Pod Insights My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark 516 - End Quote About this episode On today’s episode, Karen covers the murder of Dorothy Donovan and Georgia tells the story of Gwyneth Paltrow’s ski collision trial.
For our sources, please visit https://www.myfavoritemurder.com/episodes.
Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3UFCn1g.
Head to social media to share your favorite moments from this episode.
Instagram: instagram.com/myfavoritemurder http://instagram.com/myfavoritemurder
Facebook: facebook.com/myfavoritemurder http://facebook.com/myfavoritemurder
TikTok: tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder http://tiktok.com/@my_favorite_murder
Send your hometown stories to myfavoritemurder@gmail.com mailto:myfavoritemurder@gmail.com.
Join the Fan Cult to access ad-free episodes of My Favorite Murder. Members also receive merch store discounts, exclusive audio and video content and more! Visit www.fancult.supercast.com http://www.fancult.supercast.com/ to join.
Shop for My Favorite Murder and other Exactly Right merchandise here: www.exactlyrightstore.com http://www.exactlyrightstore.com/.
Rate, review and follow My Favorite Murder on the iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you like to listen.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 14,404 words · 13 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:06 Speaker 00 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
0:34 Speaker 01 In New Orleans, truckers kept getting sideswiped the exact same way. When a man is found murdered under questionable circumstances related to these accidents, the rubber hits the road. And what the feds uncover is a complex scheme of staged wrecks, financial fraud, and a pair of conspiring lovers behind it. This is a story about fake accidents that led to real consequences. Listen to Over My Dead Body: Operation Sideswipe wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
1:10 Karen Kilgariff? Hello. It's Karen and Georgia, here to tell you about our brand-new limited series podcast, Two-Faced: John of God, produced by Exactly Right Media and Adonde Media.
1:21 Georgia Hardstark? The series tells the story of a Brazilian spiritual healer who claimed his so-called miraculous surgeries could cure the incurable, drawing desperate people from around the world.
1:31 Karen Kilgariff? Hosted by award-winning journalist Martina Castro, Two-Faced: John of God investigates how belief, power, and silence allowed this story to go on for decades and the brave survivors who fought to bring it to light.
1:42 Georgia Hardstark? And we're proud to announce that Two-Faced: John of God will be released in both English and Spanish language versions, starting Wednesday, February 4th, with new episodes every Wednesday.
1:52 Karen Kilgariff? You can follow Two-Faced: John of God now on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. And for our Spanish-speaking listeners, Dos Caras: Juan de Dios is available on Espanol in your favorite podcast apps. Adios.
2:24 Georgia Hardstark? Hello.
2:25 Karen Kilgariff? And welcome.
2:26 Georgia Hardstark? To my favorite murder.
2:27 Karen Kilgariff? That's Georgia Hardstark.
2:28 Georgia Hardstark? That's Karen Kilgariff.
2:29 Karen Kilgariff? We like podcasting, do you?
2:31 Georgia Hardstark? Can you hear how much we like it in our voices?
2:34 Karen Kilgariff? These are pro podcasting voices.
2:37 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, how are you, do we do this when the world is such a mess?
2:42 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
2:43 Georgia Hardstark? How do I, you know?
2:44 Karen Kilgariff? It is just the current, also, it's like, the world is a mess. Everything I see on TikTok is horrifying, but I don't want to look away.
2:53 Georgia Hardstark? I know, I can't look, it's driving me, I'm going crazy. I was just laying in bed earlier, just fucking being like, everything's a mess. Now go put on makeup and fucking contour your cheekbones and podcast.
3:03 Karen Kilgariff? But here's the thing, because we got to play in Minnesota before, in Minneapolis, watching what those people are doing and watching how those people are taking it back and being like, these are just thugs and we're going to fucking treat them like thugs. It's so inspiring and it's so like, they're just not, they're not letting up.
3:22 Georgia Hardstark? And they're not letting fear hold them down.
3:24 Karen Kilgariff? No, they're, it's just very empowering for everybody else to be seen. I hope they know that.
3:30 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
3:31 Karen Kilgariff? And it's just insanity.
3:34 Georgia Hardstark? Fuck ICE, what are we doing? What is fucking happening?
3:37 Karen Kilgariff? It's clearly fuck ICE.
3:39 Georgia Hardstark? What is fucking happening? It's the fucking Gestapo.
3:42 Karen Kilgariff? And it's the Gestapo and they're attacking people who are intrinsic to this nation in every way. And not just like, people always talk about the work. It's like, these are people who were here first?
3:54 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
3:55 Karen Kilgariff? Fucking, how about that?
3:56 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
3:56 Karen Kilgariff? Here first and then basically built up, like, they were talking about, there was some story out of Minneapolis, ICE agents eating dinner in a Mexican restaurant and then arresting the workers.
4:08 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my God.
4:08 Karen Kilgariff? Where it's like, well, then there is no line then.
4:11 Georgia Hardstark? No, there is none.
4:12 Karen Kilgariff? That there's no line, these people are berserking and they have to be treated as such.
4:16 Georgia Hardstark? It's fucking terrifying and I'm a white woman, I'm not saying that I'm terrified for my, it's terrifying that this is happening to everyone, to other people, and I'm fucking so horrified by it. Also, it's, if you hate- People who are trying to make their families' lives better by coming to this country. Like, where, what's wrong with, where's your empathy? That's, they're not.
4:39 Karen Kilgariff? What's wrong with you?
4:40 Georgia Hardstark? What's wrong with you? I, I'm so, I'm so disgusted.
4:43 Karen Kilgariff? Also, I, I saw a thing where there's all this trickery in those ICE contracts. So they think they're getting paid all this money, but if they quit, they have to pay it back.
4:53 Georgia Hardstark? Wow.
4:54 Karen Kilgariff? And there's all, like, there's all these stipulations in there where it's like, of course, you're getting, this is a contract with Donald Trump. This man does not pay people. This is not a person who has ever historically.
5:04 Georgia Hardstark? Kept his word. This is a fucking liar and a monster and a megalomaniac.
5:09 Karen Kilgariff? And a criminal.
5:10 Georgia Hardstark? Dictator, pedophile, like, what?
5:12 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, God.
5:13 Georgia Hardstark? Anyways, this is our first episode on Netflix.
5:15 Karen Kilgariff? Guy.
5:16 Georgia Hardstark? Are we allowed?
5:18 Karen Kilgariff? So, are we allowed?
5:20 Georgia Hardstark? This is unprecedented fucking times.
5:22 Karen Kilgariff? No, it's, no, I'm glad you said it. And I feel like we've been saying it all the way along.
5:27 Georgia Hardstark? We haven't, yeah. I, I just want to say it before, because my fucking story is so trivial and like, that I'm going to tell you today and so fucking unimportant in the scheme of things that I feel.
5:39 Karen Kilgariff? Did you see the Golden Globes? Like, no one said a word.
5:41 Georgia Hardstark? I know. Did you see Mark Ruffalo on the red carpet? He's had some shit, thank you.
5:44 Karen Kilgariff? And Londa Sykes.
5:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, of course. Like.
5:47 Karen Kilgariff? Fuck.
5:47 Georgia Hardstark? I know. We can't not say anything.
5:49 Karen Kilgariff? The fact that it's escalating.
5:51 Georgia Hardstark? Exactly. Exactly.
5:53 Karen Kilgariff? Well, listen, here's what I am very inspired by. Because as I am addicted to TikTok, I can see what the children are doing and saying. And high schools are walking out and joining those protests in Minneapolis, like, or joining the people who are like, right on the front line, where those.
6:10 Georgia Hardstark? Risking their lives.
6:11 Karen Kilgariff? Yes, and also.
6:12 Georgia Hardstark? For other people, you know?
6:13 Karen Kilgariff? And harassing, I saw a woman who was just harassing people in San Diego who went in to submit for the job. And she was just like, it was like a comedy roast. She was just saying awful shit to them as they were walking away. And it is like the most satisfying, because she's like, what are you doing?
6:31 Georgia Hardstark? What kind of person is like, yeah, that's what I want to do? Someone who shouldn't have any authority.
6:37 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah. What if we change the subject to something so insane and different from it that it'll just feel like we're gonna break the bone here?
6:45 Georgia Hardstark? I've got it.
6:46 Karen Kilgariff? And be topical.
6:47 Georgia Hardstark? Heated rivalry. I've got it. We have, we are on the pulse of the fucking TikTok generation.
6:54 Karen Kilgariff? We're on the pulse of the distraction generation where horrors rise up in front of us on a daily basis.
7:00 Georgia Hardstark? And you have to go on with your day.
7:02 Karen Kilgariff? And you go like, yes, yes. Where do we send our money? What do we do? How do we help? And then also, get this off me, please rinse my eyes. This is horrifying. Heated rivalry.
7:11 Georgia Hardstark? I love it. It's so sexy and, oh my god, it's everything. And it took me a minute to like get into the first episode. It took me like three times to watch it because I kept getting these like funny memes about it that made me want to keep watching it. I'm so glad I stuck with it.
7:27 Karen Kilgariff? That sounds kind of like a boy's excuse of like, I had to re-watch that sex scene over and over because I just, I don't know, I wasn't into it.
7:34 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Well, I didn't know I was into that, honestly. I know my friends are, my girlfriends are like, that's, they're fucking into that. And I didn't know I was until I watched this fucking show. And then I'm like, well.
7:44 Karen Kilgariff? Kind of undeniable.
7:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. And where's my porn now?
7:49 Karen Kilgariff? I'm just so, to watch it kind of unfold on social media, and it's my friend Jacob Tierney, who I've talked about on this podcast all the time. And it's like, his baby.
7:59 Georgia Hardstark? What a success.
8:01 Karen Kilgariff? There was a guy that was filming like the final episode and, did I say this already? He was standing on Santa Monica and all four bars were playing it and the bars were packed and there was people like spilling outside and he just was like going like this.
8:13 Georgia Hardstark? In West Hollywood?
8:14 Karen Kilgariff? Yep. I was just like, oh my, oh my god, look. Look at what he made.
8:18 Georgia Hardstark? It's just so incredible.
8:20 Karen Kilgariff? And he's so deserving. He's so smart and talented and so hilarious and it's great.
8:25 Georgia Hardstark? And then what's his name? Connor? Connor Story?
8:27 Karen Kilgariff? Connor Story.
8:28 Georgia Hardstark? God, damn it. He's, he's not even Russian.
8:32 Karen Kilgariff? No.
8:32 Georgia Hardstark? I didn't know these things when I started watching. I didn't know who it was and now I know everything about him.
8:36 Karen Kilgariff? Yep.
8:37 Georgia Hardstark? What a fucking cutie pie. Please come do a podcast at Exactly Right Media so we can just have you in the office every day.
8:45 Karen Kilgariff? Can you imagine what that guy's life is like right now? Where just everyone, girls, boys, whoever are just like, I want to sleep with you right now.
8:53 Georgia Hardstark? And that ass is fucking Mothman level.
8:57 Georgia Hardstark? Mothman statue level.
8:59 Karen Kilgariff? Yep.
8:59 Georgia Hardstark? Cakes. Oh, my God, I'm like.
9:01 Karen Kilgariff? Cakes.
9:01 Georgia Hardstark? I'm blushing and I'm objectifying someone and I feel.
9:04 Karen Kilgariff? Georgia, you're a perv.
9:05 Georgia Hardstark? I feel bad about it.
9:06 Karen Kilgariff? No, it's really fun. I think it's the kind of, you know, it's as things get nightmarish, then there's just like a little bit of.
9:13 Georgia Hardstark? It's a distraction.
9:14 Karen Kilgariff? It's visual opiates to get away.
9:17 Georgia Hardstark? Definitely.
9:17 Karen Kilgariff? But then emotional, like actually really deep.
9:20 Georgia Hardstark? The like love scene, not them, but this other love scene is so fucking beautiful and lovely.
9:27 Karen Kilgariff? And I. I have to be honest right now.
9:29 Georgia Hardstark? I know.
9:30 Karen Kilgariff? I haven't seen.
9:30 Georgia Hardstark? I know, that's why I'm excited for you.
9:32 Karen Kilgariff? Liar, but because I'm like sitting here like, and it's great.
9:35 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
9:35 Karen Kilgariff? But I was at my dad's house.
9:37 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, yeah. Good luck watching it with your dad.
9:40 Karen Kilgariff? Do you want to try this?
9:41 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, oh, my God.
9:43 Karen Kilgariff? Can you imagine?
9:44 Georgia Hardstark? No.
9:44 Karen Kilgariff? My dad who gets up and slams the newspaper down when like a sex scene starts, like that's the only way he's ever reacted my entire life. Where if you're watching a movie, he's like, good night.
9:54 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, you're like, can't.
9:55 Karen Kilgariff? I didn't fucking make this movie.
9:58 Karen Kilgariff? But that and then, you know, it's just like, I want to sit down and binge the entire thing.
10:02 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
10:03 Karen Kilgariff? But I have to do it because I'm going to see it really soon.
10:05 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, you got to.
10:05 Karen Kilgariff? And my faking of like, yeah.
10:07 Georgia Hardstark? It's great.
10:08 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
10:08 Georgia Hardstark? I mean, you know, it is.
10:09 Karen Kilgariff? He's the smartest person and the funniest person, but also he started as a child actor when he was like seven years old.
10:15 Georgia Hardstark? What was it? Did he write?
10:16 Karen Kilgariff? Letter Kenny.
10:16 Georgia Hardstark? Letter Kenny. Okay.
10:17 Karen Kilgariff? And Shorzy.
10:18 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
10:19 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
10:19 Georgia Hardstark? So that's.
10:20 Karen Kilgariff? He wrote and directed.
10:21 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
10:22 Karen Kilgariff? Letter Kenny and directed Shorzy and I think co-wrote it.
10:25 Georgia Hardstark? Mm hmm.
10:26 Karen Kilgariff? But then I think he did Rivalry is all his. So and I remember.
10:29 Georgia Hardstark? His name is like on and I'm like, I know that name.
10:31 Karen Kilgariff? Created by. He read the, he's like, I don't know, there's these smutty hockey books and I think I'm going to try to option. And that was like, of course, two years ago or something like that. I know.
10:41 Georgia Hardstark? Incredible.
10:41 Karen Kilgariff? It's very, very exciting.
10:43 Georgia Hardstark? Yes. We contain multitudes here. The justification of the juxtaposition.
10:49 Georgia Hardstark? My favorite murder on this podcast.
10:51 Karen Kilgariff? I mean.
10:52 Georgia Hardstark? Is heated.
10:53 Karen Kilgariff? This is the world everyone's in right now.
10:55 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
10:56 Karen Kilgariff? Just like, here's the TV I love.
10:58 Georgia Hardstark? Here's the.
10:59 Karen Kilgariff? Tears streaming down their face.
11:00 Georgia Hardstark? It's the end of the world. Here's some cute thing.
11:02 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
11:03 Georgia Hardstark? Here's a cat meme.
11:04 Karen Kilgariff? Can I just carve out one second to make a joke? Cause I know anytime I do this, people like yell at me and then compliment me.
11:10 Georgia Hardstark? Are you talking about our beautiful fucking article in the Hollywood Reporter, written by journalist Mikey O'Connell? It was so cool.
11:17 Karen Kilgariff? Well, it's amazing if a journalist that's talking to us also listens. Cause then they're kind of like, I remember when a thing happened.
11:24 Georgia Hardstark? Insider baseball.
11:25 Karen Kilgariff? What's your version of it? We're like, yes, finally.
11:28 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, yeah.
11:28 Karen Kilgariff? It was very nice. My joke that I want to say without anybody telling me anything.
11:33 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
11:33 Karen Kilgariff? Is that in that first picture, it looks like I'm doing an impression of Peter Falk. I don't understand why I can't just take a picture and smile. It is, I'm, I've been traumatized. It's like.
11:43 Georgia Hardstark? You are not.
11:46 Karen Kilgariff? And it's like.
11:46 Georgia Hardstark? See, you.
11:47 Karen Kilgariff? I've been traumatized by show business.
11:49 Georgia Hardstark? All I saw, can I tell you what I saw? And I was like, these beautiful photos with great lighting and great makeup. And I was like, my hands look old. Like, it's just, we just do that, you know?
11:58 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, you're right.
11:58 Georgia Hardstark? We just go to that immediately.
12:00 Karen Kilgariff? I know. It's like you have to, it's like, what is the next problem I'm gonna solve?
12:04 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
12:04 Karen Kilgariff? But I don't know. It's like, I, it's like I'm holding an invisible cigar in my mouth.
12:09 Georgia Hardstark? I don't, I didn't see it.
12:10 Karen Kilgariff? Listen.
12:11 Georgia Hardstark? Listen, look and listen at how complicated life can be.
12:14 Karen Kilgariff? Look at how superficial we absolutely are in the face of everything else that we are also holding.
12:21 Georgia Hardstark? And how lucky we are. And you guys have been so incredible on our 10 year anniversary week. Thank you for all the love and the beautiful comments and just so much.
12:29 Karen Kilgariff? So nice.
12:30 Georgia Hardstark? So much love.
12:31 Karen Kilgariff? So nice. I also didn't mean to be so sneaky sliding that topic in, but it's, it feels like when it rains, it pours. And for us, we have been so lucky.
12:39 Georgia Hardstark? Oh my God.
12:40 Karen Kilgariff? From like tour on, things have just been so lovely. And I feel like humbled and grateful that they keep showing up for us.
12:48 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, we know how fucking lucky we are.
12:54 Karen Kilgariff? It's my new thing.
12:54 Georgia Hardstark? Maybe you should smoke a cigar. Maybe that's your new look.
12:57 Karen Kilgariff? I think so.
12:57 Georgia Hardstark? That's kinda hot.
12:58 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, I have a, I'm getting that kinda Russian masseuse vibe going. So I think a cigar is really the only, the only option.
13:07 Georgia Hardstark? All right. Well, so we do some Exactly Right Media. Should we do some business? Because, listen, we still have to run this company.
13:13 Karen Kilgariff? We absolutely do.
13:14 Georgia Hardstark? We have a podcast network called Exactly Right Media. And here's some business highlights.
13:19 Karen Kilgariff? Over on Dear Movies, I love you. Millie and Casey are feeling the heat as they revisit the 1998 classic, How Stella Got Her Groove Back.
13:26 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
13:27 Karen Kilgariff? Plus, screenwriter Chris Thomas Devlin joins them to talk about his area of expertise.
13:32 Georgia Hardstark? And then over on I Said No Gifts, Bridger does his best not to make it a thing when Corn Wells forces a gift on him anyway. Brings him a gift. He said no gifts. They brought him a gift.
13:42 Karen Kilgariff? They insist.
13:43 Georgia Hardstark? They get into Toni Braxton's family using hinge dates as tour guides and whether rabbits are an underrated protein source. No.
13:51 Karen Kilgariff? You've got to listen. And the trailer's out now for our newest podcast, Two-Faced: John of God. And it's our first dual-language podcast. So it will be available, of course, in English and now in Spanish. The Spanish feed is called Dos Cadas Wanda Dios. And it premieres February 4th. Follow everywhere you get your podcasts.
14:11 Georgia Hardstark? You're so proud of this. You've done so much work on this.
14:14 Karen Kilgariff? It's so exciting.
14:15 Georgia Hardstark? This has been in the works for so long. It's very exciting.
14:17 Karen Kilgariff? It has. And Adante Media, the company that we're doing it with, Martina Castro is the journalist that, that's her company. She's the loveliest person. She's gonna be on the podcast so we can talk to her about it in person, obviously. But as a company, they have just been the coolest. They're so good at what they do and they're so fun and collaborative.
14:36 Georgia Hardstark? I can't wait for the world to hear it.
14:38 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, it's great.
14:39 Georgia Hardstark? And then, as we said, My Favorite Murder is officially heading to Netflix. So on January 26th, six back catalog episodes will be up on the My Favorite Murder Netflix channel. Check it out. Followed by the first brand-new full episode on January 28th. And the first new minisode, I'm drawing a lot of dates at everyone. The first new minisode is on January 30th. They're all streaming exclusively on Netflix.
15:06 Karen Kilgariff? Exclusively on Netflix, where they now show a video podcast. Here's what I love about this. Every other episode, it's just gonna go like our normal thing. So it's a full episode and then minisodes, full episode, minisodes. I love the idea that people get to, like, a really broad group of people could get to try out the little taster of minisodes. I think people are gonna really like minisodes.
15:27 Georgia Hardstark? And I think that means we're gonna get a lot more great emails sent in of minisodes. Like, it's just gonna ramp up the, like,
15:33 Karen Kilgariff? You know what it means?
15:34 Georgia Hardstark? Stories after stories.
15:35 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, we're gonna need a mailroom. Okay, over in merch corner, Nicole is here to remind us that our 2025 tour merch is now available in the Exactly Right store. Go grab your tour hats and totes and all the apparel from our live shows.
15:48 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, at where?
15:50 Karen Kilgariff? Over on exactlyrightstore.com. Quantities are limited, so please rush and push other people out of the way.
15:58 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, and we have a quick merch show-off thing. You have these fucking adorable pins.
16:03 Karen Kilgariff? Everybody loves these pins. Oh, wait, and they are, you know what they are?
16:07 Georgia Hardstark? What are they?
16:08 Karen Kilgariff? They are magnets.
16:10 Georgia Hardstark? Magnets! How do they even work? And then you get a cute little case to put your joints in, too.
16:14 Karen Kilgariff? Magnets.
16:14 Georgia Hardstark? Okay, magnets.
16:15 Karen Kilgariff? Wait, what are we doing?
16:16 Georgia Hardstark? We've got magnets.
16:17 Karen Kilgariff? Magnets.
16:18 Georgia Hardstark? Magnets. A fuck politeness koozie here, that's so cute. My girly pink.
16:24 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, yeah.
16:25 Georgia Hardstark? But I, I always get, like, it's either black or pink, and each of us get, like, because Karen wants all black stuff. I want all pink stuff. Gray is the, like, common denominator one, I think, right?
16:36 Karen Kilgariff? Especially with their nice, with a nice red flag.
16:38 Georgia Hardstark? That's right, so the MFM flag, red flag looks amazing, and I have this pink fuck politeness, definitely getting one for Vince.
16:45 Karen Kilgariff? Say that.
16:46 Georgia Hardstark? Because he is comfortable in his masculinity and will wear pink.
16:49 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, yeah.
16:49 Georgia Hardstark? He's not a fucking toxic male.
16:51 Karen Kilgariff? He's a real close horse, you know? He loves, he has real style.
16:56 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
16:56 Karen Kilgariff? He does. Him and his, um,
16:58 Georgia Hardstark? Wife?
16:59 Karen Kilgariff? Penguinship. You wanna get in on that?
17:01 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, anyway.
17:02 Karen Kilgariff? Okay.
17:03 Georgia Hardstark? Merch. Business is over.
17:05 Karen Kilgariff? Capitalism will save us all.
17:07 Georgia Hardstark? That's the other thing, is like, can I stop consuming in 2026? I'm just not, I don't need any more of it. I don't need any more organizational fucking things and fucking plastic bullshit and fucking things that are gonna fix my life.
17:20 Karen Kilgariff? I gotta tell you, I'm very much on that track with you. I was gonna buy this little two-level shelf to put coffee mugs on.
17:27 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
17:28 Karen Kilgariff? And I was like, what am I?
17:30 Georgia Hardstark? They can just go on the surface.
17:31 Karen Kilgariff? I don't need this. Stop it. I have to like pare it all the way back to lip balms and lip liners.
17:37 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, yeah.
17:38 Karen Kilgariff? Because it's like, it's just a little something new every once in a while. But like, the mass consumption is not working for me.
17:44 Georgia Hardstark? No. Things aren't gonna fix your life. Cats and dogs are.
17:47 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, that's really true.
17:49 Georgia Hardstark? Do that.
17:49 Karen Kilgariff? Take them outside.
17:50 Georgia Hardstark? Foster them.
17:51 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
17:52 Georgia Hardstark? So you don't have to commit, because we know you are a commitment phobe. That's totally fine.
17:56 Karen Kilgariff? Cut to me with the 10 dogs in a room. Like, what?
18:00 Georgia Hardstark? Adoption fail on all of them. Uh-oh. Okay, stop it. Okay, this is the, all right, here we go. I'm just, I'm thinking of people watching this on Netflix for the first time, not knowing what this podcast is, and just being so fucking confused.
18:13 Karen Kilgariff? Click away now while you can.
18:14 Georgia Hardstark? This is like, this is pretty much what it's like.
18:17 Karen Kilgariff? Actually, but here's also what it's like.
18:19 Georgia Hardstark? Okay.
18:19 Karen Kilgariff? On episode 402, entitled "Staunch Women," I covered the story of civil rights pioneer Claudette Colvin. She was basically the first Rosa Parks. She did it when she was 15 years old. She would not get up when some white person demanded her seat on an Alabama bus. And she died on January 13th of natural causes. She was 86 years old.
18:43 Georgia Hardstark? Wow.
18:43 Karen Kilgariff? And her namesake foundation released this statement saying, quote, "It is with profound sadness that the Claudette Colvin Foundation and family announce the passing of Claudette Colvin, a beloved mother, grandmother, and civil rights pioneer. She leaves behind a legacy of courage that helped change the course of American history."
19:00 Georgia Hardstark? Incredible.
19:02 Karen Kilgariff? So sad.
19:02 Georgia Hardstark? What a, what a legacy.
19:04 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, and someone to read about and study. Listen to this episode and, and learn how to resist.
19:11 Speaker 04 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
19:40 Georgia Hardstark? There are plenty of things that keep you up at night. Your sleep tracker shouldn't be one of them.
19:44 Karen Kilgariff? You know that feeling, laying in bed, staring at the ceiling, counting all the times you said something weird.
19:49 Georgia Hardstark? And then you wake up and check your sleep score. Now you have to start your day knowing that you failed at sleeping.
19:55 Karen Kilgariff? Hatch Sleep Clock does it differently.
19:57 Georgia Hardstark? It tracks your sleep from your nightstand. No ring, wristband, or judgmental score waiting for you in the morning.
20:03 Karen Kilgariff? Instead, you'll get personalized insights to understand your sleep and recommendations to build a routine you'll love night after night.
20:09 Georgia Hardstark? Fall asleep to the next chapter of an audiobook like The Odyssey, a nervous system reset meditation, or a calming sound bath.
20:16 Karen Kilgariff? Then you can find out which gives you 20 more minutes of deep sleep each night.
20:20 Georgia Hardstark? Hatch Sleep Clock.
20:21 Karen Kilgariff? The sleep tracker designed to get you to sleep. Available now on hatch.co.
20:25 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
20:27 Karen Kilgariff? This podcast is brought to you by Squarespace. Turning something you love into a career is exciting. Then come the invoices. Lucky for you, Squarespace can handle the business stuff so you can focus on your business. From consultations to events and experiences, you can showcase your skills with a customizable website designed to attract clients and grow your business. With Squarespace's collection of cutting-edge design tools, anyone can build a beautiful, professional, online presence that perfectly fits their brand or business. Get paid on time with professional invoices and online payments. Plus, streamline your workflow with built-in appointment scheduling and email marketing tools. Head to squarespace.com/murder for a free trial.
21:08 Karen Kilgariff? And when you're ready to launch, use offer code MURDER to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Goodbye.
21:17 Karen Kilgariff? I'm very excited about this story because it is truly a classic true crime case. And it's also a classic forensic files. So you and I probably have seen it recently because when we were on the road, there were some classic forensic files that I was watching.
21:32 Georgia Hardstark? It's crazy to me that people bring their computers and watch movies in hotel rooms. Like you have forensic files on 24/7. What are you doing?
21:39 Karen Kilgariff? From 9pm on. Like it's a lock.
21:42 Georgia Hardstark? Order those chicken strips and a Caesar salad and fucking.
21:46 Karen Kilgariff? Cookies.
21:47 Georgia Hardstark? Cookies, go.
21:47 Karen Kilgariff? Okay. This story begins in Kent County, Delaware, which is in the Dover metro area. We rarely talk about Delaware.
21:54 Georgia Hardstark? No, we don't really do that, do we?
21:56 Karen Kilgariff? And we've never gone.
21:57 Georgia Hardstark? No, I dated someone from there and.
21:59 Karen Kilgariff? You're still mad about it?
22:00 Georgia Hardstark? Scrapple. That's all I know about it.
22:01 Karen Kilgariff? Scrapple. That was his name?
22:07 Georgia Hardstark? Delaware.
22:08 Karen Kilgariff? Hey Delaware. Okay, it's near the town of Harrington. Okay, so this is the night of June 23rd, 1991.
22:15 Georgia Hardstark? Okay.
22:15 Karen Kilgariff? You're 11.
22:16 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my God, I am.
22:17 Karen Kilgariff? Uh huh. It's around midnight. A 41-year-old man named Charles Holden pulls up to his trailer after finishing his shift at a factory job, and he sees a man lurking nearby. He drives to a payphone. So this is back in the time of payphones.
22:31 Georgia Hardstark? Sure.
22:31 Karen Kilgariff? Before cell phones. So weird.
22:33 Georgia Hardstark? Who?
22:34 Karen Kilgariff? I know. So he calls 911. He tells the dispatcher, there's a guy lurking.
22:37 Georgia Hardstark? Just lurking?
22:38 Karen Kilgariff? Lurking outside my house.
22:39 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, okay, got it, got it.
22:40 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, exactly. And then he asks for a police escort home. So he's really freaked out. When the dispatcher asks Charles if he's aware of anyone else being on the property, he tells them his 70-year-old mother, Dorothy Donovan, lives in the farmhouse that his trailer is next to. So it's like his family property. Charles is certain this person that he saw outside was not his mother. He specifically tells the dispatcher, quote, "I want to get someone there as soon as I can because I don't want him breaking into my mother's." So he's scared.
23:10 Georgia Hardstark? Okay.
23:11 Karen Kilgariff? The police are dispatched to the property, and what they find inside the farmhouse is an absolute nightmare.
23:18 Karen Kilgariff? Dorothy Donovan has been murdered and as Detective Captain Greg Nolt will later remember, quote, "It was a very bloody and brutal crime scene, blood everywhere, blood spatters throughout the bedroom." Jesus. From that night, when the investigation begins, this case will sprawl out over several years and take some unbelievable twists and turns as police try to piece together what happened to this woman on that night in early summer in Harrington, Delaware. This is the story of the hunt for Dorothy Donovan's killer. Wow. And the main source used for the story today is the 2008 episode of Forensic Files entitled Stranger in the Night, along with several articles that ran in the Delaware-based news journal newspaper, and the rest of the sources are in our show notes.
24:00 Karen Kilgariff? Okay, so when investigators inspect Dorothy's farmhouse that night, they find the backdoor window has been shattered, so the presumption is the murderer broke in by reaching through that broken glass and unlocking the door from the inside. And one of the reasons they think that is because there's blood smeared around the scene, and forensic analysts conclude that that blood does not belong to Dorothy. Investigators also find several fingerprints and a partial palm print that are not hers. Police run through potential motives. They don't think it's a botched robbery because nothing's missing from the house. Dorothy's purse is like right there. There's the possibility that it's a sexually motivated attack since Dorothy's body was
24:43 Karen Kilgariff? discovered in her bedroom, positioned in a way that leads investigators to consider this possibility. But really, the sheer brutality of this crime, with Dorothy having been stabbed more than two dozen times. Oh, my God. All about her face and chest is indicative of overkill, which suggests that this is a very personal and a very angry attack. An FBI profiler quoted by the news journal newspaper goes so far as to say, quote, "Some stranger did not break into the house, murder her, and leave. This is someone who knows the victim, knows her well, and knows that they can come here and that she will be the only victim in the house." Wow. End quote. Okay. We have to start saying "end quote" because we're on that plane. Oh, shit. Are we journalists now?
25:28 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah. At least we have to say "end quote." No, I don't like it. Really? No. You want to keep it loose and open? Yeah, you can tell by the tone of voice. Well, that's really true. I don't like "end quote." Write in if you think this whole thing has been a long quote since 2016. Because I never say unquote.
25:44 Georgia Hardstark? I don't either. I don't want to.
25:45 Karen Kilgariff? Okay.
25:45 Georgia Hardstark? The end.
25:46 Karen Kilgariff? The end. So, hearing this by an FBI profiler is very confusing to Dorothy's family because they're adamant, this woman has no enemies. She lived a quiet life in her farmhouse after losing her husband a few years before, and she's a beloved mom of three and a grandmother to seven. She does not have enemies. So, the motive's unclear, but one person who is being looked at very closely is Dorothy's son, Charles, who made the 911 call. It's said that when Charles first sees his mother's body, he says, quote, "I can't believe he killed her. I can't believe he killed her." Yeah. So, the investigators, it piques their interest because it's very specific. When they ask Charles who he is, he tells them
26:29 Karen Kilgariff? he actually recognized the man he saw lurking on the property that night. He says he doesn't actually know him by name, but he claims that they'd had a chance encounter earlier the same evening. So, he explains that after he clocked out from his 4 to 11 p.m. shift at the factory job that day, he decides to stop at Hardee's to pick up some dinner. Now, let's just take a break for a second so I can explain that Hardee's is the Midwest Carl's Jr.
26:55 Georgia Hardstark? You know how recently I ate the Midwest Carl's Jr.?
26:59 Karen Kilgariff? How recently?
27:00 Georgia Hardstark? Two nights ago.
27:00 Karen Kilgariff? What? Did you travel?
27:03 Georgia Hardstark? I'm depressed.
27:04 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
27:06 Georgia Hardstark? You know, I have depression.
27:08 Karen Kilgariff? I see.
27:08 Georgia Hardstark? You know.
27:09 Karen Kilgariff? I mean, I'm sorry. Fast food gets it done for me.
27:12 Georgia Hardstark? Carl's Jr. is on another level for me. Like, it's a different.
27:16 Karen Kilgariff? What do you get?
27:17 Georgia Hardstark? A fucking Western bacon cheeseburger since I was a child. The skinny little girl pounding a fucking Western bacon cheeseburger and onion rings like nobody's business.
27:25 Karen Kilgariff? So, you get onion rings on the side even though there's onion rings on that burger?
27:29 Georgia Hardstark? Uh huh.
27:29 Karen Kilgariff? What kind of rebel are you?
27:32 Georgia Hardstark? A depressed one.
27:33 Karen Kilgariff? A depressed one with depression? It works, though. Like, first of all, what a great idea. Onion rings and barbecue sauce, amazing. Those milkshakes?
27:43 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, no.
27:44 Karen Kilgariff? Have you?
27:44 Georgia Hardstark? No, I can't.
27:45 Karen Kilgariff? Do you dare?
27:46 Georgia Hardstark? No.
27:46 Karen Kilgariff? Get in there. It could cure your depression.
27:48 Georgia Hardstark? I'm the one who's like, won't even have a soda. You know what I mean? Like, I'm just here for the food. Like, I don't want an unhealthy soda.
27:56 Karen Kilgariff? Did I tell you the story of the time I was in the Wendy's drive thru on Vermont? And the guy was, I ordered my thing and I was like, uh, whatever cheeseburger and large fries and a medium uh, diet. And he was like, why don't you just get the regular? And I literally let it hang for like five seconds. I was like, are you fucking kidding me dude? And he was like, oh, sorry. Yep. Your total is nine dollars. You didn't go for the? Sure. Look, look at me right now, though. What am I fucking talking about? I'm literally drinking a fucking full.
28:22 Karen Kilgariff? Here's the thing, whether it's this, this is filled with beet juice. Go fuck yourself. We all get to do whatever we want. Yeah. I have a fucking full fat Coca-Cola right now. Got to. And I'm enjoying it. Whatever you want. Whatever you want to get you through. Full permission to our listenership, get yourself through. Yeah. Fight, fight, fight. Go, go, go. And we're back. So he stops at Hardee's, the Midwest Carl's Jr. To get his food, goes inside. But then when he comes back out, he's crossing the parking lot and he is intercepted by a hitchhiker. So that's so weird. Should I always pronounce it that way? Charles describes him as a black man in his 30s with oversized glasses, standing around five foot nine, wearing a plaid shirt and brown dress pants.
29:08 Karen Kilgariff? He claims that this man asked him for a ride to Georgetown, Delaware, which is like 25 miles away. And Charles told him he wasn't gonna drive all that way, but that he would take him down the road a few miles in the direction he was going, if that would help him. And according to Charles, the hitchhiker took him up on this offer. When Charles is about half a mile from his own home, he tells the hitchhiker, it's time for him to get out of the truck. But instead of getting out, Charles says this man's mood abruptly changes. He becomes irate and starts attacking Charles, demanding that he drive him all the way to Georgetown. Charles tells investigators, he jumped out of the truck. He starts running away from the hitchhiker, who's now chasing him with a screwdriver that he took off the floor of Charles' truck.
29:52 Karen Kilgariff? And now he's threatening to kill Charles if he doesn't keep driving him all the way to Georgetown. So Charles says, he tells the guy, okay, fine, I will do it. I'll drive you there. He calms him down a little bit. They both start walking back to the truck. And then Charles does the classic move where he just takes off running, jumps into the truck and takes off.
30:10 Georgia Hardstark? Jesus.
30:11 Karen Kilgariff? And it works. So he basically leaves this like violent hitchhiker standing in the middle of the street with a screwdriver in his hand. So Charles says he's terrified that this man is going to follow the direction of the truck on foot, since it's only like a half a mile away from where he lives. And that if he sees Charles's truck on the property, he's going to be like, I'm going to go there. That's where he is. So Charles drives around for 20 minutes before he loops back and heads to the property. But when he pulls into the driveway, he sees the hitchhiker lurking. And that's when he drives away, sees a payphone and makes the call to 911. So the detectives hear this story out from Charles, but once he's done, they waste no time telling him that they don't believe a single word of it.
30:54 Karen Kilgariff? It's so many coincidences. It's very rambling and random. And one of the officers actually tells Charles, quote, "Only an idiot would believe that story," unquote. And it does sound unlikely, especially when you consider this hitchhiker would have walked half a mile to Charles's house, passing several other homes along the way, breaking in and brutally murdering a defenseless woman sleeping inside. But he, the truck isn't there. He wouldn't know it was the man who he got into this fight with his mother. And then it's like, what is that all supposed to be a coincidence?
31:26 Georgia Hardstark? And then also like this fight he got into would explain why there's like scratches and stuff like that. How convenient.
31:32 Karen Kilgariff? Yep. And of course, there have been tens of thousands of crimes reported in this country where white people blame black people, a black man for the crime. And they're lying. So they basically say, we don't buy it. Charles holds firm. He's adamant he's telling the truth. When investigators remain suspicious, they tell Charles, take a polygraph test, and Charles says no. So that's not really surprising in this day and age because at this point, as we've talked about a lot, we know that polygraphs aren't very reliable. But this is 1991. Yeah. Where it's kind of- Suspicious if you don't. If you say no, it's suspicious. Everybody's like, this is a lock, just like blood spatter. What are you, what's the problem? Totally. So from here, police have to continue building the case.
32:17 Karen Kilgariff? They create a composite sketch of Charles's purported hitchhiker based on his description. They put it out to the public. And actually, if you look through old newspaper articles about Dorothy Donovan's murder, you can see this composite sketch. It doesn't seem to have generated many leads. Meanwhile, the medical examiner's report comes back with more details about Dorothy's murder. It's based on the physical evidence that's being processed at the crime scene, but these findings only bring more questions. For example, the medical examiner is unable to find any evidence confirming sexual assault. So the sexual angle is gotten rid of as a motive. And actually, they start to think that maybe her body was like posed in that slightly suggestive
33:00 Karen Kilgariff? way to throw police off and lead them down that path. Then, and it's still early in the investigation, police get bombshell information. They learn that not long before Dorothy's death, she's taken out an accidental death insurance policy. Uh oh. And the beneficiary is her son, Charles. So then the detectives find out Charles is in debt. Who isn't? Right. Although we don't know how much, but it does point to financial motivation. The police continue circling Charles as a suspect, but the tests show that his blood is not a match for the blood that was left at the scene. And the palm prints are clearly not a match. The police consider the theory now that Charles could have hired somebody else to commit the murder. Right.
33:44 Karen Kilgariff? And then just go in for a cut of that life insurance payout. But the police don't have enough to arrest him, so they try to find out if there's anything about his hitchhiker story that is real. If this person actually exists, he could either be the murderer or he could be Charles's accomplice. So maybe the hitchhiker story is Charles' way of covering for himself if anyone saw him and that man together that night. Oh, yeah. Okay. So detectives take that composite sketch of the man. They track down several people who were at Hardee's the night of Dorothy's murder, and they are able to confirm a huge piece of the story, which is that there was in fact a man in the parking lot that night approaching people and asking for a ride. Okay. And he looks like the guy in the composite sketch.
34:27 Karen Kilgariff? Investigators compile photos of men with criminal records who resemble this hitchhiker, down to the oversized glasses. And every person in this photo lineup is wearing glasses, so when Charles has shown the pictures, he picks out the one that he believes was the hitchhiker. Police also showed these photos to other witnesses, and three of them identify that same man that Charles does. He's a 33-year-old black man living in Harrington, miles from the murder scene. He has a criminal record, but he has never committed a violent crime. He's been convicted of forgery and petty theft, but now, given the multiple positive identifications, police think they might have their man. But when the officers show up to this man's house to question him, they immediately know
35:08 Karen Kilgariff? that he couldn't be Dorothy's killer, because it's only a week after the murder. This man opens the door, and he has a full beard. Huh. So not a single witness mentioned anything about this hitchhiker having a beard. Yeah. It's improbable this man could have grown one in a matter of days, so he is off the list. Okay. And then, when they run his prints, the man's palm prints are not a match. On top of all of that, he has an alibi that completely checks out. So, few for that guy not actually, you know, being wrongfully arrested and committed to jail. They've done it for less. Yeah. You know? For real. So, that's now a dead end, and without modern-day DNA technology or forensic tools, these leads
35:50 Karen Kilgariff? dry up, the investigation peters out, months pass, and then years. Investigators still believe that Charles has something to do with his mother's death. Can you imagine, like, the rest of his family just having to sit there, not sure? You're psychic, because that is what I'm about to tell you about. Charles maintains his innocence, but the suspicion grows in his family. Oh. And his own sisters struggle to believe the story. Shit. Charles becomes more isolated as time passes, and then around 2006, investigators working the case get access to CODIS for the first time. We've talked about it on the show a lot. It's the National DNA Database that they were developing since 1991, but a lot of people didn't have access to it in the beginning.
36:35 Karen Kilgariff? So this was the first time investigators around the country had access. And it's helped solve countless crimes and cold cases over the years. So more than 10 years after Dorothy Donovan is murdered, the mystery blood sample from her farmhouse is inputted into CODIS, and investigators finally get a match.
36:53 Georgia Hardstark? Wow.
36:54 Karen Kilgariff? It belongs to a man with a lengthy criminal record who's served time in Maryland around the late 1990s for murder. In the years since Dorothy's death, this man has been convicted on drug and robbery charges, and he served a stint in prison for that. He'd since been released, and it takes police more than two months to track him down. And when they do, they track him down to a home 40 miles away from Dorothy Donovan's home.
37:17 Georgia Hardstark? Shit.
37:18 Karen Kilgariff? The man's named Gilbert Cannon. He's in his late 30s. He looks a lot like the man in the composite sketch. But when police bring him in for questioning, he denies any involvement. Investigators start to confront him with the piles of evidence against him, including DNA and print matches, and he buckles. He tells investigators exactly what happened that night in June of 1991. And what he tells them is basically exactly what Charles said. Yes.
37:43 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, how frustrating.
37:46 Karen Kilgariff? So horrible.
37:46 Georgia Hardstark? I told you exactly what happened, like, beat by beat, and you...
37:51 Karen Kilgariff? And you went...
37:52 Georgia Hardstark? And it sounds fucking made up. It does.
37:54 Karen Kilgariff? It sounds entirely made up. And luckily Gilbert Cannon did corroborate it, because he could have just done that thing where he's like, deny, deny, and go to jail, which a lot of them do.
38:04 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
38:05 Karen Kilgariff? He was in the Hardee's parking lot that night. He was high on cocaine. He was looking to score more, presumably in Georgetown, and that's why he needed a ride there. He corroborates the entire rest of the story. We've heard Charles offers to drive him a few miles up the road. Gilbert attacks Charles with the screwdriver. They fight in the street. Charles offers him the full ride, and then he runs back to his truck and gets away. Then Gilbert fills in the rest of the gaps. He says he kept walking down that road, and then finally he decided he needed to find somewhere to sleep. He tells investigators he passed several houses, but they all had their lights on, so he did not try them.
38:43 Georgia Hardstark? Don't tell me it was just a fucking coincidence.
38:46 Karen Kilgariff? Yep. He arrived at Dorothy's house by sheer coincidence. The lights weren't on. It was just as Charles had feared when he saw the man lurking and drove away.
38:55 Georgia Hardstark? He killed him.
38:57 Karen Kilgariff? Gilbert broke in through the back door between the sound of the window being smashed and the creaky farmhouse floors. Dorothy wakes up. Gilbert is in a drug frenzy, truly, and just attacks her and stabs her with the screwdriver and murders her brutally and horribly. Gilbert was fleeing the scene when Charles arrived home.
39:15 Georgia Hardstark? Wow.
39:16 Karen Kilgariff? It doesn't seem like Gilbert understands that the same man who'd given him a ride and that he'd gotten in a fight with
39:22 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
39:22 Karen Kilgariff? was now the one pulling in this driveway.
39:24 Georgia Hardstark? Okay.
39:25 Karen Kilgariff? He tells police he acted alone and that he picked the home at random. And when police tell him that it was that same man's mother that he murdered, he is shocked. Dorothy's daughter and one of Charles' sisters, Diana, tells Forensic Files that Gilbert being shocked was, quote, "such a relief to us." That showed us that Charles was not connected to him.
39:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, because he could have lied and said, yep, he hired me, so he gets a lighter sentence.
39:50 Karen Kilgariff? Yep.
39:50 Georgia Hardstark? Like, I was just a dupe.
39:52 Karen Kilgariff? Right.
39:52 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
39:53 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah. And then the guilt you would feel that you did not believe in your own brother, even though it would be very hard to believe.
40:01 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
40:02 Karen Kilgariff? Like, all these things that are happening, it's evidence. And it's like, the part about the death insurance was, is terrible.
40:09 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. The randomness of it is what's so unbelievable.
40:12 Karen Kilgariff? Yes.
40:13 Georgia Hardstark? But it's true.
40:14 Karen Kilgariff? After confessing, Gilbert's arrested. And the following year, 2007, he pleads guilty to Dorothy's murder. When he does, it will have been 16 years since Dorothy Donovan was murdered. Gilbert sentenced to life in prison without parole, and Dorothy's surviving family members are left to pick up the pieces after years of overwhelming grief, losing their mom, along with the family tension over the doubt around Charles's involvement. Finally, Charles Holden is exonerated, but nothing can undo the nightmare of being implicated in your own mother's death
40:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
40:45 Karen Kilgariff? for 16 years. Little has been documented about how Charles felt during all of this. Understandably, he had no interest in talking to the press, but a 2007 News Journal piece briefly touches on his experience, quoting his sister Brenda Alexander, who says, quote,
41:02 Karen Kilgariff? At the time of Cannon's arrest, Charles's sisters acknowledged that they were hard pressed to understand why their brother would give a ride to a stranger. In this case, one with an extensive Delaware criminal history dating 1981. His generosity caused a rift among the siblings. But according to Alexander, "An attempt at reconciliation began Tuesday. We're working on it," she said. "We were all in court and we all went to eat afterwards. We're working on it, but it's going to take time."
41:29 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
41:29 Karen Kilgariff? End quote. That's the incredibly tragic story of the murder of Dorothy Donovan and the exoneration of her son, Charles Holden.
41:36 Georgia Hardstark? Wow, I haven't seen that, Forensic Files.
41:39 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
41:39 Georgia Hardstark? That's, I didn't know that story, that's...
41:42 Karen Kilgariff? It's like the thing people fear about being out in the country that, like, as far as I know, growing up out in the country, never happens. And then all of a sudden, this insane...
41:52 Georgia Hardstark? Unbelievable.
41:53 Karen Kilgariff? Horrible story, yeah.
41:54 Georgia Hardstark? Almost, yeah, that's, wow.
41:56 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
41:57 Georgia Hardstark? Great job.
42:00 Speaker 00 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
42:28 Georgia Hardstark? There are plenty of things that keep you up at night. Your sleep tracker shouldn't be one of them.
42:32 Karen Kilgariff? You know that feeling, laying in bed, staring at the ceiling, counting all the times you said something weird.
42:37 Georgia Hardstark? And then you wake up and check your sleep score. Now you have to start your day knowing that you failed at sleeping.
42:42 Karen Kilgariff? Hatch Sleep Clock does it differently.
42:45 Georgia Hardstark? It tracks your sleep from your nightstand. No ring, wristband, or judgmental score waiting for you in the morning.
42:50 Karen Kilgariff? Instead, you'll get personalized insights to understand your sleep and recommendations to build a routine you'll love night after night.
42:57 Georgia Hardstark? Fall asleep to the next chapter of an audiobook, like The Odyssey, a nervous system reset meditation, or a calming sound bath.
43:03 Karen Kilgariff? Then you can find out which gives you 20 more minutes of deep sleep each night.
43:07 Georgia Hardstark? Hatch Sleep Clock.
43:08 Karen Kilgariff? The sleep tracker designed to get you to sleep. Available now on hatch.co.
43:13 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye. The Hulu original series Phony is now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney+
43:18 Karen Kilgariff? Sunny's life is pretty great, until he wakes up from a car accident to a world that looks exactly like his with one exception: his mom.
43:27 Georgia Hardstark? To everyone else, she's the same Ellen they've known their whole lives, but for Sunny, he knows something is off.
43:32 Karen Kilgariff? As his relationship with his mother begins to crack in unsettling ways, he's forced to question what happens when the perfect mom becomes a perfect stranger.
43:40 Georgia Hardstark? Is this all in his head, or is there really an imposter in his house?
43:43 Karen Kilgariff? Starring five-time Emmy nominee Connie Britton and Sam Nevola, this small town is hiding the mother of all mysteries just beneath the surface.
43:51 Georgia Hardstark? Watch the Hulu original series Phony.
43:53 Karen Kilgariff? Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
43:58 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
44:01 Georgia Hardstark? Well, great job.
44:03 Karen Kilgariff? Thank you.
44:04 Georgia Hardstark? Very classic true crime. This isn't that. This is completely different than that. This is-
44:12 Karen Kilgariff? The Origin of Hardees. Oh, I'd love to hear that.
44:16 Georgia Hardstark? No, it's worse. This is the story of the Gwyneth Paltrowsky collision trial.
44:21 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, my god. What a joy.
44:26 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
44:26 Karen Kilgariff? Come on. What a great idea.
44:30 Georgia Hardstark? It's not my idea. Molly and Ally get full credit for that.
44:34 Karen Kilgariff? You lunatics. I'm so excited.
44:36 Georgia Hardstark? And I was like, okay, I guess.
44:37 Karen Kilgariff? It's such a good idea, because here's the thing. I think there was something else big happening in the news at the same time where I really there has always been for 10 years. But I felt like I couldn't focus on that the way I wanted to.
44:49 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, you just heard little blips about it, not like a whole thing about it, but you're about to hear a whole fucking thing about it.
44:54 Karen Kilgariff? Bring it to me, please.
44:55 Georgia Hardstark? Okay. So it's late January 2019, and we're in Park City, Utah.
45:01 Karen Kilgariff? You love to summer there, right?
45:02 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, I summer all the time in the snow. Why would I summer in the snow? Who does that? Rich people.
45:08 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
45:09 Georgia Hardstark? A 72-year-old retired optometrist named Terry Sanderson, or more likely one of his lawyers, files a lawsuit in Utah's civil court that immediately generates headlines around the world. His lawsuit is against Deer Valley, a nearby ski resort known for its wealthy guests and impeccably groomed runs. It's also against the person he collided with, a person we all know from Shakespeare and Love and Sliding Doors and, of course, Goop.
45:39 Georgia Hardstark? This is the story of the Gwyneth Paltrowski collision trial.
45:42 Karen Kilgariff? Amazing. Amazing. But also, it has the feeling already. And I think it's like, this guy hasn't done well in the public eye for this. It's you saying that he sued Deer Valley and her. It's like, ah, sue everyone. You can see it, like, him breaking down in the parking lot, almost.
45:58 Georgia Hardstark? I mean, it's kind of a sad story.
46:00 Karen Kilgariff? Okay.
46:01 Georgia Hardstark? That I feel like it is, but.
46:02 Karen Kilgariff? Okay.
46:03 Georgia Hardstark? You tell me. The main source of the story is reporting from NBC, and the rest of the sources can be found in the show notes. Okay, so, we're back to the day it all happened. It's February 26, 2016, and we're at Deer Valley on a green run, which I think is, you know, easy.
46:18 Karen Kilgariff? For babies?
46:18 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Called Vandana. And this is one of the easiest runs on the mountain. It's a gentle, wide slope that connects the summit to the Empire Canyon Lodge, where you would find me if I were forced to be there.
46:31 Karen Kilgariff? I mean, I'm telling you, here's our cancellation. I fucking hate skiing so much.
46:37 Georgia Hardstark? It was an activity that my single dad took us to do because he didn't know what else to do with us.
46:43 Karen Kilgariff? Like a big bear?
46:44 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. And that's the last time I did it, and I have no interest in it at all. He took us a few times.
46:48 Karen Kilgariff? It's just so out of control. Like, and I get that that's the appeal. It's very, like, surfer and that energy of, like, let's ride it and let's see what happens. I hate let's see what happens energy for things like that, for, like, physical things.
47:01 Georgia Hardstark? It was fun. I enjoyed it as a kid. As an adult, I have no interest.
47:06 Karen Kilgariff? Did I tell you the story of, with my ex, we went skiing one time because he had a big skiing family? And I was like, I don't want to do this. I was like, come on, my dad will teach you. He's a really good teacher. We literally spent, like, seven minutes on the kid's slope, and then he took me up to a thing, and I just, like, started going down, and my legs locked up. And I was like, I can't, I can't go anymore. I had to get taken down.
47:27 Georgia Hardstark? No.
47:28 Karen Kilgariff? On the ski patrols, like, laying down like that, staring up at the sky. It was so embarrassing and so hilarious.
47:35 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. So, Gwyneth is 44 at the time, and is on the mountain with her two kids, Apple, who's 12, and Moses, who's 10. Oh, Moses, like, my cat. And she's with her boyfriend, producer Brad Falchuk, who they're now married, and a ski instructor named Eric Christensen. The kids have been getting a lesson from Eric, and Gwyneth and Brad had been skiing with them. So of kind of a family lesson together.
48:00 Karen Kilgariff? Sure.
48:01 Georgia Hardstark? What happens next is up for debate. According to Gwyneth, she's gently skiing down the slope.
48:07 Karen Kilgariff? Did she use the word gently immediately?
48:09 Georgia Hardstark? Right. Well, it's like an easy run. So it's not like you have to be pro and you'd be going faster and like that.
48:15 Karen Kilgariff? Okay.
48:15 Georgia Hardstark? So she's skiing down the slope, and then she sees two skis appear between her skis. And then she feels someone press up behind her and kind of grunt. And then the two of them both crashed to the ground. So almost like someone came up behind her and plowed into her. Gwyneth and the man both freeze for a minute. And then she yells at the guy who crashed into her. She later says she yelled at him because she thought in the moment he had done it on purpose. She's a famous person, and I'm sure she gets harangued in public all the time. So she kind of thought it was one of those experiences.
48:49 Karen Kilgariff? And what did she yell at him, goop?
48:52 Georgia Hardstark? Goop.
48:56 Georgia Hardstark? And that grunt, the grunting thing was weird.
48:58 Karen Kilgariff? Yes. No, that's very jarring.
49:01 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, but she says she realizes in the moment that it was an accident and apologizes for yelling. So her kid's instructor, this guy Eric, helps the guy to his feet. And they have a brief exchange, the guy and him. And then everyone skis away. Kind of like this just thing happened and everyone is a little like, what the fuck was that?
49:19 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
49:19 Georgia Hardstark? You know, Eric, the teacher, files an incident with Deer Valley, describing the events this way, although it sounds like he didn't see the moment of impact himself and was just going mostly by what Gwyneth's description was. But he writes that the man had said that Gwyneth, quote, "just appeared in front of him," end quote. So he's saying he didn't appear behind her. She just appeared in front of him.
49:43 Karen Kilgariff? Unfortunately, I would just, as a person who has gotten rear-ended like three different cars in my life, it doesn't work that way.
49:51 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
49:51 Karen Kilgariff? If you're behind, that's your responsibility.
49:53 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, because also, like, I'm just picturing a slope. There's no out of the blue.
49:59 Karen Kilgariff? No. Unless, I mean like-
50:00 Georgia Hardstark? They're going really fast.
50:02 Karen Kilgariff? They're going really fast, but yeah, you have full breadth of vision.
50:07 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
50:07 Karen Kilgariff? It's not like, she can't drop down in front of you.
50:09 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
50:10 Karen Kilgariff? It's just a weird construct.
50:11 Georgia Hardstark? Right. But like, okay, maybe you didn't see her in front of you, but it doesn't, I don't think she could have appeared in front of you.
50:19 Karen Kilgariff? Breathalyzer.
50:21 Georgia Hardstark? That's actually, I don't think that happened.
50:23 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
50:23 Georgia Hardstark? Because everyone just left.
50:24 Karen Kilgariff? Hmm.
50:25 Georgia Hardstark? So everyone goes on with their lives for three years, or so it seems. At some point, the man, this man is a 75-year-old, his name is Terry Sanderson, and he hires a lawyer. The lawyer goes back and forth with Gwyneth's lawyers, which you know have to be like, the best in the fucking biz.
50:43 Karen Kilgariff? Just the power.
50:44 Georgia Hardstark? The most power.
50:45 Karen Kilgariff? Radiating off those men.
50:47 Georgia Hardstark? The secrets they know.
50:48 Karen Kilgariff? And women.
50:48 Georgia Hardstark? And women.
50:49 Karen Kilgariff? The secrets that they can never tell.
50:51 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, God.
50:52 Karen Kilgariff? Hmm.
50:52 Georgia Hardstark? Gwyneth's lawyers are like, fuck you, no way. That's, I'm paraphrasing. And so Terry files in early 2019. The filing includes his version of the events, which are that he was skiing down the slope when Gwyneth, skiing out of control, slammed into him from behind, knocking him unconscious and breaking four of his ribs.
51:11 Karen Kilgariff? Hmm.
51:11 Georgia Hardstark? So very different story.
51:13 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
51:13 Georgia Hardstark? Now, the central question in this lawsuit will lie in one key difference between Terry and Gwyneth's stories. Who was the uphill skier? Every ski resort has a posted code of rules that skiers are supposed to follow, and among these rules is that downhill skiers have the right of way, and uphill skiers, who fucking uphill skis?
51:32 Karen Kilgariff? Just for like, the workout?
51:33 Georgia Hardstark? Or maybe like, to get to the top of the-
51:35 Karen Kilgariff? I think they mean, it's, you know, like, downstage and upstage in the theater, they mean like, the skier behind.
51:40 Georgia Hardstark? Uphill, got it. Great job.
51:42 Karen Kilgariff? Thanks so much.
51:43 Georgia Hardstark? So uphill is meaning they're up the hill.
51:45 Karen Kilgariff? And then there's across country skiers coming across like this.
51:47 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
51:47 Karen Kilgariff? Everybody's-
51:48 Georgia Hardstark? Just like, clunking up this hill.
51:49 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
51:49 Georgia Hardstark? Yes. Okay, now that makes total sense. So uphill skiers, downhill skiers, downhill people, the people in front of you, have the right of way.
51:57 Karen Kilgariff? Because you simply can't control what's happening behind you when you cannot see it.
52:00 Georgia Hardstark? Truly.
52:01 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
52:02 Georgia Hardstark? Gwyneth and Terry each claim to be the downhill skier. So we do know that after the collision, let's call it, the Deer Valley Ski Patrol does bring Terry down the mountain on a stretcher. We're not sure if he loses consciousness at any point, but being brought down on a stretcher is common for anyone who has any kind of injury on the mountain that can't get down on his own.
52:22 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, I know.
52:25 Georgia Hardstark? You do know.
52:26 Karen Kilgariff? I know firsthand, and it's very shaming.
52:28 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, I would not.
52:29 Karen Kilgariff? And it takes forever. It feels like four years.
52:31 Georgia Hardstark? So slow.
52:32 Karen Kilgariff? And people kind of ski by you and look down at you. You just have to like, let go and let God. It's horrible.
52:38 Georgia Hardstark? And get a hot toddy. So Terry goes to urgent care later that day, and it sounds like he really did fracture some ribs. This really probably was a very painful fall. And while he's there, a friend who he'd been skiing with, a man named Craig Ramone, first tells him that the person he collided with was Gwyneth Paltrow. So he didn't even know when it happened that it was Gwyneth Paltrow.
52:59 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
52:59 Georgia Hardstark? Got all those ski equipment things on.
53:01 Karen Kilgariff? The weird yellow goggles.
53:02 Georgia Hardstark? Right. Shortly after this, Terry sends out an email to his entire family with the subject line that says, "I'm famous." It details the crash.
53:11 Karen Kilgariff? Make that a phone call. Don't put it in my name.
53:14 Georgia Hardstark? The exact contents of the email don't seem to be part of the public record, but Terry goes back and forth with one of his daughters about whether or not someone on the trail might have gotten GoPro footage of the crash, but no footage ever materializes. And then three years pass before he eventually files the suit. Initially, he sues for $3 million. Yeah. Naming both Gwyneth and Deer Valley in the lawsuit. And there's a flurry of reports about this lawsuit, at first only giving Terry's side of the story and claiming that eyewitness accounts from the slopes refute the incident report on file at Deer Valley. People love to hate on Gwyneth Paltrow.
53:51 Karen Kilgariff? She has been the subject of so much hatred, basically, since day one.
53:56 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, she's somehow an easy target. And so the idea that she ran into someone and was just a messy, rich lady.
54:04 Karen Kilgariff? Go, go, go, and skate away.
54:06 Georgia Hardstark? And she now was, you know, had hurt this old man and everything. It's like, people love that. They like that narrative.
54:12 Karen Kilgariff? Well, it's a story. It's like, we got to feed this content machine.
54:16 Georgia Hardstark? Right. About a month later, so in February 2019, Gwyneth comes forward in statements through her representatives, gives her version of events. So between 2019 and when the case finally goes to trial in 2023, the amount Terry is suing for drops from $3 million to $300,000. That is because, it's not arbitrary.
54:36 Karen Kilgariff? Because they drop a couple zeros off.
54:38 Georgia Hardstark? Please, something. Because in Utah Civil Court, there's thresholds of amounts a plaintiff is seeking that determine how many witnesses they can call.
54:47 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
54:47 Georgia Hardstark? And $300,000 is the threshold for the maximum number. Hmm. So like, do they want to call more people? Do they not want to call more people?
54:55 Karen Kilgariff? And maybe it's like, the more people you can call to prove it, the higher your number can be. But if you're fucking around and it's like, there's only the ski guy.
55:03 Georgia Hardstark? Called, yeah.
55:04 Karen Kilgariff? Then, yeah.
55:05 Georgia Hardstark? The less people called, the better your chances are of winning.
55:07 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, my, my thinking was, the less people called, the harder it is to prove the truth. So they can't go to those crazy levels. But like, if something happened that eight people were like, yes, that is exactly what happened. Then it's easier to be like, then this is provably your fault or your fault.
55:25 Georgia Hardstark? Okay. We are lawyers.
55:27 Karen Kilgariff? I'm just making everything up while I drink a big thing of beet juice. That's my new personality.
55:32 Georgia Hardstark? That should be suspicious enough already that you're drinking a big glass of beet juice. So the case isn't going to trial until March of 2023. And the fact that it goes to trial is all a testament to the fact that Gwyneth and her legal team feel that fucking Terry has no case and it's absolute bullshit. By this point, they are suing each other. Terry is suing Gwyneth for the 300,000 and Gwyneth is countersuing Terry for $1.
55:59 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, yeah.
56:00 Georgia Hardstark? Plus her legal fees, which have to be astronomical.
56:03 Karen Kilgariff? God damn it.
56:04 Georgia Hardstark? Right? So she's like, that's like, the $1 thing is so, I don't want to call it petty.
56:08 Karen Kilgariff? Mm-mm.
56:09 Georgia Hardstark? Because it's.
56:10 Karen Kilgariff? I think it's fair.
56:11 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, it's just the go fuck yourself amount.
56:13 Karen Kilgariff? Yes, it's like, this is weird that you're doing this. But I will actually go and argue this with you because
56:19 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
56:19 Karen Kilgariff? I don't want your money. I want you to.
56:21 Georgia Hardstark? Easily give you $300,000 and it wouldn't affect me for a fucking moment. But I'm not fucking doing it on principle because you're wrong. Or you're like, lying or whatever.
56:31 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, or you're just like, this is a money grab. And so instead of getting a bunch of money, I'm just going to prove that like, sometimes this is what happens to people. I mean,
56:40 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
56:40 Karen Kilgariff? Here's the thing, Gwyneth Paltrow is like a perfect blonde nepo baby Hollywood superstar.
56:47 Georgia Hardstark? Yes.
56:48 Karen Kilgariff? And god damn.
56:49 Georgia Hardstark? Touch, for sure.
56:51 Karen Kilgariff? But our culture loves to hate those women. That's like.
56:54 Georgia Hardstark? What, she's supposed to go into fucking accounting? Like, what do you want from her?
56:57 Karen Kilgariff? I know. She has a perfect face and she's really good at acting. And she's like, chill. Brad Pitt really liked her. Like, come on, give it up. But
57:06 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
57:07 Karen Kilgariff? They should have. Tons of video on ski slopes like that. Because it would be so hard to prove.
57:13 Georgia Hardstark? Right. Just for liability alone. It had to be.
57:16 Karen Kilgariff? Imagine the snowboarder that was like making his own video in the front grounds and then uphill, downhill skier.
57:22 Georgia Hardstark? Didn't even know what he's got.
57:23 Karen Kilgariff? And he's like, na na na na na na na na. And then.
57:27 Georgia Hardstark? The snowboarding influencer?
57:32 Georgia Hardstark? Okay, $1 blah, blah, blah. And the trial is carried, of course, on Court TV live and streamed on YouTube and is a huge sensation for some people, particularly when Gwyneth testifies for over an hour.
57:45 Karen Kilgariff? Hell, yes. This feels very quarantine material to me.
57:48 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
57:49 Karen Kilgariff? But I guess it was a little after.
57:51 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
57:51 Karen Kilgariff? But maybe we're still traumatized enough to be like, is she in court? What's going on now?
57:56 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
57:57 Karen Kilgariff? What's that? Where'd she get that turtleneck?
57:59 Georgia Hardstark? She looks so classy in her beiges.
58:01 Karen Kilgariff? And her chenille.
58:04 Georgia Hardstark? So her testimony is a weird thing to watch. It does seem like one of Terry's lawyers is a little starstruck by Gwyneth Paltrow.
58:12 Karen Kilgariff? So it's embarrassing?
58:13 Georgia Hardstark? So the line of questioning is weird. She asks Gwyneth how tall she is and then like goes back and forth of like, I'm so jealous or so tall. It's just weird. It's awkward and uncomfortable and weird.
58:24 Karen Kilgariff? I don't know. What are you doing?
58:25 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. I mean, honestly, it is just this like, let's be buddies, kind of a weird thing. And that's his lawyer. So he's probably just like, fucking great.
58:33 Karen Kilgariff? It would have been hilarious if she came out fucking guns blazing. It was like, shut up, immediately. Just tries to get in her face.
58:40 Georgia Hardstark? I mean, it, yeah, it's really weird. She asks Gwyneth if she knows Taylor Swift. Yeah, it's just weird.
58:46 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, no. Can I have her number?
58:48 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, exactly. Do you guys want to go out sometime?
58:50 Karen Kilgariff? That's really bad.
58:52 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
58:53 Karen Kilgariff? And also that poor man who was like, like kicked up all this dust and now he's like slowly watching it all fade away.
58:59 Georgia Hardstark? And it's live, so you can't be like, never mind. So there's lots of moments that become TikTok fodder in this testimony in the case. Gwyneth gives her version of events again. And when asked if the collision disrupted her vacation, she says, quote, "Well, I lost half a day of skiing," end quote. Which like, I don't know why I'm defending her in this thing. I'm like, she doesn't fucking mean me to. But it is like, it almost sounds like she was being facetious. She's like, that's all that happened. I lost a fucking half a day of skiing and this guy's fucking suing me for $3 million. Like, you know, like, it wasn't a big deal, but people take it as like a
59:33 Karen Kilgariff? Out of touch.
59:34 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, I lost half a second. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so.
59:37 Karen Kilgariff? But this woman, she's always on the grind for you people, you know? She's like, she never stops working. Can't she have a half a day of skiing?
59:45 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
59:45 Karen Kilgariff? Without everybody being like, fuck you.
59:47 Georgia Hardstark? Totally. So, fine, whatever.
59:49 Karen Kilgariff? I'll defend her. I don't care.
59:51 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, I mean, we will.
59:51 Karen Kilgariff? At this point, I'll defend her.
59:54 Georgia Hardstark? Because, because also after it happened, she packed in for the day and went and got a massage instead. Because she's like, yeah, someone just fucking clobbered me.
1:00:02 Karen Kilgariff? And she's made of money.
1:00:04 Georgia Hardstark? And I'm so fucking, and I'm Gwyneth Paltrow.
1:00:06 Karen Kilgariff? Her choice is like, go pick a diamond necklace, eat fucking caviar, or go get a massage.
1:00:12 Georgia Hardstark? Like, what would you do?
1:00:13 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:00:13 Georgia Hardstark? You'd do that.
1:00:14 Karen Kilgariff? What do you want her to go down and work at the buffet? It's Gwyneth fucking Paltrow. She's never lifted a finger, nor should she have had to.
1:00:21 Georgia Hardstark? No.
1:00:22 Karen Kilgariff? Thank you, Black Danner, for bringing this perfect child into the world.
1:00:26 Georgia Hardstark? We are Gwyneth Paltrow's fans here, it turns out.
1:00:29 Karen Kilgariff? We're the phoniest assholes in all of show business.
1:00:32 Georgia Hardstark? I know. We're just like, just as bad as the lawyer kissing her ass.
1:00:35 Karen Kilgariff? But I think there is a piece of it where it's like, this must happen to her or that type of person. Non-fucking stop.
1:00:43 Georgia Hardstark? Like, you just can't win. Like, anything you say is going to be torn apart.
1:00:49 Karen Kilgariff? Did you see Marty Supreme, Gwyneth is in it? As this like actress who is, you know, slightly older? Fucking incredible. She is a movie star.
1:00:59 Georgia Hardstark? She is.
1:00:59 Karen Kilgariff? That's the other thing. It's like, just, I think when people get around movie stars, whether they sue them or like, try to be friends with them, there's just a weird magic.
1:01:07 Georgia Hardstark? Like a blip in your head.
1:01:08 Karen Kilgariff? It makes you a little crazy. What's your?
1:01:10 Georgia Hardstark? I still love Odessa, that chick who's in Marty Supreme with the curly hair.
1:01:13 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, she's so.
1:01:15 Georgia Hardstark? She's in I Love L.A. and it's, she's like, she's
1:01:18 Karen Kilgariff? So good.
1:01:18 Georgia Hardstark? One of the reasons to watch it. She's just incredible.
1:01:20 Karen Kilgariff? I gotta see that.
1:01:21 Georgia Hardstark? Odessa A. Zion. And she's just like, magnetic.
1:01:25 Karen Kilgariff? I like that movie, but my sister had to go out and stand in the lobby for a while because she was over, all of her senses were overwhelmed.
1:01:30 Georgia Hardstark? Why?
1:01:32 Karen Kilgariff? Because you have to watch it, but the soundtrack is absolutely insane.
1:01:34 Georgia Hardstark? I can't watch. I have a sensory issue. I can't watch it.
1:01:37 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, she does too.
1:01:38 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, good.
1:01:39 Karen Kilgariff? You should text her.
1:01:40 Georgia Hardstark? No, I don't want to like upset her senses. That's what we don't like is to be texted. Okay. So Terry's ski buddy, that guy Craig Ramone, takes the stand. He's considered to be the only eyewitness to the actual collision. He, of course, backs up his friend Terry's story. He says that he heard a quote, "blood curling scream," end quote.
1:02:00 Karen Kilgariff? Nice.
1:02:00 Georgia Hardstark? Thank you. Before seeing Gwyneth out of control slam into Terry.
1:02:04 Karen Kilgariff? The woman has been on ski slopes since she was like probably four years old.
1:02:08 Georgia Hardstark? Totally, right. He also is questioned about a Facebook post he made shortly after the collision claiming Gwyneth, quote, "took Terry out," end quote. You know, who knows what the fuck. They're just trying to make it seem like it's her fault, obviously.
1:02:22 Karen Kilgariff? Well, he has broken ribs. I mean, like.
1:02:24 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, the broken ribs, but also he's an, I'm sorry, but like he's an older gentleman.
1:02:28 Karen Kilgariff? Right.
1:02:28 Georgia Hardstark? But she wasn't hurt at all and he broke four ribs. Not to say that, it just seems like.
1:02:34 Karen Kilgariff? Disparate stories.
1:02:36 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, and it might be more about you and your body than the crash.
1:02:40 Karen Kilgariff? Right.
1:02:40 Georgia Hardstark? You know?
1:02:41 Karen Kilgariff? Yes. I just need to know who the uphill and downhill skiers were. Because that's, all of a sudden, people being like, no, no, I was in front, is crazy and infuriating, I'm sure.
1:02:51 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. And then, of course, Eric, the ski instructor, who we must imagine is gorgeous and like, you know, fucking Fabio in the mood. Like, let's just picture that because it's fun.
1:02:59 Karen Kilgariff? Please, and stoned.
1:03:00 Georgia Hardstark? And stoned and had a fucking bird head him in the face. Backs up Gwyneth's version of what happened. He says she's a decent skier and that she had been making good turns and that she had been skiing calmly, you know, normally. He disputes the blood curling scream, saying, quote, "Miss Paltrow doesn't go down the hill screaming. There would be no reason for her to be screaming just to scream," end quote.
1:03:23 Karen Kilgariff? Well, no, that's not the claim. The claim is like, ah, coming in like that.
1:03:26 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Can you picture Gwyneth Paltrow screaming in out of control fucking craziness on like a bunny slope?
1:03:33 Karen Kilgariff? It just doesn't.
1:03:33 Georgia Hardstark? And knows how to ski.
1:03:34 Karen Kilgariff? It's a bunny slope or it's a green slope.
1:03:37 Georgia Hardstark? Slope. Is bunny like, we're not, is that not?
1:03:39 Karen Kilgariff? Bunny's the one that's like, there's almost no incline whatsoever. But then the other one's kind of like.
1:03:44 Georgia Hardstark? Okay.
1:03:45 Karen Kilgariff? Pretty serious.
1:03:46 Georgia Hardstark? Okay. So he and Terry's lawyers have a long back and forth about whether or not Eric yelled at Terry. There's all this like fucking, they're just questioning the teacher.
1:03:55 Karen Kilgariff? And he's like, hey, man.
1:03:56 Georgia Hardstark? Hey, man.
1:03:56 Karen Kilgariff? Look, dude.
1:03:57 Georgia Hardstark? Just trying to do my fucking job with Gwyneth Paltrow.
1:03:59 Karen Kilgariff? Rad the snow, baby.
1:04:01 Georgia Hardstark? The case probably falls apart for good when Terry is questioned. In his suit, he lists many health problems that he's suffered since the collision. But Gwyneth's legal team also determined that he had most of these conditions before the collision. Also, it's determined that his eyesight in one eye was already fairly impaired at the time of the collision. I feel sensitive towards him because he's my dad's age and
1:04:25 Karen Kilgariff? Oh, yeah.
1:04:25 Georgia Hardstark? I just feel sensitive.
1:04:28 Karen Kilgariff? Right. Like, it sucks to get into a ski accident, no matter what's happening.
1:04:32 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. He claims he's suffered debilitating health issues in the years since. But Gwyneth's legal team points out that he had also traveled extensively after the accident, taking trips to Europe, Peru, Morocco, the Canary Islands, Thailand, and Costa Rica, where he zip lined. In the end, Gwyneth winds up winning the case and is awarded the $1 in damages. Ultimately, Terry winds up not having to pay her legal fees because it would have been a huge amount of money. And I, you know, kudos to her for, like, not making him do that.
1:05:02 Karen Kilgariff? Being decent.
1:05:03 Georgia Hardstark? After the verdict is read, when everyone is leaving the courtroom, this is just, I mean, it's, what do you think of this moment? It's so beautifully petty, right?
1:05:11 Karen Kilgariff? It's hilarious. And I also don't know if she meant it in a petty way.
1:05:15 Georgia Hardstark? I think she was being sincere.
1:05:16 Karen Kilgariff? I do, too, because
1:05:18 Georgia Hardstark? I totally do.
1:05:19 Karen Kilgariff? It's like, you and I would do it and absolutely be sarcastic.
1:05:22 Georgia Hardstark? Okay, here, let's say it, let's say the words together.
1:05:23 Karen Kilgariff? She's a classy MF'er.
1:05:25 Georgia Hardstark? She goes by him and leans down and whispers in his ear, it's on video, she whispers, "I wish you well." So you could go, "I wish you well."
1:05:33 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:05:34 Georgia Hardstark? Or you can go, "I wish you well."
1:05:36 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, you could lock eyes and be like, dude.
1:05:38 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, like, which, well, I think the way, when you watch the video, it doesn't have a pettiness. I don't know. I don't see the pettiness.
1:05:47 Karen Kilgariff? But she's wearing a lot of cashmere, so you really give her the benefit of the doubt.
1:05:52 Georgia Hardstark? She smells amazing, too.
1:05:54 Karen Kilgariff? She has this really good glowy primer on.
1:05:57 Georgia Hardstark? God, her skin is perfect, her hair is perfect, she smells great. "I wish you well."
1:06:02 Karen Kilgariff? "I wish you well."
1:06:02 Georgia Hardstark? End quote. And that, you know, that is my, wishing them well is my talking shit that, like, I'm not gonna talk shit. I'm just gonna say, "I'm wishing them well."
1:06:12 Karen Kilgariff? And then you talk shit after?
1:06:13 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah. Well, I don't talk shit.
1:06:15 Karen Kilgariff? I'm just like, who are you talking about? You don't talk shit.
1:06:20 Georgia Hardstark? Who's that, Georgia? I don't know her. Uh, I wish you well, end quote. The reporters asked Harry if he whispered anything back to her. He answers that he said, quote, "Thank you, dear."
1:06:30 Karen Kilgariff? Oh.
1:06:30 Georgia Hardstark? End quote.
1:06:31 Karen Kilgariff? So they kind of ended friends?
1:06:33 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, like ended on a, this is stupid and we both can acknowledge that. And like, let's move on with our lives.
1:06:38 Karen Kilgariff? It's kind of like, hey, look, is this an opportunity to make a cool, easy $2 million?
1:06:44 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
1:06:44 Karen Kilgariff? Like, this is what people do because the courts are unregulated in that way.
1:06:49 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
1:06:50 Karen Kilgariff? Watch the McDonald's Hot Coffee documentary.
1:06:52 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, my God. To this day, he stands by his version of events. He has to. And that is the story of the Gwyneth Paltrow ski collision trial.
1:07:02 Karen Kilgariff? Now, do you think she really was innocent? Or do you think that she was just a more appealing witness than him?
1:07:09 Georgia Hardstark? I don't think his version of events add up. Not maliciously.
1:07:15 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:07:15 Georgia Hardstark? You know? If he were younger, I think I'd think it was malicious and like a money grab. But I just don't buy it. And then also, like, you weren't hurt that bad. You didn't, you're blaming her for that, but you're living your life. I don't know.
1:07:29 Karen Kilgariff? You're in San Moritz. Also, I think if it was a big smash up.
1:07:34 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
1:07:35 Karen Kilgariff? Every, there would be way more witnesses and way more people and like.
1:07:39 Georgia Hardstark? An incident report, because places like that are immediately, for insurance reasons, going to be like, I know everyone's fine, but we need to write out the report.
1:07:45 Karen Kilgariff? Well, didn't Eric, the ski instructor?
1:07:48 Georgia Hardstark? After the fact, which is good. But like, yeah, they would have.
1:07:50 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, it wasn't all hands on deck because there's this big terrible accident.
1:07:54 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
1:07:54 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:07:54 Georgia Hardstark? So that, to me, is weird as well.
1:07:56 Karen Kilgariff? Did they show pictures of her in her ski outfit?
1:07:58 Georgia Hardstark? Oh, I didn't see. I don't know. I bet she looks cute.
1:08:01 Karen Kilgariff? I mean, yeah.
1:08:04 Karen Kilgariff? Elite.
1:08:04 Georgia Hardstark? Why are we kissing her ass so much?
1:08:06 Karen Kilgariff? No, no, I'm not trying to.
1:08:07 Georgia Hardstark? I'm not, I am.
1:08:08 Karen Kilgariff? I mean, there's, what do we get out of it?
1:08:09 Georgia Hardstark? Free goop.
1:08:10 Karen Kilgariff? Free goop. I think it's an interesting thing when you are kind of at the hands of the public in that way.
1:08:17 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, you're like a public property.
1:08:19 Karen Kilgariff? Uh huh.
1:08:20 Georgia Hardstark? You're not a real person anymore.
1:08:21 Karen Kilgariff? Right. And then it's like even just, we bumped into each other, now you're going to pay me money.
1:08:25 Georgia Hardstark? Totally. And like the three years later thing.
1:08:29 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:08:29 Georgia Hardstark? Three years later afterwards is when he started suing her.
1:08:32 Karen Kilgariff? He had to go on vacation to eight places.
1:08:34 Georgia Hardstark? Right.
1:08:34 Karen Kilgariff? But also, in fairness, if she did come through and smash into him and break his ribs.
1:08:39 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
1:08:40 Karen Kilgariff? And ski away like two bad chumps.
1:08:42 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
1:08:43 Karen Kilgariff? And then he's just like, no one's ever gonna be on my side because it's Gwyneth Paltrow.
1:08:47 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, and I've had to go through all these things because of broken ribs, which is really fucking painful and
1:08:52 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:08:52 Georgia Hardstark? makes ziplining really hard, then like, I don't know. He reminds me of my dad a little, so I'm like, don't want to.
1:09:00 Karen Kilgariff? I know.
1:09:01 Georgia Hardstark? You know?
1:09:01 Karen Kilgariff? I know.
1:09:02 Georgia Hardstark? It's like this like sweet old, old man looking guy.
1:09:05 Karen Kilgariff? That was such a good idea and such a like.
1:09:07 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
1:09:07 Karen Kilgariff? It's almost like, hey, let's read the newspaper together.
1:09:09 Georgia Hardstark? Totally. But it's true crime.
1:09:12 Karen Kilgariff? It is.
1:09:12 Georgia Hardstark? It is, and anyone who says different.
1:09:13 Karen Kilgariff? Here's the thing, I do think that if this was different, she wouldn't have done the $1, she wouldn't have waived the legal fees.
1:09:21 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
1:09:22 Karen Kilgariff? Like, all of those moves.
1:09:23 Georgia Hardstark? Totally.
1:09:23 Karen Kilgariff? Belie, at least like a, a good faith person.
1:09:27 Georgia Hardstark? It's that thing of like, my integrity is on the line here.
1:09:30 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:09:31 Georgia Hardstark? And I refuse to back down because you're lying, because that's not true.
1:09:35 Karen Kilgariff? Yes.
1:09:35 Georgia Hardstark? So I don't think she would have done that if it were true.
1:09:38 Karen Kilgariff? Right. But I do think it was like very close to the Johnny Depp Amber Heard thing.
1:09:43 Georgia Hardstark? Exactly. It felt similar.
1:09:44 Karen Kilgariff? It was, it felt like it was right there where you're just like, what's happening all of a sudden? Court TV is back and better than ever.
1:09:49 Georgia Hardstark? Why is this entertainment?
1:09:51 Karen Kilgariff? I know.
1:09:51 Georgia Hardstark? It shouldn't be. That's the downfall of, wait a second, this is a true crime podcast.
1:09:55 Karen Kilgariff? Hold on a second.
1:09:56 Georgia Hardstark? Okay. All right, that's fucking it.
1:09:58 Karen Kilgariff? Well, that was a great way to distract from our horrors.
1:10:01 Georgia Hardstark? We did that.
1:10:02 Karen Kilgariff? Yes, we did.
1:10:03 Georgia Hardstark? I don't feel as bad as I thought I would at the end of this story.
1:10:05 Karen Kilgariff? I'm sorry, Gwyneth, but I feel fucking great after your nutso, your nutso experience. And I'm sorry, broken ribs man, because if you are right and the world is against you.
1:10:15 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah.
1:10:15 Karen Kilgariff? What a tragedy.
1:10:16 Georgia Hardstark? Truly. In this day and age of all, that's a tragedy of all tragedies.
1:10:20 Karen Kilgariff? What if she leaned forward and said, my, what is it, peace be with you? What did she say?
1:10:25 Georgia Hardstark? I wish you well.
1:10:26 Karen Kilgariff? I wish you well, but then she very quickly winked with one eye.
1:10:29 Georgia Hardstark? Just like.
1:10:31 Karen Kilgariff? Just like, no, I don't.
1:10:31 Georgia Hardstark? No, I don't.
1:10:34 Georgia Hardstark? Okay.
1:10:35 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:10:35 Georgia Hardstark? Amazing.
1:10:35 Karen Kilgariff? Good distraction. Thank you. Great story.
1:10:37 Georgia Hardstark? Yeah, thank you.
1:10:38 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:10:38 Georgia Hardstark? So now that we're back in the real world, we want to throw some money at the problem by donating $10,000 to the ACLU.
1:10:46 Karen Kilgariff? Well, considering everything that's going on, what if we give $25,000?
1:10:49 Georgia Hardstark? Love it. Let's do it.
1:10:50 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah.
1:10:51 Georgia Hardstark? In the name of murderinos and all of you guys for just supporting us and listening, thank you.
1:10:56 Karen Kilgariff? And anything you can do, go on social media. The people of Minneapolis need your help, need your support. Probably money or donations. There's all kinds of services. This is really an insane situation that everyone is in. And whether you can volunteer, give $5, or just give a shit and pay attention.
1:11:16 Georgia Hardstark? This is a pivotal moment.
1:11:17 Karen Kilgariff? Yeah, it is.
1:11:17 Georgia Hardstark? I think it's gonna be historical, so let's be on the right side of history.
1:11:21 Karen Kilgariff? God. Anyway, stay sexy.
1:11:23 Georgia Hardstark? And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Elvis, do you want a cookie?
1:11:31 Speaker 05 What gets you to believe in something? And I mean, really, really believe. To the point that you'd be willing to travel thousands of miles and put your faith, even your own body, on the line for it.
1:11:48 Speaker 06 Desperate, that's what I was, weighing freaking 80 pounds with a child to raise.
1:11:55 Speaker 07 We went to multiple doctors. They couldn't figure out what was actually the problem.
1:12:01 Speaker 08 Nobody told me they were going to cure my father. No doctor, neurosurgeon. But he said, I'm going to cure your father. And I believed it.
1:12:13 Speaker 05 How long are you willing to hold that belief? Until you question the whole thing?
1:12:19 Speaker 09 As they would say, either I believed in him or I believed in death.
1:12:25 Speaker 09 I had to believe in him.
1:12:27 Speaker 05 João Teixeira de Faria, better known as John of God, is a Brazilian spiritual healer who, over five decades, grew into one of the most famous healers in the world.
1:12:39 Speaker 10 He had healed the wives of ministers, presidents, and owners of big companies.
1:12:46 Speaker 07 This is real. This guy's actually doing surgery, and it's a miracle. I never believed that miracles were real until that point.
1:12:54 Speaker 11 You had literally thousands of people in white milling around, and everyone tells you how they've been saved by this person. After a while, I was like, well, can all these people be wrong?
1:13:07 Speaker 05 But while he drew thousands of followers, who claimed he cured their cancer or helped them walk again, over time, a darker side began to reveal itself.
1:13:19 Speaker 06 One of the reasons why I never went to the police is because I saw at least five or six men with guns everywhere he went. That was clear to me, like, close your mouth. Don't open your mouth. Don't say anything.
1:13:32 Speaker 05 From Exactly Right Media and Adonde Media, this is Two-Faced: John of God. I'm executive producer and host Martina Castro. And over the course of the next six episodes, I'll tell you how this man painted himself as a gifted healer. But as his power and influence grew, he used it to lead a double life, one driven by intimidation, greed, and sexual assault.
1:13:59 Speaker 10 It's very difficult, and it's very also lonely, one small person against God.
1:14:08 Speaker 05 Listen to Two-Faced: John of God on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. And Spanish speakers, pueden escuchar esta serie en español. Busquen a Dos Caras: Juan de Dios.
1:14:28 Karen Kilgariff? This has been an Exactly Right Production.
1:14:30 Georgia Hardstark? Our senior producer is Molly Smith and our associate producer is Tessa Hughes.
1:14:34 Karen Kilgariff? Our editor is Aristotle Lasevedo.
1:14:36 Georgia Hardstark? This episode was mixed by Liana Scolacci.
1:14:38 Karen Kilgariff? Our researchers are Mary McGlashan and Ali Alkan.
1:14:41 Georgia Hardstark? Email your hometowns to myfavoritemurder@gmail.com.
1:14:44 Karen Kilgariff? And follow the show on Instagram at MyFavoriteMurder.
1:14:47 Georgia Hardstark? Listen to My Favorite Murder on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:14:51 Karen Kilgariff? Or you can watch us on YouTube. Search for My Favorite Murder, then like and subscribe. Goodbye.
1:15:04 Georgia Hardstark? By now you've heard about Reef's shoes and sandals, but we want to introduce you to their line of women's clogs for fall.
1:15:09 Karen Kilgariff? These are the kind of shoes you'll keep reaching for because they're genuinely comfortable, but still feel cute and current.
1:15:15 Georgia Hardstark? A cute, like, flowy dress and a pair of clogs is so timeless.
1:15:19 Karen Kilgariff? And we got to get some of these clogs. I couldn't believe how cute and comfortable these Reef clogs were. They have the arch support, they have the height, they give you a little bit of height, but they're kind of simple. Check out the clogs on reef.com and redeem 15% off your first purchase.
1:15:34 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
1:15:35 Karen Kilgariff? Vacation planning should feel like a breeze, not a deep dive into countless travel sites searching for the best deal.
1:15:40 Georgia Hardstark? With CheapCaribbean's Budget Beach Finder, you can search every destination and every date all in one search.
1:15:46 Karen Kilgariff? You'll save time and money with the Budget Beach Finder.
1:15:49 Georgia Hardstark? Say goodbye to endless scrolling and tab hopping and hello to budget beach bliss at your fingertips.
1:15:54 Karen Kilgariff? Go to cheapcaribbean.com to try out the Budget Beach Finder and see just how stress-free vacation planning should be.
1:16:00 Georgia Hardstark? Goodbye.
1:16:02 Speaker 12 Do you ever feel like your computer is tracking you? Well, it's not. It's your browser following you. But not if you come back to Firefox. Firefox blocks the trackers automatically, doesn't follow you from site to site, and supports the ad blockers other browsers dropped. Plus, you can switch AI on or off when its intelligence is acting too artificial. And switching? Totally painless. Your bookmarks, passwords, and browsing history come right with you. Come back to Firefox. Visit firefox.com.
Previous Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 80: Live At The Rams Head Live Next MFM Minisode 472 Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated