Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast New pet rules for renters explained ⎥ Ep. 1926 About this episode In this episode, we discuss the new tenancy rules that landlords (and tenants) need to follow. This includes the new rules around pets ... and whether landlords can still say 'no' to a tenant having a pet. We also cover the 90-day no-cause terminations. That way, landlords and property investors can know what the new rules are (and any catches there are). For more from Opes Partners: Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter Instagram TikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, David Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 00 And on the show, we're talking about the new tenancy rules that have just been passed by the government. And in the next 15 minutes, you're going to learn, when do these new rules come in? Do property investors have to let their tenants have pets under these new rules? And a couple of things that you actually might not like as a property investor. Now, Andrew, these rules were just passed last week. When do they actually come into effect?
0:35 Speaker 01 Okay, so the big one probably for most property investors is the 90 day no cause termination. Now, I actually remember I was on a webinar, I think it was this year, maybe it was last year.
0:45 Speaker 00 No, it was this year, I remember.
0:46 Speaker 01 With Peter Lewis and it was in front of Auckland Property Investors Association. And Peter Lewis absolutely had a strong opinion about the terminology, no cause terminations. And he said, well, of course you've got a cause, of course you've got a cause to kick a tenant out. You just aren't stating it. So I get his point. So basically, this is the rule where-
1:04 Speaker 00 And just for context, Peter Lewis, Vice President of the Auckland Property Investors Association.
1:09 Speaker 01 And just for anyone that doesn't know, this is the rule where you can ask your tenant to move out without having to provide any reason. And they've got 90 days, three months to move out. Now, just remember, this is only for periodic tenancies. This is not for a fixed term tenancy. If you've got a tenant who's in a fixed term tenancy, you have to see out that fixed term in its entirety. This comes in from the 30th of January. So it's only a month from when this episode will be released. And this is the old rules being wound back.
1:37 Speaker 00 And I know some of our property managers are really looking forward to this because there are some tenants, and it's not all tenants, this isn't tenant bashing, but there are some tenants who take the mick. So there are quite set rules around when you can ask your tenant to leave. And one of those rules is if they are late on the rent, I think within a, three times within a three month period, something along those lines, I might have just butchered those rules. But what I know some bad tenants do is they will go right up to the line of how late they can be. And then they'll quickly pay the rent so that they're not outside of- Rules and can't be asked to leave. So there are some, and it's only a very, very small portion, but there are some people
2:17 Speaker 00 who know the, the residential tenancy is hacked and will game the system in quite bad faith, which makes the landlord's financial situation really difficult. And so our property managers are saying, well, this is actually a really good example of where we can use this rule to move on a tenant who isn't being respectful of the landlord or the landlord's property without having to get a set reason that can then be challenged at the tenancy tribunal. And that is not the only change that's coming in, in early January.
2:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, the other one is if you want to move into your property or do renovations now, rather than waiting a nine week stand down, your notice period goes down to six weeks. And the other big thing is that all fixed term tenancies become fixed term tenancies again. And what I mean by that is in the current rules right now, if you have a fixed term tenancy that ends, then it rolls into a periodic tenancy and then you've got to follow the normal process of giving notice. Now, if you give a fixed tenancy of 14 months, for example, because you know you're going to move back into that property in 14 months, or you want to do something after 14 months, at the end of the 14 months, that is a vacant property.
3:22 Speaker 00 And just for any new listeners to the show, just the difference between fixed term tenancies and periodic, a fixed term is when you sign a contract that the tenant's going to stay for a year and you're not going to kick the tenant out within that year. So very, very fixed, periodic is where there isn't a fixed end date. So it's just ongoing. And over the last couple of years, there've been very defined rules about when you can end that periodic tenancy. Then now if you've probably been a bit too limited. Now, these laws are not one sided. They don't only go in landlords' favour. And there is something that not all property investors will like. So tenants, when they want to leave a periodic tenancy, their notice period is going down from four weeks down to three weeks. So that is less notice.
4:07 Speaker 00 And for some property investors, that could be potentially a little bit more vacancy. Because when your tenancy is righty-o, I'm off, see you later. You've got less time to find a new tenant before they end up stop paying rent.
4:20 Speaker 01 Potentially though, the other side to that is you might see less vacancy. So for example, when we have properties come up for completion and they're being rented for the first time, sometimes there can be quite a delay of getting that tenant in there, even if they've signed up for the property because they have to give the appropriate notice to their existing landlord.
4:37 Speaker 00 I also think it puts property investors in a little bit stronger negotiating position when it comes to renegotiating fixed term tenancies. Because if I was a tenant and I'd signed up for, you know, 12 months and then I get to the end of it. Well, why would I personally sign up for another 12 months? I'll just roll over to periodic and then I can give notice whenever I want. Whereas if the landlord says, well, actually I only do fixed term tenancies. So you've got to sign up for another 12 months or nothing. Then I'm a little bit more inclined to sign on the dotted line. Having said that, in practice, I've been very, very surprised that a lot of tenants are still willing and have been willing to sign up to fixed term tenancies. I've seen that within my own properties and most people not moving across to periodic.
5:22 Speaker 00 Even though if I was a tenant, I probably would have moved across.
5:24 Speaker 01 I think people like the certainty and let's face it. If you're a tenant and you want to move out of a property, you can pretty much do that within, you know, certain parameters, so long as a new tenant's found. So it kind of doesn't really matter. Probably locks in the landlord more than it does a tenant.
5:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think this is a fair trade off though, giving tenants a shorter notice period as well as giving landlords and property investors a shorter notice period. I mean, there's got to be some give and take. And this is just what the old rules used to be. So if the government is rolling back some of the rules for landlords to what they were six-ish years ago. I think you've got to do the same for tenants. I think that the response from property investors is likely to be to use more of these fixed terms. Because then you've got 12 months notice in some ways. You know when your tenant's going to leave. You can have a conversation with your tenants upfront. You know, 60 days out from that fixed term ending. Do you want to stay on? No, all good, that's fine, I'll advertise it online. And that's quite different from what it used to be.
6:24 Speaker 00 So if you had a fixed term tenancy, you as the property investor couldn't cancel that. You were really requiring your tenant to say, that's it, I'm going to leave. And so you had to wait for them to give you that notice before you could go ahead and you could go and advertise for a new tenant. Now, because you as the landlord can also give your tenants notice, that again, gives you a bit more. Lead time to go and find that new tenant. And there was another big change around the pet bonds, Andrew.
6:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, now this is something that we're still waiting on more detail from. And there isn't a set date for when it's going to be formally introduced, but it's been passed. And we expect to have the rules for this kind of late 2025.
7:05 Speaker 00 The big delay is actually that tenancy services just need to update their software systems to allow there to be two bonds. The general bond and the pet bond. And one of the big questions a lot of you guys have been asking us is, do I have to accept a pet under this new legislation? So I went and I read it online and it's available for everybody. You can go read this online. And at first I read section 42C, which says that a tenant can have a pet, but only if the tenancy agreement says that they can have a pet. Or if you, as the landlord, the property investor, you have given them written consent. So that makes you think, okay, well, I can still decide whether to have a pet or not, whether to allow my tenant to have a pet or not.
7:47 Speaker 01 Okay. So then if I'm really worried about a tenant having a pet, I'd read that and sort of think, okay, well, I don't have to, so that's fine.
7:53 Speaker 00 Ah, but then you get to section 42D, which says that a landlord can't stop a tenant from having a pet, unless you provide reasonable grounds and write them into the tenancy agreement. For example, if you just write in the tenancy agreement, no pets, but don't write in a reason, then that doesn't count. That would be considered unlawful. The tenant is able to then have a pet. You've got to say why your specific property does not allow pets and it has to be reasonable. So these new rules force you as the investor and the tenant to start negotiating pets. And one of the big questions, Andrew, that everyone's going to want to know is, well, what is considered reasonable?
8:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, that's always the hard one when it comes to the law because it's a bit fluffy. Now, the law does provide some examples, so it could come down to the size of the pet or the type of the pet, or the species or the breed, or maybe just the number of pets. For example, is that particular dog, for example, likely to cause damage? Because the previous landlord said it was a nuisance of a dog and that's why, that's why they didn't renew the tenancy. Also, if you think about what's practical for the particular property that's being rented, if you've got a one-bedroom townhouse, you probably can't say no to a cat. Doesn't sound reasonable to be stopping a tenant having a cat in that particular property. But say it's a big dog, what are those big ones that have the things around there?
9:21 Speaker 00 Great Danes?
9:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, imagine it was a Great Dane. It would probably be reasonable to say to the tenant, look, the property doesn't suit having a Great Dane in there, so we can't actually allow that. Now, keep in mind, I'm not the decider of what's reasonable or not, although I think I should be. So if in the event that you get into a dispute, this could end up in the tenancy tribunal and they will decide.
9:44 Speaker 00 And I think that is how we're going to figure out what is considered reasonable or not. So Parliament, they write the rules, they pass the rules, and then it gets handed over to the tenancy tribunal where they're actually going to look at cases. They will decide what's reasonable or not. Give us an example of that, Andrew.
10:02 Speaker 01 So let's say again, a landlord says that the tenant can get a puppy to live in the property, but the tenants want a bullmastiff. Do you know what those are?
10:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, big dog.
10:12 Speaker 01 Yeah, then, yeah, sure, the dog might be a puppy right now and small, but it's going to grow quite a bit. Now, again, if it's a two-bedroom townhouse with a smaller backyard, it could, in my mind, be reasonable as the landlord to say, actually, that's not suitable for that dog as it grows. So we're going to say no there. But if the landlord says no and the tenant takes exception to this and goes to the tenancy tribunal, they're going to determine, actually, that's reasonable or no, it's not. And that's what sets precedent for future cases.
10:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, because on one hand, you're saying, oh, look, it's a small dog now, but it's going to get larger. And once it's larger, it won't be appropriate. And once it's larger, I probably can't ask you to move out. Though, of course, you do have the 90-day no-course terminations now. But on the other hand, you might say, well, I'm on a 12-month fixed tenancy. It's small at the moment. It's not going to grow that large over the next 12 months. So who's right, who's wrong? That's what the tenancy tribunal is going to decide for us. And I think that the good thing about all of this legislation is it clarifies what was already happening. Because tenants Kind of already could have pets. We've done a couple of episodes where tenants have moved in without pets. Then they've got one and then the pets become part of the family.
11:23 Speaker 00 Then after the fact, the landlord says, hey, wait a second, you're not allowed pets. And then they go to the tenancy tribunal and the adjudicator says, oh, yes, but the dog's been in the family for two years. And it's really a support dog for the kids. And so it would be unreasonable to ask them to leave. And so with these conditions, such as the dog staying outside, the dog can stay. And so this was kind of happening already. The good thing about this is you can get up to two weeks as a pet bond. And we've got more clarity over who's responsible and how it actually works, rather than than having been judged for us by the tenancy tribunal. And I know that some people will wanna know then, Andrew.
12:06 Speaker 00 Well, if I kinda have to allow a pet as long as it's reasonable, what happens if the pet ruins my property?
12:13 Speaker 01 Well, the good thing is now, if you've got a pet bond, that's bond over and above your normal bond that you've got funds available to deal with any damage to the property. Now, let's say there was a thousand dollars worth of damage and your pet bond was seven hundred and fifty dollars. Well, you can take the two fifty out of that general bond as well, assuming that there's enough money for that. Now, it's the tenant's responsibility to deal with any damage caused by the pets. Now, this is both accidental and careless damage. Now, this is another change in favour of the landlord. So previously, you might have remembered, we did a podcast and we spoke about a pet. Was it a dog that it?
12:48 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, I think it was a dog.
12:50 Speaker 01 Dog that had urinated on the carpet multiple times. Now, the first instance was considered accidental damage. And so that then fell on the landlord to deal with the repairs.
13:00 Speaker 00 Quite ridiculous if you think about it.
13:02 Speaker 01 Yeah. And then any subsequent was considered careless because, well, the tenant should have known better at that stage. Now, the new rules mean that any damage caused by the pet is the tenant's responsibility.
13:13 Speaker 00 Beyond fear, we're in terror.
13:14 Speaker 01 Before, yeah, yeah, yeah. So I think that's completely reasonable. Like, if if you want to have a pet and you're prepared to take on that responsibility, then you take on the responsibility of. Any damage.
13:25 Speaker 00 Do you think this will change many people's minds? Cause I know there are, there are kind of two camps of property investors. There are those who are like, pets don't bother me. I'm not too worried about it. I'm more worried about toddlers rather than, you know, a cat or a dog. And so all good with pets. And there are others who are like, absolutely not, not keen.
13:44 Speaker 01 Yeah, so I'm definitely fond of my tenants having cats particularly. I, I don't.
13:48 Speaker 00 That's because you like cats.
13:49 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I'm not really much of a fan for dogs in, in the houses. But I like a pet because it tends to keep the tenants for longer. Because I know historically, actually, some people just don't want to have it. And they're not going to agree to it unless they're made to in terms of landlords. So I'm all for it, but I, I had a conversation with one of my investors a couple of weeks ago. And she was very reluctant to have a pet. And I said, I absolutely think you should change your mind there. I think if you want to find a tenant right now before Christmas, you should absolutely accept people with pets. And they, they did and got a tenant pretty quickly thereafter. But the big thing for her was the damage. How do I deal with that? And I said, well, you've got bonds at the moment. You obviously can't implement a pet bond now after the fact, because that wasn't the rule when the tenant signed up for the property with the pet.
14:34 Speaker 01 But in the future, knowing that there's that extra money there probably would have swayed her a lot sooner.
14:40 Speaker 00 And if you're a bit worried about these new rules, like, oh my gosh, I've never been keen on pets before. Now I'm being told that I'm potentially going to have to accept pets. Just be comforted by the fact that there are rules around when you can say no. So if you've got that smaller property, then it would be quite reasonable to say, hey, no pets. Cause I'm worried about damage or no large pets because I'm worried about damage. And writing that into the tenancy agreement. So you can write down how many pets the tenant can have. You can write down, well, what sort of pets can the tenant have? Are they allowed goldfish? Maybe that's okay. Maybe that I'm not allowed a big dog in the backyard. Yeah, you do get some say, but it is a bit more balanced.
15:25 Speaker 00 The government are forcing you to have more of a negotiation and a discussion about what's reasonable. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
15:43 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host Stephen Knight.
15:46 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
15:47 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous Granny flat builders: the good, the bad & the ugly ⎥ Ep. 1925 Next Dear Santa, please give me a ... ⎥ Ep. 1927 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated