Skip to content

Pool Products That Died — And Why

The Pool Guy Podcast Show

18m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

This episode explores the pool products, smart water monitors, and small companies that disappeared from the market through failures, botched acquisitions, or shifting industry dynamics. The host examines cases like Hayward's acquisition of the Finn smart monitor, which faltered due to a poor marketing strategy telling users it would replace service pros, confusing ORP warnings, and an abrupt app shutdown. Other discontinued items discussed include the Sutro monitor, Skim Doctor 2.0, and the SolarBreeze, contrasted against more successful brand acquisitions like Pentair taking over Pleco and Fluidra purchasing Taylor test kits.

  • Positioning a new monitoring device as a replacement for pool service professionals can immediately backfire on sales. 2:10
  • Seasonality in the pool industry requires careful pricing strategies since half of the regional pools shut down annually. 7:00
  • Smaller pool product companies often struggle to survive or maintain resources without being bought out by larger corporations. 9:53
  • Some acquisitions successfully preserve the target company's original brand identity, website, and product line rather than discontinuing them. 15:09

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Podcast Sponsorships and Intro

    Hosts introduce the episode and announce sponsors Hasa and Skimmer.

  2. 1:05
    Overview of Product Disappearances

    The host outlines the focus on companies that vanished or were absorbed.

  3. 1:49
    Finn Acquisition Failure

    Discussion of Hayward’s purchase of Finn, marketing missteps, and subscription shutdown.

  4. 4:55
    Sutro Smart Monitor Challenges

    Analysis of Sutro’s pricing, cartridge logistics, and seasonal market issues leading to its demise.

  5. 7:35
    Finn’s Legacy and Crystal Water Monitor

    Exploration of Finn’s successor, the Crystal Water Monitor, and the broader smart‑monitor market.

  6. 9:08
    Skim Doctor 2.0 Vanishing Act

    The host recounts the disappearance of the Skim Doctor 2.0 and potential reasons behind it.

  7. 10:11
    SolarBreeze Evolution and Acquisition

    Story of SolarBreeze’s transition to aerial cleaners, competition, and eventual sale of its brands.

  8. 13:06
    CMP Salt Cell Discontinuation

    Details on Floridra’s purchase of CMP salt cells and their subsequent discontinuation.

  9. 15:09
    Successful Acquisitions: Pleco and Taylor

    Comparison of effective integrations by Pentair and Floridra, preserving brand and product lines.

  10. 18:26
    Closing Remarks and Call to Action

    Hosts wrap up, promote coaching program, and thank listeners.

Highlights

  • 2:10

    Botched Acquisition Strategystrategy

    Hayward bought the Finn monitor for a large sum and immediately advertised that it would replace pool service professionals, which alienated industry workers and harmed sales.

  • 2:51

    Smart Monitor Limitationsinsight

    The Finn floating monitor struggled because it only measured ORP, pH, and temperature, requiring users to manually scan test strips for other chemical readings.

  • 3:20

    Confusing Water Safety Warningsstory

    The Finn app frequently issued unsafe water warnings due to ORP thresholds, which confused consumers and caused homeowners to avoid using their swimming pools.

  • 7:00

    Seasonal Business Pressuresinsight

    Smart monitor companies failed to account for seasonal markets in the Northwest and Northeast where pools close for half the year, leading customers to stop buying subscription cartridges.

  • 9:53

    Small Company Resource Constraintsinsight

    Products like the Skim Doctor 2.0 worked effectively but ultimately disappeared because small businesses lacked the resources or supply chain stability to survive long-term.

  • 14:46

    Discontinued Salt Cell Systemsdata

    Fluidra purchased Custom Molded Products and their popular clear-case salt cell system, only to discontinue the complete unit and power supply within a year.

  • 15:09

    Successful Brand Preservationstrategy

    Pentair acquired Pleco but kept it running as a separate entity with its brand name intact, serving as a positive model for industry acquisitions.

Quotes

  • “The good thing about Pentair taking Pleco is it's being run like a separate company still, and which is good.”
    Unnamed speaker · 15:36
  • “Another successful acquisition was Floridra purchasing Taylor. They actually left the website pretty much intact.”
    Unnamed speaker · 16:30
  • Hasa 0:00–0:18
  • Skimmer 0:27–0:49
  • Pool Guy Coaching Program 1:26–1:42
  • UPA 8:46–9:04
  • Hasa 18:30–18:49

About this episode

One day a pool product feels like the future. The next day the app is gone, support is gone, and what you paid for becomes a paperweight floating in the deep end. We dig into the real-world side of pool industry acquisitions and “disappearing” brands, including what happens when big companies buy promising pool technology and the execution doesn’t match the hype. We walk through Hayward’s Fin smart pool monitor and why the marketing and user experience created problems for homeowners and poo...

Transcript

0:00
18:52

3,328 words · 2 speakers

Topics

  • Floridra
  • Finn
  • Pleco
  • SkimBot
  • Pentair
  • SolarBreeze
  • Taylor
  • Hayward
  • CMP salt cell
  • Crystal Water Monitor

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated