Skip to content

Mr. Justin Time Sets a Cruel Work Schedule

Optimist Economy

Hosted by Robin Rauzi

48m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Catherine Ann Edwards and Robin Rauzi discuss underemployment and the cruel scheduling practices that result from 'just in time' workforce management, a concept originally developed at Toyota to minimize waste. Edwards explains how this philosophy has been applied to retail and hospitality scheduling, producing unpredictable shifts, clopening (closing one night and opening the next morning), and income volatility that makes it impossible for workers to budget, rent apartments, or maintain government benefits. They cite BLS data showing average weekly hours of 30 in retail trade and 25 in leisure and hospitality, meaning entire industries are built on part-time work. A nine-month Gap experiment found a 7% increase in sales when stores used stable predictive scheduling instead of random just-in-time scheduling. The JP Morgan Chase Institute found that 27% of hourly workers experience a 10% income swing month to month. The conversation extends to Fair Work Week laws in cities like San Francisco, Seattle, and New York, and the proposed federal Schedules That Work Act by Warren and Deloria. Edwards argues that amending the Fair Labor Standards Act is one of the few policy moves available to Democrats that costs the federal government nothing.

  • The Gap experiment showed that stable predictive scheduling increased sales by 7% compared to random just-in-time scheduling, proving that treating workers as humans benefits the bottom line. 27:21
  • 40% of shift workers do not know their schedule a week in advance, making it impossible to plan childcare, rent, or other obligations. 21:48
  • The JP Morgan Chase Institute found that 27% of hourly workers experience a 10% income swing month to month, and 12% experience swings of 10 to 30%. 29:31
  • Fair Work Week laws in cities like San Francisco, Seattle, and New York require two weeks advance notice, a 10-hour break between shifts, and pay for canceled hours. 31:18
  • The Fair Labor Standards Act has not been voted on federally since 2007, meaning no new overtime, part-time, or scheduling protections have been enacted at the federal level in nearly two decades. 37:36

Highlights

  • 8:02

    Just-In-Time Scheduling Originsinsight

    Edwards traces just-in-time scheduling back to Toyota's post-WWII manufacturing model, where the goal was to order parts only as needed and eliminate all waste. That philosophy now governs how companies schedule workers.

  • 9:53

    Defining Clopeningstory

    Rauzi defines clopening as being asked to close a shift at night and then open the next morning, with a concrete example of working until 10 p.m. and then showing up at 5 a.m. for a fast food restaurant.

  • 21:48

    40 Percent Don't Know Scheduledata

    Edwards cites Shift Project data showing that 40% of shift workers do not know their schedule a week in advance, treating workers as cogs in a machine rather than people with lives.

  • 25:35

    The Gap Scheduling Experimentstrategy

    A nine-month experiment at Gap stores compared predictive scheduling to random just-in-time scheduling. Gap changed some practices before the study even began, and the stable scheduling group saw a 7% sales increase.

  • 27:21

    Seven Percent Sales Increasedata

    The Gap study found a 7% increase in sales in stores with stable predictive scheduling, a result Edwards calls massive, demonstrating that worker stability directly benefits business revenue.

  • 29:31

    JP Morgan Income Volatility Studydata

    The JP Morgan Chase Institute used transaction-level bank data to find that 27% of hourly workers experience a 10% income swing month to month, and 12% experience swings of 10 to 30 percent.

  • 34:06

    Labor Regulation Costs Nothingstrategy

    Edwards argues that amending the Fair Labor Standards Act to add scheduling protections, paid sick leave, or overtime rules costs the federal government zero in revenue spending, making it one of the few policy options available to Democrats given the deficit.

  • 38:03

    Women Leading Shift Work Researchinsight

    Edwards notes that the group of shift workers is predominantly women of color, and that almost every major researcher in the field of shift work is a woman, including Joan Williams who pioneered the Gap experiment.

About this episode

Just-in-time scheduling lets an algorithm decide when — and whether — millions of people work. Surveys find 40% of shift workers (mostly in retail and food service) don’t know their schedule a week in advance. They can also get sent home mid-shift or asked to be on call, unpaid. Studies show that more than 50% of hourly workers’ income swings up to 30% month-to-month, making it hard to budget for rent, qualify for benefits, or plan. A landmark study done at The Gap a decade ago proved stable schedules boost not only morale, but sales, so this isn't even bad for business. We already have fair workweek laws in many big cities, but this is a no-brainer for an update to the federal Fair Labor Standards Act. Chapters: 1:01 Announcements — Review shoutouts, Benevity donor thanks. 2:15 Retcon — July 4th recap, AI job-loss predictions walked back. 7:29 Terms & Conditions — Just In Time scheduling and clopening. 10:21 The Big Pilcrow: Underwork — Why part-time and shift workers get scheduled unfairly. 13:50 How the BLS tracks part-time hours by industry. 17:05 Economic vs. non-economic part-time reasons. 25:05 The Gap Study — Predictive scheduling boosted sales 7%. 28:22 Consequences — Income volatility and benefits fraud traps. 32:06 Fair workweek law and bills 35:20 Labor market regulation as low-cost policy. 41:59 Executive Orders — Credit card charge names, smaller jar lids. 43:52 Spiritual Sponsors — WaPo editorial takedown, new yoga studio. 48:12 Credits Donate to Optimist Economy: https://optimisteconomy.com Video-curious? We have clips on the Optimist Economy YouTube channel⁠⁠ https://www.youtube.com/@optimist_economy. Follow us on social media, now including Facebook! We’re also on Instagram at ⁠⁠@optimist_economy https://www.instagram.com/optimist_economy or TikTok at ⁠⁠@optimist_economy https://www.tiktok.com/@optimist_economy. Chat with other Optimists on Substack. https://substack.com/chat/4604257?utm_source=pub-nav-bar Optimist Merch: https://merch.ambientinks.com/collections/optimisteconomy Got economic questions, concerns, or executive orders? Send them to optimist.economy@gmail.com mailto:optimist.economy@gmail.com

Transcript

0:00
48:39

9,068 words · 4 speakers

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • Just-In-Time Scheduling
  • Underemployment
  • Shift Work
  • Labor Regulation
  • Income Volatility
  • Fair Work Week
  • Part-Time Work
  • Workforce Management

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated