Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast NZ’s $184 billion insurance crisis explained⎥Ep. 2039 About this episode In this episode, we discuss New Zealand’s massive insurance problem — and how it could leave homeowners seriously out of pocket when disaster strikes. You’ll hear the shocking story of one Kiwi who was left $350,000 short after their insurance payout didn’t cover the full rebuild cost — plus:What’s behind NZ’s $184 billion underinsurance crisis•Why many policies don’t pay out what you think they willAnd how to make sure you’re properly covered if your house ever burns downIf you own property, you need to hear this — because your biggest asset might not be as protected as you think. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Si.
0:11 Speaker 01 And I'm Ajnuko.
0:12 Speaker 00 And today on the show, we're talking about New Zealand's $118 billion insurance problem. We're also going to talk about how one homeowner was left 350K out of pocket with his insurance claim and why, and how to make sure that you get the money you need, even if your house burns down. And I suppose what this really comes down to, Andrew, is that insurance in New Zealand, specifically house insurance in New Zealand, has got a whole heap riskier.
0:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, it used to be pretty straightforward. So I remember like you'd buy a house, you'd ring up your insurance broker or you'd ring up the insurer and say, I want to put some insurance on this house. This is the address, this is the size, 103 square metres. And then they would send you your insurance policy and you're done. It was that straightforward. But now the insurance companies don't really do the actual replacement policies quite so easily or quite so often now. What they actually want to know is, well, what's it going to cost to rebuild that property? And the reason that's so complicated is, okay, well, you've got to figure that out with either the use of a broker or an online tool. And let's face it, probably none of us are that skilled at actually getting a good estimate of what it is.
1:23 Speaker 01 So we're probably overinsure a lot of the time.
1:25 Speaker 00 And the issue is that back in the day, if your house burnt down, they just paid you whatever money you needed to replace it, right?
1:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, so they'd make sure you had a 103 square metre house, regardless of the cost.
1:37 Speaker 00 Yes, wait, so my 100 square metre house burns down, here's the money to replace it.
1:41 Speaker 01 Yeah.
1:41 Speaker 00 But now they're like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
1:44 Speaker 01 You insured for $274,000, that's what you're getting. And if it costs you now 500,000 because the cost of building materials have gone up, tough luck.
1:54 Speaker 00 Well, that's the thing. So now we've moved from replacement insurance to some insured, where you tell the insurance company how much you want to insure your house for. And I suppose that shifts the responsibility from the insurance company to you.
2:10 Speaker 00 And I guess what a lot of New Zealand homeowners, it doesn't matter whether we're talking about investment property or just the home you live in. What you probably don't realise is you're now the one taking responsibility for that. And I know this actually happens to some Kiwis now.
2:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, I saw some stuff last year that there was this guy that owned a house and it was destroyed by Cyclone Gabriel back in twenty three. Now, he bought the house in twenty twelve, right when insurance companies were changing their policies. And we're only offering these some insured policies now. Now, it sounds like him and his broker didn't really have a conversation about insurance. And the broker applied a default rebuild rate of two thousand dollars per square metre. So when the house got destroyed, the guy got paid out three hundred and fifty grand from his insurance. That was a sum insured. Now, what it was actually gonna take to rebuild that property was seven hundred thousand dollars. Terrible, eh? So it's like just not gonna get anywhere near what he had previously.
3:09 Speaker 01 And so now he has to probably take out a mortgage or or build a different property.
3:14 Speaker 00 So he's basically three hundred and fifty grand out of pocket, right? And I suppose where that really hits you is if you thought you were insured and that you'd done everything right. And then you find out, ah, I gotta replace my house, but I either have to fork out way more money and find an extra three hundred and fifty grand that I didn't think I'd have to find. Or I need to just accept that I'm gonna build a much, much smaller house. And the reason this all changed was after the earthquakes in Christchurch back in twenty twelve, where pretty much everyone, and my run saying, had replacement insurance.
3:47 Speaker 01 Pretty much. If it was a really old house, then often you'd have a sum insured. But most people had an actual replacement policy, which was based on the square metre.
3:57 Speaker 00 And so because it costs more and more and more to build properties over time, and especially during those crises, you're likely to see that the cost of building is gonna go up even further because there is so much demand for tradies. There's gonna be so much demand for building materials. That cost can go even higher during those points where lots and lots of properties are destroyed. It was very costly for insurance companies. Yeah, that's why they decided, well, how do we mitigate this risk in the future? We can move to more some insured. Now, this does mean that you guys and all homeowners, if we've got these policies and I've got this myself, across, I think across all my properties, actually, we've got to take more responsibility. Cause we don't just get paid whatever we need to rebuild the house, we get paid whatever we've insured for.
4:42 Speaker 00 And I guess the reason we're talking about this is you've been thinking about this personally for your own home.
4:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, now, the reason this came to my mind is because I live on a hill. And hills are notoriously more expensive to rebuild on than just something on the flat.
4:56 Speaker 00 Why's that?
4:56 Speaker 01 Because there's slopes and, and it's just more complicated to clear the site and to, to, it might be that you've got to level different areas, it just, it's more expensive. Now, I was talking to a friend of mine who had just had a Q S, quantity surveyor, prices property for insurance purposes. Now, the reason he did that is because he lives quite near where the Christchurch fires were. And he found that he was massively underinsured. And he said, I need to rethink my insurance situation. He said, you need to do the same. So anyway, when I originally bought my house, I took out insurance, obviously. And I insured for, I think, just the purchase price.
5:39 Speaker 01 I think I just did it that way because I thought, okay, well, let's say the land is, you know, a third of the cost and the builder's two thirds of the cost. Then if I insure for the full purchase price,
5:48 Speaker 00 You have more money?
5:49 Speaker 01 I'll have fifty percent more than I need. And that will account for clearing the site and landscaping and all that kind of extra hoo-ha. So, Q S comes out, so I rang up this guy and said, I need you to come out and have a look at my house and price it up for insurance. So that I've got an appropriate level of cover. And I kind of thought, maybe, you know, it'll be a bit more expensive because it's been a few years since I bought my house. We've done some renovations. Guy comes out, wanders around, takes some photos, makes a whole lot of notes, goes away. And then a few weeks later, I get the report. He has quoted four times the amount of insurance cover that what I had.
6:24 Speaker 00 Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, because I know what you, I know what you spent on your house.
6:27 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:28 Speaker 00 That's millions.
6:30 Speaker 01 Yep, millions. Now, if he was wrong, right, and he had overstated, and by the way, this guy's a Q S. He, he knows a thing or two about counting good. He is going to be more accurate than, than my finger in the air. This is what I'll ensure for.
6:44 Speaker 00 And I suppose the thing that a lot of people don't think about, when you look at your council valuation, your capital valuation is what it's actually called. So your C V, your R V, your G V, all of that. So often you see the land component and then you see the building component. Now, if you just do the building component, you've got to remember a couple of things. First of all, the building has probably, or like some of the, the, the stuff inside the building has depreciated over time. And then on top of that, you've got to remember, well, if there's a fire, if there's an earthquake, you've got to pick up that existing structure, demolish it and get it off the site.
7:17 Speaker 01 Hmm.
7:18 Speaker 00 Those costs won't be included within that, that building value or improvement value component of your G V. And then on top of that, it won't be accounting for the fact that you also have to think about council fees or architecture fees or like all of those other costs of actually rebuilding it, right?
7:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, correct. And you know, then you might have extra features like retaining walls are a big one that can really catch people out. Or if you've got a swimming pool, stuff like that can really add to the cost of replacement. So had there been an earthquake and this guy was correct and that was what it was going to cost to rebuild my property, I wouldn't have been rebuilding on that site.
7:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, you would have been, you would have been millions of dollars in the, in the.
7:58 Speaker 01 Absolutely. I would, I, I just, I, I wouldn't have made financial sense to do it without having an appropriate insurance payout. So actually, the interesting thing is, I rang my insurance company and said, hey, I need to increase my insurance, gave them the number. They gasped like I did and I thought, actually, this might be actually quite a bit of a challenge to get this insured because I remember.
8:18 Speaker 00 Cause they might push back and be like, we don't want to insure it for that. That's all the money.
8:22 Speaker 01 Correct. When I let them know that I had this Q S report, I sent it to them, literally like five minutes later, they'd approved it.
8:29 Speaker 00 Oh, that's good.
8:30 Speaker 01 Yeah, really, really easy. Once you've got that substantial document to show, yep, this is what it will actually cost.
8:36 Speaker 00 And we'll talk about how much it costs to get that Q S survey in a second. But what I want to know is, what did that do to your premium? Because if you say, I'm not going to insure my house for $500,000 anymore, just using a random figure. I now want to insure it for four times that $2 million. You know, does that mean your premium goes up four times?
8:55 Speaker 01 No, it didn't. It didn't go up four times. That was the really interesting thing. I think it was about 80% more. I think it was more expensive, but it wasn't significantly more expensive, given the amount of cover that I now have.
9:08 Speaker 00 Do you have any idea why that is? Is that, is that because maybe your insurance policy includes, you know, contents and other things?
9:15 Speaker 01 No, I'm not sure why that would be.
9:16 Speaker 00 Okay, that's very interesting because one of the things a lot of people would say is, well, I don't want to do this because if I increase my level of cover, that means that I have to pay more to the insurance company. My premium's going to go up. And that is absolutely true. Of course, the reason you want to do that is so that if your house does burn down or some other catastrophic event that, you know, those kinds of things are very hard to financially recover from. You're protecting that downside. Now, if you say to yourself, well, I'm going to consciously under insure and I'm aware of that. I kind of think, okay, well, you are just self-insuring in that case. And you're saying, well, I'm not going to pay the insurance company. I'm going to take more of the risk. That's okay, as long as that is an active decision and a conscious decision.
10:00 Speaker 00 What we're really just trying to warn against here is, oh, a lot of people could be under insured. And in fact, if we look at the numbers from, I think it's from Treasury, they reckon that New Zealand houses are about $184 billion under insured in New Zealand. And so some of that will be conscious, but I bet, yeah, the vast bulk of it is totally unconscious that people haven't updated their some insured. Because the way that you often do this is you don't have to go and get a quantity survey to come to your house. A lot of people might just estimate it based on the Cordell Construction Index or there's a great calculator that I know CoreLogic has.
10:39 Speaker 01 You need to know or something like that, I think they call it.
10:41 Speaker 00 And if you own a property that's a bit more simple, like um my property's on a flat piece of land and it's not architecturally designed, I mean, it's a nice house, but it's not built to high-end architectural standards. So it it's probably okay for me to use that calculator and maybe, you know, insure for a little bit more. And then review it regularly, right? Because the cost of building materials, the cost of replacing that house will go up over time. But if you owned a property on a hill or with a pool or something that is like, if it's a twenty million dollar build in Queenstown, just to put a picture in your mind, and it's high-end, you've had an architect in there, you've had really high-end builders.
11:24 Speaker 00 You wanna probably use a quantity surveyor like Andrew has here. And, you know, what does it kind of cost to get one of those reports?
11:31 Speaker 01 So from scratch, it's typically around three to four thousand dollars plus GST. Now, if you want an update to an existing report, that's usually another fifteen hundred dollars plus GST. Now, it does vary depending on the scope. So depending on whether or not you've got a twenty million dollar house in Queenstown, like you was talking about before, that's probably gonna cost you more like seven and a half thousand dollars. But if it's just a standard property in one of the main centres, it's probably gonna cost you three or four thousand dollars the first time that you get there. And you'd probably only update if you had a significant change. Otherwise, you might inflation adjust and then every ten years you might get an update to your report.
12:10 Speaker 00 How much should it cost you?
12:11 Speaker 01 I think it was about five.
12:12 Speaker 00 If you were saying you'd only update it every ten years, that seems a bit bit light to me.
12:17 Speaker 01 So my insurance inflation adjusts by default.
12:20 Speaker 00 By what what level of inflation? Consumer price?
12:23 Speaker 01 It'll be, yeah.
12:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, because the only thing you'd just be, I'm not saying you're an idiot, I'm just saying, I mean, I'll do that later. But um the one thing to just, for people to be aware of is if the cost of construction goes up at a faster rate than general inflation, you might wanna just, you know, maybe do it every five years. You certainly wouldn't be doing it every year.
12:42 Speaker 01 In all honesty, if I got my insurance payout today, I would sell the land as it is and I would go and build something else on the flats.
12:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, okay, that probably makes a bit of sense. But you've got such lovely views at your house.
12:53 Speaker 01 Not for that amount of money. I'm laughing all the way to Tytap.
12:58 Speaker 00 And one thing you should just be aware of is like, these quantity surveying reports can actually be done pretty quickly. It's kind of two to three weeks. They'll do a bit of measuring at your house, come over, have a good old gander at it. And then they'll give you a report a little later on to send that to your insurance company.
13:12 Speaker 01 I think one of the biggest things is deciding whether or not you need to get one. So just making sure you figure out what's kept your eye. Certainly like if you've got an unusual house or you've got a house that has specific features that might be expensive in the event of an earthquake or a fire or another, you know, natural hazard. You want to make sure that you do have an appropriate level of insurance. And because it often costs more than you think it is going to cost you, your insurance company isn't going to take your best guess, finger in the air. They're going to want to know that you can substantiate that with someone professional.
13:45 Speaker 00 And I guess because, you know, according to QV, the cost of building has gone up by 44% over the last four to five years. So it's gone up a lot. So if you have not thought or haven't reviewed your house insurance policy in a decade, like the homeowner we talked about at the start, who was out 350K after Cyclone Gabriel, like you should really be thinking about this. If you own a house in Auckland and you're on a hilltop, those Auckland floods that happened not that long ago, hopefully that's making you think about your house insurance. And, you know, you really should be thinking, okay, I need to, I need to talk to my insurance broker to try and make sure that I am insured enough so that if there is another natural disaster or something bad happens to your house,
14:27 Speaker 00 you're not caught out being like, okay, I've got to find a way to find an extra 200K or 300K so I can rebuild the house that I love. So over the last 15 minutes, we've talked about New Zealand's $184 billion insurance problem, how one homeowner was left that 350K out of pocket with his insurance claim, and how to make sure you get the money you need, even if your house spoons down. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:02 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
15:05 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Lekum.
15:06 Speaker 00 We're going to be back in tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous Inside the shocking true stories of abandoned properties⎥Ep. 2038 Next How Trump's tariffs could LOWER your mortgage rates⎥Ep. 2041 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated