Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Flakes, Fails & Frustration: Real Salt System Issues About this episode Send us a textSaltwater pools may sound like the low-maintenance dream, but in this episode, I talk about the real-world problems I see every week with saltwater chlorine generators (SWGs). From customers who refuse to replace failing cells to mysterious white flake blowback, I unpack the chemistry, the challenges, and how I manage expectations in the field. If you work with salt pools or own one, this is a must-listen. Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA https://bit.ly/HASAThe Bottom Feeder. Save $100 with Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERTry Skimmer FREE for 30 days:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Get UPA Liability Insurance $64 a month! https://forms.gle/F9YoTWNQ8WnvT4QBAPool Guy Coaching: https://bit.ly/40wFE6y Thanks for listening, and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/ UPA General Liability Insurance Application: https://forms.gle/F9YoTWNQ8WnvT4QBA Pool Guy Coaching Group Join an exclusive network of Pool Service Technicians to access the industry’s leading commercial general liability insurance program. Protect your business. Premium is $64 per month per member (additional $40 for employees and ICs) $59 per month for Pool Guy coaching Members - join here! https://www.patreon.com/poolguycoaching Limits are $1,000,000 in occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate - Per member limits [ $1,000,000 per occurrence and $4,000,000 aggregate available for $75 per month ] $50,000 in HazMat Coverage - clean up on-site or over-the-road Acid Wash Coverage - Full Limits
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the Bottom Feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:05 Speaker 00 And welcome to the Pool Guide Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to take a little different slant on saltwater generators. I'm going to focus on a lot of the negative aspects that we run into out there as a pool service professional. And I'm going to cover a lot of the things that we find to be a negative attribute of a saltwater generator. Are you a pool service pro looking to take your business to the next level? Join the Pool Guide Coaching Program, get expert advice, business tips, exclusive content, and get direct support. For me, I'm a 35-year veteran in the industry. Whether you're starting out or scaling up, I've got the tools to help you succeed. Learn more at swimmingpoollearning.com. And first, I'll state that I do like saltwater generators.
1:50 Speaker 00 In fact, I have one in my pool and a lot of my service accounts have saltwater generators. I like selling them to people. I think they have some benefits. But you have to know, of course, about the negatives of saltwater generators, especially if you do pool service and you want to sell these. There are some drawbacks. The first drawback is that not every saltwater generator is created equally. And you're going to have your preferences, like for example, I'll sell the Jandy True Clear Salt cell all week long or all month long or all year long. Or this one of the ones that I actually is my go to saltwater generator. I can live with the Pentair and Hayward salt generators. I don't like them as much as the Jandy.
2:35 Speaker 00 And I think the off brands also have really good generators. CMP used to be my favorite. I don't believe they, I think they do still make some of those. But when Jandy or Felicia bought them out, they don't make as many or it's not as a robust company as it used to be. And I do like the Circupool generators. I think they're really a good saltwater generator. So the first thing, of course, is that they're not all equal. There's some off brand ones as well. If you are as old as I am and you've been doing service as long as I have, you remember in California, I don't know how far it got. But in California, there was a big push for these ecomatic salt systems. They had this clear shell, it was one of the first clear shell salt systems.
3:19 Speaker 00 And the concept was smart. They just didn't work. There were so many problems with them and a lot of accounts had these ecomatics. A lot of builders put them in and they were just pretty much terrible. So they're not all equal. So you're going to find a lot of the times you're not going to like the Hayward systems and you may have a lot of the Aqua Right systems on your route. Or you may not like the Pentair system. You have a lot of I chlor cells that are malfunctioning. Whatever the case, you're going to find that you like certain salt systems. And unfortunately, you're going to have to live with the ones that are out there. It's hard to get to customers. Sometimes you replace the whole system. And another drawback with the salt systems that I've found is that the high cost of the replacement cells are kind of frowned upon by a lot of customers.
4:02 Speaker 00 You know, if you have in a telechlor cell and you want to get the, the Pentair has a new one as well. If you want to replace it, you're looking sometimes at eight or $900 for the cell. And for a customer that's like, that's a lot of money for something that I see very little benefit from. Except that it puts chlorine in the pool for me. Is there an alternative way of putting chlorine in the pool? And then, of course, you're gonna say, well, yeah, you can just use tablets or you can use liquid chlorine in the pool and it would have the same effect. And then right away, they're gonna say, well, how much is that? You're gonna say, well, a bucket of tablets is $180 for the whole season. And then, you know, if you charge extra for liquid chlorine, you could tell them that it's gonna be $20 more a month.
4:45 Speaker 00 And they may just say, well, I want to convert to chlorine. I don't want to use the salt system anymore. So there in lies one of the biggest drawbacks to the saltwater generator, in my opinion, is that when the salt cell wears out, the customer does not want to replace it. And then you just have a chlorine pool with very high TDS because you have all the salt in the water and you have a TDS of like 3,500 parts per million. When recommended, you're recommended to drain a TDS of like 1,500. So a big drawback, a big problem is customers don't want to replace the salt cell. So you just have basically a DOA system. It's not going to be working and you just have a pool that you're going to convert back to chlorine.
5:26 Speaker 00 Now, a lot of times you can sell a new salt cell, but what I'm finding, and this is something I used to recommend, and I still recommend it in some cases, is you always want to get a larger salt cell because then you'll have more production for the pool. You know, for instance, if you have a 20,000 gallon pool, you necessarily don't want to get a Pentair IC20 or a TeleChlor 20 that's rated for 20,000 gallons because it has to be operating at peak conditions and longer to produce the chlorine. So I always recommend getting like an IC40. Or if you have a 20,000 or 15,000 gallon pool, I would recommend getting a Hayward
6:06 Speaker 00 cell that's rated, the T15 that's rated for 40,000 gallons versus a T5, which is rated for, I think, 20 or 15,000 gallons. But they're not making these salt cells as robust as they used to. It's not lasting as long as you need them to last for this to actually work properly. So it may not be worth paying extra for a larger salt cell when in fact the salt cell is not going to last anyway and you're going to be wasting. Little bit extra money on it. If that makes sense, they don't make the components as well as they used to. And even though I love the True Clear Salt System, the cells don't last usually more than three years,
6:46 Speaker 00 which is a pretty short lifespan for a salt cell. Fortunately, the True Clear cell doesn't have much to it. And so it's a really affordable replacement cell. But there is an example of a product that I really like, and I would sell the True Clear cell salt system. That's what I have in my pool, by the way, all day long. But that's what I was trying to say earlier, by the way, in the podcast, but I couldn't get that phrase out.
7:10 Speaker 00 The lifespan is shorter than a lot of the other salt cells that I have had on my route before. But it is a good system and the salt cell is affordable. So it's kind of a trade off. You're getting a good system, but the salt cell doesn't last quite as long as I would like it to last. And it's one of those things where the salt cell does have a lifespan. And if you are selling these systems to your customer, you must tell them that yes, the system is $1,800 to install. But after three to five years, the salt cell is going to wear out. And that's anywhere from whatever system you're putting in $500 to $1,200 for a new salt cell. Let them know that upfront and they can make an educated decision if they want to have a saltwater generator installed on their property.
7:51 Speaker 00 Now, when they first came out, a lot of people talked about like the corrosion of the saltwater generator on the equipment. Now that is still possible. If the salt level is above the recommended level of the manufacturer, I think most recommend like no more than 3,600 parts per million. If it does get into like the 4,000 or 5,000 parts per million range, you can actually have some corrosion of your pool equipment, some damage to it. I'm thinking about the thermistor and the heaters. Those tend to rust really fast. And you may have some filter parts that start to rust. You know, it's one of those things where salt is corrosive at certain levels. But if you're at the recommended dosage or the recommended level of salt in the pool, I wouldn't really worry about corrosion too much.
8:33 Speaker 00 Now, there are certain pool decks that are susceptible to salt. And you're going to find that there's some of these sandstone type deckings that don't do well with saltwater pools. You also may find that some of the coping gets some stains from the saltwater splash out. It does have salt in it. And so it can leave kind of a discoloration on the cement. And this is something to be aware of, but I would say that as far as corrosion goes, not, nothing to really worry about as long as you maintain the right salt level and don't go over the manufacturer recommended level. So that's really not something that I think is a negative or something that should be on the table. Unless you have like some kind of sandstone coping or decking and that could be a problem for a saltwater generator.
9:18 Speaker 00 The thing that really vexes pool pros out there is the rising pH for the salt pool. The worst case scenario you can have, and if you have this pool on your route, I feel sorry for you. It's an infinity edge pool with a lot of water features, brand new plaster, saltwater generator. You're going to have pH of like nine and it's going to be impossible to control that, at least for the first year or two. You're not going to be able to get below eight, I don't think ever. But that's like an extreme case and it's something that you may have to deal with. But in most cases, the rising pH is something that you can kind of manage. And it is irritating that every time you go back to this pool, the pH is like 8.2 or 8.4.
10:01 Speaker 00 Because the saltwater generator does raise the pH as it's generating. I'm not going to go into too much science behind it. There's also some turbidity that causes the pH to rise in there. There are certain ways to combat it. Now, one way you can combat it is to run the salt system as minimal as possible. So if you can run it for half the time the pool is running, that's going to benefit you. It's not going to raise the pH quite as high. You can taper down the water features as much as you can. And then you can add borate to 50 parts per million. And this is another pH buffer and it'll help you to maintain that pH at least fairly well in that pool. I would also consider dropping the alkalinity down to about 70 parts per million. And this will also help with the rise in pH.
10:46 Speaker 00 But at the end of the day with a saltwater pool, the pH is going to continue to rise as the, as the saltwater generator is actually operating in there. And that's a problem for pool pros because muretic acid is not cheap any longer. It used to be back in the day before COVID, you'd get four. One gallon cases of, or you get a case of four by one gallon Hossa meronic acid for like $12. I'm not kidding you. It's probably three or four times that in a lot of areas. And so acid is expensive and to lower the pH in the saltwater pools, you're going to be adding a lot of meronic acid. So that is a drawback with the saltwater pools. Also, the LSI is a little bit of a drawback because they can be scale forming
11:32 Speaker 00 with all these parameters you have to deal with. So that's another factor. That you may have more scale in the pool with the saltwater generator, not necessarily all the time, but it does contribute to the scaling. And you'll know in your area if you do have a lot of calcium in your area in the water by the salt cell itself. So another drawback that you may not be aware of is that in these areas where there's really hard water, like my area, for example, the cell plates get a lot of calcium buildup and this causes the salt cell to stop working basically because it's not conducting electricity over the plates because there's calcium buildup on it. And thereby the system is not operating effectively.
12:13 Speaker 00 You have to take the cell out, clean it with acid, an acid and water mixture, and then put it back in. And if you're like in my area, you're doing this probably every two months or so with most of the salt systems on your pool route because the water here is extremely hard and there's a lot of calcium buildup on the salt cell itself and that causes the system to stop working. A quick note, if you have any Hayward Ackerite salt cells on your route, every three months, the check cell light that indicates that the cell is dirty is going to automatically come on. It's super irritating. It's going to flash like a yellow light and then it's not going to produce the chlorine the way it's supposed to. You have to hold down that little black diagnostic button, which is miniscule. I don't know why they put this as a small button either.
12:58 Speaker 00 And you have to talk to the engineer about that. Hold that down for like five seconds and then that check cell light will turn off. It does that every three months automatically. And so the cell may not even be dirty, but it's indicating it's just like a kind of like a reminder to clean the salt cell. In some areas, you don't need to clean them like every six months. Sometimes like in my area, you have to do it sooner than three months. So it's really a useless feature in my opinion. But that's why that happens a lot with zaccharite cell. Took me a long time to figure that out, by the way. This is before like Google and YouTube and chat. And so I had to kind of like, hey, this is all that's coming on like every three months on a dot. Oh, I get it. It's like automatic. So I figured that out. Basically, the salt systems are all different too. And so there's like a little learning curve over one system over the other.
13:43 Speaker 00 But you can pick it up pretty easily. It's not rocket science. All you basically have to do is learn how to set the salt level in the pool, not salt level, the chlorine level by the output percentage wise. And then of course, some of these systems have salinity monitors to measure the salt level, some don't. And thereby is a big difference. So you have to have a digital salinity meter as well or salt meter. So you can measure the salt content of the water. Not a big deal. Everything I've I've mentioned here is what I would call a minor annoyance. There's bigger annoyances and the biggest one besides the rising pH are is the white blowback that you get in some of these systems. Now, there's two types of blowback out there.
14:27 Speaker 00 There's a lot of debate in the industry, what it is. And I think they rent the folks to say it's calcium and it's going to be calcium blowing back into there. Cause the LSI is out of bounds. That's true in some respects. And there's other aspects like Bob Lowry always thought you should have a cooling off period. So if you have a VS pump and you have a saltwater generator, run your high speed first, then run a low speed to where the salt system turns off and the pool is still running. Cause there's a lot of heat being produced in that salt cell. And that heat may contribute to some of that calcium flaking coming off into the pool. And then there's another theory, which I kind of buy into a lot because. The white flakes in my area are kind of mushy. They're kind of like slimy and mushy. And they're not really like flakes from calcium.
15:12 Speaker 00 And maybe that's some kind of biofilm. Um, there's some kind of buildup that happens with the salt generator. Usually it's with the Penter systems. That's when I get the most blowback. And this biofilm. And I find that phosphory emovers do help a lot. I have a video where I'm adding phosph- phosphore into the skimmer in a saltwater pool and it does reduce this white flaky blowback. It has kind of a slimy feel to it. So that may be another kind of white flake that you have is the kind of like a biofilm kind of flake that's kind of attached to the calcium as well. Causing it to have that slimy effect. And sometimes it's like epidemic in the pool. I have one guy here in Corona that uses his riptide to clean the pool because there's so much of this
15:57 Speaker 00 white slimy flaky stuff in the pool. That he's like using the riptide bag to get it out of the pool. That's how bad it is. So it is a drawback and it is something that you're going to run into out there in the field. Either calcium blowback. I always thought it would be a great device to invent a filter that goes after the salt cell that can filter out this stuff. So it would be not a fine filter, I guess, but a canister maybe. And then all this stuff goes in there and then you have the rest of the water returned to the pool. It can be done, I'm sure someone were to invent it. And that way all of this blowback is trapped. So again, it could be calcium. It could be calcium mixed with some biofilm. It could be the fact that the salt cell is getting really hot. And then when you turn off the pool,
16:40 Speaker 00 all of that calcium on the plates will blow back into the pool. It's all these different scenarios you can think of, but it is a problem. And it's something to be aware of. That these white flakes are going to be blown back into the pool on some of your service accounts depending on. Again, maybe the LSI of the water, the saturation index, as well as the salt system, and as well as maybe some biofilm. As far as malfunctions, every system again has their kind of drawbacks and defects. Pentair has a problem sometimes with their flow sensors. They've had a notorious run of bad sensors in the past. Others ones, like the Pentair cells also blow the fuse and the whole system goes blank. It's another problem.
17:26 Speaker 00 Then you have cells that wear out early, like a lot of the Aquarite cells may not last the four years. It may last two years. Same with the True Clear cells, so nothing is perfect out there. And you get to learn the ins and outs of every system and the problems that each system will pose. Probably the worst salt system that was ever created, besides the Ecomatic, was the Jan D Aquapure system. That thing had like two circuit boards in the control center, tons of error codes. I could never get one to work more than a year. Of course, they fixed those problems over the years, but originally 10 or 12 years ago, those things just wouldn't operate. And sometimes there would be an audible beep from the Aquapure system, like beep,
18:09 Speaker 00 beep, every like five minutes in the backyard, driving the customer crazy. So new technology, of course, has made these salt cells a lot better. A lot of those old problems are things of the past, hopefully. And you're going to find that you'll like certain salt cells. You're not going to like certain salt cells. You're not going to like certain situations, like the customer not wanting to get a new salt cell when it wears out. And these are all definite drawbacks for saltwater systems out on your pool route. I like the salt systems. I still sell them. I know the drawbacks are there. And if you know about the drawbacks and you know about the benefits, which I think is great because it's generating chlorine at the pool side. And you really never have an algae problem or a problem with the chlorine zeroing out in a saltwater pool if it's operating correctly.
18:54 Speaker 00 And so it does save you a lot of time on that respect. And then one more thing I should mention, and I'm going to be like, hey, there's another problem with salt systems? Well, not technically a problem, it's just the physics of it. Because in cold water, Electricity conducts a lot less than in warmer water. So with the water temperature gets in the sixties, I'm afraid to tell you that the saltwater generator will stop producing chlorine. Not a big drawback because in cold water, you don't need much chlorine anyway. You can get away with like one gallon of liquid chlorine in a whole month here in cold water. But it is something you should know about that when the water temperature drops a certain level, the saltwater generator stops working and won't produce chlorine. So that's something that you need to know and then you need to find alternative chlorine
19:40 Speaker 00 during the off seasons when the water temperature is too cold for it to operate. Looking for other podcasts, you can find those by subscribing to my YouTube channel Monday through Friday. You can also get them on my website on the podcast icon. I'm closing in on 1700 podcasts. You can download, you can click on that and you can see a bunch of different podcasts to listen to on your own. And if you're interested in the coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a rest of your week. God bless. This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software.
20:24 Speaker 00 Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com backslash pool guy.
Previous Summer Savior: Terry Arko Talks Borates Next Bob Lowry’s Chlorine Smackdown Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated