Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Overdoing It on Your Swimming Pool Design – When More Isn’t Better About this episode Send us a textI get it—when designing your dream pool, it’s easy to go overboard with every feature imaginable. But is that massive waterfall, tanning ledge, infinity edge, and oversized spa really worth it? In this episode, I dive into the common pitfalls of over-designing a pool, the hidden costs that come with it, and how to strike the perfect balance between luxury and practicality. Whether you're planning a new build or a remodel, this is the episode you don’t want to miss! Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros are using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:04 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to talk more about pool design and some things as a service pro that builders should pay attention to, which some don't. A lot of this has to do with what the homeowner wants, of course, so I can't blame builders entirely. But there are a lot of things that we as service pros would like to see on a pool or certain things about the pool that we would like to see to make it easier to service and maintain. That is usually an oversight, and once a pool is built, of course, we can't do anything to fix that. Join my coaching program and take your pool service to the next level. Connect with other pool pros in your area, gain valuable knowledge, and transform your business with personalized one-on-one advice from me.
1:48 Speaker 00 With over 36 years of experience, I'm here to help you succeed like never before. Learn more at poolguycoaching.com. And I have done a couple podcasts recently, one on infinity edge pools and one on equipment placement and things of that nature. But I'm going to focus specifically on things about a certain pool build that... We don't really like too much. One of the things that I don't like, and a lot of pool guys don't like this as well. Is if there's an area of the pool that's not accessible for cleaning. Now, this could be because you have rock formations on one side of the pool. Sometimes you'll have like a cliff kind of effect. Other times you'll have just no way to access the far end of the pool.
2:33 Speaker 00 This, of course, is very common with infinity edge pools again. For one side, there's just no access because it's going off the side of the cliff, basically. But we find this to be a little bit annoying when you can't maintain the pool. You have to kind of vacuum from one side or kind of use extensions to brush the pool. Sometimes the rock formation pools are extremely hazardous. You can't even get onto the other side. Without maybe falling into the pool, which I've done before. Once I was on a rock formation pool. Trying to get to an inaccessible area and I slipped and fell into the pool. It's really annoying when that happens. But really, sometimes a customer wants the pool that way, and I understand that.
3:16 Speaker 00 But I think that every aspect of the pool should be accessible. You know, there are some pools that I used to do where there was this little kind of cave area where you would sit down. Then it was really hard to reach it. What I mean by the cave area, there was like an overhanging. And sometimes there's a spa up there. Sometimes it's just a water feature. But then there's a bench there that you're supposed to clean and maintain, which is nearly impossible to reach and get to. Now, there are some pool pros that have gotten into like little rafts and, you know, the clean areas of the pool. I've never gone that far. However, I did do a pool that had an island. It's kind of weird. And the customer did have a raft in there for me to get to the island to clean the area.
4:00 Speaker 00 It wasn't a big island. I think it was maybe like, I should have taken a picture of it. This is back way before, you know, we had cell phones with cameras. But this particular island, I would say was like 10 feet by 15 feet. And the areas that needed to be brushed were the kind of soap areas on that island where the water comes up to it. Really bizarre, but really cool, I guess. If you are a kid and you want to get to the island in the pool, but really bad if you're a pool pro trying to clean that pool. Another thing also, and this doesn't really go with the pool size or anything, but it just popped in my head. Talking, thinking about the island there, but there are some backyards that are really hard to access the pool through. And you know, either it's because there's a bunch of stuff on one side.
4:46 Speaker 00 Sometimes there's RV parking or boat parking and they'll park an RV or boat and it's nearly impossible to get through there. A lot of times, maybe you have a one car driveway and you can't get past the cars there to even open the gate. Get your equipment in there, but you know, make it accessible for the pool pro to get back there. There was one account and this is true. I had to go through the house to get to the pool because there was just no way to open the gate. There was so much junk stacked there. So it rang the doorbell. Homeowner would let me walk through the house and I would go to the backyard through the sliding door. I'm not kidding. It was just that inaccessible. So that's a problem as well.
5:26 Speaker 00 I wouldn't say, I'm not sure why that popped in my head, talking about the island, but the island definitely was not accessible. But that's another kind of problem and it's not really a build problem. I just wanted to get that out there. So that you're aware that we do need to get back there. Sometimes with a service cart, they service the pool. So allow us to have the access to get into the backyard. I did mention infinity edge pools without a skimmer. That's really annoying because skimmers are kind of important, but I know the aesthetic of it. And another thing that I find to be somewhat annoying are the pools with two skimmers. But the builder fails to put in any kind of regulator valve. I know this is a problem because a lot of pool pros deal with this, but it was not that difficult.
6:10 Speaker 00 It wouldn't be that difficult to put a jandy valve somewhere to regulate one skimmer or both skimmers separately. So that you can regulate the suction, you know, if you are like me and you carry a tennis ball because you need to turn off. One skimmer so you can vacuum another. This is, this is kind of a case in point. Be easy if they just had some way to regulate the skimmer and that's not the case in a lot of builds. So you have to kind of circumvent that. There's also a tool by the Ultimate Pool Tools, the Hyper Valve. And this is a threaded fitting, one and a half inch threaded fitting with a kind of a plastic gate on top. So you can kind of close and open it to regulate the second skimmer.
6:53 Speaker 00 But really, all of this would be unnecessary, the tennis ball to put in there to block out the skimmer while you're using the other one to vacuum the pool. Or the the Hyper Valve to regulate the second skimmer. So maybe you can have an automatic cleaner on one skimmer or vacuum the other one. If the builders just put in a valve that would control one skimmer or actually you can turn off one skimmer with the valve and regulate the other with another valve. Very few pools of two skimmers that I know of, that I've taken care of in the past, had any kind of valve that would be able to be used to shut off one skimmer or regulate the suction at that skimmer. So another problem and something that is easily rectified at the build and is something that should be done in a lot of cases.
7:38 Speaker 00 Another thing is putting the equipment below sea level. Now, I know in some cases it's impossible to avoid this because of the backyard. But in other cases, it's really not impossible to avoid it. In fact, some of the below sea level equipment is just slightly below the pool water level and this may be an oversight and may just be the fact that no one thought about it. But these slightly below sea level pools, maybe they're half a foot or a foot below the water line, are problematic for a lot of reasons. One of them is any kind of major repairs that need to be done. You have to kind of know these tricks of the trade because there's no way to really shut the water off. There are tricks you can utilize.
8:22 Speaker 00 There's a device called the flood plug. If you look for this online and someone sells it somewhere. But the flood plug is a tool, kind of like the old shoelace tied to the rag trick where you tie a shoelace to a rag, stick it in the plumbing to at least stop the water while you're doing. Doing some replumbing and then once you, when you have the right angle or you're above sea level, pull that rag through with the shoelace and hopefully it won't snap off and the rag gets stuck in there. You gotta cut the plumbing and redo it, but really the below sea level are problematic. And I think the thing that really is the most irritating thing about it is when the builder's trying to do the right thing by putting ball valves in so you can turn off the flow to the equipment.
9:06 Speaker 00 Nothing wrong with that. I really like having the ball valves there because it's easy to turn off the flow to the return side and the suction side. But these ball valves invariably break, the handles break, the red handles. They do make a few with replaceable handles, but I don't think most builders put those in. And once those red handles break on those ball valves, you're using your channel locks to kind of turn it and it becomes a real annoyance when it would be so easy, extremely easy for the builder to spend a little extra money to put in Jandy valves so that you can just use a Jandy valve to turn off the flow. These are the best below sea level pools, the ones with the Jandy valves. I love these. You can turn the Jandy valves to your heart content, never have to worry about them breaking
9:52 Speaker 00 and they're really easy to turn and shut off the water. Sometimes the ball valves do get really tight as well. So if you are gonna put in equipment below sea level for whatever reason, if maybe you want to hide the equipment on the slope, make sure you have Jandy valves installed instead of ball valves because the ball valves are gonna wear out, are gonna be hard to operate and the handles invariably break over time. If you go several years, you're gonna find many pools below sea level with ball valves with all the handles broken and cracked off. In fact, I like Jandy valves for everything. I've had a few pools that had backwash valves with the ball valve and a few smart pool builders put in Jandy valves there, which is nice to have.
10:35 Speaker 00 And why would you have a valve at a backwash? Well, there are a few reasons why a valve on a backwash is kind of important. There's actually a pool guide trick where you can actually put a ball valve on a backwash line if you need. If it's just a pipe going nowhere, you can actually just put one on there without even gluing it on there with with any PVC cement. I guess gluing is the wrong way of putting it, but using PVC cement PVC cement to put the ball valve on. Cause there's not a lot of pressure coming out of there, so it's not going to kind of blow off on you. But why would you have a ball valve or a jandy valve at the end of a backwash line? Well, there's a few reasons. One, of course, is that it does prevent you from kind of leaving it open.
11:20 Speaker 00 And this is one thing that has happened to me when there is no exposed line. For instance, let's say it's going into the ground and going into a P trap somewhere on the side of the house. Or just going into the sewer line, which by the way, is the worst thing you can do with a backwash line. And I'll explain why in a second. But basically the valve will allow you to turn, open it so you know that you actually opened it. And you really can't leave it running because you're going to have to close it or you're going to see that it's open. And that's kind of like another thing that you are going to remember that you have it on backwash mode. Don't think that you're ever going to leave it on backwash mode and leave that account because it will happen eventually.
12:00 Speaker 00 I probably done have done that two or three times roughly, maybe three times, I would say. Where I left the account and I left the pool in backwash mode. Typically this happens on a 4000 series Penter filter. But I have done it with a push pull piston. Don't ask me what I was thinking or doing that day, but I've had that happen. Cause there was no obvious way of seeing the water at that point. But back to why a ball valve or jandy valve is good to have on the end of a backwash line. Is because sometimes the piston will leak or sometimes the multi port will have a problem with the spider gasket. And then water will trickle out even when the backwash is closed. So having that ball valve on there actually stops that flow.
12:44 Speaker 00 It gives you time to get back there and repair it in the future. So it's not an emergency at that point because the ball valve will turn off the backwash line. So even if the push pull piston is leaking a little bit or the multi port is leaking, not an emergency. But the ones that are kind of. Hidden where you're backwashing it and you don't have no idea where it's going. Some of these are attached to a sewer line. It's a really bad idea because diatomaceous earth, if you've ever kind of seen it in, you know, its natural state after drying out a little bit, it really gets clumpy and it really can clog up anything. And so a backwash line going directly into the sewer, I can guarantee you that in five years or 10 years,
13:28 Speaker 00 it's going to be so backed up with diatomaceous earth residue, it's not going to function. How do I know this? I have several of these on my route over the years where the backwash line is not working. So I just tell the customer, can I just cut the pipe and attach a PVC pipe and have it go out to the planter? And usually they're like, yeah, I guess that's fine. I don't know why I had this thing plumbed in the first place if you're going to do that. But needless to say, there's really nothing you can do. A plumber might be able to snake it, but in most cases it's like solid cement. Cause I was there with a plumber one time who was trying to do this. And he's like, man, what is in this line? And I told him it's diatomaceous earth. He's like, oh, no wonder it's like cement in there. So basically that's a bad idea. If you have a D filter,
14:12 Speaker 00 don't put in a backwash line that's plumbed directly to the sewer. It's better if it's just going to the planter or somewhere where you can make sure that you have a clean line. I did mention in the other podcast about equipment like right up against the wall of the house and pumps you can't move or change the motor without moving the whole pump because there's no access. Another thing that I find somewhat annoying is when a builder puts in an undersized, undersized filter. Now, a lot of times this is not happening nowadays. Most builders will put in a big filter, but this happened a lot in the eighties and nineties where you get to a service account, it's like a 25,000 gallon pool and it has a 36 square foot D filter. I'm not kidding.
14:57 Speaker 00 I'm sure you have these on your route where it's like this filter is so dingy, even a 48 square foot, I think is problematic for a 25 or 30,000 gallon pool. And then of course in Florida, the whole state. Has the single bullet cartridge filters everywhere, which I'm not sure who the salesman was back then, but they did a pretty good job of selling everyone in Florida on these really tiny filters. To me, I would say that you would want a bigger filter right away because bigger is better. There's just no arguing with that. If it's a sand filter, cartridge filter, D filter, the bigger the filter, the better the water quality, the less time in between cleanings, and the easier it is to maintain the pool.
15:40 Speaker 00 But this was a problem back in the eighties and nineties where they were just putting in a lot of smaller filters, D filters in particular, and they were just putting in a thirty-six square foot or forty square foot filter. And if you cut that thing out and put in a four hundred and fifty square foot cartridge filter, or five hundred or six hundred square foot cartridge filter, you're going to see a tremendous amount of flow for that pool, and it's something that has been a real handicap with that pool with a smaller filter.
16:15 Speaker 00 And the Pool Guy Podcast show has teamed up with UPA to bring you affordable, reliable liability insurance, starting at just sixty-four dollars a month, get up to two million dollars in coverage, and the members of my coaching group get an even lower rate, protect your business and your peace of mind. Sign up with UPA today by clicking the link in the podcast description.
16:37 Speaker 00 So even in Florida, I recommend the quad cartridge filters. It's gonna really make your life easier if you have a hundred and fifty square foot, single bullet cartridge filter, and you put in a four hundred and fifty square foot quad cartridge filter in there, you're not cleaning that filter every month or replacing it every ten months. You're actually going every six months and replacing those cartridges every three years. So it's definitely a win, in my opinion, to get a bigger filter, even somewhere like Florida, where it's kind of unheard of with all the small, single bullet cartridge filters. It's gonna make the maintenance of the pool very simple and easy with that larger filter. This, again, is not a modern problem, but it is something
17:20 Speaker 00 That you have to deal with, that is pools that are built with no side port for a suction cleaner. Now, in my area, Arizona, I'm in Southern California, but areas like Arizona, Nevada, parts of Texas, New Mexico, we like suction cleaners because of the fine dirt that gets in the pool and the ease of use. And a side port is something that most builders put in, starting in the late 90s all the way to present. I, I find it pretty rare to find a new pool without a side port installed. But there are a lot of older pools, again, built in the 80s and 90s that have no side port, which leaves you with just a skimmer for the automatic cleaner attachment. It's not the end of the world. You can attach the cleaner to the skimmer,
18:03 Speaker 00 but you're actually sacrificing some of the surface debris skimming. That's one reason why the bouncing type cleaners were so popular in the 90s and early 2000s. You may wonder, why was the Creepy Crawly or Zodiac G2 or G3 so popular? When you took over a pool, it had one of these invariably, like Creepy Crawly or something of that nature. Well, the bouncing effect of those cleaners actually knocked debris down to the bottom of the pool. So that would kind of counterbalance the fact that you have it connected to the skimmer and the skimmer is not actually taking a lot of the surface debris in, because you're, you're kind of sharing the suction with the automatic cleaner. So the bouncing cleaners actually are probably better for the,
18:47 Speaker 00 for the pools where you're connecting at the skimmer, because the bouncing action, again, will knock leaf debris to the bottom, so that it can vacuum it out. So that's kind of why they're really popular in the 90s and the 2000s, because of that reason. And then, of course, as builders started putting side ports in, the gear type cleaners became more popular, like the Hayward Navigator, the pool cleaner by Hayward, the Aquanaut, and the MX cleaners by Zodiac became popular, because you didn't need that bouncing motion, because you had a side port and the skimmer was still working at fairly good suction. Another problem with connecting the cleaner at the skimmer is that the regulator valves that come with the cleaners sometimes aren't sufficient.
19:30 Speaker 00 To regulate the flow from the skimmer and the cleaner. So there's some pool tricks, pool guide tricks you can do where you can double stack a regulator valve. So you get two regulator valves, you get a female, the female connector, and you can actually double stack these to get better flow regulation with two regulator valves in the skimmer. Also, my hole in one basket is a great aftermarket purchase. There's a hole in the bottom. It's ingenious. Who would think of such a useful product? But you can actually put your cleaner hose through this basket. That way, the debris actually gets trapped in the basket because without the hole in basket, the skimmer basket can't be put back into the skimmer with a
20:12 Speaker 00 with a automatic cleaner hose and the regulator valve there. Now, yes, Penter does make a vac mate, which is kind of like a basket with a wear gate and you can connect a cleaner hose there. But they're not that great. They don't work that well. They're really expensive. But the hole in basket is pretty affordable at like $20 or so. And you can actually have that attached to the skimmer. So there are ways you can actually do a cleaner at the skimmer. I just wish builders were more proactive and had a side port and a skimmer line back then. There's a few weird pools back in the 90s where they had like a side port attached to the skimmer itself. And it's not that effective.
20:54 Speaker 00 So there's a hole in the wall at the skimmer. You may have one of these on your route where there's a hole in the wall. And then you put the cleaner hose in there and it's still attached to the skimmer and there's a valve by the equipment that kind of regulates it. That's kind of the first side ports that they came out with and they're still around out there in some areas. But the side port is ingenious. The side port basically is a dedicated suction line. I probably should have explained that. Where you can connect a suction cleaner and regulate it at the equipment and still have the skimmer with the basket in there. And there's no need to attach your suction side cleaner at the skimmer with a side port. Another thing that I guess I would say is a pet peeve of mine is over fancy coping.
21:37 Speaker 00 Now, this may sound weird to you, but some of the pool coping is just way overboard. Flagstone, I've seen people use flagstone, but it's not just like flagstone with maybe an edge. It's like flagstone with the sharp jagged edges pointing out into the pool. Which to me is weird because if you have kids and they're trying to climb out, they have to kind of use the steps and no one can just climb out of the pool. And most kids like climbing out of the pool all over the place. But if you have that kind of coping, it's definitely problematic. Also, certain decks are problematic like sandstone. I'm not sure why you would ever use this for a pool build. They start to chip and flake, especially if there's a saltwater generator. By the way, it's even worse because the salt really degrades it even more.
22:22 Speaker 00 I would say if you have sandstone, don't put a saltwater generator in. But the sandstone surface, even without it, I've never had good success with it. It's always chipping and cracking. Getting into the pool, you have all this kind of tan residue. You have big chips in the pool and it's a big mess. So, don't use sandstone, it's a big problem. And then, don't paint your deck. It becomes very slippery when it's raining with the paint on there. I've had customers paint their deck and have fallen themselves. I just find that not the best thing as well. If your deck looks bad, of course, hire a professional to do it so they can seal it properly. Just don't get any kind of paint and try to paint it to cover it up. It's gonna be slippery and dangerous.
23:06 Speaker 00 And I don't think it's wise as well to paint a pool. The pool plaster is getting old now. I've seen this happen. This happened a lot back in 2008 and 9 when people were selling homes that were kind of repoed. And simply painting the pool itself kind of helped with the sale, but then the paint would kind of come off pretty quickly. Within like a year, you brush the pool and a white cloud comes out because all the paint's coming off. You can paint a pool, yes, but it has to be done properly. You have to get a special primer first and then you have to paint it specifically with. They pool paint and you have to know kind of how to paint it as well. Not something that most people do, but I have seen painted pools and it's a big mess.
23:49 Speaker 00 But don't paint the deck, don't paint the pools, just re-plaster the pool at that point. If you're selling the house, I understand the logic behind it. If you're buying a house on a painted pool, just realize that in two or three years, that paint's probably going to come off and just be a real mess in the pool. But those are some things and there's a lot more I can cover. But those are the things that I've run into out there and no offense to the builders in the eighties and nineties and two thousands. You probably didn't have the resources we have now. And you know, a lot of times the technology has gotten so advanced and builders have so much at their disposal. That is something that we can look back and see some of these old builds with maybe, you know, really bad plans.
24:34 Speaker 00 And improve on that. A lot of pools, new pools are just great. The builders do a great job, but there are a lot of, plenty of pools out there still right now. Where the builder didn't quite think things through and the homeowner maybe didn't think, things through enough, like with a standstone deck to realize that it's a problem and it's not really something that I would advise doing. And it's something that you're going to run into out there as a pool service provider. These older pools with maybe less build quality than a pool builder would put into it today. Looking for other podcasts that I have, you can find those on my website, swimmingforlearning.com. Click on the podcast icon, that'll take you to a dropdown menu with over sixteen hundred podcasts.
25:19 Speaker 00 And if you're interested in the coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a rest of your week and God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software. Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Previous Saltwater Generator Troubleshooting by Brand Next Selling Saltwater Systems Effectively – How to Close the Deal Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated