Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Explaining Homes.co.nz's wild price swings⎥Ep. 1996 About this episode In this episode, we discuss why Homes.co.nz's online valuations jump around so much. This includes how their algorithms work, what causes the numbers to go up and down and how often they are updated. We also mentioned that you should check out the HomesEstimate page on their website. For more from Opes Partners: Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter Instagram TikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Seven Night.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nichol.
0:12 Speaker 00 And today on the show, we're talking about why is my property's valuation just jumping around so much? So picture this, you've got a lazy Sunday afternoon to yourself. You go onto homes.co.nz, you type in your property address, maybe the home you bought five years ago, perhaps even an investment property. And you're like, hang on, why has my home's estimate or my QV or my One Roof valuation, whatever online estimator tool you're using, why has that just dropped $50,000?
0:44 Speaker 01 Now you're poor.
0:45 Speaker 00 Well, you feel poor, you definitely do. You're drinking the cheap wine that night.
0:49 Speaker 01 No, but eats that day.
0:50 Speaker 00 So over the next 15 minutes, you're going to learn what's driving these extreme swings in online valuations for websites like homes.co.nz. You're going to learn what makes those online platforms change the values you see. And lastly, what you can actually do about it. And this all happened because actually a listener of the show, they, they went on the 10th of January and they were like, hang on, yesterday their home dropped by 10% overnight. They lost on this website, quote unquote, lost $200,000 on their family home and 50 grand on an investment property, which of course is going to be very concerning if you've got quite a lot of debt on that. So what's happening here? And I'll tell you a little story, Andrew. This happened to me.
1:34 Speaker 00 One of my properties was valued, this was back in 2023. It was, I kind of say valued, but we're talking about what the online estimator says. It's not truly a valuation, but it dropped from 560 grand to $445,000 within just two weeks.
1:56 Speaker 01 Pretty depressing. Is that when you were using your work card all the time?
2:00 Speaker 00 There was 115 swing downwards, which is just way beyond what was happening within the suburb. So way, way different from what was happening in Swindon. Sort of a normal market, you'd expect some ups and downs, five K here, 10 K there. That's kind of quite normal in the property market. But in my case, I wasn't doing like what we talked about a week ago. I wasn't talking to a real estate agent and getting them to submit documentation to fiddle around with my homes.co.nz estimate. So what's actually going on? Andrew, how do these algorithms really work and what causes these jumps up and down?
2:34 Speaker 01 Well, a couple of things can happen that might cause a bit more volatility than just a normal market. And, and one of those things can be a change in the way that homes, for example, calculate your value based on the algorithm. And actually, as an example, homes.co.nz, they updated their algorithm in January 2025. So this guy absolutely could have been caught up in, in that change. And the way that works is they've got a formula that says, okay, if these number of properties sold for this amount and it was in with this distance from the house, that spits out a value for your property. And if that calculation changes, that reflects in a change in value for your property.
3:10 Speaker 00 Yeah. The other thing that they, homes.co.nz say that they've changed is that they're using more AI or artificial intelligence, especially in areas where they don't have a lot of data around what properties are selling for. So I wanted to find out a little more about that. So I got, we've got a journalist who, who calls people up and interviews them for this podcast. Cause I have no social skills. I just want to crunch numbers all day. And then I say, Jackie, what did they say? That's actually a little bit how it works. And homes.co.nz were not very forthcoming with, what does this algorithm change mean in terms of AI? And how does it work? All they'd really say is that, okay, we had an algorithm change. And so it happened pretty much, Phil,
3:53 Speaker 00 who was the listener of the show who emailed in, at the time where you're saying, hey, my property value seemed to drop by 10% overnight. Losing 200K on your family home, it coincides with that algorithm changing. Now, one big question a lot of people are going to ask Andrew is, well, how am I supposed to know whether the homes.co.nz value jumping up and down is due to my property genuinely being worth less or an algorithm change?
4:18 Speaker 01 Well, you can actually go. Go online. If you're a real nerd, I'm assuming you've done this, Ed.
4:23 Speaker 00 Of course.
4:24 Speaker 01 Yep. Homes dot co dot NZ slash home estimate. And it actually goes through the changes that they made. And you could say, okay, well, that makes sense. They've changed it in this way and that might have affected me.
4:34 Speaker 00 Yeah. And the main thing there isn't that, like, the description is a bit like, you know, when you you go to update your iPhone app or your Android app.
4:42 Speaker 01 Fixes bugs.
4:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, fixes bugs. It's basically, it's a little bit like that, but at least they give you the date of when they made an algorithm change. So I'll get producer Dave to drop that link of, where you can see their latest updates down in the show notes, in case you're really, really interested. But what I could understand it is you might say, yeah, okay, there was an algorithm change, but it still says that my house is worth $200,000 less. So like, shouldn't I still feel bad about that? I still feel 200K poorer. And I suppose the main reason we say, okay, sweet, there was an algorithm change, is it is not true that the value of your house suddenly dropped 200K overnight. And it is not true that the value of your investment property dropped automatically 50K overnight.
5:26 Speaker 00 That didn't happen. What they're trying to do with that algorithm change is, in their mind, reflects the true market value. Now, whether that's correct or not is anyone's guess. And what I would say is that homes dot co dot NZ is 10% wrong on average. That's kind of a decent ballpark. So if homes dot co dot NZ says your property is worth a million bucks, there's only a 50% chance, a coin flip chance, that your property actually sells for between $900,000 and $1.1 million. That basically means there is a coin flip chance, a 50/50 chance, that your property sells for either less than 900K or more than $1.1 million.
6:07 Speaker 00 I'm just trying to get across to you, Phil, and everybody else who who sees these algorithm changes, oh, my God, I've made 200K, or, oh, my God, I've lost 200K. I would not get too excited about any of that, because the truth of the matter is that homes dot co dot NZ is incredibly inaccurate anyway. I get that we go on there either to make ourselves feel good, hopefully some of the time, and sometimes, you know, we.
6:29 Speaker 01 Help us negotiate.
6:30 Speaker 00 Sometimes we might, oh, well, homes.co.nz and your property wasn't worth it. But the truth of the matter is that they're inaccurate anyway. Again, you've only got a coin flip chance of selling either within 10% above or within 10% below. Rough numbers. So you've kind of got to ask yourself, well, was the value that I saw on homes.co.nz or One Roof or whatever website you're using, was it more accurate a month ago before the algorithm changed? Or is it more accurate today after the algorithm changed? You don't really know, do you?
7:01 Speaker 01 Not until you sell something.
7:03 Speaker 00 Because one way to look at it would be to say, okay, it's not that your property value dropped by 200K. It was just that those previous values were 200K too high. Well, who knows whether that's correct or whether, well, they've introduced this AI. Who knows how it works? From talking to them, it wasn't obvious that they knew how it worked. So is that new 200K lower valuation, is that the more accurate one? Or is the truth somewhere in between? So my main point is when you see these algorithm changes, I would not read too much into it. To bring it back to the property I talked about before, that went from 560 down to 445K. That happened in 2023. Six months later, it dropped up back to 500K and I apparently made 50K overnight. In one scenario, I lost 115 grand overnight.
7:48 Speaker 00 The other, I made 50K overnight. And all I'm saying there is that these values drop off a cliff sometimes and sometimes they climb up a cliff. Very quickly. I'm not sure. Is there a saying around there?
8:00 Speaker 01 Just, it sounds like it might be right.
8:03 Speaker 00 Let's go with it. Let's go with it. Now, apart from the algorithm changes, even if you log on, you're like, well, the algorithm hasn't changed, but my property value has jumped a lot. What kind of pushes it up or down?
8:15 Speaker 01 So if you think about, okay, well, I've got the formula that's going to arrive at a number. But also I've got the inputs that go through that formula. And so if you've got properties in your area that are selling at higher or lower rates than what your value is, then maybe that's going to also affect the value of your property. So I'll give you an example back to Ed's property. So Ed's property was $560,000 and then it went down to 440. Forty five thousand. Now, the part of the reason for that might have been that there was a property that was pretty nearby, about a kilometre away, that sold for four hundred and seventy thousand dollars. And then there was also a property sixteen hundred metres away that sold for only four hundred thousand dollars.
8:55 Speaker 01 Now, what the formulas in the computer will never be able to tell is whether or not those people selling those properties were desperate. They might have had a really hard financial situation at the moment and they had to sell it at rock bottom prices at a really hard time in the market where maybe there weren't a lot of buyers. And so they accepted just cents on the dollar to get that property off their books. Now, as a result, that might then affect Ed's final valuation on his property.
9:26 Speaker 00 I suppose the other thing that the algorithm can't see, because it's not an accounts or database necessarily that's accessible to the algorithm, is any structural issues.
9:35 Speaker 01 Yeah.
9:35 Speaker 00 So the property you said sold for four seventy, okay, maybe that maybe that was quite a quite a fair sale, I don't know. But the one for four hundred K that seems very, very low, then you might say, okay, was there a structural issue? Maybe that was a townhouse that had a structural issue. Maybe it was an apartment block that had really high body corporate fees because there was a lot of deferred maintenance. That's something that the algorithm can't really see. And so in a market, if there are not that many transactions going on, then a couple of outlier sales will drag that value around. And it's not simply that, okay, well, if a whole heap of really expensive properties sell, that's going to pull the average value of that suburb up or the average sale price of that suburb up.
10:19 Speaker 00 So my value looks higher. Well, it's more about, are those properties that did sell, did that sell for more or less than homestock.co dot N C thought that they would? Well, if they're selling for less, then maybe the market's dropping a bit and the output values tend to change to reflect that kind of new market reality. So firstly, recent sales, they definitely impact those online estimates and and make them jump around a bit. But why else do they jump around?
10:48 Speaker 01 Well, I think it also depends on. How often their data is updated as well. So homes.co.nz, they update their values every fortnight. QV is every week. So QV, you might see value changes far more frequently than homes.co.nz. And so because homes.co.nz is a bit longer timeframe, those adjustments might be a lot sharper. And actually, our journalist spoke to James Wilson, who's the operations manager at QV. And he said, because they look at everything on a week by week basis, it can look quite jagged in terms of the, the, the ups and the downs. They don't smooth out those changes. So it would look a lot more volatile if you were looking at it week by week.
11:28 Speaker 00 Oh, so what they don't do is say, okay, what was the value last week? How has the market changed? We said that the property was worth a million bucks last week. We think that the market's gone up by a percent. So let's, let's take last week's estimate and push it up by one percent. Now it's, you know, a million and $10,000.
11:48 Speaker 01 No, it's much more binary than that.
11:49 Speaker 00 So they just, what do you mean binary?
11:51 Speaker 01 Right, in terms of they, like they have a num, a single output.
11:54 Speaker 00 They rerun the algorithm effectively every single week. And that can mean that, okay, we've got new data in. So it pushes that million dollars up to a million and $50,000 or down to $950,000. And that is why it's jagged. They're not joining it up on a week by week basis, which is probably what a lot of people would have expected them to. Like, I was quite surprised when James said that, because I was like, oh, most people would probably think that they'd be like, okay, it was a million bucks and now it's a million 5,000 and now it's a million 10,000. And okay, now it's gone down to 990, but no, it's a million, that's 1.05, that's 1.1, now it's, that's even lower.
12:36 Speaker 01 And I think people do get a little bit obsessed with this, particularly if you're bank with ANZ. If you go into the ANZ app, when you see your account balance, you also see your house value. And that's supplied by QV, I think from memory with, with ANZ. And so people wonder why it has dropped so much.
12:50 Speaker 00 One thing I have noticed is that, and this is like totally anecdotal, but just because I go on the One Roof website quite a bit, I've noticed that theirs is a little bit more smoothed out. I think it's because they work with Velocity as their data partner. And so I've just noticed that it is a little bit smoother. But I do get that a lot of people really are concerned about this. And obviously Phil, who emailed in is like, oh my gosh, maybe property's not for me. Maybe this is quite scary. I mean, how much attention should people pay to this?
13:18 Speaker 01 I think you need to separate yourself from this. And again, if you're with A and Z, you are going to see it on your app all the time. But look, at the end of the day, it only matters if you're going to probably sell the property. So if you're going to put your property on the market, you may be more actively looking at what your value is. But remember, take it with a grain of salt. But also maybe if you're going to borrow against that property to buy another property. So that might come into it, or when you go get a valuation for the bank, that might affect your borrowing ability. But at the end of the day, property prices are going to jump around all the time. And particularly if you're using these online systems, that doesn't necessarily reflect anything until you actually put the property on the market. If you think about it, like KiwiSaver, if with your KiwiSaver, that jumps around all the time as well.
14:04 Speaker 01 But because we can't access it for another 20, 30, 40 years, we kind of don't really worry about the small bumps in the short term.
14:10 Speaker 00 So what have we learned? We've learned what's driving those big ups and downs. It might be algorithm changes, it might be similar sales. And also the fact that the algorithm's been rerun. We've found out about what makes them change and also what you can do to just keep a cool head when you are looking at those online. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. It really does help us get the message out to more people.
14:39 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight. And I'm Andrew Nicoll. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the new selling property market. Until next time.
Previous I tried Rent-vesting to get a cheaper house⎥Ep. 1995 Next The truth about property flipping (2025)⎥Ep. 1997 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated