Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast Airbnb Is Riskier Than You Think⎥Ep. 2153 About this episode Airbnb can look like a cash cow … but beneath the glossy headlines, there are risks many investors don’t realise. In this episode, we break down the true costs of running a short-term rental and the mistakes that catch Kiwis off guard. Because while Airbnb can boost income, it’s not always the money-maker it seems. You’ll learn:3 hidden risks every Airbnb investor must knowWhy one Wellington investor lost money despite solid occupancyHow local councils are cracking down – and what it could cost youDon't forget to create your free Opes+ account here. For more from Opes Partners:Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletterInstagramTikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Ubers Partners. I'm your host Andrew Nicol.
0:12 Speaker 01 And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties. So you could be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're going to learn the three major risks to running an Airbnb, why this investor is making less than he ever dreamed, and why your rates bill could go up 260%. Now Andrew, can you make more money renting out a property on Airbnb versus doing it kind of just as a normal long-term rental?
0:39 Speaker 00 So you can, but there's so much more complexity to it than that. But if you think about, okay, if I rent out my property, it might be $550 a week. That's as a normal rental property. If I rent it out as an Airbnb, yep, there's some other steps I need to follow, i.e. furnishing the property, but if I did that, I might get $150 a night. And so if I rent it out for the entire week, great, I've made $1,050, which is $500. I've almost doubled my money compared to the long-term rental. And then of course, you know, you might have these really busy seasons, times of the year, where you can double that amount per night, maybe not double, but you know, you might get 50% more.
1:16 Speaker 01 I think you certainly can. I mean, in the Christmas period, if you've got a really good Airbnb property, you could easily get double what you usually would in a night, depending on what's happening within it. And so because Airbnb is so attractive, I think a lot of people start becoming very interested in it. But you've just got to be aware of the risks. So what this podcast won't be is us saying, never Airbnb your property. It is just us saying, hey, if you're going to, here are some things that you really need to think about. And one of the main ones is what we call vacancy risk. And I often think about like smaller towns that really are quite touristy. And you think that'd be a great Airbnb, but maybe it's really popular during the summer, but not in the winter.
1:58 Speaker 00 And I think problem is people go to these locations in the summer and they've got now the bias of saying, oh, wow, it's really busy and it was hard for us to get in Airbnb. Yeah, that might be the case. For three months of the year. For the other nine, it might not be.
2:12 Speaker 01 Well, one of my favorite tricks to figure out, well, what is the vacancy in an area is to use air DNA. We actually had the head of data analytics come on to our show earlier this year. But one area of the country that I'm always interested in is Ruapahu district. So in Ruapahu, you've got, you've got, oh my God, I can't believe I'm saying this. You've got Mount Ruapahu. And it's, and it's got some ski fields, it's got two ski fields. Great place to go over the winter. You've got Oakune, Mardi Gras, that happens there. So there is some, some real reasons why people decide to go to Oakune. But if we look at the occupancy, I'm like, oh, wow.
2:50 Speaker 00 It's quite low compared to what I thought it might be.
2:52 Speaker 01 It's like forty three percent is the average occupancy rate for Airbnbs in that area. And you go, okay, like, it probably is a good place to have an Airbnb for forty three percent of the year, but for some parts of it, oh, it's not. It's quite seasonal. And so the average daily rate can be quite high, you know, a hundred and ninety five dollars. But we see that it tends to be higher in July and June, when it's winter time, and really low during autumn.
3:24 Speaker 00 I actually think for a lot of people, they get into Airbnb chasing the extra dollar, but they might not necessarily have the stomach for long bouts of vacancy and it will rarely get to them. I was having a conversation with an investor just the other day and my advice to them is you guys are way too risk averse to have, you know, even a week's worth of no bookings. They would get quite worked up about it.
3:46 Speaker 01 The other thing that I was just thinking, I mean, it's amazing how simple maths pleases simple minds. But let's say that you had a property that had seventy percent occupancy on Airbnb. So if you had seventy percent occupancy, I mean, you'd feel pretty good about that, right?
4:03 Speaker 00 The number, that, that's, that would be a high number, I would have thought, yeah.
4:06 Speaker 01 But that means that you've got thirty percent vacancy, right?
4:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:10 Speaker 01 Well, thirty percent vacancy is like three and a half months of the year.
4:15 Speaker 00 That's quite a lot when you put it, when you can compact it like that.
4:18 Speaker 01 It's just over fifteen weeks. So all. Almost four months of the year empty. Now that could be spread out or it could all come in all of a sudden at once. And so it's just when you, when you say it though, that way and you think, wow, do I want my Airbnb to be empty for four months of the year? And would I be comfortable with that? And we just said that 70% occupancy was pretty good.
4:38 Speaker 00 And you can't pay your mortgage just on those 70% of the year. You get to pay it 100% of the time.
4:42 Speaker 01 Reg reg B and C, sorry, I don't have much.
4:44 Speaker 00 Seasonal adjustment.
4:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, I, I need to pay more to my mortgage during the good months and can you just reduce it during the bad months? You know, maybe you could hack it using our revolving credit, but for most people, that's not really how it works. Now, the second big risk that I see is around councils and regulation.
5:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, in my mind, honestly, this is like the number one because it's something that's completely out of your control. And there will be change, like a particularly, like if you're buying an investment property, you should be thinking about the next 10 to 20 years. And if you don't think there's going to be a change in the next 10 to 20 years to Airbnb, you're off your head. And we've already seen this, like back when Airbnb first came out and it became really, really popular in different parts of the world. It was the wild west. You could do whatever the hell you wanted. But then as time's gone on and there's been pushback from, you know, hotels and, and councils. All of a sudden, you've seen there's a lot more restrictions come in. In some parts of the world, you can't even Airbnb a property anymore quite the same way.
5:46 Speaker 00 And similarly, you know, even here in, in Queenstown, for example, where we've had lots of changes to what you can and can't do with Airbnb.
5:54 Speaker 01 Well, at one point, Queenstown was trying to basically ban Airbnbs or make it not ban them, but mean that you've got to pay much higher rates and get consent if you wanted to rent it out of Airbnb for more than 28 days. Now that didn't go ahead, but it, it shows you that there is a desire to regulate Airbnb more. And there are some restrictions down there around how, how many nights a year you actually can rent it out there.
6:17 Speaker 00 And I think a lot of people have just flown under the radar and that's okay, right? Until it's not okay. So I, like I see developers at the moment, it seems to be like the popular way to sell a property at the moment is to tell people. How much money they can make off Airbnb and their absolute nonsense numbers a lot of the time. But one of my friends, in fact, bought a property through Opes Partners that were advised by me as a normal long-term rental. Now, my friend's brother, he's made a lot of money on Airbnb personally. And so, of course, these guys had complete rose-tinted glasses around Airbnb. And I said, I wouldn't do this and you're not consented for it, but you can. And they did. So they went, they furnished the whole property. They used a lot of, like, some of the stuff that they had in storage.
7:02 Speaker 00 So it probably didn't cost them as much as, as it could have, because it was a three-bedroom house with garage. I mean, that could be, you know, 20 grand worth of furniture. Let's say they did it for 10. It was quite successful for a couple of months. Then a letter comes in the post from the council.
7:16 Speaker 01 What did it say?
7:16 Speaker 00 We think you might be using your property as Airbnb. You're not allowed to do that. And they thought, oh, just ignore that for a while, screw that up, throw it away. Another letter came and then the next one had a fine attached to it.
7:28 Speaker 01 How big was the fine?
7:29 Speaker 00 I can't remember, but it was enough that I was like, okay, this is a bit more serious now. You probably don't want to be in breach of, of what your consent is because you might find that your insurance is void if something happened to that property.
7:42 Speaker 01 So what, like a couple of hundred bucks that fine might have been?
7:44 Speaker 00 It might have been, but, but also what they would potentially do if they want to go through the process of retrospectively consenting Airbnb so that they can do it. Their rates aren't going to be three and a half grand. They'll be like seven and a half, maybe more.
7:56 Speaker 01 Well, that's the important thing in Auckland as well, is that if you rent out your property for over 180 days in a year, you're no longer going to be on the residential rate. You're going to pay a higher rate, which can be up to 2.6 times that of the standard residential rate. And it's really funny because I was recently sitting next to, at a, at a dinner, a politician who's quite high up in council. And we were talking about how there is a push from the national government at the moment to cap rates rises. So that the council will not be able to continually increase in rates again and again and again and again.
8:31 Speaker 00 Would this include properties that were then consented for Airbnb? Because then it's commercial.
8:37 Speaker 01 Nah, it would be the average increase in residential rates. And so one way to get around that, if the government decided to cap rates is, well, that's fine. We'll just go after all of the properties that are meant to be paying higher rates that are currently on Airbnb but have been flying under the radar. So that would encounters them increasing their rates, Paul, and that'd be a way to get more income. Whereas in the past, they haven't gone after it.
8:58 Speaker 00 And it's funny because I know in the show in the past, we have said, you know, the councils have been pretty relaxed at how they're policing some of this. Yeah, until they need the money. Like, that will change. Like, if you actually wanted to task people with doing this.
9:13 Speaker 01 The properties are on Airbnb.
9:15 Speaker 00 The government's got a pretty good tool to find them. Jump on Airbnb. Oh, that property there. They can track that down. Plus also, they can track it with the IRD. Like, just remember, the government agencies can speak to each other and get that information pretty quickly. I am big on this. I think that people go into Airbnb and don't think about the regulatory changes. It will change.
9:34 Speaker 01 Well, that doesn't mean that it's a risk for everyone. If you've got the appropriate consents, like some properties do in Christchurch, you're fine. If you've got the appropriate consents in Queenstown or Auckland, you're fine. It's if your business model relies on skirting under the radar from the council. And even if I was in Oa Kune and I was a councillor or worked for council, you can pretty quickly come in here and say, oh, this is a property. It's had forty-one percent occupancy. It's been available for three hundred and forty-four days. That's over the hundred and eighty day limit. Therefore, send them a letter. Let's get them paying higher rates. That's how the council could literally do it with tools that are out there. The third thing that you want to factor in is
10:18 Speaker 01 some of the hidden costs around Airbnb as well, Andrew.
10:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, you need to think about some of those costs that, again, people really obsess over my nightly rate and the occupancy. And we think, oh, yeah, this is great. But it's that old adage in business, turnover is vanity, profit is sanity. It only matters what drops out at the bottom at the end once you've paid your costs. So if you think about things like cleaning, unless you're gonna do it yourself, but at that stage, you're just giving yourself a job, you're gonna have to hire someone. It's probably gonna be, I don't know, somewhere between eighty dollars and a hundred and fifty dollars to clean the property.
10:48 Speaker 01 I can imagine you with your little yellow rubber gloves on, you know, with your little sponge.
10:53 Speaker 00 Oh, you'd like to see my maid's outfit, wouldn't you?
10:56 Speaker 01 Oh, disgusting.
10:58 Speaker 00 Think about things like your linen fees, because again, you're gonna need to be replacing, uh, you know, the sheets on the beds, hopefully. Management fees and management fees aren't like normal property management fees where you might pay eight to 10% of your rent that you collect. You're talking more like 15 to 20%. Utilities, so you don't pay for the utilities when your long-term tenant gets the power connected, but you do have to pay for things like power and the internet and the gas, if you've got gas at the property. Those are things that you'd have to wear as the landlord. And, you know, there's also just gonna be other things like consumables, like most Airbnbs are gonna have soaps and, and all of that kind of jazz.
11:36 Speaker 01 Oh, your teas, your coffees, your salt grinder, and then somebody messes it up. And then salt grinders, they're easy to mess up. I think I've messed up two or three of them just this year, Andrew. So you gotta buy some more of them.
11:47 Speaker 00 Like either you are buying cheap pepper grinders or you're not right in the head, or both.
11:53 Speaker 01 A and B.
11:54 Speaker 00 But I think maybe the, the most expensive component to the hidden cost is actually the setup. Like to set up an Airbnb, it's not like you can just put your old couch in there and, and your dusty old mattress. Your expectation for most people when, when they go and rent an Airbnb is, you know, close to a hotel room. And so you're gonna have to put reasonable furniture and reasonable setups in there. And it's everything, like it is cutlery, it's cups and all that kind of jazz.
12:22 Speaker 01 And I was speaking to an investor recently who had a, a property in Wellington. It was an apartment and he was, you know, Airbnb-ing out. And when he ran his numbers, he thought, okay, I reckon I'm gonna make about 15 grand in profit a year out of this Airbnb.
12:35 Speaker 00 15 grand?
12:36 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so you'd say, that's pretty good. That's really nice. And so he buys the property and it has quite a small mortgage on it. But then there were all of these hidden costs. So it wasn't just the management fee, but the linen fee, which I think was like $7 a night or something.
12:53 Speaker 00 Which, well, I mean, you go $7 a night. Oh, that's not very much, but it'll add up.
12:58 Speaker 01 And then because it was an apartment, there was like a, I think this was ridiculous, but it was like a lobby key box.
13:04 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah.
13:05 Speaker 01 So there was like. Of rental fee. So, so to have the lockbox with the keys in it in the lobby of this apartment building, they were charging him for that. And it was just cost on cost on cost. And oh, there's a cost to refill the soaps and there's a cost to refill that. And you go, holy heck. All of a sudden, I think rather than making 15 grand a year, he ended up making something like 1600.
13:27 Speaker 00 Which, I mean, at that stage, like, it's still great, still making money, but it's way less than what you're expecting. And it doesn't take much in terms of, okay, well, now in a few years' time, I've got to completely replace some of that furniture. That 1600 dollars a year hasn't really paid for it.
13:43 Speaker 01 And I, I just want to emphasise again, we are not saying Airbnb bad, don't do it. We are against people investing without knowing the full situation. We are against people investing with their eyes closed. We're very pro people investing and very pro people Airbnbing when they've got all the information and going in with their eyes wide open.
14:01 Speaker 00 One of our property advisers the other day ran a scenario past me where one of his customers was going to buy a property and it was the only way the numbers worked was on Airbnb. And I was like, it's such a new concept. It is a relatively new concept that will change in, I, I think the, the medium term, if not the short term. And it's so out of your control that why would you buy a long-term investment, i.e. property, with a short-term cash flow situation that's going to make it work? Like, if it doesn't work as a long-term, then it's probably a bad idea.
14:33 Speaker 01 The other thing to point out is, let's say that you were going to buy an Airbnb in a tourist town, something like Awakune. And the reason I'm thinking about this is, literally this morning, as I was lying in bed, I was thinking about Awakune. And the reason is
14:46 Speaker 00 Obviously.
14:47 Speaker 01 Is because I've read an article about that the local Iowes are trying to shut, if I've read the article correctly, someone correct me in the comments section if I haven't understood this correctly. But what the article said was the local Iowes wanted to shut down the ski slopes and say, actually, we don't, I have to send you the article. But that's, this, this is the crux of it. We don't want the ski slopes to be open. And so you go, okay, if that were to happen, what does that mean for your Airbnb in Awakune? And so all of a sudden, the industry in the town, or a lot of it, and a lot of the demand for the Airbnb is based on one or two attractions. And so you just want to think about that if you're investing in a very small tourist town.
15:30 Speaker 01 I mean, if it's Queenstown, you've got about six or seven ski slopes, you don't have to worry so much about that specific risk. You might worry about other risks, like what if tourism doesn't keep performing? But if you're looking at very specific small towns, just think about some of those additional risks and make sure there's enough going on in that town where it still makes sense as a long-term rental. And so that's the other thing I'm very, very pro. Now, having said that, how much extra would somebody usually make out of Airbnb compared to a long-term rental?
16:02 Speaker 00 We've done a few different scenarios and I think we did one on one of your apartments. And I'm pretty sure it worked out to be that you could potentially make an extra $150 a week.
16:11 Speaker 01 Yeah.
16:11 Speaker 00 Which, nothing wrong with that, like $150 is a lot of money, particularly if you went and used that to pay for your mortgage. And if you already had the furniture, so you weren't going to be having extra setup costs, or I think particularly if you're going overseas for a secondment or something like that, what a great idea if the numbers work, but always run the numbers and do it properly. Like, honestly, it really grates me that developers go out there and say, oh, this is a great Airbnb. Developers and property sales companies should not be doing things on Airbnb, it's irresponsible. So do your own set of numbers and we've got a great tool for that, Opus Plus, so you can go and sign up and, and, and put any numbers you want in there. And you can run different scenarios, that's what I love about it. You can put in a normal rental, but then you can add a scenario and then put in the
16:54 Speaker 00 higher setup costs, higher mortgage, because you might have to, you know, add on some extra money to pay for the furniture, higher property management, but higher rental income as well, and see what the numbers work out. And then you can actually work out, yeah, for that extra $500 a week, I am going to take the risk. Or for an extra $100 a week, you know what, I'm not going to.
17:14 Speaker 01 And we'll drop a link to Opus Plus down the description so that you're able to sign up for free. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned the three major risks of running an Airbnb, why this investor is making less money than he ever dreamed, and why your rates bill could go up 260%. Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast, really does help us get the message out to more people.
17:42 Speaker 01 Thanks for listening to the Property Canoe Podcast. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
17:45 Speaker 00 And I'm Andrew Nuckle.
17:46 Speaker 01 We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the news on the property market. Until next time.
Previous How This Investor is Finding 20% Gross Yield Properties for Just $360,000⎥Ep. 2152 Next Where Can I Find Cashflow Positive Properties? (NZ)⎥Ep. 2154 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated