Pod Insights The Property Academy Podcast 7 steps to make any property decision ⎥ Ep. 1944 About this episode In this episode, we discuss the 7 steps you can take to make any property investment decision. Throughout the episode, we use the question: "Should I sell my property and invest in something else?" We then apply the 7-step decision-making process, that way property investors can get a sense of how to use this model to make the right decision. Every. Single. Time. For more from Opes Partners: Sign up for the weekly Private Property newsletter Instagram TikTok
Transcript 0:08 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Opes Partners. I'm your host, Stephen Knight.
0:12 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
0:13 Speaker 00 And on the show, we're talking about the seven steps to make a good property investment decision. That includes what those seven steps are, how to use these steps to make the right decision every single time, and a real example of how to do it. Now, Andrew, what is this all about?
0:29 Speaker 01 So we talk a lot about the data to do with property investment on the show and the problems with property and how you make the right decision. But everyone faces different dilemmas emotionally when they go through the roller coaster of investing, be it property or something else. And so rather than talk about data today, we're going to use the tools that come from the seven steps from Dartmouth College, which is a big Ivy League university in the United States.
0:56 Speaker 00 And to show you how to use it, we're going to use an example that we hear all of the time, which is should I sell my investment property to go and invest in something else? Whether that be shares, another investment property, or something else.
1:10 Speaker 01 Okay, and so what's the first step in the process? And how do we, how do we apply that to this?
1:14 Speaker 00 So the first step is to identify what is the actual decision we need to make? And how are we going to go about making this decision? And some of you will have your eyes, I can see you, your eyes are glazing over right now while you're listening to this on the trade.
1:31 Speaker 01 Pay attention.
1:32 Speaker 00 This is very important because people skip this step and it bites them in the ass later on. We need to be really clear on what the decision is. So let's say that you currently have a property and it's based in Wellington and I've picked one that's currently in my Opus Plus portal.
1:49 Speaker 01 Oh yeah, so you've taken one out of there.
1:52 Speaker 00 So it's on Old Coach Road in Wellington. And let's say that I own this property and it's worth 700 grand. Should I sell this property and invest in something else? Well, the first thing you've got to say is, well, how am I going to make this decision? And what am I really looking for now? I'm a property investor, so I just want to make as much money as possible. So the measure is money, right? But that's not good enough because there are lots of different types of money. You could make money through capital growth. You can make money through cash flow. Over what period do we want to make this money? So I'm going to make this really simple and I'm going to say, I'm going to base this decision based on two things, based on cash flow and based on a return on investment analysis through Opus Plus, which is basically the new version of our return on investment spreadsheet we always used to talk about on the show.
2:37 Speaker 00 So if I feel like this property that I own is not giving me the right capital gains, it's not going up in value and it's not giving me the cash flow. I've got to say, well, what is my success criteria? And so I'm going to say my measure of success is two things. Firstly, if I sell this property and buy something else, I want to get the highest return on investment possible and I'm going to measure that through Opus Plus. The second thing I want to do is make sure that anything else I invest in has at least as good a cash flow as this property that I currently own.
3:10 Speaker 01 So let me get this straight. So step one is all about deciding what the process is going to be for success or failure.
3:16 Speaker 00 Yeah, because then we can go about figuring it actually out.
3:20 Speaker 01 And then what's the second step then?
3:21 Speaker 00 So the second step is to go out and gather all the information. What have we got to figure out in order to make this decision? And again, we're still putting in the groundwork here. And a lot of the questions that people send in on the show, we are just following this sort of process. What's success going to look like? How are we going to go about making this decision? And then we get on to step two, which is gathering that information. So the two things I really want to know in this scenario is number one, how much money am I going to walk away with if I sell? And then what are the internal investments and what do the returns on that look like? So it's really simple, really logical. If I do sell this property, how much money am I going to get?
4:04 Speaker 00 So in this case, this property is valued at $700,000 and in this example, I'm going to say it's got a 300K mortgage. So you might think, oh, well, that's good. You sell that for 700 grand.
4:14 Speaker 01 400K.
4:15 Speaker 00 You pay off your 300K mortgage, we've got our 400K. Ah, ah, ah, we've got to think about the sales costs because you're going to have to engage a real estate agent. You're going to have to think about potentially staging that property.
4:26 Speaker 01 Your lawyer.
4:27 Speaker 00 You're going to have to pay some advertising costs. On the show, we always ballpark it at 5% of your property's value. So in this case, if you sell it for 700 grand, you've got 35 grand worth of sales costs. So you walk away with 665K. You use that to pay off your mortgage, which was 300 grand, and you walk away with 365K in order to invest. So that's what we think we're going to walk away with. Now, at the same time, that's where we start to think a little bit qualitatively as well. Because you can't just think about, okay, I'm definitely going to walk away with 365K. You've also got to think about, well, what confidence do I have that I'm actually going to achieve that 700K sale price?
5:11 Speaker 01 Yeah, and what range am I going to accept? Because you kind of need to know your bottom dollar sale price if you're going to go through this process. Because you can't get it on the market and then all of a sudden take less money and then realise, actually now I don't have as good an alternative to invest in.
5:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, and so you're going to think, is this a buyer's market? Is this a seller's market? How difficult is it going to be? Am I going to achieve what I think I can? So at this point, you know the decision, you know how you're going to weigh it up. And you also know how you feel about what you currently own. And that takes us on to step number three, Andrew.
5:42 Speaker 01 Which is looking at the alternatives. So if I'm going to all of a sudden have $365,000 to reinvest, I need to know, well, what am I going to do with that money afterwards? And it doesn't have to be another investment property in the same location. You might say, okay, well, I'm going to take my money out of Wellington. And now I'm going to invest in Auckland because I think it's at a better time in its cycle to make some money, for example. Or you might say, actually, that was a growth property. But now I'm really focused on getting a higher yield because I'm about to enter a later stage in my investing career. I'm going to get to retirement sooner. So maybe you want to look at a yield property now. Maybe you'll want to go completely different and go for a commercial property. Maybe that's the path you want to go down. Or it could just be something completely different. It could be, hey, I'm going to take that money.
6:25 Speaker 01 I'm going to invest in shares for the next few years or I'm going to invest in term deposit, wait for the market to come right, whatever your decision is. But the key thing is you need to weigh up what your alternatives are with that money that you're going to net. And then you need to think about, the other option is, do I keep that property? But is it structured right? So maybe, maybe I could increase the rent to get my return up on the existing rental. Or maybe I could renovate it or Airbnb it. You need to go through these decisions in your head as well. Think about, okay, am I maximizing my return on investment on my current investment? And what's my alternative with the money if I cash out?
7:01 Speaker 00 And the reason you want to get all of these ideas out of your head is then you can start to analyse them. Where people mess up the most when it comes to making an investment decision is they come up with some alternatives, they'll start thinking about them, they'll go look at some of the evidence. But then what they'll do is they'll start thinking, oh, but what about this? But what about that? And it's all of those secondary thoughts that come through just as you're about to make the decision that throws the whole thing off course because now you're thinking about all these other things. So get everything out on paper and then we move on to step number four, which is weighing up the evidence. Look at the pros and cons. Do you know what's funny? My first girlfriend ever decided to break up with me based on a pros and cons list.
7:46 Speaker 01 I love that.
7:47 Speaker 00 Did I tell you that?
7:48 Speaker 01 No, this is, okay. And did you see the list?
7:51 Speaker 00 No.
7:52 Speaker 01 I wish, I wish you had.
7:55 Speaker 00 No, actually.
7:56 Speaker 01 It would have messed with your head.
7:58 Speaker 00 It would have been soul destroying. I remember.
8:01 Speaker 01 Why did she tell you this? To be fair, I also know that you have broken up with people using a pros and cons list, my friend.
8:09 Speaker 00 I know, it's because she told me about it. Cause I remember asking her, we are going to come back to property investment, by the way.
8:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, but this is good.
8:17 Speaker 00 But I said to her, oh, you know, how did you decide to break up with your previous boyfriend, Aiden? It was actually my friend.
8:24 Speaker 01 Oh, you dated your friend's girlfriend, ex-girlfriend?
8:28 Speaker 00 Yes, well, I mean, was he, was he, was he a good friend?
8:30 Speaker 01 Buddy, boy co.
8:32 Speaker 00 He was on my debating team. Does that count?
8:35 Speaker 01 You called him your friend?
8:37 Speaker 00 Yeah, maybe that wasn't a good thing.
8:38 Speaker 01 You dogged him, no.
8:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, I felt very self-righteous and right in that situation.
8:43 Speaker 01 Oh, that, that sounds like you.
8:45 Speaker 00 I mean, as most 17 year olds are, but maybe, maybe I should need to track him down like.
8:49 Speaker 01 Apologize.
8:50 Speaker 00 Like I'm in Alcoholics Anonymous. Do they call up? Is that what happens? They call, isn't that what happens? You call up and you make amends?
8:57 Speaker 01 So, yeah, yeah, you, yeah, I think you do.
9:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
9:01 Speaker 01 Please get him on the phone.
9:02 Speaker 00 Aiden, I'm sorry.
9:04 Speaker 01 I dogged you.
9:05 Speaker 00 Yeah. But they were already broken up. Does that count?
9:08 Speaker 01 Absolutely it counts.
9:10 Speaker 00 Anyway, so what, so you're back.
9:12 Speaker 01 Pros and cons list.
9:14 Speaker 00 And she said, oh, yes, pros and cons list. And then, and then I said, oh, why are you bringing up me?
9:18 Speaker 01 You fall victim to the pros and cons list.
9:20 Speaker 00 I did. She said, well, the cons outweigh the pros. I thought, oh, wow.
9:23 Speaker 01 I find that he's a little bit of a leaver as well.
9:32 Speaker 00 Now, anyway.
9:34 Speaker 00 How did we get on to that?
9:35 Speaker 01 Pros and cons list. So you analyse the pros and cons in step number four?
9:39 Speaker 00 Yes, because you can tell we're still on holiday. And, and I would be writing down, you know, what are some of the pros and cons of each of my different options? And I think one of the best things you could do, I don't want to come across as too self-promotional here, but I really would recommend using Opus Plus to run the cash flows on these investment properties. So especially if you are looking at investment properties, so that you could think about all of these little numbers. Because what you, again, you don't want is, oh, but what about, oh, but what about those higher rates? If I go and buy this other investment property I'm looking at? Oh, but what about the different insurance? But what about the different gross yields or the different tax that you might pay? Just use this tool like this to figure out, to consider all of that. So you can just make that really, really simple decision.
10:23 Speaker 00 So what you might do is you might jump a topus plus and say, okay, I'm going to create a scenario where I keep my current property and I renovate it. I spend 50 grand, it increases the value of that property. And on top of that, I'm going to be able to charge a higher rent and I'm not going to have to pay the real estate agent. So what does that scenario look like? Well, you can run that, that's going to give you a really good sense of what the numbers would look like. Then you might go ahead and say, okay, well, what if I sell that property and I buy a dual key apartment in, in Queenstown? What does that look like? Oh, okay. Well, I'm not going to get as much capital growth, but my cash flow is going to be better. Okay, well, what if you sell that property and you buy an existing property and it's
11:05 Speaker 00 a mild hometown of South Taranaki in Harbour on Disreilly Street? What does that look like? Well, you could weigh up all of the numbers. And then we get to step number five, which is the really fun part, make a decision. And if you find yourself getting to this stage and you're thinking, oh, what about X? Or what about Y? Then you haven't fully gone through the entire process in its entirety. So you need to go back to what you wrote down in step number one. What are you trying to do? Now, in this case, let's say renovating and raising the rent looks to be the best decision. Well, then that leads you on to step number six, which is execute the decision. Okay. And now in this case, if you are renovating the property, you need to give your tenants notice, you get them to move out, complete the renovations, and then you need to re-rent that property.
11:50 Speaker 00 And at this point, you've got to really stop second guessing yourself. Once you've made your decision, you go forward through it. And there are so many times where you might think, oh, hang on, like, am I really doing the right thing? Well, look, you've gone through the process, you've done your research, you've run your numbers, now it's about committing to it. Because if you get halfway through something and think, gosh, is this really the right decision? We've probably already spent a whole heap of money. And so sometimes it's probably worth just completing that. There is another bias, which we call the sunk cost fallacy, where sometimes people start investing or spending money on something and then they think, oh, well, I have to complete that now. Actually, sometimes it is better to cut your losses and run. You've got to take all of these different psychological biases and weigh them up against each other.
12:34 Speaker 00 But ultimately, I do think if you have made that decision and it's been a robust process, just going on ahead often is the best decision. But then you also get to review it over time. So, once you have renovated that property, you can look back, see what happened, what happened to the value, get evaluation done, confirm the new rent that you've got, and just make sure that, hey, that decision has worked out as I expected. But I think the real important part is just, if you Google seven steps to make a good decision, you'll get these seven steps from Dartmouth College and I'd recommend that you use them. Just think really logically about your property portfolio, go through all seven steps. Don't skip step number one, don't skip step number two, and then use a couple of tools to help you in those later stages as well.
13:16 Speaker 00 Right, let's wrap it up there, but please don't forget to rate, review and subscribe to the podcast. It really does help us get the message out to more people.
13:29 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Sebut Dyke.
13:32 Speaker 01 And I'm Andrew Nicoll.
13:33 Speaker 00 We're going to be back again tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics and insights to help you get the most out of the New Zealand property market. Until next time.
Previous The future of the OCR: 2025 interest rate predictions ⎥ Ep. 1943 Next The Starting Blocks (property investment stage) – 2025 update ⎥ Ep. 1945 Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated