Pod Insights Masters of Scale The Big Pivot, w/Slack's Stewart Butterfield About this episode In your company’s darkest moment, remember: You CAN pivot from failure to success. But only if you slash and burn everything that isn’t working. Slack’s co-founder and CEO, Stewart Butterfield, has twice navigated this kind of Big Pivot. He launched two different game companies, which both (surprise!) turned into game-changing communications platforms: Flickr and Slack. Hear the thinking behind making a hard left turn —and bringing your team along with you.
Read a transcript of this interview at: https://mastersofscale.com/stewart-butterfield-the-big-pivot/
Subscribe to the Masters of Scale weekly newsletter: https://mastersofscale.com/subscribe
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 We've all spent money on something that seemed incredible but didn't live up to the hype. A kitchen gadget, a car. When it doesn't deliver, the disappointment is real. Marketers suffer from this too. Chasing metrics that look great but don't translate into revenue. LinkedIn calls that bull spend. Invest in what matters and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads. You can target by company, industry, job title, and more. LinkedIn Ads also generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
0:49 Speaker 01 AI is full of possibilities. Enterprises run on realities. That's why Pega combines the world's most powerful AI with the governance, transparency, and control enterprises demand. So you can move faster, adapt faster, and scale AI with competence. All the power of AI, none of the uncertainty. Learn more at Pega.com/AI.
1:21 Speaker 02 It's 2002. Dark days in Silicon Valley. The dot-com bubble had burst. Tech investors were quiet. Almost nothing of note was launching online. And then out of nowhere came an experimental video game called Game Never Ending. A role-playing game that was all about social interaction. You work with other players online to create a world. You build buildings, houses, and other objects.
1:53 Speaker 02 For the gaming nerds out there, it was kind of a precursor to Minecraft.
1:59 Speaker 02 You could pool your resources with friends to build structures, invent new objects, and reach higher levels together.
2:06 Speaker 02 Your objective? Just keep building.
2:13 Speaker 02 Don't stop.
2:17 Speaker 02 There was no way to win this game.
2:21 Speaker 02 Hence the title, "Game Never Ending." But a goal that the most hardcore fans aspired to was to build the final item of the game: a game never-ending. So meta.
2:35 Speaker 02 It was an offbeat, self-worth game that didn't take itself too seriously. The prototype had a great cult following with thousands of users who loved it. But...
2:44 Speaker 03 But we couldn't raise any money for that.
2:47 Speaker 02 That's Stuart Butterfield. You might know him as the founder of Slack, but before that, he created this daring new game just at the wrong time. As I said, it was 2002, dark days in Silicon Valley, and tech investors weren't thinking about gaming as an online experience yet.
3:04 Speaker 03 So it was a really black and bleak-looking point in the history of financial markets generally, but anything as frivolous as a game was just not going to get funded. We got to the point where the only person on the team who got paid was the one person on the team who had kids. And we needed some kind of Hail Mary.
3:22 Speaker 02 Ludacorp was running out of money. Having no idea what the next step was or what to tell his team, Stuart needed to stall. So he and his co-founder, Katarina Fake, got on a plane to New York to attend a video game conference. But before the plane landed, things got even worse.
3:38 Speaker 03 And this sounds almost made up, but on the way, I got food poisoning on the plane, puking on the Van Wick on the way into New York, arriving at the hotel, just being sick all night, it was like 3 or 4 in the morning, trying to keep anything down like ginger ale or water. And the whole idea for Flickr came to me.
3:59 Speaker 02 Flickr, one of the most successful photo-sharing sites of all time, an idea that forever changed the way we interact with photos online. You could argue it changed the way that we interact online, period. And the idea hits him while he's crunched over a toilet in a hotel with food poisoning, Silicon Valley Lord at its best. But at that moment, Flickr wasn't exactly a game-changing vision of the future. It was a way out of the mess his company was in.
4:28 Speaker 03 It wasn't coming from a grand vision of what photos could be. All that stuff came later. There was no insight. It was just like, can we not go out of business?
4:37 Speaker 02 Can we not go out of business? These are the words that launched a thousand pivots. In Stuart's case, it opened his eyes to a service that would change the way we interact with photos forever. It would pave the way for Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram. The idea had instant resonance. It caught fire with users. It got attention from investors. The only problem? He still had this whole gaming company still operating. What do you do with an idea that isn't working? You kill it. I believe you can pivot from failure to success, but only if you slash and burn the rest of your business.
5:16 Speaker 04 You've got to have incredible talent at every position.
5:20 Speaker 05 There are fires burning when you're going out. Can you believe it? Such an idiot. And then you go back to, this is totally going to be amazing. There are so many easy wins. I have no idea what to do. Sorry, we made a mistake. But you have to time it right. Oops. Working out of a three-bedroom apartment. Stuff that just seemed absolutely nutballs. 10 years later, we're like, well, that's just how you do it. We have it made. Just how you do it.
5:46 Speaker 02 This is Masters of Scale.
5:51 Speaker 02 I'm Reid Hoffman, co-founder of LinkedIn, partner at Greylock, and your host. I believe that you can pivot from failure to success, but only if you slash and burn the rest of your business. In Silicon Valley, entrepreneurs tend to celebrate this kind of daring pivot. They see an opportunity, they act, and they don't look back. Later on, they sound a bit like Caesar reporting to the Roman Senate. "I came, I saw, I conquered." But the truth is a lot messier. There's more to a pivot than a sharp left turn. First, there's the opportunity you're pivoting toward. Can you see it clearly enough to navigate towards it? Can you convince others to come along?
6:35 Speaker 02 And then you have to pivot away from your old idea. This can be incredibly difficult because it involves humans. And humans don't tend to let go of old ideas easily. You risk blowback from your co-founders, from your staff, your investors, and your users. This will likely be the single greatest test of your leadership skills because your credibility will come under scrutiny. Are you even believable anymore? I wanted to talk to Stuart Butterfield about this theory because he pulled off two uncanny pivots. He has twice launched game companies only to pivot towards game-changing communication platforms. First, as the co-founder of Flickr, the pioneer in photo sharing; and second, as the co-founder and CEO of Slack,
7:20 Speaker 02 a platform for group communication within teams that has taken off in Silicon Valley and beyond. Both companies, believe it or not, started as online video games. And at first, this might seem like a real leap. But when you learn a bit about Stuart, it starts to make a lot more sense. For one thing, Stuart likes video games, but he doesn't like-like them.
7:42 Speaker 03 I like playing games, but I wouldn't classify myself as a gamer. I don't own a console. I definitely have played my share of Civilization. And there's stupid iPhone games, which I'm embarrassed to say that I enjoy.
7:53 Speaker 02 He loves board games and card games, old-fashioned games that bring people together. And he wanted to bring that same sense of a communal experience to video games. And one thing you should know about Stuart, he has a lot of experience with communal experiences. Let me start at the beginning.
8:13 Speaker 02 Stuart grew up in a quirky Canadian fishing village called Lund. Drive north along British Columbia's Highway 101 as far as the road will take you, and you'll arrive. There's a welcome sign at the entrance to the town that reads Lund, the end of Highway 101. It also reads Lund, the start of Highway 101. That's your first clue that the residents of Lund are an open-minded bunch. Lund was founded in the late 19th century, but settled primarily by American hippies in the 1960s. And that's where Stuart Butterfield was born. His birth name was Dharma.
8:53 Speaker 06 Let's name him Dharma.
8:55 Speaker 02 How about Moon Pickle? He changed it to Stuart at age 12. As far as I can tell, Stuart has taken to the capitalist lifestyle swimmingly, but I had to ask him about those formative years. So you lived with your parents in a log cabin that had no running water for a few years. Did this shape you as an entrepreneur?
9:13 Speaker 03 I'd like to say that there was some of that no running water, no electricity rubbed off of me in an Abe Lincoln kind of way, but I don't know if that's actually true.
9:22 Speaker 02 So he might not be an Abe Lincoln, but those years in the cabin gave him a particular lens in the world. It shaped, among other things, how he thinks about games and their ability to bring people together.
9:33 Speaker 03 My dad loved to play bridge, and he didn't like playing bridge against the computer, like there was just nothing there. He also wouldn't have invited the same three people over to his house just to hang out with and do nothing, but inviting them over to play bridge, and there was this magic. There's like, it's exercising a part of your brain, which is fun to exercise, but there's also camaraderie. I brought it here. And there's trash talking, and there's like a good amount of competition.
9:57 Speaker 02 So when Stuart thinks about games, he's thinking about something much bigger and more essential.
10:02 Speaker 03 It's not games that are so interesting to me, it's play as an excuse to interact with people socially.
10:09 Speaker 02 And this is the right way to think about Stuart's first venture: game never-ending. It was, at its essence, an excuse to interact with people socially, but it had some fatal flaws. Among them, bad timing.
10:22 Speaker 03 We were never going to raise money for the game. I had tried everything. I had put all of my savings into it. We had tapped out friends and family. We had more or less worked through all of the very small amount of angel investment we were able to get.
10:35 Speaker 02 Stuart's failing game needed a lifeline, and that's typically the moment just before the pivot. There are some examples of peacetime pivots, driven entirely by opportunity, but that's not typical. Pivots almost always spring from failure. It was the failure of game never-ending that forced Stuart to think about what would come next. And his moment of revelation over a hotel toilet in New York City gave him the idea for Flickr, the photo-sharing site. But the idea didn't come to him fully-formed. It started out hazy, as many pivots do. The initial idea incorporated photo-sharing into the game itself.
11:14 Speaker 03 We had this game interface. In the game, you had an inventory. You could pick up objects. We made that inventory a shoebox full of photos. And you could do interesting things, like drag photos around onto group conversations, and they would pop up on the other person's screen. You could annotate them in real time. And there was chatting in the game, so you could talk to the fellow players. That became a cornerstone of Flickr. Here's the twist, though. That was the first idea for Flickr, which was actually really a terrible idea that had a lot of technological innovation. And so it wowed a lot of people, but it wasn't a very useful product.
11:48 Speaker 02 Flickr may not have been entirely useful, nor fully-formed, when the idea first came to him. But the idea of sharing photos had immediate traction.
11:57 Speaker 03 Maybe three months in, it was pretty obvious that Flickr had legs. So people started to use it. People were talking about it. It got a lot of good press.
12:06 Speaker 02 For Stuart, Flickr was a sort of homecoming to his deep-seated interest in just hanging out. And that's great for Stuart. But what about the rest of his team? They had signed up to build game never-ending, and that kind of pivot can be brutal. I asked Stuart how they took the news. They were no longer a gaming company.
12:26 Speaker 03 It was rough and there was definitely differing opinions. There was a lot of arguments about what we should be doing. And for a time, we were working both on the game and on Flickr. The team was still really split, so we had a vote. And I remember this really distinctly because I had to do some backroom politicking. After the first vote ended, it was a tie game. So I called up one of my co-founders who's in New York and had to do some horse trading. Felt like I was a senator.
12:54 Speaker 02 When your team is split, it might seem smart to hedge your bets and pursue both ideas at once. It may seem to keep the peace with your team, but as a founder, you never want to say, "We're working on X and we're also working on Y because my team likes both ideas." That may be the expedient solution, but I can tell you how that story ends, like Thelma and Louise, holding hands and driving over a cliff together. You actually owe it to your team to force a decision. X or Y, choose one. It's ultimately the founder's responsibility to make that call, but you have to bring your team along. This is the situation Stuart found himself in. He almost had the votes he needed, but there was one holdout.
13:39 Speaker 03 Well, I mentioned earlier that there was one person on the team who had kids and was continuing to get paid. That was him.
13:45 Speaker 02 And this happened to be one of his co-founders at Ludacorp. Everyone else was willing to work without pay, but he had a family to provide for. Mallets to feed, soccer camp to pay for. And this was the holdout vote that Stuart needed to stop working on the game and fully focus on Flickr.
14:02 Speaker 03 So it was a little bit more, let's play this out a couple of months and see if you'd like to continue to get paid, there's only one way we're going to do this. And I wasn't, I didn't mean that to be threatening at all, just we were never going to raise money for the game.
14:16 Speaker 02 Hold on, rewind.
14:19 Speaker 03 If you'd like to continue to get paid, there's only one way we're gonna do this.
14:23 Speaker 02 Did Stuart just threaten that guy's paycheck? Not exactly. You have to understand that Stuart had the kind of trusted relationship with his co-founder where this was permitted. Working for a startup is kind of like going to war together. When you're crouched in the bunker with the rest of your platoon, you form massive trust. If I've seen you look out for me, I'm gonna look out for you. So Stuart's campaigning was pragmatic rather than antagonistic. He's saying, "Look, we all love working on the game, but the reality is there won't be any money left if we keep doing this." His co-founder heard him and got on board.
14:59 Speaker 03 And we had another vote the next day, and this time the Flickr side won. You know, at that point, I think we had less to lose and there was less invested. And it wasn't as traumatic as the next big pivot, which was Glitch to Slack. That was, you know, seven years later.
15:18 Speaker 02 And we will come to that. Indeed, we will come to that. And you Slack fans may be eager for me to pivot. But this transition from game never ending to Flickr is just such a perfect example of an extreme pivot. I had to test a few more theories. I believe that as CEO, you always have to bring the core team along during a pivot. You have to make them feel like it was a joint decision. It doesn't have to be completely democratic. In fact, it shouldn't be democratic. But it has to feel democratic. People have to feel they have a voice. And as Stuart campaigned, he was essentially hacking the quasi-democracy, saying, "Yes, your vote counts, but I can persuade you because I have your interests at heart."
16:03 Speaker 02 Finally, the team could focus on Flickr and slash and burn the rest. So Stuart and his co-founders have navigated what was in many ways a prototypical pivot. They're going down a path which was getting narrower and rougher and seemingly leading nowhere. They see a different path leading to a better place, and they pivot toward it. They lead a team through a difficult organizational transition. They weather a storm from existing customers. It might seem like the most harrowing transition was behind them. But keep in mind, Stuart wasn't just suggesting a hairpin turn for his team. He was suggesting a hairpin turn for the internet.
16:40 Speaker 03 Almost all the photo sharing at that time was entirely centered around printing. And that was the idea of what people wanted to do with digital photographs. So that, in one sense, made it very easy. There was a lot of competition at the time. There was Snapfish, Shutterfly, there was Ophoto, which Kodak had bought, and Kodak had put a lot of muscle behind it. And none of them thought of the internet, as far as I could tell, as a social medium in itself and a worthwhile place to put photos.
17:07 Speaker 02 With Flickr, the sharing itself became the primary goal.
17:13 Speaker 02 Not a print or a mug. And if this concept seems awfully familiar, it's because Flickr laid the foundation for everything we do today on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. Tagging, sharing, following, memes. It was arguably the first comprehensive experiment in modern social media, a testbed for innovations.
17:36 Speaker 02 Flickr changed the paradigm of social interaction online. It succeeded because they had the right idea at the right time, and they made the right bets. But they also had another secret weapon: good, old-fashioned manners. They knew that for Flickr to succeed as an online community, it had to be a community, period.
17:56 Speaker 03 I think one of the strengths of Flickr was a really unique culture, and a huge amount of effort went into setting that. So Katerina Fake, one of the founders of Flickr and my ex, she greeted every single user individually. There's another designer on our team, a woman named George Oates, same thing. And so I think a lot of what made Flickr great in the end came from that germ of a really strong and positive community.
18:22 Speaker 02 We'll hear more about building a strong community later this season from Katerina, Stuart's co-founder, who was equally fundamental to Flickr's success. The Flickr community scaled fast, and in 2005, Stuart and his co-founders sold Flickr to Yahoo.
18:37 Speaker 03 It all happened so fast. We launched in February 2004. And by March 2005, the acquisition by Yahoo had closed. Basically, a year in market and maybe 10 and 1/2 months before we were in the middle of negotiations.
18:54 Speaker 02 In 2008, Stuart left Yahoo. As an aside, he wrote an epic and rather confusing resignation letter to his boss at the time, Brad Garlandhouse. It's odd and wonderful. Look for it. Now Stuart had money, connections and a track record. He decided to launch a new project. You'll never guess what it was. Yes, another online social game. This one was called Glitch.
19:21 Speaker 00 We all know the disappointment that comes when a grand gesture falls flat. Something that seemed impressive in the moment, but didn't deliver the results you expected. Marketing budgets too often fall into that trap. Aiming for big impressions, big reach, but without the revenue to back it. LinkedIn has a name for it. Bullspend. LinkedIn Ads generate the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. They target by company, industry, job title and more. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 credit for the next one. Just go to LinkedIn.com/scale. That's LinkedIn.com/scale. Terms and conditions apply.
20:05 Speaker 00 When you've built substantial wealth through your business, it's often tied up in a single equity position. The upside is real, but so is the risk and knowing when to act isn't always obvious. Creative Planning works with business owners to build a strategy around concentrated equity. When to diversify, how to manage tax risk and how to protect what you've spent years building. Creative Planning, where wealth works together. Learn more at creativeplanning.com/mastersofscale. Every business hits the same wall the moment your business outgrows the systems that got you here. Spreadsheets everywhere, five different logins, data scattered across entities that don't even talk to each other.
20:48 Speaker 00 If your finance team spends more time finding data than using it, that's when you need the Intuit ERP. Intuit Enterprise Suite is the AI-native ERP solution that's powerful, painless and proven. Built for businesses scaling fast without the complexity that usually comes with it. From the makers of QuickBooks, learn more at intuit.com/ERP.
21:14 Speaker 03 The idea was pretty much the same as Game Never End, except that the technology was much better, so people could be much more creative and could be higher fidelity. A game world with no combat, very absurdist, probably too highbrow and too intellectual. Dr. Seuss meets Monty Python meets Borges. Yeah, so already you can tell that in an era where Farmville was just beginning to take off, this was not an easy sell to America's casual gamers.
21:46 Speaker 02 In retrospect, perhaps not an easy sell, but at the time, they were sure this game would be different. This game would be huge.
21:53 Speaker 03 From our perspective, okay. Now we have some money, that makes it easier. Now we have better connections. But also, computer hardware got, I don't know, a hundredfold better in those seven or eight years. We were more experienced and capable as engineers and designers. So the thought was, oh, we can't fail this time. Like, there's just no way with all of these, you know, 10 Xs that combined to make it like 1,000 or 10,000 times easier for us, it would be impossible to fail.
22:22 Speaker 02 Yes, that's usually the Ozamandian warning.
22:28 Speaker 02 So it seemed like the Glitch team had everything they needed to succeed, and the stakes were higher this time. Stuart and his team were in deep. Four years of development, 45 employees, tens of thousands of players, 17.5 million dollars raised. Glitch had a small community fanbase, but it was failing.
22:46 Speaker 03 At this point, I've learned that this is not going to be a commercially viable creation. It was incredibly powerful for the small minority of people for whom it worked. So they spent 20 hours a week playing, and they were very committed. It was a super tight community. But most people, like, you know, 97% who signed up would be out of there within five minutes.
23:09 Speaker 02 Glitch was losing money fast. For the second time in his career, Stuart needed a lifeline.
23:16 Speaker 03 The last 18 months were just a series of experiments. And like, what if we did this? What if we tried that? Maybe it's just missing this feature. We were pretty good at getting people's attention, because we had more of a reputation, we were more connected, so we could get lots of articles written about us. Because it did always seem like the next thing was going to be what saved it. Something that just didn't work.
23:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:46 Speaker 02 You can hear in Stuart's voice. He still asks himself whether he could have saved it. And these questions form the inner dialogue of most entrepreneurs in the thick of a transition. Later on, successful entrepreneurs often tell the story of the one daring pivot. They leave out the fumbles and the false starts along the way. The truth is, most entrepreneurs pivot many times before they find their footing. Sometimes you find your way cleanly to success, and sometimes you don't.
24:14 Speaker 03 There was a night where I just lost faith. Like, I just realized, okay, I have tried the 15, like, stack-ranked best ideas we could possibly come up with to turn this around, and I don't think the 16th was gonna work if the first 15 didn't.
24:32 Speaker 02 Stuart knew what the numbers were telling him. For the second time in his life, he would have to close up shop on a product and team he loved.
24:42 Speaker 03 But man, that is, it is so hard. Because the job of a CEO is often just to come up with a story that enough people believe that you can make something happen in the world. I mean, you have to convince investors, and you have to convince the press, and you have to convince potential employees, and you have to convince customers. And I'd done a lot of convincing of people. You know, a lot of convincing of people to come work on this project, to leave whatever thing they were working on before, quit their job, get paid poorly in exchange for equity. It's something that just didn't work.
25:15 Speaker 02 Stuart pulled the plug on Glitch before the money ran out, but he found a series of graceful exits.
25:23 Speaker 03 And that was a tough conversation with our board and our investors, because they actually wanted us to keep going. It was a tough conversation with the other co-founders, who also wanted to keep going. We had those conversations, and then we'd call in all hands. And I walk into the room, and it was an unusual all hands. We hadn't announced it before, so there's already kind of some nervousness in the room. And I stand up and start, and like, I didn't even get through the first sentence without starting to cry. I just, I locked eyes with one employee who, just three months ago, had moved to Vancouver to come work with us. He had moved away from where his in-laws lived, and his in-laws helped take care of his, I think at the time, like, 18-month-old or two-year-old daughter, bought a house. And now, I was telling him they didn't have a job anymore.
26:07 Speaker 02 That employee he locked eyes with? That was Tim Lefler, one of the engineers at Glitch. We asked him how he remembered that moment.
26:16 Speaker 05 Stuart came in and had a very somber look on his face. He had kind of puffy eyes. He looked tired and we kind of thought it didn't look great. But, you know, it was Monday morning, so who knows? And he came in and the very first thing he said to us was, you know, it's over and that we're shutting the game down. And a lot of us obviously knew what that meant. You know, we were not going to be working there any longer.
26:45 Speaker 02 One of the things I admire in this story isn't just that Stuart took responsibility. He also took action.
26:52 Speaker 05 Stuart and some of the web developers decided to build a page on glitch.com.
26:58 Speaker 03 We made a website called Hierogenius. We put everyone's LinkedIn up there and everyone's portfolio and everyone's photo.
27:05 Speaker 05 And the timing of everything was very deliberate so that when all of the news agencies received the press release, there was always this bit of information that would be sent out saying, and these people are looking for work and here you go.
27:17 Speaker 03 And we worked on writing reference letters and doing resume coaching.
27:21 Speaker 05 And Stuart and the group decided, you know, we're going to keep working until everyone else has another job. I received many calls and emails from people asking for me to come in for an interview. After about a week, I had a couple of offers.
27:34 Speaker 03 And we ended up getting every single person a job. We were able to give customers a choice of their money back or they could let us keep it or we could donate it to a set number of charities. So we were able to do that in a way that was really kind of elegant and built a lot of goodwill that would be useful for us later.
27:49 Speaker 02 Here's the key to managing through a pivot. Those employees, if they feel taken care of, they'll keep taking care of you. Tim and his teammates threw an epic goodbye party for Glitch's online community.
28:02 Speaker 05 What a lot of us at Glitch wanted to do is we wanted to kind of give them a nice send off. We had a horseman character. He was supposed to be a horseman of the apocalypse and he was carrying this doomsday bell and he would just walk around saying like the end was nigh. Or the end was nay. I imagine that seems like a joke that we would have put in it. I mean, nay. And there was a kind of a rallying cry from a lot of the users around kind of having these end of world parties. There'd be a big party in this one area of the world and then it would kind of get shut down and we'd move somewhere else.
28:35 Speaker 02 Stuart and his team embodied this idea of ending in the best way possible. And this isn't just the ethical, human thing to do, it's also the smart, strategic thing to do. Those employees, those investors, those users, they'll come back.
28:50 Speaker 03 So it was really, really tough. And it's easy to look back on it now and it's character building. And in fact, we ended up hiring that same guy back and he's been a Slack engineer from the early days. So everything worked out well there.
29:05 Speaker 02 While they were essentially shutting the company down, Stuart and his team start the hail Mary process again. A process that Stuart is very familiar with by this point. They had money in the bank and a mandate to make something, anything that could scale. They took a long look at all the technologies they developed for the game and asked themselves, was there anything there?
29:25 Speaker 03 We definitely knew that we wanted to keep working together and we still had money left. Investors didn't want their money back because I don't have to need to tell you, but why would you rather take a two third loss when something might come out of it? We still had five and a half million dollars or something like that left in the bank. So we didn't have to shut down. And I think that there's a real temptation to go to the last dollar and hope that there's some kind of hail Mary that will save it. The good thing about shutting it down early was that we had the ability to just not do anything for a couple of months. Within a couple of weeks, I think three weeks, we decided, there's a lot of stupid ideas first, but we decided that this internal communication system we had developed while we were working on the game, that could be a product. And
30:09 Speaker 03 we started building that. And we had great practice, but it was. A vision that might have well been passed down onto the mountaintop.
30:17 Speaker 02 So Stuart didn't get food poisoning on a plane this time, but once again, he found an unexpected way to pivot. He found his scalable product in a communication tool his team had developed for internal use, a chat-based tool for his remote team that would eventually become a product called Slack. And at first glance, this goes against something I know to be true. The most successful pivots stay somewhere close to the company's original mission. This is where Stuart is the exception to the rule. I typically tell founders to ask themselves, "Okay, in the path we've taken, is there anything that we've seen or found along our path that could lead to an alternative play?" It's not the kind of thing where you pull ideas out of nowhere. "Hey, we're just gonna go back to the whiteboard here.
31:02 Speaker 02 What do you think? Should we make an e-commerce site? How about a mobile game? What about a pizza delivery restaurant?" No, no. From our path, what do we see? A chat-based communications tool is really a far cry from the online game that Stuart set out to build. But then again, it was a tool they had already developed and used themselves. Stuart's team knew exactly why companies would adopt this new tool. They created it to meet their own needs, to communicate quickly, transparently, and sort of permanently.
31:36 Speaker 03 So when we first got started, though, when there's only four of us, the natural thing for us to use was a very old internet protocol called IRAC, the Internet Relay Chat. It predates the web by a couple of years. And because it's so old, it misses a bunch of features that are now considered just standard. So one of the things it misses is storing forward of messages. So if I want to send you a message and you're not connected at the moment I want to send it, I just can't. Like, there's just no way for me to do it. And so we built a bot that would log all messages that were sent when you were offline so you could read them when you got back online. And once we had that, we're like, "Oh, wow. It would be super convenient to be able to search these messages." And since we already had them in a database, it was easy to search them. It wasn't something that we thought about or talked about. It didn't have a name.
32:21 Speaker 03 It was just in the background. But as we started hiring people, they would join and they would have this archive of everything that happened before they got there, as opposed to most companies where you hire someone and they start with an empty inbox. They're completely cut off from that history. But again, you know, it was, and this, by the way, I think is the greatest software development methodology that's impossible to replicate, which is, don't think about what you're doing, have no ego, there's no speculation, there's no, I can imagine a user would want to, to spend the minimum number of minutes addressing the most aggravating problems that you have and just use it and then see.
32:57 Speaker 02 So as Stuart puts it, he had the idea that was passed down from the mountaintop. The core technology was already built. Now, all he had to do was convince his team to make the product. Stuart could see three steps ahead at this point.
33:10 Speaker 03 There's this deck that I put together that was like, I think we should make Slack. So we hadn't actually started making it yet. And I show this to new employees when they started Slack. It's in our archive because the amazing thing is like, it had the pricing that we went live with. It's exactly the product vision. It's exactly the way we marketed it. Like, everything was preset and we didn't have to change it because I think we had three and a half years of of practice and finding product market fit for our market of one team.
33:44 Speaker 02 The market of one team that Stuart is referring to is the team that was making Glitch, the team that had made the communications tool that would turn into Slack. They'd spent three and a half years creating a hit product and they didn't even realize it. But once they had the pitch deck in place, it didn't take long for him to take action. They were building Slack.
34:04 Speaker 03 I think all that stuff actually took place in like 72 hours and within a week we were definitely on this plan. Well, I think we knew that we had something just because of the value we got out of it. And the other thing I talk about is going to an Andreessen Horowitz partner meeting at the end of 2012, where we hadn't been in a while. They led our Series B and we're going to tell them, here's what we're doing. And part of the pitch was, we think that one day, in the fullness of time, if we're incredibly successful, we will get to $100 million in revenue on this business, and it could thereby be a billion dollar business. And there was a lot of good luck, like, not a huge degree of enthusiasm, but you know, that was our whole ambition, and we exceeded that last
34:49 Speaker 03 year, and we doubled it again this year. So, we really underestimated how big of a deal it could be.
34:55 Speaker 02 How do you go from good luck to a $5 billion valuation? Pivots in persuasion.
35:02 Speaker 03 We also underestimated how hard it would be to get people to switch, because no one thought that they needed anything. We weren't competing with anything else that was out there, other than the use of email, which is pretty much impossible to compete with, and whatever it was that people did, whether that was using a bug tracker, or a wiki, or Google Hangouts, or Skype, or, no one thought that they needed Slack.
35:26 Speaker 02 It's kind of like Genius is, you're a madman, but you're right. And this is part of the creating a new market.
35:34 Speaker 03 Well, we went out and started trying to convince other people to use it, which was way harder than we thought it was going to be. Social proof was the thing that we needed, so we needed to be able to point to teams other than our own, because of course we used our own product. So, we had some friends who worked at Ardio, the music streaming service, now defunct. I was on the board of a company called Cozy, which is a landlord/tenant app, and a friend of a company called Wantful, which is a gifting service. And we just went to their offices over and over again, and tried to figure out ways to explain why we thought it was valuable. And there's a lot of, you know, they were friends, first of all, and they were very tech-forward, very, you know, they were enthusiasts, and they
36:19 Speaker 03 would want to try new products. But what actually made it hard was, you have to get a whole group of people to change all at once. It wasn't just one person. The benefit of that, though, once you're able to break through, is, once the group starts doing it, you, the, what was difficult about it becomes its benefit. It's very hard to get the group to change to anything else, once they switch. So, Slack was a really interesting product to scale in the early days, because it had very, very little network effect between companies, but a huge, like, binary, you know, 100% or just nothing, inside of companies.
36:54 Speaker 02 So there were companies to cajole, influencers to influence, hearts and minds to win. The overarching driver of Stuart's success? The ability to tell a great story, one that inspires people to go on the journey with you as you make some seriously bold moves. It's one of his entrepreneurial superpowers.
37:13 Speaker 03 And if there was one piece of advice I wish I could phone back and give to myself was just concentrate on that storytelling part, on the convincing people. Because if you can't do that, it doesn't matter how good the product is, it doesn't matter how good the idea was for the market, or what happens in the external factors, you don't have the people believing.
37:34 Speaker 02 When Stuart knows that it's time to slash and burn the business, the only way to lead your team on the journey is to turn it into a great story. Find those moments where everything changed, whether it's throwing up in a hotel bathroom or having a mountaintop moment you have to bring to your team. Figure out what your story is and it will go a long way to bring your co-founders, employees and investors along with you. And you'd be surprised at who might come back to help. Remember Tim Loeffler, the engineer that Stuart had to lay off? He was naturally a bit reluctant to take another job offer from Stuart.
38:08 Speaker 05 I got an email from Stuart. And getting an email from somebody who previously laid you off talking about work, you know, you're a little cagey on that. But there was no reason I wasn't going to meet Stuart for coffee. And yeah, he kind of gave me the rundown of what was going on and just said, hey, we'd like to have you back and working on this product with us. I talked over with my wife. She said, if you were to leave where you're working and go work for Slack and Slack fails, how sad are you going to be that you need to find another job? And I'm like, yeah, it would suck trying to find another job and the job I might get might be worse than what I'm doing now. But then she said, well, what if you stay where you are and Slack becomes a huge hit?
38:52 Speaker 05 And I basically said, well, that would really, I would feel really bad about that. And so that kind of, at that point, was kind of the clinched decision for us and we ended up moving.
39:03 Speaker 02 Yes, Tim and his family moved again. Fortunately, it was the right move this time around. And when he arrived at the office, he was surprised to find he wasn't the only battle scarred employee to rejoin the team.
39:15 Speaker 05 I came back with a bunch of people that had also been cut and were coming back for the same reason. You know, it kind of felt like a bit of a reunion.
39:24 Speaker 02 So it seemed like the end of the road for Stuart and his team wasn't truth, only the beginning. Bear that in mind if you ever have to slash and burn your business. I'm Reid Hoffman. Thanks for listening.
39:47 Speaker 04 Hey listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show because every Friday we release a second Rapid Response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely, from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from the devil wears Prada. It takes about 10 seconds to find. Just search Rapid Response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode. I hope to see you there.
40:24 Speaker 06 Humans will never be more intelligent than AI.
40:28 Speaker 01 There's going to be two types of companies. Those are great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't. How do we build a future that is human centered?
40:38 Speaker 06 I'm Rana Elkhayubi. And on my podcast, Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works for everyone. Every week I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future and we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming.
41:00 Speaker 04 Our lives. Find pioneers of AI wherever you tune in. We all know the really prominent technology podcasts out there, but they're not actually helping the majority of people understand this space. With Future Proof, that's what we want to do. We want to talk to everyone from the top AI labs to the real builders, the people who are rolling up their sleeves, building this technology on a day-to-day basis. I'm Reid Albergati. I've been covering technology for more than a decade. If you want to really learn whether you're in the tech industry, adjacent to it, or just curious about it, subscribe to Semaphore's Future Proof wherever you get your podcasts or watch it on YouTube.
41:41 Speaker 02 Masters of Scale is a Wait What original. Our executive producers are June Cohen and Darren Triff. Our producers are Dan Kedmi, Chris MacLeod, Jenny Cataldo, and Ben Manila. Our supervising producer is Jay Punjabi. Original music and sound design is by The Holiday Brothers. Mixing and mastering by Brian Pugh. Special thanks to Chris Ye, Sayad Isapiyeva, Elisa Schreiber, David Sanford, and Stephanie Kent. Visit mastersofscale.com to find the transcript for this episode.
Previous Look for the ideas that come at you sideways, w/Diane Greene of Google, VMware Next The infinite learner, w/Barry Diller (Part 1 of our interview) Page updated October 24, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated