Skip to content

Simple Immigration Economics: Bigger is Better

Optimist Economy

Hosted by Robin Rauzi

52m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Robin Rauzi introduces a rerun of a June 2025 episode, framing it against new Supreme Court rulings ending temporary protected status for Haitians and Syrians and a White House push for ICE to arrest 2,000 people per day. Catherine (SPEAKER_03) then lays out the core economic argument: the size of the US economy equals the number of workers times their average productivity, so adding workers always makes the economy bigger. The predicted wage effect on native workers is not borne out by research, which she describes as 'mixed enough to be zero.'

She presents the scale: 14% of the US population is non-native, roughly 19.5% of workers are immigrants, and the US population would immediately begin declining without immigration. She contrasts the proposed $185 billion for immigration enforcement with the $2 billion spent on labor law enforcement protecting 170 million workers, and notes the undocumented population has been stable at around 11 million for nearly two decades. She closes by arguing that even those who oppose immigration should recognize that a large vulnerable workforce weakens labor standards for everyone.

  • The basic economic model holds that more workers times their average productivity always increases the size of the economy, regardless of legal status. 14:42
  • Economic research finds the predicted wage-depressing effect of immigration on native workers is 'mixed enough to be zero,' likely because immigrants are drawn to high-wage markets. 15:59
  • The proposed $185 billion for immigration enforcement is 90 times the $2 billion spent on labor law enforcement that protects 170 million workers. 21:23
  • The undocumented immigrant population has been stable at approximately 11 million for nearly 20 years, having peaked at 12 million in 2007. 27:30
  • Even an anti-immigration position is undermined by the fact that a large vulnerable workforce lets bad employers flourish, depressing wages and conditions for all workers. 39:58

Highlights

  • 14:42

    Workers Times Productivity Equals Economyinsight

    Catherine explains the foundational model: the size of the US economy is a direct function of the number of people working in it. More workers times average productivity equals a larger economy, and this holds whether the worker has legal permission or not.

  • 15:59

    Wage Effect Predicted But Not Seeninsight

    Theory predicts that expanding the supply of workers should pull down native wages, but Catherine says the research is 'mixed enough to be zero.' She suggests immigrants are highly mobile and drawn to hot markets where wages are already rising.

  • 18:11

    One in Five Workers Is Immigrantdata

    Catherine presents the data: 14% of the US population is non-native, roughly 19.5% of all workers are immigrants, and if immigration went to zero tomorrow the US population would immediately start declining.

  • 21:23

    Immigration Enforcement Dwarfs Labor Law Spendingdata

    The proposed $185 billion for immigration enforcement dwarfs the just over $2 billion spent on labor law enforcement protecting 170 million workers. Catherine notes this is twice the food stamp program and 50% more than the entire federal Bureau of Prisons.

  • 25:29

    Immigrants Span Farming to Computer Sciencedata

    Catherine breaks down immigrant labor by sector: at least a third in farming, building, cleaning, and construction (around 35–40% each), but also 1 in 4 computer and math workers and 1 in 4 healthcare support workers, challenging the stereotype of immigrants as only low-wage labor.

  • 27:30

    Undocumented Numbers Stable Since 2007insight

    The undocumented population jumped from 3 million to 12 million between 1990 and 2007, fell to 10 million during the recession, and has hovered around 11 million for nearly 20 years. Catherine argues the 'crisis' is manufactured around a number that has not changed in two decades.

  • 35:38

    Two Thirds Want Both More and Lessinsight

    Catherine points out that two-thirds of Americans say they don't want a path to citizenship for criminals, while two-thirds also say people who pay taxes should get legal status. She sees this contradiction as evidence of malleability and a basis for optimism about reform.

  • 39:58

    Vulnerable Workers Weaken Labor Standardsinsight

    Even for someone who opposes immigration, Catherine argues that having tens of millions of workers with no power to negotiate or report violations lets bad employers flourish, depressing wages and safety conditions for everyone in the labor market.

About this episode

(Originally aired 6/24/2025) One in five workers in the United States was born in another country. Without them, the country’s prime-age workforce would be shrinking, and thus so would our economy. So the calumny (Terms & Conditions) directed at immigrants is at odds with the basic fact that the U. S. needs them. What about depressing wages? Research finds such a mixed bag of results that the overall effect is about zero. Indeed, if the goal is to save “American jobs” or help American workers, there are a lot more effective ways to spend $185 billion than on a massive crackdown on immigration rules. Chapters: 00:02:34 Announcements 00:05:55 Retcon 00:10:43 Terms & Conditions 00:12:21 Big Pilcrow 00:43:07 Executive Orders 00:49:12 Spiritual Sponsors Donate to Optimist Economy: https://optimisteconomy.com Video-curious? Watch the Optimist Economy YouTube channel⁠⁠ https://www.youtube.com/@optimist_economy. We’re also on Instagram at ⁠⁠@optimist_economy https://www.instagram.com/optimist_economy or TikTok at ⁠⁠@optimist_economy https://www.tiktok.com/@optimist_economy. Chat with other Optimists on Substack. https://substack.com/chat/4604257?utm_source=pub-nav-bar Find utility with our merch: https://merch.ambientinks.com/collections/optimisteconomy Got economic questions, concerns, or executive orders? Send them to optimist.economy@gmail.com mailto:optimist.economy@gmail.com

Transcript

0:00
52:06

9,158 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Immigration Economics
  • Labor Markets
  • Immigration Policy
  • Wage Effects
  • Enforcement Spending
  • Population Growth
  • Labor Law Enforcement

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated