Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Could You Lose Your Deposit Before Construction Starts?⎟Ep. 2499 About this episode You've paid the deposit. Then the developer goes bust. What happens next?
In this episode, Ed and Andrew unpack one of the biggest risks of buying a new build ... and the simple checks that could save you tens of thousands of dollars.
You'll learn:
How buyers can lose hundreds of thousands of dollars before a house is even built The one line in your contract that decides whether you get your deposit back When even a Master Build Guarantee won't save you Sometimes the biggest risk isn't the house itself. It's the contract you sign before construction even begins.
Book a meeting https://bit.ly/3QE2XJN with Opes Partners to start your path to financial freedom with a detailed financial plan for $0.
For more from Opes Partners:
Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter https://www.opespartners.co.nz/newsletter-sign-upInstagram https://www.instagram.com/opes_partners/TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@opespartners
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by UBS Partners. I'm your host, David Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew McCall.
0:13 Speaker 00 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn deposit disasters, how buyers can lose hundreds of thousands of dollars on a house that never gets built, the one line in your contract that decides whether you get your money back or not, and the times when even a master build guarantee won't save you. Now, the truth of the matter is you can sign up for a brand new build, pay the deposit and then the company goes broke. And the question that keeps buyers up at night when that happens is where did my deposit go and am I going to get it back? And sometimes the answer is that it didn't go very far and you're never going to get it back. The money's been spent, the house was never built, you're basically at the
0:57 Speaker 00 back of the queue while the liquidator's winding up that company. Now, remember, a deposit on a new build, that could be 50 grand, it could be 80 grand, it could be way more than that as well. And that's often going to be like a buyer's entire life savings. But I know that you've been checking out some stories in the news and have found some pretty sad things.
1:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's been quite a bit of this recently and I saw one on staff, there's a property developer who just can't repay buyers' deposits after his company went bust and was already seeking $2 million for a brand new virtual reality venture. Like, this is a guy who has let people down, taken money, basically folded his business and not been able to pay them. And now he's going to raise money from someone else. I think that's gross. And, you know, that company, which was MGM Homes, the owner took 87,000 in deposits from one home buyer and just spent it on a whole different project. Like, in my mind, that's criminal. Like, that's cruel. That's disgusting.
1:56 Speaker 00 Now, when it comes to deposits and how protected yours is, it does depend on what type of contract you've signed. I always like that to point this out, even though we've banged on about it a lot over the last seven years of this show, but just because people don't, don't know this and it is so important, can you just briefly outline it?
2:14 Speaker 01 Yeah. So if you've got a progressive payment contract, you're going to buy the land off a land developer and then you're going to pay a builder and installments to build your house. And if you're making payments to the builder, they're going to use that money to build your house. So there's kind of no like in between deposit per se, but you probably are paying a bit further ahead than the project is because that's just the way there's the contracts are stacked generally versus a turnkey contract where you pay a deposit at the start and you pay for the balance of the property once the property is complete.
2:44 Speaker 00 And if we think about that person who lost 87 grand with MGM Homes, you know, they would have paid that money to try and get $87,000 worth of work done on this, this house starting that they're building. And then, once that money's been exhausted, MGM would come back and say, cool, pay us some more so we can keep going. But they took the 87 grand and didn't do anything with it.
3:04 Speaker 01 Now, one of the things though, that's really important. So, so not all turnkey contracts are created equal. And one of the things you want to think about is where's my deposit going? So if you buy off a developer and it's a turnkey contract, I 10% now, 90% when it's complete, if you pay that money to the developer, you're at a major risk because if the developer goes under, you're one of those creditors that you've got to go through the process to recover your money in the event of the liquidation of the company. Now, the key thing that you want to see is the money gets paid to a solicitor's trust account.
3:37 Speaker 00 Because if you're just an unsecured creditor, right? And the bank's ahead of you in the line.
3:41 Speaker 01 Join the queue.
3:42 Speaker 00 That when they get to the back of the line, right?
3:45 Speaker 01 No queue cutting.
3:46 Speaker 00 Like the banks in front of you, they're going to wind that company up and the bank of the IRD might be ahead of you in that line of who gets paid out first.
3:54 Speaker 01 And then of course, there's going to be fees and actually winding up the company. There won't be money left over, generally speaking.
3:59 Speaker 00 Now, are you actually seeing that at the moment, developers having contracts where they take your deposit, don't put it in Solicitor's trust account, use it to fund the project. You're actually seeing that.
4:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, but there are also some clever developers that I've noticed in some of the contracts. It says it's paid to a lawyer's trust account, but then it says it's released or it's not held as stakeholder, which means that basically it's held on behalf of the people involved until the project's complete. So what I would be recommending is that all contracts have a protection for the purchaser so that the deposit wasn't released until the builds met its code of compliance and title. It's been finished, basically.
4:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, because otherwise you could pay it to a trust account.
4:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, and it gets paid out.
4:42 Speaker 00 But then it gets paid out the next stage.
4:44 Speaker 01 And if that's in your contract, tough titties.
4:46 Speaker 00 That's quite clever, actually, isn't it? That's so bad. But sometimes you look at people who do dodgy stuff.
4:52 Speaker 01 I do look at them like, that was clever, that was clever, but, but wrong.
4:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, but, and I suppose that the fix to that is we, as property investors and buyers, have to be more clever and spot that as well. And if I think about a real, like, example of how bad it can get, there was, I think it's pronounced Cassini Homes. This was in West Auckland where the people who were winding up the company said that the buyers, who were mainly first home buyers, all up, these guys were owed $2 million. They, all these first home buyers and buyers, they paid deposits of 75 grand to about 100 grand each. The deposits were not held in a separate solicitor's trust account. And if you think about that, a poor first home buyer, they've put all their kiwis over the,
5:38 Speaker 00 put all of their money into this property and then it's gone. Now, the sad thing about that situation is that the land that they were going to build these houses on was never bought. There was no build in progress. And the High Court in Auckland, they appointed a liquidator and they said, we can't have a situation where developers being paid deposits when they haven't even settled on the property. And look, I see commentators in the media saying, well, we need to change the law to fix this. We need to change the law to fix this. But I know that the law is not going to change tomorrow, right? It's not going to change tomorrow to protect you. But you can protect yourself by looking out for this kind of stuff in the meantime. You know, we might never get a law change, right?
6:24 Speaker 00 So we have to be the ones who are looking out for these risks and being a bit more clever. Now, if we think about this, like we've been talking more about new builds, but what about if it's deposits for like an existing house? So you turn up to an open home, you buy a house that was built in the 1970s. How safe is my deposit if I do that? Cause I've got to pay a deposit when I buy a property.
6:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. And so usually in that case, so often you'll see that deposits will be paid actually to the owner straight away. Um, once you go unconditional. Now, it might go via a trust account and normally the real estate agent might get their commission out of that. And then the balance gets paid on to the, the owners. But actually there's, there's no development risk in that process because the property is already there, right? You might be settling in a couple of weeks' time. So it's not like the, the house isn't going to be there in a couple of weeks. So I mean, I'm sure there've been instances where someone's actually burnt down the house between going unconditional and settling just, you know, by accident. In that case, your money would have to be paid back and it's unlikely that the seller has spent that money in the meantime.
7:24 Speaker 01 But generally speaking, if you're buying an existing house, you eliminate that risk of someone going under in between. But that's not to say that new builds suck because at Opes Partners, that's all we recommend, new builds. What I'm probably just highlighting here is that that additional risk that you have, that development timeline risk, because you might pay for a deposit now and be settling in 12 months' time, two years' time maybe even. At least so at the moment, but let's say that that was the case. You just have to have some things in place to mitigate that risk, that extra risk that you're taking on. And things like, for example, deposits going to a builder or deposits going to a developer or deposits going to a lawyer's trust account and then to the builder or the developer.
8:08 Speaker 01 That's the kind of thing that my team are trained to avoid to spot in a contract because we're not prepared to let a client risk even a dollar in a deposit that might go to someone before you've got a product delivered.
8:20 Speaker 00 Now, let me ask you this about master's build guarantees though, because people sometimes say, but I've got a master build guarantee. I know I'm signing up to, to a progressive payment package. So I've bought a piece of land, the developer's doing it. I understand the risk. One of the things I'm doing to mitigate that risk is to get a master build guarantee. But what does and doesn't that cover?
8:43 Speaker 01 So the master build 10 year guarantee does cover a loss of deposit and non completion. But it does have some limits. So loss of deposit, it's the lesser of 50,000 or 10% of the contract price. Okay. So if you paid a hundred grand deposit, it's 50,000. Or in the event of non completion, it's the lesser of half a million dollars or 20% of the contract price. So there's potentially quite a big financial gap there. If you've drawn down money to pay the builder and they fail, you still owe the bank. They don't care that the builder's gone under. And so when you've got a half finished house, which isn't worth as much when it's half finished,
9:26 Speaker 01 and you're paying interest to the bank, your builder's gone missing and your master bill's got a limitation there. It really can put quite a lot of stress on you.
9:35 Speaker 00 Well, even in that example, like, let's say your builder's gone under. It takes a while to find a new builder to pick up the, the work and keep going. If that takes two months, because all the good builders already have projects or something like that, then you've still got an additional two months of mortgage interest costs that you're paying back to the bank.
9:55 Speaker 01 Well, a great example of this for me that I was kind of exposed to was my friend Brenda. She was building an investment property through Stonewood Homes when they went under, you know, way back when, before the Chau brothers bought them. And I remember like the master bill meant that someone would step in and complete that job and that it successfully did that. But it took an extra 12 months. Now Brenda, a successful businesswoman, she could afford to continue to make those interest payments. But plenty of people wouldn't have been able to do that. And I think that's really interesting. And also, you know, I've had lots of people try and make master bill claims that actually haven't gone the way that they've wanted. Like they've tried to and they've had issues doing that.
10:31 Speaker 00 Do you know the other thing that I often see when people are complaining about master build? Yeah. Is when the buyer thinks that they've got the master bill guarantee, they paid the money for it. Because remember, this is an insurance policy, right? So you pay the money. But then it's up to the builder to pay the money and lodge it with master build. And so.
10:53 Speaker 01 Done that.
10:53 Speaker 00 Yeah. And then, and if those people are a bit dodgy and they're going through some liquidation, some hard financial times and they don't lodge that, then they fall over. You think that's okay, at least I've got a master bill guarantee. But if that was never lodged, you don't have that insurance policy, right?
11:06 Speaker 01 And or if it's been transferred within an appropriate timeline. Like I've got a client who, who effectively has a policy that was paid for. But because it wasn't transferred, he can't make a claim. If he sells the property, this is the dumb thing. That policy can be transferred to the new owner, so long as it's done within the, whatever the window is, that's called a hundred days. But they can't make the claim as like, I really dislike it as a product. So anyway, there's my two cents. And just bear in mind, we are talking about progressive payment builds there. So I think, you know, builds do have more risk with them than buying something that's complete. But they've also got their benefits as well. So again, risk is okay so long as you understand what those risks are and whether or not you're comfortable with them. And then also how to mitigate some of those risks.
11:48 Speaker 01 So the things that I'd get my team to do would be finding out how much the deposit is, find out who it's being paid to and find out how long it's going to be there. I, what's the trigger for that deposit payment to be released? If it's going to a lawyer's trust account to the developer. Is it at foundations down or is it at completion?
12:06 Speaker 00 Yeah. And also what does it actually say in the contract? Because it's no use, but they said in the meeting that they didn't get the money until the end.
12:17 Speaker 01 Good luck with that.
12:18 Speaker 00 Something else in the contract, it's whatever's in the contract that you actually signed.
12:23 Speaker 01 And actually, that's a really good point because not only are we talking about developers, but even if you're working with an agent or a property investment firm or whatever, I've seen a property investment firm contract where, again, they'd said, oh, deposit's protected. Wasn't protected at all. And also get your lawyer to check.
12:38 Speaker 00 And the reason we're sharing this is because we help hundreds of clients go ahead and invest in new builds. Yeah, every single year. We see what can go wrong and what developers also try. And so this is about sharing the information of what we see and say, this is what we're trying to do to protect people. Now, if you want to get the benefit of that, you can always go on opespartners.co.nz and book a free portfolio planning session with one of our financial advisers. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned about deposit disasters, how buyers can lose hundreds of thousands of dollars on a house that never gets built. The one line in your contract that decides whether you get your money back or not, and the times when even a master built guarantee won't save you. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast.
13:22 Speaker 00 Really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:32 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Sid Attni. We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most of the news on the property market. Until next time.
Previous The Managed Fund Mistake Most Investors Make⎟Ep. 2498 Next Don't Choose Your Agent Like This⎟Ep. 2500 Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated