Pod Insights The Pool Guy Podcast Show Are All Cartridges Created Equal? About this episode Send us a textNot all replacement filter cartridges are made the same, and using the wrong one can seriously impact your pool’s water quality. In this episode, I compare different brands, discuss key factors like filtration media, pleat count, and lifespan, and share which ones I trust to keep pools crystal clear. If you're looking to get the most out of your pool filter, this one's a must-listen! Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! HASA delivers clean, healthy water solutions. https://bit.ly/HASAhttps://www.orendatech.com/The Bottom Feeder Professional Battery Powered Vacuum System. Save $100 with discount Code: DVB100https://bit.ly/THEBOTTOMFEEDERAnd Skimmer, America’s #1 pool service software! Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days at:https://getskimmer.com/poolguy Thanks for listening and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.comWatch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPLPodcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa. Pool pros, are you using the new Hasa Pro Rewards app? Earn points on Hasa and Orenda purchases, redeem them for gift cards and product rewards. Download the free Hasa Pro Rewards app today and get rewarded by the bottom feeder. With their new cartridge filter assembly, now you can vacuum dirt in a pool down to 10 microns. Don't just vacuum the pool, finish it.
0:27 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Skimmer, the number one pool service software in North America. With Skimmer, you can streamline your schedule, grow your revenue, and keep your customers coming back with five-star service. Whether you're a one-person operation or an established team, Skimmer is your partner in success. Visit getskimmer.com/poolguy to try Skimmer for free for 30 days.
1:05 Speaker 00 Hi, welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to go over cartridge filters and the brands, the different manufacturers of them. They're not all created equal. I'm going to go over what you should be replacing your cartridge filters with once they wear out. And I'll cover some of the major brands that are on the market today. Join my coaching program and take your pool service to the next level. Connect with other pool pros in your area, gain valuable knowledge, and transform your business with personalized one-on-one advice from me. With over 36 years of experience, I'm here to help you succeed like never before. Learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Whenever I do a podcast on cartridge filters, I always get like a purist emailing me or criticizing me
1:48 Speaker 00 for not going with the manufactured cartridges again. You know, if they have a Jande filter, they're like, why don't you just get the Jande cartridges? Or you know, a Hayward, Hayward cartridge filters are the best. Well, no one really buys the manufactured cartridges after the fact. There's several reasons for it. It's because a lot of the off-brand cartridge filters are just Says good or even better than the manufactured cartridges that are in there. Also, the price point of the manufactured cartridges aren't the greatest. If you wanted to get, let's say you have a Pentair Clean and Clear Plus 420 cartridge filter, and you wanted to get the actual replacement cartridges for those filters,
2:29 Speaker 00 you could purchase those from your supplier or a local pool store. And they are the Pentair 179135. And they retail for about $320 if you wanted to go with the manufactured brand filters. Or you can buy another brand filter that probably is just as good. For example, Excel filters, and they're out of Texas. They actually sell a four-pack replacement. They're actually really good filters, and I'll go over some of the material as well. These are really high-quality cartridges, and they retail for $179.99.
3:10 Speaker 00 So you can get it for $180, which is a substantial savings over the name brand. And if you wanted to replace those with the Pleco, they're the PCC 105. And Unisel has the C-7471. And the Filber has the FC-1977. And I'll touch on these other brands here, Pleco, Unisel, and Filber. I did a video several years back where I covered these different cartridges. You may pull it up on YouTube. I put like one each in a filter, let it run for, I think, five months or six months. And then I took them out and compared them together, and you could see the difference of the material. Now, they're all not made with the same material.
3:52 Speaker 00 They're all a little bit different. Pleco probably has the thickest material over the other filter types. So there is a difference between cheap paper and high-quality spun-bound polyester. And not to say that an off-brand is necessarily bad just because it's a lower price. I mean, you have a four-pack of these. You can buy these. They're called the Optimum Pool Technology cartridges, four-pack, for $139. So I'm not saying that, you know, the price is a... Huge indicator of the quality. It's all different material and you may notice the difference, you may not notice the difference. The Pleco are pretty comparable in price to the Pentair cartridges.
4:34 Speaker 00 But of course, the quality of the material from the Pleco, you're actually paying for that. And by the way, Pentair does own Pleco now. They purchased the company. I'm not exactly sure the reasoning behind it. I would assume they just needed inventory because they had a problem with getting their cartridges out and their filters and they probably saw that Pleco was for sale. And it's not a super large company, even though they seem bigger because they advertise like crazy. They had like the pool guy and pool gal of the year contest and they advertised on the back of Aqua Magazine for like 15 years, I mean forever. So they seem like a big company, but they weren't really that big actually. They were a smaller company and Pentair bought them out and they took their cartridge technology.
5:19 Speaker 00 And I'm wondering if they're going to still sell to other companies like AquaStar. And I think Waterway also uses the Pleco cartridges. I don't see why they wouldn't, but maybe they can muscle out their competitors by not renewing their contracts for the Pleco cartridges that come standard. And some cartridge brands like the AquaStar Pipeline Filter has a Pleco filter that comes sold with it when you purchase it. So there is some nice technology with the Pleco, since I'm talking about, I might as well just continue here. They have the Free Flow Core Technology. Excel Filters has a very similar core as Pleco. I'm not sure if it was patented, probably not because other manufacturers can copy it.
6:03 Speaker 00 And it does have, again, the thickest material. It almost feels like plastic and not a cloth. So some people like him, some people don't like him. It just depends on your preference for the cartridges. I like the Pleco, but I've heard other pool guys say that they're not the greatest and they feel like they don't filter as well. It's just a regular remade material that comes with the other cartridges. Now Filber and I believe Unicel are both local here in California. Don't quote me, but I'm pretty sure. Unicel and Filber are local companies here and they do make the some branded products for Superior Pool Products
6:45 Speaker 00 and for SCP which is PoolCorp and you may buy a box of cartridges at your supplier and you open them up and they could be either Filber or Unicel filters and they're made specifically for PoolCorp with their branded logo, but they are a Filber or Unicel filter and you can find the matching number pretty easily by typing it into Google. Let's say you have a Pentair Clean & Clear 520, I'll go one size larger. So the OEM is R173578. Again, just type this in Google and it'll give you all these numbers. So there's no need to have a catalog anymore or look for things. It's it's pretty nice to have everything in a, you know, at your fingertips.
7:30 Speaker 00 Back in the day, we would take the cartridges into the pool store, put it on this little, even suppliers had these like a little mat and it has like a circle that you can match up the cartridges with and then you can order the size you want. Those days are pretty much over with everything just being online here. So Pleco has a PCC 130, Filber has the FC 1978, Unicel has the C7472, Excel has the XLS 7482 and then of course the off brands will also have that. Mosimo will reference the OEM part which is the R173578 and then from there you can find the cartridges.
8:08 Speaker 00 And usually people prefer one cartridge over another. Like for instance, if I were to choose between Pleco, Excel, Unicel and Filber, I would take the Pleco cartridge because I like Pleco and I think they make a really good quality cartridge. If you, a lot of guys like the Unicel because the remade material is really easy to clean and durable. So again, it's something that is your preference for the cartridge. You know, you pick what you like and you kind of stick with that brand. I kind of like to stick with the brand because it's easy for me to, I'm familiar with it and I think it works great. I really haven't had a Problem with any of the brands. So I can't say that Pleco is like, you know, head and shoulders above everyone else. Yes, their material is different.
8:53 Speaker 00 And the most similar one to it would be the XL filters out of Texas. They're pretty close to the Pleco material. And then Filburn, Unicel, their material is very similar to each other. But really, you can't go wrong with any of these four brands. They're all going to be reliable. And then you have a slew of off brands that are on the market as well. And I just would recommend sticking with one of these well-known brands. Now let me talk to you a little bit about when to change out the cartridges, because now that I went over the brands here, you may be wondering, well, when exactly do I change out the cartridges? Well, I think if you have the quad type four cartridge filter set up on your route at a pool stop,
9:34 Speaker 00 that those should be changed out every three years, and that's it. I wouldn't go any further than that. You may go a little less depending on, you know, how weathered they get in your area, especially if you have an area where there's a lot of dirt. They may wear out quicker. And I just wouldn't go past three years. I find that the three-year mark is kind of like the sweet spot for replacing these. So what I do is I'll put in a new set. And let's say I put a new set in 2023 in June. That means that they're due up in June 2026. I'll just go there and I'll replace them. You can write on it with on the filter with a Sharpie the date you installed them. That's probably the easiest way to keep records, in my opinion, is to write on the filter
10:18 Speaker 00 when you change them and then when they're due again. And that way you kind of stick with that routine. It makes things easy. And the quad cartridge filters last about three years. Now, if you have a single cartridge filter, those won't last probably past a year. Most of those last six months to nine months. You're going to change those out because they're doing a lot more filtration and they wear out a lot sooner. So keep that in mind if you have the smaller cartridge filter. Probably the only exception would be the AquaStar Pipeline because it has that special Pleco filter cartridge that probably would last, I'm going to go out on a limb here and say, it'll probably last Same amount of time as the quad type four cartridge filters. So you're not replacing the AquaStar Pipeline Filter every six to nine months.
11:03 Speaker 00 You probably can go two or three years with that cartridge, in my opinion. It's just a really well-made cartridge. How do you know when the cartridges are worn out? Well, there's a few indicators. Sometimes the pressure gauge is not the indicator. Because sometimes if you have a quad cartridge filter, the pressure gauge doesn't really move that much to indicate that there's very low flow. Again, flow is a good indicator. So if you notice, like, a spa spillway is kind of like the key point that I look at all the time when I look at flow. You can't really look at the return jets or the skimmer. Because you don't really see flow. Sometimes if it's really clogged up and the filters are really bad, you'll notice a big drop off in the suction from the skimmer. But for me, the spa spillway, if there's an attached spa, is the best indicator of flow.
11:47 Speaker 00 If you have a VS pump, I would put it at the 3450 rpm mark, the full speed. If you have a single-speed pump, just look at the spa spillway. And water should be spilling over. That's why they call it a spa spillway. If water is just trickling over or barely getting over there, that's a good indicator that there's not a lot of flow. Even though the return jets and the skimmer may be fine, the spa spillway is my indicator that, hey, the flow has slowed down quite a bit in this pool. And if the gauge doesn't indicate it, I'll take it apart, clean the cartridge filters, and inspect them to see if that's the problem. And nine times out of 10, when I see the flow that bad, the gauge is not indicating it, and there's really not other indicators. Sometimes, yes, you can notice in the skimmer, the flow has slowed down,
12:32 Speaker 00 and the automatic cleaner is not moving as fast as it used to. The suction cleaner is not moving around the pool and zipping around. But when you take the filter apart, you'll see that the bands of the cartridges are broken. So that's one indicator. And if the bands are broken and the pleats are kind of opened up, that indicates that those cartridges are not filtering well. The bands should be intact, and the little pleats should be really close together. That's where the cartridge filter gets its amazing square footage. I mean, if you think about it, a 520 square foot cartridge filter Is like, you know, six or seven times bigger, eight times bigger than a sixty square foot D filter. Because the pleats have extra square footage because they kind of go in and then back out and the other side in and out.
13:18 Speaker 00 All around the cartridge. Now, if these are expanded and flat, you're not going to get that amazing square footage. And you'll notice that in the flow of the pool. So, once I notice that the bands are cracked or bands are torn. And the tops sometimes are cracked on the cartridges and the pleats are kind of wide and exposed. Then I know the cartridges are no good. Now, when you get to a three-year mark, sometimes you don't even see indicators that they're bad. But I still like to replace them because, you know, the material is basically a paper. And if you get a lot of dirt and algae and different things in there, yes, you can hose it off and clean them. But it's going to kind of get into the material over time. And that's why a lot of times.
14:01 Speaker 00 After you clean the cartridges, you're still going to see a kind of residue or a stain, I should say, a brown stain. They're not going to come out white. As if they were brand new. And that's because the material is getting kind of saturated with dirt. Algae and stuff doesn't really come out of the material. And that's why the three-year mark is important with the quad cartridge filters and a much shorter time with the single cartridge filters. So, keep that in mind. That they don't last forever and they are just a paper products. You want to change them on the schedule that I mentioned here. So, that's the indicator they're not working. Sometimes the pressure gauge is an indicator, especially for a single cartridge filter. It'll be maybe at twenty. You'll clean it, put it back in. The next week you get there is at twenty-five or twenty-seven.
14:42 Speaker 00 And you can really know it. You can really notice a significant drop off in flow with the single cartridge filters. Over the four quad type cartridge filters. Now, I mentioned this all the time when I talk about cartridge filters and cartridge replacements. If you have a Stay Right System Three filter, either the big one, the forty or fifty square foot. You really don't need to change those cartridges every three years. Number one, they're super expensive. So, you don't want to be changing them every three years anyway. I don't know why they're so expensive, but they cost a fortune to change them. In fact, let me look up the retail price to kind of let you know how expensive these things are. Okay, we have a few here. We have the. Not sure what store that is, 749.
15:26 Speaker 00 Then you have pool supply for less, 649. And then you have Leslie's pool supply, 919. I mean, you might as well just buy a whole new filter in that case. That's crazy. Pool parts cartridges, 677. So they're pretty expensive cartridges. And if you do these every three years, the customer is not going to be extremely happy with you when you're replacing these filters at that extent. So it's something to consider that these are designed to last longer anyway, because there's this gigantic one and then the small one in the center. And for some reason, the pleats seem to really last a long time. Now, eventually the bands are going to break. The pleats are going to expand and you have to replace them. So I would say, I'm going to go out and say that maybe every five or six years,
16:11 Speaker 00 you can replace these cartridges. Some people may want to replace them every four years. But at the three-year mark, they still look pretty good. And they have such a large surface area and they're so well-made by the manufacturer that I don't really think they wear out anywhere near as much as a quad-type filters. In fact, I love the StayRight System 3 filter. I just think it takes up too much real estate in the backyard. And it's really a time-consuming filter to clean. Even with the multi-torque set to get the clamps off, it does take a lot of time. And that, that big cartridge can be really heavy when it's waterlogged and full of dirt. So to me, it's a little bit inconvenient, but they are a great filter. And I always joke that the tank can survive a nuclear blast
16:54 Speaker 00 because it's such a thick material that, I don't know, I've never even heard of anyone having one of these filter tanks crack on them. But all the parts for this thing is, are expensive. Even the O-ring is like 60 or 70 bucks. So it's just an expensive filter to operate. I mean, brand new, these retail for about 1,500. But I don't think you would want to be replacing the cartridges at $700 or $900. You can find them a little less expensive. I mean, I think the sweet spot is around 650 for a set of these cartridges, which is still double or triple what a quad cartridge filter replacement goes for. So if you're going to get a StayRight System 3 filter, just realize that the parts are pretty expensive. And again, all the brands, in my opinion, are, they're not equal.
17:38 Speaker 00 There's better material than others. And you'll find a brand that you like and you'll gravitate towards. I like PleatCo, so I'm going to always replace. Them with Pleat Co. whenever I can find them. And sometimes you're going for the bargain cartridges. And so sometimes the branded label at your supplier is the cheapest. And that's perfectly fine. They're made by a manufacturer that's pretty well known. Filber or Unicel makes them. So I have no problem buying any branded cartridge filter at the warehouse. Looking for other podcasts that I recorded? You can find those on my website, swimmingpoollearning.com. And on the banner, click on the podcast icon. That'll bring a menu of 1600 podcasts. And if you're interested in the coaching program that I offer, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a rest of your week. God bless.
18:23 Speaker 00 This episode is brought to you by Hasa, providing products that deliver clean, healthy water for every aspect of everyday life. The bottom feeder battery powered vacuum system, portable, powerful, and only weighs 12 pounds. And Skimmer, Get Skimmer, America's number one pool service software. Podcast listeners can try Skimmer for free at getskimmer.com/poolguy.
Previous W2 Employee vs. a Pool Service Pro Next Ducks in Your Pool? Here’s How to Keep Them Out! Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated