Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast New Data: Are Rental Appraisals REALLY Accurate?⎥Ep. 2133 About this episode When you get a rental appraisal, can you trust it? Or is it just a guess that’s designed to help someone make a sale? In this episode, we reveal never-before-seen data on just how accurate rental appraisals really are – based on properties actually rented across Christchurch and Auckland. You’ll hear the numbers, the surprising truth, and what it means for you as a property investor. You’ll learn:What percentage of appraisals fall within the stated range (and which city performs better)How often properties rent for less than expected – and by how muchWhy getting this right matters when applying for lending or projecting cashflowWant to learn what a good gross yield is in New Zealand – here's our guide on what is a good rental yield nz. Don't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seb McKnight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn whether you really can believe a rental appraisal or whether it's just a fake news guess. The exact percentage of rental appraisals that are accurate based on what real property managers say and whether property managers are just gaming the system. Now, this is one of the most common questions that our team gets at Opus Property Management and on the podcast, which is can you actually trust a rental appraisal? So when you buy a house, you might get a property manager to look at it, if it's a rental property and tell you, you know, ballpark, what do they think that it's going to rent for? And that's called a rental appraisal.
0:56 Speaker 00 And as far as I know, no other company has ever looked and released the information about whether their rental appraisals are accurate. So at our company away day, Tom, who's from our property management team in Christchurch, he said, I think we should start to track that because then we could release the data and people would know whether our rental appraisals are accurate because our goal is to be as transparent as possible. Now, by the way, this is not just a big old promotion for Opus Property Management. The reason I want to give you my data and our data is so that you can get a sense of how accurate they might be for the industry as a whole, right?
1:39 Speaker 00 And although I did call up a couple of property management companies to see whether they'd give me their data, given that we're competitors, they weren't that interested.
1:48 Speaker 01 Maybe, maybe someone is listening and they are going to be brave enough to share them and if they do, then let us know and we will.
1:55 Speaker 00 Yes, no, give me, honestly, if you, if you track this as, and you're a property manager, like I'm keen, give me your data, I'll, I'll plug you. Like, I don't care that you're technically a competitor, like you might be from Nelson where we don't operate or manage properties. So I am keen for that data, but, but. Drew, why are you, as an investor, why do you even care about rental appraisals?
2:14 Speaker 01 I think the main thing is, as an investor, before I buy an investment property, I want to know what the numbers look like and to understand that, probably one of the most important things for my cash flow is, what's the property going to actually rent for? I want to look at what my top up is going to be, if any, what my cash flow is going to be. And so I need to get a property manager to give me an accurate rental appraisal so that I can work out my numbers.
2:35 Speaker 00 Now, the banks need it as well.
2:37 Speaker 01 Yeah, the banks are going to want to see a rental appraisal because they want to know what you can rent your house out for as well, when they're assessing your mortgage application. Now, so on the one hand, you don't want your property manager to over promise and then when you actually go to rent it, you're making more of a loss than you thought, or you're not making as much money as you thought. But at the same time, you don't want them to understate it and be really conservative and then end up going to the bank and they say, well, no, because we're going to take 25% off the top of it and you can't service the new mortgage.
3:05 Speaker 00 And then if they, like, were really conservative, you might end up walking away from what could have been a good investment. So are they accurate? Now, we've got two teams. We've got a Christchurch team, we've got an Auckland team. So we've been tracking this for about two months now. And it really is about for new properties that are coming to market. Like when we're renting them for the first time, what was our appraisal versus what it actually got? So for our Christchurch team, across those 55 properties, 91% of them, so 50 out of about 55, rented within the appraised range. So if we said 520 to 540 bucks a week, there was just over a 90% chance that you actually landed within that.
3:48 Speaker 00 Two of those properties rented higher than the appraised range, so that's close to 4%. And 5% rented lower than the appraised range. So just three out of the 50 properties. So I was like, oh, I'm happy with those numbers. Especially when you've got to remember that we're a little bit different to the rest of the market. Because for most property managers, if you're getting an appraisal, like they might give you an appraisal and then three months later they're renting the property. For us, a lot of our properties are new builds and so it might take 12 months, 18 months for that property to be finished.
4:20 Speaker 01 Can change in that time.
4:21 Speaker 00 Yeah. So with our Christchurch team, they might be saying, cool. In today's market, we think it's going to get five hundred and twenty to five hundred and forty dollars a week in rent. But then it's eighteen months later or twelve months later that they're actually renting it. And of course, the market can move. So that's a bit of a sign that the market has been relatively flat. But I mean, that makes you feel pretty good. One of the other things that I was interested in though is are the property managers gaming the system? Now, what I, what I mean by this, I always like to be quite skeptical. I know some of my team listens to the show, so I'm not trying to say that. I don't trust anyone, but I'm always like, okay, what would a skeptical like property investor ask? Which is, oh yeah, but if you're telling me five twenty to five forty, but maybe you're just going to push me down to five twenty
5:03 Speaker 00 and push me to the lower end of that range. So you can say, well, it's within the appraised range. So what I wanted to know is, well, where does the average property sit within that range? And in our Christchurch team for those fifty five properties, smack bang in the middle.
5:18 Speaker 01 Wow.
5:18 Speaker 00 Smack bang in the middle. So the average property, if we said five twenty to five forty, it rented for five thirty. So I was like, oh, I'm really happy with that. That tells me that's pretty accurate.
5:29 Speaker 01 Now with Auckland, yeah, the numbers aren't as glamorous, but again, we're going to share those numbers with you. And we do have a smaller data set, so we're only talking about thirty six properties now. Where the property was appraised from seven hundred to seven forty a week. Where did the average property end up getting rented? Well, it was actually at the lower end of the range, like on that seven hundred dollars a week.
5:50 Speaker 00 So while Christchurch was kind of the average property rented in the middle of the range, because the Auckland rental market has been going down and we appraised them so far in advance, they actually are sitting at the lower end of that range. So that's not ideal, but that is the reality of the market falling over the last kind of twelve months, not being as strong this year as it was last year.
6:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, definitely been harder for the team in Auckland and also again, because we're appraising things so far out that, you know, we might think, oh yeah, the, the market is actually, I, I remember a great example was just after the Auckland floods. There was actually fewer properties available in different areas that you wouldn't have expected it. As the market was going quite strong in particular areas. That of course gave our team recency bias when they're giving appraisals and then when we.
6:35 Speaker 00 Well, it's not so much recency bias, it's more that when you get a rental appraisal, that is what it would rent today. Because you can't, I mean, how can a property manager say, this is what it's going to rent for 12 months? Yeah, I can only say, well, this is what it is today.
6:50 Speaker 01 Because they're looking at what is being achieved today, right? That's what they're basing their numbers on.
6:54 Speaker 00 How many properties end up renting within their appraised range? How many were above? How many were below?
6:59 Speaker 01 So within the range, it was about 47%. Lower was also 47%. So, I mean.
7:06 Speaker 00 Forty seven percent of properties rented below their appraised range.
7:09 Speaker 01 So, so lower than that 700 in that example. And that's not a number that I'm actually that happy with. Now, again, this isn't to blame the Auckland property management team because they've been doing the Lord's work, getting properties rented on a really hard market. That just means that maybe we need to change some of our processes around how we're giving assessments.
7:28 Speaker 00 And probably just setting the right expectations around, hey, if it rents in 12 months, the market could change, it could be better. And some of our investors have definitely seen that where we appraised it for, you know, a property for maybe 700 and it ended up renting for 750. That's great news. But it can go the other way.
7:43 Speaker 01 There was still 6% that were higher. So, look, I mean, again, some people were winners in the set of data. But again, there were a lot more that didn't get the result that we would have liked. And again, that's something that we're going to say, hey, we want to do better on that.
7:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, and I, and I think we're trying to be self-aware enough that it's not like, oh, well, that's just the market. So let's just explain it away with the market's terrible. And what I want to look at the numbers, be upfront about the numbers and then say, cool, let's do something about them. But one thing I do like is that 95% of the time in Christchurch, from the numbers we've looked at, the rental appraisals, very, very accurate or higher.
8:20 Speaker 01 That's awesome.
8:20 Speaker 00 Very happy with that. 53% of the time in this limited data set we've looked at in Auckland, it was within range or higher. That's a number I want to improve on. But one thing I will just say about renting below the range, I know that sounds really terrible, that my next step was to say, well, of those properties that rented below the. Appraised range, whether it was seven fifty to eight hundred or, you know, eight hundred to eight twenty, whatever that was. How much lower than the range was it?
8:47 Speaker 01 How bad was it?
8:48 Speaker 00 How bad was it? Because if you said, cool, this property's got to rent for seven hundred to seven fifty. And it ends up renting for five hundred, that's really bad. Like, that's terrible. If you say this property's going to rent for seven hundred to seven fifty and it rents for.
9:03 Speaker 01 Six nine five.
9:04 Speaker 00 Six nine five, you go, do you know what? It's not within the range. There's a scale on here, right? Like, something being two hundred and fifty dollars a week below range would be way worse than five dollars a week. So of those properties that didn't rent within the range, the average property was twenty dollars below the bottom of the range. So what I mean by that is if it was appraised twelve months ago at seven hundred to seven twenty a week. And it was one of the ones that was under the range, then it went for six eighty.
9:35 Speaker 01 It's not bad.
9:36 Speaker 00 It's not as bad as it could have been. So that's just where I want to say, hey, look, I told you what the number was, like, pretty bluntly.
9:41 Speaker 01 Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying it's good either, but it's nowhere near as bad as what you might imagine. As soon as you hear half are outside of the range or lower than the range, that's pretty scary. But when you put some context around it, it's less scary.
9:54 Speaker 00 Well, the other thing there, remember, that was just the average property that was below the range. If you look at the average property overall in Auckland, they rented at the lower end of the range. I E, if we said it was seven hundred to seven twenty, the average property rented for six hundred. If you only look at the properties that were outside of the range, then the average property of that smaller group of properties was twenty bucks under. I know there's a lot of averages and stuff and all of these things, but I just want to get it across. The other reason that that might be the case is in a tougher market, some landlords will say, well, let's just drop the rent to to get somebody in there a little bit quicker as well. So there are a couple of factors at play. But what do you think the lessons are here?
10:34 Speaker 01 I think that you always want to take any rental appraisal with a grain of salt. And maybe when you're doing your numbers through something like Opus Plus, you put in whatever kind of number you're happy with. So is it the mid-range? Is it the lowest of the range? Is it ten percent below the lowest of the range? Whatever you're comfortable with, based on your risk profile, you put those numbers in and test some different scenarios in there because no one is ever going to get it right 100% of the time. So it's what can you tolerate if the range is not quite exactly right?
11:05 Speaker 00 Now, I would expect that if you were renting, like if you're a property manager and you're appraising a property and then you rent it out a month later, I'd actually expect their numbers to be better than this because they're not having to wait 12 months to rent out a property. And of course, the market can change more in 12 months or 18 months than it will in just, in just one to three months. The other thing that I'd say is like, this kind of shows that sometimes rental appraisals are very accurate and sometimes they're not as accurate. But again, I would rather say, well, these are what the numbers actually are. Let's keep updating you on what they are. I'll find a way to get these on our website so you can track them over time. And obviously, now that we're putting these out there, our goal is to make them as accurate as they possibly could be. And again, if you are a property manager listening to this, and some of, some of you are property
11:50 Speaker 00 managers, or you own a property management company, I would love to get a hold of your data if you track this, because it would be great to go out there and share that information and say, hey, here's a company doing really well. These are what the numbers are because you as property investors just want to know, well, if I get one, how accurate is it? And I genuinely don't think anybody's ever looked at this before. So over the last 15 minutes, you've learned whether you can believe a rental appraisal, or if they're just a fake guess, the percentage of rental appraisals that are accurate based on real property managers' data, and whether property managers are just gaming the system. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
12:36 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
12:39 Speaker 01 I'm your Nickel.
12:40 Speaker 00 We're going to be back in tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most after you've seen the property market. Until next time.
Previous Is This The End Of NZ Super?⎥Ep. 2132 Next Why the Great Wealth Transfer Isn't What You Think It Is⎥Ep. 2134 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated