Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Pick the Right Structure… or Lose Thousands⎟Ep. 2435 About this episode Are you paying more tax than you need to… without even realising it? In this episode, Ed and Andrew play “Pilfered or Protected” – walking through real scenarios to show how different ownership structures can either protect your profits… or quietly drain them. You’ll learn: The 4 main ways to own property – and when each one makes sense How the wrong structure can cost you thousands in unnecessary tax Why sometimes the smartest move is actually to pay more tax Main idea? Tax isn’t just about how much you earn, it’s about how you structure it. Get it right, and you keep more of what you make. Get it wrong, and you could be handing over more than you need to. And check out Opes Accounting to get a free tax consult. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Seb McKnight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm your Nickel.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because we're going to play pilfered or protected, which is our game show about how to save on tax.
0:25 Speaker 01 Everyone's favourite family game.
0:27 Speaker 00 The four main ways to own an investment property and when to use them and when the right answer might be to pay more tax. Now, first of all, we are never saying let's pilfer from the tax man, let's do dishonest thing. What we're saying is don't pay more tax than the amount you're supposed to, or in other words, don't tip the tax man. Now, last time we played pilfered or protected was probably about five or six years ago, where we tell you some, some different scenarios and we talk about, well, what might be the most efficient way to own your investment properties? And I remember one of Andrew's friends said to me, well, Ed, I think that's really unethical
1:09 Speaker 00 that you're talking about this because, you know, people should be paying their tax. And I said to her, I absolutely agree with you. People should be paying tax, but it's probably not a good idea to pay more than you need to. And what I see is that some property investors pay more than they need to because they're just in an inefficient structure. So today we are going to play pilfered or protected. I'm going to give you three scenarios and we've got four contestants and we're going to talk about, well, which structures would pilfer your profits and which would protect them? Now, quick disclaimer before we introduce the contestants, Andrew and I, we're not accountants. We don't have the attention to detail for that. We're just some property investors who like to geek out about the stuff and we really
1:53 Speaker 00 like reality TV game shows as well. So Andrew, who are the four contestants? What are the four ways you could own an investment property?
2:02 Speaker 01 Contestant number one is your own name. So very simple, low cost. Most people do this when they buy their own house, they just put it in their own names and you either own it individually or jointly with a spouse potentially, not through a company, not through a trust, just in your own name. And if you're earning a profit, you're going to pay tax at your income tax rate.
2:21 Speaker 00 It's quite funny calling it own name because it's just the way you own most stuff, right? Like for most of us, our cars aren't owned by a company or a trust. You just own it. And so that's, that's what own name is. Contestant number two, give it up for limited liability company, which is just a normal company. The good news about this, the company tax rate is 28%, though that throws up some very interesting things around tax we're going to talk about later. Contestant number three is.
2:47 Speaker 01 A look through company or LTC, you might hear it. And that's same as a company apart from the way that profits are handled. So the profits or losses flow through to the owners based on their shareholding.
2:59 Speaker 00 And that might sound a bit confusing if you're hearing that for the first time, but it'll make more sense after we go through a few examples. And contestant number four is the trust. Now, trust income is taxed at 39%, so a higher rate than companies, but it's very flexible. And again, oh, that's going to become very useful as we play pilfered or protected. Now, just before we do that, what structure are most of your properties in? Your own name, a trust, a different type of company?
3:28 Speaker 01 So most of mine are owned in companies, but then they're owned by trusts. So there's extra layers of protection there for me. It gets a bit complicated, so I won't bore you with the details. But yeah, that's basically how mine are owned. Not very typical.
3:43 Speaker 00 Well, I really like that because I know for me as well, I've got some in my own name. I've got some in my trust. I've got some in a company. In fact, I've got one in a company that's owned by a company that's owned by a trust. And I think what that shows is that the way you buy properties will change over time and the right answer depends on your circumstances, right? So let's go through scenario number one. I'm going to give you the scenario, Andrew, then you're going to have to tell me which ownership structure you might use. So let's say you own a property, you've owned it in your own name for a while. You bought it for 700K, it's now gone up in value, it's worth $900,000 today.
4:25 Speaker 00 You've got a bit of a mortgage on it, about $500,000, but because the interest rates have recently. Come down, you've re-fixed and now you're making a four and a half grand a year profit. And you still have a mortgage on your own home. So pilfered or protected, which ownership structure might pilfer the profits and which would protect them? Is it an own name, a company or a look through company?
4:52 Speaker 01 So often this is kind of a fairly typical structure for people that have owned rental properties for quite a long time. They've got the property in their own name because that's just the way that it's been. And they're going to have to pay tax on that profit, that four and a half thousand dollar profit. So you know, there's probably going to be about fifteen hundred dollars of tax there, which might not make sense if they've got a personal mortgage. Now, there's a bit of advice you need to get before going and applying what I'm about to talk about. But often what might happen is you might go talk to your accountant and they might say, right, we want to restructure this by moving the equity from that rental property across to your owner occupied property.
5:32 Speaker 01 So if we can strip out that four hundred K worth of equity, the difference between the value now nine hundred K and the mortgage, five hundred K and dump that against your personal mortgage, that's going to bring down your personal mortgage. And yes, it increases the investment property mortgage. Now, the benefits of doing this is it improves your cash flow because the debt, you've still got the same level of debt, but that their four hundred K has been moved to the investment property. So it's probably interest only rather than principal and interest. It's got the added benefit of potentially protecting your own home more because now you've got less debt on that. There is also the additional tax benefit because now we might be making a loss on that rental property rather than making a profit.
6:15 Speaker 01 But the key thing here that I want to get across to you is number one, you can't just move that debt across. There has to be a transaction, you have to sell that property to a trust or probably a look through company. And before doing that, go talk to an accountant because there are some implications here. And you can't just do it to save tax, that's not legitimate. There has to be more reason other than I want to pay less tax.
6:41 Speaker 00 Which might be in this case that you wanna be mortgage free, you wanna protect that investment property, you wanna protect your own home as well. But one thing a lot of people might not realise is that this is one way that you might be able to use your investment property to effectively become mortgage free. I know you've had investors who do that as well. Now, one thing to consider here is the bright line test. For instance, let's say that you just bought a property and then you renovated it. And then you decided to restructure it straight away. You might be clipped by a, the bright line test. So there was this really interesting story where a couple owned a property on Waikiki Island. They then sold it into their trust for just under three million dollars.
7:26 Speaker 00 It must have been a very nice property. About a year later, the trust accepted an offer on that property for over five million dollars. And the issue there is they were caught under the bright line test and they had to pay nearly eight hundred thousand dollars worth of tax. Now, if they'd just kept that in their own name and then sold it, they wouldn't have had to pay that. But because they, they did restructure it into a trust, they were then caught. So there can be some complications here. Now, I'll give you scenario number two. This is where you own three investment properties that are all outside of the bright line test.
8:09 Speaker 00 You wanna sell one of them and pocket the cash. Now, the property you're selling has about a hundred and twenty five grand worth of equity in there. So after paying your real estate agent, you wanna walk away with a hundred K in cash. Now, which one would pilfer the profits? Own name, company, or a trust?
8:28 Speaker 01 Now, in this case, it's the company that would pilfer it. Now, the reason for this is if you own a property or properties in a closed company, a normal company, that hundred K cash sits inside the company. It's the company's money and not yours. That's the catch. So we always think, oh, that company's ours because we own the company. But no, it's still a separate entity and there are some rights and responsibilities within that. And to get the money out, you've got three options, neither of which are really that great. Number one, you pay it out as a shareholder loan. So you've got a shareholder current account. Number two. You pay a taxable dividend. Or number three, you liquidate the company. But of course, you've got two other rental properties in this, in this case.
9:10 Speaker 01 So if you own those three properties, you'd have to restructure them all, which might mean selling them and then resetting the bright line there and maybe do it. It's just, it's just complicated. So your own name or a look through company would have been better in this instance, because the money, the cash, is going to go straight to you.
9:28 Speaker 00 And I think a lot of people don't understand how shareholder loans and shareholder current accounts work. So that would be that you've got a hundred K, and correct me if I'm wrong here, Andrew, is that you've got a hundred thousand dollars in the company. They then loan that effectively to you as the shareholder. But what that means is eventually that debt has to be paid back, right? And that could be that you either liquidate the company eventually, or the company has to pay out a taxable dividend so you can pay that money back. So it's simple to do upfront, but it means that you, yourself, as a shareholder, owe money to this company. And if something goes wrong and somebody else tries to liquidate that company,
10:11 Speaker 00 for instance, the IRD, you might have to pay that loan back. And so I'm just trying to show you here that, oh, there are a few more complexities than you might think, rather than, okay, there's typically no tax when you sell a house. So I'll just take that money out. Okay, righty, I'll worry about that later. Well, if you just take that money out, you might not realise that you still owe that money back to the company. That might not be an issue when everything goes right, but when things go wrong, it can become an issue. Now, I'll give you a third scenario. This is actually a really good one. I love this one, Andrew. Let's say we've got a couple. One partner earns a hundred and thirty grand a year, right? So they're paying a tax rate of thirty three percent. The other partner has just gone on parental leave because they're having a kid. So that's exciting.
10:55 Speaker 00 They've got no income, so they're on a lower tax rate of ten and a half percent. Now, they own some investment properties. Those properties generate fifty grand in taxable income per year. That's your profit. Which structure would protect those profits? Own name, a look through company, or a trust?
11:12 Speaker 01 Now, in this case, it's a trust, and here's the reason why. You know, three scenarios. If you own them in your own name and you've got a thirty-three percent tax payer, then all the money's going to be taxed at the higher rate. And so therefore, your, your tax on that fifty K is about six and a half grand. Now, if you had a look-through company and it was split fifty-fifty, that means you pay based on your, your respective tax rates. So it would work out to be tax of eleven and a half thousand dollars. Now, if it's owned under the trust and you're going to pay out this cash to the person who's on mat leave, okay, well, that means they don't have an income at the moment other than this. So therefore taxed at the lowest rate. Based on that, the effective rate's going to be ten and a half percent,
11:56 Speaker 01 which is about seven and a half thousand dollars.
11:59 Speaker 00 The first part of it would be taxed at ten and a half percent. And then you've got the marginal rates. The effective rate's about fifteen percent.
12:06 Speaker 01 Yeah, so that means roughly when it's paid out, the tax is going to be about seven thousand, seven hundred dollars, which is significantly less than if it was just owned under the own name and the thirty-three percent earner. We're paying almost an extra ten thousand dollars, more than double.
12:22 Speaker 00 And I think what a lot of people don't realise is that most income in New Zealand is going to be taxed at your personal rate most of the time, right? If we're earning rental income from property and paying it out. And what I think people don't really understand is that sometimes there is a difference in incomes between the partners. So I've shared on the show in the past that my wife has gone out on her own, starting a business. That's really exciting. That means that her income is lower at the moment because she's starting her business. And so that means her tax rate will be lower than my tax rate. And so let's say that we owned an investment property together that earned an income. Today, the most efficient structure might be a trust because then when you have a trust,
13:07 Speaker 00 you can decide where that income goes and we could choose to distribute it out to her. Because she doesn't earn an income, she gets a lower rate. Now, people might say, oh, well, this is all very, very dumb, isn't it? Because that means that if people are on different incomes. Incomes, they might be able to have some tax advantages compared to if we just paid taxes if it was the whole household. Well, there was a very intelligent politician called Peter Dunn from the United Future Party, who was banging on about this probably about fifteen years ago. Nobody decided to vote for the, well, very few people, I should say, decided to vote for the man in the bow tie. And so that never became policy. But because of that, we have these, these interesting situations where there can be tax benefits,
13:49 Speaker 00 where a lot of our, our money is effectively taxed as individuals. But here's an interesting situation about where it could make sense to pay more tax. Oh, what's this here? You're telling us to pay more tax? Well, potentially if there are relationship property concerns. So let's say that Partner One owns two properties and then they decided to get with Partner Two. And let's say Partner One owns these two properties in a trust and they're earning good cash flow. Now they go and get a prenup, so a contracting out agreement, where Partner One says, I owned these two properties before we got together. So I want to protect those in the event that we break up. Okay, that all makes sense.
14:33 Speaker 00 They then decide to have a baby and Partner Two is going to stay at home with the kids, so won't earn an income and is on a lower tax rate, whereas Partner One is still out there working. Now, their accountant says to Partner One, oh, well, why don't you make your partner, Partner Two, a beneficiary of the trust? They've got a lower tax rate and so you could distribute the money out to them. Ah, I see you're nodding, Andrew, you know where I'm going with this. Then what happens is those properties could be subject to relationship property, right? And that's because the income from those properties is now being used to support Partner Two.
15:15 Speaker 00 They then break up and assets that previously were protected could now be considered relationship property. Now, I'm not saying that they definitely would, because I'm not a lawyer, but I'm just saying that they would get more scrutiny than would otherwise be the case and could put you. Preen up, your contracting out agreement, your relationship property agreement, a little bit more in jeopardy. You're with me on that?
15:39 Speaker 01 A hundred percent. There have been numerous times in my investment career where I've been advised from an accounting perspective to be more aggressive in my tax position, pay a lot of tax. And the thing that's always stopped me doing that is muddying the water with relationship property situations. And so I am more than happy to pay the maximum amount of tax that I have to pay in an effort to protect my assets.
16:08 Speaker 00 And that's where all of this can get just a bit more complicated, right? Because you often want to talk to both your lawyer and your accountant when you are doing things like this, because your accountant might say, here's a way to save tax. And you go, oh, that sounds pretty good. Then you talk to your lawyer and they say, well, don't do that because then you're going to muddy the water in terms of relationship property. It might save you a couple of grand a year in tax, but if it means that you've got to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars out in the event of a relationship breakup, that might make you think, ah, maybe it's okay to pay a bit more tax because I don't want to muddy the water in other areas. Now, if you didn't have a relationship property agreement at
16:51 Speaker 00 all, then you might say, oh, okay, yeah, let's, let's go ahead and do that trust thing. But it depends on your situation, which is why you really need to make sure you're getting some good legal advice and some good tax advice. Now, if you are looking for an accountant that specializes in property investors and for property investors, you might like to check out Opes Accounting because we only work with property investors and you can book a free tax consult at opesaccounting.co.nz. Our last producer, Dave, to drop that link down in the show notes. Because over the last 15 minutes, you have played pilfered or protected, we've talked about how to save tax, the four main ways to audit investment property and when to use them, and when the right answer might be to pay more tax. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the
17:36 Speaker 00 podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:46 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
17:49 Speaker 01 How's your neck on?
17:49 Speaker 00 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the estate and property market. Until next time.
Previous This Floor Plan Mistake Could Cost You $100K⎟Ep. 2434 Next How to earn $100k passive income in 15 years (through property) Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated