Pod Insights My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 471 About this episode This week’s hometowns include the Poe Toaster and a grandma getaway driver.
For our sources, please visit https://www.myfavoritemurder.com/episodes.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3UFCn1g.
Head to social media to share your favorite moments from this episode.
Instagram: instagram.com/myfavoritemurder http://instagram.com/myfavoritemurder
Facebook: facebook.com/myfavoritemurder http://facebook.com/myfavoritemurder
TikTok: tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder http://tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder
Watch full episodes of My Favorite Murder on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@my_favorite_murder
Send your hometown stories to myfavoritemurder@gmail.com mailto:myfavoritemurder@gmail.com.
Join the Fan Cult to access ad-free episodes of My Favorite Murder. Members also receive merch store discounts, exclusive audio and video content and more! Visit www.fancult.supercast.com http://www.fancult.supercast.com/ to join.
Shop for My Favorite Murder and other Exactly Right merchandise here: www.exactlyrightstore.com https://www.exactlyrightstore.com.
Rate, review and follow My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you like to listen.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Speaker 00 This is exactly right.
0:06 Speaker 00 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
0:35 Georgia Hardstark? Everyone loves the idea of spending an afternoon curled up with a good book.
0:39 Karen Kilgariff? Well, grow up because it's almost impossible.
0:41 Georgia Hardstark? Luckily, you can take your next great story with you on Audible.
0:44 Karen Kilgariff? Audible has a massive selection of titles to choose from, including This American Life, new books by Michael Connelly, along with classics from Magga the Christie, and so much more.
0:53 Georgia Hardstark? Whether you want a mystery, a true crime story, or something completely different, there's always something new to listen to.
0:59 Karen Kilgariff? New members can start listening with a 30-day free trial at audible.com/mfm.
1:04 Georgia Hardstark? Audible, stories that speak to you.
1:06 Karen Kilgariff? Goodbye.
1:24 Georgia Hardstark? Hello.
1:25 Karen Kilgariff? And welcome.
1:26 Georgia Hardstark? This is My Favorite Murder.
1:27 Karen Kilgariff? That's Georgia Hardstark.
1:28 Georgia Hardstark? That's Karen Kilgarret.
1:29 Karen Kilgariff? This is a mini-soad.
1:30 Georgia Hardstark? That's right.
1:31 Karen Kilgariff? We don't do it like that.
1:32 Georgia Hardstark? I know, but it's OK.
1:33 Karen Kilgariff? OK.
1:33 Georgia Hardstark? It's 2026. The world is ending. We can do whatever the fuck we want at this point. Nope.
1:38 Karen Kilgariff? Yep, you're right. This is where we come to get away from that stuff.
1:42 Georgia Hardstark? Turning my phone off.
1:43 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, is that the police?
1:44 Georgia Hardstark? Hello. Hi, OK. It's a mini-soad.
1:48 Karen Kilgariff? We're going to read you emails that you sent to us.
1:50 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Should I go first?
1:51 Karen Kilgariff? Sure.
1:51 Georgia Hardstark? OK. This is called "New Orleans Car Crash."
1:55 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
1:55 Georgia Hardstark? "Hey, I love y'all and could go into pleasantries for five paragraphs, but I don't want to."
2:00 Karen Kilgariff? I want you to.
2:01 Georgia Hardstark? "When I was 23 years old, I was driving home around 1:00 a.m. after having a movie night at a friend's house. I was crossing a major intersection underneath an overpass when a car came out of nowhere, made an illegal left turn, and smashed into my driver's side door." I did not see it coming. My car spun around twice and hit a cement support underneath the overpass. All the windows, including the windshield shattered in the collision, all the windows, and all the airbags deployed. My driver's side door wouldn't open and I was forced to climb out of the passenger window. The car that hit me had fled the scene. It was late, I was scared, and in a bad part of town. I called the New Orleans Police three times and no one ever showed up.
2:42 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, you're in a bad part of town.
2:44 Georgia Hardstark? Right, no one's coming.
2:44 Karen Kilgariff? They don't get that service.
2:46 Georgia Hardstark? Right. All of a sudden, six people ran from the gas station across the street. They helped me push my car out of the intersection and told me there was no way the police were coming, but they would sit and wait with me on the curb until someone came to get me. One of them was a nurse getting off shift from the nearby hospital and used her phone light to check me for concussions.
3:05 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
3:06 Georgia Hardstark? Concussions or just concussion? It says concussion.
3:08 Karen Kilgariff? Multiple concussions all over her head.
3:10 Georgia Hardstark? Can you get multiple concussions?
3:11 Karen Kilgariff? Maybe if you hit your head on the steering wheel and then back really hard.
3:15 Georgia Hardstark? One here, one here, one here.
3:15 Karen Kilgariff? And then here comes the airbag.
3:17 Georgia Hardstark? I don't know how it works. She informed me that if I had braced for the collision, there was a good chance I would either be unresponsive or worse. Did you know that? Like, you get injured worse if you're like, oh!
3:28 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, and that's why drunk people usually come out of stuff like that just fine.
3:32 Georgia Hardstark? I remember, I got in a bad car accident like 10 years ago and I remember going, I saw it coming and I said to myself, just relax. Like, I knew it was gonna happen and I just, like, made myself relax.
3:42 Karen Kilgariff? Okay, can I just tell you that's the benefit of your anxiety?
3:45 Georgia Hardstark? I said it all the way!
3:46 Karen Kilgariff? You probably absolutely ran that possibility in your head at one point.
3:50 Georgia Hardstark? Absolutely, always.
3:51 Karen Kilgariff? Jesus Christ.
3:52 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, wow, yeah, that's so cool. And I was fine. Like, it was a pretty bad accident.
3:57 Karen Kilgariff? God damn, Georgia.
3:58 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, like, cut on.
3:59 Karen Kilgariff? Fucking A.
4:00 Georgia Hardstark? Jesus, alright, so everyone remember that, in your anxiety daydreams.
4:04 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, go ahead and relax during the car crash.
4:06 Georgia Hardstark? An inevitable car crash. And then they said, I luckily left the accident with only cuts from the glass breaking. One man, the sweetest Nola grandpa you've ever seen, informed me the car which had hit me had pulled two blocks away and was sitting down the street with the lights off. That's so menacing.
4:24 Karen Kilgariff? Or like, maybe they were like, I did something bad, I can't go away, but I don't know what to do.
4:29 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, just waiting and watching. I don't know about y'all, but if I was to hit someone that badly, I would be running out of the car to make sure they were still alive. So they were just sitting in their car.
4:38 Karen Kilgariff? Could've been in shock.
4:39 Georgia Hardstark? That's right. As I walked up to the car to get the driver's info, all six people walked with me as support. When the driver rolled down their window, they were clearly under the influence and struggled to get their things. I have made mistakes in my past and I know things happen, but empathy for other people has to be above fear of getting in trouble. My six new friends were very helpful in this situation. When I finally got the driver's information, all six people from the gas station gave me their information and I was able to use them as witnesses in court.
5:08 Karen Kilgariff? Wow.
5:08 Georgia Hardstark? It goes to show that sometimes the support you need comes from unexpected places and never underestimate how powerful community is. I know we're supposed to look for the helpers, but this night, the helpers found me.
5:20 Karen Kilgariff? Good.
5:21 Georgia Hardstark? P.S. When I went to check on my car the next morning, the license plate of the driver who hit me was embedded in the metal of my driver's side door. I don't know who was up there in the sky, but I'm glad she was looking out for me that night. And I'm thankful for the amazing community in what I think is the best city ever. People really are amazing. S.S.D. Jam and please don't hit and run. G. She. Her.
5:44 Karen Kilgariff? What a wonderful request at the end of that email. That is like so touching.
5:48 Georgia Hardstark? I know.
5:49 Karen Kilgariff? Also, the odds that a nurse would be standing by is miraculous and wonderful.
5:55 Georgia Hardstark? And that six people are the kind of people who run towards the emergency. Like six, that's so heartwarming.
6:02 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
6:03 Georgia Hardstark? Incredible.
6:03 Karen Kilgariff? God, that makes me think of my car accident at the end of your street that night.
6:07 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
6:07 Karen Kilgariff? And it was like a lady going, "Go ahead, you can go." And then the next thing I knew, it was a loud noise and just dust in the air and I didn't understand what was happening. So crazy.
6:19 Georgia Hardstark? Knock on wood.
6:20 Karen Kilgariff? I hate car accidents.
6:21 Georgia Hardstark? Me too.
6:23 Karen Kilgariff? The subject line of this email is "The Time Three Little Girls Were Going to Take Down the Night Stalker." Hey there, my make-believe besties. During the summer of 1985, my sister and I came up from Oceanside to stay with my family in Whittier. I was 16, my cousin was 14 and my sister was 10. And this was peak night stalker panic. It was terrifying, especially for us kids, because he was loose in our area. The news kept tossing out ominous patterns like what color houses he targeted. Remember that?
6:50 Georgia Hardstark? Jesus. No, I don't. What year was it?
6:52 Karen Kilgariff? You were too young. It was like in the early 80s.
6:55 Georgia Hardstark? Okay, yeah, I was too young. No, but I've since read that and that just sounds fucking horrifying.
6:59 Karen Kilgariff? It would just be on the nightly news. He's looking for yellow houses.
7:02 Georgia Hardstark? Did you just always think someone was about to climb through your fucking window?
7:05 Karen Kilgariff? It was so crazy. It was really... I thought it was later, though, but it was, yeah, it was high school. Like what color houses he targeted or whether he picked victims near freeways. I was already a budding murderino, so my fear and fascination were basically holding hands. One night, my grandfather dropped the three of us off at my aunt's house to spend the night. We had plans with her the next day, but she was out at a business dinner, so there were zero adults home. Honestly, we didn't care. Being unsupervised felt like freedom until it didn't. We were in the den watching TV when a helicopter started circling overhead, over and over. Immediately, we all had the same thought. The night stalker is absolutely in our neighborhood right now.
7:47 Karen Kilgariff? We locked the den door and tried poorly to convince ourselves everything was fine, until a huge crash came from the kitchen. I swear, I still remember that drop in my stomach. My brain went straight to, he's in the house.
7:59 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
8:00 Karen Kilgariff? We panicked, but we panicked with purpose. I grabbed a bat. I handed my 10-year-old sister a can of bug spray and my cousin a can of hairspray.
8:08 Georgia Hardstark? Amazing.
8:09 Karen Kilgariff? Because you know, nothing says self-defense like Aquanet. That's actually true. That shit can do serious damage.
8:15 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, get a lighter near there and you're fucking...
8:17 Karen Kilgariff? You're done for. We crept through the pitch-black living room and burst into the kitchen, ready to attack the intruder. But no one was there. The kitchen light fixture had fallen and exploded everywhere.
8:27 Georgia Hardstark? What?
8:28 Karen Kilgariff? That's it. Just a rogue ceiling light trying to murder us.
8:30 Georgia Hardstark? My god.
8:31 Karen Kilgariff? We were still shaken, but we survived the night. I can't remember whether we ended up calling my grandparents on the rotary phone or if my aunt checked in on us, but we stayed until she got home like the brave little idiots that we were. Fast forward to after your San Diego show when my sister and I were telling my mom this story. My sister suddenly goes, I still can't believe they left us alone that summer. A literal serial killer was running around Southern California and everyone was like, eh, the girls will be fine. It's so true.
8:59 Georgia Hardstark? So fucked up.
9:00 Karen Kilgariff? Stay sexy and check your light fixtures. Danielle. Danielle.
9:04 Georgia Hardstark? Danielle. Oh.
9:06 Karen Kilgariff? Danielle.
9:07 Georgia Hardstark? Danielle. I love that and I love Panic with Purpose. That's our new.
9:12 Karen Kilgariff? Panic with Purpose.
9:13 Georgia Hardstark? That's the theme of this is Panic with Purpose.
9:16 Karen Kilgariff? It's kind of what you did in your car accident.
9:17 Georgia Hardstark? Exactly.
9:17 Karen Kilgariff? You can panic, just panic with.
9:19 Georgia Hardstark? Panic with Purpose, like it's okay. I love that. We have to get shirts made like in, in sweet honesty writing. Panic with Purpose.
9:26 Karen Kilgariff? Panic with Purpose.
9:27 Georgia Hardstark? The new fragrance.
9:28 Karen Kilgariff? By Georgia Hardt.
9:30 Georgia Hardstark? It smells like beer.
9:32 Karen Kilgariff? NBO.
9:36 Georgia Hardstark? The holidays are right around the corner, which means people are about to do a lot of shopping.
9:40 Karen Kilgariff? And if you have a small business, they could be shopping with you.
9:43 Georgia Hardstark? Get your business ready with Shopify.
9:45 Karen Kilgariff? Shopify is the platform for a record-breaking, reliable holiday selling season at every stage.
9:50 Georgia Hardstark? They power millions of businesses worldwide, from household names to those that are just getting started.
9:55 Karen Kilgariff? Shopify's pre-built website themes make it easy to launch a beautiful, professional looking store without ever touching a line of code.
10:01 Georgia Hardstark? And Shopify's mobile app lets you run your store from anywhere, from tracking inventory, to customer support, to handling payments and more.
10:08 Karen Kilgariff? If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com/murder to start your free trial.
10:14 Georgia Hardstark? That's Shopify.com/murder.
10:16 Karen Kilgariff? Go to Shopify.com/murder today to hear your first.
10:19 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
10:22 Speaker 00 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds up to $200,000 right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
10:53 Georgia Hardstark? There are plenty of things that keep you up at night. Your sleep tracker shouldn't be one of them.
10:57 Karen Kilgariff? You know that feeling, laying in bed, staring at the ceiling, counting all the times you said something weird.
11:02 Georgia Hardstark? And then you wake up and check your sleep score. Now you have to start your day knowing that you failed at sleeping.
11:07 Karen Kilgariff? Hatch Sleep Clock does it differently.
11:10 Georgia Hardstark? It tracks your sleep from your nightstand. No ring, wristband, or judgmental score waiting for you in the morning.
11:15 Karen Kilgariff? Instead, you'll get personalized insights to understand your sleep and recommendations to build a routine you'll love night after night.
11:22 Georgia Hardstark? Fall asleep to the next chapter of an audiobook, like The Odyssey, a nervous system reset meditation, or a calming sound bath.
11:28 Karen Kilgariff? Then you can find out which gives you 20 more minutes of deep sleep each night.
11:32 Georgia Hardstark? Hatch Sleep Clock.
11:33 Karen Kilgariff? The sleep tracker designed to get you to sleep. Available now on hatch.co.
11:38 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
11:41 Georgia Hardstark? This one is about Poe, Edgar Allan Poe, and this episode comes out on his birthday.
11:48 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, so great.
11:49 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
11:50 Karen Kilgariff? This is also a literary podcast.
11:52 Georgia Hardstark? That's right. We are so smart.
11:53 Karen Kilgariff? Who is us?
11:54 Georgia Hardstark? Hi, murder raccoons. Oh, that's a first.
11:57 Karen Kilgariff? This is a real smarty pants email.
11:59 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. And this is called Hometown Story. Poe, Baltimore, and the mysterious Poe toaster. Like, what do you think about Poe toaster? Sounds like a machine in your kitchen, right?
12:08 Karen Kilgariff? My hope is that it's a toaster that when the toast pops up, his face is on that toast.
12:13 Georgia Hardstark? Okay, it's not. It's confusing. They mean like a toast as in like cheers.
12:17 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, okay.
12:17 Georgia Hardstark? So it confused me at the beginning. Okay, hi, murder raccoons. I was thrilled when the 28 October 2021 episode discussed the death of Edgar Allan Poe. I now live in Canada, but I grew up in Baltimore. So assuming Poe was a victim of foul play, that's a hometown murder for me. You've got a lot in Baltimore. And I thought you might also like to know about a Poe but not murder related mystery, the motivations and identity of an unknown person or people referred to as the Poe toaster. Toast. Poe's birthday is January 19th. And for the whole time I was growing up, it was an annual event that a figure dressed in black, face obscured by a hat or a scarf, would enter Baltimore's Westminster burying ground on the night of January 19th. The person would then stand at Poe's grave,
13:02 Georgia Hardstark? pour a glass of cognac, toast the grave, and drink. Along with the cognac bottle, three red roses were always left on the grave. Occasionally, there would also be a note. And then the Poe toaster would leave until the next year.
13:15 Karen Kilgariff? Was it a raven?
13:19 Georgia Hardstark? No. There are theories about why these specific objects were left, but to this day, no one knows for sure who the Poe toaster was or why this person carried out this annual ritual. I learned about this tradition on an eighth grade field trip that took my English class to the Poe house, where that year's coneyac and roses were displayed on a mantelpiece. Note that we also visited Poe's grave and got to see collapsing wooden coffins and skeletons in the catacombs. Best field trip ever. Turns out, the Poe toaster tradition might have started as early as the 1930s. Baltimore press started reporting on this visitor to Poe's grave in the 1950s. Over the years, folks would start to gather near the graveyard on January 19th to watch.
14:00 Karen Kilgariff? To gather to watch the toaster come and be...
14:03 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, this anonymous toaster.
14:06 Georgia Hardstark? A note left in 1998 suggests that the original Poe toaster died and passed along the tradition to someone else. In 2006, someone tried to grab the Poe toaster and determine the individual's identity, but bystanders helped him get away. Who the fuck is grabbing...
14:22 Karen Kilgariff? A ruiner.
14:23 Georgia Hardstark? A ruiner. The only time anyone ever interfered. Some might say that the tradition died out, but I think of it as evolving. In January 2010, there was no Poe toaster appearance. Over the next few years, several people showed up dressed in black. In 2011, four on the same night. Someone was like, "I'm gonna do it."
14:41 Karen Kilgariff? I'll do it.
14:42 Georgia Hardstark? You're just not original.
14:43 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah. Or you just want to be a part of things.
14:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, or you just be friends with each other, actually.
14:47 Karen Kilgariff? You're all in the same, like, American lit class?
14:50 Georgia Hardstark? The press dubbed them the "Foe Toasters."
14:55 Karen Kilgariff? The press is covering this.
14:57 Georgia Hardstark? I love it, yeah. Then in 2015, the Maryland Historical Society set up a competition to choose a new Poe toaster. Since then, the appearance of the Poe toaster has become sort of a civic celebration. I love being from a city that takes such pride in a weird, brilliant, gothy Victorian poet and horror story writer, in no small part because he died there. Yes, the football team is called the Ravens because of Poe's poem. Do we know that?
15:21 Karen Kilgariff? I did not know that.
15:22 Georgia Hardstark? That's amazing. And I think it's cool how, over the course of decades, what possibly started off as a personal tribute to a beloved author turned into another mystery. If you read this hometown story on the podcast, please send my love to my sister Dani, who introduced me to your work, one of many ways she has made my life better by being in it. Oh, Dani. Thanks for the stories you share. Stay sexy and don't be a foe toaster, Erin. And then she gave us the Wikipedia. Page for it.
15:47 Karen Kilgariff? That's amazing.
15:48 Georgia Hardstark? How cute is that? So if you're listening to this on that day, go see the faux toaster tonight.
15:53 Karen Kilgariff? This would be the faux toaster or the po toaster?
15:56 Georgia Hardstark? Go watch whoever.
15:57 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
15:57 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
15:58 Karen Kilgariff? Go watch that guy.
15:59 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
15:59 Karen Kilgariff? Or gal.
16:00 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
16:00 Karen Kilgariff? Or they're she or.
16:02 Georgia Hardstark? What about like a deathbed confession from your grandma that she's the original po toaster?
16:06 Karen Kilgariff? She's like, honey, I thought of that. I thought it'd be real funny. Why does she have that accent? She's in Baltimore. I could never do that Baltimore accent.
16:13 Georgia Hardstark? Grandma from fucking Tennessee suddenly.
16:16 Karen Kilgariff? She moved. She was transferred at her job.
16:19 Georgia Hardstark? Yes, it happens.
16:20 Karen Kilgariff? Okay. The subject line of this email is, why were you not asked back to babysit? Remember that?
16:25 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
16:25 Karen Kilgariff? We asked people to send these emails in and I won't read the rest of that title. It says, hi pals, I could send a thousand emails detailing the things you've seen me through as a day one listener. College, my amazing mom dying of pancreatic cancer, marriage, moving to the middle of nowhere, finishing my last year of my MA in clinical mental health counseling. I digress.
16:47 Georgia Hardstark? Wow.
16:48 Karen Kilgariff? What an arc.
16:49 Georgia Hardstark? Amazing.
16:50 Karen Kilgariff? These are the things that make up our lives. You've been through it all with me and for that, I'll be eternally grateful. Thank you for being my friends.
16:58 Georgia Hardstark? That's so nice. I'm scared to cry.
17:00 Karen Kilgariff? Your recent request for why weren't you asked back to babysit stories really struck a chord.
17:05 Georgia Hardstark? I don't remember that, but I love it.
17:07 Karen Kilgariff? It was like somebody sent in a, somebody doing a bad job and we're like, we've all done a bad job. This one comes from my later babysitting years as a well seasoned 17 year old with five full years of childcare under my belt. I was definitely 12, watching my four month old cousin a story for another time. But I did learn the hard way that while fiber one bars are a delicious treat to find in the cupboard after the baby's asleep, you should not eat five in a row.
17:33 Georgia Hardstark? Oh God. Oh God, the stomach cramps, the fucking horror.
17:39 Karen Kilgariff? It's just like a young babysitter's entry into cupboard freedom.
17:45 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
17:45 Karen Kilgariff? And it's like.
17:46 Georgia Hardstark? Gone wrong.
17:46 Karen Kilgariff? I could eat a can of kidney beans right now if I wanted to. What are these? Fiber one bars?
17:52 Georgia Hardstark? Like when you'd eat up fucking, you know, like you shouldn't eat more than like two dried apricots or you'll be farting for the rest of your life. That's like, I found a whole bag of them in animal.
18:01 Karen Kilgariff? They're like candy. As a 17-year-old, I was now a professional. I was babysitting the daughter of a woman who worked in administration at my high school. They were out at a holiday party on a weeknight, so things were relatively tame. I helped my charge to bed and, like the responsible adult I was, took out my homework to complete before her parents returned. When in your life?
18:23 Georgia Hardstark? Never, ever.
18:23 Karen Kilgariff? Did you ever pull out your homework to complete?
18:25 Georgia Hardstark? Didn't have any. Never had any.
18:28 Karen Kilgariff? As contact wearers can empathize, the radiator heat in the apartment had my eyes feeling like sandpaper. I pushed through it for a bit, but eventually decided to hunt around for some saline or eye drops. A happy excuse for my actual favorite activity, snooping.
18:42 Georgia Hardstark? Yep.
18:43 Karen Kilgariff? The second job you have as a babysitter.
18:45 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
18:46 Karen Kilgariff? With relief, I saw a massive bottle of eye solution on the counter as I entered the bathroom. I flipped open the cap and doused my eyes in sweet relief. Returning to the table to work, I was puzzled and discouraged to feel that my eyes still felt dry and uncomfortable.
18:58 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, no.
18:59 Karen Kilgariff? Several trips back to the bathroom later, redousing my eyes with no change, I eventually gave up deciding this family must be buying the one-ply toilet paper version of contact solution.
19:09 Georgia Hardstark? What was it? I'm scared.
19:10 Karen Kilgariff? About 20 minutes later, I started to feel increasingly frustrated as the page of my textbook was becoming cloudy, almost blurry. Rubbing my eyes without relief, I returned to the bathroom to look in the mirror. To my horror, my pupils were the size of dinner plates.
19:27 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, god, oh, god.
19:28 Karen Kilgariff? Taking up the entirety of my iris so no green was visible, only huge, black, very suspicious eyeballs staring back at me. Panicked, I reached for the saline bottle, holding it as far from my face as possible. I read, quote, "Dilating eye drops are X-only."
19:46 Georgia Hardstark? Holy shit.
19:47 Karen Kilgariff? Flashing before my eyes were scenes of the child I was babysitting talking about her eye patch worn to correct her lazy eye and the drops she hated that her mom had to put in to correct her vision. I'd effectively triple-dosed myself with dilating eye drops and had less than half an hour before this child's parents were due home.
20:06 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my god.
20:08 Karen Kilgariff? I went in high school to the doctor, had to get my eyes dilated for an exam. I went back to school and my friend Jenny Gillan was like... We were at a, like, an assembly. Yeah. And I was like, hey, what's up? And she's like, oh, my God, are you on acid? Why are you on acid at school? And I was like, what are you talking about? Yeah, I just came to school after I dropped a bunch of acid. Yeah, I thought that'd be funny. Shout out Jenny Gilligan. She's alive. Sorry. Shout out Jenny Gilligan. Don't point out to the heavens, then. I packed my things and sat quietly at the table contemplating my fate. When they returned, like the responsible 17-year-old I was, I said nothing, stared only at the floor, not making eye contact, accepted my cash payment, and left as fast as humanly possible.
20:50 Karen Kilgariff? I don't recall exactly if I declined all future babysitting offers from this family, or if they never came after my exceptionally sketchy goodbye that evening. But that was my last trip to that house. My eyes were dilated for two weeks. Shut up. Before returning to normal size. See photo attached for their status about eight days afterwards. Stay sexy and just wear glasses. Ingrid Vermont. Holy shit. What happens when you put those in? You... I know that you dilate, but like, can you damage your eyes? Yeah, because all the light just goes in. Right. So you have to, like, wear sunglasses and, like, be super careful. Right. I had those weird, that day at school, I had those weird paper, they look like old people sunglasses.
21:36 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, that's what you're supposed to do. That's fucked up. Like, she dilated her eyes for two weeks. Two weeks is like, I would have, I wonder if her parents were like... Are you on acid? Taking you to the hospital or something. She got Gilligan.
21:51 Speaker 00 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of 5-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval. There are plenty of things that keep you up at night. Your sleep tracker shouldn't be one of them.
22:24 Karen Kilgariff? You know that feeling, laying in bed, staring at the ceiling? Counting all the times you said something weird.
22:29 Georgia Hardstark? And then you wake up and check your sleep score. Now you have to start your day knowing that you failed at sleeping.
22:34 Karen Kilgariff? Hatch Sleep Clock does it differently.
22:37 Georgia Hardstark? It tracks your sleep from your nightstand. No ring, wristband, or judgmental score waiting for you in the morning.
22:42 Karen Kilgariff? Instead, you'll get personalized insights to understand your sleep and recommendations to build a routine you'll love night after night.
22:49 Georgia Hardstark? Fall asleep to the next chapter of an audiobook like The Odyssey, a nervous system reset meditation, or a calming sound bath.
22:55 Karen Kilgariff? Then you can find out which gives you 20 more minutes of deep sleep each night.
22:59 Georgia Hardstark? Hatch Sleep Clock.
23:00 Karen Kilgariff? The sleep tracker designed to get you to sleep. Available now on hatch.co.
23:05 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
23:07 Karen Kilgariff? This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace. Turning something you love into a career is exciting. Then come the invoices. Lucky for you, Squarespace can handle the business stuff so you can focus on your business. From consultations to events and experiences, you can showcase your skills with a customizable website designed to attract clients and grow your business. With Squarespace's collection of cutting-edge design tools, anyone can build a beautiful, professional, online presence that perfectly fits their brand or business. Get paid on time with professional invoices and online payments. Plus, streamline your workflow with built-in appointment scheduling and email marketing tools. Head to squarespace.com/murder for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch,
23:49 Karen Kilgariff? use offer code MURDER to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Goodbye.
23:57 Georgia Hardstark? My last one is cat murder. I love to blab, so this is me trying really hard to be focused and concise. You asked for stories of lies your parents told you. Well, for context, I was an only child until I was 10, so this explains the lack of life skills and thinking things through in the story. I had a childhood cat named Angie. We found Angie in the streets and I picked her because she meowed a lot more than the other cats she was with. Angie was a real trooper, as my New Year's resolution every year growing up was to be nicer to Angie. She was an angel cat and would let me dress her in doll clothes and push her around in a stroller. Poor Angie. Whiskers. She was, I covered her in barrettes as a child. Whiskers?
24:42 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. She was so patient. Growing up, we also had two green parakeets named Jacob and Sarah. Well, yes, I did get my self-esteem from academic achievement and had no creativity growing up. In my child brain, I was convinced that Jacob and Sarah were going to lay eggs soon and made them a nest in their cage and would check religiously if they had laid eggs yet. Suddenly, Jacob died. A few days later, Sarah was laying lifeless on the bottom of the cage. I was a wreck. How did my beloved expectant bird parents just mysteriously die with no heads up? The only solution to my heartbreak was to beg my parents for new birds. Unfortunately for me, my parents informed me that there was a bird flu going around that made the birds sick, so if I got more birds, they would also die. How did this bird
25:26 Georgia Hardstark? flu work, you ask? It caused the birds to get an infection in their wings, and the next thing you know, they are dead at the bottom of the cage. Sound familiar? Right. Yeah. Fair enough, I would just have to wait out the bird flu, I thought. For the next few years, I would ask my parents for updates of the prevalence of the bird flu, which they always stated was still happening. Yeah. Fucking loud, those parakeets. Man, I feel them. I began to reference the bird flu socially, telling my friends all about it and feeling super smart that nobody else knew about the infectious bird wing mystery disease. In high school, I even wrote about the bird flu in one of my exams that was submitted to the college board. Oh, wow. Wow. You couldn't let go.
26:11 Georgia Hardstark? Repercussions. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, but they let. Okay. They let her believe it. Yeah. Then comes COVID lockdown, when families are forced to actually talk, where my parents were shocked to find out that at the age of 21, I still believed the bird flu was the origin of Jacob and Sarah's death. Turns out, the reality is that my sweet, beloved, overweight, brown tabby cat, Angie, murdered the birds by jumping on their cage, knocking it off the cage hook, and trying to capture them until they both had heart attacks and died. Oh, my god. Oh, Mo. Mo would be so proud of himself. Like, I could see him doing that.
26:48 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, yeah.
26:49 Georgia Hardstark? That's such a cat thing. And then it's on a paragraph. I am still processing this. To truly explain how we just do not talk about things in my family. My first year of medical school, I was living in another state and had-
26:59 Karen Kilgariff? I'm sorry, this is a fucking doctor we're talking about? Only children are fucked up.
27:04 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
27:04 Karen Kilgariff? Wow.
27:05 Georgia Hardstark? They have no, like, can I bounce this off of you real quick?
27:07 Karen Kilgariff? Yes.
27:08 Georgia Hardstark? My sibling thinks this is bananas, too.
27:10 Karen Kilgariff? Yes. Or like, my sibling's here to ruin everything intentionally for me, which actually educates me about the world.
27:16 Georgia Hardstark? Like, if this person had got made fun of for believing that by a sibling, they would have gone on to it quicker than-
27:23 Karen Kilgariff? Nope.
27:23 Georgia Hardstark? 21.
27:24 Karen Kilgariff? No.
27:24 Georgia Hardstark? "My first year of medical school, I was living in another state and had dreams nightly that Angie was dead. She was 17 at the time, so we knew her time was coming to an end, but she was visiting me in my sleep nightly. I would ask my mom if Angie was okay because I was so thrown off from my dreams, and she would always reply that Angie was alive and well, catching lizards and begging for treats. Just cat stuff. Then, one hour after my first medical school exam, my little sister, then 12 years old and mean, so she was an only child till she was 10-
27:52 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
27:52 Georgia Hardstark? Then, 12 years old and mean, called and said only the following: Angie died three weeks ago, and we didn't want to make you fail your test if we told you. Bye."
28:02 Karen Kilgariff? Bye.
28:04 Georgia Hardstark? Bye. And hung up. "Yes, I should get a therapist. Pictures of Angie attached. Stay sexy and don't assume your child has common sense. S."
28:13 Karen Kilgariff? So she, aw.
28:15 Georgia Hardstark? She's a beautiful cat in a dress.
28:17 Karen Kilgariff? That's a hilarious picture of a cat.
28:18 Georgia Hardstark? In a dress.
28:19 Karen Kilgariff? That's really funny. No, this one-
28:20 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, that one? Yeah, she looks very stupid.
28:23 Karen Kilgariff? She's like, get me out of here.
28:24 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my god.
28:25 Karen Kilgariff? But then, S really dreamed this cat died, like, was really connected.
28:29 Georgia Hardstark? And it did.
28:30 Karen Kilgariff? Hmm.
28:30 Georgia Hardstark? I know. And they fucking sisters. Like, even when you have nothing in common, like, nothing to do with them, they're gonna be a jerk to you, anyway.
28:38 Karen Kilgariff? Also, that 12-year-old was just sitting there, waiting until the moment that she could make that phone call.
28:43 Georgia Hardstark? Yep.
28:43 Karen Kilgariff? That's so funny. Okay. The subject line of this email is "The Getaway Driver." It just starts, "Now, let's get into it."
28:54 Karen Kilgariff? In the mid 1970s, my grandma was babysitting my brother and sister. I wouldn't be born for another eight or so years. She had also had to get some work done in her car. She and the mechanic agreed on a price and my grandma went to the bank to withdraw the necessary cash. When my grandma, brother and sister went back for the car, the mechanic wanted more money than they had originally agreed. While pretty much everyone knows that this is par for the course with mechanics, they don't know Grandma Jessie. My grandma wasn't just regular Scottish amounts of frugal. She was, quote, "raised on a farm, formative years in the Great Depression and World War II, and had to earn her own money for her own stuff because I guess my grandpa didn't think that raising five kids was job enough level frugal." Jesus. Mm-hmm.
29:37 Karen Kilgariff? She handed the keys to my siblings and told them to go wait in the car. My brother did what he always did when he got into the car at that age, immediately laid down on the backseat and went to sleep. When he woke up, there were sirens. They were being chased by the police. So who was the getaway driver? My grandma. Instead of paying the extra fees, my grandma got into the car and rammed it into the locked gates and took off. No way was a shady mechanic gonna make her granddaughter late to gymnastics. My grandma also did not pull over for cops but drove the 4.5 kilometers, about 2.75 miles, to gymnastics before dealing with the fuzz. Because she sent my brother and sister inside, this story never really had a proper resolution, so I asked my mom to fill in the end.
30:22 Karen Kilgariff? My grandma was never charged, so she probably flirt intimidated the cops. My grandpa settled up with the body shop. Yeah. Thank you for the forum to share this Jessie story. She died October 3rd, 2020, and COVID prevented us from having the kind of funeral where this story would have brought the house down. Proud to do it now. Yeah. Grandma Jessie is a badass. Stay sexy and get away with property damage, April. Oh my god, Grandma's... Legendary Grandma stories always welcome on this show. Panic with purpose. Yes.
30:55 Georgia Hardstark? Yes. What's your panic with purpose story?
30:58 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
30:58 Georgia Hardstark? Do you have one of those, anyone, everyone?
31:00 Karen Kilgariff? Like, for example, when I got caught in a wave in Hawaii and I knew I wasn't coming out of that water. So I was like, I was in a ball.
31:07 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
31:07 Karen Kilgariff? Tumbling in a wave. And I was like, you can't panic.
31:10 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
31:10 Karen Kilgariff? Just hold your breath and hang out. Then I popped up.
31:13 Georgia Hardstark? Fucking anxiety, man. It saved your life.
31:15 Karen Kilgariff? It really does.
31:16 Georgia Hardstark? Send us your panic with purpose stories at myfavoritemurder@gmail.
31:19 Karen Kilgariff? We're just really pushing this panic with purpose.
31:21 Georgia Hardstark? I'm excited about it.
31:23 Karen Kilgariff? Stay sexy.
31:24 Georgia Hardstark? And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie?
31:35 Karen Kilgariff? This has been an Exactly Right Production.
31:37 Georgia Hardstark? Our senior producer is Molly Smith and our associate producer is Tessa Hughes.
31:40 Karen Kilgariff? Our editor is Aristotle Lassaveto.
31:42 Georgia Hardstark? This episode was mixed by Leona Scolacci.
31:44 Karen Kilgariff? Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder@gmail.com.
31:47 Georgia Hardstark? Follow the show on Instagram at myfavoritemurder.
31:50 Karen Kilgariff? Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
31:54 Georgia Hardstark? Or watch us on YouTube. Search for My Favorite Murder and then like and subscribe.
31:58 Karen Kilgariff? Goodbye.
32:06 Speaker 03 When you send a business gift, you're doing more than saying thank you. You're recognizing a moment, expressing appreciation, and making a statement about your brand. With Forimprint, that message lands with certainty. With thousands of customizable products from premium apparel and branded drinkware to smart tech bags and thoughtfully chosen office items, Forimprint helps your brand show up with the kind of care people remember. You can tailor every detail, your logo, your message, your look. And with thousands without a setup fee, it's easy to create meaningful moments without added cost. You'll also get expert support, dependable service, and their 360-degree guarantee, so you can be Forimprint certain
32:48 Speaker 03 your gifts arrive exactly as intended, on time and on brand. Because in a season built around appreciation, the right gift should say it all with confidence, care, and attention to detail. Explore gifting with certainty at forimprint.com.
33:06 Georgia Hardstark? You know a favorite M-word? Magnesium.
33:08 Karen Kilgariff? Like the kind that's in Dr. Teal's magnesium spray.
33:11 Georgia Hardstark? Made from a proprietary blend of topical minerals, it's designed to relax and prepare you for a night of rest.
33:16 Karen Kilgariff? If you need a reset after your day, make Dr. Teal's magnesium spray part of your nighttime routine.
33:21 Georgia Hardstark? Generously spritz each foot before bed and you'll be all set. I've actually started doing this and I'm obsessed with magnesium. It does everything.
33:28 Karen Kilgariff? Something like this is just like, it's simple, it's easy, and it actually works.
33:32 Georgia Hardstark? Totally. For wellness you can feel, find Dr. Teal's magnesium spray online or in your local bath aisle.
33:37 Karen Kilgariff? Goodbye.
33:38 Georgia Hardstark? By now you've heard about Reef's shoes and sandals, but we want to introduce you to their line of women's clogs for fall.
33:44 Karen Kilgariff? These are the kind of shoes you'll keep reaching for because they're genuinely comfortable, but still feel cute and current.
33:49 Georgia Hardstark? A cute, like, flowy dress and a pair of clogs is so timeless.
33:54 Karen Kilgariff? And we got to get some of these clogs. I couldn't believe how cute and comfortable these Reef clogs were. They have the arch support, they have the height, they give you a little bit of height, but they're kind of simple. Check out the clogs on reef.com and redeem 15% off your first purchase.
34:09 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
Previous 515 - 10 Year Anniversary Special! Next Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 80: Live At The Rams Head Live Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated