Skip to content

The Diet Crimes of Metabolife

Maintenance Phase

57m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

The episode covers Metabolife 356, a diet supplement from the mid-90s that contained ephedra (marketed as Ma Huang) and guarana. The hosts trace the regulatory environment that allowed it: the 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act, which exempted supplements from FDA drug approval, was lobbied for by the supplement industry with the help of a Mel Gibson ad depicting SWAT raids on vitamin users. Co-founders Michael Ellis and Michael Blevins had a history including a 1990 meth-cooking charge. By 1999, Metabolife reported $1 billion in sales, but FDA records showed over 1,000 adverse reactions and 35 deaths. By 2002, the toll reached 95 heart attacks, 69 strokes, 70 seizures, and 81 deaths. The company sued media outlets for defamation, spent $2 million promoting an uncut 20/20 interview, and Ellis invoked the Fifth Amendment at congressional hearings. The final blow came when Baltimore Orioles pitcher Steve Belcher died at 23 during spring training in 2003. The FDA banned ephedra that December. At the time of the ban, ephedra products represented 5% of supplement sales but 45% of adverse events. Ellis was sentenced to six months and a $20,000 fine for lying to the FDA, while the company was fined $600,000 for concealing over $93 million. The pseudoephedrine ban was eventually buried in the Patriot Act.

  • The 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act exempted supplements from FDA drug approval, meaning makers do not have to prove an ingredient is safe before taking it to market. 6:03
  • By 2002, FDA records showed Metabolife users had reported 95 heart attacks, 69 strokes, 70 seizures, 91 cases of high blood pressure, and 81 deaths. 44:32
  • At the time of the FDA ban, ephedra products represented 5% of dietary supplement sales but 45% of adverse events linked to any supplement. 54:05
  • The pseudoephedrine ban, motivated by its role in black-market meth production, was passed as part of the Patriot Act rather than as a standalone bill. 54:53
  • Metabolife's claim of being 'lab tested for safety' was unsupported: their studies had extremely small sample sizes, high dropout rates, and in one case they could not account for bottle contents in a blinded trial. 37:09

Highlights

  • 3:08

    Mel Gibson Vitamin Raid Adstory

    A supplement industry ad shows SWAT teams breaking into a house, only to reveal it is Mel Gibson in a bathrobe taking vitamins. The hosts note no such raids ever occurred; the ad was designed to astroturf the idea that supplements were overregulated.

  • 6:03

    DSHEA Deregulates Supplement Industryinsight

    The 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act recategorized supplements as food, exempting them from FDA drug approval entirely. Supplement makers do not have to prove safety before market, and the FDA can only restrict an ingredient if it poses a 'significant and unreasonable risk if used as instructed.'

  • 12:33

    Co-Founders Cook Meth, Hire a Cookstory

    Michael Ellis and Michael Blevins rented a house and hired a meth cook in 1990. They kept getting interrupted by landlord showings and had to dismantle the lab. Ellis later claimed they turned themselves in, but the hosts note this is implausible.

  • 35:21

    Two Million Dollar Uncut Interview Campaignstrategy

    After 20/20 filmed a 72-minute interview with Ellis in 1999, Metabolife uploaded the uncut version to televisioninterview.com and spent $2 million on full-page newspaper ads and TV spots promoting it, including spots during 20/20 itself.

  • 44:32

    Death Toll From Ephedra Supplementsdata

    By 2002, FDA records showed Metabolife users had reported 95 heart attacks, 69 strokes, 70 seizures, 91 cases of high blood pressure, and 81 deaths. The DOJ launched a criminal investigation that same year.

  • 51:28

    Steve Belcher Dies at Spring Trainingstory

    Baltimore Orioles pitcher Steve Belcher, 23, collapsed and died during spring training in 2003 after taking an ephedra supplement. Another Oriole had previously collapsed and disclosed ephedra use. Sales of ephedra products fell from $1.28 billion in 2002 to $510 million in 2003.

  • 54:05

    Five Percent of Sales, Forty-Five of Adverse Eventsdata

    At the time of the FDA ban in December 2003, ephedra products represented 5% of dietary supplement sales in the US but accounted for 45% of all adverse events linked to any dietary supplement.

  • 54:53

    Pseudoephedrine Ban Buried in Patriot Actinsight

    The ban on pseudoephedrine, motivated by its role in black-market meth production, was introduced as a standalone bill but ultimately passed as part of the Patriot Act, which the hosts note was dropped at night and ran to many pages.

About this episode

The rags-to-riches tale of how an illegal methamphetamine manufacturer became a legal methamphetamine manufacturer. Support us: Hear bonus episodes on PatreonWatch Aubrey's documentaryBuy Aubrey's bookListen to Mike's other podcastGet Maintenance Phase T-shirts, stickers and moreLinks! How the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 Weakened the FDAMad About MetabolifeStimulant Propels Diet EmpireThe dangers of the herb ephedra - Harvard Health An Historical Review of Steps a...

Transcript

0:00
57:08

9,652 words · 4 speakers

Topics

  • Ephedra
  • Dietary Supplements
  • Regulatory Deregulation
  • MLM
  • FDA
  • Corporate Accountability
  • Public Health

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated