Pod Insights My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 489 About this episode This week’s hometowns include a younger sister posing as a grandma for booze and a train derailment with a shocking twist.
For our sources, please visit https://www.myfavoritemurder.com/episodes.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3UFCn1g.
Head to social media to share your favorite moments from this episode.
Instagram: instagram.com/myfavoritemurder http://instagram.com/myfavoritemurder
Facebook: facebook.com/myfavoritemurder http://facebook.com/myfavoritemurder
TikTok: tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder http://tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder
Send your hometown stories to myfavoritemurder@gmail.com mailto:myfavoritemurder@gmail.com.
Join the Fan Cult to access ad-free episodes of My Favorite Murder. Members also receive merch store discounts, exclusive audio and video content and more! Visit www.fancult.supercast.com http://www.fancult.supercast.com/ to join.
Shop for My Favorite Murder and other Exactly Right merchandise here: www.exactlyrightstore.com https://www.exactlyrightstore.com.
Rate, review and follow My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you like to listen.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Karen Kilgariff? This is Exactly Right.
0:06 Georgia Hardstark? Everyone loves the idea of spending an afternoon curled up with a good book.
0:10 Karen Kilgariff? Well, grow up, because it's almost impossible.
0:12 Georgia Hardstark? Luckily, you can take your next great story with you on Audible.
0:15 Karen Kilgariff? Audible has a massive selection of titles to choose from, including This American Life, new books by Michael Connelly, along with classics from Magathah Christie, and so much more.
0:24 Georgia Hardstark? Whether you want a mystery, a true crime story, or something completely different, there's always something new to listen to.
0:29 Karen Kilgariff? New members can start listening with a 30-day free trial at audible.com/mfm.
0:34 Georgia Hardstark? Audible, stories that speak to you. Goodbye. The Hulu original series Phony is now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ Sonny's life is pretty great until he wakes up from a car accident to a world that looks exactly like his, with one exception, his mom.
0:50 Karen Kilgariff? Starring five-time Emmy nominee Connie Britton and Sam Nivola, this small town is hiding the mother of all mysteries just beneath the surface.
0:58 Georgia Hardstark? Watch the Hulu original series, Phony.
1:00 Karen Kilgariff? Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply. Goodbye.
1:05 Speaker 02 Do you ever feel like your computer is tracking you? Well, it's not. It's your browser following you. But not if you come back to Firefox. Firefox blocks the trackers automatically, doesn't follow you from site to site, and supports the ad blockers other browsers dropped. Plus, you can switch AI on or off when its intelligence is acting too artificial. And switching? Totally painless. Your bookmarks, passwords, and browsing history come right with you. Come back to Firefox. Visit firefox.com.
1:53 Georgia Hardstark? Hello.
1:54 Karen Kilgariff? And welcome.
1:55 Georgia Hardstark? To My Favorite Murder.
1:56 Karen Kilgariff? The minisode.
1:57 Georgia Hardstark? Where we read you.
1:58 Karen Kilgariff? Your emails.
1:59 Georgia Hardstark? Your stories.
2:00 Karen Kilgariff? And emails.
2:01 Georgia Hardstark? Emails and stories. And anything in between.
2:04 Karen Kilgariff? Friends and neighbors.
2:06 Georgia Hardstark? I think you're first, yeah?
2:07 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah. Okay. The subject line of this email is, "My Younger Sister Did the Illegal Part." "Hello Karen and Georgia. You guys are the best and seeing you in Chicago was a highlight of 2025."
2:21 Georgia Hardstark? Oh.
2:22 Karen Kilgariff? "You absolutely crushed it. My story firmly falls into the older sister puppeteering younger sister category." We love those. "The year was 2009 and it was a summer afternoon in the south side of Chicago. I am the eldest of five kids. At the time, I was 19. My twin sisters were 18 and my twin brothers were 13."
2:42 Georgia Hardstark? Jesus.
2:44 Karen Kilgariff? "This lineup has probably tipped Karen off to our Irish Catholicness."
2:48 Georgia Hardstark? Nice.
2:49 Karen Kilgariff? And Georgia. "Growing up, I had the ideas and my sister Bridget did the doing. She is deeply funny and gave little fucks, making her the perfect puppet. On this particular afternoon, we found ourselves sitting around plotting how we could get alcohol for later that night. We had exhausted our rolodex of older cousins and we were not feeling brave enough to get a run. Did everyone call it this, when you sit outside a liquor store and ask a cool looking adult to buy you beer?"
3:17 Georgia Hardstark? Done it so many times.
3:18 Karen Kilgariff? "My cousin Eileen, I remember, she called it tapping shoulder."
3:22 Georgia Hardstark? That's so good.
3:23 Karen Kilgariff? I think they made that up. Anyways, "We had no options left when an idea occurred to me. Old people don't get carded. My plan took little convincing. Bridget was immediately in. I spent the next hour Mrs. Doubtfire style."
3:37 Georgia Hardstark? No.
3:38 Karen Kilgariff? "Transforming her from sunburnt teenager into the most convincing grandmother our resources could manage."
3:44 Georgia Hardstark? Oh my, that would have never crossed my mind because I can't act too. I would have been laughing or crying the whole time.
3:51 Karen Kilgariff? Or just being like, ugh.
3:52 Georgia Hardstark? Scared. Oh my God.
3:54 Karen Kilgariff? "We used an old Halloween wig, an obscene amount of makeup." We relate.
3:58 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
3:59 Karen Kilgariff? "And the oldest looking clothes we could find in my mom's closet. Bridget practiced her old lady walk and satisfied with the results. We were off."
4:07 Georgia Hardstark? If this works, then I'll believe in God.
4:11 Karen Kilgariff? Here we go. We loaded into our hand-me-down 1999 silver grand marquee.
4:17 Georgia Hardstark? Amazing.
4:17 Karen Kilgariff? That's an old lady car.
4:18 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
4:19 Karen Kilgariff? Never more grateful for this geriatric monstrosity of a car than in that moment. Surely, any liquor store employee seeing someone exit this vehicle would assume she's at least 65. We parked and Bridget shuffled in. We held our breath and watched from the car as she made her way to the back of the store. She paused in front of the beer, then grabbed a case of Twisted Tees.
4:41 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my God. So grandma.
4:43 Karen Kilgariff? You know, yeah.
4:44 Georgia Hardstark? What grandma strength?
4:44 Karen Kilgariff? Old people love Twisted Tees. She later said that she panicked and could not decide what a grandmother would be buying at noon on a Tuesday. As she hobbled up to the counter, she suddenly realized that she had forgotten about her chipped, black nail polish.
4:58 Georgia Hardstark? Jesus.
5:00 Karen Kilgariff? The attendant did not seem to notice. He smiled and asked, "Aw, fun party tonight?" She put on her best fake granny voice and replied, "Er, yes." He handed her the change, completely unaware that she was a high school senior, and told her to have a good day. We started cheering as she walked out. She looked at us, jumped straight into the air, and I shit-knew-you-not clicked her heels together before sprinting back to the car.
5:25 Georgia Hardstark? It worked!
5:26 Karen Kilgariff? It fucking worked. The afternoon ended. There's a picture.
5:30 Georgia Hardstark? Okay. Oh, my God!
5:31 Karen Kilgariff? Uh huh. The afternoon ended with us driving to the bar where we knew my grandpa Charlie and his brother Jimmy were at. Bridget cruised in and sat down next to them, still fully in character.
5:41 Georgia Hardstark? No.
5:41 Karen Kilgariff? She tried to talk to them for five minutes, but they wanted absolutely nothing to do with this random old woman. Finally, she ripped off the wig and yelled, "Papa, it's me!" The entire bar erupted. My grandpa was a little horrified, but mostly amused. We decided not to push our luck and never dusted off that old lady wig again, despite none of us liking Twisted Tees. You better believe that we forced our way through them that night.
6:05 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
6:06 Karen Kilgariff? I'm attaching pictures of Grandma Bridget for your viewing and sharing pleasure, as I believe the statute of limitations has expired on this. Stay sexy and don't underestimate a bad wig, Maggie.
6:17 Georgia Hardstark? I can't wait to see this. Yep. I totally buy it. A hundred percent. Look at that outfit.
6:23 Karen Kilgariff? It's fucking brilliant.
6:25 Georgia Hardstark? It's so good. It's like not too over the top.
6:28 Karen Kilgariff? It's not.
6:29 Georgia Hardstark? But it's enough. The teeth give it away because she's got perfect teeth.
6:32 Karen Kilgariff? Right. She should have yellowed those up a little bit.
6:34 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
6:34 Karen Kilgariff? The glasses are perfect. The blush is perfect.
6:37 Georgia Hardstark? The fucking blazer.
6:38 Karen Kilgariff? I think the scarf around the head tied under the chin is an overplay.
6:42 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
6:42 Karen Kilgariff? But it's still, nobody gives a shit.
6:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
6:45 Karen Kilgariff? It gives and as long as she was kind of crouched over and talking and
6:49 Georgia Hardstark? Sure.
6:50 Karen Kilgariff? in the old lady voice.
6:51 Georgia Hardstark? Coin purse. Oh my God. Like I, I hate that we just gave her a bunch of teenagers a fucking.
6:57 Karen Kilgariff? There's a.
6:59 Georgia Hardstark? There's a great phone over. There's one on her across the top of the fucking.
7:02 Karen Kilgariff? Grand Marquis.
7:03 Georgia Hardstark? Posing like a pinup girl. We'll put them on our Instagram.
7:06 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, that second picture is absolutely joy. Also, I think the Grand Marquis was 50% of that.
7:12 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
7:13 Karen Kilgariff? Journey right there.
7:13 Georgia Hardstark? It's a giant silver like cop car.
7:15 Karen Kilgariff? It's a total grandma car.
7:17 Georgia Hardstark? I want it. Okay. I want Bridget to have become an actress and I want her sister who wrote it in to be a makeup artist.
7:22 Karen Kilgariff? Oh my God.
7:23 Georgia Hardstark? That's what happened in the end.
7:25 Karen Kilgariff? What if it's Maggie Gyllenhaal and her sister Bridget.
7:29 Georgia Hardstark? Bridget Gyllenhaal.
7:30 Karen Kilgariff? Bridget Gyllenhaal. The infamous Bridget Gyllenhaal.
7:34 Georgia Hardstark? Wow. That was, that was one for the ages.
7:36 Karen Kilgariff? So epic.
7:37 Georgia Hardstark? So good.
7:38 Karen Kilgariff? This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace. Turning something you love into a career is exciting. Then come the invoices. Lucky for you, Squarespace can handle the business stuff so you can focus on your business. From consultations to events and experiences, you can showcase your skills with a customizable website designed to attract clients and grow your business. With Squarespace's collection of cutting edge design tools, anyone can build a beautiful, professional, online presence that perfectly fits their brand or business. Get paid on time with professional invoices and online payments. Plus, streamline your workflow with built in appointment scheduling and email marketing tools.
8:16 Karen Kilgariff? Head to Squarespace.com/murder for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code MURDER to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Goodbye.
8:26 Georgia Hardstark? All right. Wow. Okay. We'll have to follow that one with. Uh, tornado story.
8:31 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, yes.
8:33 Georgia Hardstark? Dear Karen in Georgia, let's jump right in. In April of 1979, my mom, Vicky, was 16, a junior in high school in her Wichita Falls, Texas, and dealing with a breakup. On the dresser in her bedroom, she had her class ring, her mom's class ring, and her recent ex's class ring. The ex, Mark, had come by asking for the ring back, but my mom refused and simply told him that she'd give it back later.
8:57 Karen Kilgariff? Mm, sure. She wasn't ready.
8:59 Georgia Hardstark? No. Nobody could have known how much later that would be. On April 10th, 1979, a massive tornado ripped through town in an event now known as Terrible Tuesday.
9:09 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, God. You love tornadoes.
9:10 Georgia Hardstark? I do. The tornado touched down at 5:55 PM, traveled eight miles through the city, killing 42 people and destroying more than 100 commercial businesses, two schools, and more than 3,000 homes.
9:23 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, my God.
9:24 Georgia Hardstark? On that evening, my mom, her parents, and her brother, who had come by the house for dinner, were getting ready to eat when the tornado warning hit. My granddad ordered everyone into the car to drive out of town. My mom argued because even at 16, she knew that being in a car during a tornado is a famously bad idea. But dad said, "Get in, and when the Texas dad says that, you get in." The only one not required to leave was her brother, who stayed behind. I guess he was over 18, so he was like, "Fuck you."
9:52 Karen Kilgariff? I'm just gonna hang out here.
9:53 Georgia Hardstark? In the tornado house. They drove out of town a bit, but then couldn't go anymore as there was too much traffic, with cars pulled over as everyone was trying to leave.
10:03 Karen Kilgariff? That's so scary.
10:04 Georgia Hardstark? That's like why you don't get in your car and try to drive somewhere.
10:06 Karen Kilgariff? Also, that's when the LA fires were happening, and I had fires literally in a ring around my neighborhood.
10:12 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
10:13 Karen Kilgariff? I left my house because I was like...
10:15 Georgia Hardstark? Same.
10:15 Karen Kilgariff? I can't get out while everyone else is trying to get out.
10:18 Georgia Hardstark? Exactly. That's exactly why I left, like, before I needed to.
10:22 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
10:22 Georgia Hardstark? That's... And my cousin was one of the ones who got stuck in the Palisades, like, driving out, and her car got fucking burned.
10:28 Karen Kilgariff? For real?
10:28 Georgia Hardstark? Because she had to get down and run. Yeah. So, that day, I was like, "I'm not doing this."
10:32 Karen Kilgariff? No.
10:33 Georgia Hardstark? My God, terrifying.
10:34 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
10:34 Georgia Hardstark? Um, so my mom watched the tornado as it barreled through town. It was over a mile... Wide and looked like a massive black wall. When it passed, they drove back toward their house and realized at the end of their block that all of the houses were leveled. It went from a normal neighborhood and houses to nothing. Her brother, who had stayed behind, survived by sheltering in a closet under the stairway. And when he emerged, the entire second story of their house was gone. So I can show you a photo of the houses, the before and after of the house. Beautiful, 70s looking, normal house. And then that. Like, if her brother hadn't been there, he would have died.
11:14 Karen Kilgariff? Right.
11:14 Georgia Hardstark? But he was hiding, like, somewhere there.
11:16 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, somewhere there.
11:17 Georgia Hardstark? Isn't that fucking, but like, that's an uninhabitable teardown.
11:21 Karen Kilgariff? Yes, and so random.
11:23 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, we'll show it on our Instagram. Okay, and so the entire second story was gone, which meant my mom's room and the class rings were gone as well. Remember that? My mom really only cared about the class rings and even searched in the ditch behind the house, she never found them. In the end, my grandparents decided to sell the lot rather than rebuild, and the rings were presumed lost. Fast forward 10 years to 1987, Vicky and Mark exchanged different rings.
11:49 Karen Kilgariff? What?
11:50 Georgia Hardstark? So they get back together and get married, and then emoji with a heart in its eyes.
11:55 Karen Kilgariff? What?
11:55 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Fast forward 16 more years to 2003, I'm 13 years old, the middle of Mark and Vicky's three daughters. The family who rebuilt the old lot is still living there. Their 19-year-old son is in the backyard when their dogs dig something up, and what do they find?
12:12 Karen Kilgariff? No.
12:13 Georgia Hardstark? A Ryder High School class of 1979 ring with the initials M.L.
12:18 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
12:19 Georgia Hardstark? The photo of it, too.
12:19 Karen Kilgariff? Shit.
12:20 Georgia Hardstark? This is from Molly. You fucking killed this email.
12:22 Karen Kilgariff? Molly.
12:23 Georgia Hardstark? Look at that, vintage class ring.
12:25 Karen Kilgariff? Unbelievable.
12:26 Georgia Hardstark? They borrow a yearbook, realize the former resident is now married to a guy named Mark, and call my mom. My mom brought my sisters and me in on the news, and one night, we played a game of asking my dad if he could remember what his class ring looked like. He ended up describing it all wrong, classic, and then my mom said, "Did it look like this?", and held out the ring to him. He was shocked and amazed, of course. Stay sexy and give your ex his class ring back so it's not lost in a tornado, or maybe don't, Molly.
12:56 Karen Kilgariff? Oh my God.
12:57 Georgia Hardstark? I know.
12:58 Karen Kilgariff? That is, when you start, like, when it started going that direction, I was like, they found the ring.
13:03 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
13:04 Karen Kilgariff? Like, how is that possible?
13:05 Georgia Hardstark? And just in the backyard, sitting there. That's why you need to always bring a-
13:10 Karen Kilgariff? Own a metal detector.
13:11 Georgia Hardstark? Exactly, and bring it with you everywhere you go. That's literally what I was gonna say.
13:14 Karen Kilgariff? From house to house.
13:18 Georgia Hardstark? Buying furniture is a lot of pressure. It has to look good, feel good, and hold up to everyday life.
13:23 Karen Kilgariff? Take it from me, a bad couch can ruin your life.
13:26 Georgia Hardstark? That's why Article focuses on stylish, high-quality pieces designed to last.
13:30 Karen Kilgariff? Article makes it effortless to create a stylish, long-lasting home at an unbeatable price.
13:35 Georgia Hardstark? They take great care in curating their collection, focusing on pieces that stand the test of time. There's no filler. Every item is chosen for its craftsmanship, design, and lasting value.
13:45 Karen Kilgariff? And with Article's 30-day satisfaction guarantee, you can shop with confidence, knowing that if you're not completely in love with your new furniture, you can easily return it. Man, there was nothing I loved more than when I was broke and I could still buy furniture that I needed at Article. It wasn't cheap-looking. It's like, I was investing in these pieces that were comparatively inexpensive, and I was like finishing rooms. I was like getting the kitchen table that was like bringing the whole thing together. And it was such an incredible thing, because I never got to do that before. I love that about Article.
14:17 Georgia Hardstark? Article is offering our listeners $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more.
14:21 Karen Kilgariff? To claim, visit article.com/murder, and the discount will be automatically applied at checkout.
14:26 Georgia Hardstark? That's article.com/murder for $50 off your first purchase of $100 or more.
14:31 Karen Kilgariff? Goodbye.
14:33 Georgia Hardstark? The Hulu original series, Phony, is now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+.
14:37 Karen Kilgariff? Sonny's life is pretty great, until he wakes up from a car accident to a world that looks exactly like his, with one exception: his mom.
14:45 Georgia Hardstark? To everyone else, she's the same Ellen they've known their whole lives. But for Sonny, he knows something is off.
14:51 Karen Kilgariff? As his relationship with his mother begins to crack in unsettling ways, he's forced to question what happens when the perfect mom becomes a perfect stranger.
14:58 Georgia Hardstark? Is this all in his head, or is there really an imposter in his house?
15:01 Karen Kilgariff? Starring five-time Emmy nominee Connie Britton and Sam Nivola, this small town is hiding the mother of all mysteries just beneath the surface.
15:09 Georgia Hardstark? Watch the Hulu original series, Phony.
15:11 Karen Kilgariff? Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for bundle subscribers. Terms apply. Goodbye.
15:19 Karen Kilgariff? Okay, I'm not going to read you the subject line. It says, "Hey folks, my maternal great-grandfather, or Papa Pete, as my family called him, was a character. He was a raging alcoholic who, to me, sounds like a total piece of shit, but at his core, cared for his children, my grandmother and her siblings. The closest fictional character I can compare him to is Frank Gallagher from Shameless."
15:41 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, fuck. That's rough.
15:43 Karen Kilgariff? "He frequently went on drinking and gambling binges where his family wouldn't hear from him for weeks. He gave classic drunk advice, my favorite of which being, 'If you have nowhere to sleep, sleep on a grave, because no one will bother you.'" And then it says classy. But that's really true. I kept thinking about that, where I'm like, that's really true. You go into a graveyard.
16:05 Georgia Hardstark? At night, you're alone, pretty much, kind of.
16:07 Karen Kilgariff? Well, some drinking teenagers, but they're scared of you.
16:10 Georgia Hardstark? And ghosts.
16:11 Karen Kilgariff? And ghosts, but they're also scared of you.
16:12 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
16:13 Karen Kilgariff? So, without further ado, it's the late 60s in the small town of Watumpka, Alabama, a population of about 4,000 people at the time. My great-grandmother, Big Mama, no, I'm not kidding, gets a phone call from a sheriff in Texas. "Ma'am, are you the wife of Pete Rooks?" "Yes." "Ma'am, your husband is dead. He drunk himself to death. You're gonna have to come to Texas to collect his body." Big Mama, who's only about 30 at the time, while holding this charming nickname, by the way, is devastated. She takes her two young teenage daughters on a road trip to Texas to bring the body of their father home to Alabama to be buried. They enter the police station, they explain that they are there to collect Mr. Rooks' remains.
16:58 Karen Kilgariff? The young mother and her daughters are brought around the corner to the cells, only to find Pete Rooks drunk off his ass and slurring his hellos to his wife and daughters.
17:09 Georgia Hardstark? What?
17:10 Karen Kilgariff? Pete had gone on a bender so grandiose that it carried him three states away. Upon being arrested for god knows what, the sheriff must have asked him who he could call to come pick him up from the station. Pete knew no one would come pick him up in Texas all the way from Alabama.
17:25 Georgia Hardstark? No way.
17:26 Karen Kilgariff? And he was out of money, so being the genius he was, he told the sheriff to call his wife and tell her that he had died.
17:33 Georgia Hardstark? Okay, the sheriff is so complicit, and it's so not okay, and it was your job to not do that.
17:38 Karen Kilgariff? This is... This is a real bros before hos situation.
17:42 Georgia Hardstark? Seriously.
17:43 Karen Kilgariff? That is like, and that's why-
17:44 Georgia Hardstark? Like the devastation that they went through the whole time before knowing that. Just because you were like, "Come pick me up."
17:50 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
17:50 Georgia Hardstark? And the sheriff was like, "Let's do it."
17:52 Karen Kilgariff? Boys' club.
17:53 Georgia Hardstark? Wow.
17:53 Karen Kilgariff? That's why the girls' club must, must, we must get serious about the girls' club.
17:59 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
17:59 Karen Kilgariff? Because the boys have been boys' clubbing for far too long.
18:02 Georgia Hardstark? Bros, you've had your fucking day.
18:03 Karen Kilgariff? Can you imagine how furious you would be?
18:05 Georgia Hardstark? No.
18:06 Karen Kilgariff? Okay.
18:09 Karen Kilgariff? "He knew that the only way his wife would come pick his dumb ass up in a whole other state after no contact, no apology, and no money to fund the trip was over his dead body. I can't even imagine that 12-hour car ride of shame home." And that's my crazy great-grandparents story. JS.
18:29 Georgia Hardstark? Shit.
18:31 Georgia Hardstark? You got one of those stories? Email them to us.
18:32 Karen Kilgariff? Please.
18:33 Georgia Hardstark? What's the most fucked up thing someone's ever done to you?
18:35 Karen Kilgariff? Also, if you feel shame, yeah, maybe not that, but if you have a story that, where you feel like you're supposed to feel shame, or that somebody's bad, they're not.
18:45 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
18:45 Karen Kilgariff? Write it in. Let us decide.
18:47 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, we'll tell you the truth.
18:51 Karen Kilgariff? Okay, we'll tell you the truth.
18:53 Georgia Hardstark? Let's see, okay. Oh, and this is, it's Memorial Day when this comes out, so this is kind of a Memorial Day story. "Hello, ladies and emotional support animals. I was born and raised in Buffalo, New York. My family traveled from Italy sometime around 1890 and decided to make the city of Good Neighbors their home. In 1996, my grandfather embarked on a dedicated search to locate his missing uncle Bartholomew, who had served in World War II. Initially, the family had been informed that he was missing in action, but later the military communicated that he had been killed in battle with no remains discovered. Due to the onset of Alzheimer's disease, my grandfather's pursuit was tragically interrupted. However, in 2019, my father took it upon himself to continue the search.
19:38 Georgia Hardstark? He began reaching out to distant relatives he had never met and joining Facebook groups dedicated to the families of missing veterans. After years of tireless research, my father discovered a cemetery in Luxembourg that still contained approximately 100 unmarked graves. Given that Bartholomew's last known location was in this area, and he had been missing for 75 years, it seemed to be the most likely place to find him." In a remarkable turn of events, several family members submitted DNA samples, which ultimately allowed us to confirm Bartholomew's identity among the unmarked graves.
20:11 Karen Kilgariff? Whoa.
20:11 Georgia Hardstark? I know. After all that time.
20:14 Karen Kilgariff? So I wonder if the army or whatever it was, has some sort of procedure to keep something so they can test.
20:20 Georgia Hardstark? Totally. And then his remains were repatriated to Buffalo for a proper military burial, just in time for what would have been his 104th birthday on Memorial Day.
20:30 Karen Kilgariff? Wow.
20:31 Georgia Hardstark? On Saturday, June 1st, 2024, Bartholomew received full military honors and was laid to rest with his family, bringing closure to a story that has resonated in our family for generations. It is a profound and moving moment to know that after so many years, he will finally rest with those who loved him. My papa, who passed away on October 14th, 2024, has now been reunited with his beloved uncle, SSDGM K.
20:57 Karen Kilgariff? Wow. That's a powerful story.
21:00 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
21:01 Karen Kilgariff? For Memorial Day.
21:02 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
21:04 Karen Kilgariff? Wow. Well, if you're enlisted, if you're in the, in any part of the military in this country, thank you for your service.
21:11 Georgia Hardstark? Yes, thank you.
21:12 Karen Kilgariff? And thank you to World War II veterans for fighting Nazis.
21:16 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, literal Nazis.
21:18 Karen Kilgariff? Very important to fight Nazis.
21:21 Georgia Hardstark? Let's do it. The Hulu original series Phony is now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+
21:28 Karen Kilgariff? Sonny's life is pretty great, until he wakes up from a car accident to a world that looks exactly like his, with one exception: his mom.
21:36 Georgia Hardstark? To everyone else, she's the same Ellen they've known their whole lives, but for Sonny, he knows something is off.
21:41 Karen Kilgariff? As his relationship with his mother begins to crack in unsettling ways, he's forced to question what happens when the perfect mom becomes a perfect stranger.
21:49 Georgia Hardstark? Is this all in his head, or is there really an imposter in his house?
21:52 Karen Kilgariff? Starring five-time Emmy nominee Connie Britton and Sam Nivola, this small town is hiding the mother of all mysteries just beneath the surface.
22:00 Georgia Hardstark? Watch the Hulu original series Phony, now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+ for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
22:07 Karen Kilgariff? Goodbye. Sometimes being a little salty is completely justified.
22:11 Georgia Hardstark? Care your salty side with something sweet with the new salted caramel flavor from Kachava.
22:16 Karen Kilgariff? Kachava is a whole body shake with plant-based protein, fiber, greens, and other nutrients to help fill nutritional gaps.
22:23 Georgia Hardstark? Just two scoops provide complete nutrition your body craves with protein, fiber, greens, and so much more.
22:29 Karen Kilgariff? Their new salty caramel flavor combines sweet caramel with a little salt. So you get that salty-sweet balance along with the nutrition Kachava is known for.
22:37 Georgia Hardstark? When the day demands your salty side, fuel it with plant-based protein that actually tastes delicious.
22:42 Karen Kilgariff? I really do love Kachava and I really do think it does taste delicious for getting you through the morning, filling in the gap if you just need some protein and you need some vitamins. It's such a nice little treat.
22:53 Georgia Hardstark? It's such an easy way to get everything you need and it tastes good, too, which is just huge bonus.
22:58 Karen Kilgariff? So embrace your salty side.
22:59 Georgia Hardstark? Go to kachava.com and use code MFM for 15% off your first order.
23:04 Karen Kilgariff? That's Kachava, K-A-C-H-A-V-A dot com, code MFM.
23:08 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
23:11 Karen Kilgariff? Okay, my last email, the subject line is "A Fun Train Derailment?" Question mark. "Hello, murder pals. I know you're awesome. You know you're awesome. We don't need to discuss it." "Some random Wednesday in 2007, my grandfather picked me up from school, just like any other day. We made some small talk on the way home and when we walked in the door, he told me that he had a gift for me. While I waited, my grandmother showed me a brand-new diamond ring he had just given her. This was weird, since my grandparents weren't exactly well off. My gift was a brand-new laptop. Since our household computer was of the 90s and it was on its last leg, I was eager to get on MySpace in less than a 15-minute wait time.
23:54 Karen Kilgariff? So I stopped wondering if my grandfather had pulled a bank job and I went on to my room."
23:58 Georgia Hardstark? That's right.
24:00 Karen Kilgariff? "Don't ask questions, just log on." "Fast forward to a few hours, when the nightly news came on. Being a teenager, I didn't watch the news, but I happened to walk through the living room at just the right time to see my grandfather on the screen, talking about how something felt like an earthquake. Super confused, I stopped to listen. That afternoon, he had stopped at a convenience store. It was one of those stores you wouldn't know was a store unless you were a local, just a boring, tiny building on the side of the road. There's nothing unusual about him stopping there, but what he conveniently didn't mention at all that day was that while he was there, a fucking train ran through the store."
24:41 Georgia Hardstark? Well, I forgot about the train completely.
24:42 Karen Kilgariff? Right? According to the news, a train engineer ignored a stop signal when he was backing up on an offloading track, which caused three train cars to roll through a dirt barrier and hit the store 30 feet from where the truck ends. The owner managed to get everyone out safely, including having to pull out a customer who went into shock and had to be sent to the hospital. My grandfather had only a tiny cut on his nose, probably from his glasses being pushed into his face from the impact.
25:11 Georgia Hardstark? Dude!
25:12 Karen Kilgariff? Of a train.
25:13 Georgia Hardstark? Of a train.
25:14 Karen Kilgariff? I don't remember the store ever reopening, and eventually it was demolished. But as far as I know, trains have run without incident in my hometown ever since. Oh, yeah, and the gifts? He stopped there to buy a lottery ticket. The ticket won him $100,000.
25:30 Georgia Hardstark? I'm sorry, what the fuck? I was like, he stole the money when everyone had evacuated?
25:35 Karen Kilgariff? Nope. He says, "Yeah, not only did he survive a freak train derailment, but he won more than my salary from the ticket he bought immediately before it happened."
25:45 Georgia Hardstark? What the fuck?
25:47 Karen Kilgariff? Stay sexy and avoid stores near train tracks, Brit.
25:50 Georgia Hardstark? Or don't.
25:51 Karen Kilgariff? And then our producer Kate Schalenbach looked the incident up, and she says there was indeed a train derailment in Lancaster, South Carolina in 2007. The train ran into a buy right convenience store, and Kate found a print interview quoting a witness who had stopped in to get a lottery ticket when the train crashed into the store. No one died in this incident.
26:14 Georgia Hardstark? I mean, the timeline that you're on in this life, if that's it.
26:20 Karen Kilgariff? After that?
26:21 Georgia Hardstark? That's pretty fucking great.
26:22 Karen Kilgariff? Constant whistling. Constant chill attitude.
26:27 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, someone likes you.
26:28 Karen Kilgariff? Just, I am blessed.
26:29 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my god. Wow. Okay, my last one is just about medieval family folklore.
26:36 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, just that?
26:37 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Hi, Karen and Georgia, greetings from Brussels. I'll get straight into it. I'm from the rural part of Belgium, Limburg. I've been to Belgium. Isn't that weird?
26:47 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
26:48 Georgia Hardstark? Back in the late medieval times, this area was mostly farms, tiny wooden houses with batched roofs and local pubs. Take me there.
26:56 Karen Kilgariff? So fun.
26:57 Georgia Hardstark? Life was fine if you were hardworking. Unfortunately, I come from a long line of, quote, enthusiastic enjoyers of life.
27:06 Georgia Hardstark? Not exactly aligned with the whole reap what you sow lifestyle. So my ancestors found a solution, a gang. Not just any gang, the biggest and most notorious one in the region. Their name, okay, here I go, Dubakken Riders.
27:21 Karen Kilgariff? Dubakken Riders?
27:22 Georgia Hardstark? Dubakken Riders.
27:23 Karen Kilgariff? Dubakken Riders?
27:24 Georgia Hardstark? Literally the goat riders.
27:26 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
27:27 Georgia Hardstark? And this is, I know, goat riders. Folklore says they rode goats through the night. Some stories even mention flying goats. In reality, they were more into leaving threatening burn letters on people's doors, not to be confused with the Mean Girl burn book. And since everything was made of wood and straw, very flammable vibes, the letters basically said, "Nice home you got there. It would be a shame if it burned down." People had to pay to avoid that.
27:53 Karen Kilgariff? Oh shit, like early mafia or Brussels mafia.
27:56 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. My family name shows up in multiple court documents connected to this gang. I find that both cool and slightly concerning, and honestly, a bit explanatory for how my family still operates today. No crime, just creative thinking. It doesn't end well, though. Two of my ancestors were hanged in a nearby town after being tortured for a confession. When I was about eight, my dad took me there. The original gallows were still standing in front of the town hall.
28:23 Karen Kilgariff? Whoa.
28:24 Georgia Hardstark? My dad somehow arranged a meeting with the mayor to discuss our family history. I vividly remember us walking into the office and my dad immediately joking, "So, who here hanged my family?"
28:36 Georgia Hardstark? It remains one of my favorite childhood memories to this day. Now that I've uncovered my dad's side, I'm looking into my mom's. Apparently, my grandparents were heavily involved in resistance efforts during the Nazi occupation.
28:46 Karen Kilgariff? Hell, yes.
28:47 Georgia Hardstark? They rarely talked about it because of the trauma, even though that's where their love story began.
28:52 Karen Kilgariff? Wow.
28:53 Georgia Hardstark? Maybe a story for another day? Anyway, thank you for being you. Heart emoji. Stay sexy and maybe don't trust anyone who rides goats. M.
29:02 Karen Kilgariff? M, please write in the love story where your grandparents met during the resistance.
29:06 Georgia Hardstark? We need resistance love stories.
29:08 Karen Kilgariff? We need all resistance stories, any.
29:10 Georgia Hardstark? Any, like today? Are there any resistance love stories?
29:12 Karen Kilgariff? That's right, Minneapolis? Come on, let us.
29:15 Georgia Hardstark? Write us at, what is it? MyFavoriteMurder@gmail.com.
29:19 Karen Kilgariff? Thank you, goat riders in the sky.
29:21 Georgia Hardstark? That's right.
29:21 Karen Kilgariff? Stay sexy.
29:22 Georgia Hardstark? And don't get murdered. Goodbye.
29:25 Karen Kilgariff? Elvis, do you want a cookie?
29:34 Karen Kilgariff? This has been an Exactly Right production.
29:36 Georgia Hardstark? Our senior producer is Molly Smith, and our associate producer is Tessa Hughes.
29:39 Karen Kilgariff? Our editor is Aristotle Lasaveta.
29:42 Georgia Hardstark? This episode was mixed by Liana Scolacci.
29:44 Karen Kilgariff? Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder@gmail.com.
29:47 Georgia Hardstark? Follow the show on Instagram at MyFavoriteMurder.
29:49 Karen Kilgariff? Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
29:54 Georgia Hardstark? And now you can watch My Favorite Murder on Netflix.
29:56 Karen Kilgariff? And when you're there, hit the double thumbs up and the remind me buttons. That's the best way you can support our show. Goodbye.
30:09 Karen Kilgariff? Calling all amateur detectives and podcast obsessives.
30:13 Georgia Hardstark? Virgin Voyages' second True Crime Voyage sets sail March 20th, 2027, for a five-night escape to Grand Turk and the Beach Club at Bimini.
30:21 Karen Kilgariff? As part of the On Air at Sea collection, this immersive sailing brings together fan favorite podcasts, including Disgrace Land, Buried Bones, and Wisecrack, for live recordings, behind-the-scenes access, exclusive meet-and-greets, and crime-themed programming that you won't find anywhere else.
30:38 Georgia Hardstark? All aboard our award-winning, kid-free ships.
30:41 Karen Kilgariff? Head over to virginvoyages.com/truecrime to secure your spot. Goodbye.
30:46 Speaker 03 Halloween's almost here and I've got plans. My first stop is Total Wine & More for cold beer, ready to drink cocktails, and a bottle of wine to share. And I know I'm getting the lowest prices. Get the fun started at Total Wine & More. Spirits are not sold in Virginia and North Carolina. Drink responsibly. B21.
31:01 Speaker 04 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of 5-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
Previous 533 - An Exercise in Frustration Next Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 98: Grasp It Page updated October 30, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated