time of his heroic act.
28:37 Speaker 02 Was it 1999?
28:39 Speaker 16 Yes, it was early in the morning. It was like...
28:42 Speaker 13 3:19 a.m. in a small town near Pittsburgh.
28:45 Speaker 16 Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
28:46 Speaker 13 Monongahela, Pennsylvania.
28:48 Speaker 16 We was in bed sleeping and my wife heard a loud crash. I actually didn't hear it. And the dog, my one dog was carrying on. So right away, I run down there.
28:58 Speaker 13 Mr. Pennell went outside his house. There was a very bad automobile accident. A car crashed head-on into a utility pool.
29:05 Speaker 16 Flames was like rippling up the windshield out from under the hood.
29:08 Speaker 13 And he responded to the scene wearing only sweatpants.
29:11 Speaker 16 No shoes or shirt or nothing on.
29:13 Speaker 13 Bare-chested and barefoot.
29:16 Speaker 05 So here we are. Bill's standing in front of this ball of fire. There are three drunk teenagers inside that car, though he doesn't know it. He can either, A, do nothing, or B, go in.
29:28 Speaker 13 Through the driver's door.
29:33 Speaker 16 And this big fella slumped out the door. So I reached in and grabbed a hold of him.
29:37 Speaker 13 Around the chest, pulled him from the driver's seat, out to the ground.
29:41 Speaker 16 Meantime, the car was just like blazing. And my neighbor was there, she was hollering, "There's more of them in there." So I run back to the vehicle.
29:49 Speaker 13 Found that the front seat passenger was trapped in the wreckage.
29:53 Speaker 16 I finally got him loose and pulled him out.
29:55 Speaker 13 Apparently, Mr. Pennell was aware that a third person was in the car, a third young man. Uh, Mr. Pennell entered the car a third time. By then...
30:03 Speaker 16 There was tires blown out.
30:05 Speaker 13 Flames had grown to about three feet above the car's roof.
30:08 Speaker 16 The interior, like the headliner of the car and stuff, was dripping like plastic down on my back. I mean, I'm in there screaming, you know, "Somebody give me a hand in here."
30:22 Speaker 16 But nobody, nobody would help. And, uh, I reached in and grabbed a hold of the kid that was in the back, by the scruff of the neck, and pulled him out.
30:30 Speaker 02 Alright, so when you were coming out of your house and, and you're looking at that car, what was going through your head?
30:35 Speaker 16 Hmm, well, just trying to, try to help. I mean, I, I, I did what any normal person would do. I mean, you know, I just kept saying, "This is somebody's kid," you know what I mean? At the time, my daughter was like 16. And I'm saying to myself, you know, if something, God forbid, would ever happen to her, that I would hope someone would be there to help.
30:56 Speaker 02 Did you ever talk to your neighbors and ask them why they didn't come in there?
31:01 Speaker 16 Uh, you know what, that's, it's funny you brought that up because no, I've never, never brought it up. Never brought it up.
31:08 Speaker 02 How come?
31:09 Speaker 16 I don't know, I guess, uh, maybe I probably wouldn't like their answer. I, I don't know. Uh, I don't know why I've never asked them out.
31:19 Speaker 02 What do you think is the difference between you and, and those other people who just sort of stood by?
31:24 Speaker 16 Uh, I, I couldn't answer that. I couldn't answer that.
31:29 Speaker 05 So our bull girl, she didn't know. This guy didn't really know either. Somebody must be able to tell us something about what they were thinking at that moment that allowed them, that gave them the courage to do what they did.
31:41 Speaker 13 I can't give you a definite answer as to what propels people to do this, no.
31:44 Speaker 05 But we took one more shot with Walter. And he told us about a case, that of all the cases he's heard, this is the one that puzzles him the most.
31:53 Speaker 13 It's the case of Wesley James Autry, a construction worker from New York, 50-year-old man, who did jump into the track bed in a subway station to remove a fellow, a young man, who had fallen onto the track. The gentleman was 6'180 pounds. He was inert. And yet, Mr. Autry persisted despite the fact that a train was coming. There would come a point, at least in my estimation, where you would have to say, "I have to get out of here because I'm going to be killed. I'm not suicidal." But Mr. Autry didn't think that way. He and I part in this manner.
32:34 Speaker 13 What he did was, he lay atop the victim, between the rails, while the train passed over them. In the farthest reaches of my imagination, I can see myself jumping onto a subway track to attempt the rescue. What I can't see myself doing is lying atop the victim while the train passes over me.
32:57 Speaker 05 Making this story even more nuts? When we finally met up with Wesley Autry on the platform where this incident happened, 135th and Broadway, he explained to us that his daughters had been with him.
33:09 Speaker 17 They was OK. How old were your daughters? At that time, my daughter was 4 and 6, and this them there.
33:18 Speaker 05 Showed us picture.
33:20 Speaker 17 Oh, my God.
33:21 Speaker 05 Super cute.
33:22 Speaker 17 The one behind me is Shukey, and this the baby, Sashi.
33:26 Speaker 05 So when they're standing there, and this guy starts convulsing and then eventually falls off the platform, onto the tracks, right as a train is coming, his choice is pretty stark. In order to save this complete stranger, he's got to leave his daughters behind, potentially without a dad.
33:42 Speaker 17 I'm looking at him shaking and going into another seizure. For some strange reason, a boy out of nowhere said, "Don't worry about your own, don't worry about your daughters. You can do this."
33:52 Speaker 05 So he jumps. Runs to the guy.
33:56 Speaker 00 Is he conscious?
33:57 Speaker 17 No, no.
33:58 Speaker 05 Tries to grab the guy's hand.
33:59 Speaker 17 And each time I grab his hand, we'll slip apart. And when he slip, I look up, the train is getting closer. I grab his hand again, we'll slip apart. The train is closer.
34:08 Speaker 05 Fifty feet, twenty feet, ten feet, and then it's right there. And all he can do is grab the guy, get him in a bear hug, and flatten his body against the guy as much as he can.
34:23 Speaker 17 The first train car just grazed my cats.
34:26 Speaker 05 Oh my god. Train car went right over them.
34:29 Speaker 17 And when the train came to a stop, four to five cars passed over us. I looked them in the eye, I said, "Excuse me, you seem to have a seizure or something. I don't know you, you don't know me." So I just kept talking to him until he came through. And he was like, "Well, where are we?" I'm like, "We're underneath a train." He said, "Well, who are you?" I said, "I came down to save your life." So he kept asking me, "Are we dead, are we in heaven?" I gave him a slight pinch on his arm. He's like, "Ouch." I said, "See, you're very much alive."
34:57 Speaker 00 Have you, did you ever ask yourself at this point, like, "What am I doing here?" I mean, he asked it, "What am I doing here?" But what about you?
35:04 Speaker 17 I can hear the two ladies, we had my daughter standing in between their legs. I can hear my daughter screaming. So when that train come to a stop, I yelled up from underneath the train, "Excuse me, I'm the father, we're okay. I just want to let my daughters know that I'm okay, because I know that they are worried about me." Everybody start clapping.
35:23 Speaker 05 Can I ask you a question? So the point at which you said you heard a voice?
35:28 Speaker 17 Yes.
35:29 Speaker 05 That said, "I can do this."
35:30 Speaker 17 I can do this.
35:31 Speaker 05 What is amazing to me is that you left your daughters right here and dive after a guy you don't know.
35:38 Speaker 17 He was a stranger, total stranger. But you know what? The mission wasn't completed. I was chose for that.
35:45 Speaker 05 You felt chose, like you were...
35:47 Speaker 17 I felt chosen. I felt like I was the chosen one.
35:50 Speaker 05 Wow.
35:51 Speaker 00 For a religious person, though, I would wonder... Why me?
35:56 Speaker 17 Well, you know what?
35:59 Speaker 17 Maybe 20 years ago, I was supposed to be at a certain point.
36:04 Speaker 05 And then he explained to us exactly why he had jumped. He was the one guy who could. He said, right before his feet left the platform, this one specific moment from his life flashed to mind.
36:13 Speaker 17 This thing that happened, you know, I had a gun pulled to my temple, but, you know, it was a misfire, so, you know.
36:22 Speaker 00 A gun was put to your head and missed? So you were almost dead for a second or two?
36:26 Speaker 17 I was almost dead.
36:27 Speaker 00 Oh, so you think you might have been spared for a purpose?
36:29 Speaker 17 I was spared for a reason.
36:31 Speaker 05 After that moment, he says, when the gun went click and he didn't die, he always wondered, why had God spared him that moment? Until he was on the platform and he saw the guy fall off. He says then he knew, this is why.
36:45 Speaker 17 I can do this.
36:47 Speaker 05 He was just, I can do this?
36:48 Speaker 17 I can do this. That voice, when that voice said that you're gonna be okay, I knew everything was gonna work out.
37:02 Speaker 00 You know what I think, at the end of the day?
37:04 Speaker 05 What's that?
37:05 Speaker 00 I don't think that there's an answer to the question we asked. I don't think-
37:08 Speaker 05 A hero question?
37:09 Speaker 00 Why were you a hero? I don't think that any three of these heroes, I mean, the last one had the longest explanation. He had been selected for some purpose, but does he know why he was chosen? Not a clue.
37:20 Speaker 05 See, guy number three gives me something.
37:23 Speaker 00 What does he give you?
37:24 Speaker 05 Okay, so the first two, right? They have no idea.
37:27 Speaker 00 None.
37:27 Speaker 05 So there's just something in them that made them act. But guy number three is talking about circumstances. The world prepared him for that moment. Serendipity. So it makes me think, well, what if circumstances are just right? Maybe any of us could do that.
37:42 Speaker 16 I get a mailman, he used to say to me all the time, he says, how did you manage to do that up there? How did you manage to pull them kids out? I don't know if I could have done that. I said, well, you know what? Don't say you wouldn't do this or you wouldn't do that till you're put in that situation.
37:56 Speaker 05 In fact, when we asked Walter, how many nominations do you get a year? Are they hard to find?
38:01 Speaker 13 No, they are not hard at all to find. We are fortunate to be living in a society, regardless of what you hear elsewhere, we are fortunate to be living in a society where people do look out for others, even strangers.
38:13 Speaker 05 He told us, they've even had to up their guidelines to make it harder to win.
38:16 Speaker 13 Simply because of the vast number of heroic deeds that happen in day-to-day life.
38:26 Speaker 18 After some actual fake polls came to light, pollsters are in the hot seat. But they say, don't be too quick to dismiss the entire industry.
38:35 Speaker 19 People want to raise taxes on the rich. I can tell you that definitively because we know it from polling. And if we lose trust in polls, we have no way to understand what Americans want to be done.
38:48 Speaker 18 On this week's On the Media from WNYC. Find On the Media wherever you get your podcasts.
38:58 Speaker 05 Hey, this is Radiolab. I'm Jad Abumrad.
39:00 Speaker 00 I'm Robert Krillwich. Oh.
39:03 Speaker 05 Yes, would you like to say our topic, Robert?
39:05 Speaker 00 Our topic today is goodness.
39:07 Speaker 05 Niceness.
39:08 Speaker 00 Or altruism would be another bigger, fatter word.
39:11 Speaker 05 Yep. Thus far, we've met a couple of folks, individuals, who have struggled with altruism in some way.
39:16 Speaker 00 Now, we're going to sort of pull back and go from specifics to grand global.
39:23 Speaker 05 Strategy.
39:23 Speaker 00 Yes.
39:24 Speaker 20 Hello?
39:24 Speaker 05 Hello, hello? And we're going to tell you a really cool story, we think, that begins with this guy.
39:29 Speaker 20 My name is Robert Axelrod. I'm the Walgreen Professor for the Study of Human Understanding in the Department of Political Science and the Ford School of Public Policy of the University of Michigan. I know, that's a mouthful.
39:44 Speaker 00 That was like your dean was like looking over you and says, say it all, please. Say it all.
39:48 Speaker 20 Yeah, well, you know, you could just say, I'm a professor of public policy and political science or something.
39:53 Speaker 00 Well, but before he was all of that, Axelrod, when he was in high school, he was one of those guys who just loved computers.
39:59 Speaker 20 Well, yes, in 59, 1960, I hung around the Northwestern University Computer Center.
40:05 Speaker 00 59, 60, so what, were those large pieces of furniture in refrigerated buildings?
40:11 Speaker 20 They were. In fact, the whole campus had one computer, and they let me use it for 15 minutes here and 15 minutes there.
40:17 Speaker 05 And what would you do with the computer?
40:18 Speaker 20 What I did, I did a very simple computer simulation of hypothetical life forms and environments for a science project.
40:25 Speaker 00 Really?
40:26 Speaker 20 Yeah.
40:26 Speaker 00 You're a pre-geek, is what you are.
40:28 Speaker 05 Yes.
40:28 Speaker 00 Before the word had been invented.
40:29 Speaker 20 I think you could say that.
40:32 Speaker 00 But then, in 1962, when Axelrod was down in a computer basement, I guess, somewhere, all over the world, everybody else was watching one of the great dramas in modern times.
40:42 Speaker 21 Good evening, my fellow citizens.
40:44 Speaker 00 Unfold.
40:45 Speaker 20 The Cuban Missile Crisis.
40:46 Speaker 21 Within the past week... Unmistakable evidence has established the fact that a series of offensive missile sites is now in preparation on that imprisoned island.
40:58 Speaker 00 And Axelrod started thinking about the dilemma we were in.
41:00 Speaker 20 Well, each side wants to spend more money buying missiles and things.
41:04 Speaker 00 You know, we could build more bombs, but then they could build more bombs. It would be better if they would both stop, but if we stop and they don't...
41:11 Speaker 05 That'd be bad.
41:11 Speaker 00 Very bad.
41:12 Speaker 20 Yeah, and so I was interested, what's a... what were the conditions that would allow people to get out of this problem?
41:18 Speaker 00 And then he starts thinking, well, wait. Maybe I could use my computer to help me figure out...
41:22 Speaker 20 What's a good strategy for this?
41:24 Speaker 05 For something like the Cuban Missile Crisis?
41:26 Speaker 20 Well, yes, right.
41:27 Speaker 05 And what made you think that computers could help with that?
41:29 Speaker 20 Well, I came across a simple game called The Prisoner's Dilemma.
41:37 Speaker 05 Okay, so The Prisoner's Dilemma is a very famous thought experiment. It's a little tricky to describe, but I got a friend of mine, Andrew Zalay, who's written about The Prisoner's Dilemma in an upcoming book.
41:48 Speaker 22 Resilience: The Science of Why Things Bounce Back.
41:50 Speaker 05 I got him to lay it out for me. What is The Prisoner's Dilemma?
41:54 Speaker 22 So imagine that two bank robbers are hanging out across the street from the First National Bank. And the police pick them up. They've received a tip that these two guys are about to rob the bank.
42:08 Speaker 05 Got it?
42:09 Speaker 22 Yep.
42:09 Speaker 05 So the cops take these two guys back to the station, do the whole law and order thing, put them in different rooms.
42:14 Speaker 22 They walk into each one, let's call them Lucky and Joe. And they say to Lucky, "We have enough to make sure that you go away for a six-month sentence."
42:27 Speaker 05 But this is not really what the cops want. They want a longer sentence for one of these guys, so they make Lucky an offer.
42:33 Speaker 22 If you, Lucky, rat out Joe, and Joe doesn't say anything, you will go free, and Joe will go to jail for 10 years. If the reverse happens...
42:45 Speaker 05 Meaning if you say nothing and Joe rats you out?
42:47 Speaker 22 You're going to jail for 10 years, and he's gonna walk free.
42:51 Speaker 05 If you both end up ratting on each other, you both get five.
42:55 Speaker 22 Five years.
42:56 Speaker 05 Whereas if you both keep your mouths shut?
42:58 Speaker 22 You're each going to jail for six months for loitering.
43:01 Speaker 05 So somehow if Lucky and Joe could talk to each other, they'd both say, "Don't speak."
43:05 Speaker 22 Absolutely, but the big problem that Lucky and Joe have is they can't talk to each other.
43:12 Speaker 05 All right, so you're Lucky, okay? What do you do? Do you rat Joe out or not?
43:17 Speaker 00 Do I know this guy?
43:18 Speaker 05 Uh-uh.
43:20 Speaker 00 At all?
43:21 Speaker 05 I mean, you met for this one job, but tomorrow you'll never see him again.
43:24 Speaker 00 Ever.
43:24 Speaker 05 Ever.
43:25 Speaker 00 Well, like, if I knew him and I could trust him, then I think I know what I would do.
43:30 Speaker 05 You'd keep his mouth shut, because then you'd get six months, because he'd keep his mouth shut.
43:33 Speaker 00 It would be a sweet thing.
43:35 Speaker 05 Indeed.
43:35 Speaker 00 But, see, since I don't know him, what would happen if he rats me out?
43:38 Speaker 05 You'd go to jail for ten years. He'd go free, that bastard.
43:42 Speaker 00 Ten years.
43:43 Speaker 05 Yeah.
43:43 Speaker 00 But if I rat him out, then the worst I get is...
43:47 Speaker 05 Five years.
43:48 Speaker 00 Or, you know, I go away free. I'm totally free.
43:52 Speaker 05 Do it, Crow. Say what's in your heart.
43:53 Speaker 00 I'm gonna... I'm throwing him under the bus, Jack.
43:55 Speaker 05 Yes, throw him under.
43:56 Speaker 00 What's his name again?
43:57 Speaker 05 Joe.
43:58 Speaker 00 Joe.
43:58 Speaker 05 You see, he's already gone.
43:59 Speaker 00 I swear, you don't even remember him. You're dead to me, Joe.
44:03 Speaker 05 So you see, in this type of scenario where you don't know the guy, you have a very strong incentive...
44:09 Speaker 00 To rat the other guy out.
44:11 Speaker 05 Or, as the social scientists would say...
44:12 Speaker 00 To defect.
44:13 Speaker 20 That's right. If you play it only once, if you only meet somebody once, whatever the other guy does, you're better off defecting against them.
44:20 Speaker 05 Just here on out, whenever you hear the word defect, know that it means screw the other guy over.
44:24 Speaker 20 But the really interesting stuff happens if you play over and over again, if you're gonna meet the same people again.
44:29 Speaker 05 Because now you're thinking, should I help this guy out the next time? If he screwed me, should I screw him?
44:34 Speaker 21 But this secret: swift, extraordinary buildup of communist missiles.
44:39 Speaker 00 What do you do? You wanna cooperate, but you don't wanna get screwed.
44:44 Speaker 23 Right. You know, these kind of thoughts were paramount in those days because the prisoner's dilemma was being played between the two superpowers.
44:52 Speaker 00 This is our friend Steve Strogatz, the Cornell mathematician, who says, at that time, all kinds of folks...
44:57 Speaker 23 Political scientists, and economists, and psychologists, mathematicians.
45:01 Speaker 05 Were writing papers about the prisoner's dilemma.
45:03 Speaker 00 Literally, and thinking, come on, we've gotta be able to win this game if we're gonna play against the Russians, and we have to do it right.
45:10 Speaker 20 Exactly. But there was no consensus on the best way to do it. And so I was interested, what's a good strategy for this?
45:17 Speaker 00 And that's when Robert Axelrod, sitting down there in the basement, somewhere in the Midwest, with the big computer, that's when he had his idea.
45:25 Speaker 23 His approach, which was really novel at the time, was to conduct a computer tournament. A computer tournament?
45:33 Speaker 20 And invite the people that had come up with these different ideas to play with each other.
45:38 Speaker 23 In other words, what he said is, "All right, Mr. Wise Guy, you've written so-and-so many articles on The Prisoner's Dilemma, you think you understand it. How about joining this tournament where you have to submit a program that will play Prisoner's Dilemma against programs submitted by the other experts? We'll have a round robin."
45:57 Speaker 20 Right, try these different programs against each other.
45:59 Speaker 00 So all these computer guys are brought to Caesar's Palace in Las Vegas, and they all wear tuxedos, and they're all sat down at a table?
46:06 Speaker 20 No.
46:06 Speaker 23 It's a nice image, but what really happened was everyone submitted their programs to Axelrod.
46:11 Speaker 20 They would mail their entries to me. But there was a trophy.
46:15 Speaker 00 There was a trophy.
46:17 Speaker 20 So I wrote to people, and I said, "If you win, I'll send you a trophy." You know, a little plaque that says you won the computer tournament.
46:24 Speaker 00 Okay, so here's the deal. Every program will play every other program 200 times. There will be points in each round, and then Axelrod will total the scores.
46:33 Speaker 20 And see what actually worked.
46:35 Speaker 00 By which he means, in the long run, even if you lose some rounds here and there, one of these strategies is going to beat all the others, meaning it'll let you survive. Maybe even prosper. That's the game.
46:48 Speaker 20 That's right.
46:48 Speaker 23 And can you introduce us to some of the contestants?
46:51 Speaker 20 Yeah.
46:52 Speaker 23 So there was one program called Massive Retaliatory Strike.
46:56 Speaker 20 On the first move, it just cooperates.
46:58 Speaker 00 But then, as soon as the other program doesn't cooperate?
47:01 Speaker 23 It would then retaliate for the rest of the game.
47:05 Speaker 23 Like, "Sorry, man, you blew it."
47:07 Speaker 20 "I'll never trust you again."
47:08 Speaker 23 Yeah, "That's it for you." This is like the way my wife is. Whenever a guy in her earlier life stood her up, that was it. Game over.
47:20 Speaker 00 But there were also some trickier programs.
47:22 Speaker 23 I mean, some crafty ones tried to make a model of the opponent.
47:25 Speaker 00 Like, you mentioned one that was called Tester.
47:27 Speaker 23 So Tester would see what you were like. It would start by being mean.
47:33 Speaker 23 And then if you start retaliating, it backs off and says, you know, "Ho, ho, chill out. It's okay, man," and you know, and then starts cooperating for a while. Until it throws in another.
47:44 Speaker 00 Just to test the other guy, because after all, it's called Tester.
47:48 Speaker 20 Yeah, so Tester is kind of designed to see how much it could get away with.
47:51 Speaker 23 I mean, it sounds kind of sensible in a way. I mean, mean, but...
47:54 Speaker 20 Well, but if you see, if you think about what happens if these two players play each other.
47:58 Speaker 00 If Tester plays Massive Retaliation 200 times...
48:02 Speaker 20 Pretty soon, the Tester will defect. And then Massive Retaliation will never cooperate again.
48:09 Speaker 00 Screw you, pal.
48:10 Speaker 20 Yeah, no, screw you.
48:12 Speaker 00 Screw you.
48:12 Speaker 20 Let's go.
48:13 Speaker 00 Screw me.
48:13 Speaker 20 You screw me.
48:14 Speaker 00 You come in here.
48:14 Speaker 20 Screw you.
48:15 Speaker 00 You come in here.
48:15 Speaker 20 I'll come through this glass. So in fact, they'll do very badly, both of them.
48:20 Speaker 00 When you're sitting there, did you have a hunch as to which would be the most successful program?
48:26 Speaker 20 Well, I didn't know, and which is why I wanted to do it. But I did have a hunch that, you know, thousands or tens of thousands of lines of code would be needed to have a pretty competent program.
48:37 Speaker 00 So when the mailman delivers the fattest envelope to your house, you're like, "This could be the one."
48:42 Speaker 20 Well, yes, right. Now, it didn't turn out that way.
48:46 Speaker 00 When it was all said and done, when he loaded all the programs into the computer, when they'd all played each other 200 times, the program that won?
48:56 Speaker 20 It's really two lines of code.
48:59 Speaker 23 Two lines of code?
49:00 Speaker 20 Yeah, it's got a simple name. It's called Tit for Tat.
49:03 Speaker 00 First line of code?
49:05 Speaker 23 Be... Nice. Nice? Yeah, nice. Nice is a technical word in this game. Nice means I never am nasty first.
49:15 Speaker 20 And after that...
49:16 Speaker 00 Second line of code?
49:17 Speaker 20 It just does what the other player did on the previous move.
49:20 Speaker 23 Oh.
49:22 Speaker 20 So if the other player has just cooperated, it'll cooperate. And if the other player has just defected, it'll defect.
49:27 Speaker 23 It retaliates on the next move. Couldn't be clearer. On the other hand, it only retaliates that one time. I mean, unless provoked further. It does its retaliation, and now bygones are bygones, and that's it. So wait, how exactly did it win? I mean, can you give us a sense of why it won? Okay, so let's suppose, here, let's take an extreme case of some very simple programs. One of them I'll call Jesus.
49:58 Speaker 00 Just for the sake of our name.
50:00 Speaker 23 Now, the Jesus program cooperates on every turn. That is, it's always, it's always, you know.
50:06 Speaker 00 Good.
50:06 Speaker 23 Yes.
50:07 Speaker 05 So the Jesus program is a simple algorithm that says, "Always be good."
50:11 Speaker 00 Good, good, good, good, good.
50:12 Speaker 23 That's right. And let's say the other program is the Lucifer program, which, no matter what, always is bad.
50:20 Speaker 05 Okay. These are your two extremes, says Steve.
50:22 Speaker 00 And of course, most programs and most people fall somewhere in the middle.
50:25 Speaker 05 Right.
50:25 Speaker 00 But in tit for tat, you've got a strategy that can swing both ways.
50:29 Speaker 05 For instance, with Jesus, tit for tat starts by cooperating, as does Jesus.
50:34 Speaker 23 And then they're going to keep cooperating for the whole 200 rounds.
50:40 Speaker 00 Which is, you know.
50:41 Speaker 05 Good.
50:42 Speaker 23 But now, let's suppose it plays Lucifer.
50:44 Speaker 05 Where there's no chance to cooperate.
50:45 Speaker 00 Then, says Steve, tit for tat just plays good defense. So when Lucifer does his thing, tit for tat retaliates.
50:56 Speaker 00 And they pretty much keep doing that.
50:58 Speaker 23 Yeah.
50:58 Speaker 00 And stay even. So in other words.
51:00 Speaker 23 It's a very robust program. It elicits cooperation if the opponent has any inclination to cooperate, but it doesn't take any guff.
51:09 Speaker 05 And it wins. So you might say, in evolutionary terms, this program?
51:14 Speaker 00 Is the fittest.
51:15 Speaker 23 So actually, Axelrod played an evolutionary version of his tournament. That is, he had these programs, after they played their tournament, get a chance to reproduce copies of themselves, according to how well they did.
51:27 Speaker 05 You mean, the winners would get to have more babies?
51:28 Speaker 23 Yeah.
51:29 Speaker 05 And then would the babies play each other?
51:31 Speaker 23 Yeah, he ran them again. I mean, he ran them for many generations. And so, like, suppose you have a world of Lucifers, and there are a few tit for tat players out there. Can they thrive? Can cooperation emerge in this horribly hostile world?
51:45 Speaker 05 Wow, what an interesting question.
51:46 Speaker 23 So he looked at that, and the answer was, if you have enough of them, so that they have enough chance of meeting each other, then they can actually invade and take over the world, even if the world starts horribly mean.
52:01 Speaker 23 I mean, what I take to be the big message, though, I mean, what always sent chills down my spine is that we see this version of morality around the world. Be upright, forgiving, but retaliatory. I mean, that sounds to me like the Old Testament. It's not turn the other cheek, it's an eye for an eye, but not 10 eyes for an eye. And to think that it's not something that's handed down by our teachers or by God, but that it's something that came from biology. I like that argument personally.
52:36 Speaker 00 From biology. Now, do we know whether the math has anything to do with real people in real-life situations? Or are we just abstracting behavior here? Is this wise, or is this just math?
52:56 Speaker 23 This is what's so impressive to me about Axelrod's work. So, he's not just playing math games. He tries to tie this to history and politics as seen.
53:06 Speaker 20 I like to scan journals. One of my, I wouldn't say it's past Angus, it's part of my profession, but I came across a book called "The Live and Let Live System in World War I."
53:17 Speaker 05 So here's where we jump away from the math and the computer tournaments and into something very real.
53:22 Speaker 24 The war began late in July 1914.
53:26 Speaker 05 That's Stan.
53:27 Speaker 24 Stanley Weintraub.
53:28 Speaker 05 Expert in World War I.
53:29 Speaker 24 Evan Few Professor Emeritus at Penn State.
53:32 Speaker 05 And the story that Stan's going to help us tell takes place on what was called "The Western Front," which was basically these two lines of trenches.
53:39 Speaker 24 Very close to each other, a few hundred yards apart.
53:42 Speaker 05 And they stretched for hundreds of miles. And that fall...
53:45 Speaker 24 In November, the weather turned bad. Heavy rains, then it became icy.
53:53 Speaker 24 And then slush, and then snow. It became disgusting because the trenches also were filled with rats. Rats. The rats went after not only the food, but after corpses.
54:07 Speaker 05 And it was oddly in this miserable, disgusting hellhole that something quite amazing happened. No one quite knows how it started, but one day, maybe around daybreak, let's say, while the two sides were fighting, some of the British soldiers-
54:20 Speaker 24 Stop firing long enough to have breakfast.
54:26 Speaker 05 And as they were eating, they noticed, hm, the Germans stopped too, to have their breakfast. And when they were both done-
54:31 Speaker 24 They'd begin firing again.
54:34 Speaker 05 Next morning, same thing. British take their breakfast break at about the same time. The Germans do the same thing. Morning after that, the same thing, and then the next. And after a while-
54:43 Speaker 20 Both sides caught on that if they didn't interrupt the other one, then they wouldn't be interrupted.
54:51 Speaker 01 On the whole, there is silence.
54:56 Speaker 05 This is from a letter a British soldier sent home to his wife at the time.
54:59 Speaker 01 After all, if you prevent your enemy from drawing his rations, his remedy is simple. He will prevent you from drawing yours.
55:07 Speaker 05 When Axelrod read this-
55:08 Speaker 20 I thought, gee, this sounds very familiar.
55:11 Speaker 05 Line one of "Tip for Tat," "Be nice first." Now, the Brits probably didn't mean to be nice first when they started the breakfast truce, but it happened, and then the Germans reciprocated, which is line two. Now, keep in mind, these two sides are at war, and implicit in line two is a threat. If you mess with me, I'm gonna mess with you.
55:30 Speaker 20 Well, think about snipers, for example. There's letters where they explain where the snipers would shoot at a tree over and over and over again, showing that in fact, they were really accurate, meaning that if they wanted to kill you, they'd get you.
55:42 Speaker 05 And this was going on during the breakfast truce. And these little agreements, you know, like, "I'm gonna be nice to you, but I could kick your ass, don't forget." Well, these little truces spread all up and down the Western Front until things really changed.
55:56 Speaker 05 Fast forward to December, Christmas Eve.
55:58 Speaker 24 The climate was just about freezing on Christmas Eve. And the Germans had a tradition of tabletop Christmas trees, small trees.
56:07 Speaker 05 For weeks, he said, the German government had been-
56:09 Speaker 24 Shipping small trees, literally, to the trenches. Hundreds and hundreds of trees.
56:13 Speaker 05 And that night, on Christmas Eve-
56:15 Speaker 24 At dusk, the Germans began putting up their trees-
56:17 Speaker 05 Mounted them on the rim of their trench-
56:19 Speaker 24 And lit candles on them, singing a Christmas carol.
56:27 Speaker 24 The British, who might have been no more than 50 or 70 yards away, crawled forward into no man's land to see better.
56:35 Speaker 05 And then they were spotted. Here's a letter from a German soldier sent home to his family, which describes what happened next.
56:42 Speaker 25 I shouted to our enemies that we didn't wish to shoot. I said, "We could speak to each other." At first, there was silence.
56:51 Speaker 05 And then very slowly, out of the darkness, the British guys approached.
56:55 Speaker 25 And so we came together and shook hands.
56:59 Speaker 26 See, this is where I start to think, are you making this up? Because this is where it starts to sound sort of crazy to me.
57:05 Speaker 05 That's Pat Walters, our producer.
57:07 Speaker 24 It sounds as if this is being made up. And the result was, for many decades, people assumed that this was just myth. It couldn't possibly have happened. But we know it had happened because we have the letters that the British and the Germans sent back home. We know that they met in darkness and decided, "Why don't we have a truce in the morning?"
57:28 Speaker 05 Next morning, thousands of soldiers put down their rifles, climbed out of their trenches into no man's land, and started hanging out with each other. A lot of us went over and talked to them, and this lasted the whole morning. I talked to several of them, and I must say, they seemed extraordinarily fine men. Soldiers got together, started fires, cooked Christmas dinners-
57:48 Speaker 24 Swapped presents and drank.
57:51 Speaker 05 The Germans hauled out these enormous-
57:52 Speaker 24 Barrels of beer.
57:53 Speaker 05 They traded stuff.
57:54 Speaker 24 Cigars and trinkets.
57:56 Speaker 05 Even helped one another.
57:56 Speaker 24 Buried the dead.
57:59 Speaker 05 And in some places on the Western Front, this period of goodwill lasted a whole week.
58:07 Speaker 05 But then, the generals found out.
58:10 Speaker 20 They were very angry about this and they said, "We didn't send you to the front to be nice to the other guys. We sent them to kill them."
58:15 Speaker 00 If the general says, "Hey, I want you to shoot those Germans," that's an order.
58:21 Speaker 20 Well, then they would...
58:22 Speaker 00 Wouldn't that...
58:22 Speaker 20 "Oh geez, sorry, General, I missed, but I'll try again better next time."
58:25 Speaker 00 I see.
58:26 Speaker 20 The way the generals finally figured out how to disrupt this whole thing is they would said, "Okay, you guys go out on a raid and I want you to bring back a prisoner or a corpse."
58:36 Speaker 05 In other words, "Show me a scalp." That's an order.
58:38 Speaker 20 And that messed things up royally.
58:42 Speaker 05 Here's a letter from a British soldier whose unit contained a band, which was apparently pretty common. He writes this letter about one of the moments when the truce vanished.
58:51 Speaker 01 At six minutes to midnight, the band opened with "Die Vokte Am Rieh."
58:59 Speaker 05 Which is a German patriotic anthem. So, some of the Germans, according to this letter, climbed up onto the rim of their trench to listen to this English band playing their song.
59:12 Speaker 01 Then, as the last notes sounded, every grenade-firing rifle, trench-mortar, and bomb-throwing machine let fly simultaneously into the German trench.
59:26 Speaker 05 So you can imagine the Germans that weren't killed would have felt betrayed. They'd just been hanging out with these guys, and the next night, they would have attacked back, and the British would have attacked them back, and then the Germans would have retaliated against them, and on and on and on.
59:41 Speaker 20 And it would kind of echo back and forth forever.
59:43 Speaker 05 And that's what happened.
59:44 Speaker 24 There were immense casualties, as many as 50,000 casualties in a day.
59:50 Speaker 05 And this, says Axelrod, is where you see sort of the dark side of tit-for-tat.
59:54 Speaker 20 One of the weaknesses of the tit-for-tat strategy, or one of the problems with it, is these echoes.
59:59 Speaker 05 Not just echoes of good, obviously, but echoes of violence.
1:00:02 Speaker 20 Could get bad. So, what I found, though, was that instead of playing pure tit-for-tat, where you always defect if the other guy defects...
1:00:10 Speaker 05 There are certain circumstances, he says, and this I find completely fascinating, where you want to modify that second line of code, so that you're not always retaliating, you're nearly always retaliating.
1:00:21 Speaker 20 Right. If you were a little bit generous, by which I mean, say, 10% of the time, you don't defect, then what happens is that these echoes will stop, and I would call that generous tit-for-tat.
1:00:33 Speaker 05 So, this is kind of interesting. Like, we started with Moses, you know, eye for an eye. But here it's saying, maybe for every nine parts Moses, you need one part Jesus.
1:00:42 Speaker 00 Meaning, like, turn the other cheek?
1:00:44 Speaker 05 Turn the other cheek.
1:00:45 Speaker 00 It sounds like you've described like a cooking recipe or something.
1:00:47 Speaker 05 Well...
1:00:48 Speaker 00 Like, nine parts, one thing...
1:00:50 Speaker 05 Yeah, I mean, if you abstracted, it's kind of a recipe. It's a recipe for life.
1:00:53 Speaker 00 But it isn't a recipe. That ignores the deep fact of it. Look, if I were punching you in the face right now, what are you gonna do?
1:01:00 Speaker 05 I'm gonna punch you back.
1:01:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I'm gonna punch you back. You punch me back, and we're in pain.
1:01:05 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:01:05 Speaker 00 And somehow, in the middle of being blasted by my powerful fist, you have to come up with the moral courage to say, "I think I'm gonna kiss this guy now." And that is not, as you well know, that is not an easy thing to do.
1:01:18 Speaker 05 All right, but you're making it all personal. My point is, if you zoom out, this is a strategy that just seems to be woven into the fabric of the cosmos. It works for computers, it works for people, it probably works for amoeba, okay? It just works.
1:01:32 Speaker 00 And you think that exists on some higher plane?
1:01:35 Speaker 05 I do, I do.
1:01:36 Speaker 00 I don't. I think this is still, as you just called it, very personal. I think a person has to choose to be kind.
1:01:43 Speaker 05 All right, I'm gonna make that choice right now, then, okay? Even though you're irritating me, I'm gonna say to you, "Robert, you look very nice today."
1:01:49 Speaker 00 You know what I'm gonna do to you?
1:01:53 Speaker 05 All right, enough of this. Radiolab.org is our online home. You can read lots of stuff there, and you can subscribe to our podcast.
1:02:00 Speaker 00 It's W-W-W dot...
1:02:02 Speaker 05 That's implied.
1:02:03 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:02:09 Speaker 27 Hi, I'm Shivam Sharmuri, and I'm from Mumbai, and here are the staff credits. Radiolab is hosted by Lulu Miller and Latif Nasser. Soren Wheeler is our executive editor. Sarah Sandback is our executive director.
1:02:28 Speaker 27 Our managing editor is Pat Walters. Dylan Keefe is our director of sound design. Our staff includes Jeremy Bloom, W. Harry Fortuna, David Gable, Maria Paz Gutierrez, Sindhu Niyana Sambanthan, Matt Kielty, Mona Madgaukar, Annie McEwen, Alex Neeson, Sarah Kari, Anisa Vidza, Aryan Whack, Molly Webster, and Jessica Young. With help from Rebecca Rand. Our fact-checkers are Diane Kelly, Emily Krieger, Anna Pujol Mazini,
1:03:12 Speaker 27 and Natalie Middleton.
1:03:17 Speaker 28 Leadership support for Radiolab's science programming is provided by the Simons Foundation and the John Templeton Foundation. Foundational support for Radiolab was provided by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.
Previous The Alien in the Room Next Fertility Cliff Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated