Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Is this new rule the solution to NZ's housing crisis?⎥Ep. 2048 About this episode In this episode, we discuss whether the government’s RMA reforms could be the policy that kills the housing crisis — or creates a whole new one. You’ll learn:What the new RMA changes actually mean for the property marketWhether this could lead to a housing oversupply in some parts of the countryAnd when these changes are expected to kick in and how they'll impact house prices in NZIf you’re a property investor or developer, this is one policy shift you can’t afford to ignore. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Andrew Nicoll.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And today on the show, we're talking about is this government policy gonna be the housing crisis killer?
0:18 Speaker 01 Déjà vu.
0:19 Speaker 00 Could it lead to a housing oversupply? And when will these new rules kick in? Of course, we are talking about the RMA reform. But I always think every time I hear like, oh, we're gonna change the RMA. My eyes always glaze over because there's all of this technical speaking. You kind of don't know what the politicians are really doing. So simplify it down for us, Andrew. What is the RMA, the Resource Management Act?
0:43 Speaker 01 So the RMA basically is the rules that govern what you can do with your own land and basically what you can build and where you can build it. Now, Labour, they tried to do this. Then National came in, they scrapped all of Labour's rules. And now they're going to rewrite the rules again. And basically, they want to make it easier for developers to build more houses.
1:03 Speaker 00 And, you know, I think we can all understand that in principle. Okay, we're gonna change the rules, try and make it easy to build. But it's sometimes like getting blood out of a stone to try and figure out, well, what is actually changing? And I was just saying off air, if I had a dollar for every time a politician said, we're gonna change the RMA, I've got, I've come up with this idea. We're gonna change the RMA.
1:23 Speaker 01 A new idea.
1:24 Speaker 00 We're gonna fix the housing crisis and it's all gonna be good. Honestly, I wouldn't have to invest in property if I had a dollar for every time a politician said that, I'd be as rich as Andrew Nicoll. And so, I mean, it kind of feels like the RMA is like Madonna. It's had so many facelifts and makeovers.
1:40 Speaker 01 You've been thinking about that one all weekend, haven't you?
1:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, talk to Jay GBD, give me an analogy.
1:45 Speaker 01 Did you?
1:45 Speaker 00 No, no, I didn't. But I should have.
1:48 Speaker 01 I thought Jay GBD is getting quite sassy.
1:52 Speaker 00 So Andrew, what are these new rules gonna do?
1:55 Speaker 01 Well, the whole idea is that it is just gonna make it simpler so that you can build more properties on your land. And the real problem is that all the way through kind of a construction process, there are just all these different areas that you get a no out of. The councils are very good at giving you a no, and I'll give you an example I saw on the spin-off. A builder wanted to put an 11-storey apartment block on a site in K Road in Auckland, so really central location. And obviously that was gonna add to the housing supply, which is awesome. And then the council said no.
2:33 Speaker 00 Why did they say no?
2:34 Speaker 01 Well, the council's problem with the proposal was that they thought that it was gonna significantly impact, in a negative way, K Road, right? K Road's massive and there's-
2:44 Speaker 00 So adding housing supply to an area of the country and the city where there's actually a decent amount of homelessness, that's gonna negatively impact K Road if we build more houses.
2:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. And if you know the site, and I knew instantly the site that they were talking about here, that site's been bare for ages, it's just got a big wall along it with a bunch of posters, like-
3:03 Speaker 00 So it's an empty lot at the moment. I think it's right between a car park and a petrol station, right? And they're saying, oh wow, no, it's gonna impact the neighbours, really gonna impact that petrol station.
3:14 Speaker 01 The petrol station would love it.
3:16 Speaker 00 The spin-off starts querying this, that's a publication in New Zealand, and they were like, well, come on, how's it gonna impact the car park next door and the petrol station? They said, we see that it could potentially impact all of K Road because we're gonna have a new apartment block. K Road's got a bit of character.
3:33 Speaker 01 It's a grungy.
3:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, a little bit, but in a nice way. I mean, it's got some great restaurants, quite like K Road. But they're like, well, you know, if you build this big 11-storey thing here, it could impact the whole road. And you're like, yeah, in a positive way, because you've got more people living there in a part of the city where we need more, more housing. So council's got real creative at saying no. I'll give you another example that I saw. In Balmoral, which is another suburb in Auckland, a developer wanted to build three townhouses, right? The council said no because we need to preserve- Tram heritage in the suburb. Now, there's never been trams in Balmoral. Well, I'll give you another one. In Waikou, which is a suburb in South Auckland, like real quite rural. There were some people who wanted to put in a dairy, right?
4:16 Speaker 00 And then the council basically said no, because there might be too many traffic jams by people trying to get it and buy some snacks. I'm like, have you been to Waikou? There ain't no traffic jams.
4:28 Speaker 01 People getting a sausage roll gonna cause a major traffic jam. Plus, we're talking about Auckland here.
4:33 Speaker 00 The other one, and this is the one that really got me. So the spin off reported that Auckland Council opposed some new housing. This was at Sylvia Park, which is a major mall, because motorists won't be able to see a hill. And so what the council said was that if they build these new houses near the mall, well, that could overpower the motorway's initial sense of connection with Hamlin's Hill. And so basically, they were saying, if we put in this housing, that could ruin people driving on the motorways' spiritual connection to the hill.
5:09 Speaker 01 Who's looking at the hill? Aren't we really busy texting while we're driving?
5:12 Speaker 00 I don't, I don't know what shamans are working for Auckland Council, checking all of this. But I think some of these examples, you know, add them all up and you go, it probably has gone a bit too far. You can't even build what you want on your piece of land, even if it's not really gonna impact other people. And this kind of idea of, you know, well, what counts as impacting other people is so expansive.
5:36 Speaker 01 Yes.
5:37 Speaker 00 So National's talking about wanting to move from a culture of no to a, I mean, their slogan has moved to a culture of go. But what does that actually mean in practice?
5:45 Speaker 01 It'll probably be a culture of maybes, let's face it. But there hasn't been any lockdown rules yet. This is obviously what they're gonna work through over the next wee while. But the whole idea is that if you've got some land and you're gonna build on it, and there's not gonna be a negative impact on someone else, then you should be able to get a yes.
6:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, and they've got some quite interesting principles, which I agree with most of them. I mean, even though I'm always sceptical of RMA reform, given that everybody says that we're gonna make everything so much more simple. Like saying, right, rather than having one law, we're gonna have two laws. We're gonna have a planning act and we're gonna have a natural environment act.
6:22 Speaker 01 Makes it so much simpler.
6:23 Speaker 00 You know, we don't need, we don't need one law, we need two. But I do agree with some other things, like saying, we're going to really dive in on this economic concept of externalities, which is basically like you and me own houses that are right next to each other. Now, if I build a six-storey building, that impacts you because I'm gonna cast a big shadow over you. So there should be a rule, that means that I can't build this massive apartment block right next to you, because that's gonna have a negative externality on you. However, if I build a two-storey house and it doesn't cast a shadow over you, well, you don't really care what the floor plan is inside of my house. I should be able to make it whatever it is, because that only impacts me, it doesn't impact you.
7:07 Speaker 00 And so what some of the principles Chris Bishop, the Housing Minister, is saying is, well, if we think about apartments, there should be rules around where you can build apartments and how tall they can be, and if they cast shadows, all of that. But there shouldn't have to be a rule around whether apartments have to have balconies or not, because that doesn't impact the petrol station next door, that only impacts the people who live in them. And it impacts the developer and what they can sell that property for. Similarly, the internal floor plan of these apartments, well, that doesn't impact other people, it just impacts the person who is living in there. So there should be fewer rules about what happens inside the building, but we can still have some rules about how tall you can build them,
7:49 Speaker 00 maybe what it's made out of, make sure that it meets the good building code as well. But, you know, we could, we could relax some of these rules. I think that's fair.
7:56 Speaker 01 And I know in talking to a bunch of developers at the moment who are really struggling with councils' overreach, is that often there are times where they say, the council want us to do this, that's not what the market wants. So in fact, one developer was in our Christchurch office the other day, said, I'm gonna write a letter and just outline. Exactly what you've just told me in terms of the feedback we've given him about a project, which is the thing that the council is pushing you to do, that won't sell. People aren't going to want that. The market doesn't want that. So who cares if the council wants it? Let's just do something that's right to provide more housing.
8:30 Speaker 00 There's another interesting one. So I didn't realise there are something like eleven hundred, almost twelve hundred different zones in New Zealand. And it's because we have sixty six different councils. And so they have developed all of their own rules in terms of what's a commercial zone, what's a medium residential zone, what's a residential zone. And they'll all have slightly different rules because they're all independent. The government wants to scrap all of that and say, no, we're going to have twelve to fifteen zones. They're all going to have the same definitions and you local council or you different sixty six councils, you get to decide how you zone your areas, but you have to use our definitions. Because that way we can standardise it across New Zealand.
9:15 Speaker 00 I know that recently happened in Melbourne and in Victoria over in Australia. My understanding is that also happened in Japan where they started scrapping all of these different definitions, trying to standardise it a bit.
9:27 Speaker 01 So if I get this right, so rather than Christchurch having its definition of residential and then Auckland having a different definition, everyone's just got the same one. And so then if a developer's wanting to go build in a different location or the councils are stretched in Auckland at the moment. So Hamilton picks up some of their consenting process. It makes it a lot easier, right?
9:48 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah. I didn't actually, to be honest, didn't even think about councils outsourcing it. That would happen as well. I think it's probably mainly going to impact group home builders or developers who are operating in multiple areas. I'll tell you the other people who it could help is land surveyors. So I remember when we had service on here and they were talking about how, well, if you want to subdivide a property in Auckland, it's going to be very different. If you want to subdivide in Christchurch, it's going to be very different. That if you want to subdivide in Selwyn District, which is just fifteen minutes that way. So they've got all of these different rules, but actually if we can simplify it down, that could really benefit a lot of people.
10:24 Speaker 01 But the whole idea of this reform is that we're gonna move to a yes and less approach. So you should be able to get a yes unless it has a significant impact on someone else.
10:35 Speaker 00 Now, one thing that I've always liked is a bit like, okay, sweet. How much of an impact is this really gonna have? Cause it sounds good, but you know, like, what's the practical impact on housing supply?
10:46 Speaker 01 Well, I think the big one that you and I were talking about off air is that actually this is going to be quite a long process. And it's actually not gonna come into force until twenty twenty seven to begin with. And then the councils have to understand the new policies. It might slow down, things might bottleneck for a wee while. So yes, there could be an impact, a positive impact at some stage. But it is quite a wee way down the road before we start to see an impact. It might be kind of two to five years before we see any kind of meaningful change.
11:16 Speaker 00 The other thing you've got to factor in is like, okay, best case scenario, this gets into council's hands in twenty twenty seven. We have an election in twenty twenty six, right? Like, that's the next election that's coming up. And so let's say, I don't, I mean, we're so far out, you can't really forecast too much based on today's polls. But let's say that Labour gets in, they might scrap National's rules, just like National scrapped Labour's rules before. And say, do you know what we're gonna do? The way we solve the housing crisis is we're gonna rewrite the rules again. So you're like, okay, that could potentially happen. There could also be delays to this coming in. They might write the rules and say, cool, we've got these fifteen zones.
11:59 Speaker 00 But actually, the councils don't change how they're zoning properties or how they're zoning land. So we'll see how it actually gets implemented. In terms of housing oversupply, I am always very sceptical about politicians saying this is gonna be the thing that really changes everything. I think it probably will have an impact. When I, when I look back at, I think it was episode seven hundred or something. So like a couple of years back, where we were talking about Labour's reforms. What we said back then is, yes, this could enable more housing. I hope it does enable more housing because that would be a really, really good thing if our housing market. It becomes more stable, but I don't think that it completely kills the housing market. And the reason is that developers still have to have an incentive to build properties.
12:45 Speaker 00 And over time, we know that building costs continue to go up. Over time, real land prices will continue to grow up as incomes rise. And so the only way you'd get into a housing oversupply is in two real situations. Number one is kind of what we've seen, where you go through a property boom. And you get to the height of the market and developers are building, building, building, building, building. The the ass falls out of the market and then they're like, oh, we've built a few too many houses. Now, that is not a permanent oversupply because the population will continue to grow. And those houses will get soaked up by natural market demand. And developers will massively pull back while that housing supply gets cleared.
13:27 Speaker 00 That's kind of what's happening at the moment. That's why the number of dwelling consents has really fallen off a cliff. The second way is if the government decided to subsidise home building and say, we really want to push for housing supply. And so we're going to put our thumb on the scale in the market to make sure that more properties are built. But in a free market, over the longer term, you tend not to see massive permanent housing oversupplies. Because there might be periods where people are building too much, but then developers pull back after that. And that excess stock starts to get absorbed.
14:00 Speaker 01 So I don't think you're going to see any massive drops to house prices as a result of this. And particularly in its infancy, in terms of actually becoming policy. And I think the thing to remember is, again, there's going to be a two to five year journey. If it gets in place and it it doesn't get intervention from Labour Government, taking over and and scrapping the whole thing again. And you've got to remember, there are other factors that are going to happen at the same time. As interest rates come down and population growth increases, we may see migration numbers increase again. You know, again, this kind of all offsets each other.
14:33 Speaker 00 I always think you never want to be too roast into glasses, right? And be like, okay, this won't have any impact because it certainly could have an impact. But at the same time, you don't want to be so scared or Believe politicians' promises so much that you're like, this is going to change everything. I'll give you another example. So as part of the, the government's most recent changes, they're like, we want to introduce way, way more building products into New Zealand. And so we were talking about, well, how much of an impact has that had? Now, remember, we were talking about that probably a year and a half ago, when the coalition agreements first came out late 2023. I don't think anybody's seen any impact in terms of more building products being introduced. In fact, I think I was just reading in business desk, people saying, yeah, that's not going to have any impact.
15:18 Speaker 00 So you do want to kind of live in the real world and say, okay, there could be some changes. We don't want to underestimate them. We also don't want to overestimate them. But this is always why I say to people, don't bank on house prices going up by seven percent a year like they have in some cases in the past. Use a more conservative rate when you're forecasting your property investment numbers and use kind of 5% for all of New Zealand and maybe 6% for Auckland and Queenstown. So that's the government policy that could be the housing crisis killer. Could it lead to a housing oversupply? And also, when will it all kick in? Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate, review
15:54 Speaker 00 and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people. Thanks for listening to the Prop Economy Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. I'm Andrew Nettle. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of your selling housing market. Until next time.
Previous How I went from $5/hr to $8.5 million in property⎥Ep. 2047 Next The Airbnb tax trap no one talks about⎥Ep. 2049 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated