Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast They Paid $10K… Then Everything Stopped Overnight⎟Ep. 2402 About this episode Thousands of dollars… paid for “lifetime” coaching. Then the company shuts down overnight. In this episode, Ed and Andrew break down what happened when a property investment company abruptly closed – and what it means for investors who thought they were signing up for support that would last decades. You’ll learn: What to do if you paid for “lifetime” coaching... and it suddenly disappears Why “lifetime” promises often mean the lifetime of the company, not you Your real options – from Disputes Tribunal claims to Commerce Commission complaintsThe key takeaway? If a promise sounds too good to be true, it probably is. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account and Wealth Plan here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Urbis Partners. I'm your host, Seb McKnight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is a show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment property. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn what to do if you pay $10,000 for lifetime coaching and the company just shut down. Why lifetime promises from property companies don't often mean what you think and what your legal options actually are. Now, some companies sell lifetime property coaching programs in New Zealand and then they close down. And I really feel for clients of positive real estate where some had shelled out $10,000 to get lifetime coaching. And then just recently, on Thursday, the 2nd of April, the day before Good Friday,
0:56 Speaker 00 the day before the four day long weekend, clients in the positive real estate Facebook group woke up to a post from the director, Sue Matheson, saying that after 15 years, positive real estate in New Zealand was closing down effective by the end of that day. So no wind down period, no transition plan, just a Facebook post. And then the website was down, the doors were shut by the end of that day. I mean, what do you think of that, Andrew?
1:25 Speaker 01 It's always a hard one because let's say Sue went out there and said, we're going to be around for the next 12 months and then we're going to close down after that. Potentially then people just get grumpy about that as well. I don't like the fact that people are just kind of told via a Facebook post that the carpet's been ripped out from underneath them. But I don't know that there's ever a good answer when it comes to bad news like this.
1:46 Speaker 00 And I suppose we should point out our own biases before we go on because positive real estate, we're a competitor of ours, of us at Opes Partners, they do similar things. Not that we've got a 10K coaching program, but there is a bit of bias there. So we're going to stick to the facts as we go through this because if you are a positive real estate client, you're going to be thinking, well, what do I do? And Andrew, you've got some screenshots in front of you, looking at some of the reactions People.
2:10 Speaker 01 Yeah. So one client wrote, we paid 10K to Positive Real Estate for lifetime mentoring and coaching. We only got six years and people responded with, we're in the same boat, same here. We paid a whole bunch of money for only four years. It's an interesting one because, you know, 10K is no insignificant amount of money. But if I got six years worth of coaching, I think that was probably actually relatively good. But I guess everyone's looking at the fact that, well, I signed up for a lifetime and I didn't get lifetime.
2:37 Speaker 00 Well, I agree with that. If you signed up for a lifetime, it doesn't matter what the, what the amount of money was. It could have been a thousand dollars. You've paid for lifetime mentoring. You paid for lifetime coaching and then you didn't get it, right? And look, I want to be really fair here to Positive Real Estate. There were some clients in there who were really grateful, right? So some people have been with the company for a few years and got real value. But there were people who signed up recently. I saw one person saying that they had only paid the full amount months ago and were pretty understandably upset. Because if you're one of those clients, you're probably wondering, well, what the hell do you do now? And this isn't the first time this has happened.
3:18 Speaker 01 Yeah. Actually, do you remember Danny? Danny used to work in our Opus Accelerate team. And I remember she'd gone along to the kind of rich dad, poor dad group called Legacy that were going around doing these programs. I went along to one of their, their weekend programs as well with, with one of our team. I think it was about $25,000 for their lifetime coaching program. And, and the interesting thing about these guys, this wasn't just a New Zealand company. This was a worldwide company where Robert Kiyosaki was kind of endorsing them and part of the program. And, and you kind of think, okay, well, Robert Kiyosaki, he's a rich man. He's got a, a, a long and successful career. And Danny paid the money for her lifetime coaching and, and then they went into liquidation as well.
4:01 Speaker 00 And then she didn't get her 25K back. She was just 25K worse off. And this is where we've got to understand that what lifetime means to us as consumers is very different from what a business means when they say lifetime.
4:16 Speaker 01 The lifetime of their company.
4:18 Speaker 00 Well, yeah, I think that is exactly what it is. It's about the lifetime of the company rather than your lifetime, which is what I think you might have reasonably thought. I remember speaking to someone who owned a company that offered lifetime coaching. And I said, but I just don't get it. How is it possible that you can commit to giving advice for somebody's lifetime when your company's only been up and running for six to 10 years, right? Like, in reality, you've never delivered a lifetime of advice to anyone, which might be fine, but you're saying lifetime. And to me, lifetime means lifetime, not six years, not four years. I paid you the 10 grand, not that I actually did, but if I was a consumer in this situation, I paid you 10 grand for lifetime coaching.
5:02 Speaker 01 I want my lifetime.
5:03 Speaker 00 Go on for my lifetime. And what they said is, oh, well, in reality, most people use our service for two years and then they go off and they do their own thing and they don't really use us anymore. And I thought, okay, well, that's interesting. That's, that's how you kind of make the business work. You know, because if I pay you upfront for a lifetime of services, I'm like, well, how are you going to deliver this, right? I just think it'd be a bit better if they were more upfront and said, you know, it's a five-year coaching commitment or a two-year coaching commitment rather than lifetime, because otherwise we get into situations like Danny or these people at Positive Real Estate where you think you've paid 10 grand to get a lifetime of, of advice. But actually, in this case, it doesn't go on for your lifetime.
5:45 Speaker 01 Well, let's face it, there is no business model that could exist where you can offer something for a lifetime, but only receive a payment upfront.
5:53 Speaker 00 If it's a service, I, I agree with that, right? It'd be extraordinarily difficult. But the thing is, they chose to market themselves as lifetime, right? So I understand you saying, oh, well, you know, six years is, is pretty good. But these people signed up for lifetime. But let's move on from that. Let's say you are impacted. What could some? Body who's a positive real estate client or in a similar situation. Let's say that you've signed up for a different lifetime coaching program and then they shut down. What can you do?
6:21 Speaker 01 So step one, I think you need to find your contract and find out what you actually agreed to, what you, what the terms were of your lifetime membership. Because maybe, maybe in the contract it says lifetimes defined as, you know, a fair amount of time, which may be two years. Maybe it's very specific. Maybe it says a 24 month contract. And, and I've seen instances where companies market lifetime coaching, but they actually put a one year term in the contract. So there's a big difference between if you've signed a one year contract and you've had that year of service, or if the company says lifetime in the contract, or maybe, you know, again, it might say one year, but like those people we'd mentioned before, you're only a couple of months in.
7:04 Speaker 01 Depending on what you've agreed to and your specific situation, might depend on what your rights are.
7:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, and it's always interesting because we like to talk about very specific companies like on the show and be like, well, this is what we've seen. Sometimes they get in touch afterwards and say, oh, there's a bit more to it in this story. Now let's say that somebody's just paid the money for this coaching. It could have been that they signed up to get two years of coaching. They paid the fee over the two year period. And so they've just finished their last instalment or something along those lines. There's a bit here that we don't know, but we're looking at it from the outside and we know that there are going to be clients of positive real estate who are really concerned, which is why we want to record the show. So step one's to get the contract. What is step number two?
7:49 Speaker 01 Step two, you want to find out whether or not the person that you're going to try and make a claim against, or the company you're going to make a claim against is actually still registered. So as of today, Positive Real Estate New Zealand still appears to be registered with the company's office. Now, what that means is it hasn't been struck off or put into liquidation. And the directors, they're based in New Zealand.
8:10 Speaker 00 Or at least one of them, as I should say, one of them's in Queensland.
8:12 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so, so this, this stuff kind of matters because it affects which options you've got. Now, if the company was already in liquidation, then you will become what's called an unsecured creditor. So basically you join the queue. And to be honest, that queue probably means that once everything's wound up and sold for parts, you might get cents on the dollar if you're lucky.
8:34 Speaker 00 And you'd only become an unsecured creditor if you had a genuine claim, right? That's, that's the main thing. If, if you've paid your money, but it turns out your contract said, oh yep, you get two years of coaching, even though it was marketed as lifetime. And you've had six years, you might find that actually, unfortunately, you, you don't have a legal leg to stand on. And if that was your situation, you might not be able to do anything. It might be that the company has closed down and you got your six years, but it doesn't continue for your lifetime. And that's really tough if, if, if you were thinking that you were going to continue getting that. The third step is consider the disputes tribunal. We're big fans of the disputes tribunal here on this podcast. Because this is where you can go and make a claim against a company or a person.
9:16 Speaker 00 You can claim up to sixty thousand dollars and there's no lawyers. There's only a very small filing fee and it's basically the way that Kiwis can get justice without having to pay tens of thousands of dollars to lawyers, right? And so what you could do is, is make a claim against positive real estate. If you found out after reading your contract that they said lifetime in the contract. So they're not delivering a lifetime. If that was the case, you could maybe take the company or the directors to the disputes tribunal and try and get some compensation that way. Which could be like a refund of some of your fees. But the first step is not to go to the disputes tribunal. The first step is to read whatever you signed with them to check what did you sign up for?
9:59 Speaker 00 Because again, I have seen a company where they marketed a lifetime coaching service, but actually the contract was for 12 months. And so the disputes tribunal is probably not going to look at what's on the website or what was it on the website or what a salesperson said to you. What they're going to be saying is what was in your contract? What was in your agreement with positive real estate? But here's a bigger question I want to ask you. Why is it that we keep seeing these kinds of lifetime promises sprouting up in the property investment industry?
10:28 Speaker 01 I guess because if you're going to get someone to part with some money for an education service, it makes sense that it would be really easy to market, or it sounds good when you market a lifetime guarantee to that, especially because I know, because I know someone that used to work at Positive, he said that one of the challenges they had were selling that lifetime program or the coaching program when hopeless partners go and give everything away on their bloody podcast, make it easy for people to get the information. So they really leaned into this lifetime commitment because, you know, then you've got one-on-one coaching. It's not just you have to listen to a podcast and figure it out for yourself. You, you can actually ring someone up for, for forever. And, you know, that pay once and get support forever. It does sound good, but as we've seen in
11:13 Speaker 01 practice, it can be quite a lot harder to actually be able to provide that.
11:17 Speaker 00 Now, one thing that I've been thinking about, Andrew, is the Fair Trading Act, because let's say a company advertises lifetime support, but the contract says 12 months. I mean, that could be misleading, right? If that was happening, I'm not saying this is what happened with Positive Real Estate, but I've seen instances like it.
11:35 Speaker 01 Yeah. If a company advertises a lifetime support and the contract says 12 months, even though you've signed 12 months, if it was advertisers lifetime, that could be seen as misleading. Now, the Commerce Commission, they handle complaints about misleading conduct for businesses in New Zealand. And if you have a complaint, you can go online and go to comcom.govt.nz and just lodge a complaint. Now, in this instance, my understanding is you're not going to necessarily just get your money back. But the Commerce Commission, they might do an investigation if they thought it was worthy of it. I don't know that there'd be much in this one because the company's now closed down. So I don't know whether or not there's much benefit in the Commerce Commission going through that, but that would be for them to decide.
12:18 Speaker 00 And one other thing that stood out to me here is that somebody might have looked at Positive Real Estate and said, well, actually they are an international company, right? I'm dealing with Positive Real Estate New Zealand, but they're pretty big in Australia. And one thing you've always got to be aware of when you're working with like a franchise is that your contract- Is typically with the franchise, not with the big company. And it's a little bit like we see with group home builders. So you might be dealing with a Golden Homes or a Signature Homes. But your contract could be with the local franchise, not with the big national body. And so if that small local franchise falls over, you could still be left in the lurch.
12:59 Speaker 00 Now, I only give you that example to say that sometimes when you work with the smaller companies, the franchise might fall over, but the big company up the top, the big brand that you know, like and trust, they might not always step on in. So I will be interested to see, does Positive Real Estate Australia come in and try and make good for these Kiwi clients? Or is it that actually there's, there's nothing they're doing, they're exiting the New Zealand market and that's that?
13:24 Speaker 01 I think for me personally, if I'd paid a fee and I'd got a few years worth of service, I probably wouldn't go to the extent of trying to track down everyone to try and get my money, only because I know that it probably wouldn't have much luck. It'd probably just be really frustrating for me, a process and can often just, just use your mental bandwidth. I'd probably just get on with things. Now, if that person was correct and they were a couple of months in, I'd feel pretty aggrieved. I'd, I'd definitely try and get my money back in that sort of instance. But certainly when you've got like people overseas, getting your money back is very challenging.
13:57 Speaker 00 One thing that does stand out for me from the Facebook post as well is that I saw that Sue, the director of the company, said they'd hope to put a succession plan in place to keep the company going because she's retiring, right? She's done it for 15 years and I can certainly understand being like, well, I know that the company has signed up to give you these services, but I'm still allowed to retire and go on my merry way at some point, right? But it does make me think if a promise sounds too good to be true, it probably is. And lifetime is a really, really, really long time in some cases. And no company can guarantee they're actually going to be around for your entire life, right? This is just the latest example. There have been many others in the past. Now, what I do want to say is if you are a positive real estate client and you're impacted by this,
14:42 Speaker 00 and you're thinking, gosh, I really need to review my portfolio now because I'm not going to get these reviews that I was. Used to in the past, then you might like to book a free session with one of our team at Opes Partners because we'll sit down with you, review where you're at and help you figure out what the right next step is for you. And we'll actually do it for free, not the 10K. So go to opespartners.co.nz, click that big orange button and book a free session with one of our financial advisers, if that's something you're into. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned what to do if you pay $10,000 for lifetime coaching and the company just shuts down. Why lifetime promises from property companies often don't mean what you really think and what your legal options really are. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:34 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Tim McKnight. And I'm Adrian O'Callaghan. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights on how to get the most out of the selling property market. Until next time.
Previous Are Mortgage Rates About to Go Up? Here’s What’s Really Happening⎟Ep. 2401 Next Epi. #2403 Is the Rental Market Finally Turning? Here’s What the Data Shows⎟Ep. 2403 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated