Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast We Bought a Property Together, and Now We Hate Each Other⎟Ep. 2366 About this episode We bought a property together… and now we hate each other. It sounds dramatic, but it happens more often than you think. In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack three real New Zealand cases where co-ownership went badly wrong — and the one document that could have prevented every single one. You’ll learn:3 true stories of property partnerships that ended up in courtWhy doesn’t the bank care who “stopped paying”The simple agreement that could save you years of stress If you’re thinking about buying with a friend, sibling, partner, or even your in-laws – this episode is a must-listen before you sign anything. Because love is blind, but money isn’t. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obers Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to hear about, we bought a house together and now we hate each other. The three real stories of Kiwis who bought property together and it all went wrong. And the one document that could have prevented every single case. Now, people often ask, should I buy a property with a friend or my brother or my partner? And what we often say is that it can be a good idea and it often works for a while. But you need to think about what happens when it doesn't. Because I read about the most interesting story where two friends in Palmerston North got together and they decided to buy a house for about 600 grand.
0:56 Speaker 00 This was in 2017.
0:59 Speaker 01 It's quite an expensive house for Palmer for that time.
1:01 Speaker 00 It would have been quite a nice house, but these are two older ladies with families.
1:05 Speaker 01 More established.
1:06 Speaker 00 More established. Don't pretend like you're the nice one. Well, one of them was because friend number one puts in 108K. Friend number two only puts in 11K.
1:16 Speaker 01 Oh yeah, sounds about right.
1:18 Speaker 00 And then the friendship falls apart and it falls apart bad, right? So friend number two, who put in less money, her kids start threatening to cut friend number one's throat.
1:29 Speaker 01 When you say falls apart, threatening to slit someone's throat is pretty much the extreme of falling apart, yeah.
1:38 Speaker 00 Well, I mean, this is why I don't want to move in with you. I mean, who knows what Eliza's going to threaten.
1:44 Speaker 01 I'd rather end to cut your throat faster than she would.
1:47 Speaker 00 In fact, what ended up happening, friend number one started walling off and putting a gate in the house so that friend number two's children couldn't get down the hall to attack her.
1:57 Speaker 01 Eliza would do that.
1:58 Speaker 00 And then on top of that, friend number two, who put in less money, she stops paying the mortgage, then friend number one moves out, then comes back. And when she does, she finds that her very expensive plasma screen TV smashed up.
2:13 Speaker 00 I mean, we're laughing just because it's bad, right? Like, that's about as bad as it can get.
2:17 Speaker 01 Hang on, the TV being smashed is worse than the throat slitting?
2:20 Speaker 00 No, it's all together, isn't it?
2:22 Speaker 01 All together, okay.
2:22 Speaker 00 And she's had to wall herself into one part of the house. Then she's worried that, oh gosh, if there's a fire, I'm not going to be able to get out because I've locked myself in. Can't get my keys out, jingle, jingle, to get the gate open.
2:34 Speaker 01 Just for context, if you touch Ed's screen of his computer, he basically wants to murder you. So, I mean, this is, this is pretty extreme now.
2:41 Speaker 00 Yes, but that's just a viable manslaughter. And I suppose there's a really big issue because what happens if friend number two stops paying her share of the mortgage?
2:51 Speaker 01 So sometimes people think that if you go into a JV together, you're both responsible for your part of the mortgage. And then the bank's going to say, oh, well, well, Ed's paid his part, but Andrew hasn't paid his part. So all good, we'll just, we'll chase up Andrew, not Ed. Doesn't work like that. So mortgages are what's called jointly and severally liable. So if I miss my part, they're going to chase both of us for the entire repayment.
3:15 Speaker 00 So what happens when it gets this bad in terms of two friends together? Well, you end up going to court, right? And the judge ordered that the house be sold and the money split because he says, look, this is the only realistic solution. Now, after all of the loans and all of the costs were paid, there was only a hundred and two grand remaining. This is a couple of years later.
3:37 Speaker 01 So that's less than their entire, their collective deposit, right?
3:40 Speaker 00 That's right. So their collective deposit was, what was it? I'll have to add it up quickly.
3:44 Speaker 01 Hundred and twenty grand, so.
3:45 Speaker 00 About a hundred and twenty grand. And the Palmerston North property market had gone up by about eighty grand at this point. So, so they're both gone backwards and, and certainly gone backwards more than the market.
3:57 Speaker 01 And how do you divide that money then?
3:59 Speaker 00 Well, in the end, the judge looked at all of the circumstances and gave it all back to friend number one because of the poor behaviour of friend number two.
4:07 Speaker 01 Friend number two is going to be very angry now.
4:10 Speaker 00 But on top of, well, I mean, she's got to live in a house and not pay the mortgage, right?
4:14 Speaker 01 This would have been an expensive court process as well.
4:17 Speaker 00 Well, that's exactly right because the big issue is they didn't have that document we're going to talk about now. So what went wrong in this situation?
4:26 Speaker 01 So because they didn't have any agreements or think about how to structure the property ownership, what they missed out on was what's called a property sharing agreement. Now, basically, this is kind of like your breakup agreement in the event that something goes wrong with the property. So. This will establish how the property is owned and who gets rights to it. Now, there are two ways to own a house with someone. Either joint tenancy, where both owners have an equal interest. So if Ed and I own a property together and I die, highly probable, then the property automatically passes on to the other person. Now, that's very normal for married couples, right? Because you would expect in the instance that I die, that Lauren might inherit the half of the house that was mine.
5:11 Speaker 00 Oh, what about my share?
5:12 Speaker 01 Now, yeah, now from a friendship standpoint, where maybe like in this example, where two people are living in here and you wouldn't expect that the surviving partner in the in the deal ends up with the other half, you can have what's called tenants in common, which means that each owner has a defined share. Now, that could be 50 50 or it could be split 70 30, for example. And and in this case, you know, again, someone put in a lesser amount of money. So maybe you divide it to account for that. Now, in this instance, if I die, then my share goes via my will to whoever I've allocated those funds to. So if Ed and I both get kicked out of our respective homes, we buy a property together as tenants in common. We own it 50 50.
5:55 Speaker 01 In the event that I die, my half goes to the cats protection league.
6:00 Speaker 00 But what these guys should have done is decided, made the decision. And this is the part that sounds quite boring, but they're important. You should have defined in this situation, are you going to be joint tenancy, which possibly might not be appropriate? More common would be that they they buy tenants in common because they're friends. And then they could have that discussion about, well, do we own this 50 50? Or because friend one put in more deposit, does she own more of it? Now, that's something that you might have had a discussion about. But if it's not in writing, negotiated with a lawyer, it doesn't count for anything, right? It's quite funny. One thing I never actually knew before I started researching for this podcast, what tenants in common really mean.
6:41 Speaker 01 Oh, really?
6:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, because I know that that our lawyer, who we both use, she always puts tenants in common whenever I've bought a property, whether it was with my wife or or with you. And I thought, okay, I don't know what that means, but okay, sign it away. So all good, fine. But now I just realised like, oh.
6:59 Speaker 01 That's quite a good way of doing it.
7:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, it's not bad. Now, we're very motored on this show, so this other story caught my eye and walk us through the details.
7:10 Speaker 01 This is a wild one. So saddle up for this one here. So there is a throuple.
7:16 Speaker 00 Now you.
7:16 Speaker 01 What's a throuple? So that is when there are three people in the relationship and this was in Auckland, of course. And I remember reading about this in the Herald and basically you've got this married couple, right? And they're married back in 1993 and then in 2002, they think they're going to spice things up and they meet Fiona.
7:35 Speaker 00 Do you know how it actually happened? Cause I started to get into the details for this.
7:38 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:39 Speaker 00 What happened was wifey is overseas, right?
7:42 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:43 Speaker 00 And then the husband meets Fiona.
7:45 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah.
7:45 Speaker 00 They settle up, wife comes back from overseas, meets Fiona. How wonderful. They're all going to be together.
7:52 Speaker 01 Really?
7:52 Speaker 00 Yeah. How interesting is that?
7:54 Speaker 01 Really?
7:55 Speaker 00 I know.
7:56 Speaker 01 Okay.
7:56 Speaker 00 Angela, don't go overseas.
7:58 Speaker 01 How long was she away for? The wife away for? Was it like a weekend trip to Sydney?
8:03 Speaker 00 I think it's about six weeks.
8:04 Speaker 01 Six weeks? Oh. Now, anyway, Fiona's on the scene now and they form this free way relationship and they move into a four hectare property out in Kumu. Where they can commit all their sins in privacy. Now, the interesting part.
8:20 Speaker 00 Love is in a sin, Andrew.
8:25 Speaker 01 Now, the interesting part, they purchase this property in Fiona's name. So Fiona's number three, right? I'm just gonna have to get number them now and they purchased for 533K. She puts in a 40K deposit and they borrow the rest in Fiona's name. Now, lo and behold, poor old Paul gets sick of being told what to do by two women now. And so eventually his wife says, you know what? I'm out. So she leaves.
8:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. So wife number one's now out.
8:54 Speaker 01 She's gone. Then the following year, the husband thinks, you know what? This, I'm still not so keen on this whole thing. And so he moves out as well. Now, at this point, the house has gone from half a million bucks to two million. Now remember Fiona, number three, she's the one that owns the property. She's the one that bought it. But wife number one thinks, look at this. I've had to put up with all this. I want my share. So she applies to the court to find out how much does she get?
9:23 Speaker 00 Now, this is where it gets complicated and interesting. And just what happens when wife number one takes Fiona to court to get a share of her house?
9:34 Speaker 01 So it goes to the family court, then the high court, then the court of appeal, then to the supreme court. Like, that's the top court.
9:42 Speaker 00 Ain't no privy council no more.
9:44 Speaker 01 No, and this whole case takes six years to get wrapped up. And in the end.
9:51 Speaker 00 Did you know it only got wrapped up last year?
9:54 Speaker 01 Really?
9:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, twenty twenty five.
9:56 Speaker 01 I remember reading about it and, and, and in the end Fiona, the original owner, person number three, she has to pay out six hundred K each to the original husband and wife.
10:10 Speaker 00 Yeah, so she's down one point two mil.
10:12 Speaker 01 But that's, that's madness though, isn't it? Because at that stage, like you've paid out one point two of a two million dollar house. Where's Fiona's share?
10:19 Speaker 00 Well, it's the, it's the other six hundred K that's in there. Because what ended up happening?
10:24 Speaker 01 But they'd be dead on that. There's not equity.
10:26 Speaker 00 Well, uh, we're assuming she's paid, paid down some of it over the twenty years. But here's the, here's the issue. Fiona was trying to say, well, hang on, hang on, hang on. This isn't three separate relationships. I don't have a relationship with him and a relationship with her. And they have one together.
10:43 Speaker 01 They should get half.
10:44 Speaker 00 This is a three way, so this should, they should get half. The court said, no, no, no, no, no. We view it as three separate relationships. So you've got to pay out a share to both of them. I really feel for her and obviously if she could go back in time, she might've decided to get a relationship property agreement.
11:00 Speaker 01 You kind of think though, those two are married. I'm just a girlfriend or whatever the hell's going on. Like, I could understand you'd think that you'd be protected because how do you be de facto, or considered de facto with a married couple?
11:15 Speaker 00 Well, that's why it went. Through all of these layers and the Supreme Court ended up saying, you know what? Even though the law talks about couples, that is not exclusively two people. So actually we're going to push it back to the family court and the family court can decide. Now, it was a split decision, right? But three out of the five judges said, yep, we're going to consider this. There is a relationship property considerations. We're going to push it back to a lower court to decide what happens. Now, the reason why this is so interesting. The night after I was like researching for this, right? Cause we've got to research these stories, right? Like, I don't know them off the top of my head. I was tweeting one of my friends. Uh, she had the story about throuples without going into all the details. And she said, well, do you know what?
11:59 Speaker 00 I've got a friend, he, I can't remember what he does, but he, but he earned some good money. And he ended up in a relationship with a girl who already was in a relationship. Now, it's not a three-way relationship, it's not a throuple, but.
12:15 Speaker 01 It's a, it's a flow down.
12:16 Speaker 00 But girlfriend, is that, is that what it's called?
12:18 Speaker 01 I just made that up.
12:19 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah. Anyway, so the girl and her original boyfriend move into the house that new boyfriend lives in, right? They all share like resources and like they're pretty free flowing with income.
12:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
12:34 Speaker 00 Anyway, I said, he needs to get a relationship property agreement. They need to talk about this because then I shared the story about Fiona and what happens in 20 years. And then he loses not half of his, of his assets, but potentially two thirds of it, right? So what does the law actually say if you're stuck in a co-ownership dispute? Like, what are your options?
12:57 Speaker 01 So any co-owner can apply to the court to have an order to divide the property. Now, the court can say one of three things. It can say, right, you are entitled to some money. So therefore, number one, we're going to force you to sell the property and the proceeds are going to be divided. Number two is they can tell you to petition it off. So like actually a physical division around the land or the house. Now, this is probably far less common than one of the other two options. Because you have to have a house where that's practical to be able to do that.
13:28 Speaker 00 Like if it's like a big lifestyle section or a big piece of land.
13:30 Speaker 01 And there are a couple of houses on it. And number three is just compulsory buyout like Fiona had to do where, hey, you can still, still live in the property. It's still your property, but you need to pay out your exes 600 grand in that, in that instance.
13:43 Speaker 00 But it's not just us normal folks who get into these sorts of disputes. This third story involves a mayor and his mother-in-law.
13:51 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. So this one made the news and involves the mayor of Lower Heart, Campbell Barry, and the Barry's bought this five hectare property in Wainui Mata, and it was joined with his wife's parents, so John and Debra Harris. Now, the plan was simple. We've got this big lifestyle property. We're all gonna live together. We'll share in the cost, two families, one big piece of land. But then, in 2022, the parents separated.
14:16 Speaker 00 Okay, so.
14:17 Speaker 01 So the in-laws have split.
14:18 Speaker 00 What happens then?
14:19 Speaker 01 So father-in-law goes, right, bugger this, I'm off to live overseas. Debra, mother-in-law, stays in the property and John, the father-in-law, keeps paying the share of the cost.
14:31 Speaker 00 What a nice guy.
14:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, good guy.
14:34 Speaker 00 I mean, doing what he has to do anyway, but yeah.
14:36 Speaker 01 So now he's over in Thailand, say, enjoying his life.
14:39 Speaker 00 By the way, we made that up. No defamation, but he probably was in Thailand, okay?
14:44 Speaker 01 And, and he made nine separate offers to buy out his ex-wife, the mother-in-law, and she refused every one, probably why it didn't work out. And it gets really ugly. And so in the end.
14:54 Speaker 00 Thank you for your relationship advice, Andrew Nickle, relationship specialist. Yeah, okay. So, so, so what happens when they go to court?
15:04 Speaker 01 So in the end, the judge ordered Debra Harris, so the mother-in-law, to relinquish or sell her share of the property. And so basically said, enough's enough. You've had some fair offers. You've been living on the pig's back. Time to get out or pay out.
15:21 Speaker 00 And look, I've got one last one for you. This one's interesting. So we had a couple come and see us at Opes Partners. They built a wealth plan together. They, they decided to buy an investment property. Everything's on track. And they buy a new build, which might take, you know, 12 or 18 months to be finished, right? To get built. A month before settlement, they break up. And
15:43 Speaker 01 A month before.
15:44 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:44 Speaker 01 Just hold on another month, wouldn't you?
15:46 Speaker 00 Well, that's where it gets interesting. And so the advice says, well, what do you want to do here? Because if you guys decide not to buy this property together, one of you is going to have to settle on it or you're going to default. And that's going to, like, if you've signed a contract to buy something and then you decide not to buy it, the developer could keep your deposit.
16:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, they don't, they don't care that you split up.
16:05 Speaker 00 Well, it's not, it's not their problem that one of them spent too much time down at the bar, is it? And, and so they ended up saying, well, do you know what? We'll just buy this investment property together. We don't hate each other, but we'll get a property sharing agreement. And we'll make sure that there are some rules about if one person wants to sell it, the other person gets to buy the other out first. So they ended up settling on that property. Funny thing is, a couple of months later, the relationship's back on.
16:34 Speaker 01 Really?
16:35 Speaker 00 The relationship's back on.
16:36 Speaker 01 Money fixes everything.
16:37 Speaker 00 No, the investment property heals all. So here's my relationship advice to you. If you think your relationship's on the rocks, buy a new built house. There we go. Now, that didn't work out for me though, remember, I had to split it up. It was very stressful.
16:53 Speaker 01 It is funny, I like, people do need to have an agreement at the start because the idea of assets going to the other party can really get in people's heads. I know that I've worked with some investors. One investor I worked with, like, they had four rental properties with no equity in them because they borrowed a hundred percent using the no cash needed method. And then when they split up, the wife could not get her head around the fact that she was taking the house which had no debt on it, but he was getting four rental properties. That was completely unfair, even though like there was so little equity in them at that stage. He could refinance them away. But again, because there was no agreement, it was really, really messy and, and she couldn't move on.
17:33 Speaker 00 So this is your fair warning. If you're buying a house for somebody else, especially if they're not your partner, property sharing agreements. And if you're going to be in a throuple, I mean, it's a very modern world we live in. Relationship property agreements, something very important to consider. Cause in the last 20 minutes, you've learned we bought a house together and now we hate each other. The three real stories of Kiwis who bought property together and it all went wrong. And the one document that could have prevented every single case. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
18:13 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
18:16 Speaker 01 And I'm your host, Nick O'Callaghan.
18:17 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, technical insights to help you get the most out of using the property market. Until next time.
Previous Auckland’s 2 Million Home Plan Just Shrunk – Here’s Why⎟Ep. 2365 Next The 4 Ways to Make Retirement Cheaper (or More Expensive)⎟Ep. 2367 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated