Pod Insights Masters of Scale The co-founder effect, w/Rothy's Stephen Hawthornthwaite and Roth Martin About this episode Running a business can be a lonely job. The long hours, the existential threats — it can feel like the weight of the entire company is on your back. That’s where the transformative power of co-founders comes in. Co-founders provide more than added manpower; they bring fresh perspectives and talents that help businesses conquer problems at speed. And the co-founder effect extends beyond the people who started the company: The lessons hold true for every team member that contributes in a foundational way. The more voices you add, the more resilience you build in yourself, and your organization.
Read a transcript of this episode: https://mastersofscale.com https://mastersofscale.com/
Subscribe to the Masters of Scale weekly newsletter: https://mastersofscale.com/subscribe
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 We've all spent money on something that seemed incredible, but didn't live up to the hype. A kitchen gadget, a car. When it doesn't deliver, the disappointment is real. Marketers suffer from this too. Chasing metrics that look great, but don't translate into revenue. LinkedIn calls that bull spend. Invest in what matters and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. LinkedIn Ads also generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
0:48 Speaker 00 The very best founders I know are brilliant at building systems. They connect teams, they remove bottlenecks, and they eliminate single points of failure. And yet, when it comes to their own wealth, most are running a disconnected stack. A tax accountant here and a state attorney there, a wealth manager who doesn't talk to either one of them. Creative Planning was built to fix exactly that. One integrated team of tax professionals, state planners, investment specialists, all coordinated by a dedicated wealth manager who sees your full financial picture and keeps every piece working together. Proactive tax efficiency, estate strategy, investments, all under one roof.
1:32 Speaker 00 Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale.
1:41 Speaker 01 AI is full of possibilities. Enterprises run on realities. That's why Pega combines the world's most powerful AI with the governance, transparency, and control enterprises demand. So you can move faster, adapt faster, and scale AI with confidence. All the power of AI, none of the uncertainty. Learn more at Pega.com/AI.
2:07 Speaker 02 On a lifted table, three feet in diameter.
2:13 Speaker 02 Three dancers perform on top of this table.
2:21 Speaker 02 They're really intimate with each other, physically intimate, being really close to each other.
2:27 Speaker 02 But they're also telling a story.
2:37 Speaker 03 That's Matt Kent, artistic director of the dance company Palobulus. And the dance he's describing, like most of the work Palobulus is known for, features bodies assembling like Voltron into elegant, complex shapes.
2:53 Speaker 03 From a moving VW bus to an elephant wiggling its ears in time with its swishing tail.
3:02 Speaker 03 These physical collaborations do more than create pretty pictures. They give the dancers leverage that almost works like a superpower.
3:11 Speaker 02 When you are lifting someone, when you're partnering, your center of gravity has changed, which means that you can jump a little bit further. You can lean a little bit further. You can reach out a little bit further because you're working with another person.
3:27 Speaker 03 Speaking of working with others, Matt doesn't leave the company alone. He shares that job with his co-artistic director, Rene Jaworski.
3:35 Speaker 04 Our physical partnering is really just the physical representation of the collaboration of the minds as well.
3:46 Speaker 03 Palobulus has been making work for over 50 years, performing everywhere from the Olympic Games to the Academy Awards. And they've done it with an approach so collaborative that it actually makes some people uncomfortable.
3:59 Speaker 02 We've been in situations where people have literally come behind the stage and said, "Who's in charge?"
4:04 Speaker 04 Please tell me who's in charge here.
4:06 Speaker 02 They don't understand.
4:07 Speaker 04 And it's stressful for some people.
4:10 Speaker 03 But for Rene and Matt, the collective input of the group is the essential ingredient that drives their company to keep inventing.
4:18 Speaker 02 Our ability to fail together is our insurance against mediocrity. It feels like a Ouija board.
4:26 Speaker 02 You want to go this way, but sometimes you feel a little pull in a different direction.
4:31 Speaker 02 If you just were like, "Come on, we're going this direction," and yank it over, you're going to lose the groupness. And that groupness is what we protect.
4:46 Speaker 03 In business, leaders are constantly trying to channel this kind of collective spirit into a company that can innovate, move fast, and beat its competitors to scale. But it's incredibly hard to harness a collective by yourself. That's why I believe that two co-founders are better than one, and a few voices are better than fewer voices at any stage of business.
5:10 Speaker 05 You've got to have incredible talent at every position.
5:14 Speaker 05 There are fires burning when you're going home. Can you believe it? Such an idiot. And then you go back to, this is totally going to be amazing. There are so many easy wins. I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake. But you have to time it right. Oops.
5:28 Speaker 06 We're working out of a three-bedroom apartment. Stuff that just seems absolutely nutballs. 10 years later, we're like, well, that's just how you do it. We haven't made it. Just how you do it.
5:40 Speaker 03 This is Masters of Scale.
5:49 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock, and your host. And I believe that two co-founders are better than one, and a few voices are better than fewer voices at any stage of business. There's a famous song you might know that starts with this iconic line.
6:14 Speaker 03 That was recorded in the year I was born, 1967, by a musician named Harry Nielsen, though you might be more familiar with the versions by Three Dog Night or Amy Mann. It was inspired by a time Harry called an acquaintance and got a busy signal. And you can hear the echo of that beep, beep, beep in those first opening notes. This song has special resonance for founders and business leaders because running a business often feels like a lonely job. You have multiple fires burning every day posing existential threats to your business. You're working 60, or 80, or 100-hour weeks just to get a foothold. Even with a terrific team, it can feel like you have the weight of the entire company on your back.
6:56 Speaker 03 That's where the transformative power of co-founders comes in. Co-founders don't exactly lessen the workload. There's more than enough to go around. But they can distribute the work, bringing complementary perspectives and skill sets that help you conquer problems with conviction and creativity. I wanted to talk to Stephen Hawthornthwaite and Roth Martin about this because as co-founders of the sustainable shoe and handbag company, Rothies, they've leveraged each other's strengths to build Rothies into an e-commerce Cinderella story. Celebrities from Kristen Bell to Meghan Markle have been photographed in their eco-friendly shoes knitted with yarn made from recycled water bottles.
7:39 Speaker 03 As of 2022, the company has diverted nearly 150 million single-use plastic water bottles from landfills or the ocean. And we'll get to how they did it in just a moment. But first, a short disclaimer. There's one word you're going to be hearing a lot of in the next 30 minutes, and that word is "if." Because the relationship between you and your co-founder, whether it's one or many, is personal and conditional. When I say that two co-founders are better than one, that's only true if you work well together, if you are equally committed, and if together you build a plan to empower future employees. Pay attention to that word "if" in Rothies' founding journey.
8:23 Speaker 03 Because their story is so full of uphill battles and tough breaks, it would be a minor miracle for Rothies to succeed at all if it weren't for Roth and Stephen's incredible co-founder relationship.
8:35 Speaker 07 It was October of 2011, and we were at a friend's 40th birthday party.
8:42 Speaker 03 That's Stephen.
8:43 Speaker 07 We had met each other through our wives and had been friends for about six years at the time.
8:48 Speaker 03 That's Roth. And they're about to tell us about the night these friends decided to become business partners. We were in the back room of a restaurant in San Francisco.
8:58 Speaker 06 I think there were probably forty or fifty people there and Roth and I were seated together.
9:04 Speaker 03 Professionally, they couldn't have been more different. Steven had spent years in investment banking, advising on mergers and acquisitions at Barclays and other firms. Roth, meanwhile, was in art and antiques, running the Hedge Gallery in San Francisco's financial district. But there was one thing they realized they had in common: they were both looking for a change.
9:26 Speaker 06 I was forty-one at that point, Roth was thirty-seven.
9:29 Speaker 07 I was sitting at the dinner complaining about what I was doing.
9:32 Speaker 06 I had made the decision at that point to leave the deal business in the hopes of starting my own business.
9:39 Speaker 07 And I was just becoming increasingly disenchanted with what I was doing at work.
9:43 Speaker 03 We just realized that professionally, we were in the same place at the same time. As they talked, Roth and Steven each saw something valuable in the other. Individually, each had been feeling the need for a career shift, but together, party talk started morphing into something more serious. The two decided to go into business together. What that business would entail, that would come second. And here's where we'll want to deploy the magic word, if, because this is not a template that works for everyone. Many co-founder relationships start with a product idea first, a better mousetrap, or the next killer app. Others, like Roth and Steven, form the relationship first and then start talking product.
10:27 Speaker 03 Both are valid, but only one might be right for you. One of the first decisions Roth and Steven had to make was whether to go into software or physical goods. Or, as I often describe it, the world of bits or atoms. If you said, hey, there's these two guys who are founders, one has in-depth technology and experience, the other one has been running an amazing gallery. What product do you think you create? Women's shoes wouldn't be top of mind, right?
10:58 Speaker 06 Really, right? Reid, you'd be surprised how many times we heard that.
11:01 Speaker 07 We weren't thinking about service businesses or technology businesses. We had a shared passion around creating a physical product that was innovative, right? That didn't exist. Both of us were adamant about not creating a copy and paste product that you just add marketing to. And maybe it was naive, but really believed in like, if we built the product right, it would sell itself.
11:22 Speaker 03 Steven and Roth started to think about the patterns they'd been observing in their daily lives. Was there a product not yet invented that might actually sell itself? That's when their attention drifted to something they both saw, their spouses. If you wind the clock back and you think about 2011, women were in Lululemon tights all the time.
11:44 Speaker 07 All of a sudden, every woman we knew was wearing Lululemon leggings and they had no idea what shoes to wear them with. They were wearing them with running shoes when they weren't going running. They were wearing them with flip flops sometimes, with dressy flats.
11:58 Speaker 03 Both of our wives would go to SoulCycle or yoga, drop the kids off at school, maybe go to the office, out to dinner. And there just wasn't a clear footwear complement to that outfit.
12:09 Speaker 07 There's all these frustrations around it. It was like, God, these kill my feet. I love these, but I don't want to ruin them today. Just was like a lightbulb moment.
12:18 Speaker 03 Notice that this lightbulb moment might not have occurred to either Roth or Steven on their own, but together they were able to recognize a pattern. This wasn't just something their own wives were struggling with. It was a common problem with a large, total addressable market. This is one of the co-founder effects most powerful functions, making it easier to spot major trends. Each person added to the team acts as a prism to reflect back and clarify the observations of the others.
12:50 Speaker 07 I think really the white spaces kept drawing us back to this, that there was a true need for it. Witnessing our wives and women we knew not knowing that this product didn't exist and how much that they really would value it.
13:03 Speaker 03 For Roth and Steven, the appeal of this white space was electrifying. A well-designed shoe that behaved like a sneaker and tapped in the Lululemification of women's wardrobes. This was a product that might sell itself once it met the market. Now Roth and Steven just had to figure out how to make it. We had no idea how hard footwear is. We had a vision that if we could crack the code on creating the perfect shoe that really sits at the front of the closet, that's equal parts, style, comfort, and sustainability, that we'd have a shot at
13:38 Speaker 05 Building a global brand. What we didn't know was that it was going to take four years to create the product.
13:46 Speaker 03 Keep that four-year timeline in mind. That will become relevant a little later. It's worth noting that Steven and Roth were entering an industry in which they had zero experience. This isn't a small challenge. If you're building a software product, having a technical co-founder is almost always a stronger position than if you have to hire out all the coding. And in fact, some VCs will insist that you add a technical co-founder before they invest. But again, let's deploy the word "if." The entrepreneurship journey is one of constant learning, and presumably, something you're doing has never been done before, or else there's no room for upside in your business.
14:27 Speaker 03 This is where newcomers can bring a unique outsider perspective that can disrupt old, calcified ways of doing things. Entering an unfamiliar sector doesn't have to be fatal to a startup or an established business, if you and your co-founders and teammates can learn the rules quickly. This is how Steven and Roth found themselves in southern China, crisscrossing the landscape to learn about their newly adopted industry: shoe manufacturing.
14:53 Speaker 07 Driving four hours this way in a minivan and four hours that way across Guangzhou, we took this trip to China and toured footwear factories left and right.
15:02 Speaker 03 Steven and Roth were in China to learn their new business. One dismal discovery: shoemaking is wasteful. All the die-cutting and all the off-cut waste, look at leather or fabric, if you need a circle, you start with a square piece of fabric and you die-cut out a circle. Cutting a circle out of a square means you're shedding all those corners and throwing them on the scrap heap. It's simple geometry with profound consequences for the planet. But that wasn't the only wasteful process Roth and Steven noticed.
15:36 Speaker 07 Behind each subsequent door was another thing that didn't make sense. Why does it require so many materials to make a shoe? Why is the supply chain so disparate? Or when we went to look at the merchandising processes, why are lead times so long? Why make a product if you may not even sell it? To produce the materials, to commit the labor to it, to make a box for it, to put it in an ocean container and ship it across the world...
16:06 Speaker 05 To have it sit in some warehouse, and maybe in the worst case of all, it's incinerated.
16:14 Speaker 06 That's what ultimately led to knitting. Why can't we just knit the circle from the beginning and only use the material we need?
16:23 Speaker 03 That's right. Roth and Steven's answer to a more sustainable manufacturing process was to deploy the same process that makes sweaters and mittens for making shoes.
16:34 Speaker 03 Knitting the upper soother shoes would make them much more sustainable in two ways. First, as Steven just told us, it meant that they could produce just the material they needed at the moment they needed it. And second, it would allow them to make their own yarn from reclaimed ocean plastic using computer-aided design software in a process called additive manufacturing. It's sort of like 3D printing. In fact, it is 3D knitting. Note, their vision came long before they'd worked out the details, but if they could pull it off, the environmental implications would be huge.
17:10 Speaker 05 Really, the innovation with which we were trying to create shoes had never been done before, which is a massive reduction in the amount of parts, materials, suppliers, all these kinds of things.
17:21 Speaker 03 Figuring out low-waste manufacturing was one kind of disruption they wanted to take on. The other wasn't about what to make, but where.
17:30 Speaker 06 Out of the gate, we wanted to do this in the US. We had networked through LinkedIn to a number of footwear professionals in the US, and we told them, you know, we're going to try to do this in the US. And they said, you are certifiably crazy. Like, it cannot be done. The entire footwear supply chain in the US went offshore in the 80s and the 90s. Everyone knows this has to be done in China.
17:55 Speaker 03 Roth and Steven had wanted to onshore jobs to the United States. They were also skeptical that they'd be able to convince factories in China to change everything and do things their way. So they started testing and probing the problem. This is a powerful advantage of the co-founder effect. When you conceive of a radically new approach to an old way of doing things, it could mean you're delusional, or it could mean you're about to become a major disruptor. And often, what separates one from the other is the ability to problem solve and the conviction to keep going. It's hard enough to tell an entire industry, "Hey, you're doing things wrong." But it's much harder when you're the only one saying it.
18:38 Speaker 03 And that's true whether you're founding something new or are in an established business trying to make a change. Having even one other co-conspirator to poke holes in the status quo gives you the resilience and confidence to say, "This can work." Steven and Roth badly wanted manufacturing their shoes in the US to work. So they scouted for anyone who might be able to help them. And as it turns out, they did have one surprising predecessor in this space. The military, they're required to make their boots in the US with US materials. So we went to military boot manufacturing complexes, one in Tennessee. We went to Puerto Rico.
19:20 Speaker 03 We thought if we can find the machinery, we may also find some of the materials. We ultimately ended up in a town called Lewiston, Maine in 1938. They made more shoes in Lewiston, Maine than anywhere else in the world. We decide that we need to set up a workshop or a small factory. We're convinced that there are enough engineers and suppliers in the area, and we start to work.
19:43 Speaker 05 We set up shop above a used footwear machine salesman. He was fixing up these old 1950s Goodyear welding machines, and we got a little bit of know-how from him. Everyone was trying to contribute and say, "Well, you might try this." All these different things. Came down to almost reverse engineering the supply chain.
20:03 Speaker 07 We ended up developing the shoe we practically make today, the flat, here in the US.
20:10 Speaker 03 This development process itself was a feat of engineering and co-founding. Because some of your most important co-founders aren't limited to the people you formed the company with. It could be the machine repair downstairs from you, or the early employee who invents a great cultural practice, or the supplier who fixes a supply chain challenge. In the case of Rothy's, that supply chain piece was one of the most critical puzzles to solve. Earlier, we talked about the additive manufacturing process that enabled Rothy's to knit the uppers of their shoes with yarn made of recycled plastic, such as the kind you get from single-use water bottles. Spinning empty bottles into yarn like an eco-friendly Rumpelstiltskin
20:52 Speaker 03 wasn't a broadly available process at the time, so they had to create their own.
20:59 Speaker 07 Our yarn, we had developed with a US supplier to transform single-use plastic water bottles into a yarn.
21:08 Speaker 07 We had developed the machinery and the computer programs to knit our parts and assemble the shoes in the US.
21:16 Speaker 03 Creating their own process for sourcing materials was a major triumph. Maybe they could revitalize an American industry, single-handedly. But then, one year of research and development turned into two, and two turned into three.
21:33 Speaker 07 This just ended up to be a very lengthy development process.
21:37 Speaker 03 People really were looking at us and like, okay, guys, you've been working on this for three years. We have yet to see a shoe. What is taking so long? We think it's a great idea, but somebody's gonna come out with something else.
21:51 Speaker 03 As often happens in the world of atoms, developing the prototype was one hurdle. Getting to mass production was a taller one.
21:59 Speaker 07 After considerable time and a lot of challenges with getting the product consistent, really,
22:06 Speaker 06 We're at the dead end and looked at each other one day and I said to Stephen, I said, look, I think I better go to China.
22:14 Speaker 06 And so I left Stephen in Maine and I flew with our yarn and the machinery and the computer programs to knit our parts.
22:24 Speaker 06 I took all that in a Pelican storm case and flew over to a sweater factory in Fujian, China.
22:34 Speaker 03 One benefit of co-founders is the ability to actually be in two places at once. But which place would hold the future of their company remain to be seen?
22:46 Speaker 00 We all know the disappointment that comes when a grand gesture falls flat, something that seemed impressive in the moment, but didn't deliver the results you expected. Marketing budgets too often fall into that trap, aiming for big impressions, big reach, but without the revenue to back it. LinkedIn has a name for it, bull spend. LinkedIn ads generate the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. They target by company, industry, job title, and more. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
23:29 Speaker 00 When you've built substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative Planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity, when to diversify, how to manage tax risk, and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale. Stripe Treasury is your new financial operating system built for what's next. With Stripe Treasury, the place your business accepts payments is also where you can store balances, move funds, and pay vendors worldwide.
24:13 Speaker 00 If you're building for global scale, get a business bank account that lets your money move instantly, whenever and wherever you need it. Learn more at stripe.com/treasury. Stripe is not a bank. Banking services provided by Fifth Third Bank, National Association, Member FDIC.
24:31 Speaker 03 We're back with Stephen Hawthorne Thwait and Roth Martin of Rothies. If you're enjoying this episode, share it with your co-founders by clicking the share button in your podcast app. And to hear our complete conversation with Roth and Stephen, become a Masters of Scale member at mastersofscale.com/membership. There, you'll find stories we didn't have time to cover in this episode, like Roth's early adventures in biotech and the time Stephen spent learning how to make men's suits. And you'll hear how Rothies took their e-commerce business, IRL, at the farmer's market in San Francisco's Ferry Building. You won't want to miss it. When we left off, Roth and Stephen had just made a dramatic decision in the life of Rothies.
25:13 Speaker 03 For over three years, they had worked to develop a washable, versatile women's flat, knitted from plastic water bottles, and made in America. They had ticked the first two boxes on that list, but the third had proven an unvanquished foe. After all that time, they still didn't have a product release date or a timetable for when that date might be.
25:35 Speaker 07 We were able to make 30 or 40 pairs of shoes that were okay, but they were not beautiful, and the writing was on the wall.
25:45 Speaker 03 So they had sent Roth to China to see if a factory there might be more viable. And at bearish saying, this moment of reckoning can be a bitter one. You've been hammering away at executing on something that's critical to the mission, but the obstacles and market realities have been hammering back. And at some point, it begins to dawn on you that the obstacles might win, and you start to wonder if it happened because you and your colleagues had the same blind spots. Sometimes, we refer to this as groupthink, which we are generally told to avoid, but allow me to offer a slight reinterpretation of that word, which I shared recently with my producers. Blind spots are just the flip side of strengths and weaknesses. We go, well, our blind spot is a predisposition to speed.
26:30 Speaker 03 And sometimes we don't realize that sometimes it needs to be done long. Yep, right? So it's kind of just a question of shaping the right ones. Where these are our collective hypotheses, our collective theory of the world. And what you're really saying, group think, is the ones that are bad, that might kill you, that you're not seeing because of your point of view. And that means you have to be able to ask each other, learning like, oh, I talked to this really smart person. Maybe we should take this seriously. I see this happening with our competitor. I see this happening in the market. Maybe we should reevaluate this. We have a group learning that us learning and being right is more important than our collective theory of the case. Roth may have been the first to see that their factory in Maine
27:14 Speaker 03 wasn't going to get them to scale. But the learning was a collective one with both of the co-founders. So instead of doubling down on an old mistake, they moved forward. A decision that had its own challenges.
27:27 Speaker 05 I flew over to a sweater factory in Fujian, China, and set up with them. And keep in mind that Roth does not speak Mandarin. And he's using WeChat to communicate. China all of a sudden was like, oh, my God, I can access materials, you know, in an nanosecond. I can access the know-how, the engineering, all these things.
27:48 Speaker 03 Through grit, determination, and WeChat, Roth worked with fabricators in that sweater factory to see how quickly they could produce a Rothy shoe.
27:57 Speaker 05 We had no formal agreement, nothing. I gave them our programs. We started to work immediately and made progress. Called Steven about a week later, I think, and was like, you know what? This is just never going to happen in the US.
28:09 Speaker 03 When you're wrong and realize you've been wrong, the right partner gives you double the resilience to keep going and double the manpower to put things back on track. As Roth scaled operations in China, it fell to Steven to shutter the factory in Maine.
28:24 Speaker 07 So after I shut down the factory, I'm in the background, working in the US, trying to set up an e-commerce business, setting up Shopify, doing photo shoots.
28:34 Speaker 05 And so it was really going in parallel.
28:37 Speaker 03 As both co-founders followed these parallel tracks, one fact was becoming clear. Their US factory may have failed, but the product they'd innovated at that factory really held up. The additive 3D knitting process using reclaimed plastic yarn went shockingly fast in the hands of Chinese manufacturers. Every day, production was gaining speed. However, there was one thing they'd had at the US factory that was proving harder to replicate in China using contractors, and that was team cohesion.
29:09 Speaker 05 So along the journey had OEMs defraud us.
29:14 Speaker 06 OEM, original equipment manufacturer.
29:18 Speaker 05 Had workers treated incredibly poorly where they weren't paid, had machinery stolen. And so navigating that really started to create the desire to build our own factory and to do things in a way that would ideally influence the state of manufacturing in China.
29:36 Speaker 03 These painful experiences, working with a piecemeal workforce, taught Roth and Stephen a critical lesson. The wrong partners are as detrimental to your growth as the right partners are additive. Building their wholly owned factory in China wasn't feasible, yet, but little by little, they did their best to build a team they could rely on.
29:56 Speaker 05 I would say by October or November, the shoes were far enough along that we confirmed a final order. I think Roth and I bought 8,000 pairs of shoes. Our website was ready. We combined our Rolodexes, which was, for me, bankers, attorneys, friends from schools. Roth had gallerists and artists. Maybe we had 5,000 names.
30:21 Speaker 03 Stephen mentions this in passing, but their ability to combine two vastly different sets of contacts is no small thing. It's one reason that diversity of experience is a great thing for co-founders to have, because when you combine networks, it's more than additive. It's a force multiplier. Nearly five years after the fateful birthday party that brought Stephen and Roth together, they got their 5,000 name mailing list all ready and launched their first campaign.
30:48 Speaker 05 It was a very quiet launch. We didn't make a lot of noise. We just hit send on a few emails.
30:54 Speaker 03 The launch may have started quietly, but it soon took on a distinctive sound.
31:00 Speaker 06 We were on Shopify, right? And Shopify has this amazing sound, but it's like cha-ching, right? And this thing is just cha-chinging, cha-chinging, cha-chinging. Holy is it ever gonna stop? You look in, you start to look at the orders, you're like, oh, I know that person. Oh, God, they're just being nice. And I know that person, they're being nice. Then, you know, a couple of days later, it's like, I don't know this person. I don't know this person. Oh, my God. I think they might like this, right?
31:24 Speaker 05 The analogy I use sometimes, we decided we were going to bake a cake. We had no idea what a cake was. We didn't have a recipe. We spent four years figuring out what that recipe was. No one really tried the cake. And then we put it up for sale and people said it was the best cake they've ever had.
31:42 Speaker 03 This instant kind of product market fit is not the norm. Rather, it's a combination of luck, timing, and design. The integrity Roth and Stephen both brought to building their product was reflected in the responses from customers, which is not to say that the existential fires stopped burning the day they launched.
32:02 Speaker 05 We sold a couple hundred thousand dollars worth of product and we thought, wow, it's been almost five years. Now we're gonna go on vacation. And we woke up on December 25th to an inbox that was just overflowing with emails about, hey, this is a great product. I want to exchange. How do I do that? I got a gift card. How do I use it? And I think that's when we quickly realized like, this is real. There's no holiday vacation.
32:28 Speaker 03 For nearly five years, Roth and Stephen had been operating more or less on their own clock, dictated only by their resources and personal capital. That's actually rare. More often, new business ventures find themselves racing multiple competitors to scale. As much as Stephen and Roth had been frustrated by the lack of imagination in footwear, it was this very lack that gave them time to innovate and build their product. But the launch drastically accelerated their timeframe. If Rothies couldn't deliver an e-commerce experience as beautiful as their shoes, their customers would evaporate or drift to a competitor who by now would be on their trail. They had to move fast. So once again, the co-founders divided and conquered.
33:14 Speaker 06 Steven went about fixing a lot of our e-commerce problems and
33:18 Speaker 05 And answering thousands of emails, one by one.
33:21 Speaker 06 He did. He was the sole customer service representative. And I went back to China.
33:27 Speaker 03 Notice how Roth and Steven each claim their own area of expertise, even if it didn't start out as something they were expert in. Nothing about Steven's previous experience said he would be a fit to handle thousands of customer service emails. And as we've discussed, Roth's experience with the manufacturers in China was learned entirely on the fly. Each co-founder had to trust that the other would learn to master their new skill set. That trust is what growing teams learn to rely on.
33:55 Speaker 06 I think that's one of the dynamics. You're always trying not to let each other down. And I think that pushes you to actually ideally outperform.
34:02 Speaker 03 As Steven dug into every customer question, Roth worked to fulfill the dream of opening Rothies' own vertically-integrated factory.
34:11 Speaker 06 Factory is rich. It was a tiny office with two knitting machines. And I started to hire a few good people, and a few good people led to a few more good people, and that's how it started.
34:21 Speaker 03 A few good people leading to a few more good people sounds like a simple formula. But in fact, this is the way team building works. The co-founder effect provides a model all teams can use as they scale, where each new member has room to add their voice to the mix. And if everyone's playing well together, more voices are better than fewer.
34:43 Speaker 06 January 1st, 2017, we cote over to our own factory, and we were nine people making shoes. And we like to say, if you were a dog on the street that knew how to make shoes, we would have hired you.
34:54 Speaker 03 Our fact checker asked us to mention that dogs lack the opposable thumbs and fine motor skills for machine work. But you get his point. Opening their own factory let Rothies close a loop that had been stubbornly open for five years.
35:09 Speaker 06 There are very, very few footwear manufacturers that own their own supply chain or that are vertically integrated. And we think it's the future. It is what has allowed us to innovate. The designers at Rothies get to put their hands on the products as they're on the manufacturing lines and optimize for like, oh God, that extra step there, I didn't realize the unintended consequences of me designing something a certain way results in a whole lot of extra work for someone else. And so that connectivity to the design process and the ability to put that back into iterating your designs and make them better is one of the true benefits of being vertically integrated.
35:47 Speaker 03 Remember, co-founders are more than just the person you started the company with. That goes for anyone creating and owning the processes to become more integral to the business. Consider it another kind of additive manufacturing where instead of adding plastic yarn in geometric shapes, you're adding people and their ideas. As Rothies scaled, their manufacturing got more and more reliable and their airtight product market fit has led them to steady growth ever since.
36:15 Speaker 05 Rothies is a beneficiary of a lot of repeat business. Our customers, once they try the product, they love it, they want to come back and buy again. We have customers that own seven pairs, 20 pairs, 40 pairs.
36:28 Speaker 03 Forty pairs?
36:30 Speaker 05 I mean, we have customers who send us pictures of their closets that they have had custom built to accommodate their Rothies collection. And for some people, it's also a considered purchase and they might own one pair.
36:43 Speaker 03 Roth and Steven, take these messages from customers seriously because in a way, your customers have a co-founding role as well. They can be your ambassadors, your quality control and your source for new ideas.
36:57 Speaker 05 I was really struck by the power of the consumer. And when you have a product or a service that really resonates with the customer, their desire to tell their friends. It's hard to create, but if you tap into that lightning in a bottle, how powerful it can be.
37:14 Speaker 03 In recent years, because of feedback from customers, Rothies has been able to launch new product lines like handbags, wallets, and men's shoes. And because of the customer love they've received over their commitment to sustainability, they can keep driving in that direction. In fact, they have very specific plans to make their company even more sustainable, which is one of the goals that Roth and Stephen bonded over when they first started.
37:40 Speaker 06 Rothies is incredibly proud to have pledged to be fully circular by next year. And we've run a pretty tremendous recycling program this year and using a lot of emerging technologies in that space, such as chemical recycling. On the sustainability front, there's so much happening on the fiber side, the shapes that you're able to impart onto those fibers, how they're spun. It's a space that there's a lot of innovation happening in. All that goes back into creating, you know, geez, those aha moments in the factory where you're like, why are you doing it that way? We could actually engineer this better. I think it's akin to cooking, right? You buy all these ingredients and you figure out how to put it together.
38:16 Speaker 03 Roth's reference to cooking makes perfect sense, and it leads us to the unspoken question beneath the subject of co-founding and adding more voices as you scale. Everyone is familiar with the saying, "Too many cooks in the kitchen." How do you ensure that you have the right number of cooks for your business? It comes back to our magic word, "if." If your cooks aren't well-coordinated, or if they're confused on who's making the final call, then even two cooks is too many. And you have to fix your processes before adding more. But if your chefs do play well together, trust each other, and value each other's expertise, then your number of co-founders and refounders
39:01 Speaker 03 can and should increase with time. We took this question of cooks to Renee Jorowski and Matt Kent, the artistic directors of Palavellis, from earlier in the show.
39:11 Speaker 02 I would say it is a real thing to have too many cooks in the kitchen, but it changes by the moment.
39:16 Speaker 04 I think it's all about the casting, in my opinion.
39:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, right, the hangout.
39:21 Speaker 04 It's all about the hangout. So yes, you can have 25 people, 25 cooks in the room. And if they're all talkers or they're all trying to take the spotlight, then that's too many cooks. But if you've got half listeners, half talkers, if you find this happy medium where you're not all vying for the spotlight at the same time, you find a flow, I think it depends on who's in the room.
39:48 Speaker 03 Exactly.
39:49 Speaker 05 As I reflect on it, you know, I think the starting point is trust.
39:53 Speaker 06 And I think if someone asks you to be a co-founder, you should just say yes to the first person who asks you. No, it's such a hard thing to get right. Being able to pass the baton back and forth is immensely powerful and I think helpful. And God, doing it by yourself as if it's not hard enough.
40:09 Speaker 03 Finding your perfect co-founder is rare, but your co-founder and your next team members can come from anywhere if you share values, trust each other, and bring equal commitment to the mission. Accomplish that, and the co-founder effect is that one plus one is significantly greater than two.
40:29 Speaker 05 At the end of the day, I can't imagine starting a company by myself. I really can't.
40:35 Speaker 03 I'm Reid Hoffman. Thanks for listening.
40:39 Speaker 00 Global hiring is such a headache when you're building fast, but don't let payroll, compliance, or onboarding slow you down. Companies like 11 Labs and Mistral are scaling globally and effortlessly with Deal. 11 Labs quadrupled their headcount in 2025, and Mistral pays 364 employees across 15 countries, all from one system. Build your global team with Deal. Visit deal.com/mos and start expanding your business today. That's D E E L dot com slash M O S.
41:15 Speaker 00 Every business hits the same wall the moment your business outgrows the systems that got you here. Spreadsheets everywhere, five different logins, data scattered across entities that don't even talk to each other. If your finance team spends more time finding data than using it, that's when you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI-native ERP solution that's powerful, painless, and proven, built for businesses scaling fast without the complexity that usually comes with it. From the makers of QuickBooks, learn more at intuit.com/erp.
41:56 Speaker 00 Before we get to the rest of our conversation today, I want to spend a moment sharing with you about Masters of Scale Summit, which returns to San Francisco this October 20th to 22nd. So many of us feel overwhelmed right now. It feels like so much of the world is careening, and we don't have power. We don't have agency. That's the thing about the Masters of Scale Summit. It's really designed to remind us that we do have agency, agency to lead, agency to design, to build the relationships and the partnerships that empower us and to make the change that we want to see. We program a stage, we curate an audience, we set a schedule that builds in time for these relationships to be made and to grow so that by the time you leave Summit,
42:40 Speaker 00 you are fired out of a cannon, ready to run through walls to do better in the world with the agency that you actually have. I hope to see you there. Visit mastersofscale.com/summit.
42:59 Speaker 03 Masters of Scale is a Wait What original. Our executive producers are June Cohen, Darren Triff, and Jordan McLeod. Our head of content and production is Lori Hoffman. Our producers are Adam Skuse, Catherine Clark-Bray, Alex Morris, Tucker Legursky, and Chris Gautier. Our editor-at-large is Bob Safian. Our music director is Ryan Holiday. Original music and sound design by Eduardo Rivera. Audio editing by Keith J. Nelson, Stephen Davies, Andrew Nold, and Brad Worrell. Mixing and mastering by Aaron Bastinelli. Special thanks to Chris Ye, Alisa Schreiber, Aria Finger, Saida Sapiyeva, Greg Beato, Adam Heiner, Alfonso Bravo, Colin Howarth,
43:42 Speaker 03 Willem Crowls, Tim Cronin, Kelsey Capitano, Samyoputa, Anna Pizzano, Sarah Tarter, Leah Sermedis, Charlie Meneses, Chineme Azequena, Emily McManus, Hallie Bondi, and Sierra Black. Become a member of Masters of Scale to get access to a year's worth of courses and content on the Masters of Scale courses app. Find out more at mastersofscale.com/membership.
44:11 Speaker 06 Hey listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show because every Friday we release a second Rapid Response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely, from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from The Devil Wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find. Just search Rapid Response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there.
Previous Rapid Response: The rise of the “wisdom worker,” w/Modern Elder Academy’s Chip Conley Next Rapid Response: Danny Meyer on the wrenching decision to do layoffs Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated