Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
The episode traces the origin of the phrase "I can neither confirm nor deny" (the Glomar response) from the CIA's 1974 recovery of the Soviet submarine K-129. After the sub broke apart during the lift and the story leaked to the press, CIA lawyer Walt Logan devised the response in roughly 30 minutes to navigate the tension between the newly empowered Freedom of Information Act and the legal obligation to protect intelligence sources and methods. The phrase has since spread to the Department of Commerce, Treasury, Energy, and the CDC, becoming boilerplate across government.
The episode also explores how journalists and the ACLU strategize to get around Glomar responses—by finding specific mentions of documents by public officials and then FOIA-ing those exact items—and how the response functions as a multi-year litigation delay that lets the government win by attrition. The human cost is illustrated by Irina Zhuravina, widow of the K-129's second-in-command, whose husband's death certificate read "Cause of death: presumed dead," a phrase she has called "horrible" and "inhumane" for 30 years.
- The Glomar response was developed in about 30 minutes by CIA lawyer Walt Logan in 1975 to answer FOIA requests about Project Azorian without revealing or denying the existence of classified information. 18:29
- The Glomar response has spread beyond the CIA to the Department of Commerce, Treasury, Energy, and the CDC, making it a standard government boilerplate. 20:27
- Journalists can circumvent Glomar responses by finding a specific mention of a document by a public official, then FOIA-ing that exact item by title. 25:09
- A Glomar response effectively imposes two years of litigation before the substantive argument even begins, meaning the government often wins by the time truth emerges. 25:48
- The Soviet government's refusal to acknowledge the K-129's loss resulted in a death certificate for the crew reading "Cause of death: presumed dead," which the widow called inhumane. 28:50
Highlights
- 8:15
The Eight-Fingered Ocean Clawstrategy
The CIA's plan to recover the K-129 involved building a gargantuan eight-fingered claw on a ship, lowering it three miles on a pipe string, and yanking the submarine into a chamber—like a carnival claw game at ocean depth.
- 10:39
The Sub Breaks Apartstory
About 9,000 feet from the surface, the operators noticed their TV feeds had not refreshed in 15 minutes. The real-time image showed they had lost most of the submarine, including the section with the nuclear missiles.
- 18:29
Thirty Minutes of Legal Geniusinsight
Walt Logan, the CIA's Associate General Counsel, developed the Glomar response in roughly half an hour. That single formulation has since tortured journalists and lawyers for nearly four decades.
- 18:37
The Glomar Response Textstrategy
The response reads: "We can neither confirm nor deny the existence of the information requested. But hypothetically, if such data were to exist, the subject matter would be classified and could not be disclosed." It satisfies truthfulness without revealing anything.
- 20:27
Glomar Spreads Across Governmentdata
Since 1975, the response has been used by the Department of Commerce, Treasury, Energy, and the CDC—agencies that are not obviously tied to national security secrets.
- 22:11
The Thief Analogyinsight
Robert Quillich compares the government's logic to a thief asking a cop if he's being investigated: saying yes lets the thief hide, saying no reveals the cop is bad at his job. Either answer exposes the system.
- 25:58
The Pen Strategy Against Glomarstrategy
The ACLU's approach: over the two-year litigation window, search for any public official in the same agency who mentions the document in passing. Once a specific title or reference exists, the government can no longer deny the document's existence.
- 28:50
A Death Certificate That Says Nothingstory
Irina Zhuravina, widow of the K-129's second-in-command, reads her husband's death certificate on Russian television: "Cause of death, presumed dead." She asks who authored this "horrible, inhumane document" and says it is what they have lived with for 30 years.
About this episode
Whether it comes from government spokespeople or celebrity publicists, the phrase “can neither confirm nor deny” is the perfect non-denial denial.
Transcript
5,252 words · 8 speakers
Topics
- Glomar Response
- CIA Secrets
- Cold War
- Freedom of Information Act
- National Security
- Government Transparency
- Submarine Recovery
- Journalism and Secrecy
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated