Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast How to investigate any property developer (NZ)⎥Ep. 1992 About this episode In this episode, we discuss how you can investigate any property developer in New Zealand. That includes the 3 things you must do before trusting a property developer. One of these is to use the Developer Database. You can use this to get free data about the big developers around the country. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast, my opus partners, I'm your host 79 And I'm Andrew McCall And today we're talking about how to dig up dirt on any property developer in New Zealand. That includes how to get access to 10K worth of data for free, how to read this data so you can figure out, well, which developers are growing and which ones are shrinking, and also the three steps that you absolutely must take before you start trusting any property developer in the country. And the reason we're talking about this is probably at the start of the year, I stole about 10 grand worth of money from Andrew and I came up with this idea of we should come up with a database of developers so that you can research them because it's quite difficult to. And we get asked all the time, what do you think about this person? And what do you
0:53 Speaker 00 think about this person? And does it way to just find it all in one spot? And one of the interesting things that I actually have never told you, Andrew, is when I was a kid. Here we go. I found out about this website called Cult Watch. I don't know how I found out about it. Is it actually cults? Yeah, it's about like religious cults. Look how old this website looks. Oh, it's real old. It was, it was good back in the day though. But like if you, let's find one that's like not very controversial. Is that, is that controversial? Yeah, no. No, that's not controversial these days. Yeah. And they, they talk about, is it a cult or not? And I always thought, oh, I'd love to create Cult Watch for property developers. Devwatch. To be honest, in my mind, this was a much better website. But back when I was looking
1:32 Speaker 00 at it, back in, it would have been 2006, maybe 2007. So what are we talking about? Almost 20 years ago. This was groundbreaking. It's probably not been updated in the, in the previous 17 years. But here we go. We've got Cult Watch for developers. And let's just chuck in like New Zealand's largest property builder, DJ Gardner Homes, and see what sort of data you can find out about them. I mean, what are you seeing here, Andrew? So I think the first thing is how many consents they've got being issued. And so whether or not they're increasing or decreasing. Now, the whole market has been decreasing over the last couple of years, but you probably want to get a sense of whether or not it's completely. Dropped off the side of a cliff or whether or not it's just dropped down to a more moderate level at the moment while the market's hard.
2:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, so G J Gardner's dropped from about sixteen hundred and eighty five consents a year. So that was the peak in twenty twenty one and they've dropped right back to just under eight hundred consents in the twenty twenty four data. What else is interesting for you? Uh, the next thing you can ever look at is what is their average build price? So if you look at G J's gardeners again, for example, you can see that they've been steadily increasing year on year. Now, does that mean that all of a sudden they're a really expensive builder? And I don't want to build with them? No, not necessarily. That might just mean that they're building bigger houses or more bougie houses. Yeah, I suppose the big thing as well is we've got this awesome rating on the site as well. Where you can say, okay, well, how big is this developer? Well, because one of the big questions you might ask is, okay, seven hundred and ninety nine
3:01 Speaker 00 consents, is that a lot or is that a little? Actually, that's a lot. So they are the biggest builder in New Zealand, biggest home builder in New Zealand at the moment. Their build cost is above average. It is on the more expensive side, but they are also building, you know, relatively large properties and they've been around for a while. I mean, there's a lot more in here, Andrew, but if you're digging through, how do you start to use this information? What information's important? What information's not? Because sometimes people will say, look, it's great info, but how do I use it? So I'd be thinking here about, okay, well, if I'm gonna go with G J Gardner, I mean, the the age of the company probably gives me a bit of comfort that they've been around for a while. So they're probably more likely to be around for a bit longer. That would be my first kind
3:45 Speaker 00 of thing. Then I'd say, okay, well, they're a larger development company. Some people prefer to work with a larger company. Some people prefer to work with a smaller company. So that's kind of a personal preference. Then I'd probably look at the build costs and size together. So then I'd say, okay, well, I'm looking for a house. So I would expect it to cost more to build that, but I am looking for a developer that's gonna be able to produce a larger style property for me because I'm looking for a family home. These are the right fit for me, for example. Yeah, I think property size and build costs become quite important, especially interplay between them. So if we consider somebody like G J. And we compare that to, let's use another well-known property developer like Wolfbrook, which was one of the companies people wanted to know most about.
4:29 Speaker 00 And our recent webinar, we can see that their build costs of their property size is actually a lot lower. So GJ Gardner, their average property size is 165 metres squared, building it for 540 grand. Wolfbrook are building townhouses and so their build cost is roughly half of that. If not slightly under half, the average build cost is 240 grand. Against a property size of just under 100 square metres. And so that tells you something about the sort of properties they are building. Now Wolfbrook don't build standalone houses, but let's say they had that offering. You'd probably look at this data and say, okay, well, they're probably not the sort of person you'd hire to build you a standalone home because they're building lots and lots of smaller, more affordable properties.
5:13 Speaker 00 Now, again, they don't specifically have that service, but that's an example. And again, if I'm looking at the number of consents, because I want to know, yep, have they got some substance in terms of being able to weather the storm that we're currently in at the moment in terms of the harder market? Okay, yeah, they peaked at 329 back in 2022. They've dropped like everyone has, but they've, you know, they're still maintaining quite a good level in terms of properties that they're consenting. I'll take the other reason why I really wanted to create this is if we look at, you know, a bigger company like a Wolfbrook or a GJ Gardner, we've written like lots of reviews about property developers in the past. I've got a whole one about Wolfbrook. But if I think about a smaller home builder like Orange Homes, we've actually had them on the show before. There is no chance that building, how many are they building, like 30 a year?
5:57 Speaker 00 There's very little chance that we're going to write a whole review about them. And so if we could get data for the top 200 developers and just give it away for free, that's going to be a good thing for people because then you can actually use it. I suppose the other thing that's quite interesting is really comparing like-for-like developers. So, okay, comparing Wolfbrook and GJ Gardner, they are quite different. So it's kind of hard to get a meaningful comparison between them because they are building quite different properties. But if I was to compare people who are building something quite similar, so say Oakridge is A Canterbury based developer that builds standalone homes. And I also pull up data about, say, Golden Homes, which also operates in Canterbury, but also around the whole country.
6:41 Speaker 00 Then because they are building similar properties, we can get quite a meaningful comparison. So what are the sorts of things we'd look at, Andrew? Well, the first thing I'd probably look at is, okay, does the developer size and the age of the company, does that give me some comfort around? Yep, who I'm buying with. And if we tick that box, then I'd move on to probably the build cost and the build size. And then I'd compare those next to each other. So I'd say, okay, the size might be, for example, on the average for Golden Homes is one thirty one square meters and the average build price is three hundred and fifty K. And then if I look at Oakridge, I'd say, okay, well, the average size house is quite a bit bigger. And actually, the average build cost is quite a lot cheaper.
7:22 Speaker 00 So if I'm looking for a larger house at a more affordable price, I'd probably say Oakridge wins out of that. Because in this case, I think Oakridge's houses on average are twenty five square meters larger, but cost forty five grand less to build. And so that's where you start to get a bit of insight. You take the data and you're like, okay, this is quite interesting. This gives me a sense about which way that I should go. The other thing I really like here is, and I know you can get this from Google, but you can look at their most recent Google reviews and the average of them. So, okay, there's only, there's only fifteen of them for Oakridge because they're a newer company. But they're all really, really good. Let's have a look at Golden Homes. I actually haven't looked at theirs. So they've got fifteen reviews as well, but their average is three and a half. So same number of reviews,
8:06 Speaker 00 but significantly worse reviews by looks of it. Unfortunately for them, the two most recent reviews for Golden Homes, and which Golden Homes office is this? This is for Golden Homes in Auckland. Their two most recent reviews are actually one stars. Now, it's really important to understand that we can only pull Google reviews at the moment for like one office. Now, for a smaller developer like in Oakridge, they only have one office anyway. For Golden Homes, which is a franchised company, I don't know the exact number of offices, but they might have twenty different. Ones around the country and at the moment we're only pulling from one of them. So make sure you check that out. And let's say you were buying from Golden Homes in Vicar.
8:48 Speaker 00 Well, their reviews might be quite different from the ones that we're showing on this website because these are being pulled from a Golden Homes office in Auckland. So do just keep that in mind. I always say some data is better than none, but we do also just have to be careful about it. And that leads to a really good question about, well, how accurate is this data? And it's quite funny because on a podcast not that long ago, we were talking about David Reed Homes. And I'll actually pull up their data so we can talk about it, Andrew. So David Reed Homes, we were talking on the podcast about how they peaked back in two thousand and six at like a hundred and eighty nine consents. And they've fallen off a cliff, according to this data, going down to about eighteen consents in twenty twenty four for this, this period that we're looking at.
9:31 Speaker 00 And I actually got a, got an email from David Reed's Business Development Manager. Is this after the webinar? No, after one of our, uh, it was a podcast, maybe three or four weeks ago. And he said, Ed, I really like your podcast. But just talk to me about where this data is coming from, because you're saying eighteen consents. But, you know, I'm not sure whether this is entirely accurate. So just talk to us briefly. Where did this data come from? So we get the data from a company called BCI and basically they go out and collect a bunch of information and then they collate it. And then they produce it publicly. You have to buy it though, right? You gotta, you gotta pay for it. Yeah. And so that basically shows all the consents that have come in from the different various building companies.
10:13 Speaker 00 Now, one thing that David Reed's pointed out is that it doesn't necessarily capture if they've got someone who independently applies for a consent. So I'll give you an example. Imagine I want to build an architectural home and I go to an architect and they design it for me. The architect might apply for the consent rather than the builder. And so as a result, that doesn't get caught up in David Reed's numbers, even though David Reed are the builders for it. Yeah, I put that to BCI as well though, and said, hey, this is, this is the feedback I've got. What's your take on this? And they said, well, you know, we've got twenty six researchers who call up developers all the time to find out what's going on. On the market, we've got a specialist building consent team who's through their experience and their algorithms trying to amalgamate that data.
10:57 Speaker 00 So even if the architect submitted the consent, trying to get that into David Reed's numbers. I'll tell you one little story as well, and that's a little bit funny. We've kind of had conflicting views out of David Reed as well. Like, because when we were on the phone with them, they were like, okay, just remind us, what did you say for the 2024 data? And we said 18 consents and they said, oh yeah, maybe that sounds about right. But I know that specifically at the end of the year, they're like, well, we signed 60 contracts over that that year. And so what you've just got to be aware of is consents and contracted sales are quite different. So they might have got 18 building consents issued, but they signed many more contracts and those might come through next year.
11:40 Speaker 00 Another good example would be probably a company like Williams Corporation at the moment. So I think they are at just over 200 consents, 225 consents over the period we're looking at. But their number of sales could be higher or it could be lower than that because we know that one of the reasons that the building has slowed down is they've got quite a lot of completed stock. This doesn't tell you how many properties they've sold, it only tells you how many properties have been consented. Yeah, and having a consent to build something doesn't necessarily mean you're going to build it either. The other thing is the way I would take this information and say, okay, well, even if the number's not correct,
12:18 Speaker 00 the number would have had that same variance over the last 10 years because you'd had the same issue with Dave Reed Homes where people were using architects as well. And so I just look at the kind of direction of everything, right? I always think the direction is the most important thing. Like, does it matter that G J Gardner peaked at like 1600 properties and has had 800? I don't know if that 800 number is exactly correct or whether that 1600 number is exactly 1685 as opposed to 1686 or 1684. The the exact number doesn't really matter. What matters is the trend and also the comparison to other developers as well. So let's say that G J Gardner's consents were massively undercounted.
12:59 Speaker 00 Well, if that undercounting happens across all developers, well, the relative position of who's larger, who's smaller, that should still be intact. But what I would always say is you can pick holes in any data set, right? Like, you absolutely could. If I wanted to play devil's advocate, I could. Be on my own YouTube videos being like, this guy doesn't know what he's talking about. He hasn't, he hasn't counted this, he hasn't counted that. That's what I do at the weekend. Oh, really? That's what I do, what I, call me on your videos.
13:31 Speaker 00 But we've got to understand that just because something might have a couple of flaws, doesn't mean that it has no value at all. We've got to acknowledge the flaws while also acknowledging the benefits. Just one other thing, uh, speaking about David Reed and BCI. So when I called up BCI and said, hey, I've had some questions around this data. What they said was, well, this is going to be really positive because if David Reed got in touch with them and said, hey, look, uh, your numbers aren't correct. We had more than 18 consents in this period within 2024. BCI will be like, sweet, give us your numbers and We'll update it. We will update it. Isn't it amazing that BCI, because they've been around for as long as I can remember. It takes us to do a webinar for Dave Reed to actually look at the numbers and then contact them.
14:14 Speaker 00 Well, I think that what David Reed were talking about, and I think this is a pretty fair point, is in the past, BCI, they put out reports and they're kind of industry-based PDF reports. So what I mean by that is they get a PDF of all the numbers and it's a massive table. And I'll actually show you one, Andrew, because I've got one. I'm pretty sure I've got them right on my desktop. There we go. I'll show you what it looks like because it's not, oh, we'll all look at the Taranaki one. So if we look at house builders in Taranaki. Are you going to say that their, their argument is that no one really looks at them? Well, uh, I probably am going to say that, but you know, we get this table of numbers and I don't expect anybody to understand exactly what this means.
14:55 Speaker 00 But you know, it's just got the consents broken down. So GJ Gardner, Taranaki, this is for 2019. They did five in January and five in February and one in March. And you know, to be honest, the average consumer isn't going to look at this. But I think because now we're making it public and saying, cool, these are the numbers. I think they're like, okay, well, if it's just builders sizing themselves up against other people, I probably don't care. But if customers or people who are buying properties or wanting to build properties are then using this to make a judgment. Actually, we probably care a little bit more about correcting the record. And I think that can only be a very, very good thing to make sure that the data is as accurate as possible. I know you've also had emails from developers about this.
15:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, I've had more emails about this than any of our webinars before. And either from customers saying, hey, I noticed that X, Y, Z aren't on there yet. Or a developer saying, how the hell do we get on here? We're not on this last year. I'm quite surprised by that because. You think a lot of people would be worried about it. I thought it was the opposite. I thought, take me off that. I was, that was what I was expecting. And there's why aren't I on there? I want to be in there too. I want to be on property developer cult watch. Because some of them have seriously dropped off the side of a cliff because a lot of developers are sitting on their hands at the moment, waiting for the market to correct. Some of those names emailed me. I thought surely you don't want to be on there at the moment seeing this massive drop off, but they, they want to actually be on the list. They want to be part of your club, Ed.
16:22 Speaker 00 That first, for the first time ever, people want to be part of Ed's club. Oh, I love it. Ed's developers, that's what we'll call it. And a lot of people said, well, why aren't they on the list? So what I've done is all we've looked at is this specific period in 2024. So it's between October 2023 and September 2024, because that was the data we had available. And we said, okay, let's just look at the top 200 developers within that period. So let's say that there was someone, I'll just pick a random name, who's not on there, like GrowCrop Freer, which is a, a, a quite a large developer in Christchurch, right? So they're not currently on there. And the reason might be that within this period that we looked at, they didn't issue a lot of consents. But maybe that's because they're building all of the properties that they consented the year before.
17:06 Speaker 00 So they could still be very, very busy. They just haven't done a lot of consents within that 12 month period. And so at the moment, I've only got the top 200 builders or the top 200 consenters for this period. But I've got a lot more others on my list. If I tell you the exact number of developers who I've got data on. Ah, here we go, ranked developers. Do I have all of them in here? Yes, I do. Am I reading that right, saying it's 10,000? Yeah, so we've got data on just over 10,000 builders. Now, quite a number of those are going to be like. Just look at the one that's actually at the bottom of my list. So Wish Homes, doesn't that sound like the shopping app? So they've basically built nothing until, I think, twenty twenty four, where they've consented three properties.
17:51 Speaker 00 So very few people are going to be searching for Wish Homes. So you've left them off for now. Exactly. And so anybody who's, who's kind of these very small builders that have maybe only done one project, we've kind of left them off. And I've just said, okay, give me the top two hundred. But Andrew, the other thing that we mentioned that we talked about at the start is, okay, what are the three steps you've got to do before you trust a property developer? Like, how do we, how do we dig up some more dirt on them? Okay, so developer database, that's number one. So you've looked at the data there and gone, yep, these guys look like the right fit for me. Then you want to go to good old Google. So go to Google and use the news tool. So we're looking at Google News, not just at, at regular old Google. Yeah. And let's give you an example. So Flower Day Homes is a good example. So this is a developer I get asked about often.
18:36 Speaker 00 So you might search for them and have a look at, okay, what, what does the news say about them? And more importantly than just the name of the company, you want to dig into who the owner of the company is and then search their name as well. So let's go to Flower Day Homes. So if we jump on their website and we look at, you know, who's in their team, we see that it's led by a guy called Rick Flower Day. So let's have a little look, look see at that in Google News. And probably I'd also encourage you, don't just look on the about page on their website. Look at the company's office and then do a search of the shareholders and directors as well, because it might be that someone is behind the scenes and they're not publishing them on the internet. Okay, so if we Google Rick Flower Day, there's some more, more recent articles.
19:21 Speaker 00 But there's this one from two thousand and eight. And this is an article about the fact that Rick was actually tied up with a company called Blue Chip. And some of your older listeners will remember Blue Chip were a big developer that collected a bunch of deposits off people and then went broke and didn't pay anyone back. They ripped a whole lot of people off, basically. And so this might give you a bit of a sense like, okay, maybe these are some questions that you want to ask if you want to work with a specific developer going forward. So I think Google News is a highly underutilized tool. I know everybody says Google them, just Google them. But I specifically reckon Google News because then you're going to be able to get articles that might be buried.
20:01 Speaker 00 And you also want to make sure that you're using Google correctly. So do you want to show how you use inverted commas to make sure you get a name correct? Oh, yeah. Okay, this is pretty cool. So this is why it's called Boolean logic. So if you say, hey, look, I don't want Ricky Flower Day, I don't want Rick Flower Days, I don't want Rick Flower Da. I just want the specific phrase. So if you chuck a double apostrophe around the name, that'll just search that specific phrase. Just be a bit careful because in this case, I think the name was. Variation was actually useful, right? Yeah, it was quite useful because I think the name was maybe Ricky Flower Day in that specific article. Let's find out. It is always interesting when you're, when you're looking up names, people that do have stuff that they don't want you to find.
20:46 Speaker 00 You'll notice they change their name or the way they advertise their name. So Ricky's obviously gone from Ricky to Rick, and I'm sure he might goes Richard if something else went wrong. Well, that's actually funny you should bring that up because another one that I've heard about or often get asked about is a company called Investment Build NZ. And I remember we used to get a lot of questions about them because they're doing a lot of social media advertising. And they've got quite a nice website. They've got a, a logo with a lion in it. You know, in 2021, they built 43 investment builds. So you're like, okay, I'm interested in building an investment property. Maybe I should talk about these. Now, one thing that's quite interesting, and this kind of comes to the third thing you should do.
21:27 Speaker 00 Is there aren't a lot of names on this website, just a guy who either calls himself Blake or Blakey. So one of the things I often recommend people do is go to the New Zealand Insolvency Register. And this will tell you whether a company or a person has been bankrupted in the past. So if we just type in Blakey and hit enter, we see that twice a person called David Blake or David Blakey has been made bankrupt. And so that happened in 1991, happened in 2006. My understanding is actually changed the name again, and I think it, I think it was three. For three, wasn't it? Yeah, I think so, but I can't, I couldn't recall it straight off the top of my head.
22:07 Speaker 00 And so that might be like, okay, maybe this is not the sort of company that I particularly wanna work with. So some combination between using the developer database, that's step one. Step two, checking out Google News specifically, both the name of the company and the name of the directors, perhaps even the shareholders, other people who are involved with it, and then the insolvency register as well. And that'll give you a really good understanding of what comes up. And I think I spoke about this on the podcast last week as well. Sometimes if, if you can't find information on a website, like just basic information, that is a major red flag for me that I will dig in even deeper. So we had an example where there were some properties that we were gonna have a look at. And I went to the developer's website and there was just nothing about them.
22:52 Speaker 00 No name anywhere. I thought, that's really, really weird. I did Ed's trick of using the privacy policy and terms and conditions, couldn't find anything. Then I went to the, the domain registration page, the WHOIS. And then I found the phone number and then I Googled the phone number with the inverted commas and ended up tracking it down to an ex Deval employee. Now, that wasn't an issue in itself, but once I scratched the surface some more, it was a couple of Deval staff members that have gone out and started their own thing. One of whom was quite a senior member of the team, a director there. So that would not be someone that I'd be recommending. So you really wanna just see if you can scratch the surface and go a bit deeper, particularly when companies are vague, they don't talk about who's behind it.
23:36 Speaker 00 Yeah, good example of that probably is Investment Build. So we've got a first name or just aunt name, Blake is the contact and a phone number. Typically, my trick is to go to the privacy policy or the terms and conditions on a website, because it will usually say what the company name is. So this presents itself as investmentbuild.co.nz. But what is the company name that I can then take and put into the company's office to find out who the shareholders are? One other trick is to go to the Domain Commission in New Zealand. And I use a slightly different website. But if we type in investmentbuild.co.nz, we confirm that. We're not a robot. Wow. I don't know that ticking a box will confirm you're not a robot. No, no, no, it does. That's how they do it. Don't do that.
24:20 Speaker 00 And what we can start to see is, well, who registered these domain names? And we say, okay, there's this person Blake D N Z. Okay, yes, that probably is David Blake. We see a company Builder Management Limited. Okay, they're the registrant contact. Now I can start to search for them. And so that kind of gives you a sense of, okay, well, how do I, how do I dig a little bit deeper here? So that's how to get free data about any developer in New Zealand. That's how to read it. So you can kind of get a sense of whether these developers are really good or not. And the three steps you must take before trusting a developer. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more people.
25:06 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host Stephen Knight. I'm Andrew Nicoll. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most of you in the property world. Until next time.
Previous "The property developer screwed up - But I won anyway"⎥Ep. 1991 Next NZ Herald is wrong – what they missed about retirement⎥Ep. 1993 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated